13 ms·
Declassified documents show why the US and the USSR came close to war in 1973
- jsiepkes 8y ago> For many years we thought the aggressive Soviet behavior during the war was a ploy to undercut American influence, or gain access to oil or warm-water ports. The new evidence suggests it was simply a case of bad crisis management. Never attribute to malice what you attribute to incompetence....
- philipov 8y agoAny sufficiently advanced incompetence is indistinguishable from malice.
- verelo 8y agoWhen two parties cannot effectively communicate, that’s true. Most of the time when a real conversation can be had these issues quickly dissolve, but having a conversation like that in a political environment or large corporate environment can be super tough to make happen. It’s sad we struggle to find common ground with others and resort to war and second guessing our “competition”.
- kbenson 8y agoI love everything about this sentence. It also feels very relevant to current events.
- barrow-rider 8y ago> It also feels very relevant to current events. What events are you referring to? Having a heart-to-heart honest communication isn't going to solve shit if the parties are greedy as fuck, or out-and-out Nazis.
- kbenson 8y ago> What events are you referring to? A lot of events, all over, but mostly politically and with offenders on both sides. Neither is interested in even trying to understand the underlying emotions and reasons for the actions of the other. They're both so bad at understanding each other that at this point all they see is malice. > the parties are greedy as fuck, or out-and-out Nazis. Case in point.
- ocschwar 8y agoI should light a candle for St. Stanislav PEtrov.
- TeMPOraL 8y agoRemember to light one for Vasili Arkhipov and another for John Bordne, on 27th and 28th of this month, respectively. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10452983#10455951 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10452983#10455951
- kkotak 8y agoDon't forget; Henry Kissinger was involved.
- cies 8y agoOh shit.
- Synaesthesia 8y agoGood lord I’ve heard before about how there was a close superpower conflict in 1973. This is very alarming, and it could still happen between the US and Russia or China. We’re really playing with Fire if you look at the number of close calls there have been with nuclear weapons. The only sane way we can carry on guaranteeing a decent existence for mankind is to work towards a world free of nuclear weapons. https://www.upi.com/Yom-Kippur-Israels-1973-nuclear-alert/64941032228992/ https://www.upi.com/Yom-Kippur-Israels-1973-nuclear-alert/64... https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2012/oct/15/cuban-missile-crisis-russian-roulette https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2012/oct/15/cuban-...
- WrtCdEvrydy 8y agoWe actually have slowly begun having less and less nuclear weapons, you just don't hear about it https://fas.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/Stockpile-History.jpg https://fas.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/Stockpile-History...
- Synaesthesia 8y agoIt’s still plenty enough to destroy the world. We’re still spending money to modernize nuclear weapons, and now Russia and China are too, a logical response.
- avar 8y agoThis is true, but once you start looking into it is highly misleading. A huge (and maybe only) reason for this is advances in targeting systems. In the 70s and 80s targeting systems were much worse, so you might expect to send tens of nukes to destroy a single reinforced bunker, since many would miss by hundreds of meters to kilometers. So often you needed tens of nukes for a single strategic target. Nowadays targeting systems are so good and launch / reentry vehicles so reliable that a single nuke can hit exactly in the right x-y coordinate and in the exact z coordinate sweetspot to destroy that bunker. So you don't need as many. So the number of nukes has gone down, but the destructive power is quite similar, although I suppose in the event of an all-out war we'll have less fallout.
- 40acres 8y agoTwo things strike me after reading this. 1: How much conflict has been spawned due to the UN Partition plan which created Israel? I haven't dug deep into the factors that led to this decision (I'm sure the aftermath of the Holocaust was understandably huge) but the idea that a new sovereign nation would be created catering to individuals who don't currently live in the land which consists of that new nations borders just seems absurd to me. 2: Maybe this is ageist on my part but after watching hours of Senate committee hearings this year (Zuckerburgs testimony and the Kavanaugh hearings) I would not be against a mandatory mental health check up for our highest officials which includes some sort of mechanism to remove them from office if they are determined mentally unfit to serve. I can't imagine the pressure that government officials deal with everyday but I don't think its safe to assume that the levels of bureaucracy are enough to contain an individual who is mentally unfit from making rash decisions that can affect the nation.
- will4274 8y ago> How much conflict has been spawned due to the UN Partition plan which created Israel? Why would you brame a UN agreement from 20 years earlier instead of blaming the countries which violated the peace treaties they signed only 8 years earlier?
- rrggrr 8y ago>1: How much conflict has been spawned due to the UN Partition plan which created Israel? I haven't dug deep into the factors that led to this decision (I'm sure the aftermath of the Holocaust was understandably huge) but the idea that a new sovereign nation would be created catering to individuals who don't currently live in the land which consists of that new nations borders just seems absurd to me. Okay, so why not do some reading on it before deciding its absurd? Tens of thousands of Jews were displaced during and after WWII and no country would take most of them, period. Go back, get educated, and then post the less "absurd" alternative. >2: Maybe this is ageist on my part but after watching hours of Senate committee hearings this year (Zuckerburgs testimony and the Kavanaugh hearings) I would not be against a mandatory mental health check up for our highest officials which includes some sort of mechanism to remove them from office if they are determined mentally unfit to serve. The 25th Amendment and Congressional Impeachment power provide such mechanisms for removal. As for diagnosis, and similar to your prior comment, you really need to understand how politics works before you propose candidates submit to psychological evaluation prior to assuming elected office. In other words... who then is going to evaluate the (unelected) evaluators?
- kop316 8y ago"A nuclear standoff. One leader is drunk. The other is delirious. The underlings scramble to avoid the worst. This is not an end-of-the-world Hollywood thriller, or an episode in President Trump’s erratic diplomacy." No matter you're opinion of Trump, I find it extremely off putting when you are reading an article and the author feels the need to get in a jab like that, on either side of the political spectrum. I have seen that in other lectures before, and I feel it undermines the credibly of the author.
- rat87 8y agoIf you want to pretend we live in a world where the US has a sane President it's your choice. The fact that legally no one can stop the president from ordering nukes launch is a flaw our system has long had but this is easily the time where this flaw is more frightening since Nixon's aides illegally conspired to prevent a drink Nixon form launching nukes during impeachment This isn't some sort of political bias, it's just acknowledging reality. This is one of the many things keeping washintons foreign policy professionals awake at night during the Trump era
- rrggrr 8y agoOne can pathologize almost any President and be right. Kennedy, Roosevelt, Clinton, Reagan... from drug addiction to senility something has afflicted all of these men. Its not led to nuclear war precisely because there exists a command authority and leadership depth in the US (and Russia) that has worked well enough. Try not to confuse political rhetoric with a lack of self-awareness when judging the current President. One who pays close attention to his extemporaneous comments and speeches will notice a familiar struggle between impulsivity and self-awareness driven self-control that is actually pretty reassuring.
- jonathankoren 8y agoThe law is clear. The president has complete control over nuclear weapons, and can order their deployment at anytime. That is by design. This is the lynchpin of mutual assured destruction, and what enables launch on warning to occur. A president at any time can spin the globe, close his eyes and pick a city at random and say “nuke it”, legally it is a valid order. I too have paid closer attention to the current president’s remarks, and I see so evidence of self-awareness and self-control. I see bullying pretending to be strength. I see habitual self-aggrandizing lies. I see the worst kind of bullshitter: one that believes his own bullshit.
- empath75 8y agoThe interesting thing to me in this article is that basically the equivalent of ‘the deep state’ — the intelligence services — acted to control the worst impulses of the leader, something that I sincerely hope is also happening in both countries right now.
- rrggrr 8y agoWhich "worst impulses" are you concerned about controlling "right now"? Because the only impulse providing a check against Chinese and Russian national interests globally, is the current administration's readiness to go to war - if necessary - to preserve a semblance of rule-of-law. US soft power hegemony was spent, utterly depleted during and after Gulf War II. Rebuilding it requires a hard power economic and military commitment no other candidate/administration was willing to undertake.
- macintux 8y agoIt's remarkable how different people can read the same actions in very different ways. "Rule of law" is not something I would ascribe as a high priority to the current U.S. administration.
- rrggrr 8y agoReally? Because the South China Sea dispute is an excellent example. Nobody supports China's sovereignty claim over the disputed islands. International law and custom does not support China's claim. Who is standing up for rule of law? The current administration. The same can be said of chemical weapons use in Syria, and Russian assassinations in the UK, trade manipulation by China, etc. Rule of Law isn't what you think it is, and it doesn't work in the manner you assume.
- empath75 8y agoLol, most of the republicans in the administration don't believe that international law even exists.
- 8y ago
- workmandan 8y agoThe mixing of sleeping pills and alcohol causing poor decision making reminds me somewhat of Elon Musk's recent outbreaks. I believe I read somewhere he is currently taking lots of Ambien.
- tabtab 8y agoMaybe we need 3 Presidents for each shift. If you woke me up at 4am, I'd be so grouchy I'd press every button around me.
- interfixus 8y agoLate 1973 - when I was fourteen - was a seriously scary time. I have a very clear memory of hearing on the news one Saturday afternoon that Arab forces were moving against Israel, and of hastening outside to tell my father, who was mowing the lawn. I still consider it a defining moment in my life: Like September 2001, or the Kennedy assasination. Always surprised that noone else seems to recall it like this. To me, that was truly the start of the dreary seventies, very much the deat knell of the last remaining sixties optimism. Oil shortage real or imagined, rising unemployment, a crisis spirit that stayed with us for many years and still cast shadows. And the nuclear alert. It was known at the time that the US had gone on heightened alert. It scared me shitless, I remember.
- i_am_nomad 8y agoI’m reminded of the lyric, “We haven’t had that spirit here since 1969.” That loss of optimism is exactly what Henley was singing about.
- mrleiter 8y agoWhat a fitting article on #worldmentalhealthday.
- duxup 8y ago>When Mr. Brezhnev’s message arrived, Mr. Nixon was reported to be indisposed; Mr. Kissinger and the White House chief of staff, Alexander Haig, decided not to wake him up. Instead, Mr. Kissinger called together a meeting of principals to consider America’s response. They moved the nuclear alert level to Defcon 3, the highest since the Cuban missile crisis. Maybe time to wake the president if you're chaining the defense condition...
- nabla9 8y agoNixon was suffering from mental illness and taking daily mediation without a prescription. He was under heavy stress from the Watergate scandal. Schlesinger (Secretary of Defence) ordered military not to react to orders from the White House unless he cleared them first. Nixon ordered bombing raids that were silently canceled by Kissinger.
- duxup 8y agoWell that is terrifying / rumor has it not unlike our current POTUS with the military rumored to be ignoring orders. Comforting at least that there are people responsible enough to ignore those orders.
- mionhe 8y agoDo you have any sources for that? I haven't personally run across any rumors to that effect...
- duxup 8y agoI think it was in the book that came out or one of the many sources from inside the white house where supposedly Trump ordered Asad killed and the order was simply ignored. That was the most dramatic, but not the only report of his own people working around his orders. There have been quite a few such news reports.
- 8y ago
- kposehn 8y ago> If there is a lesson today’s leaders should heed, it is that in the end, luck always runs out. The good ‘ol hot-hand fallacy in action. It surprises me how easily otherwise intelligent people in positions of significant power (in regards to their situation, such as an unchallenged boss at a small company all the way up to national leaders), forget that what they believed to be true yesterday could easily not be tomorrow. Challenge your assumptions constantly.
- FahadUddin92 8y agoBoth have been fighting proxy war since then in Afghanistan and other countries. Pakistan fought proxy war against USSR for US and has since been bearing the loss. And now Trump says Pakistan doesn't do much efforts. US used Pakistan as their scapegoating.
- bunderbunder 8y agoIf you're interested in this sort of thing, check out the book Essence of Decision, by Graham T. Allison. It analyzes the Cuban missile crisis under three different models for understanding how organizations make decisions, and talks about how one might make sense of the facts in light of those models. It's a fascinating read. The situation comes out feeling like a particularly operatic Kurosawa movie. Only the whole thing actually happened.
- jld 8y agoIf anyone is interested in reading a modern, hopefully fictional take of a similar situation, I recommend the 2020 Commission Report by Jeffery Lewis. https://www.amazon.com/Commission-Report-Nuclear-Attacks-Against-ebook/dp/B079VDR6HM https://www.amazon.com/Commission-Report-Nuclear-Attacks-Aga...
- equalunique 8y agoI wouldn't. Seems to me that the author is cashing in on his ability to fear-monger rather than providing something of substantial value.
- jld 8y agoI found value in understanding how disconnected chains of command/advising can impact decision making, as well as lessons in assuming how your adversaries will interpret your actions is not always correct. It certainly is an approachable layman's novel, not an academic piece. Definitely worth the few hours it took to read.
- anon49124 8y agoI was listening to a podcast about a Scandinavian sounding rocket causing Boris Yeltsin to insert the key/codes in the nuclear briefcase and nearly pushed the button to launch a counter attack if that rocket were a surprise American attack. Apparently, it was proactive readiness and the Russians only disclosed week/s on to not alarm people unnecessarily.
- sailfast 8y agoThis author suggests the lesson is that a leader’s time always runs out. What I took out of this history (as a student of it) was that if something crazy comes across the wire, be patient. Sometimes ignoring the cable / letter that doesn’t fit is the right call.
- jumelles 8y agoHere's a direct link to the archive: https://digitalarchive.wilsoncenter.org/collection/505/yom-kippur-war https://digitalarchive.wilsoncenter.org/collection/505/yom-k...
- gukov 8y agoStanislav Petrov single-handedly prevented an all-out nuclear war in 83: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1983_Soviet_nuclear_false_alarm_incident https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1983_Soviet_nuclear_false_alar...
- thansz 8y agoVasili Arkhipov also helped to prevent nuclear war in 1962: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vasili_Arkhipov https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vasili_Arkhipov Boris Yeltsin also had enough presence of mind not to launch a counter-attack to what was presumed to be a US first strike in the Norwegian Rocket Incident: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Norwegian_rocket_incident https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Norwegian_rocket_incident Unfortunately, there are too many close calls involving large scale nuclear conflict that are publicly known: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_military_nuclear_accidents https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_military_nuclear_accid... Who knows what the actual number is. Now throw in the ramifications of climate change like political instability, infrastructure strain, resource scarcity, and refugee migrations into the mix. Not blowing ourselves up will really be a challenge, something we as a species have to get right every single day...forever. Let's hope it's not our Great Filter.
- PhasmaFelis 8y ago> Declassified documents show why the US and the USSR came close to war in 1973 I read that and immediately thought "probably because their leaders were goddamn idiots," then chastised myself for being so reductionist. Then I read the article and the answer is, literally, "because Nixon and Brezhnev were blasted on booze and pills."
- sAbakumoff 8y ago>> Mr. Brezhnev had developed an addiction to sleeping pills that, combined with alcohol, was undermining his ability to think straight. And this person was the leader of evil empire for 18 years!!! How lucky we are that he hasn't started the nuclear war.