13 ms·
Radical open-access plan could spell end to journal subscriptions
- Vinnl 8y agoThis is a fantastic step forward, and the most drastic of measures I've seen so far. The most important part, in my opinion, is the exclusion of hybrid journals, which do not help at all in the transition to open access other than extract even more public money. Other important steps: - Abolishing copyright transfers - No more embargo periods - A cap on publication fees ("Article Processing Charges")
- SOLAR_FIELDS 8y agoThis is the closest I've seen to people attacking the problem at its root. Academics need grants to survive, and they will go after them even if it means being forced to publish in a lower-tier journal. Over time the lower-tier journals gain more status since the high-dollar grant chasing academics start publishing high quality research in them. The paywalled journals ideally subsequently either diminish in quality, lowering the incentive to publish there or switch to an open-access model.
- btrettel 8y agoWith regard to copyright transfer agreements, I have found one publisher willing to publish an article I retain copyright of. I asked at a conference. I have not yet published in a journal, as I am not willing to transfer copyright and find conferences acceptable, but when I do, this will be how. Then they won't be able to stop me from publishing the final version of the paper on a preprint site (for free access), and I still get the benefits of my research being in a journal.
- crankylinuxuser 8y agoPerhaps you could assign rights to the FSF. I'm not sure if they're prepared for that kind of battle, but my gut indicates they might be in a better place than the rest. And, they have 35 years of history showing they wouldn't sell your content under the bus.
- Fordec 8y ago"As written, Plan S would bar researchers from publishing in 85% of journals, including influential titles such as Nature and Science." - Nature Conflict of interest with this reporting much?
- apetresc 8y agoConsidering that the article is clearly sympathetic to the idea, I don't really understand how you think this conflict of interest is manifesting itself.
- GuB-42 8y agoThere is an obvious conflict of interest. However I see nothing wrong with the article. What is written here is a fact. 85% of journals don't match the criteria for Plan S and Nature and Science are definitely influential. Arguments of both sides are presented, not too much sensationalism, that's better journalism than many so called "independent" newspapers.
- dwheeler 8y agoOh, the text is biased. E.g., the word "radical" is not emotion free, it is clearly selected to suggest that this is a bad idea. They also emphasize strongly the number of journals that do not meet this criteria, without noting that changes are absolutely possible. The percentage is so small because of the strong armed resistance of organizations like theirs. We should not expect that an organization used to free money would be happy about losing their exclusive access to hard work that was paid for by the public.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> E.g., the word "radical" is not emotion free, it is clearly selected to suggest that this is a bad idea. No, it's clearly chosen to suggest it is an extreme break from the status quo practice.
- sohkamyung 8y agoOn occasion in its news articles, Nature News has stated that it is editorially independent from the rest of Nature. I don't have a link to that statement, unfortunately, but I have seen it when Nature News has to discuss items that impact Nature publications. Edit: here's a statement from a 2016 article: Nature’s news and comment team is editorially independent of the publisher’s research editorial teams [1] [1] https://www.nature.com/news/open-peer-review-finds-more-takers-1.20969 https://www.nature.com/news/open-peer-review-finds-more-take...
- denzil_correa 8y agoGreat step forward IF the Open Access fee is rationalized. Take for example, Nature Communications - which only publishes OA. The OA fee for one article is €3,850! [0]. Why should tax payers pay two times - to conduct the research, to access the research - to access the research which they fund? Specially, when most of the work is done by the researchers themselves. And before someone talks about journal costs etc. I have been a reviewer for different journals and conferences for many years now. I haven't received a single penny for peer reviews. I highly doubt hosting a PDF on a server takes € 3,850. [0] https://www.nature.com/ncomms/about/article-processing-charges https://www.nature.com/ncomms/about/article-processing-charg...
- spacenick88 8y agoI think the solution isn't to change the publishers it's to let them go bankrupt. In my experience in Computer Science most papers are at conferences and if those simply focused on the conference itself and maybe a website linking to the arxiv versions of the accepted papers there simply wouldn't be a need for any other publishing. As it stands 99% of the burden is on the scientific community anyway, that leaves publishers with abysmal editing and extortion.
- klmr 8y agoI agree but to be fair the editing done by journals does provide some value: Most researchers, in most fields outside of mathematics, physics and computer science, have rudimentary editing skills at best. Many very good biologists I know outright refuse to learn LaTeX, decrying it as a waste of time. Of course this isn’t an insurmountable problem but at least for now there’s a clear demand that journals fill; take a look at manuscripts submitted to bioRxiv. The average quality is a lot worse than CS conference papers or arxiv submissions — not just in terms of text layout and formatting but also for rudimentary language editing etc.
- zdragnar 8y agoPerhaps editing could then be a product sold to the researcher, rather than a reason to yield publishing rights to a single journal.
- John_KZ 8y agoThat's great, and definitely better than paywalls, but how are we going to fund the work of good reviewers?
- foxes 8y agoMost reviewers (at least from my experience in maths and physics) don't get paid.
- georgeam 8y agoComputer Science too don't get paid from my experience either.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- mvonthron 8y agoreviewers are not paid by the publisher in the current system either basically: - authors pay to publish their work - readers pay to read the articles - reviewers review pro-bono now you are thinking "well where the hell goes the money" and you are in the same situation as 99% of scientists
- ethanwillis 8y agoIt goes to funding distribution models that can't deliver unicorns, rainbows, OR puppies to your doorstep. See the following quote from William Gunn, Communications head at Elsevier. When one user argued that people in rare-disease families “shouldn’t have to jump through additional hoops to access information,” Gunn responded, “Yes, everyone should have rainbows, unicorns, & puppies delivered to their doorstep by volunteers. Y’all keep wishing for that, I’ll keep working on producing the best knowledge and distributing it as best we can.” https://slate.com/technology/2018/08/who-gets-to-read-the-research-taxpayers-fund.html https://slate.com/technology/2018/08/who-gets-to-read-the-re...
- thechao 8y agoThis is a great idea. Even better if they applied the requirement retroactively.
- pbhjpbhj 8y agoI don't understand the "bar publishing in 85% of journals" part; presumably they mean "exclusively". That actually means that papers (and research data hopefully?!) can be published for the people who bought the research to be able to legally access it; but journals have opportunity to prove their added value still. And if they do add value, the market can provide a price for it. So non-OA journals can still curate, review, typeset, index, etc., just not lock the publicly funded research itself away.
- IanCal 8y agoIt depends on how you read part of the EU statement, but there's a note about not accepting "the hybrid approach". If this refers to hybrid journals, then that would be the barring of publishing in large numbers of journals.
- pbhjpbhj 8y agoSo if commercial services can add something -- on top of full, open disclosure of research findings -- they're going to make that unlawful? That seems strange: what does the public gain from that?
- IanCal 8y agoNo. There can still be commercial services, commercial for-profit publishing, etc. What they're saying is that simply they don't want to publish findings in subscription journals. > what does the public gain from that? The public and researchers gain permanent access to the research output regardless of which publisher, what deals are in place, where they are or whether their library has a current subscription. It allows researchers to do work analysing the content itself too as they'll then have a licence to do so (useful if you want to analyse, say, 10M papers). Research output reported in the news will be available for any interested party The downside is that instead of publishing for free and then the readers paying, the payment model will be flipped to upfront payment for services and then free access.
- Vinnl 8y ago
- PeterStuer 8y agoBeen a while since I left academia, but certainly at the time this would open the door wide for atrocious publication fees as long as quantitative productivity ranking based on Science Citation Index was upheld. Since the publication fee is covered as direct costs in research grants reimbursed at 100% by the funding authorities, there is no incentive for writers to be price conscious while at the same time being strong-armed to publish in those journals or lose their job.
- Vinnl 8y agoThat's mostly still the case, and they're hoping to mitigate that by capping publication fees. I do think a change in incentive structures, where you need to publish with certain journals to advance your career ("pay to promote"), is still needed though.
- StreakyCobra 8y agoIn complement to the Nature's article: The FNS/SNF (Swiss national science foundation) explains on its website the reason for not signing it (yet): http://www.snf.ch/en/researchinFocus/newsroom/Pages/news-180904-open-access-snsf-supports-plan-s.aspx http://www.snf.ch/en/researchinFocus/newsroom/Pages/news-180...
- buckminster 8y ago"We have a different plan and we're sticking to it" is not much of an explanation. (I'm paraphrasing, but that's the gist of it.)
- Vinnl 8y agoTo be fair, it's more like "we committed ourselves to a different plan to other stakeholders, and we're sticking to it until we have convened with those stakeholders whether they're OK with us joining this plan".
- undreren 8y agoThis could be great for replication studies, as they are really hard to publish under the current model.
- buboard 8y agoThis is not about publishing itself, but about access to published articles. Journals will keep wanting to maintain prestige and be picky, so guess which studies are not going to be accepted.
- dwheeler 8y agoIt's about time. Currently governments fund most of the research, and then constantly have to pay exorbitant fees for every copy of the resulting work. This will also have a tremendous positive effect for the public, Who currently do not have easy access to the work that they're paying for, and in many cases the only stuff they can easily get is quackery or old things. The only thing this is bad for is the Publishers who do not want to adjust to the internet.
- phoe-krk 8y agoI find it funny that this article, or even the HN comments at the moment of me writing this one, do not mention SciHub. It's effectively the most radical open-access plan for science paper nowadays after all. SciHub is the original reason why open-access plans like this one have a chance of working at all. The authors of this paper simply announce that the SciHub approach has won and it's time to stop pretending otherwise and break the status quo of modern science publishing.
- vanderZwan 8y agoThen again, isn't that always the case when a system is rotten but those in power have no incentives to change, and eventually said change is accomplished through a form of civil disobedience?
- rotskoff 8y agoWhile sci-hub undoubtedly plays a role here, in my field the arXiv is really what has obviated the necessity of journal subscriptions. Essentially all math papers, in both the preprint and post-review form, can be found on the arXiv. I would also emphasize that, with regard to decisions involving journal subscriptions and access, authors generally have very little power. As a researcher, if you have the grant money, you can pay to make your work open access; alternatively, you can restrict yourself to only open access journals (which in some fields, could come at significant opportunity cost).
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- phoe-krk 8y agoarXiv is a very important entity here, correct. It performs a different role though. arXiv positions itself in a place before the journals in the food chain; anyone can upload a paper there, including authors who submit to journals, but all of these papers are "preliminary", as in, "before journal edits". It's questionable if journal edits actually bring any value, but nonetheless, their status is that they're going to be "likely different in some way" than whatever journals publish. SciHub allows free access to the "final" pieces of work, even if they're equivalent (or even equal) to the "non-final" ones available on arXiv. That's a big mental difference.
- goldfeld 8y ago"Rent-seekers could lose their privilege and everyone else could win indirectly."
- ricksebak 8y agoAaron Schwartz is like "wait, what was I on trial for again?"
- lerie82 8y agofree software, free science, free the labor force with software and science.
- SimplyUnknown 8y agoHow is this radical. People who have invested in knowledge (e.g. via taxes) should be able to access that knowledge, i.e. reap the benefits of their investment. There is nothing radical here. Sure, I get that this is radical in the sense that some leeches' industry will dry up. That's a good thing but it puzzles me how we got in this situation in the first place.
- ericb 8y agoI'm curious, can anyone update me on the related problem of whether it is still the case that failing studies are rarely published so there's a potential for duplication and misreading of significance--because if 101 studies are run and publish the one time it hit p 0.01 you got what would be expected by chance. Are the structural problems inherent in publish-or-perish mitigated in any way yet?
- Vinnl 8y agoYes, that is still the case, and while a problem, it's a different one than the problem of restricted access to research.
- dschuetz 8y agoFinally a legal way to find and read and cite publicly funded scientific papers. What a time!
- bmurray7jhu 8y agoPreparing papers for publication requires a non-negligible amount of not-fun work. Someone has to proofread the paper, verify compliance with the journal's house style guide, manage the interactions with reviewers, etc. For high impact journals, it may be possible to find enough volunteer editors who are willing to accept compensation solely in the form of a line of their CV. Less prestigious journals need to provide additional incentives to editors, and cash has a proven track record of motivating people. Perhaps academic publishers collect to much rent from their pseudo-monopolies on specific publishing niches, but it is difficult to escape the basic economics of publishing.
- eslaught 8y agoI just don't get this. I was involved in a conference committee this year (CS is published in conferences), and as far as I know everyone from the general chair on down was a volunteer. There were some costs like conference space for the program committee meeting that had to be covered via the cost of admission to the conference, but in a journal presumably even those would not exist since you don't need reviewers to meet in person. As far as I know, the only ongoing costs for the publisher (not immediately recouped via conference admission) would be running their own website and providing downloads. These hardly seem like massive expenses to me. I don't see any fundamental reason why the model in CS couldn't work for other disciplines even if you don't want to adopt conferences; people are willing to step up and do the work, so why is so much money going to the middle men?
- untilHellbanned 8y ago> so why is so much money going to the middle men? Because the scientific community hasn't put forth an alternative.
- dwheeler 8y ago> why is so much money going to the middle men? Because the middle men like getting free money, and it's not other people's jobs to fix the problem. If you're an academic, your job is to produce papers that get published, not fix the publishing system. If you're a library, your job is to make materials available to patrons, not fix the publishing industry. In contrast: If you're a for-profit publisher, your job is to maximize profit, which means minimize your costs and maximize your income. What's changed is that the costs are now so steep, and the value provided by publishers is so little, that it's become painfully obvious that scientific journal publishers don't provide value compared to the rent fees they charge everyone else.
- buboard 8y agoIts a little confusing because the declaration of the initiative says that the "hybrid" model is not acceptable yet just before that it says that they will pay open access fees up to a specific capped amount throughout Europe. Which one is it? In any case, some disciplines in life sciences pay the fee to commercial publishers in order to avoid their own internal politics. Open access publishers can have their own problems with politics and transparency which are at this time masked because everyone publishes in high-impact third party commercial publishers. It is a little more difficult to trust the publication record as a proxy for value when you know that e.g. connections have played a part in it.
- IanCal 8y agoPaying for OA is not hybrid. Hybrid usually refers to journals that have some OA and some non-OA content. However, I'm not sure if the initiative is talking about not publishing in hybrid journals at all, or that publishing non-oa followed by later paying for OA is not acceptable. > In any case, some disciplines in life sciences pay the fee to commercial publishers in order to avoid their internal politics. Open access publishers can have their own problems with politics and transparency which are at this time masked because everyone publishes in third party commercial publishers. I'm not sure if I understand right, but there's no distinction between OA publishers and commercial publishers. OA really just refers to the rights of the final paper, not whether the publisher turns a profit.
- buboard 8y agoOK that makes sense, but that's a tiny distinction. Paying for open access used to be optional (like in Cell) now becomes mandatory (like in Cell Reports). The scientist still pays a hefty fee ($5000) to publish a paper. It's probably more economical for the Funding bodies to pay the OA fee rather than paying the subscriptions, but it still foots a bill. > I'm not sure if I understand right I was making a point about how impact factors are used as proxy for value in life sciences. Because life scientists have done that, they are now dependent on a model in which a third party (the commercial publishers) is judging their work. Going fully open access means the journals will more or less have the same impact factor, because the strong incentive to work towards increasing it (more paid subscriptions) has gone away. So , at least in life sciences, academics will have to learn to evaluate the work of each other more openly, something that other disciplines have achieved long ago (e.g CS, math , physics).
- j0e1 8y agoDoes anyone know of any open-source arXiv like frameworks that can be self-hosted?
- mjfl 8y agoDoes anyone else find this ironic that this article is published in Nature, a subscription journal?
- mark212 8y agoThe solution here is easy and obvious. The Nobel Committee should adopt a rule saying that any research first published in a pay-walled journal will not be considered in evaluating a candidate for any of the Nobel prizes. That would stop publication in a day. Or less.
- pdfernhout 8y agoThank Goodness. I've been advocating for funders to insist on open publication of results (and more) for over a decade: https://pdfernhout.net/open-letter-to-grantmakers-and-donors-on-copyright-policy.html https://pdfernhout.net/open-letter-to-grantmakers-and-donors... "Foundations, other grantmaking agencies handling public tax-exempt dollars, and charitable donors need to consider the implications for their grantmaking or donation policies if they use a now obsolete charitable model of subsidizing proprietary publishing and proprietary research. In order to improve the effectiveness and collaborativeness of the non-profit sector overall, it is suggested these grantmaking organizations and donors move to requiring grantees to make any resulting copyrighted digital materials freely available on the internet, including free licenses granting the right for others to make and redistribute new derivative works without further permission. It is also suggested patents resulting from charitably subsidized research research also be made freely available for general use. The alternative of allowing charitable dollars to result in proprietary copyrights and proprietary patents is corrupting the non-profit sector as it results in a conflict of interest between a non-profit's primary mission of helping humanity through freely sharing knowledge (made possible at little cost by the internet) and a desire to maximize short term revenues through charging licensing fees for access to patents and copyrights. In essence, with the change of publishing and communication economics made possible by the wide spread use of the internet, tax-exempt non-profits have become, perhaps unwittingly, caught up in a new form of "self-dealing", and it is up to donors and grantmakers (and eventually lawmakers) to prevent this by requiring free licensing of results as a condition of their grants and donations." Longer version: https://pdfernhout.net/on-funding-digital-public-works.html https://pdfernhout.net/on-funding-digital-public-works.html Related pledge for organizations: https://pdfernhout.net/pledge-to-only-fund-and-create-free-works.html https://pdfernhout.net/pledge-to-only-fund-and-create-free-w... "Our organization, ______, pledges to our our stakeholders and the people of the world that from this date forward, ________, whenever we use charitable or public dollars to fund or create any new content, software, or any other sort of copyrightable or patentable materials intended for public distribution and public use (or substantially modify existing public content), we will ensure those works will be distributed to the public under free/libre licenses. Free/libre licenses means those who receive the works have the freedom to use, run, copy, study, change, improve, redistribute, and/or distribute modified versions of the works without paying additional fees or obtaining additional permissions."
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- syntaxErr 8y agoThere are alternative ones which are using blockchain technology. I know Pluto project(https://pluto.network https://pluto.network) and ScienceRoot project(http://www.scienceroot.com/ http://www.scienceroot.com/). It's not exactly same with open-access(they insist a fair rewarding system.)
- amai 8y agoIn the meantime Germany and Sweden are having fun with Elsevier: https://www.the-scientist.com/news-opinion/universities-in-germany-and-sweden-lose-access-to-elsevier-journals--64522 https://www.the-scientist.com/news-opinion/universities-in-g...