11 ms·
Rain ruins one of Norway’s richest men
- crb002 8y agoAttorneys drafting derivative contracts need boundary conditions so this doesn't happen. The boundary conditions would also signal to those who rely on them to get protection if a boundary is hit. Zero and infinity are simply ignored.
- slykar 8y agoIf he were successful with the gambling the news title would probably be different. It's not the rain that ruins him, it's his decisions.
- pfortuny 8y agoAnother instance of greedy forecasting gone wrong. We (all of us) never learn.
- dmix 8y agoThis was ultimately just a transfer of wealth between two parties. There wasn't much of a loss for society as a whole (besides maybe to Aas's creditors and the clearing house but they can handle this risk)...
- maaaats 8y agoThe fund that got depleted has to be topped off again, with money from the other participants in the market. Fortum, for instance, will have to pay ~23M euro, and is largely owned by the Finnish state. Same goes for lots of the other players.
- gregoriol 8y agoPoor guy, he bet money, he lost. Hundreds do that too in casinos and lotteries. Why do we need news about that?
- expertentipp 8y agoGood. More from among the richest should follow him.
- rebuilder 8y agoWho do you think was on the other side of this bet?
- expertentipp 8y agoHouseholds paying their monthly electricity bills?
- HeadsUpHigh 8y agoOther rich people who got richer.
- rebyn 8y agoMind if I ask who? Honest question :).
- rebuilder 8y agoI don't know, it's not even exactly clear to me what kind of trade was in play here. My point was, the other side probably wasn't Joe Average. IOW, while you can frame this as a rich man losing due to greed, that's just another way of saying some other rich person won big. Exaggerating here, there were probably multiple counterparties and I'd think they were probably institutional investors, or maybe power companies.
- adrianN 8y agoI often wonder why people who have so much money already gamble like that to get even more money. If I had roughly a million dollars I'd put it in an index fund and live a happy live without having to worry about work or money. Yet people like that guy have a hundred times more money than I'd need for the rest of my life and risk it all to become even richer.
- beefield 8y agoFirst, it is a game. The one with largest number "wins". Second, people do not see how much more wealthy they are than most others. They see how much less wealthy they are to the ones having bigger jets and charity programs and whatnot.
- bitexploder 8y agoYep. Hedonic treadmill. It’s a nice theory/observation to summarize this behavior. It is amusing to note despite having more, less, or almost zero dollars, it doesn’t seem to make folks much happier. Hmm.
- tialaramex 8y ago"almost zero" is exaggerating. When humans worry about basic needs like food and shelter this makes them notably unhappy. In many countries even a basic full-time job might not alleviate poverty enough to take you up to this line where your basic needs are met and the Hedonic treadmill kicks in. And in the Industrialised North lots of people actually live _below_ zero, with consumer debt at unprecedented levels.
- bitexploder 8y agoI was thinking in the context of very wealthy individuals. So, let’s call almost zero an annual salary of 80-100k. https://www.advisorperspectives.com/dshort/commentaries/2016/10/21/happiness-revisited-a-household-income-of-75k https://www.advisorperspectives.com/dshort/commentaries/2016... — essentially above the so called “happiness” threshold.
- csomar 8y agoMost people are missing an important point. From FT Website: > That prompted Nasdaq to cut the entire trade on Wednesday and the exchange confirmed that the loss accounted for all of the exchange’s own default fund of €7m and swallowed €107m, or two-thirds, of its €166m mutual default fund that clearing house members must contribute to. So a single, one person trader was able to basically bankrupt the Nasdaq insurance fund. This fund is supposed to cover all of the margin trading misfortunes but a single guy/position took it all away. This means that the Nasdaq (and probably any other exchange) is not ready for a volatility event. In the case of extreme volatility, the Nasdaq insurance fund will be 0. Counterparties in derivatives won't get paid, and potentially the mutual funds/etfs/other structures depending on these derivative trades will collapse. The next financial crisis is just one trade away. Edit: re-reading and searching further, it looks like the fund that was depleted was not that of the Nasdaq but rather a mutual fund for several exchanges. The Nasdaq had only 7m euros. What a joke.
- charlesdm 8y agoApparently, based from the comments, it was because he could clear his own trades
- csomar 8y agoClearly he couldn't. Not only that but the whole Nasdaq and other exchanges (mutual fund) struggled at doing that. Something is wrong.
- charlesdm 8y agoWell, that's the point -- he couldn't. He was also trading from a personal account it seems. Seems a bit odd they would allow that.
- runarb 8y agoThe rules also allowed a single trader to own 25% of the marked[0]. 0: In norwagian: https://www.dn.no/nyheter/2018/09/14/1431/Finans/-einar-aas-ble-for-stor-for-markedet https://www.dn.no/nyheter/2018/09/14/1431/Finans/-einar-aas-...
- jacknews 8y agoHe got it by gambling, he lost it gambling. So what. The sad thing here is that it is indicative of how extremely wealthy people often get that way. The system should reward innovation, hard work etc, but instead it is skewed towards gambling, system-gaming, rent-seeking and so-on.
- isostatic 8y agoThe system never has rewarded hard work on its own. 100 people work hard. 10 of them are lucky and see the benefits. 90 of them aren't lucky and don't see the benefits Everyone looks at the 10 who are lucky, and they say "The key to success is to work hard". Classic survivorship bias.
- jryle70 8y agoIt doesn't hurt that those lucky 10 also work hard. Or may be 9 of them do. Lucky wouldn't appear on your door. Also, you gave the impression that the other 90 are losers because they work hard. Life is not an extreme. They may not become as rich, but they aren't poor either, and they maybe lucky in other metrics. They aren't loser.
- isostatic 8y agoMaybe some do. I'm lucky I don't know the meaning of the word 'work hard'. I'm sitting here on a sunday afternoon working, or rather waiting for things to go wrong. Sure it's a 12 hour day, but it's not hard working. Those holding down two jobs and doing 80 hours/week of non-stop work on their feet filling amazon deliveries or cooking burgers or picking fruit for minimum wage know what working hard is. I doubt anyone ever became independently wealthy through hard work. Is it right our society is set up to reward luck above all else?
- rootusrootus 8y agoIs someone making a career out of amazon deliveries or burger flipping or fruit picking really a good demonstration that hard work is not rewarded? That's merely hard physical labor. How about hard work like making sacrifices today so that tomorrow you're not competing in the deep end of the labor pool? I'm not sure that society is really just rewarding luck.
- alcio 8y agoOne of the most important thing to learn when trading is risk management, how to preserve your capital. Being wrong is part of trading, staying wrong isn't. It's especially interesting to see it happen to someone that actually worked as a risk manager in his early days ; especially so close to the anniversary of Lehman's demise.
- dmix 8y ago> Aas bet that the spread between energy prices on the Nordic and German electricity markets would narrow. I'm not super familiar with finance but this is a 'derivative' right? Is there a website where you can follow these types of large derivative investments? The type that gamble on market trends like this? I'm curious what other types of things people are gambling large funds on. Or even large short positions...
- RandomInteger4 8y agoYes, specifically spread betting, which is illegal in the US, but more common overseas I believe, because it basically is pure gambling. The other variations that are legal in the US are futures and options, with the latter being the most similar to spread betting I think. Futures is a market to reduce risk for commodities producers. Options are higher risk I want to say? Search around Investodpedia for better explanations; really good site that one. EDIT: or maybe the spread referred to in the article is on the options market. I'll have to reread.
- lordnacho 8y agoBetting on a spread is not spread betting. You can but Coke and sell Pepsi, you then have a position in the spread. That's not spread betting, which is just a retail way to gamble on a price movement. You cannot say options are more risky than futures, the two are related but different in nature. Whether he implemented his trade in the options or futures is irrelevant, there was always going to be a blowout risk. Source: I'm an ex options and futures trader.
- RandomInteger4 8y agoThank you for the correction.
- hippich 8y agowhy ex? i.e. why you stopped? (i am learning about options trading right now)
- chi3 8y agoWorking at one of the top 5 members of that clearing house in Scandinavia, very few people I've spoken to about it at work earlier this week thinks he is actually bankrupt. He's filing for bankruptcy so that he won't have to cover his own loss.
- wcoenen 8y agoI thought a bankruptcy procedure is about distributing the remaining assets to creditors in an orderly and fair way. How can this prevent him from losing his assets?
- lordnacho 8y agoYou're mostly right, but there's probably laws governing exactly what assets are redistributed to the creditors. Maybe he is able to stash some assets with his wife or in some complex offshore setup. You'd need lawyers to say. Or the bankruptcy court even.
- gorm 8y agoThere was recently a high court judgment in Norway with Alexander Vik who refused to pay for a large currency trade. He tried for years not to pay and even moved his values over to his family, but at the end he lost in court and the money was claimed from his relatives. https://www.forbes.com/sites/nathanvardi/2014/03/05/the-riddle-of-alexander-vik/#4363c5846460 https://www.forbes.com/sites/nathanvardi/2014/03/05/the-ridd...
- charlesdm 8y agoHe might have put a subset of his assets in a foundation, which is not included in bankruptcy (as he no longer owns the assets -- the foundation does). Foundations however, have no owners (generally only beneficiaries), so they often cannot be held liable for the debts of the (original) founders.
- marvin 8y agoIs that even possible under Norwegian law? To my understanding, Aas has been trading as a private individual, meaning not through an LLC (an AS in Norwegian terminology). If the rumors I'm hearing are correct, this was in order to avoid publishing his trades and profits, which he would have been required to do if he was trading through an AS. Personal bankruptcy is a very pietistic, convoluted procedure in Norway. It requires giving up all your assets and surrendering all of your income (above a sustenance limit) to creditors for five years, and can only be done once in your life. If Aas is going this route, he will not be able to save any owned assets from the proceedings, and will more or less consent to being a debt slave for the next half-decade. That's an extreme measure that people only do when there is no other option. (The default option being to just not pay anything and leave creditors hanging indefinitely, with the expected consequences for any personal financial endeavor in the future). So at most this is a play to negotiate with creditors, if the understanding I have is correct. There would be no way to save any assets if actual bankruptcy is the chosen move. You seem to know a lot about this, though, given that you work with this. Are there some facts here that I'm not aware of?
- mobilefriendly 8y agoRich people are a huge benefit of the system. Think of Elon Musk putting his wealth into SpaceX or Bill Gates into charity work. The fact that people who've demonstrated the ability to successfully manage capital investment and innovation get to control more resources is a positive feature.
- jondubois 8y agoI don't care about SpaceX. It doesn't benefit me at all in any way. In fact, some of my tax money probably subsidizes those spaceships so that big telecom companies can launch their satellites into space more cheaply and juice more profits out of my current ADSL contract; which won't get cheaper. I appreciate Bill Gate's charity work but I understand that it also doesn't benefit me personally - It probably costs me as well. Lifting people out of poverty means that they will be able to get an education to compete against me in the job marketplace in the future and will lower my wage. I can cope with that on a moral basis, but I'm pretty sure that Bill Gate's donations cost me more (in terms of how it affects my humble net worth) than it costs Bill Gates himself (in terms of how it affects his net worth).
- expertentipp 8y agoInstead of "trickling down", a perfectly tight pipeline system was designed and build so that each single drop is taken care of... one can lick the pipes still.
- dagss 8y agoIf you are going to include remote effects like competition from poor people getting education, you also need to include an infinite amount of other effects; in particular world stability, the chances of terrorist attacks, 3rd world war, refugee crises, trade wars etc With the technology we have now the world does in fact have plenty of resources to have basic needs satisfied for everyone (e.g., we throw away many times more food than what it would take to fix hunger). There is no actual need to compete. Such a world is safer for everyone, including the rich, and Bill Gates is one of many working long term towards that goal. See lifting the poor as a rather cheap insurance against political instability. We are always one major war or one generation away from having the entire system toppled, and the very meaning of "property rights" that make the rich rich overturned. Civilizations are not forever, whatever the people currently at the top may hope for. Intentionally keeping the poor poor, and keep concentrating wealth, is not a recipe for stability.
- vinni2 8y agoLiving in Norway currently it is absolutely crazy to me so many electricity companies trading middlemen making money just by trading they don’t don’t produce or supply just pure middlemen. I heard of some scamming companies too. I just said no to a fixed price binding contract which would have been a disaster. Now I have the cheapest prices of the year so far! It is completely non Norwegian from my experience. Everything else is so monopolizes and controlled here.
- 3rdAccount 8y agoIt's not a scam, but you're correct that they don't produce anything physical. Their point is to mostly converge disparate markets. So if they notice a separation between day ahead and real time prices, they can make money off of that while helping to plug a hole in the market as that could be the result of bad data...etc. There is an on-going debate as to whether their involvement (most of the financial only players are banks) is really that helpful as it can cause other issues if they do a bad job and cause divergence.
- qeternity 8y ago> they don’t don’t produce or supply just pure middlemen They produce liquidity and price discovery, which are extremely important. Most energy companies don't know what the "efficient" (market clearing) price for power is and also want to mitigate the risks they inherently face by supplying these markets. Speculators allow natural longs like energy companies to hedge risk (reduce their risk) so that they can focus on the things they're good at: building, maintaining and operating power generation and distribution. If you're not an expert trader, which most utility CEOs are not, how can you invest in projects for the next 5, 10 or 50 years without markets that allow you to lay off some of the price risk of the good you're producing (power). This dynamic is what is facilitated by so called middlemen. They are absolutely essential, even if there are spectacular failures like this from time to time.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- cosmic_ape 8y agoHow did it happen that default funds of the clearing houses had to be accessed? Did the spread change in one day from normal spread to 17 times normal? Otherwise the margin should have depleted only his own money.
- genericacct 8y agoHonestly I dont understand why NASDAQ could be involved if he was trading european electricity. Even if he was trading ADRs they'd be on NYSE.. The article must be missing a few details.
- mortehu 8y agoNasdaq Inc (as opposed to the NASDAQ Stock Market it owns and operats) has more than a few subsidiaries, and operates many markets around the world: https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1120193/000119312512077518/d259668dex211.htm https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1120193/000119312512...
- kgwgk 8y agoIn particular https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nasdaq_Nordic https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nasdaq_Nordic https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nordic_energy_market https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nordic_energy_market
- timwaagh 8y agodebtors prison? i kind of like the concept of paying in real life for things like this. he gambled with somebody else's money. and lost. if he just goes bankrupt and gets debt payment assistence without suffering anymore consequence than having to live a normal persons life for once, its not quite enough for the damage he has wrought.
- rossdavidh 8y agoHistorically, debtors prisons never ended up being for rich people who lost more money than they had, they always seemed to end up primarily with poor people who took out loans to stay alive and then couldn't pay back because they were unlucky.
- timwaagh 8y agooh well, one can dream.
- man-and-laptop 8y agoFinance jargon is impenetrable. Aren't you supposed to gamble with a fixed percentage of your money in case a long tail event happens? From an outsider's point of view, that seems like rule number one. Questions about NASDAQ: - What is NASDAQ? Wikipedia says they're a "stock exchange", which supposedly means they provide a place for people to trade in stocks and bonds and various other "securities". - How was NASDAQ affected by this guy's decisions? Are they trading something? Cheers.
- Animats 8y agoAt least he went bust, rather than faking balance sheets to hide losses, borrowing and getting deeper in the hole, like Enron.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- blunte 8y agoWhen you're young and you can absorb total losses, big bets (high risk/high return) are ok. Mid-life and beyond, it's nuts to be risked or leveraged to the point where you could lose everything. I can't say how he thinks, but some people have earned or lucky successes that give them a sense of invulnerability... and then they take unreasonable risks. This seems like one of those cases.
- cannabis_sam 8y agoHow is this kind of derivative trading any different than online poker on credit? Turns out the other guy had the nuts, well sucks to be a norwegian tax payer I guess. Yeah, sure we need liquidity and market makers do have a job, but this makes the nasdaq look like a mismanaged casino..