10 ms·
States should ban contracts barring employees from seeking higher pay at a rival
- vfulco2 8y agoCapitalism...workers are just another expense to be eliminated
- BLKNSLVR 8y agoSqueezed. Not eliminated.
- liftbigweights 8y agoI believe the technical term is liability. Workers are liabilities. You are right. A part of capitalism is to increase the assets and reduce liabilities.
- FranzFerdiNaN 8y agoWhich is why it cannot help but create its own downfall. But before that we will have to end up with that unholy alliance between government and industry called fascism, as that will be the final attempt to extract wealth from a society that has been drained, by tapping directly into taxes collected by the government. You simply cannot have a system that needs consumers to spend money when its in every single companies best interest to pay as little, preferably nothing, to those whose business and expertise you need to survive. You can expand to other nations as a temporary solution but in the end you will run out of people to sell stuff to.
- Melchizedek 8y agoNot to mention the unholy alliance between the contemporary elite "left" and capital, called globalism. The only real counterforce to global capitalism has historically been the people of a nation, and the populist nationalism of a few nation states has been the only example ever known of an economic system that has upheld basic human dignity (whether it has been called social democracy, christian democracy or something else). This is now going down the drain.
- Intermernet 8y ago> the populist nationalism of a few nation states has been the only example ever known of an economic system that has upheld basic human dignity Can you give me some examples? I'm honestly curious as I can't think of any off the top of my head.
- SmellyGeekBoy 8y agoDPRK? Nope... China? Erm...
- Melchizedek 8y agoSweden (as it used to be). By "populist nationalists" I mean what they really are, not necessarily what they call themselves. The Swedish Social Democrats of old are a good example who in practice created a national welfare state, often even with explicitly nationalist rhetoric.
- weregiraffe 8y ago> contemporary elite "left" and capital, called globalism To anyone who is not in the loop (of the alt-right/4chan jargon), "globalism" is currently a code-word for "Jews".
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Karunamon 8y agoWTF?!
- Melchizedek 8y agoNo, globalism means globalism and has nothing to do with Jews. This is simply an attempt by (extremely well financed) globalists to smear anti-globalists with antisemitism.
- weregiraffe 8y ago>The only real counterforce to global capitalism has historically been the people of a nation And yet every time there is some great nation-building exercise, the nation in question immediately attempts to build a global empire for itself, by subjugating other nations. France of Napoleon. Germany of Bismark. Japan of Meiji. Germany of Hitler. USSR. Current day USA. Human dignity, my ass. PS. Arabs of Muhammad and Mongols of Genghis also qualify.
- aetherson 8y agoThis comment suggests that you are trying to support a political point by using obfuscated technical terms you do not understand. "Workers" do not show up on a balance sheet: they are neither an asset not a liability "technically." There may be a payroll liability briefly, though it will then be paid out and taken off the books. Accrued vacation is a liability, which is why we have "unlimited PTO" policies. It is impossible, in double entry bookkeeping, to "increase assets and reduce liabilities." Every asset must be balanced with a liability. That's the fundamental basis of that accounting system. To the extent that we're speaking metaphorically, workers are assets. To the extent that we're speaking technically, it's clear that you tried to apply jargon that you didn't understand to confuse others.
- umichguy 8y agoWell, everyone is a number somewhere on a spreadsheet. Call me cynical, but I have long given up on the notion of company loyalty etc. Looking back at my bright-eyed idealism coming out of college, makes me laugh.
- BLKNSLVR 8y ago"bright-eyed idealism coming out of college" Where does that come from though? Is that still the case for the current generation of college graduates? Do the kids need to be educated closer to reality? The notion of company loyalty is good for a productive workforce - UNTIL the illusion is shattered, which can take parts of the rest of an individuals positive world-view with it.
- geezerjay 8y ago> The notion of company loyalty is good for a productive workforce - UNTIL the illusion is shattered It should also be noted that this illusion is not specific to any economic system. The soviet union also saw its share of jaded idealists who were gullible to the point of believing that all those promises of owning the means of production had any credibility. At least in capitalist economies workers are educated with regards to liberal ideas. Thus they are informed that a work relation is just like any business relation, and therefore they are compelled to look after their own best interests without falling for the "company loyalty" emotional trap. Your employer owes you the salary and you should expect nothing more in return, and consequently you as a worker are compelled to always look after more favourable arrangements just like your employer is perpetually doing wrt your job.
- BLKNSLVR 8y agoThe comment to which you're replying wasn't intended as a jibe at capitalism, just pure observation of unrealistic expectations of a college / university graduate in an ignorance-is-bliss kind of naivete. Faith in the reciprocation of loyalty with thine employer can be just as misplaced as with your government, whatever shape of ideology it follows (any system is corruptible; gosh-darn humans).
- BLKNSLVR 8y agoEstablished companies all trying to protect themselves from competition because it's an easier / cheaper approach than continuing to actually compete. Like when a football team is in a winning position and "goes defensive" to the detriment of their effectiveness. The problem is, once a company / team changes their approach to "the game", it's often too hard to change it back. Capitalism has developed ADD. It's all about short-term reward and for all intents and purposes the future is too far away to consider.
- dotdi 8y agoIt's simple. The rich are getting richer and the poor are getting poorer. With more money, the rich have more and more power to make sure that it stays that way.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- NTDF9 8y agoI've never understood why the structural flaw of unfettered capitalism isn't obvious to most people. The rich will keep getting richer, at the expense of peasants.
- LyndsySimon 8y ago> The rich will keep getting richer, at the expense of peasants. Historically, the second half of that assertion is not borne out.
- ionised 8y agoHow so? The wealthy reap mnore and more of the benefits of the economy than the average person, in ever increasing measures. The fact that a working class person might now have access to 4k TVs and new cars on finance doesn't change the fact that overall, their share in the prosperity of their nation in shrinking, even though it might seem like gradual improvement. Luxuiries don't mean shit when you can't save, afford to treat a major illness or have to work two jobs to pay the rent. Half of the US doesn't even have any savings and are in a state of persistent debt servitude.
- geezerjay 8y ago> The wealthy reap mnore and more of the benefits of the economy than the average person, in ever increasing measures. The success of some does not mean that others have been defeated, or forced into a position where they are worse than before. This fallacy is often repeated by people obsessed with egalitarian views, where they consider any difference in access to resources (even those which have been earned through hard work and not squandered away) as being somehow a major injustice. Yet, just because some multimilionaire wastes wads of cash in conspicuous consumption that doesn't mean that societies based on capitalism don't enjoy humanity's highest quality of life and access to goods and services, to the point that some are even considered by "the people" as being infinite and a god-given right.
- int_19h 8y ago
- netcan 8y agoNon compete contracts and non poaching agreements are insidious and should be illegal. Ilegal, not just unenforceable. But, among the many imbalances between employees and employers... few are as easy to fix. A major imbalance is information. One radical idea is salary transparency. It would be an emotionally difficult transition, but I think the effect on salaries would be transformational. Information is, a big part of what markets are. If you are negotiating salary armed with the same information your counterpart has, you are in a much better situation. At the very least, it would help those people who are the worst at negotiating and have an employer that will take advantage of this. Eliminate anti competition agreements, in a year you may find a measurable marginal effect. Publish all salaries and the effects will be everywhere.
- piokoch 8y agoSalary transparency. Let's imagine you have a brilliant employee, you want to pay her or him twice more than others, because that person truly brings that much value for your company. Do you really think other employees would say - yes, this guy/gal is really smarter than we are, she deserves all those money? Wouldn't such person be bullied by others (think of what often happens to the best pupil in the class, where you have "grades transparency"). Let me cite François de La Rochefoucauld, "Although no one is happy with his fortune, but everyone - with his wits.
- Dumblydorr 8y agoI’d rather have it that way than at my last company, where I discussed salary with someone of lesser education and talents, but who was female. She found out I was making more due to my education and negotiation, then she went complaining to all of my bosses and HR about a gender pay gap, and come Christmas time she got a raise much larger than mine so we were making the same. Even though she didn’t negotiate and had no masters. How is that fair to me as someone who arguably deserved the higher salary? I knew more and played the market game better, yet because of my gender I then make the same as a less productive worker? Salaries should be transparent and the reasons for higher pay should be merit based. I left that company immediately afterwards because another one offered me 50% more to do what the first company wasn’t even thinking of doing yet. So overall, I think the current system of secrecy and unjustified numbers is far from ideal.
- aetherson 8y agoThe problem here is information asymmetry. It's hard for employees to know how valuable it is for them to sign a non-compete. It's hard for companies to advertise their desirability based on, "those other guys will make you sign a non-compete. We won't." So it becomes low cost for people to ask for it. In the current environment, non-competes should be banned: California proves this is a viable approach. But perhaps a better long term solution that seems within technical reach right now would be some kind of AI legal assistant that could demystify and educate people about the contacts they're asked to sign. Like imagine if you had a smartphone app. You scanned the contract with your camera and the app said, "This is a non-compete agreement. 60% of the companies in this field use them. Best estimate is that signing it costs you $30k in lifetime earnings." Then a job seeker could just negotiate to their own best interest.
- konschubert 8y agoIt's also power asymmetry. Some people just can't afford to NOT sign a non compete. That's why laws and regulations are needed to protect the poor.
- ams6110 8y agoThe poor are, in most cases, not qualified to do very skilled high-paying work. That is part of why they are poor. Are the jobs they can get really requiring non-competes? If I take a job at an Amazon distribution center, am I going to be asked to agree that I won't later go to Wal-Mart? And if I do, will Amazon actually bother to enforce that? Last time I had a decision to make on a non-compete, I did consult with a lawyer and he basically said there are no guarantees, but generally a non-compete cannot be enforced if it prevents you from earning a living. Edit: the article implies that places like McDonald's do this. I worked there (albeit years ago), and at that time it was not true. We would have been rightly laughed at if we asked for a non-compete on a minimum-wage job like that. It was hard enough to hire people who were reasonably well-groomed, punctual, and energetic. We would not have added unnecessary barriers like that.
- crankylinuxuser 8y ago
- mrweasel 8y agoIs that actually legal, and enforceable in the US? The union for engineers in Denmark have basically told its members to just sign contracts with non-compete clauses, because they aren't actually enforceable. Not without the company compensating you financially, even if you're fired. Assuming a five year non-compete clause, the company should expect to pay you for those five years. Essentially the worker sign away their most marketable skills, and that's no free.
- johnnyfaehell 8y agoThey are enforceable in some parts of the EU. In the UK they need to be very specific about it and have a fair time limit. Saying "You can't poach any clients or employees" is unenforceable saying "You can't poach Employee A and Employee B for 1 year" is. Most companies just have a poorly worded contract that isn't enforceable.
- bradleyjg 8y ago> Is that actually legal, and enforceable in the US? The US is 52 different legal jurisdictions. This is one of the areas where there those different jurisdictions differ quite a bit.
- talltimtom 8y agoIn Denmark the law is very clear on what you can require in a non-compete, and what level of compensation you must at minimum include. Maximum of 12 months, and they must give you a 150% old salary one time payment at the onset. And if you are either unemployed or working in a significantly new job type after 3months they must supplement your salary up to 50% if you old one for the duration of the contracts. Owing to the very clear rules, I have never heard anyone from Unions saying they where unenforceable, so I’m curious if you have any reference on that part?
- skh 8y agoWith his Lordship’s permission I wish to leave your manor for another. The floggings are less intense there.
- C1sc0cat 8y agoYou jest but labour law in the USA and the UK descends from the "master and servants act"
- HoochieKoo 8y agoThe beatings will continue until morale improves.
- thelasthuman 8y agoThe beatings will continue until they are accepted as a fact of life. If humans were as free as capital to go where they can get the most benefit to me, I'd move to Denmark in a heartbeat. Truly sounds like a workers paradise, at least compared to the USA. But we aren't free, capital is. Priorities I guess.
- choot 8y ago1. Make salaries public. 2. Have an exchange where we can bid on an individual just like stock market 3. Remove taxes 4. Add exchange fee No salaries exist. No employee is tied to a particular employer. We can get access to a person if we bid the right amount.
- kevin_b_er 8y agoThis is because the philosophy of "at-will employment" being good is a lie sold to the public. It is to benefit the corporation, and thus the rich, and not the human or the poor.