24 ms·
Just wait until it really sinks in for their dealers that selling electric cars means greatly reduced maintenance. Given what fraction of their dealers' revenu
by btilly 8y ago
Just wait until it really sinks in for their dealers that selling electric cars means greatly reduced maintenance. Given what fraction of their dealers' revenue comes from maintenance, this will be a left hand doesn't know what the right hand is doing kind of situation as the manufacturer and the dealer's interests fail to align.
Tesla worked hard to avoid having dealers. And I believe that dealers will be a weakness for the legacy auto industry here.
- dabeeeenster 8y agoThere was an article about EVs in the FT this weekend, stating that several manufacturers dont include EV's in their dealer's sales targets, which is only going to make this issue worse.
- robterrell 8y agoThe non-Tesla EVs I've owned have required frequent software updates & had several serious-sounding recalls. I assume the manufacturer pays for these visits. So, not zero revenue! At least for a few years. And I'm sure they'll invent some clearcoat-style bullshit they can aggressively push. Premium-electron filters, or some such crap.
- chaostheory 8y agoWhich ones did you own? I've owned both the 1st and 2nd gen Chevy Volt. I have not needed any software updates or patches and my recalls were not serious. The only real maintenance I've done on both cars is for tires and an oil change every 2 years. This is nothing compared to a car with a combustible engine. Yes the manufacturer pays for recalls, but since it's from one large customer; the dealers probably generate less revenue from the manufacturer vs a horde of consumers
- mikestew 8y agoThe non-Tesla EVs I've owned have required frequent software updates & had several serious-sounding recalls. Nissan Leaf owner almost since they first rolled off the production line, and not one recall or update was required to keep the vehicle running tip-top. Sibling comment ruled out the Volt, so what were these buggy EVs that had required software updates?
- robterrell 8y agoI've had two non-Tesla EVs: the Fiat 500e and the BMW i3. The Fiat 500e had two recalls while I owned it. Both were for a possible propulsion system fault that could result in the vehicle stalling while driving. They sent a flatbed tow truck instead of letting me drive it in. The BMW i3 had a recall for a safety issue, unrelated to the electronic nature of the car. Although it's probably fair to relate it to the "let's make an all-new car design from the ground up" impulse behind it. BTW, I just went back to a more traditional plug-in hybrid over weekend. Five years as an EV driver (not in a Tesla) was a long time to be feeling range anxiety. I look forward to watching Mercedes and Porsche stick the landing.
- mikestew 8y agoThe Fiat 500e had two recalls while I owned it. Both were for a possible propulsion system fault that could result in the vehicle stalling while driving I suppose it would be in poor taste to make jokes at the expense of Fiat reliability in this case. But holy cow, so much for the simplicity and reliability of electrics. :-P Thanks for sharing your experience. I will say as a counter example that our Leaf is the most low-attention vehicle we’ve owned. By eliminating gas stops, we literally just get in and drive between yearly check-ups (which amount to “check battery, change cabin air filter”).
- robterrell 8y agoYeah, don't blame Fiat too much, the EV conversion was done by Bosch! And remember Tesla had a rash of much-publicized propulsion system stalls (as did the Tesla-powered Toyota RAV4 and MB models). Aside from the few recalls and range anxiety, my experience with EVs has been stellar as well. I wish there was a long-range EV I could afford... (that didn't look like a Bolt.) Kind of dreading dealing with gasoline engines again. I'm basically treating this new car as an EV with a extra-large REX.
- floatrock 8y ago> And I'm sure they'll invent some clearcoat-style bullshit they can aggressively push. Premium-electron filters, or some such crap. These are commonly "electric system warranties." But then again, these aren't quite at the level of the clearcoat... anyone who's ever had an electrical gremlin knows how expensive diagnosing those can be. When your brake squeals, any mechanic can figure out what part to replace. When your battery slowly drains over two days, it is much more labor intensive to figure out what part is responsible or where on the wire harness there's a short...
- dragonwriter 8y ago> Just wait until it really sinks in for their dealers that selling electric cars means greatly reduced maintenance. Given what fraction of their dealers' revenue comes from maintenance, this will be a left hand doesn't know what the right hand is doing kind of situation as the manufacturer and the dealer's interests fail to align. Or, manufacturers will share more sales revenue with dealers to align incentives (which will raise vehicle costs compared to production cost), which they’ll have to do anyway to support the sales infrastructure of they aren’t going to take it over; of course, Tesla has greased the legal skids to enable carmakers to deal directly if they decide not to rely on a dealer network, so that’s not a durable competitive advantage, just a place where Tesla has paid a first-mover cost.
- btilly 8y agoI don't believe that Tesla has really solved the legal problem for legacy manufacturers. And Tesla really hasn't solved the problem that going direct will piss off dealers, and dealers retaliating by selling other brands would threaten the existing ICE sales that make up the bulk of the legacy manufacturer's revenue. If you read The Innovator's Solution you'll find that it is common for top leadership at the legacy companies to recognize the coming future and announce initiatives to fix it, but their initiatives fail because the company's existing distribution networks undermine the initiative. So the fact that dealers are not aligned with manufacturers in this case is a special case of a general trend, and historical data points are not promising for the future of legacy manufacturers.
- czankel 8y agoI would actually argue the contrary. I don't see where Tesla has established new sales channels or a new market. They are selling through the same channel (dealers) as traditional auto manufacturers. Yes, they revolutionized the engine, but other car manufacturers can follow suit. Unless Tesla cracks the ride sharing market with self-driving cars (new market), for example, they are not out of the woods, yet.
- madengr 8y agoDealers are still crooked, and will manufacture excuses for maintenance. “You need your reduction gear fluid changed”.
- vasco 8y agoThis seems like an easy problem to solve for these companies. Unless you're worried about the dealers.
- btilly 8y agoThe problem is that dealer networks are protected by state franchise laws. The manufacturer can't readily cut the dealer out of the loop and go into direct competition.
- ebikelaw 8y agoThe guy sitting right next to me has been increasingly angry about not being able to get a new headlight for his Model S, at a price well over $2000, for over a year. I don't think the lack of a dealer service network is a big plus for Tesla. It's just another aspect of their "disruption" circus.
- compcoffee 8y ago>not being able to get a new headlight for his Model S, at a price well over $2000, for over a year. Most of the main stream media seems completely oblivious to the struggles with parts and service Tesla is having. Twitter and the forums are filled with people who have had their cars waiting for parts for weeks and sometimes months. And this supply chain will be strained moreso after all these Model 3s have been in service for a while. Meanwhile, some people talk about how superior this system is. Can anyone explain the difference between a "dealer" and a "Tesla service centre/store"?
- dsfyu404ed 8y agoI find those details hard to believe If they cost $2k and are backordered a year then why hasn't some dude in china with a set of dial calipers and a Rolodex of people who own factories that make plastic car parts isn't making good enough knockoffs for $500 and selling them on eBay and Alibaba for $1000?
- Avshalom 8y agoI'd guess Tesla has a 5$ headlight and a 1995$ encrypted ROM to brick your car if you go outside their supply chain
- dsfyu404ed 8y agoAt some level hardware is hardware. If the headlight has a module that needs to to authenticate then someone would offer a "send in your core and we replace all the shattered plastic and glue it back together" service. Such services are commonplace in the aftermarket parts industry. Usually they just charge you for the core and credit you when the core you send in is good but for rare/low volume stuff you have to send in a core before they do anything which is the business model I would expect to see for something like a Tesla headlight.
- craftyguy 8y agoWhy do manufacturers feel like they must always have dealers? Why don't they ditch the dealers and sell directly?
- prostoalex 8y agoWall Street historically has preferred manufacturers to concentrate on R&D and manufacturing. Manufacturers with large offline presence would have inflated staff numbers, higher labor costs, massive real estate presence and are harder to operate in case of a downturn. Having some well-resourced locals willing to take up those risks seemed like a win-win at the time.
- craftyguy 8y agoI can understand why we got here, but I don't understand why there are any reasons why we must stay, other than to keep dealers in business. You don't need a real estate agent to buy a home. Do they make it easier for some folks? Yes, but you definitely pay for that convenience. You always have the option of doing it yourself (again, which saves a lot of money). Buying a car should be the same way. If you need help selecting a car (or whatever it is that dealers do), pay extra for the service. For everyone else, buying direct from the manufacturer makes more sense.
- prostoalex 8y agoI'd imagine the "selling" operation of the dealership is insignificant, at least the new cars department. Trade-ins, used cars, service and maintenance are the margin drivers. If you go through TrueCar, or any of their white-labeled sites (Costco Auto, Amex Cars, Overstock Cars), you're more or less buying direct.
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> Why don't they ditch the dealers and sell directly? This is illegal in many states.
- 8y ago
- majormajor 8y agoI'm sure they'll still have plenty of other places to put fancy electrical or computer-controlled gizmos that break often. They wouldn't be German if they didn't! (Though I've never owned a Mercedes... just pretty much all of the other German brands.)
- adrr 8y agoMost new cars all run synthetic fluids and platinum plugs so maintenance is already greatly reduced. Oil change every 10k miles, spark plugs every 75k miles. The other liquids don't even need to be changed except maybe a flush of the radiator every 100k miles. The most costly thing on luxury cars is that they usually come with performance tires that last 20k miles.
- qaq 8y agoIf you think this all the maintenance Mercedes or BMW will need ...
- close04 8y agoThe maintenance costs almost surely drop assuming everything else stays the same. Simply by having a far simpler drivetrain that should need less maintenance. But I'm sure auto manufacturers and dealers will invent new ways of making money. Paid software updates? Prohibitively expensive batteries and battery swaps? Charging slightly more for the increasing number of parts that make up the rest of the car and break down regardless of drivetrain? An ICE powered car can happily chug along with relatively little maintenance for far longer than any of today's batteries will last. The engine won't wear out as quickly as the battery. This means the resale value of an EV could be vastly diminished if the buyer realizes the utility of the car has gone down because the battery is worn to a level that would require the above mentioned swap. Also, with the quick pace of advancing technology an old EV has very little resale value unlike classic tech that mostly gets touchups these days, so 5 years difference isn't that noticeable. So don't worry about these guys, as long as something can break down they will find ways to milk you for the repair. And on top of that there's nothing stopping classic manufacturers from dumping dealership networks altogether as soon as they go EV only if they find this to be a financially sound move. I'm pretty sure everybody is just calculating what's the perfect time to introduce subscription services so they don't cannibalize current sales. So future sales and support models will surely be very different from what we take for granted today.
- rebuilder 8y ago
- 3pt14159 8y agoIn the long run, they're screwed anyway. Electric cars are less dramatic, so tolerances are going to be tighter. Maintenance is going to be automated and automated means centralized. Baring intervention on the owner's part, cars are just going to self-drive an half an hour away to get serviced when their owner is asleep or at work. Also, just realized who I was replying to. Thanks for all the things you've written over the years Ben. When I was first getting back into tech your presentation on split testing was invaluable and your articles and HN comments are always great.
- Someguywhatever 8y ago>Baring intervention on the owner's part, cars are just going to self-drive an half an hour away to get serviced when their owner is asleep or at work oooh I didn't even consider that, an excellent idea. I hope this comes to fruition.
- beerlord 8y agoAt that point it will be pointless to even own the car. Might as well just subscribe to 'Mercedes Prime' for $500/month and have their automated vehicles available on demand.
- godzillabrennus 8y agoExactly. The entire industry realizes the shift to a subscription is coming and getting here fast. As a city dweller I got rid of owning a car in 2015. Now I just hop in someone elses car using a ride sharing app if I'm going a short distance. If I am going a long distance I can rent someone elses car, either from a company that owns a fleet or from an individual using Turo / GetAround. In SF you can rent a car to drive somewhere using Uber's GetAround integration for as little as $8/hour. Crazy.
- xevb3k 8y agoThe rental price quoted above (500USD/month) is probably near the average price I’ve paid to buy a car... I hope subscription is kind of less than this otherwise it seems like pretty bad news for the average consumer.
- Marsymars 8y agoReduced maintenance hurts dealers and independent mechanics, but if electric cars also come with much increased long-term durability, that also torpedoes manufacturers' revenue. (e.g. if the long-term per-km capital cost of driving is halved, that halves the entire car manufacturing sector's revenue.)
- yellow_postit 8y agoWhat’s the resell market like for EV? I wouldn’t ever buy new and with the change in maintenance I’m wondering how viable just going to a mechanic to checkout a craigslist car purchase will be as EVs make up a greater share of vehicles on the road.
- Marsymars 8y agoIf long-term reliability really is good for EVs, it should be cheap for manufacturers to offer long-term warranties, transferable between owners, as a point of differentiation over their competitors. As-is, EVs don't (yet?) have better warranties than ICE cars.
- snark42 8y ago> What’s the resell market like for EV? Leaf's are pretty cheap relative to new, I think some buyers remorse is leading to a flooded market but I'm not sure. Tesla's aren't that much less than new (although I was looking at "certified" ones through Tesla.) I decided there wasn't much reason to buy used. Maybe in 3-5 years it will be different.
- rsynnott 8y agoI suspect part of that is just how much better the current model Leaf is than the old ones. In a rapidly changing market, you can’t expect much resale value. Of course, this implies the next problem; it’s never the right time to buy an electric car, because next year’s range is going to be a lot better..l
- 8y ago
- NickM 8y agoOh I don't think we need to wait, pretty sure it's already sunk in, and the effects are measurable: https://electrek.co/2018/05/21/electric-car-adoption-deceptive-car-dealerships-new-study/ https://electrek.co/2018/05/21/electric-car-adoption-decepti...
- VectorLock 8y agoI've heard a lot of dealerships are relying heavily on maintenance for their incoming even such things as Toyota dealerships which are know for low maintenance and high reliability.
- Johnny555 8y agoWhen dealers charge $450 for a regular 15K mile service, it's not hard to make a living even with just routine maintenance. Many car owners are afraid to go anywhere besides the dealer for routine maintenance 'lest they void their warranty (which is not the case, but that doesn't stop dealers from raking in money from those people).
- sremani 8y agoYes, EVs have "low" maintenance but they are not without maintenance and other usual car issues like A/C, accident related fixes etc. Owning Tesla outside of Warranty is worse than owning Benz outside warranty. Unless Tesla expands its support and does a better job with "ownership" and "repairability" of their Cars, I would Trust an 8 year Benz to an 8 year old Tesla .
- dalbasal 8y agoThe experience of owning an 8 (or 18) year old car has a big impact on how I view quality and there are as many people in my shoes as there are in new car buyers'. But.... us old car drivers opinion isn't that commercially important. Resale-ability impacts new car sales to an extent, but a lot of manufacturers (looking at you peugot & renault!) are willing to make cars that have no value by year 8-10. Mercedes & Tesla trade at the higher end, where just the impact on perceived quality (in addition to the quantifiable financial benefits of buying a car that will maintain value) is important. OTOH, EV are already knowingly buying a car that ranks poorly on that front. Who wants to buy a 2015 model EV in 2018? Range improvements alone would kill the price. So... not sure it matters too much yet. Going forward.. who knows. I think tesla may already be "in for a penny, in for a pound."
- close04 8y ago> (looking at you peugot & renault!) are willing to make cars that have no value by year 8-10 But if we're being honest the money you lose after a decade is a lot less then the money you saved when you purchased it.
- gsnedders 8y agoIs that true, though? Here (UK) Kia and Hyundai offer seven year warranties, and most of their products are competitive against Peugeot/Renault.
- jacquesm 8y agoThey mostly offer those long warranties because they severely damaged their brands with the quality of the products they rolled out initially. So now they have to give huge warranties to offset the meme that Hyundai and Kia will not survive even a few years out of warranty without major work.
- Keyframe 8y agoMaintenance finds a way.
- eknkc 8y agoMy dealer changed the brake fluid on my BMW i3 at 15.000km routine maintenance. I have no idea why it would be necessary. Guess that was the only fluid they could change. Got myself an invoice comparable to ICE oil change. Life finds a way...
- Neil44 8y agoBrake fluid absorbs moisture from the air and it's boiling poing reduces over time, making it more likley that heavy braking will boil the fluid and kill the brakes.
- kevin_thibedeau 8y agoBut that's based on time not mileage.
- mikestew 8y agoNo, it's based on people (understandably) not ranking car maintenance high on the list of things they worry about in the dark hours of the morning. So it's easier to just look at the odo, rather than ask the customer who is just going to (knowingly or otherwise) lie to you anyway.
- eknkc 8y agoI get that it needs replacing but owning several ICE cars, I can’t remember having a break fluid change on the very first periodic maintenance of the vehicle. BWT, you use breaks a lot less on an EV, does that have an effect on degredation or is it simply a function of time?
- jacquesm 8y agoIt should not be that expensive, but replacing brake fluid periodically is good practice, it is very hygroscopic and will cause corrosion and eventually seals will fail. But i3 brake fluid change should cost no more or less than any other car with that many disc brakes.
- LinuxBender 8y agoA coworker has had nearly every part in his Tesla replaced. Motors, batteries, controllers and a bunch of parts in the body/frame. He has a heavy foot, but normal drivers will need their Tesla services eventually.
- rcMgD2BwE72F 8y agoCould be the exception that proves the rule. Tesla car reliability is above average in its class (and that is improving over time as Tesla gains experience): https://www.consumerreports.org/car-reliability-owner-satisfaction/tesla-model-s-model-3-reliability/ https://www.consumerreports.org/car-reliability-owner-satisf... We'll see what happens with EVs made by legacy automakers, but they have far less experience in this space.
- nlowell 8y agoI'm interested in seeing if that trend holds while Tesla appears to be taking greater and greater risks in their pursuit of production milestones.
- btian 8y agoI'm not sure about that. People are still going to crash, and they'll need parts. EV parts are more expensive. EVs use more tires because of instant torque. If everything else fails, dealers can just raise their margin at point of sale.
- chc 8y agoDo EVs really go through more tires due to torque? My impression was that the difference in torque was more than balanced out by the fact that EVs tend to brake more smoothly (due to regenerative braking).
- btian 8y agoI would think so. I went through a set of tires after 11,000 miles on my Model S. They usually last 25k-30k miles on the Porsche.
- simplyluke 8y agoTire life probably had more to do with specific tire choice and driving style than EV vs. ICE.
- rconti 8y agoDealerships don't do crash repairs, typically.
- btian 8y agoThey sell parts to body shops.
- wuschel 8y ago> Just wait until it really sinks in for their dealers that selling electric cars means greatly reduced maintenance. That depends. Initially, your argument stands. While it will take years to figure out how to engineer in planned obsolecence into the electric car product, it will eventually happen. I would love to hear an expert opinion on this, actually.
- kevin_thibedeau 8y agoThey already solved that problem with exorbitant markups on bumpers and mirrors. Just take that to the next level for all commonly damaged parts and wear items to cover the lost revenue from drivetrain maintenance. Also make sure all areas that require routine maintenance are hard to access and require many hours of additional labor to perform.
- turbinerneiter 8y agoApple showed that if you are selling a premium product having a premium store is important. Car dealerships will change, but I think that the carmakers could benefit from having them - if they play it right. They have a lot of inertia, so change is hard, but they also have deep pockets. And in Germany, they have the government in their pocket.
- TeMPOraL 8y agoI fully expect the maintenance costs to go up over time, as the market becomes more competitive. EV may have low baseline maintenance requirements, but what's the force that will keep them low when the pressure to cut corners and make manufacturing cheaper increases?
- rz2k 8y agoI think that Mercedes is aware of this, and implemented a long term strategy of acquiring dealerships from their owners a few years ago. "Through the grapevine": they have mandated costly architectural redesigns, and they have had a right of first refusal for at least some dealership owners who wanted to exit the market and sell their dealership to people other than Mercedes Benz itself. They may also have mandated in increase in maintenance service-related revenues to further tighten the screws on dealership owners.
- amelius 8y ago> Tesla worked hard to avoid having dealers. So, can't Mercedes do the same?
- reaperducer 8y agoPossibly not, since that would mean burning bridges with its existing dealer network. If MB decided to go back to dealers, nobody would trust it.
- gowld 8y agoMercedes already has dealers for their non-EVs. They can't just dip their toe in the water without starting fight with their dealers.
- _pmf_ 8y agoTheir dealers have practically no leverage, or am I missing something?
- btilly 8y agoMany dealers, such as AutoNation, sell multiple brands of car. It is much easier for the dealer to decide to push, say, Porsche over Mercedes than it is for Mercedes to replace the dealer. Mercedes really can't afford to piss off these dealers.
- _pmf_ 8y agoOK, so it seems to be different in the US; I've been thinking about the situation in Germany, where at least for domestic brands, dealers are pretty much exclusive.
- floatrock 8y agoTheir exclusive sales distribution channel has no leverage? Dealers have been going through a process of consolidation to the point that one group or company owns many dealerships across multiple brands. Autonation has gotten so big it's a public company. As soon as one OEM tries to rebel, the dealers will tighten the screws across all their sales outlets, relying on their other OEM properties to carry them through. Dealers have all the leverage. Tesla was only able to do it because they had no legacy distribution network they had to keep alive or else risk their board finding a new CEO.
- pkaye 8y agoI expect the electric car dealers to charge more for the repair and maintenance work that remains. Also I've seen gasoline engines get pretty reliable these days. The standard maintenance that my Toyota Camry needs for the first 120K miles is an oil/filter change, cabin filter change, tire rotation on a yearly basis. Maybe a brake pad change once in the 120K. But electric cars also need the cabin filter, tire rotation, maybe brake pads. So really it is just the oil/filter change that remain.
- davidgould 8y agoAn electric car in normal road use is unlikely to ever need brake pads ever unless you turn off regenerative braking. When I upgraded the tires on my first Spark EV at 10000 miles and got a look at them I was amazed that the rotors still had the factory crosshatching on them and the inside of the wheels were clean instead of being filled with brake dust.
- TimesOldRoman 8y agoThat the US Dealers already know that electric cars will hurt their service revenue. They realize that have a monopoly on auto sales and won't willingly give any revenue stream.
- zebraflask 8y agoThis is all well and good, but I'm concerned that if you give a Benz driver a better car, they're going to drive worse than usual.
- dcooper8 8y agoWe leased a Chevy Bolt back in February. $2000 down and $325/month including lease & tire protection plan (3-year lease, 15,000 miles per year). $41/month flat rate for electricity for the garage charger. 240+ mile range and great pickup and driveability (not quite the acceleration of Tesla's Ludicrous Mode, though). But yeah, it was pretty obvious that the dealer wasn't thrilled about carrying and selling this model. They don't push them or advertise them at all -- I'm guessing because they hardly go in for repairs or maintenance.
- tgtweak 8y agoI think we're in the last decade of "buying" and owning a car individually. Seems natural that once self driving is competent enough to get unmanned cars from A to B, you'll just subscribe to your provider of choice and beckon a car when you need it, like Uber. It's basically public cloud for transportation. Our average utilization of our cars is terrible. Parking lots and garages are minimally required in this reality.
- jachee 8y agoSounds a lot like well-run self-driving buses would be even more efficient, were the streets devoid of other traffic.
- patfla 8y agoOne way in which I'd thought of Mercedes going back to high school (1970's) was in terms of their reliability so I was very surprised then to look in consumereports and find just how much most German auto manufacturers have fallen in their maintenance ratings - which would eliminate one reason people used to have in buying these cars.
- robdachshund 8y agoThe slow introduction and adoption of EVs, and the high cost of repairing them should even things out. Mechanics are going to start having to learn EV repair, and they will be able to charge an arm and a leg for it. Also cars are getting a reduction in mechanical complexity in exchange for an increase in electronic complexity. That's going to mean less work on parts like engines and a lot more of swapping out dead computer modules and batteries. That's easier work for less money.
- cptskippy 8y agoI don't think they'll have any trouble scamming people out of money. I bought a used Nissan Leaf with ~12k miles it that was certified with all the extra warranties offered from a certified dealer. The very first time I took the car in for inspection at ~20k, I was told all the brake, coolant and transmission fluids needed to be changed for the tidy sum of $475.
- vesrah 8y agoThey were just trying to get money out of you, the recommended service intervals for those consumables can be found here: https://owners.nissanusa.com/content/techpub/ManualsAndGuides/LEAF/2017/2017-LEAF-service-maintenance-guide.pdf https://owners.nissanusa.com/content/techpub/ManualsAndGuide... Brake fluid, for one, isn't due to be flushed until 45k / 36mo.
- cptskippy 8y agoI'm aware. When I asked "Transmission? Do you mean the reduction gear?" the service manager was confused and started stammering when I asked why all of them need off schedule service.
- inferiorhuman 8y ago> I'm aware. When I asked "Transmission? Do you mean the reduction gear?" the service manager was confused and started stammering when I asked why all of them need off schedule service. Page 19, reduction gear oil should be "inspected" every 15,000 miles or 12 months. Unsure what kind of inspection they'd do, but annual replacement seems like overkill (unless Nissan cheaped out on the fluid and/or cooling).
- cptskippy 8y agoThere's two schedules based on driving habits in the owner's manual. IIRCC the earliest scheduled change is at 90k.
- pesmhey 8y agoWould dealers be in a good position to transition into a sort of local power station? Would be a neat transition into a new business model.
- Shivetya 8y agoManufacturers have caught on, hence the arrival of data packages, services packages to cover navigation and real time traffic, and BMW even charges to connect your Car Play. So fully expect manufacturers to find a way to profit off the car long term and expect more to eventually lock out Carplay/Android auto as revenue will be their first choice not paying Apple to use car play. dealers will end up consolidating and there is easily one generation if not two still to be had doing service for petrol cars and related needs. dealers may morph into on demand rental hubs and the like. now oem and after market parts companies of which I work for are going to have to scramble a bit. the heavy duty market will be a refuge for awhile.
- paulddraper 8y ago> Just wait until it really sinks in for their dealers that selling electric cars means greatly reduced maintenance. How true is that? Batteries are expensive and wear out faster than engines. Even in conventional cars, some of my more expensive repairs have been electronics. And it's not like an electric car doesn't have a hundred mechanicl parts that wear out just as fast as a conventional car. I could see a specific brand or model being very reliable, but I'm skeptical electric cars will make extensive car maintenance far less common than it is now (especially anywhere that doesn't require emissions testing).
- btilly 8y agoPer https://www.tesla.com/Support/Maintenance-plans-ms-mx https://www.tesla.com/Support/Maintenance-plans-ms-mx, Tesla vehicles require no traditional oil changes, fuel filter, spark plug replacements, or emission checks. As an electric vehicle, even brake pad replacements are rare because regenerative braking returns energy to the battery, significantly reducing wear on brakes. That's a lot of regular maintenance that just went away. Per https://cleantechnica.com/2018/04/16/tesla-batteries-have-90-capacity-after-160000-miles-may-last-for-500000-miles/ https://cleantechnica.com/2018/04/16/tesla-batteries-have-90... real world data suggests that Tesla batteries are operating at better than 90% efficiency after 100,000 miles, and are projected to be operating at around 80% efficiency after 500,000 miles. The often repeated claim that batteries will wear out faster than engines is contradicted by the evidence. There isn't enough real world experience to prove it, but electric motors are physically simpler than internal combustion ones and it is believed that few electric motors will need repair before hundreds of thousands of miles. That gets rid of more big repair bills that car owners face. Consider that as https://www.yourmechanic.com/article/the-most-and-least-expensive-cars-to-maintain-by-maddy-martin https://www.yourmechanic.com/article/the-most-and-least-expe... points out, the per year maintenance on a used car is generally $1-2K per year.
- paulddraper 8y ago> The often repeated claim that batteries will wear out faster than engines is contradicted by the evidence. My (anecdotal) evidence was that I replace my regular car battery in my cold-weather state every few years, and it does barely anything! And my sister just replaced the main battery in her 2006 Prius. On a more applicable note, a Leaf loses 33% of its range after 56k miles [1]. I'm not nearly as familiar with Teslas (unfortunately); perhaps they have cracked the formula to long-lasting batteries. [1] https://www.nimblefins.co.uk/nissan-leaf-battery-capacity-range https://www.nimblefins.co.uk/nissan-leaf-battery-capacity-ra...
- Stryder 8y agoDealership is an outdated component that needs to be phased out as quickly as possible.
- threeseed 8y agoI don't believe so. People like to interact with the physical cars given it is such a large purchase. They get to bring their family, sit in it, talk through options with a salesperson. It's like telling Apple or Chanel to get rid of their stores. It's ridiculous. For servicing most people want to take their car somewhere local to be repaired. And many types of servicing need a workshop i.e. to get under the car.
- hinkley 8y agoWe've had this sort of discussion at work a few times (two people here were on the Tesla 3 wait list). There's lots of ways you could encourage people to bring their car in for service for upgrades or customizations. For one thing, most tires lose performance long before they become unsafe (there are a few models advertised as only losing ~10% of their performance at 50% wear). In a world where your car needs less maintenance in general, pushing people to do the maintenance sooner isn't as hard of a pill to swallow. But the limiting factor on most cars is that the things a consumer might wish to change, the cars aren't designed to make those changes simple. Put more engineering effort into maintenance accessibility and you can give the dealer a reason to exist.
- foobar1962 8y agoAgreed about the dealers missing out on revenue from annual services, and Tesla being smart to avoid a dealer network in the first place. However there is very good money to be made in spare parts, and the dealer network can be a huge part of that. From what I've read Tesla is dropping the ball on spare parts at the moment.
- hijinks 8y agoI dunno.. I like Tesla but can't see myself buying one till they open up and let 3rd parties work on them. I can't see paying Tesla 12k on a repair when people that know how to do the repair say $3k max.
- lsllc 8y agoI'm sure they'll find a way to make money ... how long do you think 3D printed struts, suspension arms will last? Maybe they'll just switch to mandatory monthly maintenance fees!
- _Codemonkeyism 8y agoIf we assume your argument is right, how are dealers a weakness? They close shop and Mercedes adopts the Tesla sales model and increases margins if the Tesla model is superior?
- cmurf 8y agoClobber them like Apple did.