50 ms·
Ask HN: Is there a modern “power on to basic” computer, for kids to learn on?
I want to give some young kids a small cheap computer that "switches on to basic" or some other programming language?
Like in ye olde computer days when you brought home your Commodore 64 and turned it on you were in basic.
I'm guessing everyone will want to say "Raspberry Pi" of some form, but does that meet my requirement? Plug it into TV, turn it on and you're in basic and can start programming. Ideally with some sort of book or resource for learning how to make the computer do things on the home TV screen.
- jstewartmobile 8y agoYou'd think that we'd have a modern version of such a thing, wouldn't you? Closest modern analogue I can think of is the "console" tab in the browser "developer tools" window. Still stuck with a host OS and JavaScript though...
- potta_coffee 8y agoThe closest thing I've found to this is Pico-8: not a computer, a piece of software, but it's very cool. It has a simple text editor for writing Lua code, a simple sprite editor, and a simple sound editor, all for creating games. It's a nice little sandbox for playing with code and creating things. https://www.lexaloffle.com/pico-8.php https://www.lexaloffle.com/pico-8.php
- nicolashahn 8y agoI upvoted this but I need to reiterate my support. When I was a kid, I was heavily into video games and had a burning desire to create my own. However, the options for doing so were not great. One of my middle school teachers tried to introduce us to programming via creating Space Invaders in perl, which went as well as you might imagine. There were a few GUI game making applications that were all terrible and extremely limited. I eventually managed to make a game using Flash, but all the overhead of arcane Actionscript APIs was overwhelming and discouraging. I stopped programming and for several years thought I was going to go into media, creating films and animation. I eventually picked up programming again in college, but there were many years of programming experience I could have had if I had stuck with game dev. I'm convinced that if PICO-8 existed when I was originally interested in making games, I never would have stopped programming. PICO-8 is the perfect balance of easy-to-learn and powerful. Lua is a good first language because it's so small, and encourages you to build your own solutions rather than rely on magical libraries. For example, I never knew how a list-shuffling algorithm (Fisher-Yates) worked until I needed to write my own because Lua and PICO-8 don't provide one. The limited sprite and sound options encourage you to spend time not on the assets but on the gameplay (the code). It's quick to get things on screen and working because the PICO-8 API is simple, logical, and not arcane (cough Actionscript cough). Basically, it introduces programming in an instant-gratification way that's able to grab and hold a child's attention, while still being powerful enough to produce games that aren't hamstrung by toy programming languages.
- jchw 8y agoAnd the great thing about today is, there's a metric ton of free software you can move on to. Like, I would've killed for Godot when I was a teenager.
- codebolt 8y agoYou think you had it rough, at 15 I taught myself C/C++ Win32 programming with COM and early DirectX versions from textbooks and online tutorials. I'm thankful now though, as most modern frameworks are a breeze to learn by comparison. Looking back it was a bit like learning to swim by jumping in the deep end of the pool. It certainly gave me the confidence that I can figure stuff out, even in a new domain. And it's given me some valuable lessons in what makes a good vs bad API design.
- andrepd 8y agoMine was Pascal in Turbo Pascal (6?) for DOS, circa 2004. It speaks volumes to the outstanding quality of Turbo Pascal and the Pascal language that it still holds up, more than 20 years later.
- matt_the_bass 8y agoI feel old. Mine was commador64 basic in 1988
- dwd 8y agoDon't feel old. My first Basic experience was on a VIC-20, and I later got my own C64 in 85. Great computer to learn on but I don't think I would have got far without the Programmers Reference Guide.
- wiz21c 8y agoI started with AppleSoft basic around 10 years old. It was fairly simple to achieve "stuff". But if your dream was videogames (and when you're 10 years old, well, you see :-)), then you ended up in front of the assembler/machine code wall. And there your dreams vanished (or you were crazy enough to learn by yourself and books). So I think Pico8 or Scratch are cool in the sense that they give you an environment to start programming. But OTOH, if what you look after is AAA games, then you'll soon be confronted to a brand new wall, ie : DirectX, GPU, C++ whatever. Now I rememeber of Processing which is cool too.
- joeberon 8y agoI love pico 8, but I think that Lua is probably the worst language for coding in an editor that can fit so few characters on the screen, and it feels like using an external editor defeats the point. Granted, I haven't used the software in a couple of years, has it improved on the editor front?
- veli_joza 8y agoI'm surprised you feel that way. Lua seems like a perfect choice for pico-8. Its syntax is friendly and concise, and it's maybe simplest language to embed, with tiny footprint. Almost all other languages I know of would be a worse choice. Scratch would be nice, but graphical editor is harder to integrate. What's more suitable language in your opinion?
- joeberon 8y agoWell it's only because of the issue with the built-in editor, since lua isn't really that concise in terms of character count imo. Also the official tutorial is a published book which I find a little distasteful although understandable. You are right though I can't really think of a better language to use
- WillPostForFood 8y agoYou can attach an external editor if you want, though I think it is not needed for learning. There is more value in the tight integration than the conveniences of a great text editor. I've used this Sublime Text Package which works well: https://packagecontrol.io/packages/PICO-8 https://packagecontrol.io/packages/PICO-8
- astrodust 8y agoThe great thing about Lua is the language itself is so small, and not just from an implementation perspective. The spec and documentation are also small because there's not much to learn. You can explain it in an afternoon. Try that with C++ or JavaScript.
- makmanalp 8y agoI think Pico-8 would be perfect if: a) The code editing story was a bit nicer (better resolution / builtin support for external editing and reloading etc) b) If there was some kid-specific introductory game programming content for it (even "type all this in and play around with it after" worked for me as a kid)
- sdegutis 8y agoIt has both of those. Most of the tutorial is in the pico8.txt file though.
- WillPostForFood 8y agoYou should check out the Pico-8 fanzine. It is super cute, has coding tutorials and game building walkthroughs. I think there are now 8 issues. https://sectordub.itch.io/pico-8-fanzine-1 https://sectordub.itch.io/pico-8-fanzine-1
- jpfed 8y agoPico-8 was my son's very first introduction to programming. He does much more with the integrated sprite editor and sfx/music editors than he does with actual coding. I would like to get him interested in TIC-80 as a replacement. Key weaknesses of Pico-8 for kids learning to program: 1. The editor runs at the same resolution that the games do. Maybe this is because they didn't want to make their VM flexible enough to deal with multiple resolutions, or they just wanted to make the illusion that the Pico-8 is its own machine very consistent, but the end result is still a painful code editing experience. When I make example programs for my kids, I need to compromise between descriptive variable names and indenting code blocks. 2. Deviations from the standard lua API/libraries mean that normal learning resources like PIL have to be interpreted with an asterisk. 3. This is a minor thing, but the fixed palette is annoying. In graphical terms, Pico-8 lies roughly between the Atari 2600, 7800, and NES, but all of those systems handled colors more flexibly. 4. Splore allows children to find games that are not appropriate for their age. It's just not designed for kids and parents. My son found a game featuring smoking and thought it looked SO COOL (this was easy to disabuse him of). He also found a game that puts you in the role of a cyberbully, and the subtle psychological effects of that sort of "edgy" game aren't as easily undone with a single conversation. It is possible to mitigate this by putting whitelisted carts into the bbs carts folder and then making that folder read-only. TIC-80 improves on the first three points. The editor is still running at the same resolution as the games, but uses a higher resolution (and the editor can optionally use a thinner font). The lua implementation is much more standard. And the palette can be changed (even per-scanline, I think). The music editor lets you draw your own waveforms, but in other respects is less intuitive than Pico-8's. (I haven't looked at TIC-80's cart browser so I can't comment on it.)
- Impossible 8y agoAll of these are explicit design choices, for example a fixed palette is important to give games a "Pico-8" look and also reduce decisions regarding color choice. I suggest you watch Joseph White's practice talk (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=87jfTIWosBw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=87jfTIWosBw) if you're curious about design decisions that guided Pico-8. Multiple resolutions would absolutely break the "Fantasy console" feel of Pico-8, even though I understand why programmers universally hate that. To be fair a lot of people do code editing outside of the Pico-8 editor. #4 is an interesting point. The trick here is that different parents have different ideas of what is and isn't appropriate, and of course different kids will have different responses. It seems like the answer is to maybe have a version of Pico-8 that removes splore and expands the demo carts with some universally safe, popular titles. TIC-80 is cool btw and might be a better learning environment for kids. I don't like it (or any of the other fantasy console\pico-8 clones) quite as much as Pico-8 because they remove constraints, making them feel more like generic game editors and less like imaginary retro computers.
- greenspot 8y agoCeleste, one recent major indie game, was started and initially developed on Pico-8. If are into games, check out Celeste. Just the music is reason to play this game (I played it on PS4 but all versions are equal).
- tmountain 8y ago+1 for Pico-8. It really takes you down the rabbit's hole in a way that stimulates learning all the core concepts in creating a basic game. "Cool, I have a sprite on the screen. Now, how do I make it move?". "What about gravity?". "What about collision detection?" (I've done at least 5 collision detection "engines" so far...). Games can be compiled to HTML5, ando/or distributed as PNG files with all source code and assets included. There's also a builtin community game browser with ratings, etc. Some bigger name games were prototyped in Pico-8 (i.e., Celeste), and it has a lot of love in the indie community.
- gwicks56 8y agoI can't find any info on recommended ages for Pico-8? What age range do you think it works for?
- emmanueloga_ 8y agoThere are a bunch of these "fantasy consoles" now. From a quick search: * Pico-8: https://www.lexaloffle.com/pico-8.php https://www.lexaloffle.com/pico-8.php * Liko-12: https://liko-12.github.io/ https://liko-12.github.io/ * Tic-80: https://tic.computer/ https://tic.computer/ * Pixel Vision 8: https://www.pixelvision8.com/ https://www.pixelvision8.com/ I have no idea how they compare to each other.
- emmanueloga_ 8y agoOh damn, such a rabbit hole :-p. Also found this list [1]. A couple on the list run BASIC! E.g. [2]. I just learned there's this thing "Windows 10 IoT", [3] a Win10 version for low power devices like the raspberri pi. Would be interesting to try to run B8 in there! 1: https://github.com/paladin-t/fantasy https://github.com/paladin-t/fantasy 2: https://store.steampowered.com/app/767240/BASIC8/ https://store.steampowered.com/app/767240/BASIC8/ 3: https://developer.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/iot/Downloads https://developer.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/iot/Downloads
- jedieaston 8y agoWindows 10 IoT can't run Win32 applications, so Steam and BASIC8 won't work without major re-tuning.
- emmanueloga_ 8y agoGot it. Next best thing I could find: a mini PC. E.g. you can get one of these gigabyte ones for about $100, but I think comes w/o an HDD. 1: https://www.gigabyte.com/Mini-PcBarebone/GB-BXBT-2807-rev-10#ov https://www.gigabyte.com/Mini-PcBarebone/GB-BXBT-2807-rev-10...
- jpfed 8y agoTic-80 is slightly higher resolution than Pico-8, with a user-definable palette and a more standard lua implementation. The music editor is slightly less intuitive, though. Pixel Vision 8 is more flexible and complex than the other alternatives. One KEY difference between it and the others is that you can define your own editor tools... but the way this is done means that you must save your work every time you switch from tool A to tool B, or your work in tool A will be lost! It also is built with a focus on interoperability with external tools; it isn't as focused as the others on being a cozy self-contained environment.
- tlrobinson 8y agoNext Thing used to sell a "PICO-8 Console Kit" using their "Chip" single-board computer: http://blog.nextthing.co/pico-8-now-free-for-all-c-h-i-p-s/ http://blog.nextthing.co/pico-8-now-free-for-all-c-h-i-p-s/ Sadly they went out of business. It would be easy to build something similar with a Raspberry Pi though.
- austinl 8y agoI started to program in Lua with the LÖVE game engine in early high school, and can say it's one of the main reasons I was motivated to study CS in college. It's a simple, 2D, open-source game engine that runs on all platforms — I'd recommend this and other sandbox-style environments to anyone getting into programming. https://love2d.org/ https://love2d.org/
- int_19h 8y agoThere actually was a computer that ran PICO-8 out of the box, too: https://www.theverge.com/circuitbreaker/2016/7/19/12227806/pocketchip-review-portable-linux-computer https://www.theverge.com/circuitbreaker/2016/7/19/12227806/p... Unfortunately, the company has shut down, and these aren't made anymore. But it looks like they can still be found on eBay: https://www.ebay.com/itm/Pocket-C-H-I-P-sealed-portable-handheld-computer-from-Next-Thing-Co/202441401896 https://www.ebay.com/itm/Pocket-C-H-I-P-sealed-portable-hand...
- wodenokoto 8y agoThe first version of Celeste was done in Pico-8 at a games hackathon, and the success caused the author to develop an expanded version, which in my opinion is one of the greatest platformers ever. The pico-8 version exists as a game within the game and is great fun as well! Website: http://www.celestegame.com/ http://www.celestegame.com/ GDC talk about development of Celeste: https://youtu.be/4RlpMhBKNr0 https://youtu.be/4RlpMhBKNr0
- dasmoth 8y agoAt a technical level, JSFiddle or equivalent comes kind-of close. Set up a template with a nice big <canvas> element, then you've got a simple imperative API to draw stuff which really does come pretty close to what you'd get from a BASIC> prompt. That said, I wonder if it's even possible to replicate the C64 (or equivalent) experience. Looking back, I think a big part of the "magic" was that there were relatively few distractions. Just you, the machine, and (maybe) some paper documentation or a magazine with a few listings [1]. Can that be replicated once you're used to network-connected computers that are gateways to almost unlimited amounts of video, colourful games, etc.? (My child is getting to the point where I wish I knew the answers to some of this myself...) [1] I'm pretty certain type-in listings were the biggest contributor to my learning, early on. That doesn't seem to be something that comes up terribly often nowadays (although I note that Zed Shaw's "Learn Python the Hard Way" is pretty specific about telling you to hand-type in the examples...)
- joeberon 8y agoIn my opinion anything js-related is the furthest you can get from "power on to BASIC". I can say that for me it feels less enjoyable to have to rely on an external website (like jsfiddle), also requiring that you be able to write (very) basic HTML and maybe even CSS. I agree that once it's set up it can be very interactive, but it's non-trivial to get to that point
- zimpenfish 8y ago> Plug it into TV, turn it on and you're in basic and can start programming. No reason why someone couldn't create a Pi installation which does that - RetroPie boots into the game console screen, after all. BasicPie could just as easily boot into a Basic / Lua / Pico8 interpreter. (Get a normal Pi install with X and set Scratch to be the startup/only X app? Would that work?)
- jschwartzi 8y agoIn Ubuntu you'd just use console 1-6 instead of console 7. Console 1 is typically a terminal, while console 7 is typically a GUI. You could configure getty to start a REPL as a shell instead of the normal login shell.
- dmitripopov 8y agoPi plus boot-on MSX emulator (or Commodore C64 or ZX Spectrum). Also there are a lot of functioning retro-comps on online auctions.
- thrower123 8y agoI'm sure you could setup a machine with FreeDOS and boot it right into QBasic at startup. That'd probably be almost perfect; you'd have the relatively good built-in interactive help files, and all the graphics and sound APIs to actually do some cool stuff out of the chute.
- petermcneeley 8y agoYa this appeared on HN previously http://www.nicolasbize.com/blog/30-years-later-qbasic-is-still-the-best/ http://www.nicolasbize.com/blog/30-years-later-qbasic-is-sti...
- gaius 8y agoWhy not use an actual Commodore 64? I’m serious, get one for a song on eBay and a SCART adaptor and you’re in business. There are ample books around, they will be cheap too.
- PeanutNore 8y agoI have a Commodore 64 and due to its age it's a rather temperamental piece of equipment, and the 1541 disk drive even more so. I'm planning to replace all of the electrolytic capacitors in it which should help a lot, but that's probably beyond the abilities of most people. Setting up a Pi or something to boot directly to a C64 emulator would be easier and an order of magnitude less expensive for most people.
- leoc 8y agoYou could buy a reburbished C64 or (better) C128, and use a SD2IEC https://www.thefuturewas8bit.com/shop/commodore/sd2iec-c.html https://www.thefuturewas8bit.com/shop/commodore/sd2iec-c.htm... for storage.
- mstevens 8y agoI found the CG Maximite lately, which powers on to BASIC and has composite video or VGA out: http://geoffg.net/maximite.html http://geoffg.net/maximite.html There's also the fignition which has a composite out and powers on to forth: https://sites.google.com/site/libby8dev/fignition https://sites.google.com/site/libby8dev/fignition But does require assembly & soldering.
- Koshkin 8y agoColour Maximite is a lot of fun [1]! The BASIC environment it has is quite powerful, and it even runs a full-screen text editor. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XQA8lowEKOo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XQA8lowEKOo
- bartread 8y agoBeat me to it: I was going to post a link to the 8-Bit Guy's video as well. There are, I believe, various versions available and if you just want something to learn and write BASIC programs on it's difficult to imagine a better place to start because it boots directly into a BASIC prompt, just like 8-bit microcomputers from the 80s.
- Slimbo 8y agoDepending on their age, for young kids best results I've had are Pi's (or old/cheap pc's) that boot straight into scratch. Far better results than an intimidating command prompt. https://scratch.mit.edu/ https://scratch.mit.edu/ Alternatively Pi's (or old/cheap pc's) that boot straight into Minecraft Eduction Edition: https://education.minecraft.net https://education.minecraft.net This has paths for the very young in minecraft itself to older kids using ide's.
- martin1b 8y agoI second this. My kids love scratch. It shows them event driven programming with quick returns. The can also share their apps and download others so they can download and modify.
- d_runs_far 8y agoHow old are the kids? Mine is just turning 5, and I've been looking at this as an option, but as many have said, I don't want to feel like I'm 'forcing' the tech learning on him.
- Slimbo 8y agoScratch is good from around age 8 to 14 or so, depending on their ability. Most kids don't even know they're learning, scratch is really fun. Coder Dojo has some great lessons, eg this one to make your own version of plants v zombies: http://kata.coderdojo.com/wiki/Scratch_Plants_vs_Zombies http://kata.coderdojo.com/wiki/Scratch_Plants_vs_Zombies
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- meehow 8y agoIt's actually very easy to setup "boot to scratch" in raspi-config: https://geek-university.com/wp-content/images/raspberry-pi/boot_behaviour_raspbian.jpg https://geek-university.com/wp-content/images/raspberry-pi/b...
- ynniv 8y ago"power on to genera" would be nice.
- exikyut 8y agoOne of these days somebody needs to find the email addresses of the people that need emailing and make the effort to politely pester and track the progress of opening Genera. I'm interested enough but can't guarantee low enough email latency on my end of staying in touch.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- fusiongyro 8y agoI would suggest checking out the Micro:bit: https://www.microbit.org/ https://www.microbit.org/ Not exactly the same as what you're looking for, but the idea here is to introduce kids to programming with a small, self-contained environment, and there is both a graphical coding environment and you can move to Python or Javascript.
- dmlorenzetti 8y agoMicro:bit has a lot going for it. Comes with a 5x5 LED array, an accelerometer, two physical push-buttons, three capacitive sensors, and a bluetooth antenna, already on-board. It means you can start programming without having to plug in to a breadboard and wire up your inputs. You can also hang external sensors and actuators off of it, but the point is you don't need to in order to move beyond toy demonstrations. It was designed specifically for education, so there are lots of beginner-oriented tutorials available, as well as educator-oriented lesson plans. As fusiongyro points out, you can program it using three high-level languages. The graphical language lets you toggle to the Javascript version, so there's a clear learning path built-in. These provide high-level commands, such as "get the orientation", or "get the number of button presses since the last query", which makes programming it very straightforward. It removes a lot of toolchain fussiness. Just run an online editor, or a desktop editor (Mu). These produce binaries that you drag onto the Micro:bit, which mounts to your desktop like an external drive. You can also program it from a smart phone or iPad.
- fusiongyro 8y agoYou can also get Python onto it directly with uflash. https://pypi.org/project/uflash/ https://pypi.org/project/uflash/
- davidandgoliath 8y agoMy kids are enjoying working through the kano. It's a raspberry-pi with a linux distro attached to it, lots of coding opportunities. A bit too graphical for my tastes, and lots of distractions — but, lots of learning.
- makz 8y agoSetup a raspberry pi to boot directly into pico-8 in full screen mode and you are ready to go.
- sneak 8y agoBonus points: leave the pi/raspberry login there for when they get old enough to google about VTs and figure out how to exit the matrix.
- alliecat 8y agoHear me out here; Apple's Swift Playgrounds on an iPad. I'm involved in an extracurricular thing in Scotland focused on giving kids an environment they can figure out computers. We've seen a lot of different approaches to the problem of "how can we get kids to code", and Swift Playgrounds is consistently where we see youngfolk making the most progress. It gives you a nice, guided framework to get the very basics of programming, and slowly gives you more and more "rope" to play with, ultimately leading you to move your projects to Xcode on a Mac. Swift may not be your favourite language, and Apple are totally doing this with a view to people becoming iOS/MacOS developers (not necessarily a bad thing), but Swift Playgrounds is definitely best-in-class when it comes to having kids teach themselves how to program. The integration with real-life robots and drones is really impressive, too; the kids absolutely love being able to write real code that makes a real robot do things, it's exceptionally motivational.
- athenot 8y agoMy kids don't have tablets but this would be the application that would make me buy an iPad for them. Very close in spirit to the old LOGO, but with the added bonus of laying the foundation using a real language—real as in something used in our industry and with concepts that are easily transferable to other languages.
- alliecat 8y agoI am a strong believer in kids having access to technology, but also creating the frameworks in which they can learn how to keep themselves safe. I grew up around a software company and I was exposed to computers and the internet from a very young age; I had my first computer that could be considered "my own" at about five years of age (a little hand-me-down desktop from my father's company) and cut my teeth on that, building little static websites, stuff like that. It's definitely what lead to my lifelong interest in computing (as much as I can't stand this industry sometimes) and a healthy career in IT infrastructure.
- nickthegreek 8y agoYou can also put an ipad into an kiosk mode where they cannot exit an app without a pin. This will help keep the ipad as a 'power on to code' system and not let them drift into other apps.
- Kim_Bruning 8y agoRaspberry PI cab be said to be evolved from a ~ power-on-to-BASIC computer; to wit: the (BBC) Acorn Archimedes. You can still get RISC OS for it even. Basically, you power on; hit F12; *BASIC >_ and bob's your uncle: you get a nice BBC BASIC prompt at the bottom of your screen. https://www.riscosopen.org/content/downloads/raspberry-pi https://www.riscosopen.org/content/downloads/raspberry-pi (that said, why not use pi + python? It's the new BASIC. And it supports turtle graphics besides ;-) )
- pmyteh 8y agoYes. Raspberry Pi plus RISC OS Pico will drop you straight into a BASIC prompt. And one which is largely compatible with software written the original BBC BASIC from the early 1980s, if you have that nostalgia. The embedded assembler is ARM rather than 6502, and there are improvements and changes to some of the OS interfaces, but most simple stuff will work unchanged.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Legogris 8y ago> and bob's your uncle Completely OT, but I had just had to look up this phrase and the supposed origin made me chuckle: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bob%27s_your_uncle https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bob%27s_your_uncle
- dsr_ 8y agoSurely Bjorn Stronginthearm's my uncle?
- simion314 8y ago>why not use pi + python? Do you have experience with teaching python to kids? I am afraid to try it with my son because white space is important, I tried only Scratch and making him think as "a machine" is hard enough adding syntax errors on top would make the job much harder, let me know if you have experience with this and if you think I am wrong.
- gowld 8y agoWhat's the point? "Power on to BASIC" is running an app on an old small OS. What's wrong with running any programming environment app fullscreen on a modern computer?
- lostgame 8y agoIt introduces a vastly larger number of elements to a new mind much more quickly. Comparing opening Windows 10 and VS and starting a new project to turning on a computer and being presented an in-line-text IDE is to introduce degrees of complexity greater than is needed to understand or teach the fundamental concept (programming).
- lupire 8y agoAn interactive BASIC interpreter (or something saner, like Python) can run on a modern computer. It doesn't have to be a VS project. Anyone ready to learn to program can handle the complexity of tapping on an icon to launch an app.
- ziaddotcom 8y agoNothing wrong with it. However, I think an 8 year old seeing a 30 year old computer turn on instantly to the same thing a supposed "better computer" takes 10 minutes to boot to might surprise and teach them something. I think your question, although sincere, is a variation of "why not give a child a 4 wheel drive suv instead of a silly old go cart?"
- androidgirl 8y agoI definitely think Raspberry Pi is what you want. If you want the login shell to go straight into programming, you could launch an interpreter or text editor on login using .profile or what have you.
- tyingq 8y agoDuinomite: https://www.olimex.com/Products/Duino/Duinomite/DUINOMITE-MINI/open-source-hardware https://www.olimex.com/Products/Duino/Duinomite/DUINOMITE-MI... You'll need a keyboard with PS/2 connector and a monitor/tv with a VGA port. And it does "power on to BASIC." Cheap too...20 EUR. There's also a "mega" version with added USB and composite video: https://www.olimex.com/Products/Duino/Duinomite/DUINOMITE-MEGA/open-source-hardware https://www.olimex.com/Products/Duino/Duinomite/DUINOMITE-ME...
- dvfjsdhgfv 8y agoDuinomite is great, the only drawback of the VGA solution is the distortion on modern high-resolution screens, i.e. if you use the CIRCLE command the result is hardly a smooth circle.
- modzu 8y agoserious question: if you're looking for a commodore 64 why not use a commodore 64?
- ikeboy 8y agoI learned on a TI calculator
- kipchak 8y agoThe Kano kits come to mind in spirit, Though it's more of a guided cushier approach than just getting into basic. The basic idea is a Pi and it's accessories that you "build yourself" and then some optional add ons like a light grid display. I think the actual coding Python and Javascript with a block formatting kind of like lego Mindstorms. Come to think of it you can use Small Basic on Mindstorms which might be interesting. For the Kano the coding portion is web based and free if you want to take it for a spin, as well as their OS. https://world.kano.me/coding-challenges/training https://world.kano.me/coding-challenges/training https://kano.me/store/us/products/computer-kit https://kano.me/store/us/products/computer-kit
- linsomniac 8y agoI really like the Kano, but my son was able to figure out how to get into youtube with it and it's become a "all youtube all the time" environment. Been using repl.it and the "Python with Turtle" flavor this week and he's been having fun with it.
- mixmastamyk 8y agoYep, my daughter plays minecraft with it about 98% of the time. Not what I had in mind, haha.
- amasad 8y agoThat's awesome. Repl.it ceo here. Check out our forum, there's lots of material shared by kids like your son. Here is one tutorial on pixel art with Turtle https://repl.it/talk/challenge/How-to-draw-Pixel-Art-on-Python-with-Turtle/7556 https://repl.it/talk/challenge/How-to-draw-Pixel-Art-on-Pyth...
- linsomniac 8y agoThanks! We will check that out tonight!
- nobody271 8y agoWhy not a Raspberry Pi? Boot into bash and you have what you wanted. 3D print some cases (or buy them) and pick up some cheap monitors. The whole setup would be maybe $50 per computer.
- sneak 8y agoI am not affiliated with them in any way, but I adore this high quality $15 metal rPI case and bought like 8 of them in red and blue: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B071YPZFZ4/ https://www.amazon.com/dp/B071YPZFZ4/
- damianmontero 8y agohttps://googlecreativelab.github.io/coder/ https://googlecreativelab.github.io/coder/ Google has a sd card that you put into a raspberry pi (everyone has one of these hanging around, if not ask your friends for theirs) and with NO SETUP just hooked up to the internet you can learn full web development, NO SETUP!
- swiley 8y agoJust give them a computer running linux without going all the way to runlevel 5. Bash is fairly expressive and gets you the basics of programming, and then you can easily use a more complex language fairly easily and have all the abstractions from bash that lets you build fairly useful programs without having to build complex UIs.
- normalhuman 8y agoI too grew up with a "power on to basic" computer, in my case the ZX Spectrum. I don't think that people that did not have that experience at that age can truly get it. I was able to create graphics and play sounds with a very simple language. The text editor, the graphical display, the "OS", it was all the same thing. The manual taught you how to program in BASIC. It was an amazing tool of creativity and intellectual development. It was truly magical. I know you mean well and I have nothing against bash, but I promise you it will not replicate that experience nor excite kids.
- teddyh 8y agoYour personal experience is not the only correct one. I assure you that the people coming before you, making their own computers out of chips and resistors with a soldering iron, would say the same thing about you. And people who grew up with Windows 98 say the same thing about people only exposed to iOS and Android, and so on.
- itomato 8y agoThey are all more justified than the person who claims Swift playground on an iPad is the pinnacle of CS for Primary School.
- teddyh 8y agoI understand, in a sense, what you mean (since I am of an earlier generation than the one which learned programming on that particular platform), but why should that necessarily be true? Hasn’t it always been the case that the current generation skips learning about useless lower layers used by older generations? How could it be that the layers you grew up are the special ones which are still useful, when all the layers which came before, which people at the time thought essential, have turned out not to be so? I am, below, trying to imagine what an argument could be for any specific example to be worse than the previous ones. One could make an argument that when the level of abstractions eliminate Turing completeness, they have eliminated an essential quality. (But this does not even eliminate Swift playground, I think, so in this case it does not apply.) Or one could make an argument about a lack of program interconnectedness, which, I am given to understand, is very much a problem in modern smartphone and tablet environments. But I could be out of date and/or misinformed. Nevertheless, it would be a reasonable argument (and I don’t know if it applies to Swift playground on an iPad or not). Very constrained environments, like Minecraft, can also be argued against on practical grounds – it’s simply too difficult to make something useful within them. Not technically impossible, just too difficult once you get up a bit in abstraction levels. In my opinion, this argument also applies, sadly, to BASIC: The lack of functions and other methods of abstractions is, I think, a killer. Or one could argue (which I think I personally favor doing) that software freedom for end users is an essential quality which must never be lost, for reasons which are only tangentially based on what is good for learning. It is almost special pleading, but has its own reasons for doing so, and the logic, on its own terms, is sound. But none of these arguments are insurmountable by some theoretical device and environment which avoids any or all of these specific criticisms. Therefore, I think that any argument based solely on the age and abstraction level would not be valid.
- agumonkey 8y agopower on to lua: nodemcu https://duckduckgo.com/?q=nodemcu+lua&atb=v119-3__&iax=videos&ia=videos https://duckduckgo.com/?q=nodemcu+lua&atb=v119-3__&iax=video...
- 6keZbCECT2uB 8y agoxonsh from linux A shell is an interactive programming environment (like basic) that is the primary interface for communicating with the computer. (remember Commodore BASIC was also how you used the computer) Linux with auto-login directly into a shell with xonsh as default does exactly this. Go directly into a shell from a PTTY or set up your desktop environment to automatically launch a terminal.
- adroitboss 8y agoThere is an app on the Nintendo 3DS called Petit Computer which is a basic interpreter.(It might currently be called Smile Basic). There are tons of tutorials and you can make simple applications to advanced games.
- skjdflsiugf 8y agoplease dear lord not BASIC! Those of us who learned to code on 8-bit micros back in the day never used BASIC anyway & ended up writing everything in machine code. You could use an emulator: the Jupiter Ace for example, which ran Forth (quite a good first language to learn) I'd suggest Wolfram langauge on the Raspberry Pi, or Squeak Smalltalk
- sparkie 8y agoLudovic Courtes created a Boot-to-Guile image a few years ago, packaged using Guix: https://lists.gnu.org/archive/html/guile-user/2013-02/msg00131.html https://lists.gnu.org/archive/html/guile-user/2013-02/msg001...
- CodeArtisan 8y agoThere also is Armpit Scheme that is targeting single board computers http://armpit.sourceforge.net/ http://armpit.sourceforge.net/
- lukego 8y agoI’m starting my kids on electronics. LEDs, buttons, breadboards. A bit of soldering. Soon transistors. Reminds me of my “BASIC in the 80s” childhood even though it’s circuits rather than programs. Kits cost about $2.50 on Aliexpress.
- exikyut 8y agoI want to give real-world advice as opposed to some of the more theoretical suggestions (the mention iPads doesn't quite line up with "small cheap computer"). A lot depends on unspecified contextual factors, so I'll just throw a couple ideas at you. If you have a cache of sub-GHz hardware already lying around, I would recommend Win98 and QuickBASIC 4.5. The ability to hit F5 and immediately get output is excellent for reinforcement learning, and being able to CTRL+Break out of unruly mistakes gone rogue great as well. After a few months (or only weeks?) of QuickBASIC I would move up to Visual Basic. To be entirely honest, I stumbled on VB 1.0 while browsing at a library many years ago, threw added it to my CD to take home "for the lulz"... and ended up writing a ton of things in it. I found 2.x-5.x's UI to be unnecessarily full of things I didn't want to know about at the time. It _is_ very Spartan; this may appeal for a very short time. After the novelty of drawing up terrible UIs has worn off, throw them a curveball in the form of VB 6. They'll have the fascination to chow through the additional UI complexity, and VB 6 occupies the sweet spot of being the last in the pre-.NET series and a good preparation for Visual Studio... ...which will need to be introduced at some point, presumably along with an OS switcharoo from Win98 to Win10. My recommendations for such archaic platforms are not without due consideration; the "total mental model surface area" of Win98+DOS is orders of magnitude smaller as Win10, which may provide a friendlier learning environment than "hi you can play in the rocket capsule but don't do anything that affects the engines underneath or you'll blow us all up and I'll be really mad." The very opposite will be true since it's a "toy" environment, so the kids would be free to kill everything as many times as they wanted/needed (within the limits of your patience ;)), and this will fuel the inspiration to discipline their interest in discovery and learning into something usable. A microcontroller-based environment does provide some of the kinds of bare-metal experience that using QB on an old PC does, but only if you completely ignore tooling and infrastructure. Unfortunately I have insufficient (...any...) experience so can only really comment on the difficulty of this aspect. The above reflects (part of) my own history (I unfortunately skipped the bit about VB6, which was why I had so many things in VB1.0. I only ended up learning how I'd even go about finding a copy long after the window it would have been useful had passed, so perhaps I'm a bit biased about it.) The one thing I'm trying to consider, though, is the thing about total surface area, for want of a better phrase - I can remember struggling to figure out JavaScript using IE 5.5 because I didn't know anything else even existed at the time (in 2003, no internet) and perceiving the existence of and hating the browser sandbox. The devtools REPL makes things so different nowadays but it's undeniable that a browser is a gigantic pseudo-operating system on top of another operating system and most problematically this is viscerally perceptible; it's not seamless at all. There's no sense of true freedom, that you're pushing what you're controlling to its limits. (Incidentally speaking, this has some interesting parallels with the Web's recent transformation into the media format of the day, its adoption of DRM, etc.) The same is true to some extent with QuickBASIC, and this is why I would recommend using it for a maximum of 6 months, but only allowing someone to use it for that long if they had learning difficulties. I personally believe that my own development was severely impaired by the fact that I had nothing else available when I was younger. I'm only just breaking even in terms of having a mind able to make use of CS first principles, but in all fairness this is predominantly due to my autism and not entirely QuickBASIC's fault ;) A short, engaging path straight to assembly language might be a good idea. I'm still yet to wrap my head around this particular subject, nearly 20 years on, because I'm still un-learning the very complacent computer science models I unfortunately ingrained when I was very young.
- reificator 8y ago> Like in ye olde computer days when you brought home your Commodore 64 and turned it on you were in basic. Why not try, you know, a Commodore 64? https://thec64.com https://thec64.com Hooks up via HDMI, powered by micro USB, and has two USB ports for keyboards and joysticks. No longer boots straight into BASIC, but scroll to the right and hit enter and you're there.
- PyroLagus 8y agoThere's also going to be the http://mega65.org/ http://mega65.org/ which is a spiritual successor to the C64. It's completely open source, even the FPGA code implementing the 6502 (although the FPGA is most likely not going to be open source), and it has better specs than the C64, but it should still be compatible with the original C64 and its games from what I understand.
- jasonm89 8y agoAny idea when the mega65 is going to be released?
- andrewguy9 8y agoThe browser console
- KirinDave 8y agoPower-on-to-basic is gone in the world of more sophisticated hardware and power management. But! You can always alter a homebuilt hardware to boot into the next best thing: DrRacket. Just modify the init scripts to go right into this: https://racket-lang.org/ https://racket-lang.org/ Grab a copy of "the little schemer" and let them go. And when they're through that, then you can unlock the rest of the computer. As for the hardware, I have recently been building this kit. It affords a very small, humble laptop from the base parts up. You literally build it up. You can re-open it pretty easily. https://www.olimex.com/Products/DIY-Laptop/ https://www.olimex.com/Products/DIY-Laptop/
- peatmoss 8y agoThere’s also Realm of Racket which uses games to teach.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- bsenftner 8y ago"Back in the day" the BASIC language made sense, as it was right at your prompt in text based interfaces. The same situation today is the web browser, and the ability to open up the developer's console and getting direct access to a web site's JavaScript, html & CSS. Forget BASIC, and introduce your kids to web developing. They will "get it" much faster than <kid's voice here> "boring dumb BASIC, can't do web stuff, it sucks."
- khazhou 8y agoA huge part of the appeal of C64-style BASIC is the lack of distractions. I mean, you're already talking about CSS! :-) A better match than Javascript (which doesn't have an interactive console, and HTML+JS is event-driven) would be Python.
- TallGuyShort 8y agoSome basic scripting is probably still a good starting place for younger kids to wrap their minds around syntax, basic constructs, etc. Dropping them in the DOM right away is probably in the deep end, too much, although I'd agree getting them there quickly opens a lot of fun and practical doors faster than almost anything else. edit: Second the suggestion of Python below, even if it's just for a few months to learn the basics of coding in general. Pivoting a few months in to a new environment is also hard in and of itself, but that's the path I'd go. As a little bonus, then you don't get too stuck in one way of thinking :)
- 8y ago
- reubeniv 8y agoAn actual commodore64 is still an option https://www.amazon.co.uk/Koch-International-242390-THEC64-Mini/dp/B0764BK6L1 https://www.amazon.co.uk/Koch-International-242390-THEC64-Mi... The mini boots straight to basic still I understand Otherwise I'd recommend some free software and some tutorials, Udemy has a very good C# Unity course for example that can often be found at ~$/£10
- joeberon 8y agoThis thing reviews terribly. I think it's more meant for nostalgia for the older generation. Also the keyboard is just for show which is quite sad
- jnurmine 8y agoI think it will help once they release the new firmware that lets you more easily access disks stored on a USB stick. Doing LOAD "$",8,1 etc. is rather tedious with the virtual keyboard. Also, they have promised a bigger version with a fully functional keyboard. That will be awesome once it's out. I'm waiting for it since it was actually the thing that made me join their crowdfunding campaign.
- CiaranMcNulty 8y agoIt boots to a loading screen from which you can select BASIC or a game
- tootie 8y agoWhat I bought for my kid and what is now taking over American schools is a Chromebook. I got one for maybe $140 that has an 11" screen and is super light and thin. Yes, it's a UI and yes they can surf the internet and play games. There's plenty of parental controls. Mine uses it for fun, but also to work on Scratch and use CodePen. I'm not sure teaching shell commands is actually very beneficial.
- ryandrake 8y agoOne other thing to add to this request is that the machine boots around as quickly as the Commodore did. Modern PCs have clock speeds thousands of times faster than the C64, and boot up 10-100x slower. A sub-1-second “boot to BASIC” time should also be added to the requirements.
- forinti 8y agoI recently found out about a Japanese computer called Ichigo Jam: https://ichigojam.net/index-en.html https://ichigojam.net/index-en.html Seems to be something between a Micro:bit and a Raspberry Pi and has Basic built in.
- lioeters 8y agoThe site seems to be down (403) - but I found some related pages: IchigoJam BASIC on Raspberry Pi - https://ichigojam.github.io/RPi/ https://ichigojam.github.io/RPi/ https://ja.wikipedia.org/wiki/IchigoJam https://ja.wikipedia.org/wiki/IchigoJam
- tmaly 8y agoThe new Scratch 3.0 that is in beta is all web based. You could use a tablet or Chromebook to get the child started right away if specialized hardware was not a requirement. I have been teaching my 5 year old programming with it.
- modeless 8y agoTI graphing calculators boot to BASIC. I don't know about the newer ones but the old ones are extremely simple computers with Z80 or 68k processors and hardly any operating system, fun to program in BASIC or assembly language or C. Modern kids might find them boring but they are great places to learn how a computer really works without piles of modern software cruft between you and the hardware. That's where I learned.
- dharmab 8y agoTI-BASIC was the first language myself and a few colleagues learned, by automating our algebra homework.
- craftsman 8y agoFor those interested in hearing more about TI calculators and hacking on them, this episode of the Embedded.fm podcast was really fun, and there are a couple interesting links in the show notes: https://www.embedded.fm/episodes/259 https://www.embedded.fm/episodes/259.
- mj_olnir 8y agoHas any here played LittleBigPlanet (specifically, the sequel)? I'm young enough to learn boolean logic from that game, and went on to develop a true love for programming.
- tomc1985 8y agoIf it boots to a bash prompt, you can program that :P Actually, I wonder if kids could learn shell script?
- Jach 8y agoThis was going to be my suggestion. You could also make sure some sort of curses library is installed, e.g. https://bashsimplecurses.readthedocs.io/en/latest/ https://bashsimplecurses.readthedocs.io/en/latest/ But really the question is misguided. Kids need to want to do something with a computer, and in order to do that they will learn shell script, basic, javascript, asm typed from magazines, whatever, to get it done. The environment itself is instrumental, not terminal.
- ziaddotcom 8y agoI think the color maximite is this http://geoffg.net/maximite.html http://geoffg.net/maximite.html https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XQA8lowEKOo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XQA8lowEKOo
- archi42 8y agoIf it was my kid, I'd use any single board computer or an old laptop (pro: integrated keyboard and screen, e.g. Dell D630), and install a Linux that boots straight into QB64: https://www.qb64.org/ https://www.qb64.org/ I didn't test if it runs in pure Linux text mode, but if possible that's what I'd use.
- blihp 8y agoFor those of us who grew up in the 8-bit era, this has a lot of appeal since that's how we got engaged. But for most kids today, is this sort of ab initio approach really the right way to go about it? Based on my experience with a few different types of kids/personalities, I'm skeptical. Dropping them into the command line / IDE of any language / environment is likely to leave them both unimpressed and lost. Neither the Raspberry Pi (more software oriented) or Arduino (more hardware oriented) is going to be terribly impressive from a standalone point of view compared to the PC/iPhone/XBox they're used to. But the thing they've got going for them are a lot of cool projects other people have done with them, step-by-step tutorials, and pre-built stuff that's relatively easy to re-create and/or integrate. Will the 8-bit recreation you have in mind have any of that?
- mixmastamyk 8y ago> they're used to Maybe they're not used to them, because we haven't given them one? Or largely restrict their use? Necessity is the mother of invention for kids.
- blihp 8y agoOnly if they don't have friends. I have a family member who tried that and failed miserably: not only are the kids computer illiterate (from not having any positive/useful exposure to technology when they were younger) but now they are hooked video games and social 'stuff' from their friends / school. The parents have now thrown in the towel and use technology as a pacifier for their adolescents. Just because you don't allow it at home, don't assume they're not getting it somewhere else.
- mixmastamyk 8y agoNope, my daughter is very social, an avid reader, and can program minecraft too. The fact that friends have toys doesn't solve the learning/boredom drive at home. Also, playing with an iphone or x-box, is not computer-literate.
- seanmcdirmid 8y ago
- squarefoot 8y ago"Plug it into the TV" as a requirement would restrict the choice. Why not something that can be programmed through a PC, fun enough to attract the kids attention, with great instructional value, powerful enough to be used for serious tasks (LCD+wifi+bluetooth+buttons+battery=IoT terminal) and cheap? Take a look at this: https://www.hardkernel.com/main/products/prdt_info.php?g_code=G152875062626 https://www.hardkernel.com/main/products/prdt_info.php?g_cod...
- crooked-v 8y agoThere's always 'web browser and Javascript'. Start with document.write, ease into more complicated input/output methods.
- mdhughes 8y agoWhile that's what I grew up with, too, it's probably too isolated anymore. Find a cheap laptop or desktop, or a pi, install Python3, and make IDLE easy to reach. For graphics, "import turtle" and later "import tkinter". Grab any learning Python book. It's not that far from how we learned back in the day.
- s73v3r_ 8y agoI mean, you have to click an icon to open Scratch, but other than that, the Raspberry Pi is what you want.
- fooblat 8y agoI would consider something like the BBC MicroBit[0] or Calliope Mini[1]. Similar to an Arduino but much more accessible for first time coders. And, as many have mentioned, the Raspberry Pi series. 0. https://microbit.org/ https://microbit.org/ 1. https://calliope.cc/en https://calliope.cc/en
- ddebernardy 8y agoCouldn't an old (or a new?) HP graphic calculator do the job? It's not technically basic, but you can do tons of stuff on it in addition to arithmetics and function plotting - including programming games, etc. Plus, it's organized as a LIFO stack. To do e.g. 2 * (2 + 2) you'd enter: 2, 2, 2, +, *. Which helps train the mind to think far ahead about what you want to calculate and how.
- AntonyGarand 8y agoThis is known as the Reverse Polish Notation: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reverse_Polish_notation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reverse_Polish_notation
- sneak 8y agoYes, the Raspberry Pi supports this (via the smaller non-GUI “Raspbian lite” SD image), with Bash, Python, and JavaScript. No GUI or browser or internet connection required. Plug in TV and keyboard and fire up an editor. (You will want to change the keyboard layout from uk to us first, but after that it is smooth sailing.) For daily use, you or your child may have to log in as pi/raspberry first, it does not boot directly to a REPL, as there is an OS. But immediately after typing a username and password you are in a bash REPL that is fully programmable. If you then type ‘node’ or ‘python’ you get the same thing. TBH I would have preferred a bash shell with readline and an editor to appleII BASIC when growing up.
- city41 8y agoAnother option, a modern Commodore 64. For example the C64 Mini has BASIC: https://thec64.com/basic/ https://thec64.com/basic/ It doesn't boot directly to BASIC, but I do believe that is achievable with other modern C64s, like the C64 DTV: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/C64_Direct-to-TV https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/C64_Direct-to-TV
- xena 8y agoI wish TempleOS was in more of a state to be usable by kids and the like, but it is about the gold standard for this kind of stuff I feel.
- nurettin 8y agoI will tell you why whatever you find won't feel like the old C= 64 no matter how good the properties are emulated. It is the culture, and the music. You will never find an equivalent, so might as well consider yourself lucky, move on and let the kids beat their keyboards typing JavaScript into their browser in debug mode. If you want to give them something they can program as soon as it boots up, just install any Linux on any pc.
- fit2rule 8y agoI'm seriously into retro-computing, having kept every computer I've ever owned since the 70's .. So I admit my bias in this, but I have to say it: those 8-bit machines are still out there, can still provide endless utility, and are also integrating quite nicely with the modern era. In my 48k Oric Atmos, I have an 8G SD card-based filesystem. My CPC6128 has Internet access over the house wifi. Old computers never die - their users do!
- lcuff 8y agoSqueak, Alan Kay's environment for kids, evolved from Smalltalk, would be a very hot prospect if I were in your shoes.
- fit2rule 8y agoDisclaimer; I have raised my kids with my computer collection, which means we've done all of the following and found great rewards: Just get an old, retro, 8-bit computer to use to teach your kids computers. Seriously. Something like an Amstrad Spectrum +3. Or maybe a CPC6128. Or an Amiga - although all of these machines can easily be used only as games-machines, the documentation for creating software on them is a high-value read. My kids love the +3 and the stack of 80's magazines with type-ins and machine-code tutorials. These are awesome, still, 30 years later and with a few modern accessories, are simply awesome systems - and they will still teach your kids to program, and to manipulate computers, in ways beyond the reach of the average consumer-bot. By way of an 8-bit machine, new students can learn all the components of computing, and immediately apply it to bigger/newer/contemporary things. Of course you have to appreciate the aesthetic. So another thing you can do is load up an old laptop with antirez' wonderful LOAD81: http://github.com/antirez/load81.git http://github.com/antirez/load81.git We have a Toshiba tough-book running puppy booting directly to LOAD81. This is a modern version; and has the bonus of being a Linux-machine behind the curtains, to boot. Another great avenue. And then, if you can find it, you could do the cocktail thing and get a PocketCHIP .. mine sits in the drawer, wrapped in its 3d-printed keyboard, ticking away .. so I'm still using it. But its pretty much the 'pocket boot to basic' ideal, since it comes with PICO8 already ready already. (OpenPandora, DragonPyra: same deal; probably a fair bit more expensive though...) The key thing is: as long as there is a compiler on-board, you can 'boot your kids to basic'. If you get results with a new-school retro-rig (OricAtmos+Cumulus ForeveR!), or if you just re-purpose an old laptop with auto-boot to load81, there are definitely options for this ethos ..
- davegardnerisme 8y agoPower on to BASIC! I’m going to try it out with my kids. https://basicengine.org https://basicengine.org
- DanBC 8y agoI don't know what the status of Maximite is: http://geoffg.net/maximite.html http://geoffg.net/maximite.html
- astrodust 8y agoIn the old days you saved up an extraordinary amount of money, bought a Commodore 64, plugged it in, and then had absolutely no idea what to do unless you had books. So you went and got books or magazines, some maybe from the library, some from bookstores, and many of them might be for systems other than the C64. It wasn't uncommon for a magazine to have to cater to a dozen slightly different versions of BASIC: Apple ][, Atari, BBC Micro, PET, Sinclair, TI, Tandy, VIC-20 and more. I remember finding all sorts of interesting programs in magazines that weren't for the computer I had, so they were basically useless. This was because a lot of BASIC code that did anything useful consisted of PEEK/POKE calls to manipulate memory, and as the memory layout of each computer was often completely different. Having a book about the Altair was of no help when trying to program anything but an Altair. Even if you did get a book that had the right code, for the right hardware, typing it in was frustrating because the computer didn't ship with anything that resembled an editor. You just typed in line numbers and statements and hoped it all worked out. You could LIST your code, but unless you organized it well, you'd get lost quickly. Anything over a hundred lines became an unmaintainable mess of garbage. So yeah, you could program, but you could only program in BASIC, and that language is one of the absolute worst. There's been joke languages that are more pleasant to use and more educational. Today there's JavaScript and it works roughly the same everywhere, is thoroughly documented for free, and there's places to ask about coding that simply didn't exist when the C64 launched. Going back is a mistake. Programming back then was a nightmare, it was an awful, discouraging experience, and I wouldn't wish it on anyone. Presumably a lot of the golden-hued nostalgia here comes from the fact that you could program a computer, something that at the time was a relative impossibility for most people. That by typing in code you could make the computer Do Things, which can be thrilling. The thing is today you have things like Arduino, the Pi, and others, where you can not only program them in sensible programming languages inside of civilized build environments, but you can make them interact with hardware in ways that really weren't possible on the C64. For that sort of thrill, give someone a Feather board they can program with Micropython.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> In the old days you saved up an extraordinary amount of money, bought a Commodore 64, plugged it in, and then had absolutely no idea what to do unless you had books. While I never got a C64, I did get a Timex-Sinclair 1000, a Timex-Sinclair 2068, and a PC clone in the early-to-mid 1980s, and all of them came with complete BASIC manuals as well as other system documentation.
- jaclaz 8y agoI guess you could put up any old PC (or laptop) to run VICE[0], if you automate the booting (you can use DOS or Linux as "base" OS) you will be greeted by the: “COMMODORE 64 BASIC V2” [0] http://vice-emu.sourceforge.net/ http://vice-emu.sourceforge.net/
- nicole_express 8y agoI'm curious why the 8-bit machines themselves aren't an option here; I'd recommend the Commodore 128, as it was the newest of the Commodore machines and had their most advanced BASIC (so you can actually do graphics stuff without directly manipulating memory) Finding a working one might be a bit more pricy these days than a Raspberry Pi, though. Otherwise, I'd say the web is probably the closest thing; once you help them over the initial hurdles of setting up a basic site with a simple JS program that they can mess with, it's possible to do quite a lot, in an environment most kids are going to be familiar with; configure a simple Linux environment to open a web browser and a text editor on boot and there you go.
- amasad 8y agoWhen we're building Repl.it we think about this a lot and we think we're building "power on to basic" for the cloud era. Where the microcomputer in the mainframe era made computing more accessible, we think Repl.it is the microcomputer to the mainframe's cloud. In fact most of our users that use it as a platform, and not just a repl, are kids. Check out our hackernews-like forum where mostly teenager are sharing what they're building: https://repl.it/talk?order=votes https://repl.it/talk?order=votes
- 0xdeadbeefbabe 8y agoBASIC is more readable than forth, but forth is good for things too. What about an hp48 or http://amforth.sourceforge.net/ http://amforth.sourceforge.net/ on some atmega device?
- banach 8y agoI would consider https://www.nand2tetris.org/ https://www.nand2tetris.org/ for a similar from-metal-to-application understanding of computing. It is a ground-up course that covers the construction of a CPU using only a NAND circuit, and ends with implementing Tetris on top of this computer.
- JacobJans 8y agoThis post reminds me of a running line of thought that's been going on in my head for quite some time: "Single Purpose Devices." The main disadvantage of most computing devices is that they offer too many options; making them mentally unwieldy. A "single purpose device" is created to support just one purpose. The Kindle is perhaps the most famous example; it practically created an industry. Sure, it can do more than just present books, but everything is designed to support reading. Ideally, there would be a "computer", where every aspect of it was designed to teach computer programming. I often fantasize about a device designed solely for producing new writing. It would have a nice screen, and a nice keyboard, but only a very very limited web-browser, and would sync with Google Docs, Office, or something similar, so that you can do the more advanced stuff elsewhere. Such devices are about empowering the user to go down a specific path; one they choose as soon as they start interacting with the device. Kindle -> Reading Typewriter -> Writing Hammer -> Hitting things "Power to Basic" -> Learning to program
- nyjah 8y agoI know I am lucky to have this setup, but I keep 2 laptops and 2 tower computers or 4 separate computers. 1 for biz, 1 for downloading and email, 1pc for gaming, and 1 for activities best kept in private browsing..
- JacobJans 8y agoVery interesting. What kind of software do you have on the computers? Is there anything, beyond the physical separation, that supports the purpose of each device? (Maybe something as simple as physical location, color, a "sticker", or something else altogether.)
- nyjah 8y agoOnly software on the machines are strictly for what I am using them for. I have a router with a harddrive if I do download something and want to put it on another machine, but I don't remote desktop into them or anything. Each computer is on a separate desk, own monitor and mouse and keyboard. I just like it separate and not complicated. Keeps work stuff super focused and clean, for me. I could network them more if I wanted to, but gets the job done.
- yellowapple 8y agoThis is almost exactly what TempleOS was/is billed to do; you'd need to provide the hardware, but once you've installed it, you end up with a machine that boots into a REPL/shell using the same language (HolyC) used to write the whole OS itself (and all the applications thereof).
- onlyrealcuzzo 8y agoI'm testing a business right now for fun family learning activities. The original offering is an arts-and-craft type product. But if it works out, one of the products I want to test is something computing related. The general idea is a digital escape room. But this thread has been super inspiring and led me to a lot of great resources, so thanks for bringing it up [=
- vgoh1 8y agoI think that the Arduino is worth mentioning, even though it fails the "power on to basic" need of the OP. Once setup, it is fairly easy to compile and upload to the board, and there is a lot that you can do with it, if they are not to into making thier own video games.
- crispytx 8y agoRetro/Vintage computing enthusiast here. I actually got into playing around with old computers because I was interested in using a computer that simply ran Microsoft BASIC for the operating system. Much simpler times! But yeah, I don't think there is anything out there right now like what you're talking about. I would suggest simply purchasing a retro computer if you want to teach your kids the old school way. Python is a pretty good substitute for BASIC in my opinion, the only problem is you have to teach object-oriented stuff if your students want to make anything interesting with graphics. (I teach kids to code btw, thus my interest in the topic) EDIT: I forgot to mention FreeBASIC. With FreeBASIC you can do a lot of stuff the old school way, including graphics. However, I haven't actually gotten around to playing with FreeBASIC yet so I don't have a whole lot to say about it.
- thedaemon 8y agoAlso QB64, which has been mentioned here. It's pretty backwards compatible with QBasic, which is what I learned Basic with. It's cross compatible as well.
- ChuckMcM 8y agoWorking on it... :-) But not that I've seen. Some come closer than others. The current suggestion is a Raspberry Pi type system that is manipulated into booting into a BASIC or some other development environment. The closet thing right now is a micropython board.
- etaioinshrdlu 8y agoGet them Mathematica.
- 3rdAccount 8y agoThere's a lot of cool stuff you can do with Mathematica and it is available for free on Pi, but some people will take offense at closed source proprietary software and for good reason. Some things in the Wolfram language are so amazing though. Stephen Wolfram has commented on how bad highschool CS education is. Learning hello world and some Java or JS is great, but being able to seamlessly use the thousands of functions in Mathematica is really neat. For example, things like Conway's Game of Life, other automata, sound processing, image processing, neural networks...etc are all built in and composable primitives. The big downside is you're really just learning their tech stack and you often use a declarative approach, so they may miss out on imperative concepts (for loops are a code smell in wolfram language).
- matt-daemon 8y agoI saw some links to JSFiddle, but here's one that's maybe a little better (software-wise): Khan Academy [0]. It uses JavaScript, and they've added ProcessingJS wrappers so you don't have to use raw canvas API. They also have instructional videos and other content. It's also gamified. [1] [0] https://www.khanacademy.org/computer-programming/new/pjs https://www.khanacademy.org/computer-programming/new/pjs [1] https://www.khanacademy.org/computing https://www.khanacademy.org/computing
- lupire 8y agoThis seems overcomplicated, asking for setup that suits the parents' nostalgia instead of useful and attractive to the modern child. Just grab any handy compiter, open an interpreter window / shell console for the language of your choice, and let the kid play and learn.
- andrewstuart 8y agoThere's quite some distance between unboxing a Raspberry Pi and getting basic on a screen versus unboxing a BBC/Acorn to basic on the screen. I'd like it if there was a genuine retro computer remake like a C64 or really any of those old machines. When I say genuine I mean not an FPGA thing that looks the same and has the same feel but inside is a modern FPGA. I mean a computer with a real 6502 or Z80, "power on to basic" plus a real keyboard. There's so much old great books and educational materials for those old machines too. The problem with modern retro remakes is that they focus on being about games and ROMs and I can't think of any with a nice keyboard.
- cjdell 8y agoWhen I was running kids workshops I created this site so kids could write scripts (accessible by pressing ESC) to manipulate a Minecraft-style and using it they could even build their own games: http://webblocks.uk/ http://webblocks.uk/
- jaysonelliot 8y agoPersonally, I'd just get them an Apple II. They're still plentiful and cheap to find on eBay, and it's exactly what you're looking for. There are modern hardware upgrades you can find to use CF or SD cards in place of floppies, so old media won't be an issue, as well as modern ways to connect to an LCD screen, and even Ethernet cards if you want to go online. And of course, the Apple II is supremely open and hackable, perfect for kids who want to have access to the entire computer.
- drivers99 8y agoI second that. I just set up an Apple IIgs last weekend and was making some small Basic programs with my son. He was actually really into it, unlike in the past when he was too young. He has had some exposure to Scratch so that may have helped as well. We didn't have any way to load or save programs, so I'll have to look into the cards you mentioned.
- jaysonelliot 8y agoI have a CFFA3000 and an SDFloppy II. Both are great, but I prefer the CFFA3000 and use it regularly. CFFA3000: http://dreher.net/?s=projects/CFforAppleII&c=projects/CFforAppleII/main.php http://dreher.net/?s=projects/CFforAppleII&c=projects/CFforA... SDFloppy II: http://www.a2heaven.com/webshop/index.php?rt=product/product&product_id=124 http://www.a2heaven.com/webshop/index.php?rt=product/product... Another good option, the Floppy Emu: https://www.bigmessowires.com/floppy-emu/ https://www.bigmessowires.com/floppy-emu/
- sea-shore 8y agoI missed the c64 etc. but.. Any smartphone or laptop can do this and more, even within a browser. What might be the real question is what do we need to limit for new users to reach that state of boredom needed to explore and create, instead of getting stuck in The feed. Perhaps disable the network or pointing device? (Dedicated hardware per task, even for myself, is slowly winning me over)
- tlrobinson 8y agosudo apt-get install nodejs echo "/usr/bin/node" | sudo tee -a /etc/shells chsh -s /usr/bin/node Replace node with your favorite programming language :)
- Jun8 8y agoThere you go, I just saw this on Hackaday: https://hackaday.io/project/2428-single-chip-avr-basic-computer-v03 https://hackaday.io/project/2428-single-chip-avr-basic-compu...
- 3rdAccount 8y agoZXSpectrum Next is exactly this. An old ZXSpectrum computer that is newly made with more RAM and in a much better package. Complete with lots of games you can get. I think they're always out though....not sure if we'll ever see more :(
- danilocesar 8y agoWhen I was a kid there was a program called "MultimediaFusion". It was a drag'n'drop with some pre-defined elements and included a visual logical editor to define how objects behave (if then do that). I used a lot, I had no one to help with instructions, no internet, i didn't even know english at that time but I was able to write some games (bricks/arcanoid clone, space invaders clone, etc). I believe something like that would be a good way to teach pretty basic programming logic (no complex code). But this was almost 20 years ago... I'm pretty sure there's something better (and OSS) today.
- abijithk 8y agoIf the idea is to teach kids the constructs to coding then we are trying to achieve it through our products at - https://www.makewonder.com https://www.makewonder.com Its the first robot that was designed to teach coding to kids. It requires a robot and a tablet.
- cm2187 8y agoWhat about python for minecraft? I am not sure how accessible it is but I can see how it would appeal to kids, and they would learn a language that they can apply to other things.
- muxator 8y agoI learnt event-driven programming, OOP and GUI toolkits architecture studying a "borrowed" Pascal Turbo Vision manual that nobody in my high school was using. Later on I wanted to mess around with VGA mode X and direct memory access, but there was no internet at the time, and I had no books. So I just tried and tried, until it eventually worked. In a way, being limited to just a few sources of high quality information forced the young me to learn how to study them in deep. This was helpful because it gave the foundations and the method, and made it possible to explore unknown fields without guidance. Now that I wrote it down, I realized that this journey was so satisfying that it continues, in other forms, to the present day. I would not be surprised if the OP was moved by a similar desire to offer this kind of experience to kids. If so, I definitely can understand why.
- sigjuice 8y agoDijkstra’s blog post from 1975 is somewhat relevant :p https://www.cs.utexas.edu/users/EWD/ewd04xx/EWD498.PDF https://www.cs.utexas.edu/users/EWD/ewd04xx/EWD498.PDF
- leo_song 8y agoBASIC and any other toy platform are a bad ways of starting programming and primary school kids do speak in assembly code. Throw some microcontrollers, LEDs and motors to them, they will be happy. Boards like Arduino may be a good option.
- progval 8y agoDespite being 25yo, this is how I started programming too. My "computer" was a TI-80 calculator I had laying around. It can be programmed in a simple variant Basic: 26 variables, 6 arrays, but also plotting capabilities. You can probably still find such a calculator, like the TI-82 family which is being revived. Just avoid the TI-Nspire which looks fancy but is hard to program.
- krick 8y ago> everyone will want to say "Raspberry Pi" of some form, but does that meet my requirement? Uhm, yeah, I'd say it does. Autorun ipython on startup, either no graphical shell or very restricted WM and you are done.
- d99kris 8y agoWhile not a complete hardware/software solution, there are some simple "OS'es" that boots directly into a BASIC interpreter, which should be possible to use on any old x86 laptop. OS64: https://github.com/xlar54/emudore64 https://github.com/xlar54/emudore64 NopeOS: https://github.com/d99kris/nopeos https://github.com/d99kris/nopeos (Disclosure: I wrote - or rather glued together - NopeOS)
- dahart 8y agoI learned on power-on-to-basic computers in ye olde days... Atari 800, Apple ][, C64, IBM PCjr. I have tried to teach my kids programming exactly the same way, I was looking for the same thing. I don’t think we can bring back ye olde days. My kids are actually interested in programming, but they don’t have the patience for command line anything. It was my wish to teach them the same way that I learned, but in retrospect, I don’t think it’s the best way for them to learn. My oldest (14 years) has been a tech freak since he was 3 years old, and he’s just starting to dig into text programming and command lines, but he won’t work on it for more than a few minutes before he’s off to YouTube. I was into that stuff by the time I was 10 and could do it for hours. Tablets and smart phones and Nintendos and Netflix and Steam add up to an environment where the choice to slow down and read console is too difficult for young kids. If teaching is the primary goal and a power-on-to-basic not necessarily required, then there are so many great options for starting. Maybe too many. There are literally dozens of fantastic suggestions in this thread. Mobile tablets have a built-in TV and there are great apps for beginner coding. Some of the “no code” game engines are excellent for the beginner. I looked through all the suggestions and didn’t see this one yet: open your browser devtools. You always have a browser, and it comes with a JS REPL. Chrome (for example) lets you save and evaluate snippets, and you can choose easy stuff to start with using only console.log(). It can be very similar to BASIC.
- cozzyd 8y agoYou could try adding init=/usr/bin/ipython to your kernel command line, but I bet that won't end well (way too lazy to try this).
- masto 8y agoThere is exactly this: https://basicengine.org/ https://basicengine.org/ The catch is that you have to build it yourself, and there is some surface mount soldering. I put one together and found it to be an enjoyable project.
- justaaron 8y agomicrocontrollers... arduino seems to be a popular smoothed-over platform/IDE/ecosystem that's friendly to beginners. The actual C++ is largely hidden and one deals with statements inside one of a few preset event handlers in an event-loop...
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- mhh__ 8y agoCould you buy a BBC Micro? Pricey probably, but great heirloom too
- anttipoi 8y agoDrRacket? (https://racket-lang.org https://racket-lang.org) That is what I gave my mom when she asked what she could try programming on. It features a simple whole window editor/repl where you can get straight into business. What failed was the supporting literature. I thought Realm of Racket would have been ideal for self-study but it did assume more background than she had... https://www.amazon.com/Realm-Racket-Learn-Program-Game/dp/1593274912 https://www.amazon.com/Realm-Racket-Learn-Program-Game/dp/15...
- a-saleh 8y agoAt a previous team a colleague was a big proponent of BBC MicroBit [1], I have seen it sell around 15-20$ You are expected to code in your browser, then download a binary and copy it over to the little device that is recognized as a usb-drive. You have scratch-like javascript ide [1] and a python ide [3] I remember a presentation about the ways they used in a class of 8yo kids. They were making simple games, managed to network them to create simple pagers. It is the most hardware thing you can get with the lowesr barier to entry, i.m.o :) [1] https://microbit.org/resellers/ https://microbit.org/resellers/ [2] https://makecode.microbit.org/# https://makecode.microbit.org/# [3] https://python.microbit.org/v/1.1 https://python.microbit.org/v/1.1
- pxi 8y agoI've been maintaining an obscure version of BASIC called "SmallBASIC" for a few too many years. It started out as a calculator for the PalmPilot (by another developer). You can build it on a raspberry machine or there's an out of date binary you could try. https://smallbasic.github.io https://smallbasic.github.io
- jdck1326 8y agoWhen I was about nine I used something called misoft basic! on ios. Not exactly what you're asking for but it did the job.
- yetanotherfrank 8y agoI separate "power on to" and "BASIC". In my view, Python, is the language closest to "BASIC done right," so I am interested in "power-on-to-Python". In classic "power-on-to-BASIC," the BASIC interpreter was a single shell that allows interactive instructions, OS commands, and editing (with line numbers). Even to run a game, one needed to know and type at least one BASIC command. Python's shortcoming here is that one cannot easily run Python programs from inside the Python REPL. Check out this silly attempt at Python with line numbers and a READY prompt...: https://github.com/frankseide/basicpython https://github.com/frankseide/basicpython The big difference between a Python IDE and Scratch (and similar GUI-based systems) is that Scratch is a top-down approach that start with high-level objects/operations and gradually give access to more and more details. On the other hand, the classic BASIC computers, and a Python system, are bottom-up. Those would not allow self-written games to be flashy from the start, but on the other hand kids would gain a much deeper understanding since they have to build things up themselves.
- IcePic 8y agoThere are quite a few "boot to basic" comments here, but one of the things I think they are missing when suggestions like "you can just have rpi start X,Y,Z at boot" or "use W,R,S in your browser" come is that when you have something like ZX Spectrum or C64 it was a static platform for 5-10 (and now upto 30) years, so there was no "oh, you can't DL jquery so your fancy webthing broke" or "you'll get to your IDE soon but first java updates, apt updates, chkdisk, fdisk, or something else that needs to pop up in your face", and of course no other kinds of distractions like "bah, my game doesn't work, lets zone out on youtube lolcats or play $random_FPS instead" to take up your attention.
- joaofiliperocha 8y agoSinclair ZX Spectrum was a greate machine to learn Programming