24 ms·
Who Are My Investors?
- wtvanhest 8y agoI find the way he describes "gulf interests" to be almost racist. Is money from Kuwait the same as money from Saudi Arabia? Obviously not. [Corrected syria to saudi Arabia]
- darawk 8y agoRelax. It's clearly a euphemism for Saudi Arabia.
- mgarfias 8y agoSyria isn’t the gulf.
- forkLding 8y agoSyria is the Levant, Gulf countries are countries in the GCC (Gulf Cooperation Council) and in the Persian Gulf.
- wp381640 8y agoIt is shorthand for UAE, Bahrain, Qatar, Kuwait and Saudi - countries that are just a few of the handful remaining autocratic theocracies in the world with terrible human rights records
- wtvanhest 8y agoThose countries are wildly different in terms of human rights violations.
- diminish 8y ago>> Who are our investors and can we be proud of them? And do we want to work for them? > Sadly, the answer for many will be no and it will not be easy to unwind those relationships. So fond structures are hard to reveal.
- leowoo91 8y agoEven giants have contracts among them, money is just money unless you give control.
- kvm 8y agoSide question: why do VCs never disclose who their LPs are?
- paulddraper 8y agoCase in point.
- spamizbad 8y agoMy guess: that information could stifle entrepreneurship
- luibelgo 8y agojust wondering, it would disclose a large part of their portfolio and so their investment strategy
- shemtovo 8y agoMany do, look at Notion or Ice Breaker for example. Many LPs don't want to be named though
- twunde 8y agoI think some do if you ask. I know for a fact that the founders of the company I work for would ask for intros to some of the LPs as part of the fundraising process (we do Enterprise b2b sales so they were mostly looking for sales prospects). Protip: if an investor (potential or otherwise) tells you to let them know if there is something they can do for you, look through LinkedIn and ask for intros to sales prospects
- nradov 8y agoBecause their LPs usually insist on confidentially as a condition of investment. Some institutional investors do disclose which VC funds they participate in, though.
- neom 8y agoI would imagine an element of it is concern about a founder contacting them after a particularly difficult board meeting etc.
- ssijak 8y ago"“Bad actors” doesn’t simply mean money from rulers in the gulf who turn out to be cold blooded killers." - like we all did not know that before the referenced event?
- sk5t 8y agoYou're not the only one puzzled by this namby pamby opinion piece.
- ed_balls 8y agoAs other commenter pointed out, we don't have enough information to judge the situation beyond reasonable doubt. MBS was selling himself as a reformer and everybody deserves a benefit of a doubt. Maybe it was of one the generals that decided to kill the journalist. Why would MBS risk all the deals he has made and about to made? Oil doesn't give him that much leverage right now and sanctions could topple the government. I'm not trying to make a case for or against him. It's impossible for an average person to know what is going on exactly.
- ssijak 8y agoYes you can know. It is not like this was the first bad thing Saudis have done under his command.. Not to mention the usual evils of such oil nations like spending bilions on personal yachts, art, mansions, etc..., having slave-like labor in your country, kidnapping, behedings for many non-crime (in civilised world) things, etc. "reformer" thing is a joke and a mask.
- samsonradu 8y agoNot sure one can know. From all angles it looks like a very stupid and badly executed assasination plot. There are a lot more discrete ways to kill someone than flying 15 people/agents over on a private plane. Time will tell hopefully.
- ed_balls 8y agoUnless you want to send a message, not just kill someone. Similar to Skripal.
- AndrewKemendo 8y agoAt any business effort beyond hyper local markets, there is virtually no way to avoid tainted money or unethical markets. You're going to have to compromise somewhere. The question is, how and where do you draw the line? At some point as a founder/fundraiser, you will cross paths with finance or supply chains that support exploitation, coercion, violence or illegality. The most successful business people don't seem to care about these cases, and as long as they don't come with explicit connections that would be bad for business or can't be managed, the more the merrier. At any scale of business that is globally impactful, it's fundamentally impossible to avoid these chains, so I'm not sure what the actual response should be. I've thought through many approaches here, from realpolitik pragmatism to ethical fundamentalism but none feel correct.
- loceng 8y agoIn fact for the corrupt, it could even be viewed as a net positive to know you have bad actor money "on your team" - whom may directly or indirectly help your cause to get things in your favour.
- threatofrain 8y agoThat's true for any "side", corrupt or non-corrupt -- you want more money because you trust your moral vision more.
- loceng 8y agoThen that "non-corrupt side" is corrupt, therefore it's only the corrupt who do this; is ignorance bliss and an acceptable excuse and make you less responsible, how far along the chain of trust is enough? Someone's moral compass is inherent to the equation - their path dictated by their ability to understand/be compassionate, and level of non-violent practice they hold themselves to; if they lead with bad acting and violence as "a means to the end" then I'd argue they're less intelligent - whether through emotional blocks from unhealed trauma early in life that put their ego mind up on guard and started layering coping mechanisms that blocked ability for compassion, and/or inherently on their genetics, brain structure, has prevented this. This is all a holistic fight against violence and aggression, which through intelligence, the battle has become more and more and more subtle as a means of violence sustaining itself; we quickly put someone in confinement if they're physically aggressive and attack someone in our society, however manipulation and the such is perhaps the least aggressive - and so doesn't cause a reaction until it's perhaps too late, when the network of bad actors is large enough - and where they as a whole eventually realize they are or can get away with more and more.
- buboard 8y ago> that has found its way into the startup/tech sector over the last decade That seems disingenuous "we stumbled upon some mountains of money"
- 40acres 8y agoMy general feeling is that no one involved really wants to know how the sausage is made. Recent events have highlighted Saudi Arabia as a major investor and that's caused more focus but deep down I don't think engineers, executives, VCs and everyone involved is really committed to getting the most transparent view of money flows. Because at the end of the day it means less money overall. I think regulation would have to come into play to enforce transparency, do firms disclose their largest investors when filing an S-1? Even if they do, is it possible to get down to the root of each dollar? Shell companies exist for a reason.
- dwaltrip 8y agoI'll throw my hat on the side of wanting to know how the sausage is made. I'm sure I'm not the only one. I believe we are fully capable of making a better sausage, and doing it in better way. There may be many difficulties along the way, but that's the case with everything that is worthwhile.
- bilal4hmed 8y agooh nice, I hope they dont take any Chinese money, any Russian money, any African money, US money, European money, I hope they dont borrow money from banks, from foreign banks.
- chickenfingerz 8y agoThis moral compromise by silicon valley is going to come home to roost in the near future. Dictators are wealthy by virtue of stealing money from their subjects. No free person should voluntarily work for a dictator by accepting resources stolen from the enslaved. People in free countries should reject all investment from dictators. And they should reject jobs at companies that take their investment. As technology increases transparency across the world it inexorably raises the moral standard for all free people.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- aznoz 8y agoThe world is cruel and reckless. People should come to terms with this.
- mc32 8y agoThe question posed by the CEO in question, while valid, is futile --verging on naive. To really mean it, you'll refuse: money, investment and goods from China, Russia, Gulf, many African countries, Latin America, etc. to such an extent so as to bring the world economy to a virtual standstill. In addition to refusing money also No Oil from Saudi, Venezuela, Russia, or Goods from China, Minerals from Africa... It's well meaning perhaps, but utterly disingenuous. It's mostly CYA.
- cm2012 8y agoI'd say it depends how much you can separate the cash from the malicious governments. There are plenty of chinese investors only connected to the Party by one or two links. Not so in Russia or SA.
- wslh 8y agoYou can't if at the end your company is public or acquired by a public company.
- jjeaff 8y agoThere's a difference between accepting money and goods from Chinese or Russian investors and accepting money from specific bad actors. For example, taking investor money (and thus giving voting rights) from groups like SoftBank (which has a ton of Saudi Royal family money), is a totally different ballgame from say, buying MacBooks that are made in China.
- mc32 8y agoIt's more than just MacBooks manufactured by internal migrants in China[1]. You also have many Chinese tech giants with SV offices: what, refuse to rent them RE, or refuse them building permits? How far does this go? [1]https://www.ft.com/content/463b162a-8a3d-11e8-b18d-0181731a0340 https://www.ft.com/content/463b162a-8a3d-11e8-b18d-0181731a0...
- jjeaff 8y ago
- simonebrunozzi 8y agoI've been following Fred Wilson for a long time (like many others!), and I have a feeling that he genuinely cares, despite not enjoying full freedom on what to say and do, because that's the compromise you accept when you take money from others. This topic, "Who are my investors?", is incredibly important, potentially complex, and hard to judge or evaluate fully. Let me try to share my thoughts. Your job as a VC is to manage money on behalf of others; specifically, LPs (Limited Partners: pension funds, endowments, private funds, family offices, etc) give you money for 10 years, and want you to bet on very risky startups. VCs represent to them a specific asset class, with its geography, risks and rewards. VCs are typically paid 2/20 (2% of the amount invested is given to them every year to pay for salaries and expenses; 20% is the "carry", or how much they take from profits). The "2" is given annually, the "20" is given at liquidation events (typically acquisitions or IPOs). Each VC firm has its own approach to which money to accept. A simplified view is that if you can afford to say "no" (in other words, you are offered more money than you want to "raise" in your next fund), you typically choose based on your principles and morals, to an extent. If you cannot afford to say "no", I'd bet most VCs would simply take the money they can get. Few decide they'd rather not be a VC at all, and stick to their principles. Sometimes it's hard to know where the money comes from, but in most cases you get a general idea. Pension funds, etc, are straightforward. Family offices, well, they represent the interest of a specific family, which is tied to what business or inheritance or political situation allowed that family to gain money. If there's such a thing as the Gaddafi family office, you know the money comes from having been the dictator of Libia for decades. On the VC side, the simplest thing to do would be to fully disclose who your LPs are, how much they invested, and what's the exact entity that invested. Doing so would have two ripercussions: one, LPs might want to pull out, and based on their contractual agreement, might be able to do so; and two, you will probably have a hard time raising a new fund in the future, because a lot of powerful people will try to send a message to others. A better solution would be for some very prominent VCs to "come out" all together (USV, A16Z, Benchmark, Sequoia, Kleiner Perkins, Index, GC, etc), so that their collective power couldn't be easily challenged by these powerful people. However... Can you imagine tens of rich VCs being able to agree on something potentially destructive for the entire sector? What if money "dries out" for VC funds? But let's not forget about startups, either. What about them? As usual, you might be in the position to say "no" if you are offered more money than you need. Lucky you. But most of us (I'm a startup founder myself) are not in that position. We have been, are, and will be presented with opportunities where we might be interested in the "reputation" of that investor, but really don't care much about everything else. How many of us have thought about which LPs invested in our VCs? I bet very few. Imagine if, as a startup founder, I go out and publicly say that I refused money from a certain VC because I don't like their LPs. What kind of signal would I send to other VCs? Probably: "Seems a principled guy, but who knows? He's probably nuts, and not someone I would invest into. Dangerous.". If that's transparency that we want, it should be VCs AND startups together. And my Italian pessimism tells me that this is even less probable than the "VC collective" initiative I was describing earlier. I feel that most human beings, when facing a decision where the future is at stake, are not really capable of sticking to their principles, especially if doing so means dire consequences for their business, their money, and even the other people/employees involved. A sad truth. Message to Fred: this is an opportunity for you, and for other famous VCs, to be a hero. You don't have to, but please think about it.
- detcader 8y agoThe intent is good but I feel this is a pretty futile angle. On an aggregate scale if you don't take authoritarian money, your competitor will and then they will have more money than you. Luckily these days we have a system of checks and balances on authoritarian entities throwing around huge amounts of money to get what they want; it's called democratic government. These days you can help democracy in your own country by working directly on campaign finance reform and voter's rights in your local communities and greater state and federal campaigns. So the people in your government aren't mostly millionaires. That helps. But I've seen first-hand working on these issues that they come off as unsexy and grindy to many.
- flyinglizard 8y agoThis moral high ground is a very tricky thing. We need to accept different parts of the world operate differently and not to deny them from participating in technology. You could find something uneasy about anyone and anywhere. China, Israel, Gulf states, and of course USA itself.
- mrleiter 8y agoBen Hunt pointedly said in his recent article [0]: "With Saudi Arabia, the ubiquitous private information was that Saudi Arabia is a thug state and their Crown Prince MBS is a wannabe Bond villain. But no one acted AS IF they knew this until a Missionary event – in this case Turkey’s very public denunciations of the Saudi government’s murder of Jamal Khashoggi – turned that private information into common knowledge, something that now everyone knows that everyone knows." He coined the term >common knowledge game< [1] as the "information, public or private, that everyone believes is shared by everyone else". In the case of MBS, or Saudi Arabia specifically, everybody (privately) already had the information that this is a brutal regime. But they acted as if no one knew this. Until the tragic and brutal death of an exiled journalist in a consulate and the public denunciation by Turkey. Now it has become common knowledge and actions must be taken accordingly. [0] https://www.epsilontheory.com/saudi-arabia-and-the-common-knowledge-game/ https://www.epsilontheory.com/saudi-arabia-and-the-common-kn... [1] https://www.epsilontheory.com/sheep-logic/ https://www.epsilontheory.com/sheep-logic/
- barrkel 8y agoIt was ubiquitous information, but it lacked relatability, strategy and focus. Erdogan has been playing this one very well. The chap is relatable - an American resident, writing for a US newspaper, critiquing a government, just the kind of thing westerners like to venerate in their cultural products. Erdogan has drip-fed the media with information. Since it's so lurid, each extra dose gets more headlines - it's concentrated, potent stuff. And he's kept Saudi guessing - threatening that if they don't come out with the truth, he'll release the details. He'd lose all leverage if he actually did release everything, but the strategy works very well. Everybody knows MBS almost certainly ordered this clumsy attack in a very naive way. But Erdogan has used the unknowns of the information, and gradual disclosure, as a lever to make Saudi replace their lies repeatedly over time, eating away at their credibility. By keeping western media on the boil, he encourages western politicians to say that Saudi isn't explaining enough. It's been very interesting to watch, a master class. (It's not the common knowledge, or the crystalized idea that everybody knows that everybody knows. That's not right at all. It's political pressure being maintained by someone with leverage, a steady hand on that leverage, and a strategy to move things. The lever is joined up: leaks -> western media -> western politicians -> Saudi. Without the continuous pressure, this would all blow over because democratic citizens have pretty short memories most of the time.)
- vasilipupkin 8y agoWait till SV learns that DST is Putin’s money. Once you start down this rabbit hole, where do you stop?
- dcposch 8y agoPretty much every single comment so far is cynical. "No one really wants to know how the sausage is made", lots of money is tainted anyway, it's just PR fluff, etc etc. The classic HN Middlebrow Dismissal in full effect. Counterpoint: cynicism is too easy. Actually giving a shit is harder, it's uncomfortable, it involves compromise. Yes, if you refuse investment from any country that has ever violated a human right, you will raise $0. But that doesn't mean all money is created equal, or that Fred Wilson's effort here isnt worthwhile. He's simply calling for VCs to a) refuse money from the worst offenders and b) be transparent about who their LPs are. He's also calling on startups, founders, engineers etc to demand this transparency, to care who they ultimately working for. It's a simple ask.
- barrkel 8y agoI think a better ask is to create self-sustaining processes that ratchet to improve the system over time. In a word: regulation. You can't be sure you're consuming ethical meat through consumer pressure alone. You need more eyes in the system, with enough force to be able to see through the veils that the profit motive will put up.
- downandout 8y agoNot everyone in the world can afford "ethical meat" but they still need to eat nonetheless. This is one of the things I have never understood - people that are into concepts like "ethical meat" tend to be left leaning, and people on that side claim to be compassionate toward the poor. Yet it appears from your comment that if you had your way, you would use regulation to force the costs of eating up, which would dramatically affect the ability of poor people to eat. You can’t simultaneously claim to have compassion for poor people and advocate for regulations that will make their lives more difficult and expensive than is absolutely necessary.
- 3pt14159 8y agoThe problem with the global system cracking is that it's pushing this work onto low-information people with mismatched incentives. If the Sauds have routine trouble getting money into funds they'll resort to tricks that will get them exposure in one way or another. They can acquire a company, they can create their own VP that doesn't list investors but co-invests. It's a never ending battle and one that we're not capable of fairly judging. This should be a Nato / EU / US or UN thing where we have real tools to enforce sanctions.
- barrkel 8y agoOne of the biggest upsides of capitalism, where upside is defined as increased economic activity, is that it hides morally dubious actions behind a simple monetary exchange. You get to buy goods, and you only need to think about the price at checkout, whether virtual or physical. You don't need to think about how much human suffering or environmental degradation you're funding, where each sliver of profit goes, and what plans those people have for your money. If you have to visit your butcher and look them in the eye to buy your meat, with sawdust underfoot to soak up any fluids from the carcasses still hanging, you might have a greater appreciation for the sacrifice of the animal. All nicely packaged up in plastic, in a standard unit, coming from a centralized slaughtering system, it's easier to forget that your clicks & coins fund killing. And that's just stuff we've largely morally made our peace with, at least until there's an equivalently tasty alternative. A large part of government regulation is to add back more eyes into the system when your own eyes can't see beyond the immediate transaction and the supply chain leading to the transaction is too long for you to research, never mind perceive at the point of sale. Labour laws, food standards, inspections and regulations - far more oversight is made necessary due to capital's natural obfuscation.
- tomkit 8y agoHonorable, but it could also be a slippery slope: how far back do you look? If an LP, or investor in general, uses their personally earned money, but they earned it through capital gains from tainted money - let’s say from stock in a company with human rights issues - do you ask about that and if so do you take their investment? If you only look at one degree, ie are your direct investors’ money clean, you could also be targeted for laziness in the “supply chain” of your investors’ money. This is similar to problems with blood diamonds, organic foods, unethical coffee etc. What's needed is a framework and policy in the community for what's acceptable due diligence.
- cowpig 8y agoSlippery Slopes are a slippery slope. If you reason about everything in extremes, how can any solution ever be acceptable? The worst case for all real-world solutions are always bad.
- tomkit 8y agoYou can't. What's needed is a framework and agreed-upon policy of what is acceptable due diligence in the community when taking investment money. Varying degrees of "organicness" for startups - like what you see in the meat section at Whole Foods.
- BeetleB 8y agoHe did not say "Let's reject all this because it is a slippery slope." He is merely alerting people that the slope is slippery.
- someguydave 8y agoIt’s racist to assume all Suadi money is corrupt
- cco 8y agoCould you clarify this comment? It doesn't immediately make sense on the surface. Who's being racist and why?
- stephengillie 8y agoNo, it's nationalist. Racism would be assuming all Arabic money is corrupt.
- abalone 8y agoI love that Wilson gives examples of ethical LPs like pension funds and educational endowments. Much of the criticism here is “well if you refuse to take tainted money then the world economy will grind to a halt.” But think of it... if the business community stopped taking tainted money, holding everyone to a high standard, that would be a powerful force to curb human rights abuses in the world. We do have ethical alternatives.
- nafey 8y agoIts a zero sum game. You might reject the investment but others wont
- unknownkadath 8y agoThat's fine. Your conscience will be clear, and if you have a winner, you should attract other money. The biggest drawback is if your project is easy to replicate, in which case you have to ask if it should attract smart money in the first place.
- QML 8y agoIt’s not a zero sum game — just because a company makes an unethical decision to gain a competitive advantage doesn’t mean you have to. And it doesn’t mean you can prosper by acting ethical either.
- abalone 8y agoNo, South Africa ended apartheid when the international business community and their governments mostly decided to boycott them (after public unrest). It turned businesses that supported apartheid into pariahs.
- ed_balls 8y agoI guess China wasn't an option?
- ionised 8y agoThat's a cop-out. It has to start with someone saying no.
- sanj 8y agoI applaud Fred’s efforts here. And I hope other firms follow his lead.
- newnewpdro 8y agoThis ball was set in motion long ago when we decided it was appropriate to trade our money with these nations for their oil. If we ever wanted to see that money again, we were going to be doing business with them in the future. It's not as if we were ignorant of their dismal records on human rights and lack of democracy. We've been throwing money at oil-rich nations for a very long time, and now they have leverage in terms of buying power. What do we have to offer in return? They can buy our startups, our land, and our weapons.
- rdlecler1 8y agoI’m going to be cynical here. AVC is an established fund with a great track record and can take a moral high road and ask others to do the same. But what if they were 18 months into raising their first fund and still pushing for the first close. Would they be so eager to take that high road?
- jacobsheehy 8y ago> Would they be so eager to take that high road? In my opinion it has been made clear that doing business honestly and with morals will win in the long run. So yes they would have taken "that high road" because, if you want to be cynical, that is the way to make the most money. The only thing cynical about your comment is the idea that acting in bad faith is more profitable than acting in good faith. I think that our society, especially the financial part of it, knows that now.
- qaq 8y agoDo you have any good examples ? I'd love to believe "doing business honestly and with morals will win in the long run" I am not really seeing it play out in the real world especially when big biz. is concerned.
- nodesocket 8y ago> They include large pension funds for public employees like teachers, firemen, police, and the like. How is investing in internet startups part of teachers, fireman, and police pension? It's just about the most risky and difficult investment to get right. Most startup investors aren't successful and if they are it's because 50 portfolio companies fail and 1 or 2 exit for a billion. I don't understand how the retirements of middle class Americans can be bet (litterally craps style on green) on startups.
- refurb 8y agoI hate it when, just because something becomes a big media story (I.e. Saudi Arabia killing a journalist) everyone comes out of the woodwork “oh dear! How can we not do business with these people?” When in fact, it’s been going on for decades and nobody gave a shit... until now, when giving a shit can firm up your virtue signaling.
- mattigames 8y agoSo you are suggesting people just keep doing business with them... or are you suggesting people don't try to make other people do that? Because you can call it "virtual signaling" or however you want but both are still pretty bad options.
- ohashi 8y agoSo what are you suggesting or are you just complaining to no end?
- zt 8y agoExcept, Fred made the decision about his LPs over the last 15 years...
- jamiequint 8y agoThere's nothing in the article to suggest that this is due to virtue though. It may be just that USV has the luxury of raising from only top tier LPs given their relatively small fund size ($1bn across 6 funds).
- zt 8y agoYou’re right. It is true that top quality LPs tend to be universities, foundations, and pension funds. And with a funds USV’s size it’s pretty easy to only fill it with those good guys. I was surprised they had any family offices. Before the global growth fund, Sequoia claimed that all of their LPs were not-for-profits (although excluding pensions funds is usually for transparency reasons). Having said that, I don’t think that every top quartile fund could make the same claim even if USV, Sequioa, and Benchmark could...
- the_common_man 8y agoPractically speaking, what are we supposed to do here? Slack raised 250m from Softbank which we know is driven be Saudi investment. Should we stop using Slack? Honestly, I doubt anyone would do that despite all this "outrage". I put it in quotes because all these principles are great to talk about but people won't do even a small thing like leaving Slack in their companies.
- QML 8y agoDon’t interpret the words given as a common prescription. Most of us don’t have enough to make a global impact—only a local change. Wait and see if Masayoshi Son, or SoftBank, will comment on the situation; see if Stewart Butterfield, or Slack, will. If neither of them say anything, then that’s when you should decide to continue using Slack or drop it; but don’t pretend you were oblivious.
- perseusprime11 8y agoThis does not answer anything. Fred needs to list out all the sources by name and amount of money.
- mtrovo 8y agoI keep thinking what Iraqi startups would think about accepting american VC money. The thing is, international politics is really hard. I'm pretty sure that it makes sense to track where your money is coming from but every single country is going to have a different set of "worst offenders", and you will see that the list carry a lot of political interest. I mean, we're looking at Erdogan [1] pointing the finger at the Saudi's about how they're a ruthless regime. Hell, go back 10 years and even the Saudi were in the other side of this hardball game, what changed from there? [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2016_Turkish_coup_d%27%C3%A9tat_attempt#Possible_government_motives https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2016_Turkish_coup_d%27%C3%A9ta...
- wp381640 8y agoAmerican VC money is distinct from American government money. The same cannot be said for Saudi, Qatar, UAE, Russia, the Central Asian kleptocracies, and to some extent - China, etc.
- sneak 8y agoThe people who are ultimately in charge of Google Ventures fly from a federal government airport on taxpayer subsidized jet fuel, and are currently embroiled in a dispute with their labor force about building ML tools for the military’s drone program—with the leadership being the initiators of the program and the objections coming from the rank-and-file. Don’t be so sure of the lack of integration here. If they’re willing to bend for China’s censorship, why wouldn’t they bend for any manner of much-more-palatable (to them) directives from their home government?
- noddy1 8y agoThis is an excellent opportunity for social pressures so curb behaviour. MBS has 45 billion dollars in the vision fund, and if it doesn't work out well, he will look stupid. If the vision fund loses ability to invest in the best companies, this could potentially ruin their performance. Masayoshi Son and MBS need to be sent a message that their ability to invest will be limited if Saudi Arabia behaves in a shitty way.
- throwawayinside 8y agoMark Zuckerberg and senior FB execs are limited partner in several funds, such as Greylock’s latest raise. When you pitch these guys on your next Facebook-killing idea, beware. Personally, I think there’s money in the Valley that’s as dirty as the Saudis.
- rl3 8y agoWhy is it assumed that this morally undesirable money would take the form of an LP directly signed on with one's VC? Can't this money instead invest itself with an existing LP that's seemingly on the up and up? For example, say Goldman is an LP on one of your VC's funds from which your company receives money from. Setting aside how morally dubious they are on the face of it, they're otherwise a reputable and respected American company.[0] However, where's their money coming from? On a larger scale Goldman absolutely does business with the Saudis and has forever. On a smaller scale, I'm sure there's any number of vehicles or ways to otherwise structure the money going into a particular investment such that it'd be difficult for the eventual recipient (i.e. the startup) to know exactly where it's coming from, let alone the VC. [0] https://www.foxbusiness.com/business-leaders/goldman-quietly-sending-reps-to-controversial-saudi-conference-despite-ceos-comments https://www.foxbusiness.com/business-leaders/goldman-quietly... /s
- jwr 8y agoI really like this. If we all started factoring moral issues into our decisions, the world would start becoming a better place. Unfortunately, people love to justify doing nothing. Approaches like whataboutism, relativism, and convincing yourself that your decision doesn't matter because X/Y/Z are rampant — as witnessed by comments under this post.
- lordnacho 8y agoI've come across this problem a few times when running a hedge fund. To what degree does one care where the money came from, aside from following AML rules? I get the feeling you only write articles like that if you have more people wanting to invest than you have capacity for. - A friend called, asking for a recommendation for a job he was applying for. And advice about whether it was worth taking. Turned out, it was the firm that managed Libya's (ie Gaddafi's) wealth. They were making a big push at the time and needed a software developer. Was I going to tell him not to take the job? How complicit are you if you write some exchange connectors for a dictator? He ended up taking it, and they ended up in the news. - A gulf state sovereign fund called. We didn't even flinch to take it. I think we just assumed they had a lot of oil money and didn't think any further about it. If you read the news, there's some not nice things about the place. Treating manual laborers badly, lack of proper rule of law, that sort of thing. Took the money, didn't think about it much. Not sure I would act differently now, to be honest. Basically the business needed the investment, and there wasn't anything specific and horrible to tell us not to. - And where do you draw the line? What if a benevolent, enlightened, prosperous but essentially a dictatorship state from the equator wants to invest? And they could well claim to be a democracy. You'd be in endless discussions about which investors to take, which presumably 99% of your competitors would not have a problem with. - The family office of a guy who'd been in jail called. He was known to have made his money in a seedy way, and tended to have large guys standing around guarding him. I doubt if he actually was a gangster, just seemed to like having a certain tough-guy air about him. Were we going to turn him down? Again, business requirements prevailed. Basically, if it's legal to take his money, most people will do so. If someone does something horrible like with this journalist, and you are an organisation that is large enough to have a PR footprint, you might care. If you're just a small fish, you are always going to have huge pressure to take the cash. I know what my partners would have done if I'd put up any resistance in these cases; they'd have just ground me down with endless rationalizations, and we'd have ended up doing exactly the same. People always find reasons to do what they have decided to do, and not in that order.
- howlgram 8y agoI just want to mention that Gaddafi brought a lot of development to Libya and his death did nothing for his people. It's easy to say "oh he was a dictator and dictators are bad" but it's not so simple.
- venantius 8y agoAs a soon-to-be-regulated financial institution in the UK, we have to be careful who our investors are (and that includes getting into who the LPs our in our investors' funds). It's very easy to take cash, but nobody wants to have that hard conversation with the regulators 6-12 months down the line when they ask you to fully look up your cap table and you realize a quarter of your company is Russian oligarch money / from the middle east / from questionable shell corporations / etc. As regulators around the world get more serious about money laundering, this will become an increasingly important question for venture-backed firms.
- mychael 8y agoThe context for this post is that money is money and money is currently cheap. VCs work hard to create the perception that their money is more valuable than investor's money.
- walrus01 8y agoOn the flip side of "we don't want dirty money from ethically questionable non democratic states investing in our fund": Things start looking really dirty, really fast when you look at what major institutional investors put money into things that are highly ethically questionable. For example a major Canadian pension fund was recently discovered to be investing in private prisons/immigration detention facilities in the USA. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2018/oct/12/canada-pension-fund-invests-in-us-immigration-detention-firms https://www.theguardian.com/world/2018/oct/12/canada-pension...
- tw1010 8y agoFounders should take into account the dirtiness of the investment commensurate with how much leverage they have. But we shouldn't ostracise or penalize small companies who can't afford to take into account where the money comes from. No need to enforce an equally high ethical threshold on the whole startup community.
- protomyth 8y ago“Bad actors” doesn’t simply mean money from rulers in the gulf who turn out to be cold blooded killers. If your knowledge of the House of Saud's crimes start with the death of one reporter, then you really need to do some research. Just look at what constitutes a capital crime in Saudi Arabia. Look at your colleagues and ask how many of them would be jailed or executed? If you were fine taking money from them a year ago, then I really question what makes one more soul lost special for you? Realpolitik means nothing of substance will be done because we have other enemies and $400/barrel oil would not go over well just as I'm sure this incident too will fade before the next storm.
- rajekas 8y agoI am several standard deviations to the left of Fred Wilson, but I can't fathom why his decision is being greeted with so much negativity. He might have taken dodgy money at some point (but he's willing to acknowledge it) and now he's big enough to screen his LPs but he still didn't have to write this piece. That he has chosen to do so is a sign of progress. Let's give credit where it's due. As a vegan, I want the world to stop eating slaughtered flesh, but I will be the first person to applaud if McDonalds stopped purchasing factory farmed meat (if only!). There's always the next frontier in our quest for justice and all the more reason to applaud an act of courage.
- hkyeti 8y agoAgree, too often we appeal to futility to justify (subconsciously) doing nothing... there's a lot we can do, and most impacts follow a power law curve
- jacquesm 8y agoThe seeds for this were planted long ago, here was an interesting exchange between PG and Fred Wilson: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3144224 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3144224
- perpetualcrayon 8y agoOne of the problems here is: are the venture capitalists, who are willing to expose who their investors are, able to take on most of the businesses that will one day be successful? There will always be entrepreneurs unwilling to give up on their dreams just because ethical investors aren't willing to invest in them. Maybe this is another good argument for universal basic income. Those who want to spend their lives as entrepreneurs never have to take money from bad actors and will be able to grow their businesses organically based on the natural success and will be able to reap all the rewards on their own terms.
- readhn 8y agoDirty money (drugs, corrupt politicians, gangsters) is THE elephant in the Western Room. Everyone keeps ignoring it as long as the money keeps flowing into real estate, companies/start ups.
- mindgam3 8y agoAfter 15 years working in Silicon Valley startups, I am as jaded and cynical as they come, but this is really refreshing. A VC making a stand for values, and having the balls to admit that his own hands aren’t entirely clean? Outstanding. We need more conversations about integrity, and more high level players with the integrity to admit that they have been wrong in the past.
- thoughtstheseus 8y agoAn added issue here is that most money flowing from SWFs have a significantly lower return target(cheaper money- in my experience), as compared to nearly every domestic funding source.
- forgingahead 8y agoInteresting that "educational endowments" made it onto the list of "ethical" LPs -- one could argue the opposite, given that the size of most of these endowments are directly due to the easy credit market of student loans, which is now a $1.6 trillion monster.[0] [0]https://money.cnn.com/2018/06/05/pf/college/student-loan-stats/index.html https://money.cnn.com/2018/06/05/pf/college/student-loan-sta...
- timavr 8y agoNot naming LPs and stating that they are awesome is just using your influence to whitelist market participants and is very self-serving. Large pension funds have a lot of problems too, like embezzlement/corruption/failing fiduciary duties. So it is pretty binary, either you are transparent or you are not. And if you are not, claiming that you are better then others, is just marketing. It is pretty low to use someone tragic death to score some cheap deal flow points.
- jypepin 8y agoI've never been in the game, so it's hard for me to judge, and too easy to say "yeah! Always do the right/perfect thing". I still appreciate this kind of comments, especially is they help some people, sometimes make a better decision. But I think it's not always as straight forward as what the article is making it sound. A few following questions - Pension funds? How proud should they be about managing their money? I'm sure pension funds do a lot of shady things, have corruption, etc. even the ones for teachers, firemen etc. - What if your company is doing something very good for the world, but has trouble finding financing. Does it balances out? Is it better to let something great for the world die in the name of not taking dirty money? Or vice versa? - Where do you draw the line? Related to my first question. A gulf dictator is bad, but corrupted US funds are better? How about taking money from Leman Brothers post-crisis for example?
- timavr 8y agoThe whole premise of good/bad money is misleading. There is legal/illegal, which is super clear. Good/Bad is really up to individual and company to decide. But if someone took Saudi money which US government takes every week during Bill Auction, then they shouldn’t be judged worse then the government itself. And the US uses this money to pay teachers and firefighters which finishes in pension funds, which at this point is clean money, according to Fred.
- enter_life 8y agoI have a feeling that this is going to be yet another wave that passes in a few days without any long-term consequences :(
- rajacombinator 8y agoIf you’re willing to take this guy’s money after reading Hatching Twitter, I doubt there’s anything that could convince you otherwise.
- person_of_color 8y agotl;dr?
- chutiyapanti 8y agoWell, please do correct me if am wrong, but I have always had the notion that most instances of extreme wealth throughout the history has always been built on some kind of unethical (unethical is a very mild word in my opinion) activity, or let's say some activity that was unfair to a large amount of other people. Consider the wealth generated by Bill Gates or Mark Zuckerberg. I can't take away from them the fact that they worked hard when they saw a great opportunity and made themselves insanely wealthy in doing so, but history will may not judge their actions in a way that they are shown as messiahs. So I find all this discussion just a bit hypocritical to be very honest. Comments most welcome to change my, rather cynical, opinion.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]