31 ms·
Apple CEO Tim Cook Calling for Bloomberg to Retract Its Chinese Spy Chip Story
- crb002 8y agoIowans are calling on tax crook Tim Cook to respond to the Libertarian lawsuit he bribed the City of Waukee $100m influencing their vote to abate $170m. If you or I paid our city $1000 to abate $1700 unjustly enriching the city at the expense of the school/county/State we would be in jail.
- aparadja 8y agoI think this is not related at all to the linked article. If you have a story about this, could you post it as a separate link and see how it does on its own? Trying to hijack other threads with politically loaded stuff usually goes sour here.
- kreetx 8y agoSubmit this as a separate story if you think this is important! As you see, you're downvoted since this lacks context and sounds harsh. EDIT: double barrel! Well done, aparadja :)
- androidgirl 8y agoReally interesting twist in a crazy story that's gotten this far. I'm interested in seeing how this all plays out, Bloomberg's reaction, etc. At this point I don't know what to think, so I'm waiting for the consensus.
- jjtheblunt 8y agoGood because Bloomberg seems to feel entitled to behave like a new incarnation of the New York Times, maligning with impunity.
- moocowtruck 8y agoi'd rather these big companies like apple faceboook google, to own up to their security breaches and waste less time on bloomberg crap
- cirenehc 8y agoAllegations of a security breach is useless without evidence backing it up. So far, Bloomberg has provided zero evidence.
- paleotrope 8y agoYeah, someone needs to cough up a compromised board here. Otherwise the whole story stinks.
- unknownid 8y agoIn this case, there is no evidence saying Apple has anything to fix.
- stingraycharles 8y agoIt’s fascinating to see this story unfold. On one end you have Bloomberg doubling down on their claims, and here you have Apple making a move that shows their confidence in their claims. For a while I was buying the subpoena theory, but this action clearly doesn’t fall under that, and they would be setting themselves up for serious liability / damage claims if it were true. Either there is some gross miscommunication going on inside Apple and Tim Cook is not properly informed - which is very unlikely at this point - or there might be less truth to Bloomberg’s story. The frustrating thing is, we’ll probably never know the answer.
- fullshark 8y agoGiven the hack involves hardware I'm quite inclined to believe Apple and all the strong denials.
- manfredo 8y agoI concur. If it really is a chip being inserted on a board, then that's hard evidence that can be verified by cracking open the hardware and looking for said chip.
- duskwuff 8y agoAnd Apple -- being, in part, a hardware company -- has extensive tools and expertise at their disposal to investigate any hardware abnormality. If they've concluded that everything is normal, I'm inclined to believe them.
- munificent 8y agoCook is claiming everything is normal, but that doesn't necessarily mean that's what Apple actually knows and believes. It is also possible that they have investigated, did find tampering, and are still publicly denying it.
- 8y ago
- fhood 8y agoMan, I am now 90% convinced that someone intentionally misled Bloomberg. It looks like this may end up being an extremely embarrassing episode for them.
- flamtap 8y agoAnd potentially a group of people. Maybe I am giving Bloomberg too much credit at this point, but their article cites a number of sources -- albeit anonymous ones -- and I think it could very well be a coordinated effort from a group of interested parties.
- acqq 8y agoSee what one of the sources says: https://risky.biz/RB517_feature/ https://risky.biz/RB517_feature/ He showed the “emails he sent to Bloomberg, prior to the story’s publication, that said the hardware back-dooring the article described “didn’t make sense”.” Another text about that source: https://iphone.appleinsider.com/articles/18/10/08/security-researcher-cited-in-bloombergs-china-spy-chip-investigation-casts-doubt-on-storys-veracity https://iphone.appleinsider.com/articles/18/10/08/security-r...
- aero142 8y agoIt's all just speculation but this seems like the exact kind of story you would want in order to pass some legislation to prevent foreign manufactured chips being used by USG.
- lwansbrough 8y agoI'm all for globalism but that's one area where the best strategy is probably to keep production inside the borders. Not that I'd condone misleading the press to create a case for the legislation.
- sneak 8y agoYes, manufacture the high security chips on one of the many 7nm fabs in the US. I suppose it also follows that the fab and design should be staffed only as NOFORN? That rules out the lead on the Apple silicon team. I don’t think you understand how this works. This isn’t a nationalism vs globalism thing.
- newscracker 8y agoWith all the strong denials so far, my guess is that heads are going to roll at Bloomberg and that there may be retractions. Worst case, Bloomberg gets caught as publishing fake news endangering entire countries and companies, and closes shop in shame. There’s too much at stake for Bloomberg here. Hopefully someone at the top at Bloomberg is taking this seriously and looking at some quick and decisive actions. These back and forth exchanges don’t seem to be working well in Bloomberg’s favor as far as perceptions are concerned. Bloomberg might also find itself an outcast in the tech circles.
- blueboo 8y agoIf this were proved beyond a shadow of a doubt, China would be shown to be guilty of a massive act of corporate espionage. Surely geopolitical pressure combined with the commercial pressure for that not to happen is enough for Bloomberg to retract its story regardless of truth?
- newscracker 8y agoYes, that’s also possible in making Bloomberg retract the story. But it would take a big hit on its reputation (whatever it is) and also lose a lot of sources. I’d also imagine reporters leaving it for other places, thus making it worse. It seems like there’s no good ending for Bloomberg in this story. One escape route seems to be the nuclear option of revealing some (not all) sources, what they said, when, where, etc. But that also guarantees a mutually assured destruction. I feel bad for the Bloomberg reporters now (assuming they didn’t do this out of malice and dishonesty). Maybe a closed hearing with all parties involved could bring some closure, with some face saving retraction or statements.
- eiaoa 8y ago> If this were proved beyond a shadow of a doubt, China would be shown to be guilty of a massive act of corporate espionage. > Surely geopolitical pressure combined with the commercial pressure for that not to happen is enough for Bloomberg to retract its story regardless of truth? Perhaps that could also be the source of Apple and Amazon's strong denials. What if they were told on no uncertain terms by the Chinese that if they corroborated Bloomberg's story, they would be shut out from the Chinese market? The PRC could even cripple Apple's international operations by interfering with their manufacturing. I think Tim Cook would have a very hard time doing anything but deny, if confirmation meant writing off a billion-user market and justifying it to Apple's shareholders.
- mohammedbin 8y agoSomething I posted elsewhere - I highly doubt Bloomberg would run this story without a lot of faith in this. Michael Bloomberg has strongly hinted at plans to run for president on a democratic ticket and it's in his interest to undermine trumps anti-china agenda and something you can expect his eponymous news org to help him with.
- eli 8y agoIt's a reputable news organization. Mike ain't calling the editorial shots. It's possible that both sides completely and earnestly believe their story is correct.
- jimmydef 8y agoJournalistic freedom in the US has allowed American journalists and news organisations to publish a lot of untruths. The hurdle to prosecute for slander and libel is much much higher in the US than many other European countries. We can debate its pros and cons but that's the way it is currently and Michael Bloomberg would not be affected in the slightest even if it turns out the story is all toss. This is especially so in the current "China threat" political climate in the US. China is essentially a boogieman in the US right now and attacking it has proven to be a great generator of votes for politicians.
- mohammedbin 8y agoI agree with all you said but it seems that you misunderstood what I was trying to convey (or I what you were trying to convey) I'm saying Bloomberg the publication is likely right about the story because they are taking a stand that hurts Bloomberg the persons presidential aspirations. They wouldn't have ran it unless it really was something.
- parliament32 8y agoInteresting tidbit from the linked twitter post: "Something is wrong. Blanket denials from companies, NCSC and DHS are v. unusual. The only precedent for this is a 2014 Bloomberg article, by the same author, which claimed NSA exploited Heartbleed, and was vigorously knocked down with zero follow up by Bloomberg or correction." https://twitter.com/nicoleperlroth https://twitter.com/nicoleperlroth
- sandyarmstrong 8y agoFor the lazy: https://twitter.com/nicoleperlroth/status/1049018902984835072 https://twitter.com/nicoleperlroth/status/104901890298483507...
- krn 8y agoI think it's in the best interest of the US not to turn this case into international relations nightmare. > I mean, this is just intense now. On record statements from four different huge players in this field, clearly and forcefully stating there was no hardware-based backdoor inserted by PLA with regard to Apple and Amazon. https://twitter.com/hatr/status/1048859348489916417 https://twitter.com/hatr/status/1048859348489916417
- crankylinuxuser 8y agoLong story short, this is really wanting me to obtain the gerbers for the motherboards I use, and verify the parts on the board are the parts listed. This the basis of open source hardware. The next step is to obtain firmware for each chip, and compile and load it on all programmable chips. Again, but open source firmware. Then moving up, we need an open source OS, which we have. The last area is having open source silicon... but given that it's $10m minimum for a basic fab, this isn't happening anytime soon. Although, FPGAs could supplant some hardware. Then we'd need the synthesis code for the design. Long story short, is there a way to make a trustworthy OS if you don't trust the underlying hardware? Is that even possible?
- 8y ago
- tw1010 8y agoHas anyone written a blog about the game theory of this whole ordeal? Feels a bit like the snowdrift game.
- why_only_15 8y agoI feel like we don't really know enough what is happening. It is very possible, as another commenter mentioned, that both sides are acting in good faith.
- sharemywin 8y ago“Seventeen individual sources, including government officials and insiders at the companies, confirmed the manipulation of hardware and other elements of the attacks. We also published three companies’ full statements, as well as a statement from China’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs. We stand by our story and are confident in our reporting and sources.”
- gvb 8y agoOTOH, Joe Fitzpatrick, one of the few named sources, is very very doubtful of the veracity of the story. Blog interview with Joe Fitzpatrick: https://risky.biz/RB517_feature/ https://risky.biz/RB517_feature/ https://appleinsider.com/articles/18/10/08/security-researcher-cited-in-bloombergs-china-spy-chip-investigation-casts-doubt-on-storys-veracity https://appleinsider.com/articles/18/10/08/security-research...
- woodrowbarlow 8y agothat's a credible perspective but let's not be vague: fitzpatrick wasn't a primary source, he is an expert on hardware implants who was consulted by the reporter prior to the original publication.
- sooheon 8y agoReading between the lines, Fitzpatrick's claim is that other primary sources could be fictitious, and the writer fabricated them based on interviews with him.
- duskwuff 8y agoFitzpatrick wasn't a primary source, but somehow his theories on how an implant could theoretically be implemented appeared in the Bloomberg story, as details of how it was actually implemented. This seems really fishy.
- exabrial 8y agoThis is turning out to be one of the most bizarre news stories ever
- grillvogel 8y agoguys the government and corporations all told us that it wasn't true, we have to believe them. they wouldn't lie about this.
- elicash 8y agoLet me ask you the question this way. What evidence would have to be produced for you to disbelieve the Bloomberg reporting?
- Rainymood 8y agoRemember that article where Bloomberg employees get paid more if their stories move markets? Yeah ...
- Stryder 8y agoThere is a distinct whiff of the aroma of propaganda around this one.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- hugh4life 8y agoIf it turns out to be false, should the SEC look into it?
- jsoc815 8y agoPossibly, but in all likelihood, no. I know that some people here like to get hung up on literal interpretations and stated missions, but they really shouldn't. (Sorry, can't get into it here.) For many reasons, there isn't a lot of good that would come from them making a big deal about this among the general public. Feel free to see my earlier post.[1] [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18141186 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18141186
- jsoc815 8y agoSeriously, how is a public SEC investigation going to benefit the "integrity" of the system and "inspire confidence among investors"? If the story is both fake and some grand market manipulating plot, most people involved are 1) going to hope that the public forgets that this story ever was; and 2) deal w/this privately. But since some clearly disagree, I eagerly await your well-informed case.
- kentuf 8y agoNo, I think we should create a new Ministry, let's call it the Ministry of Truth, and they are responsible for dealing with these Fake News™ stories before they are published. No more anonymous sources!
- appleiigs 8y agoWhat happens to Tim Cook if Bloomberg is correct?
- Pharmakon 8y agoHe utterly loses the confidence of his shareholders and customers, and probably leaves Apple. I don’t know if this story is true or not, but I doubt he’s going to be in a position to be proven outright wrong. I’d he were, I think he’d be keeping shtum.
- brynjolf 8y agoHe lied to congress before about tax. I think he will be fine. He is a seasoned and perpetual liar.
- electrograv 8y agoI think Bloomberg was probably irresponsible to publish the Chinese spy chip story, whether it was true or false! Here's why: * If the story is false, it's irresponsible because it causes severe monetary and reputational damage to companies that do not deserve it (e.g. Supermicro's stock is still down ~ 40%). * If the story is true, it's a MAJOR breach of classified information from US intelligence operations; operations which I assume (without evidence to the contrary) are operating in good faith -- in the interest of the US and its citizens. Breaching classified information of such ongoing investigations to trace supply chains of spy chips could very well compromise those investigations (which would be irresponsible to risk). So either way, it's irresponsible IMO. P.S. IMO you cannot justify leaking this kind of info by comparing to Snowden, for example, because Snowden was a whistle-blower revealing information about operations that compromised citizens rights, which even congress was lied to about.
- twtw 8y ago> may take a huge stock market and reputation hit I think you can use the past tense here.
- electrograv 8y agoFixed!
- IBM 8y agoIt's not irresponsible at all if the story is true. Bloomberg has no responsibility to Supermicro's stock (or anyone else's). They also aren't responsible for protecting classified information. But the story probably isn't true.
- electrograv 8y agoI'm not trying to argue that Bloomberg did anything illegal, so lets stay away from that red herring. I'm talking about whether their action was morally right; granted, morality and civic duty is a much more ambiguous topic, and I'm open to the possibility that my position is incorrect here. To make an analogy: What if a newspaper was given sensitive personal information about someone that was legal to publish, but could have damaging effects to that person and the population as a whole if published too soon? Do newspapers have a civic responsibility to hold off on publishing information that would only be damaging to everyone (at least until it's safe to do so)?
- mrb 8y agoIn the past, Apple has lied about a severe security incident involving Super Micro hardware. In 2016 Super Micro Senior Vice President of Technology himself said Apple found "infected firmware." It was so bad that Apple "discontinued future business [with Super Micro] as a result of a compromised internal development environment". Strangely Apple at the time was denying the whole thing: https://appleinsider.com/articles/17/02/23/server-firmware-security-incident-in-2016-forced-apple-to-sever-ties-with-vendor-super-micro https://appleinsider.com/articles/17/02/23/server-firmware-s... But today, 2 years later, in a statement denying the current spy chip saga, Apple now appears to acknowledge this 2016 security incident, while minimizing it: they say it was "an infected driver on a single Super Micro server in one of our labs" (https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2018/10/what-businessweek-got-wrong-about-apple/ https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2018/10/what-businessweek-got...) Why would Apple deny then 2 years later confirm this security incident? As usual, the truth is probably somewhere in the middle. It is very possible the anonymous sources at Apple who support the spy chip story are not technical persons and are confusing this 2016 incident with the spy chip incident (in fact it's what Apple theorizes in their statement.) It is very possible the spy chip does exist and was found at some companies, just not at Apple. I also find it very interesting that the FBI, the one organization allegedly at the center of this saga investigating the spy chip, has remained completely silent, neither confirming nor denying the story.
- IBM 8y agoWhat they denied was that the servers were used in production. They also said they didn't find the firmware on the server as shipped from Supermicro, it was downloaded from their website [1]. >Update: A source familiar with the case at Apple told Ars that the compromised firmware affected servers in Apple's design lab, and not active Siri servers. The firmware, according to the source, was downloaded directly from Supermicro's support site—and that firmware is still hosted there. Apple issued the following official comment: Apple is deeply committed to protecting the privacy and security of our customers and the data we store. We are constantly monitoring for any attacks on our systems, working closely with vendors and regularly checking equipment for malware. We’re not aware of any data being transmitted to an unauthorized party nor was any infected firmware found on the servers purchased from this vendor. >I also find it very interesting that the FBI, the one organization at the center of this saga who is allegedly investigating the spy chip, has remained completely silent, neither confirming nor denying the story. That's not true. Christopher Wray, in a congressional hearing, said "be careful what you read" in a response to a question about the story [2]. [1] https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2017/02/apple-axed-supermicro-servers-from-datacenters-because-of-bad-firmware-update/ https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2017/02/apple... [2] https://www.cnbc.com/2018/10/10/fbi-director-wray-on-super-micro-servers-be-careful-what-you-read.html https://www.cnbc.com/2018/10/10/fbi-director-wray-on-super-m...
- apeace 8y agoIs the following a possible explanation? * Random Apple engineer finds the implant. * Goes directly to FBI without telling boss at Apple. * FBI gags the engineer, says "Do not even tell your boss about this, it's national security and we're handling it". * Bloomberg catches wind of this (maybe the same engineer leaks to them?), publishes their story. * Engineer is now freaked, goes back to FBI and says "Are you really sure I shouldn't tell by boss?" and they say "Yes, we're sure, you are legally bound to secrecy". I don't know how security teams, the FBI, or national security work. But that's the only scenario that comes to my mind which would explain both sides being completely sure of their version of the story.
- xGrill 8y ago> Goes directly to FBI without telling boss at Apple. This is really hard to believe. An engineer who found this bug at Apple would most likely be praised for finding it. It is a huge discovery. What motivation would he have to not tell his manager?
- jsoc815 8y ago> would most likely be praised for finding it. It is a huge discovery. Seriously, history, recent and otherwise, is littered w/the ghosts and carcasses of employees who were anything but rewarded for identifying problems great and small. Oftentimes the safest thing to do is to pretend that one saw/heard/knows nothing while hoping that someone else has the steel to sound the alarm. And for this sort of situation, there's too much at stake and are too many known and unknown stakeholders involved to blindly believe that this would be an exception to what I wrote above. On a separate but related note, for those playing the "conspiracy theory" game: - On October 4th, Bloomberg releases The Big Hack story; and - On the same day, VP Pence gives a speech at the Hudson Institute about...? China being a bad actor which indulges in all sorts of behavior (that the United States would never ever engage in or condone).[1] Factor in the "trade war" and long-ongoing attempts to 'encourage' companies to rethink their supply chains/ relocate production... [1] https://www.hudson.org/events/1610-vice-president-mike-pence-s-remarks-on-the-administration-s-policy-towards-china102018 https://www.hudson.org/events/1610-vice-president-mike-pence...
- pastor_elm 8y agoBloomberg says they have THREE senior sources at Apple. Why would they retract? My guess is Cook is fishing for the leaker.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- cwyers 8y agoAnd Bloomberg is standing by the story. All of the people who think that Apple is being misled coerced by the government into denying factual reports, I want to know how that belief is squared with the _lack_ of a retraction. If the government is powerful enough to get Apple to go to these lengths in defense of a falsehood, why can't they convince Bloomberg to retract?
- bunnycorn 8y agoBecause "free press", "they are attacking the press", yadda yadda yadda.
- allemagne 8y agoAt this point I don't think Apple is lying or the Bloomberg story is accurate, but I do think that some hypothetical coercion of Apple would be much much much less problematic than the government literally forcing a press organization to publish false information.
- dannyw 8y agoPerhaps the answer is that Bloomberg were mislead, either by intentional state agents* or by a reporter who recklessly mis-understood and/or cherry-picked sources? * not necessarily from the US.
- jimmydef 8y agoI don't see any reason why the Trump administration and the intelligence community would ever want Apple to deny the reports. On the contrary, I think they would love it if Apple/Amazon came out and said that they were hacked so it can give further justification to the trade war and further paint China as a sinister threat to US security.
- vectorEQ 8y agohardware implants are why people do chip decapping and hardware assurance. this practice is more old than cybersecurity itself. even IF this story is false, the fact is that some actors implant chips into many many devices. these come from china, but ofcourse the contractors who make these chips aren't neccesarily only serving their own masters - that is an assumption. And lets not start about how hypocritical it is to put everything on china all the time while western governments just implement the same backdoors and data harvesting techniques in software. lawful intercept is a documented way to do it, but there's plenty undocumented. (as that once also was.) if you doubt this information, look on youtube for 'chip decapping defcon' and see how 2 british persons show how they do this kind of assurance work and show how people have already found these kind of implants many many many times before.!
- tunesmith 8y agoIs it precedented for a news organization to double down like this in the case where a reporter just makes stuff up Stephen Glass style? Because barring a Stephen Glass scenario, what's fascinating here is that no matter which side is right, this is evidence of some sort of mysterious power play. Either Apple was hacked, they know, and are denying, which is evidence of them being under the thumb of U.S. national security. Or, they were hacked and an internal team knows and Cook doesn't, which is evidence of U.S. national security having powerful influence inside of Apple. Or, they weren't hacked, and Bloomberg is doubling down, which at this point would mean that someone has successfully hacked their journalistic verification processes to an extreme level. In all three of those cases, it points to a level of attacker competence that I'm not normally inclined to believe in.
- vitalus 8y agoI don't agree with the "journalistic process being hacked" as being the only line there, as it implies some deliberate power play by bad actors which would omit said integrity. It seems plausible that it's more along the lines of "journalistic process being broken" for this type of article, that all parties might be acting in good faith and that there is some level of misunderstanding.
- Barrin92 8y agoYou don't need to resort to spooky forces to imagine why Apple wants to deny an attack on their security. It damages the value of the company, especially in a time when they try to market themselves as security conscious.
- Sephr 8y ago[comment deleted]
- jim-greer 8y agoIn the US a plantiff must prove negligence or malicious intent to win a libel case. That's a very high bar.
- genericone 8y agoJust curious, what would the libel case complaint be, how would the argument be structured?
- DannyBee 8y agoIn the US Apple would lose such a lawsuit for sure.
- tango24 8y ago> “We turned the company upside down,” Cook said. “Email searches, data center records, financial records, shipment records. We really forensically whipped through the company to dig very deep and each time we came back to the same conclusion: This did not happen. There’s no truth to this.” Wow, ok then..
- wpdev_63 8y agoI really have little doubt that the Chinese are integrating their spy chips into computer hardware going to the big four or even the pentagon. It's probably how they stole the designs to the f-35[you know that plane that costs over a trillion dollars to develop]. It would catastrophic if apple knew or even acknowledges the possibility of the Chinese having a backdoor into their servers and would result in massive shift in policy[+profit]. The NSA has been known to intercept electronics in shipping and putting in their own specialized pcb board replacements with microphones, cameras, etc. and are _very_ hard to detect. Hell the Russian even went back to typewriters for security purposes[0]. It would be foolish to think that the Chinese/Russians aren't doing the same thing to us. [0]:https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/europe/russia/10173645/Kremlin-returns-to-typewriters-to-avoid-computer-leaks.html https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/europe/russia/101...
- bnastic 8y ago> you know that plane that costs over a trillion dollars to develop From my understanding, it's the joint cost of the program over its projected lifetime over the next 50+ years. Not the cost of getting it up in the air.
- jschwartzi 8y agoI find it extremely hard to believe that China is inserting magic backdoor chips into all of our computer hardware. What's much more likely is that they were able to bribe or threaten some engineers into giving information away. That's been a common tactic since spying became a thing.
- bilbo0s 8y agoDoesn't even have to be an engineer. You gather intelligence wherever you can. The Chinese are at least as smart as I am, and for me, the guy who runs the xerox machine or cleans the office will do nicely, thank you very much. I don't need some high powered engineer. So I'm almost positive they don't either. It seems like putting magical chips into computers is one of the most difficult methods of acquiring what at the root would be the same intelligence.
- 8y ago
- cmurf 8y agoShades of Operation Mockingbird (1953), and "The CIA and the Media". http://www.carlbernstein.com/magazine_cia_and_media.php http://www.carlbernstein.com/magazine_cia_and_media.php Of course, whether the story is true or not matters, but at least as important is who Bloomberg's source is - as that goes to motive for releasing this information (true or false). And it isn't just Bloomberg who will be asking these kinds of questions.
- RaceWon 8y agoWell, Bush did say this ended in 1976 [1] "In February 1976, George H. W. Bush, the recently appointed Director of the CIA, announced a new policy: 'Effective immediately, the CIA will not enter into any paid or contract relationship with any full-time or part-time news correspondent accredited by any U.S. news service, newspaper, periodical, radio or television network or station.'{13} He added that the CIA would continue to 'welcome' the voluntary, unpaid cooperation of journalists." So there you go. Proof positive. + 1 On Mockingbird btw, I was reading the comments before I posted it myself. [1]https://ipfs.io/ipfs/QmXoypizjW3WknFiJnKLwHCnL72vedxjQkDDP1mXWo6uco/wiki/Operation_Mockingbird.html https://ipfs.io/ipfs/QmXoypizjW3WknFiJnKLwHCnL72vedxjQkDDP1m...
- jsoc815 8y ago+1 for the Bernstein ref. Had it mind, but couldn't remember the deets.
- crimsonalucard 8y agoWe live in a fantasy world, a world of illusion. The great task in life is to find reality.
- Kocrachon 8y agoI doubt anyone will see my comment since I am a few hours late. BUT, I want to say, despite what bloomberg AND apple say, here is why I think Bloomberg failed on this report, and didn't do enough to PROVE their claims were accurate. They made the flat out claim that AWS sold its Chinese infrastructure because of the hack. But this is flat out not true, anyone who actually knows anything about the Chinese goverment knows that AWS, same as Microsoft, cannot operate out of China. They are required to have a PARTNER to operate in China. I worked for Microsoft during the deployment to China, and we too had to have a partner. We were essentially "leasing" our technology for them to run it. http://www.miit.gov.cn/n1146295/n1146557/n1146619/c4860613/content.html http://www.miit.gov.cn/n1146295/n1146557/n1146619/c4860613/c... "According to the China Telecommunication Regulation, providers of cloud services—infrastructure as a service (IaaS) and platform as a service (PaaS)—must have value-added telecom permits. Only locally registered companies with less than 50 percent foreign investment qualify for these permits. To comply with this regulation, the Azure service in China is operated by 21Vianet, based on the technologies licensed from Microsoft. Microsoft Azure operated by 21Vianet (Azure China 21Vianet) is a physically separated instance of cloud services located in mainland China, independently operated and transacted by Shanghai Blue Cloud Technology Co., Ltd. ("21Vianet"), a wholly owned subsidiary of Beijing 21Vianet Broadband Data Center Co., Ltd. " So this to me proves that Bloomberg didn't fact check this story enough, and there are holes in it. Does this mean that China DIDN'T try anything? No, but this leaves me to question Bloombergs sources and not fact checking their reports, as there is obvious misinformation in it. EDIT: I googled AWS China, and this is the FIRST link. https://www.amazonaws.cn/en/about-aws/china/ https://www.amazonaws.cn/en/about-aws/china/ And at the bottom it covers all the same legality stuff. So again, its like they didn't even bother to research AWS China for 10 seconds.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- AlexCoventry 8y ago> anyone who actually knows anything about the Chinese goverment knows that AWS, same as Microsoft, cannot operate out of China. They are required to have a PARTNER to operate in China. IIRC, the Bloomberg article is consistent with this. AWS sold their business interests to that partner.
- qubax 8y agoSomething like this only happens when there is a rift within the elite/intelligence community. Both apple and bloomberg are heavily back by intelligence and elite community. Bloomberg would never have published this story without the approval or permission of some section of the intelligence community. And apple/amazon/etc would never have come out against it as strongly without the approval or permission of some section of the intelligence community. Seems like after Trump's election, there is a war between globalist pro-china elites and the nationalist anti-china elites. This story, saudi journalist story, north korea, china, russia, europe, brexit, etc... There is a rift within the elites. We'll never know the behind the scenes full story but it should be interesting to see how things unfold. Are we on the cusp of a global paradigm shift or will the old guard win and maintain power?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- nil_pointer 8y agoTim Cook has called China the biggest and most important market for Apple. With this in mind, of course he wants the story retracted. Appeasing China is the most important thing for Apple. It definitely doesn't mean the Bloomberg story isn't true, though.
- GeorgeTirebiter 8y agoExactly. Why hasn't Apple sued Bloomberg?
- jmull 8y agoSo interesting. With a year of reporting on this story Bloomberg has a LOT of unpublished info. If they are correct they should have a ton of information to back up the claims in their story, including plenty of stuff to put the lie to some/many of the specific denials Apple has made. Maybe they are waiting, to let Apple hang itself with strong, detailed, public proclamations. Then, bam! They publish all their proof, blowing up Apple's denials, forcing Cook and many other to resign, etc. Or... they've actually got nothing. In that case they won't be able to refute Apple. Either they slink away, hoping everyone forgets, or issue a massively embarrassing retraction. I'm fascinated to see what happens. I think we'll know in the next few weeks or months at the most.
- htk 8y agoThey might have nothing, but even so, celebrate.[1] [1]:https://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/erik-wemple/wp/2014/04/23/bloomberg-celebrates-challenged-story-on-the-nsa-and-heartbleed-bug/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/erik-wemple/wp/2014/04/...
- sooheon 8y agoLooks like a similar pattern and the author is the same as with this "Big Hack". But I don't see any hard evidence to say that Bloomberg is completely wrong, either. Just that NSA etc. have officially denied it (which you assume they would).
- raarts 8y agoIf the Chinese can infect hardware, and they obviously can, they could also infect phones. Where are phones manufactured? How easy would it be to move the manufactoring back to the US? All this is a PR and business Armageddon.
- bigbluedots 8y agoNow would be the time for Bloomberg to publish some of the hare evidence they have from the year-long investigation. Let's see it.
- cronix 8y agoOr mysteriously "get hacked" and have everything uploaded to wikileaks...
- panda888888 8y agoThe involvement of Elemental is enough evidence for me. A then 200-person startup with maybe 10 hardware engineers and lots of government clients would be a great target. It makes me thing the hack was real.
- cronix 8y agoLet's just say the Bloomberg reporting is accurate for the sake of discussion. They claimed it wasn't ONLY Apple, but also the NSA, CIA, military and other critical defense/intelligence systems used some of these boards. Do we think those "entities" wouldn't do whatever they had to do in order to keep that secret, legal or not, to preserve national security? What would the public response be if everyone knew our major national security systems were breached? I think it would cause a panic immensely larger than if we knew Apple was breached. I do agree with others that Apple has a hell of a lot to lose if this story proves to be true, but I think that's really more of a footnote compared to what will happen if the article proves to be true in its entirety. The data Apple has is nowhere near as critical as the data the NSA/CIA/MIC have.
- AnthonyMouse 8y agoThe interesting thing about this story is that everyone is hopping up and down trying to figure out if it's true, but the one thing everybody agrees with is that the attack is practical. Whether it happened in this specific case or not, what are we doing to prevent it from happening in general?
- therealdrag0 8y agoIn a previous discussion of this on HN, there was some disagreement about whether what is described by Bloomberg is a viable approach. But I don't know enough to know how valid the debate is.
- zaphar 8y agoI was under the impression they all agree it's theiretically possible but wildly impractical to pull off.
- AnthonyMouse 8y agoThe wildly impractical parts are some of the specific details, e.g. the logistics of getting a specific board to a specific customer without involving enough people that it creates a high risk of getting caught. But if you just backdoored a random 10,000 boards out of ten million and let them go to 10,000 random customers, you would get internal access to thousands of random companies, and at least some of them would be interesting.
- taysic 8y agoThis is a great point.
- rajacombinator 8y agoIf Apple is proven wrong, will they have to retreat from the rapacious anti-consumer design and pricing decisions of recent years? If so - wishful thinking, I know ... - I’m hoping they get btfo by Bloomberg.
- weliketocode 8y agoThere are so many conspiracy theories around how the story could be true, but seemingly no theories about what happens if the story is false.
- thstart 8y agoBloomberg was all for China before now against China, go figure what changed for Bloomberg?
- draw_down 8y agoIt’s interesting how both sides doubling down has observers relying on their existing biases. Most people’s stance seems to boil down to which one they’ve got a bigger ax to grind with- Apple/tech companies generally/intelligence agencies, or tech press generally/all press generally/Bloomberg specifically.
- calimac 8y agoApple has a nefarious history in regards to these types of issues.
- oh-kumudo 8y agoLikely Bloomberg is wrong. There is enough time for them to offer concrete evidence just for the sake of spinning more drama and hype. The attention they are getting by proving Apple/Amazon is lying would be incredible. Yet, there is nothing except denial and then silence. Without going too far into the conspiracy realm, the answer right now is that they can't. The longer they still quiet, the bigger joke they will become.
- reilly3000 8y agoI don't understand why China would do such a thing, when they have a pretty effective dragnet on US cell towers and routing equipment (alleged to me by a security expert). Hardware seems like such a fragile and expensive hack. That said, even if the story is a complete fiction it does help shine light the surveillance state that has emerged in China, and its global ambitions.