18 ms·
The rise of the robot farmer
- ihuman 8y agoOP's link goes to a comment. Here is a fixed link: https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2018/oct/20/space-robots-lasers-rise-robot-farmer https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2018/oct/20/space-ro...
- uxhack 8y agoI think op wanted to point out the comment that was saying how impossible picking grapes would be by ai.
- the-pigeon 8y agoBah. Difficult is the word. When someone says something is impossible is just means they don't know how to solve the problem.
- dbcurtis 8y agoOr maybe the guy that "knows how to solve the problem" is solving some other problem, not the actual problem. I count three wine makers among my friends. None of them machine harvest their own grapes, nor will source machine harvested grapes from other growers. It would be very bad for their respective brand images.
- PhasmaFelis 8y agoDoes that mean they're convinced the results would be unsatisfactory, or just that their rustic image is more valuable than increased efficiency?
- dbcurtis 8y agoSome of both. Machine harvested grapes have a lot of field run, leaves and twigs, etc, and also the grapes are not as gently handled. So you at least have to keep the larger pieces of cruft out of the fermentation vats. But marketing image is also a big part of it, rightly or wrongly, which is all top-line dollars, less cost of harvesting crew, of course, but it pencils out. We are talking premium wines here, not two-buck-Chuck.
- HeyLaughingBoy 8y agoWhy does it need to be AI? One of my neighbors has an Italian tractor that harvests grapes. Just takes one person to drive it along the vines.
- dang 8y agoFixed now. Thanks! The comment was https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2018/oct/20/space-robots-lasers-rise-robot-farmer#comment-121692929 https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2018/oct/20/space-ro... if anyone's curious.
- uxhack 8y agoIn Spain and in Portugal grape harvesting machines are common. They are also used for harvesting olives. The vines have to be planted in hedges. The machines straddle the hedges and gently shake the tree with rubber flippers. The vines have to be ripped out when they become to brittle.
- rripken 8y agoWe have mechanical harvesters in California but I haven't seen any that are gentle or use rubber flippers. Mechanical harvesters typically shake the trees/trunks a small amount but quite quickly. For grapes the shaking might move the top of the vine a foot or so at several hertz. The shaking is strong enough that most grapes are plucked off the stem merely because of the weight of the berry and the whip-like motion of the shaking. The newer style bow rod machines use multiple UHMW rods bent into a question mark like shape. A large number of materials were tried but UHMW is the strongest material that could be found for the application. If adamantium or vibranium could be sourced I'm sure it would be used.
- pwaivers 8y ago> “I expected farmers to be quite luddite about the adoption of new technology,” he [Ben Scott-Robinson] says, as he packs Rachel away. I actually assume farmers are very welcoming of technology. They are hard workers and good business men. Usually technology makes them more efficient and more money.
- decebalus1 8y ago> I actually assume farmers are very welcoming of technology They should be, especially wrt to automation, considering farmers have been the most prolific in hiring undocumented workers while at the same time being some of the most vocal republican supporters. WAY less cognitive dissonance.
- borkt 8y agoA lot of them use legitimate guest worker systems, and it benefits everyone to have access to these workers.
- decebalus1 8y ago'a lot of them' means exactly nothing. How many? Do you have some numbers? Last time I checked, the dept of labor was saying that about 40% of all agricultural workers are illegal immigrants and United Fresh Produce Association between 50 and 70 percent. So yeah, a lot of them don't use 'legit' systems. It must be very hard to cheer for building 'the wall' while employing illegals and getting federal subsidies. That's why I have great faith in farming automation as it would provide some well deserved relief.
- bluGill 8y agoFarmers is plural - there are many of them and they do not agree. The farmers hiring illegals are not the same ones against building the walls. I do know a farmer who have stopped offering more wages when they didn't get anyone to agree to work for $25/hr - meanwhile he can find illegals who will work for $15. (Compare to what walMart pays, he isn't trying to hire engineers)
- pwaivers 8y ago> This is the one note of darkness that enters an otherwise optimistic conversation. “This technology could be used in a completely different way,” he says. “You could have entire states in America with no people in them. The potential for what we’re doing to be used in the wrong way is there.” What is inherently wrong or evil about this? If we could automate a state-size farm to feed everyone, isn't that a good thing?
- wolfram74 8y agoWell, the one person in the state would get two senators and a representative, so that's one thing to consider.
- neuromantik8086 8y agoThat's why I'd be in favor of making vertical farming more prevalent- by making farmers physically closer to the coastal cities they serve the rural areas will be starved economically. At this point in time, it's my conviction that retribution for the present tyranny of the minority will best come through technological means rather than warfare or politics.
- aurailious 8y agoFully automated tower farms are a dream of the future city.
- nradov 8y agoVertical farming is a pipe dream for everything but specialized high-margin produce. There's just not enough space to grow staple crops in coastal cities. Those volume crops will always be grown in large open areas and then hauled in to population centers. And no, improvements in solar cell efficiency or whatever won't change that equation.
- neuromantik8086 8y ago> in coastal cities I've never heard this being proposed- most vertical farming startups with any true prospects tend to be just outside the cities, but substantially closer than other farms. The chief advantage in vertical farming has nothing to do with actually farming within a city and everything to do with shortening supply lines. Likewise, I've never seen any company propose that they could completely replace conventional farms, but it's worth noting that every crop that can be grown with vertical farms allows another crop to be grown on arable land.
- rmason 8y agoIn Michigan we've already got family farms with a man, two sons and a single employee handling 10,000 acres. Robots driving tractors, trucks and combines would allow that to expand 5-6X. In turn that would lead to a reduction in farmers of up to 80%. This is a trend that has been running for close to a hundred years. Remember at one time a quarter of America's population were farmers and now it's under 2%.
- clarkmoody 8y agoThe immense productivity gains in agriculture have driven down food costs, which improves the standard of living of everyone. It also frees up those who would have worked farm jobs to do higher-valued labor in the economy.
- radiorental 8y ago> frees up those who would have worked farm jobs to do higher-valued labor in the economy That's the ideal, in reality too many of these people live in areas where there are no other opportunities. They are also often fed the line that the job can be brought back. Put simply, we've observed generational shifts to higher-valued jobs in urban areas. A farmer, coal miner , etc who loses their job today is unlikely to re-skill & move to other industries
- dv_dt 8y ago> A farmer, coal miner , etc who loses their job today is unlikely to re-skill & move to other industries Don't confuse what is the current outcome with what has to be the outcome. Those individuals might not reskill in todays environment because of a combination of receiving an insufficient amount of the value they produced in their wages (preventing them from having the resources to retrain themselves), as well as social programs for reskilling being severely limited in both funding and how they constrain how and what skills are trained. (preventing gov't resources from retraining workers). Neither of those has to be a forgone conclusion.
- 8y ago
- Invictus0 8y agoPotentially relevant article that came to mind: https://www.bloomberg.com/graphics/2018-us-land-use/ https://www.bloomberg.com/graphics/2018-us-land-use/ The point about entire states being used for agriculture is interesting, and I guess whether you see this as utopic or dystopic really depends on the nature of the owner of the land. If the government owned the machines, land, and produce, and socialized the gains, this seems like a utopic solution, although obviously there is potential for abuse and bureaucrazy. On the other hand, if a corporation owned it, it would seem very bizarre and symbolic of income inequality. I wonder if Marx was simply too early. Let the machines be the proletariat and let all of society be the bourgeoisie, and maybe communism can work in some industries.
- stevenwoo 8y agoThat was a pretty inspirational tale about the startup the guy founded in terms of purpose and possibility and application of technology. For me it's better than anything I've heard about recently in America, though I am not an expert in this.
- thruflo22 8y agoI’m co-founder of the “space bots with lasers” company. Happy to answer any questions.
- noonespecial 8y agoCool. How does the laser kill the weed without risking starting a fire that might damage the crops?
- nkoren 8y agoNot the OP, but I'd just point out that all you should need to do is get the stem above the boiling point of water, which is well below the combustion point. What wavelength to use for that could be an interesting discussion. Makes me wonder whether you could use masers (microwave lasers) rather than optical lasers for a more efficient "heating the weed from the inside" effect.
- thruflo22 8y agoYup. There are peaks for energy transfer into water around 1 and 2 microns. So mid-IR.
- philipkglass 8y agoWhat precautions do you need to maintain eye safety around these bots? Can lasers kill weeds at the root, or do you just keep them "mowed" down to size with repeated applications?
- thruflo22 8y agoA skirt around the laser. There’s a few techniques. You can cut the meristem or you can heat the weed. If you can explode the physiology, they don’t grow back.
- nathan_long 8y agoHow efficient is laser weeding in time and energy? Like, can the robot move down the row as fast as a human weeding by hand? Can it carry a car battery and weed for an eight hour shift?
- zackmorris 8y agoNow for a bit of hubris: anyone else reading this feel that building a robot that could do pest/weed control and harvesting is almost a triviality compared to say, fixing enterprise software to maximize customer purchases and ad revenue? What are we all doing? Seriously, why can't each of us take a year of our lives and automate all the most awful jobs in the world? Asking for a friend :-P
- wccrawford 8y agoSee the XKCD comic about pictures in parks and kinds of birds.
- zackmorris 8y agoHah thanks for that! https://xkcd.com/1425/ https://xkcd.com/1425/ Still, image recognition is effectively a solved problem at this point for AI. Maybe there are still problems with notation and terminology that prevent widespread adoption?
- stevenwoo 8y agoIs there an update to this story or is it not true or some other possibility? https://www.wired.com/story/when-it-comes-to-gorillas-google-photos-remains-blind/ https://www.wired.com/story/when-it-comes-to-gorillas-google... If you prefer a story not on wired (sometimes it shows a subscription nag for me) - https://www.theverge.com/2018/1/12/16882408/google-racist-gorillas-photo-recognition-algorithm-ai https://www.theverge.com/2018/1/12/16882408/google-racist-go...
- PhasmaFelis 8y agoI don't think that's changed, no. My hypothesis, incidentally, is that it's really hard for an AI to tell the difference between human and ape facial features at all; they're too similar. It seems easy to us because a big chunk of the human brain is devoted to face processing. The AI pretty much just knew "primate face," and knew that pale primate faces were usually human, but with a dark primate face it could only guess. (Which doesn't excuse Google for releasing it in that state, of course.)
- elchief 8y agoAs imagined in 1984 in Runaway starring Tom Selleck: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pan5Jo91e8I https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pan5Jo91e8I
- stevenwoo 8y agoOr more optimistically, 1972's Silent Running.
- sleepychu 8y agoI've been interested in setting up setting up some sort of micro farm in my flat (led based) for a few years. Anyone got some good resources for the novice micro farmer? (I like robotics/automation as well so if I could blend that in it would be cool)
- HeyLaughingBoy 8y agoForget LEDs and just put it in a window that faces the sun.
- sleepychu 8y agoHah, what sun? I live in Scotland :-(
- stevenwoo 8y agoThe personal food computer here looks applicable but that seems like some wasted space vertically depending upon the plant desired. https://www.media.mit.edu/groups/open-agriculture-openag/projects/ https://www.media.mit.edu/groups/open-agriculture-openag/pro...
- hvass 8y agoRelated: Can someone from the industry share what is the current status of vertical farming? Is this considered the future or the verdict is not out yet? Any good people/startups/articles to check out?
- jelliclesfarm 8y agoNo one is making a profit. Yet. Energy costs a lot. Even led has gone great strides. Operational costs are expensive and lettuce won’t rake it in. Marijuana growers are likely killing it but I am pretty sure they won’t be tripping over to share data. But a head of lettuce is around $1.50. A lb of marijuana is like ..what..$250 now? So.
- otakucode 8y agoI eagerly await the introduction of fully automated farming. Not, however, on farms. In my own garage. I see no reason I should simply let a "farmer" purchase the automation gear and then collect profit after wasting tons of energy in transportation. There's dirt, water, and sun at my house. There's no reason a robotic farming situation couldn't be shrunk down and made into something private individuals or small families could own to provide for their own food needs.
- nradov 8y agoThere's nothing stopping you from planting a garden today. It's not a huge amount of work, and any robots that become available in the next few years will only marginally reduce that labor.
- otakucode 8y agoIt's not a huge amount of work, but it is a significant time investment. I'm thinking more of a nearly-sealed box that is entirely automated, a family could purchase for a couple thousand dollars, and then it produces food for a few years. It's not so much robots in the sense of things which drive around the landscape that will improve that sort of things, but the work in the 'vertical farming' market. Isolated systems which eliminate the need for pesticides, herbicides, etc, can greatly reduce water usage, can optimize light cycling, maybe even automatically perform selective breeding to a degree, etc.
- HeyLaughingBoy 8y agoYou're very unlikely to get a couple thousand dollars of food over a couple of years out of even a large "box," where the box is approximately the size of a bedroom. This is one of those cases where it's cheaper to simply buy the food from someone who has economies of scale on his side. It costs even less if you cut out the middlemen (supermarkets, distribution, etc) and buy directly from the farmers where possible.
- nradov 8y agoVertical farming is not an economical method of producing useful quantities of food. The people pursuing it appear to be motivated by utopian idealism and inaccurate cost estimates. Any future "farm in a box" is going to require about as much labor as a garden does today. Someone has to clean the filters, wipe off the mold, plug the leaks, replace the corroded parts, etc. Those activities won't be practical to automate in our lifetimes.
- nathan_long 8y agoThe pitch from Small Robot Company's home page (https://www.smallrobotcompany.com/ https://www.smallrobotcompany.com/): > We’re an agri-tech start up commercialising a deceptively simple idea: small robots not big tractors. > Because unfortunately big tractors are neither efficient nor environmentally friendly. Currently, 95% of energy is used ploughing. And ploughing is only necessary because of heavy machinery crushing soil. > We are building robots that will seed and care for each individual plant in your crop. They will only feed and spray the plants that need it, giving them the perfect levels nutrients and support, with no waste. > This level of detail allows you to be kinder to soil, kinder to the environment, more efficient, more precise and more productive. It’s the best of all worlds. An increased yield, as well as minimal chemical usage. So you can increase revenues by up to 40%, reduce costs by up to 60%. > Our robots are being designed and built by farmers, for farmers. Because we have spent the last year talking to you, we know you don’t want to buy robots. You are worried about the cost, and what happens if they break down. Instead you can lease our robots through a Farming as a Service (FaaS) model. Obviously it may not be as good as it sounds. But it sounds amazing. Also these quotes from the article about scale were interesting: > The agility of agricultural robots means small farms with compact fields will no longer be at a disadvantage; independent shops and restaurants will be able to grow their produce on smallholdings efficiently tended by Rachel-like machines. > ... > “Most people think this is going to be expensive, is going to do everyone out of a job and is going to be good for the big farms, not the small farms,” he says. “It’s actually the exact opposite. The big farms are all about economies of scale: big fields, big tractors. We are developing small machines. I believe the extra production we need to feed the planet is going to come from small farms that can’t use those economies of scale.” I love the idea of a farmer on 2 acres competing with Big Ag on price.
- nitwit005 8y agoI'm slightly surprised the use of the laser is killing weeds instead of insects. There have been some prior efforts at killing mosquitos with lasers: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mosquito_laser https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mosquito_laser
- beerlord 8y agoHuman ingenuity is amazing when applied to labour shortages. The Black Death, Brexit, the recent American Immigration Crackdown. All of these events reduced the supply of labour, resulting in increased wages and productivity. Goes to show that arguments about needing migrants and refugees from poor countries to fill labour shortages in the West do not hold water.
- jelliclesfarm 8y agoI am encouraged by what they are doing across the pond. Not so much stateside. I have been trying to form a framework for a few years now. Small acreage farmers growing organically need automation. Large corporate farms are already mechanized. As are most commodity crops. Speciality crops that need a lot of human labour and expertise..especially in organic operations need help from automation and robotics tech. The trend I am seeing in the US is mostly data collecting intelligence. Everyone is doing something in AI or ML or blockchain. But small acreage farmers like me need more automation. I have noticed that the trend in the states seems to be data collection technology which needs massive datasets. There isn’t a lot of care or use from small acreage farms. This is the biggest stumbling block for small farms(less than 100 acres) to be included in the big boys game. We need small cheap robots that does a diverse set of tasks. At this point, for small farms, human intelligence trumps AI. But data is king. More money is made off data harvested from farmers than the actual produce itself. Because farmers sell wholesale but we pay retail for the tech. We are lagging behind in the United States compared to endevours in the EU or down under. Not everyone can be a unicorn. Not everything has to be big. In a way..we don’t have to try because we have super cheap migrant labour. For now. I will bet my bottom dollar that it will be gone in a few years time. What then? We are also spoilt for choice by the produce bounty from Mexico. But for how long? As a small farmer who is interested in automation, a few thoughts : 1. I would like a robotic platform that can be modular depending on my operation. Diff farmers use diff methods. We live in diff zones and have diff pests and diff soil and diff water. One size won’t fit all. 2. There is more to farm labour than just weeding bots. 3. I need to own my farm’s data and be able to commodify it. 4. We need to be partners. Because bots are not farmers and the industry needs us to train them. Include us. I am the domain expert. Not the roboticist or the engineer. 5. I would pay upto 20-25k for a robotic platform with a certain set of features. It’s worth it for me. That’s because I have a smattering of interest about robotics and automation to know what’s possible and how much it would cost. I also know how valuable data is and I want to make money off my data. A seemingly expensive platform is still worth that to me..however, I find it very difficult to convince my fellow farmers. Why? Distrust. 6. Farmers distrust technology because we deal with perishables and tech we can’t control is our work rotting in the field. 7. Farmers don’t get enough respect. Not the farming concerns with 10s of thousands of acres or corporate farms that have lobbies and trade memberships. Not commodity farmers..but regular farmers who sell at the farmers markets or to restaurants. 8. Nobody works with us. They ask us questions and once funding comes through, they are being nudged towards larger farms. They won’t grow bitter melon or fenugreek. Those huge farms won’t grow the eggplant from Laos or India. Or that specific spicy hot pepper from some place in South America. Without small farmers, we will all be eating the same kinds of foods. Same variety of tomato or the same kind of sweet pepper bred for machine harvest and mass production. I started out naive. I am not under any illusion anymore that I can design a small acreage robotic platform. But now I know what’s out there and how I can make it work for smaller operations. And how to integrate the many things we do seamlessly as a new kind of Ag for us. Afterall, in other countries..the average farm size is 2-3 hectares. And they feed local population. So my platform will be useful elsewhere even if it doesn’t gain traction in the states. I also have realistic expectations of technology now. And people. I am excited every time I read about innovations across the pond. Maybe we will get it for small acreage specialty crop organic farmers here. Or maybe not. But when we consider global momentum, some really exciting things are happening. And it’s happening fast!
- winningcontinue 8y agothis doesn't sound like it's even in the technology's infancy. prototypes are being drawn up in the labs. they don't understand any drawbacks. when they eventually come up with something, inevitably it'd disappoint and fail. I can't see robots making the complex decisions of harvesting individual plants with all its variables involved, especially at the scale to not fail. This is much more than three years ago. This is a cheer leading fluff piece.