7 ms·
It's not actually all that secretive. There's two related levels though: personal and corporate. As soon as you're making more than a few hundred grand, or you
by lordnacho 8y ago
It's not actually all that secretive. There's two related levels though: personal and corporate.
As soon as you're making more than a few hundred grand, or you become a junior on a ladder that looks like you'll get there, people will get a hold of you on the personal side.
On the corporate side, as soon as you touch offshore, one of the big 4 that you already work with will suggest some tax optimization as a matter of course.
It's always weird, requiring whole pages of A4 diagrams, and you'll never really understand why these constructions work.
Some of the ones I've been offered have been downright ridiculous. One involved setting myself up as an advisor on rap lyrics. Another required me to publish my own poetry. IMO the weird ones are the most aggressive, and it's always sold as a tax reduction, so I've never gone ahead with them. It just seems too good to be true, and someone's gotta pay for social expenses.
On the corporate side, it's a bit less clear cut. You have a duty to shareholders to more or less do what everyone else does. There's also the fact that some governments actively court firms to set up shop with a discount, which is a sort of mutually beneficial bargain.
- chii 8y ago> someone's gotta pay for social expenses. while it's honorable to do so, one single person/entity isn't gonna change the tide. It's political will and changes to tax code that will make the difference - stop tax loop holes, and stop off-shore accounts that are untracable, etc.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- gaius 8y agoA previous employer had an extremely weird WAN topology, until you realised that all this data was circumnavigating the world as part of a grand tax reduction strategy. All fully legal of course. In the end they simplified by simply cutting a deal with the Irish government. Of course they also went on enjoying all the facilities and infra provided by those who did pay their fair share of UK taxes. If any of the directors or their children had been taken ill or been in an accident, they surely would have expected the NHS to take care of them... At the time, this was many years ago, I just saw all this as a fascinating technical challenge in database replication and distributed transactions; I’m obviously alot more woke now and wouldn’t get involved with it now.
- Scoundreller 8y agoMy guess is that they tried to claim the "value-add" was all in this other jurisdiction (e.g. the DB or the "secret sauce" algorithm, or something as boring as applying their "valuable" trademark after paying a license fee). Canadian mining companies do this with "hedging" contracts with their Swiss subsidiary that is basically a desk with 3 directors. Wait until you've hit a low in the market, then sign away the future growth to the subsidiary for "price-stability". On the WAN side, I deliberately choose foreign AWS locations just to avoid the sales tax from domestic AWS sites...
- PaulAJ 8y agoTerry Pratchett wrote a letter to The Times about taxes, reproduced in "A Slip of the Keyboard". In it he says: I have been enormously buoyed up, though, by hearing from journalists and other pundits that ‘the rich won’t end up paying the 50 per cent income tax because their smart accountants will find a way around it’. When I put this to my own accountant, a senior member of a reputable London firm, he laughed and said: ‘Unless you want to go and live abroad for a very long time, or associate with some extremely unsavoury people, or invest in risky tax schemes, then for someone like you there is really nothing that can be done.’
- saiya-jin 8y agoThat ain't true at all, there are tons of options in Europe where you can hide, well anything. UK has their own Channel islands, for various purposes you have Luxembourg, Malta, Switzerland, Monaco and so on. You only need to be resident on paper, never physically set a foot there. Every politician, tax attorney/advisor or tax collector knows this, if they claim they don't they are lying to your face (or are utterly incompetent). Why do you think normal flat in Monaco costs up to 20+ million eur? It is a nice place, but not THAT nice (In MCO case you need only postbox which can be rented cheaply as many professional athletes do... unless you are French citizen, then you are screwed but can go elsewhere)
- graeme 8y agoHide legally, or hide illegally? Pratchett may have been referring to legal methods only.
- saiya-jin 8y agoOf course its legal by laws of the place where it happens. That's why EU has some issue with some of its members like Ireland, or Luxembourg. Hiding usually means just avoiding paying most of the income taxes (ie 5% instead of 40% or even much more in places like Scandinavia). In most countries, tax brackets for really high incomes are just ridiculously high, so everybody seeks to pay less taxes while staying legal. Taxes are a sinkhole from rich payer's perspective - you get back very little and you pay a lot. It's like expecting common Joe not claiming some tax breaks he is entitled to. Why on earth would he not do it?
- bryanrasmussen 8y agoCan you describe the advisor on rap lyrics and publish own poetry models more closely, I would like some examples of how the weird ones work.
- lordnacho 8y agoSo I think they were related, due to there being some law about writing off artistic ventures. Unfortunately I don't really understand the details. The idea was for people to spend at least a couple of hours a week listening to and commenting on the music of P Diddy. I'm not sure how it connected legally on his side of the deal, but I also got this feeling that my musical input would not have a great impact on the artistic vision of Mr Diddy. The poetry one was some guys who somehow found out that you could publish a book of crap poetry and write it off as a loss. Some spidery network of entities would in effect use this to reduce your taxes by a lot. I know of people who've had the court rule against them, and they ended up in massive trouble.
- fjsolwmv 8y ago>You have a duty to shareholders to more or less do what everyone else does. This is a insidious myth that has never been uphed in court. It's just an excuse managers use.
- lordnacho 8y agoThe point is not whether you are in fact legally obliged; You will have one more thing to explain if you don't just do what everyone does.
- vonmoltke 8y ago> The point is not whether you are in fact legally obliged Then don't use the word "duty", which indicates a legal obligation.
- null000 8y agoIt's just an excuse assholes use