14 ms·
After century of removing appendixes, doctors find antibiotics can be enough
- ArcMex 8y agoHm, interesting article. Had mine removed last year. Stayed in the hospital for about a week, then made a full recovery three weeks later. I am ready to become physically active again.
- cabalistik_ 8y agoGot confused there for a moment, thought it was about PDF files...
- doon123 8y agohaha ... abe chutiye !!!
- montenegrohugo 8y agoSo what is the biological mechanism at work here? Take boatloads of antibiotics and kill most of your intestinal flora, so that inflammation on the appendix is reduced? (If I'm completely of the mark please correct me, it's been years since I had any biology related coursework) With all the recent studies of the evolving antibiotic-resistant properties of bacteria and the importance of mantaining a healthy intestinal flora and how much the gut influences the brain, I am not sure that this treatment is necessarily preferable to modern appendix removal surgery. That said, if given the option, I'd probably prefer this than getting cut open (even if the incision with modern techniques is very very small).
- alFReD-NSH 8y agoI'm guessing you still have to take antibiotics when you have any surgery to reduce chance of getting an infection.
- kristofferR 8y agoThe whole point of the appendix is maintaining a healthy gut flora, so removing it for the sake of avoiding antibiotics that impact the gut flora doesn't seem that wise. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Appendix_(anatomy)#Maintaining_gut_flora https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Appendix_(anatomy)#Maintaining...
- jaggederest 8y agoIt's interesting, an acquaintance of mine had this happen. Hospitalized, with antibiotics, but just fine, no knife. Definitely surprising to hear about, but I'm glad we're still learning about these kinds of things. Imagine all the things we take for granted that are simply superstition when examined closely.
- amelius 8y ago> Imagine all the things we take for granted that are simply superstition when examined closely. I see it more as a refinement of knowledge, just like Newtonian mechanics -> relativity. Or perhaps this is a bad example which should be the other way around because surgery works in all cases whereas the antibiotics work in most but not all cases. Ok, never mind :)
- dagurp 8y agoI had my appendix removed in January and the doctors told me back then that it's sometimes treated with antibiotics but you risk having appendicitis again. I'm pretty sure I had chronic appendicitis so I was really glad to be rid of it.
- jazoom 8y agoIn Australia, where public hospitals provide a free service, antibiotics are first line for uncomplicated appendicitis. Most people recover just fine. It's amazing how things are different when a surgeon doesn't want to do a procedure since it means more work for them, compared to where a surgeon wants to do a procedure since that's how they get paid. Obviously, it's much better for the patients if they avoid unnecessary surgery.
- sonnyblarney 8y agoEven in socialized medicine systems, doctors who do more stuff get paid more. 'Single Payer' usually means the government runs insurance not the doctors office. So the doctor bills more in both cases. Both of those inscentives are maligned though - the doctor should do 'what's right'. What's also nutbars is that there isn't a standard playbook for this stuff. There should be specific procedural research on all of this stuff with the 'best practices' updated all the time. There should be ongoing debate and churn around the practice, but once it's published, the doctors should all be in sync. Doctors, like judges, have too much leeway. I think they feel that 'every case is special' and they are to some extent, however, I feel that they are playing against a statistical game and that their 'gut' is not right. Just like airline pilots go through massive 'checklists' ... so should doctors. I've been misdiagnosed for heart burn (doc thought it was heart palpitation) and for wound infection (was not infected, just a little red) - which is tragic because those are very common things.
- dalbasal 8y agoThis is a tangent but... Medical Science is an interesting institution. It's a huge, formalized truth-values finding process... A half sibling of Law (the other formal truth finding institution) and Science (the abstract unformalized institution).
- rscho 8y agoYeah, so unfortunately regarding medical science "formalized truth-values finding process" is actually about as far from reality as you could be. "Politicized agenda-propelled random search" would be closer. However, we still slowly are making progress thanks to new technologies, so all is not lost...
- arkades 8y agoI understand that, looking at individual scientific problems, it's easy to get cynical. It's even fashionable to be so. Deaths attributable to heart disease in 1970 were just shy of 800k per annum. As of 2010, it was about 600k. A 25% drop in the leading cause of death, in less than a generation. Life expectancy was 70.8 years in 1970, and 78.7 in 2010 - an increase of more than 10% in a single generation. Science isn't a process that moves along by weeks, months, or even years. It's something that moves generationally, and our society has made impressive strides. You're welcome to be skeptical - science would die without that. But be the "loyal opposition," not a casual cynic: help the process improve, don't discard it as some political shell-game. Lives are in the balance.
- rscho 8y agoI have both feet in the game, being a clinical researcher. So, cynic but not casual.
- carapace 8y ago"Politicized agenda-propelled random search" Lol! I think you and arkades both have it right. It's a "politicized agenda-propelled random search" on a large enough scale and over a rich enough search space that it "has made impressive strides" despite its flaws and inefficiencies. I have a friend who works as a Healer. People come to him and pay him good money and he gets results. He doesn't advertise, he gets referrals by word-of-mouth alone. My point is he gets results.[1] He can do things that are totally off the map of conventional medicine. However, he's uninterested in science and scientists (in general) are uninterested in him. "It's something that moves generationally" indeed, if paradigm shifts really require the dying out of the old guard. If we think of inefficiencies in the search due to e.g. politics and superstition as a kind of malady, then it seems we are witnessing a phase of "Physician heal thyself", what with the advent of mass medical monitoring and big data correlation, eh? [1] Have you heard the joke, "If alternative medicine works it's just called medicine."? Well, yes and no. Some things that work are too far outside the belief structures and will be ignored or ridiculed.
- shoo 8y agothis qualifier is interesting: > researchers led by Paulina Salminen randomly assigned 530 patients that showed up in the hospital with an acute, uncomplicated appendicitis to get either a standard, open surgery to remove their inflamed organ or a course of antibiotics. (By “uncomplicated,” the authors mean there weren’t other issues like perforation, abscess, or suspicion of a tumor.) although if your appendix is already perforated then it's a bit late to try to prevent it from perforating by cutting it out, so fair enough.
- arkades 8y agoYou've made the correct conclusion. Management of a perforated appendix is vastly different from management of the (much more common) uncomplicated appy. There isn't much controversy about the management of the perforated appy: it's going to be surgery and antibiotics. Removal at that point isn't in question, because the perforation is due to an increase in intra-appendiceal pressure compressing its vasculature, causing a focal necrosis. The perforation happens when a piece of the appendix dies, and thus loses its integrity. Dead tissue has to go. And of course surgical clean-up of the abdomen must follow, along with a big pile of abx.
- saiya-jin 8y agoSo no need to have appendixes removed prior to being stationed in Antarctica anymore?
- shoo 8y agoi think this is for the scenario where you have uncomplicated acute appendicitis that can be treated in time. there can still be scenarios where you developed acute appendicitis, it isn't treated in time (by either surgery or antibiotics), it perforates, possibly causing "infection of the lining of the abdominal cavity" so i'd guess that removing the thing before there are any symptoms would still reduce risk, although maybe the cost-benefit tradeoff is a bit less clear.
- xbmcuser 8y agoWait is that a requirement?
- TheSpiceIsLife 8y agoFrom the Australian Government - Department of the Environment and Energy, Australian Antarctic Division: The answer is no, however doctors who are wintering at Australian Antarctic stations are required to have their appendix removed. This is because there is usually only one doctor on station during winter, and evacuation back to medical care in Australia is impossible for at least part of the year. The requirement dates from the 1950s, when an Australian Antarctic doctor developed appendicitis on Heard Island and required a very challenging evacuation back to Australia. In 1961 a Russian doctor successfully removed his own appendix at Novolazarevskaya station in Antarctica. With no outside help possible, he used local anaesthetic and had two expeditioners assist with surgical retractors and a mirror so that he could see what he was doing. The operation was a success and the doctor was back on duty within two weeks. It's not a situation that Australian Antarctic doctors would like to find themselves in! As part of their overall medical review, all expeditioners are required to have a dental check before they depart for Antarctica within six months of their departure date. There is no requirement for expeditioners to have their wisdom teeth removed unless the dentist identifies that they may cause a problem over winter. The station doctor has eight days of training in emergency dentistry as part of their preparation, but this does not include wisdom teeth extraction. http://www.antarctica.gov.au/about-antarctica/people-in-antarctica/health http://www.antarctica.gov.au/about-antarctica/people-in-anta...
- qwerty456127 8y agoGreat news! Seems like I (not a doctor but probably the most medically-qualified person in any group of random people that doesn't include anybody with actual medical education) probably won't end up doing an appendectomy on anybody after I move to a deep rural area...
- PakG1 8y agoAn appendectomy might be easier than procuring the necessary antibiotics in a deep rural area, depending on how rural....
- qwerty456127 8y agoBeing a person fairly interested in medical science and lacking insurance I always take care to have some antibiotics for just a case (I ask friends from Russia to get them for me, you can buy antibiotics without prescriptions there) although I hardly ever use any actually. Needless to say, I'm going to take quite a selection with me when I travel to some place where they're hard to get and there are no doctors around. By the way one should better have antibiotics ready when performing this kind of surgery or chances are their patient is going to die of sepsis.
- peteretep 8y ago> I ask friends from Russia to get them for me http://www.chicagotribune.com/news/ct-xpm-2002-09-01-0209010411-story.html http://www.chicagotribune.com/news/ct-xpm-2002-09-01-0209010...
- qwerty456127 8y agoWould you mind telling what's there? It says "Unfortunately, our website is currently unavailable in most European countries..." as I open it directly and shows no article body as I open it through us.ixquick-proxy.com.
- 8y ago
- algorias 8y agoThat's great to hear. However, keep in mind that appendicitis is still an extremely serious condition that will kill you if left untreated. The fact that you can avoid surgery in some cases doesn't mean that surgery is not an adequate treatment. It's amazing how medicine has advanced: We can now cure illnesses with very minimal amount of invasiveness required in most cases. Even before this news, open surgery was already mostly supplanted by laparoscopy, which involves only a few tiny cuts.
- Cthulhu_ 8y agoIn this case, would they keep you in hospital for a while to see if the antibiotics work, while being on standby to do emergency surgery?
- fredsanford 8y agoAppendicitis will kill you! And the surgery in most cases will save you. :) At least in my case. I technically died from a ruptured appendix and spent 9 days in ICU. The doctors delayed surgery to see if the antibiotics would work. This was ~10 or so years ago.
- da02 8y agoCan you give more details of "technically died"? Any after-life experience?
- saadsg 8y agoa little too late perhaps?
- pbhjpbhj 8y agoA friend (in UK) had a similar condition called diverticulitis wherein the intestine makes a new pouch and it gets infected. They were treated only with IV antibiotics (and pain killers) but spent almost a week in hospital vs people attending for surgeries who were out again in a couple of days. I imagine _if_ it requires a longer hospital stay that will override the medical necessity. Perhaps samples could be taken, eg of stool, in order to select bacteria with which to reseed the intestine? I suppose that's quite labour intensive.
- rincebrain 8y agoThere's also some evidence that the bacteria in your stool is even less well-correlated to the bacteria further up your intestines than we thought (and we already thought it wasn't great). [1] [1] - https://www.theguardian.com/science/2018/sep/06/probiotics-not-as-beneficial-for-gut-health-as-previously-thought https://www.theguardian.com/science/2018/sep/06/probiotics-n...
- bookofjoe 8y ago"Sulfonamide drugs were the first antibiotics to be used systemically, and paved the way for the antibiotic revolution in medicine."—Wikipedia. These drugs came into widespread use in the late 1930s.
- bookofjoe 8y agoSomewhat OT but interesting: "When [Kurt] Semm introduced laparoscopic surgery at the University of Kiel, he had to undergo a brain scan at the request of coworkers as 'only a person with brain damage would perform such laparoscopic surgery.' On September 13, 1980, Semm performed the first laparoscopic appendectomy, opening up the path for a much wider application of minimally invasive surgery. At first, his operation was severely criticized. Initial attempts to publish it were rejected, and the American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology stated that his technique was 'unethical.' The president of the German Surgical Society demanded that Semm be suspended from medical practice."—Wikipedia
- MaysonL 8y agoThe "Semmelweiss reflex" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Semmelweis_reflex https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Semmelweis_reflex
- bookofjoe 8y agoThat the laparascopic pioneer's name is Semm is unreal. You couldn't make it up.
- morgancmartin 8y agoWow, given the context, I just immediately assumed it was coined because of the story OP detailed. An incredible coincidence!
- knodi123 8y agoto paraphrase randall munroe, what are the odds that we would have two unrelated US presidents whose names both started with T-R-U-M ?
- omneity 8y agoI found this definition very strange, from its choice of words and mentioning “undeveloped planets”?! "Mob behavior found among primates and larval hominids on undeveloped planets, in which a discovery of important scientific fact is punished"
- sureaboutthis 8y agoThis reminds me of when tonsils were removed at the first sign of trouble. When I was in my early 20s, in the 1970s, I went to my doctor about a bad sore throat. He advised me to see an ENT who barely bothered to look down my throat for more than a second and automatically declared I needed mine removed. That bothered me but I very much respected my personal doctor who said he respected this ENT. When I mention this to doctors nowadays, most nod their heads that, today, it's not likely mine would have been removed.
- bootcode 8y agoIt depends on lots of factors. Under age of six they have decent chance to grow it out, but doc should check for other conditions like missing some breathing while asleep etc. Also depends on risk avoidance of your doc in general.
- Cthulhu_ 8y agoGrowing up, I felt like getting tonsils removed was as common as changing teeth, it must've happened to a third or so of my classmates at the time. It seemed harmless enough from a distance, they pull out some stuff from your throat and you get ice cream.
- pjc50 8y agoI had mine out as an adult and it was a pretty painful week of recovery.
- sureaboutthis 8y agoYes but Allison visited me in the hospital! TIL: Alisson liked me!!
- tjohns 8y agoThey tell you you can have all the ice cream you want to eat, but neglect to mention that you'll be in too much pain and too nauseous to actually want to eat any. :P Believe me, all the ice cream in the world isn't worth that experience. You're not missing anything.
- arkades 8y agoA few notes of interest: 1) Europe has been doing abx before surgery for a while now. Unfortunately, their data has largely been lacking (thus the need for this trial), creating the impression that this was pushed by their national health services as a cost-saving measure rather than a patient-oriented one. The culture among surgeons in the US, regarding abx for appendicitis, is largely "we don't kill patients just to save a few bucks." The irony that the bucks being saved go directly into their pockets usually goes un-mentioned, but they are in earnest. It's just a win/win that their earnest desire to do the best for patients also pays their bills. It feels nice to get paid for doing the right thing. However, that creates a cultural bulwark against a change in expectations on appendicitis management. 2) There is often a feeling that "if we have to end up doing surgery anyway, we should just do the surgery. There's no value in making the patient go through two such episodes when we have definitive treatment." It's going to be highly subjective whether you think a 1/3 chance of two appendicitis episodes and inevitable surgery vs. a 2/3 chance of avoiding surgery means "it's obvious you should get abx" vs. "it's obvious you should get surgery." I think this study doesn't make anything obvious, but does pave the way to giving patients a reasonable alternative course of action. 3) This is not tantamount to saying "well, we've just been rash all these years in just going straight to appendectomy." Previous trials on this have been, methodologically, poor. Even this trial is a five-year follow-up to what was initially a one-year trial that wasn't adequately persuasive. The initial trial showed a 27% rate of return appendicitis. You can imagine that if the five-year results showed "80%" vs. "36/39%" we'd be having a different discussion. If it showed that having an appendicitis pop up a few years later had more adverse effects, we'd be having a different discussion. So this data was needed, and the fact that docs didn't jump on previously heavily flawed data is... well, docs doing what they're supposed to. You don't want your doc jumping after every poorly-supported shadow. 4) Appendicitis isn't diverticulitis. There's often a layman's shorthand that diverticulitis is just left-sided appendicitis, but it's not. The pathogenesis and appropriate treatments vary quite a bit: conservative treatment of a piece of normal anatomy is quite different from conservative treatment of a piece of herniated, pathologic anatomy. Don't confuse this study for meaning anything regarding the appropriate management of diverticulitis. That's not to say that abx management for diverticulitis is inappropriate, per se, but just saying these are different diseases and not to be confused here. 5) One shouldn't expect this to result in cultural change too quickly. There remains the fact that the primary protection against a malpractice suit is "local standard" - if all the local docs are doing the same thing, it's not malpractice to follow suit. The first doc to go out on a ledge with this is going to be minced meat the moment there's a bad outcome and someone sues. A study is beside the point - if you point to a new study during a suit, the plaintiff's attorney says, "Oh? You have a PhD in study design? No? Then what qualifies you to analyze this study better than every other doctor in your community?" This really won't go anywhere until an entire medical department agrees to go in on this simultaneously - most likely an emergency medicine department. Politically, though, they'd probably have to go to war with their hospital's surgery department to push it through, or otherwise have the surg folk on-side. It'll happen eventually, but it's not going to happen overnight.
- ransom1538 8y agoI found this conversation unnerving at 13 years old: Doctor: "Does all this make sense? We need to remove your appendix.. now." Me: "Doctor, ok, so you need to remove my appendix cause if you don't I could get really sick. " Doctor: "Yes." Me: "What does the appendix do?" Doctor: "We don't know."
- bitexploder 8y agoDoctor: in your case, kills you in about 24-48 hours. I had mine out as well. I was 19. My dad drove me to the hospital. Doc slipped his finger up my bum, said, “you have appendicitis. You need surgery. Now.” I was being operated on quickly after that. It had ruptured. So it goes.
- lightbyte 8y ago>Doc slipped his finger up my bum Is this a standard way to diagnose appendicitis?
- bitexploder 8y agoHeh, yeah. It is traditional. And ineffective (of course). https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1071072/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1071072/ I was kind of out of it. Maybe there was a lot of pain, but my memory of it was just so much discomfort, what is something minor like that?
- thomasfedb 8y agoThat's an excellent article you link - to paraphrase the conclusion: digital rectal examination should not be performed routinely for abdominal pain, but should be considered an investigation to consider when diagnosis is unclear.
- bitexploder 8y agoThanks. I guess it isn’t fair to say it is ineffective, it can give some information.
- ParanoidShroom 8y agoIs this really news ? I've gotten it removed, and before had antibiotics to cure an infection. They misread the echo and though it was too infected to start antibiotics. It hurt like hell. After the operation, he said they removed it but could have been fixed by antibiotics earlier. They decided during the operation is was safer in the future to remove it (as I had more problems with it). They really don't want to remove it here, so I'm surprised this is news ...
- teekert 8y agoI also know 3 people that went to the doctor after some time of belly aches and the doctor telling them: "You probably had an inflamed appendix but it's ok now."
- bwldrbst 8y agoAs a kid in the mid-80's I once woke up with a bit of a belly ache and thought "I can milk this for a day off school to play with Lego" Ended up having an emergency appendectomy that night.
- mscasts 8y agoThe removed mine while I had another surgery just in case.
- deskamess 8y agoJust in case of ...? I do not usually think of surgeons having the mentality of 'I was in the neighborhood... so.... yeah, why not!'.
- mscasts 8y agoWell, they were fiddling around with my intestines, moving them around (I have / had intestinal malrotation) and they told me that it could be an issue if they didn't remove it. Although they told me afterwards, but the surgeons were extremely competent so I don't question their judgement.
- 0xcafecafe 8y agoI wonder if this would eventually be extended to wisdom teeth, something dentists are too trigger happy to remove.
- SECProto 8y agoNot quite sure I understand - give antibiotics instead of pulling wisdom teeth? They pull them because wisdom teeth often grow in at an angle to a mouth of fully developed and settled adult teeth. Sort of a "why mess with a good thing" (the teeth there already) approach. I certainly see an issue with the rampant pulling of wisdom teeth for cosmetic reasons, but don't see how it's relevant to a new treatment method for a life threatening illness.
- 0xcafecafe 8y agoI meant the overall principle of maintain rather than remove.
- eigenstuff 8y agoSo... braces? It's cheaper just to pull them. You really have to if you're someone like me whose mouth was too small for them to even come in. My wisdom tooth extraction was a shit show for that reason, but I've had all my 12 year molars removed since then, the last one a couple of weeks ago, and the recovery is pretty easy. (They wanted to root canal it and crown it... I was like bro just pull it because otherwise we're just gonna have this same conversation again in 10 years.)
- rsynnott 8y agoFillings. For people who have reasonably well aligned wisdom teeth (not impacted, functional teeth), some dentists are inclined to remove them anyway; others to treat any decay which shows up but otherwise leave them alone. Again, this is something where norms differ by country. Edit: Wait, you’ve had all your _second_ molars removed? That seems very unusual. I’m a little surprised the dentis was willing to do it, unless there was a big problem that couldn’t be dealt with otherwise.
- crazygringo 8y agoI'm so confused. From Wikipedia: > Appendicitis is caused by a blockage of the hollow portion of the appendix. This is most commonly due to a calcified "stone" made of feces. Inflamed lymphoid tissue from a viral infection, parasites, gallstone, or tumors may also cause the blockage... The combination of inflammation, reduced blood flow to the appendix and distention of the appendix causes tissue injury and tissue death. If this process is left untreated, the appendix may burst, releasing bacteria into the abdominal cavity, leading to increased complications... Acute appendicitis is typically managed by surgery. While antibiotics are safe and effective for treating uncomplicated appendicitis, 26% of people had a recurrence within a year and required an eventual appendectomy. Given that bacteria are not even listed as a cause of appendicitis above, how do antibiotics help at all? Is there anything they can do to prevent "tissue death" in the appendix itself, and how? What about that "stone"? Or are the antibiotics for dealing with an actual ruptured appendix (to kill leaking bacteria from the gut into the rest of the body), while the appendix presumably eventually resolves its blockage and heals itself on its own? Which sounds... scary, but of course I'm no MD. Would love if anyone here knows how to explain what the article doesn't.
- gwbas1c 8y ago> Or are the antibiotics for dealing with an actual ruptured appendix If your appendix ruptures, it is life threatening and has to come out. Most appendix removals happen before the appendix ruptures. The conclusion of the study is that high doses of antibiotics is an effective way to prevent the appendix from rupturing without surgery.
- JoeAltmaier 8y agoI still have the question: what about the 'stone'? Do antibiotics cure that somehow? Or is that the reason that 30% of those treated with antibiotics ultimately have the surgery?
- takeda 8y agoI thing it is the second one. I don't see antibiotic helping with that.
- colordrops 8y agoI recall reading sometime in the past that appendectomies are the perfect cash crop at hospitals. Most are not needed but it's not worth the risk so everyone gets them, they are a low risk easy surgery, and they can charge a lot for them. I also recall that the cost for the surgery varies widely across hospitals.
- russdill 8y agoWhat's interesting is that you'd think the switch over to a laparoscopic technique would save money, but it actually costs more. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4653254/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4653254/
- ectospheno 8y agoArticle says sick leave on antibiotics was 11 days compared to 22 with the invasive surgery. The non invasive surgery only has you taking it easy for 7 days with no lifting anything over 10 pounds for a bit after that. They send you home from the hospital after 2 days. Most people resume work during the initial week.
- rsynnott 8y agoStudy was in Finland. How much time people take off presumably depends heavily on national laws and norms around sick leave. Some countries have very generous laws around paid sick leave; others, like the US, don’t have mandatory paid sick leave at all. Finland seems to be a special case; 10 days paid sick leave for a given incident, but in practice this is improved on by collective bargaining agreements in many trades.
- wccrawford 8y agoI had the non-invasive version a year or so ago. That matches my experience pretty much exactly.
- adanto6840 8y agoI had the surgery via laparoscopy ~10 years ago; go to the ER at 8AM, surgery at Noon, and home by 9PM the same day.
- srik 8y ago.
- bpizzi 8y agoYou're literally playing with your life.
- Retric 8y agoWaiting cures a wide range of problems, that don't end up killing you. It's really hard to separate 'doing a rain dance' and 'just waiting' when you have a sample size of 1.
- D-Coder 8y agoAnd the ones who do die, don't post here to let us know how it turned out.
- blaisio 8y agoI'm glad it worked for you but usually appendicitis is caused by an infection which will cause sepsis if the appendix ruptures, and fasting won't fix that. If you think you have appendicitis at least talk to a doctor, because if it ruptures there is a high probability you will get sepsis and die.
- ChrisClark 8y agoI hate that the healthcare situation actually forced you to flip a coin for your life. :( (I'm assuming you're in the US or somewhere like it where an appendix removal isn't free)
- medicalhistory 8y agoI had an appendectomy a few years ago (in my late 20s) and I really wish the doctors had given me the option of just antibiotics. I was in severe pain and had spent the entire day vomiting, but from the CT scan my appendix wasn't at risk of rupturing at that point. They basically told me they were going to take it out as it was faster for them to manage it that way. It's anecdotal, but ever since I had my appendix out I've struggled with digestion issues. I've tried so many things: elimination diets to discover food allergies, probiotics, a switch to vegetarianism, tons of fiber supplements, no fiber supplements, intermittent fasting, acupuncture, traditional Chinese medicine. I tried out uBiome to see if I could discover anything with that. Nothing really has worked. On top of that, the surgery cost $25k. Certainly there are instances where the surgery is absolutely needed, as a rupture will kill you. I'd really like to see more research on the theory that the appendix holds a backup copy of good bacteria, because at this point I'm willing to believe the appendix isn't just vestigial and actually plays a role in intestinal health that we just don't understand.
- sandworm101 8y agoDo we need more reasons to soak ourselves in antibiotics? Appendectomies on otherwise healthy people are extraordinarily safe procedures. And while some research has indeed shown the appendix as a useful organ, having it out doesn't have lasting side effects. Given the coming tide of antibiotic resistance, perhaps this is an area where physical intervention via surgery can reduce the need for antibiotics. (I know antibiotics are normally prescribed after an appendectomy anyway, but I presume that would be less than the dose needed to kill the primary infection outright.)
- cbdumas 8y agoThere is currently a very similar study being conducted in the US. I am a subject in this study after I got appendicitis last summer. I chose to be treated with antibiotics and have been symptom free for the last ~14 months. I could also have opted to participate in the randomized controlled trial (where a treatment would have been randomly assigned to me) but surgery isn't really something I'm comfortable leaving up to chance.
- arisAlexis 8y agomany people will die from this article because they wil not believe their doctor and go to another one with a broken appendix that kills you in a few days from septic shock.
- httpsterio 8y agoFinally a thread where I can contribute! I was part in the Finnish APPAC trial (published on JAMA/2015). In April 2012 I was in an out of the hospital for four or five times with intensive stomach pains, but as they weren't localised in the mcburney area and my white cell counts weren't elevated, I just got sent home with painkillers. The last time my white cell counts were slightly elevated (around 36 when under 14 is considered to be normal) and the stomach pains were worsening while jumping and the pain localising in the lower right of my stomach I was personally sure about what I had. Doctors still disagreed. I was then told that there's an experimental trial and if I sign up for it, they'll do a CT scan (I had begged for this the previous visits). Lo and behold, the scan showed inflammation not caused by a stone. I got ertapenem intravenously for three days and 7 days of metronidazole and levofloxacin. For about a year everything was fine, but I started to get occasional localised pains again, but they came and went and never really worsened. I think between 2013 and 2017 I've been to the hospital about 6 or 7 times because of the pains but they've always resolved by itself. Two months ago it came back again and it was worse than the first time I got diagnosed. Spent two nights in the ER waiting for surgery. Again, ct scanned and blood levels show inflammation. I get sent home with pain killers and metronidazole and floxacin. ER nurses and surgery doctors were baffled by the case, said they've never seen an inflammated appendix been put on the non-urgent surgery waiting list. Got told today that it's going to be removed this year, lol. After six years and asking every time to have it removed. Approximately 80% of the appendicitis cases are not at risk of bursting anytime soon so an immediate surgery is not necessary. The rest are complicated and need urgent surgery. I've been told that about 74% are fine after the antibiotics for the first year but a majority in the trial have ended up with it removed within a 5 year window. So, while having an appendix would be ideal and it's cheaper to throw a ct and some medicine at the patient, a surgery is still almost always needed. In my personal experience, I have a strong gut feeling that a low carb diet might've affected how many times my appendix has shown slight signs of inflammation. Up until 2016 I was in ketosis for a four years and that was when I had issues most often (although the latest has been the worst overall). The sample size of this idea is just n=1 so take it with a grain of salt. Oh, a sidenote, latest hospital ordeal put me in bed rest for almost a month because metronidazole did not play nicely with my ankles and I lost my job during that time so I'm also going through talks with my lawyer about a suit for unlawful termination. Fun times. Please do ask questions if I can clarify anything or you want to hear about something specific!
- geff82 8y agoThis is no new news. When I was 17, I had all the signs of an appendicitis. But I really feared to go to the hospital. I read through some medical books where they mentioned that after 72 hours of pain things can get real dangerous. I found some old antibiotics in the house (well beyond their date), took them and after 48 hours the apendicitis was gone. When I was 34, appendicitid struck again. I new instantly that I had it, and this time I did not fear the hospital. This time, I wanted to avoid hospital because we were just a few weeks from moving to a new house. So I took antibiotics again, measured the fever, noted every measurement point in Excel but after 36 hours I found that it was not getting any better. So finally I took advantage of my wonderful German health insurance and got the appendix brilliantly removed... Just want to state: there are times when antibiotics work and times when they do not.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- SketchySeaBeast 8y agoFor myself appendicitis was a condition that recurred - I didn't realize what I was having at the time until one night when I put the symptoms together and went "uh oh", when I'd probably experienced those symptoms a half dozen time in my adult life. I wonder what antibiotics mean for re-occurrence, do you end up treating it like an ear infection, and take em when you get a flare up?
- DoreenMichele 8y agoI had a cousin who delayed being seen for their stomach ache and the appendix burst. They ended up hospitalized for like 6 weeks with one end of the surgical opening left open so the wound could be drained or repeatedly cleaned out or something. I'm glad they are doing studies here. Please note the phrasing in the article concerning "uncomplicated" cases. I have plenty of criticisms of modern medicine, but let's not throw the baby out with the bathwater here.
- arwhatever 8y agoIt would be interesting if someone were to compile a list of surgical procedures that have been performed too proactively throughout history. Uteruses, molars, tonsils, breasts, I think some cases of prostate cancer, now appendixes. My list might contain huge errors - I am not a medical professional, but even as a medical layperson, it's really remarkable how common this general type of situation occurs.