5 ms·
Getting rid of zoning laws only works if you have a lot of extra land to sprawl out onto. Otherwise, even if you build up to get more dense ala NYC, HK, Tokyo,
by seanmcdirmid 8y ago
Getting rid of zoning laws only works if you have a lot of extra land to sprawl out onto. Otherwise, even if you build up to get more dense ala NYC, HK, Tokyo, or Shanghai, the area will just become more attractive and more people will want to live there. No easy solutions here.
- wycs 8y agoYou say that like vastly increasing the productivity of our largest cities is neutral at best. This would create an extraordinary surplus, and other cities that can build out would compete for citizens, just like Texas is doing right now.
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoNo city in Texas is dense, its all sprawl, even in liberal Austin.
- graeme 8y agoI looked into this and Texas still has a lot of pro-sprawl policies, such as mandatory parking minimums. People paint them as no zoning, but that's only on one specific measure.
- barry-cotter 8y agoHousing prices have been more or less flat in Tokyo for 30 years. https://marketurbanismreport.com/tokyos-affordable-housing-strategy-build/ https://marketurbanismreport.com/tokyos-affordable-housing-s... > According to the website RealEstate.co.jp, average housing prices throughout Greater Tokyo have actually decreased since 2006. In 2014, the average price of second-hand condos was 27,890,000 yen, or about $232,914. This is above the U.S. median of $187,000, but is a steal when considering that average housing prices in many destination U.S. cities are triple or quadruple this amount.
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoAgain, it only looks like a steal if you look at unit costs and not per square feet/meter costs. This puts Tokyo on par with Seattle. See https://www.numbeo.com/property-investment/compare_cities.jsp?country1=United+States&country2=Japan&city1=Seattle%2C+WA&city2=Tokyo&tracking=getDispatchComparison https://www.numbeo.com/property-investment/compare_cities.js...
- nradov 8y agoIt's easy to keep housing prices from rising when a country has a low birth rate and minimal immigration.
- barry-cotter 8y agoTokyo’s population has grown in every census since 1955. http://www.newgeography.com/content/002923-the-evolving-urban-form-tokyo http://www.newgeography.com/content/002923-the-evolving-urba...
- dba7dba 8y agoI heard many many commuters who work in Tokyo actually live pretty far away, commuting via the bullet trains. So the housing market in Tokyo is not in tremendous demand.
- amanaplanacanal 8y agoGood public transportation certainly helps there, which most of the US doesn't have.
- losteric 8y ago> Getting rid of zoning laws only works if you have a lot of extra land to sprawl out onto. Other way around. Zoning encourages horizontal growth by constraining vertical growth. Once supply has reached horizontal and vertical limits, prices skyrocket to reach equilibrium with demand. > Otherwise, even if you build up to get more dense ala NYC, HK, Tokyo, or Shanghai, the area will just become more attractive and more people will want to live there. Density implies noise, pollution, traffic, people, and a certain type of urban lifestyle... all of which decrease attractiveness.
- seanmcdirmid 8y ago> Density implies noise, pollution, traffic, people, and a certain type of urban lifestyle... all of which decrease attractiveness. Prices in big dense cities say otherwise, there is plenty of demand to be where all the economic action is, many people also prefer urban lifestyles. The lack of zoning doesn't encourage density at all, if there is land to build out instead of up, everyone will prefer the former because its cheaper and can provide amenities like free parking. Zoning can prevent that, it can also discourage vertical growth but at the same time discouraging horizontal growth as well.
- losteric 8y ago> Prices in big dense cities say otherwise, there is plenty of demand to be where all the economic action is, many people also prefer urban lifestyles. Prices just show urban areas are highly valued, there is no proof those areas defy supply and demand. Density increases attractiveness for some people, but the trade-offs are clearly not for everyone given NIMBYism and higher prices outside some urban areas. Increasing supply may increase demand to a point, but there is still an equilibrium - density is still part of the solution. > The lack of zoning doesn't encourage density at all, if there is land to build out instead of up, everyone will prefer the former because its cheaper and can provide amenities like free parking. Zoning can prevent that, it can also discourage vertical growth but at the same time discouraging horizontal growth as well. Moot point, this entire discussion is about urban areas where land has already run out. > if there is land to build out instead of up, everyone will prefer the former because its cheaper and can provide amenities like free parking. "Everyone", except people that care about the time cost of commuting and the financial obligation of car ownership.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> Otherwise, even if you build up to get more dense ala NYC, HK, Tokyo, or Shanghai, the area will just become more attractive and more people will want to live there. The problem with this theory is that it's zero sum. If density attracts people and prices there rise, those people will have come from some other place. Then the prices in that place will fall and we still serve the goal of giving people an affordable place to live. You can't increase demand in every place at the same time. It has to come from somewhere. And if you increase density everywhere at once, it also can't move from everywhere to everywhere. If one city increases density it attracts new people from other cities. If every city does it there is no net migration because the benefits accrue everywhere, so the demand in each place stays the same and the greater supply lowers prices.
- cimmanom 8y agoPopulation growth can increase demand everywhere at once. And affordable housing away from a high demand urban center is no use to anyone and not going to attract anyone if there aren’t good jobs there.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> Population growth can increase demand everywhere at once. But where is the extra population coming from? If you're talking about any other place, it reduces housing costs in that place. If you're talking about a rise in birthrates, that's theoretically possible (though by no means guaranteed), but the timescale is so long that there is plenty of time to build even more housing by then. > And affordable housing away from a high demand urban center is no use to anyone and not going to attract anyone if there aren’t good jobs there. Where do you expect the people to be coming from? If it's another city, that's still an urban center with jobs. If it's the suburbs, people can still live there and work in the city as they do now. And they can't be from the middle of farm country because there aren't enough people there to be a major source of demand, even before accounting for the fact that they would have to both want to move to the city and be able to afford to.
- 8y ago
- imtringued 8y agoDemand isn't infinite. Every person that moves to the attractive city is one less person that wants to move to the attractive city because that person is already there. The goal isn't lowering the housing price. If one person moves in and the price stays the same that alone is already a success.