20 ms·
Cincinnati Joins the List of Cities Saying ‘No’ to Parking Minimums
- tomohawk 8y agoSo glad I live in the burbs where artificial scarcity induced by petty local politics isn't a thing. There's petty politics everywhere, of course, but worrying about where to park my car? No really something I have time for.
- 0xB31B1B 8y agoWhich burbs, the burbs are usually the definition of artificial scarcity. Setbacks, minimum lot sizes, FAR restrictions are all a suburban concept for the most part.
- opportune 8y agoYes, in parts of Seattle and SF for example, the "suburbs" would really be at least 4 floor multifamily residences (some a lot taller) if not for "artificial scarcity induced by petty local politics"
- jonknee 8y agoHow is a parking minimum artificial scarcity? If anything it seems like it's an artificial excess.
- closeparen 8y agoRequiring housing to be accompanied by parking yields more parking but also less housing, as the additional cost takes projects on the margin below profitability and the space occupied by parking can't be used for more units (without expensive underground garages).
- Zarath 8y agoThe burbs are absolutely horrible. You literally can't do anything without getting into your car and driving.
- icebraining 8y agoI was liked this example by Andrés Duany: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W1X5uVR5NxY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W1X5uVR5NxY (The whole lecture is pretty good)
- twblalock 8y agoParking requirements are artificial surplus. Letting businesses decide how much parking they want to build is not artificial scarcity, but just the free market at work. If the majority of people are like you, businesses will be incentivized by market forces build enough parking to accommodate them. So what are you worried about?
- ChuckMcM 8y agoAnd the strongtowns take: https://www.strongtowns.org/parking/ https://www.strongtowns.org/parking/ It seems to me it would put pressure on other issues (investing in public transit) which may not followed up on, thus leaving you with a dysfunctional urban infrastructure.
- twblalock 8y agoIf there hadn’t been minimum parking requirements in the past, cities would have been forced to develop better transit. These requirements were a direct subsidy to car owners, which most people were not conscious of. This will be a painful transition for people who depend on the status quo. But you have to pull the band-aid off sometime, and waiting longer won’t make it any better.
- GW150914 8y agoConsidering that “cars owners” in America represent 88%, maybe it’s just an alignment of interests. Maybe alternatives are rejected not because of these subtle systemic issues, but rather because a supermajority of Americans own cars and don’t want the alternatives? Talking about “car owners” like that isn’t synonymous with “most Americans” is a very particular way to frame the issue that makes it seem like a top-down structure when it isn’t.
- twblalock 8y agoThe problem is, everyone driving and parking a car in dense urban areas is not sustainable past a certain level of density. This results in heavy traffic and a large amount of land dedicated to parking which could be better used as anything else. This is a top-down structure that was intentionally designed by urban planners after WWII and it is reaching its scalability limit.
- GW150914 8y agoIt’s a giant country, and despite what people in the Silicon Valley bubble think, there are a lot of cities with a lot of space. This is an insoluble problem if everyone demands acces to a spot in one or two major cities, because that’s where VC money is concentrated. That’s not a problem for most people though, who frankly don’t care about housing problems or traffic problems for techies. They’ll switch over to EV’s, but good luck trying to get them to embrace trains and busses.
- twblalock 8y ago
- sandworm101 8y ago>>> "The Seattle bill required commercial and residential buildings to charge residents for parking only if they actually had a car." They did this in my old hometown. (North Shore, Vancouver.) They allowed all sorts of condos to be built on the assumption that they would be rented by retired/rich people. Retired people don't drive. Rich people don't have jobs. So the buildings went ahead without associated infrastructure/transport improvements. Now the nurses coming to take care of the elderly residents have to part at the local mall (Park Royal) which is now debating payed parking. Visiting grandchildren (minivans) fight for street space. And the city is becoming grayer and grayer. I've since moved out of vancouver, to a much younger and more vibrant city. I cannot remember the last time I paid for parking.
- Zelphyr 8y agoI saw this exact situation happen at a previous employer. Three large high-end apartment buildings were built in an area where a large percentage of the residential population are older wealthy people. The three buildings have minimal parking and are located right across the street from a mall. Within two years of the first building being completed, the mall implemented paid parking.
- Fomite 8y agoIn the town I grew up in, this happened as well - and is now killing said mall.
- luma 8y agoIn private conversations with the local city mobility department (which covers public transport and parking), there is a lot of tension building up due to the expectation of autonomous vehicles coming online within a decade. Floating a 20 year bond to build new parking structures used to be a safe investment but there is now a widespread expectation that personal vehicles will not require parking facilities well before that bond could be paid off. It is forcing a re-evaluation of the traditional regulatory, zoning, and financial instruments historically employed by cities to address these problems, and nobody is certain of the answer.
- joe_the_user 8y agoGood. It would ironic if an expectation of autonomous vehicles actually forced cities to create public transit if they failed to appear.
- mc32 8y agoIt's reasonable to be tentative given the uncertainty. Is it possible to build a mixed use structure with parking at the lower levels that are designed with enough use flexibility that they could be converted into regular occupancy use if (when) parking demand is reduced?
- ghaff 8y agoThose cars still need to go somewhere. Maybe there's more sharing from the outskirts? But if you assume that cars will just drop off and then drive out to some vaguely defined area outside of the city where parking is plentiful, you're going to massively increase congestion.
- joe_the_user 8y agoSelf-driving cars technically wouldn't have to go anywhere besides the roads - except maybe periodically to charging and a repair station. Of course, by 3 am, it might be cheaper to have them parked. But there's a lot of parking currently available at 3 am. Of course, these cars occupy space, which means the road they'd be on would be a good deal more occupied. But remember, parking and traffic aren't static per-car, it's all a matter of rates.
- finaliteration 8y agoI feel really mixed about things like this. I absolutely appreciate the need for additional housing in urban centers, especially if it makes housing more affordable. However, I’m also someone who lives relatively far from an urban center with no reliable public transportation for the sake of having housing that isn’t ridiculously expensive. This means I’m required to drive into the urban center for work where parking is already expensive and difficult to find. The lot where I usually park has months long waiting lists to get a monthly pass. Again, I totally understand the rationale behind it. It’s just frustrating for those of us who have no better options in the near future.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- secabeen 8y agoPark-and-ride is the usual solution. Can you drive in from your home to a large lot where the reliable public transit begins, and then ride from there? That can work pretty well.
- finaliteration 8y agoWe have some of those available, but they would increase my commute time by 30 minutes both ways, and the busses can be unreliable, which means sometimes it can take an hour. It may work for some people, but unfortunately I’m not willing to give up an extra two hours of my day when I can drive in. I used to take a train, but it took 50-60 minutes, and any delay meant I missed a connection or transfer which then added even more time. As much as I want to do it and support it’s just not feasible.
- another-cuppa 8y ago> I’m not willing to give up an extra two hours of my day when I can drive in. Right. But in the future you won't be able to drive in. So move closer to work, I guess.
- crwalker 8y agoI am optimistic that we are relearning how to build great cities in the US.
- village-idiot 8y agoGood. Let the price of parking float rather than artificially depressing the price via zoning.
- vermooten 8y agoWhat are 'parking minimums'?
- TulliusCicero 8y agoMost US cities have land use regulations that mandate a minimum amount of car parking for any building type. Things like "at least 1.5 parking spaces per apartment unit" or "1200 sq ft of parking for each 1000 sq ft of retail space" (yes, sometimes they're really that high). This guarantee subsidizes car parking at the expense of other modes of transportation, whose users are indirectly paying for the cost of that parking, and who suffer disproportionately from how spread out that extra parking makes everything in a city.
- twic 8y agoI'm always bemused by the idea. In London, we have parking maximums - expressed as the number of spaces per housing unit, for various sizes of housing unit (measured in habitable rooms per unit), and various levels of public transport accessibility: https://www.london.gov.uk/sites/default/files/parking_standards_malp_for_publication_7_april_2016.pdf https://www.london.gov.uk/sites/default/files/parking_standa... At one extreme, a three-bedroom house in an area of the suburbs with poor public transport could have two parking spaces. At the other, a five-bedroom house in an urban area with excellent public transport could only have one parking space. Even then, "all developments in areas of good public transport accessibility (in all parts of London) should aim for significantly less than 1 space per unit".
- MBCook 8y agoRequiring at least X parking spaces for every Y hundred square feet of floor space in a building. Or based on maximum occupancy or some other metric. It’s why you see small niche businesses in strip malls with large and always empty parking lots. They’re REQUIRED to have lots that big if they don’t/can’t get a variance. And it can be a lot of wasted space, and a deterrent to using public transit. After all, there is always easy parking.
- TulliusCicero 8y ago
- thomastjeffery 8y ago> “Unbundling makes parking more transparent,” a researcher from Sightline told Next City at the time. “When people realize they’re paying $200 a month for parking they might opt out or get by with one car instead of two, then the market builds less of it which is what we want.” What is "it" in this sentence? Parking? Why do you want less parking?
- ImaCake 8y agoMaybe it's more a general complaint about cars. If the city has been requiring free parking spaces then it has been effectively paying for people to own cars. In general I can see why certain leaderships would wish for less cars for broader reasons. Cars are wasteful and consume precious resources. They kill people, both directly, and indirectly. They discourage people from walking and cycling - both are good ways to increase livability and safety of a community. Finally, cars contribute to the damage we are doing to the planet. Some leaders care about the environment, or at least pretend to for votes.
- smackfu 8y agoI’ve noticed sometimes the parking minimum is essentially just used as a source of power for the zoning board. They don’t actually want places to build the required large amounts of parking, but they don’t want to have to rubber stamp developments that they don’t like. So they waive the parking requirements of people that make the changes that they want.
- lewis500 8y agoParking minimums are based on a handbook full of pseudoscience. When city engineers crack open the ITE handbook, it’s the equivalent of a doctor cracking open some old medieval text about humours.
- jstanley80 8y agoThis makes sense for Cincinnati's urban core, since it once had a population density similar to New York. The neighborhoods referenced in the article are incredibly walkable and the city has already invested in a streetcar system to move between neighborhoods. Overall, Cincinnati's neighborhoods within 10 miles of downtown are filled with dense, pre-war construction centered around public squares connected by public transit. The city is already laid out to function without cars (streetcars were abundant here in the 1800s).
- qwerty456127 8y agoThat seems a really weird move for a place where almost everybody has a car. It would be reasonable if the public transport system was well-developed, growing rapidly and meant to be the main means for the people to travel the city but isn't the USA (with exception of a small number of places) primarily a car country?