7 ms·
“Not all customers deserve a company’s best efforts,” says Peter Fader, a marketing professor at the University of Pennsylvania’s Wharton School who helped popu
by azinman2 8y ago
“Not all customers deserve a company’s best efforts,” says Peter Fader, a marketing professor at the University of Pennsylvania’s Wharton School who helped popularize lifetime value scores.
I feel like this is a succinct argument against the idea to privitize everything — there’s no accountability nor notion of “fairness” baked in whatsoever.
- DiffEq 8y agoAre you implying that government, local or national, is "accountable" or "fair" somehow? All of human experience demonstrates the opposite.
- gumby 8y ago> All of human experience demonstrates the opposite. That's an absurd exaggeration.
- DiffEq 8y agoEqual to OP's absurd argument for less privatization.
- lostmyoldone 8y agoNot all human experience. There are certainly countries where government is considered to be - on average - rather fair.
- bjelkeman-again 8y agoMost (all?) Northern European countries strive hard to achieve that fairness and are reasonably successful in doing so.
- mfringel 8y agoCan you restate your assertion in a way that can not be trivially torpedoed by a single existence proof?
- DiffEq 8y agoThere is no need. OP seems to imply that there is some kind of inherent fairness built into human governments; as if they are outside the influence of human nature. My assertion contains all of human history; within each of those governments one can find some form of injustice or lack of fairness. OP thinks government it a solution to the woes of privatization - even a casual look at the world and at history will show that neither has given us what we seek.
- mfringel 8y agoYou used a universal quantifier in your initial statement. That is, all of human history, implying all governments at all times. This is trivially falsifiable. With your current statement, you're attempting to modify that to all governments in human history, at a single point in time for each of them. In the most charitable case, that's vacuously true. You chose the hill you wanted to defend... it's a bit late to complain about the location. The question stands.
- DiffEq 8y agoSo if it is so trivially falsifiable...please provide the trivial evidence.
- mfringel 8y agoYou first. You've already proved you're willing to move the goalposts once. I've not moved mine at all. Clearly, it should be much easier for you to prove something to me. The original question stands, and remains unanswered.
- DiffEq 8y agoYou have learned to use big words and have taken a logic course perhaps...but have learned nothing. I have not moved the goal posts, I have stated several things about human history/governments that are as apparent as the sky is blue. OP being the pot was calling the kettle black. You are saying that the pot is not black, I asked you to show where it is not, you refuse - because you can't.
- pc86 8y agoWhy would fairness factor into a business transaction? And I'm not sure why you're making this a public v. private thing, that's not really relevant to the article at all.
- hn_throwaway_99 8y agoI interpreted the parent comment differently. Basically, I think they are agreeing with you, that fairness shouldn't necessarily factor into a (private) business transaction. However, many people do feel that their should be some notion of fairness factored into what have been historically governmental responsibilities (e.g managing roads, prisons, etc.) and that the push to privatize many of these functions is dangerous if it does away with "fairness" in these functions.
- azinman2 8y agoExactly
- pc86 8y agoOK, but I don't know that the comments on an article talking about using LTV to manage help desk call volume is a relevant place to discuss public v. private responsibilities. It seems unrelated. "Some companies use LTV to determine how long you wait on hold." "This is why we shouldn't have private prison."
- wpietri 8y agoIt seems relevant to me. When we look at topics like transport, education, and communications, we're in an era where those things are tilting private, often due to companies discussed here and that employ people who participate on HN. As an example, the US Postal Service, which has a universal service obligation, has made a huge difference in how the country developed. Everybody was in an important sense equal. The Internet started out with that spirit, but its implementation on mostly for-profit infrastructure means that isn't guaranteed. With the loss of net neutrality, we've taken a further step away from fair infrastructure. Is that a good idea? This article is an example of why it might not be: because companies tend to optimize for short-term revenue gains and to wildly favor rich people.
- bb2018 8y agoIt all depends on your notion of fair. If one percent of people call up customer service to complain about 50% of their transactions they are clogging up the system. I only call if something is breaking and I've exhausted all troubleshooting and automated methods.
- Scoundreller 8y agoYou’ll get put on hold forever: “this person’s calls take 30 minutes to resolve” Edit: and makes our call takers feel dumb with low resolution rates
- benologist 8y agoThese systems only exist to help their customers so if it is "clogged" it is probably indicative of fat execs and a successful round of layoffs after they realized they could "make more" by supporting their customers less.
- athenot 8y agoOr they might have a legitimate case. You can't tell just by looking at volumes. It could be that fringe group of customers who use international credit card numbers (but also happen to spend well). It could be elderly consumers who consistently get bitten by a rough edge in the UX. It could be users who don't use English as their primary language and don't understand a colloquialism in the interface.
- sandworm101 8y ago>> It could be elderly consumers who consistently get bitten by a rough edge in the UX. Or the elderly customers who call just because they want someone to talk to. I used to do some PCI compliance work and occasionally had to listen in on customer calls to call centers (to verify procedures were being followed). They don't want service. They want to chat. They may have some small issue with the UI, but then they want to add something to the order. Does it come in red? Will it match the one I ordered last week? Will the delivery people set it up? Can I make sure it doesn't arrive on monday because I'm going to the doctor?
- mkirklions 8y ago>argument against the idea to privitize everything Go to a different company next time? If the government denies your paperwork, you get to keep working with the same government.
- crdoconnor 8y agoComplaining to a congressperson is usually more effective than complaining to a monopoly/oligopoly like Comcast.
- TylerE 8y agoNo it isn't, because Comcast has all the congresscritters bought and paid for, or at least enough of them to prevent anything it doesn't like from actually getting passed. https://www.opensecrets.org https://www.opensecrets.org
- azinman2 8y agoDepends on what you're complaining about. If you're complaining about your own individual experience and being wronged (versus something where the law needs to be changed), then often local representatives can surprisingly get things done.
- azinman2 8y agoRight.. except most of the time I don’t have a choice for internet, power, garbage, etc. So much of infrastructure and basic services are regional (for a variety of reasons) that you don’t have this infinite choice. Often even if you do have “choice,” it’s a few equally bad options. When startup cost to challenge is so high, and the switching cost means most people won’t, the idea that anyone would just break into the market falls flat. Add non-accountability, and there’s no recourse. At least with the government, they cannot legally prioritize one person over another, and there exists judicial recourse.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- tomcam 8y agoWho wants to privatize everything?
- azinman2 8y agoGOP, libertarians, free market evangelists, private equity firms, Wallstreet....
- wallace_f 8y agoYou might be surprised to know many (most?) libertarians are against privatization of prisons, policing, courts, national parks service, and so on. Also, the GOP is completely fine with the military industrial complex, big budget deficit spending, tariffs, and other anti-free market policies.
- azinman2 8y agoOh I never said that the GOP (or any group) is entirely consistent in ideology, or is homogenous. But it’s a common part of their platform and has been for years. https://www.statesman.com/news/20180904/commentary-republicans-like-privatization-often-benefiting-donors https://www.statesman.com/news/20180904/commentary-republica... https://www.thenation.com/article/this-is-how-the-republican-party-plans-to-destroy-the-federal-government/ https://www.thenation.com/article/this-is-how-the-republican...
- wallace_f 8y agoYou said "everything," and have been trying to make the point that privatization is bad.
- pkaye 8y agoWith private companies you many times have a choice. With public organization, most times you don't. I needed to go to the CA DMV to renew my drivers license and appointments are booked 3 months in advance and if I go to visit them, some people are waiting 3-4 hours. Because of my flexible schedule I managed to estimate and go at a less peak time and reduce it to half this time. There is certainly no accountability in the DMV either.
- christianmello 8y agoWhat would an alternative to the DMV be, in this case?
- jonahhorowitz 8y agoThere's a very specific reason for the high wait times at the CA DMV right now - the new ID requirements forced upon us by the TSA. CA had to decide if they wanted to massively staff up to handle the increased processing required, or if they wanted to just work through the surge since it's temporary (once everyone has a new ID, the renewals will be easier). I wouldn't say there's no accountability. They just didn't make the decision you wanted.
- gowld 8y agoCA stalled on REAL ID for 5 years, leading to a burst of demand now.
- empath75 8y agoHave you ever had a customer facing job? Some customers are just toxic. Rude, demanding and usually a cheapskate as well. It’s just not worth spending time dealing with them.
- baddox 8y agoI presume you're making a distinction between services from private businesses and services from the government, and I feel like there are also nearly equivalent succinct arguments for how terrible government services are for certain groups of people (particularly poor people and minorities). So, yes, you can call that a succinct argument against privatizing everything, but very few people actually advocate for that (and those that do generally have ideas about revolutionizing the entire social and/or economic system, not just "eh, just turn off all the public services overnight."). It's easy to pick and choose certain services where private businesses seem to provide better access, and other services where the government seems to provide better access.
- Rescis 8y agoI really appreciate your statement that even us crazies who want to privatize everything generally want to do it slowly, and don't think that just abolishing the government today would be beneficial at all from a humanitarian perspective.
- Vraxx 8y agoIt seems a ridiculous opinion to say privatize everything, but I've seen more and more politicians in the US who support that, or at least that's what I hear when they talk about privatizing education, healthcare, and even the FAA. I agree that, as you point out, some government services are terrible for certain groups of people (poor and minorities), but I don't think that's an argument for privatization because at least we try to pretend we hold the government to those standards. Nobody pretends that we do or even can hold corporations to any sort of standards. Sometimes there's regulation to help with that, but it's fought kicking and screaming the whole way from the regulated industry and is followed by constant lobbying to repeal or relax said regulation.
- baddox 8y ago> but I've seen more and more politicians in the US who support that, or at least that's what I hear when they talk about privatizing education, healthcare, and even the FAA. We're still losing the distinction between privatizing more things and privatizing everything. I'm not aware of any federal-level US politicians who want to privatize, say, the military. > but I don't think that's an argument for privatization because at least we try to pretend we hold the government to those standards. Personally, I'm not interested in the standards we pretend to hold the government accountable to. I'm interested in actual outcomes. If privatizing some service can vastly improve outcomes, then great, if government can do it, then great. Sure, there's the high school social studies explanation that governments are accountable to the people while corporations aren't, but in reality I think that varies vastly from one sector of society to another. Sometimes government accountability to the voting population seems to work, but sometimes it fails miserably. Sometimes corporate accountability from the market seems to work, but sometimes it fails miserably.
- notatoad 8y ago>Not all customers deserve a company’s best efforts it might not sound nice to phrase it that way, but don't the most loyal or high-value customers deserve better support? If you spend $100k a year on office supplies at staples, you're going to get more attention than a guy who goes in to buy a ream of paper. what's unfair about that?