5 ms·
One of the interesting things about social science observations is there's a lot of noise. Both the lead and the abortion hypotheses could be true. In fact the
by lordnacho 8y ago
One of the interesting things about social science observations is there's a lot of noise.
Both the lead and the abortion hypotheses could be true. In fact they could both be true AND the papers indicating one explanation could conceivably throw out the other explanation. If you're interested in one hypothesis, you might not spend the time going through alternatives as thoroughly as someone investigating the other.
Looking specifically, the studies are always trying to isolate some effect, often using some sort of clever control derived from the proposed mechanism. So in this case there's a paper that points out how lead only goes into the water if the water is acidic, and they look at places with non-acidic water or non-lead pipes to control. For abortion, it's been a while since I read it, but there would be something along the lines of when abortion became widespread in a given community. You'd then look at differences in frequency and think about whether that came out in the crime stats when the kids got older.
The rabbit hole is where you can come up with ever more interesting corollaries and data that support or do not support some hypothesis. You see this across the social sciences all the time. There's also confounding problems, say you know people tend to move to the city when they grow up (I don't know if this is true), then how valid is your birth -> crime data?
Here's a load of random observations I thought up:
- If abortion is the key, why do crime rates keep falling? Why is it not a step effect?
- If it's lead, did crime rates increase 20 years after leaded fuel became a thing?
- What if it's abortion AND lead? There are countries where abortion and lead are timed differently, how about looking at them?
- What if it's neither, but both are caused by some other thing? Say economic development -> both?
- sutterbomb 8y ago>> If it's lead, did crime rates increase 20 years after leaded fuel became a thing? Yes. The rise and fall of violent crime rates correlate very tightly to the rise and fall of leaded fuel, with a ~20 year gap. You see the same correlations in different countries that had different phase in / phase out times, and different U.S. states that had different timelines. (E.g. if a state phased out leaded gas 5 years earlier than average, their crime wave also started abating 5 years earlier than average)
- refurb 8y agoSource? Crime in general decreased quite a lot after the depression, but the use of leaded gasoline was quite prevalent regardless.
- AnthonyMouse 8y agoLeaded gasoline was introduced in the 1920s but there weren't that many cars until starting in the late 1950s. (Construction of the interstates started with the Federal Aid Highway Act of 1956.) Then we saw the huge crime wave starting 20 years later, which peaked and started tapering off in 1993, 20 years after the phase out of leaded gasoline began in 1973. There is also the point that the people who did have cars in the 1920s were the aristocrats, and twenty years after that...
- UncleEntity 8y ago> Then we saw the huge crime wave starting 20 years later, which peaked and started tapering off in 1993... This seems to correlate fairly well with the government's war on (certain) drugs as well.
- anoncoward111 8y agoIt also correlates with population density, public housing, migration, and crack cocaine use. I highly doubt there's one contributing factor to crime, and I highly doubt it is solely from leaded gasoline.
- smallnamespace 8y agoThere are many things that influence crime, the question is how much of the total variance is due to gasoline? And the answer from this research is quite a lot, because the timing of the rise and fall in crime match the timing of leaded gasoline (with a 20-year lag) across cities, states, and countries. To say that 'other factors are responsible' would be to posit that there is some other factor that holds both across and within different cultures and countries that perfect accounts for the pattern in crime rates that we see. That seems much harder to believe than simply 'leaded gasoline causes crime', which we both have robust evidence for now, and for which we have a very plausible mechanism of action.
- philbot1008 8y agoFurther data supporting your point: http://www.tylervigen.com/spurious-correlations http://www.tylervigen.com/spurious-correlations
- tgb 8y agoWhy would you expect a step effect from abortion legalization? It depends upon current criminals dying off or aging out, which happens gradually.
- lordnacho 8y agoI'm no expert but I would think that if the mechanism is abortion, it's such an important decision that everyone who wants to get one will do so. So then ~20 years later all the aborted criminals vanish from the statistics and stay gone, leaving the other criminals to draw their own stats. I'm not saying abortion is the ONLY factor, just that if it is, you'd see a step (or sigmoid) in the crime data and then that's it. As in there's a constant density of abortion sensitive criminals until they get aborted. Similarly if abortion became illegal again, you'd see a step the other way. I'm not familiar with it, but I've heard it's gotten very hard in some places in the US to get an abortion.
- emmelaich 8y agoFWIW, it's not just lead in fuel, it's lead in paint (banned in the USA in 1978) that is a source.
- joe_the_user 8y agoI like this argument which only looks at very long term statistics. Violent crime has been decreasing since colonial times if not earlier and globally. In this sense, a particular decrease in violent crime doesn't explanation as such (though the long term trend does. Perhaps lead exposure has been decreasing for a long time, perhaps not). Increases in crime, long term, are correlated roughly with veterans returning from war. See this link for the argument. http://blogs.berkeley.edu/2010/06/16/a-crime-puzzle-violent-crime-declines-in-america/ http://blogs.berkeley.edu/2010/06/16/a-crime-puzzle-violent-... Edit: also the original lead argument pretty hinges on a single moment of crime increase. I don't see how more detailed studies of the correlation could be more revealing since reality only provides one instance of a potential to leaded gasoline and reality is going to be noisy.
- sutterbomb 8y agoThe author ends his post by stating that the rise of crime from the 60s through the 80s is a major puzzle (to him, in 2010 when he wrote it). I don't see this as an argument against the lead hypothesis in any way. Re: your second point, one of the three studies in the parent article looks at city level crime in the 1920s/30s using city piping infrastructure (lead vs. iron) for test/control groups. The leaded fuel was a substantial source of increased lead levels but not the only one.
- im3w1l 8y agoYeah there can be multiple explanations and even "anti-explanations". Things which should lead to increased crime but whose effects were swamped by other things.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- dalore 8y agoMy issue was that they stated very adamantly that there was no other explanations, when clearly they are. Without stating which explanation is correct (which is impossible to prove). We can easily disprove the statement that no other explanations exist though.