10 ms·
Cargo ships that sink when their cargo suddenly liquefies
- dk1138 8y agoTotally fascinating read. What's amazing to me is what the insurance costs and payouts happening must be. I imagine the losses are staggering.
- rm_-rf_slash 8y agoEqually amazing is that catastrophic failures like these are almost invisible to the consumer. The economy just keeps humming along and we don’t even register a major cargo ship sinking because the shelves are always full.
- protomyth 8y agoNo doubt. I was really surprised when I started following sites like https://gcaptain.com/ https://gcaptain.com/ how many cargo accidents take place per year that practically no one hears about.
- holmet 8y agoThe losses are most prevalent on ULBCs, resulting in the biggest ships of all capsizing. Insurers work with ship regulators and ship owners to prevent this, as not only does it mean they've lost the ship and cargo, but picking up a new ULBC is not a quick process.
- seem_2211 8y agoWhat's a ULBC?
- jsjohnst 8y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bulk_carrier https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bulk_carrier (Which uses this as it’s source: https://web.archive.org/web/20070408154846/http://www.nautinst.org/info/acrnm_abbrev.htm https://web.archive.org/web/20070408154846/http://www.nautin...)
- wyldfire 8y agoULBC: Ultra Large Bulk Carrier
- holmet 8y agoUltra large bulk carrier
- ghrifter 8y agoShouldnt use such a precise jargon acronym like ULBC
- ChrisLomont 8y agoThe article says there are around 10 solid cargo ships lost per year. There are around 10,000 such ships in use. Such a ship costs ~$20M new. Cargo shipments take around 7 weeks door to door, so assuming that also roughly covers dock time, and ships run to near capacity timewise, on avg a ship makes ~7 trips per year. So, out of around 70K trips, 10 result in ship loss. It's entirely possible that the cost to reduce that loss rate against all reasons for loss and across all 10K ships and 70K journeys is far greater than simply allowing 10 failures. Those losses are also likely insured against with the cost spread across the 70K trips. The insurance against them is likely therefore cheap.
- Guvante 8y agoThe insurance cost assuming a 10% overhead is something like $3,200 per trip and that is just the portion of insurance for this one kind of event. Thus eliminating 90% of these events would save around $20k per ship of insurance cost per ship per year. While that isn't a huge amount compared to say their capital costs it is a non-trivial amount of money. Note that your $20M ignores the cost of the cargo as well as the cost of the lives lost. The later can tend to get much higher if fixes aren't found for problems that are known since letting ships sink to save some money is negligence assuming a fix can be reasonably found.
- ChrisLomont 8y ago>since letting ships sink to save some money is negligence assuming a fix can be reasonably found I'd assume there are smart people in the shipping industry that have spent a lifetime on such issues. I suspect there is not some "reasonably found" solution that will help. It may be as simple as surprise severe weather events sink many of those lost - and the cost to protect such a large fleet from rare events is extremely costly. Paying $3200/trip for insurance against ship loss of this kind is peanuts for protecting a $20M item that generates millions annually in revenue. And the insurance on the goods (and this $3200) is simply passed on to those paying to ship goods.
- peteretep 8y agoThere's a very similar phenomenon as a plot point in Neal Stephenson's The Baroque Cycle, involving waves in medieval Japan
- gliese1337 8y agoI have read The Baroque Cycle, but it is huge and my memory is imperfect. Mind reminding me of the details of this plot point, so I don't searching through the whole un-indexed stack of bricks on my bookcase? :)
- dwater 8y agoWhen they are leaving Japan after trading the damascus steel ingots for quicksilver, the Japanese fill all the quicksilver bottles to a level that will cause it to slosh along with the same frequency, causing harmonic resonance to sink the ship. Before leaving they open all of the bottles and transfer the quicksilver so that they are filled to the top and can't slosh. This is from memory and may not be completely accurate.
- saltcured 8y agoNot only tuned to a common frequency but tuned to match a predominant wave pattern in the mouth of the harbor they were departing. I had a hard time reading this part, as the puzzle placement seemed so forced and nonsensical to the plot. What did the Japanese gain from this stunt if it worked? A sunken ship in their harbor leaking mercury from hundreds of smashed jars...?
- hinkley 8y agoI thought I had heard at one point that Industrial Age Japan was responsible for some substantial fraction of mercury contamination of the ocean but I can’t find a citation for that. What I did find is Minamata disease, which is a particular set of symptoms from severe mercury poisoning, documented in a town in a bay on the western end of Japan. Maybe Neal was making some sort of nod to that?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- _carl_jung 8y agoWhy don't they treat this cargo under the assumption that it is a liquid and transport it accordingly (e.g. in large barrels)? I mean this question genuinely as someone with little knowledge of logistics.
- jabl 8y agoBecause bulk transport, even including the cost of occasional sinkings due to liquefaction, is cheaper? See also Glückauf, the first tanker designed to transport oil directly in the hold rather than in barrels. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gl%c3%bcckauf_(1886) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gl%c3%bcckauf_(1886) I suppose in addition to the measures described in the article, bulk ships could adopt cargo holds divided into more subcompartments (including longitudinally, to reduce risk of capsizing) , similar to tankers.
- holmet 8y agoTry putting 200,000 tons of coal into barrels, transport it, and then unbarrel it at the other end. The extra cost and time would be massive.
- lqet 8y agoWhat about just compartmentalizing the ship's cargo space?
- pohl 8y agoThis reminds me of the meme that goes "when I was a kid, I thought quicksand was going to be a much bigger problem than it is."
- winceschwab 8y agoSo, this is kind of similar to the whole corn-starch-and-water non-newtonian solid kind of problem, right? A little different, because this isn’t entirely about mixtures, aqueous solutions or colloidal suspensions, but more about the fundamental behavior of large quantities of particulate solid mass. The title could differentiate between being a total loss at sea, versus sinking while docked in a harbor, at least in terms of statistics and death. Also, how is there not one picture of a listing ship in this article?
- itissid 8y agoSo ship shakes. The aluminum ore, bauxite, turns to liquid due to pressure increasing (or friction decreasing). Ore moves to one side of the ship. Pressure drops as shaking subsides. Ship becomes side heavy and lists and sinks. This is as weird as things can get with reality.
- winceschwab 8y agoIt doesn’t really “turn to liquid” but really starts behaving according to fluid dynamics. Nothing melts or freezes. More to the point, the motion of the macroscopic objects (rocks, sand, dust, powder) being dumped in by conveyor belt create huge piles that slump in odd ways, as piles form, and then settle oddly.
- DonHopkins 8y agoTo illustrate what you mean: The Abelian Sandpile Model, aka the Bak–Tang–Wiesenfeld model, is a dynamical system displaying self-organized criticality, that suggests you can't predict the behavior of adding one more grain of sand to a pile, because it might have very little effect, or it could cascade into a huge landslide. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abelian_sandpile_model https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abelian_sandpile_model https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Self-organized_criticality https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Self-organized_criticality >In physics, self-organized criticality (SOC) is a property of dynamical systems that have a critical point as an attractor. Their macroscopic behaviour thus displays the spatial and/or temporal scale-invariance characteristic of the critical point of a phase transition, but without the need to tune control parameters to a precise value, because the system, effectively, tunes itself as it evolves towards criticality. >The concept was put forward by Per Bak, Chao Tang and Kurt Wiesenfeld ("BTW") in a paper published in 1987 in Physical Review Letters, and is considered to be one of the mechanisms by which complexity arises in nature. Its concepts have been enthusiastically applied across fields as diverse as geophysics, physical cosmology, evolutionary biology and ecology, bio-inspired computing and optimization (mathematics), economics, quantum gravity, sociology, solar physics, plasma physics, neurobiology and others. >SOC is typically observed in slowly driven non-equilibrium systems with extended degrees of freedom and a high level of nonlinearity. Many individual examples have been identified since BTW's original paper, but to date there is no known set of general characteristics that guarantee a system will display SOC.
- LeonM 8y agoFascinating read! Can this situation can be avoided if the loading bay has a cover/lid on top of the material? As long as the loading bay is 'full' (or the top is movable to fit the cargo) the material won't be able to slosh around, thus preventing the situation described in the article.
- werdnapk 8y agoEven if a lid would work, I'd assume it would be too large and expensive to deal with. The lid would have to be rather heavy duty. As noted in the article, the solution needs to be cheap and relatively easy to deal with.
- chillydawg 8y agoThe usual solution, as with petrol tanks in cars and elsewhere, is to use baffles. It effectively turns one large tank into several smaller ones and stops the liquid from freely sloshing from one side to another. The sloshing causes problems non-linearly with size of tank, so reducing one tank into 4 or 8 has a huge impact on the risks of sloshing. The partitions/baffles are always vertical (although I expect aerospace baffles are a bit more fancy).
- MPSimmons 8y agoAgreed. I read this and thought, "Oh my God, why not use baffles?"
- amelius 8y agoYeah, but the original state of the material was solid. You can't compartmentalize a solid unless you break it.
- maffydub 8y agoIt was solid, but granular - the article gives the example of crushed ore and mineral sands - so it's already broken up.
- aunty_helen 8y ago
- vermontdevil 8y ago10 ships a year + 10 years = 100. Wow. I’m guessing insurance going to be even more expensive now unless 10 ships a year out of however many ships out there is minimal.
- holmet 8y agoThis has been a problem for decades and is already priced into the insurance. It's also not a big part of the world fleet.
- gnode 8y agoThe Wikipedia article on bulk carriers states the fleet size as: "9,570 vessels over 500 GT". https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bulk_carrier https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bulk_carrier
- dredmorbius 8y agoSomething to consider when people suggest nuclear marine propulsion.
- pasta 8y agoThis is a very old problem and solutions and knowledge has been available for over 20 years. But I think the main problem is cost: not waiting for the rain to clear, not making time to install temporary bulk heads, and so on. Edit. for example this article from 1998: http://www.gard.no/web/updates/content/52980/shifting-solid-bulk-cargoes http://www.gard.no/web/updates/content/52980/shifting-solid-...
- soneil 8y agoThat was my first thought too. Shipping liquids is a solved problem. You baffle containers to limit shifting and slapping. Doing the same for dry bulk seems like a no-brainer? There must be a consideration I'm entirely missing.
- phkahler 8y ago>> There must be a consideration I'm entirely missing. Just the standard business "reason" - cost.
- mannykannot 8y agoI am sure that is the main part of it, but there is probably a certain amount of complacency and ignorance in play. I would guess that, for the vast majority of bulk-cargo voyages, there is no noticeable shifting, making it it easy to assume that it is not a risk. A captain who has never experienced the problem is probably less likely to stand up to the shipper (and the ship owner's management, which is an issue in itself) over whether a cargo is fit to ship. The article linked by pasta shows that the problem has been recognized and regulated, for some cargoes, a while back (e.g. grain in 1982), but the lesson has not been generalized.
- DonHopkins 8y agoIn case of a grain liquefaction emergency, you can simply toss in a few tribbles, and its consistency will quickly change from granular to fuzzy. Also, the rock eating monsters of Janus VI work well against bauxite liquefaction, and M-113 salt vampire creatures are highly effective against salt liquefaction (but unfortunately there is only one surviving creature).
- breitling 8y agoInteresting read. I thought all along that materials change state due to temperature changes. Time to track down my teachers and show them this article. You learn something new everyday
- johnnyletrois 8y agoThis is called free surface effect with liquids and as has been mentioned by other posts is a common and known problem with liquids. Free surface effect is a core component of vessel stability and is part of maritime stability education.
- hectorr1 8y agoIf you want a quick primer on buoyancy physics and ship design, Marine Insight has a good writeup: https://www.marineinsight.com/naval-architecture/intact-stability-of-surface-ships/ https://www.marineinsight.com/naval-architecture/intact-stab... As the article mentioned, wave action will cause the center of gravity (CG) of the liquid to shift, and with it the overall ship's CG. This puts the ship in a new stable equilibrium heeled over to that side. If the compartment isn't dewatered, this process can repeat until the 'stable' equilibrium includes upper decks taking on sea water. CG shifts up, righting arm becomes flipping arm, hull experiences stress beyond tolerances, breaches kill remaining buoyancy, and down she goes. By the way, the easiest way to tell if a ship is in danger of hitting critical (aka neutral aka very very bad) stablility, watch how long it takes to rock from side to side. A ship that has an excessively long roll period and appears to be hanging to one or both sides can in serious danger.
- astrodust 8y agoLoading the cargo into close-packed hexagonal storage silos would prevent it from shifting too much during transport, and even if it did liquify, it wouldn't slide too far out of balance. You can fill/empty these of granular cargo using large diameter hoses. You could also create one or two special storage bins that can be rotated to an arbitrary degree to help right the ship if it gets into trouble. They're carrying ridiculous amounts of ballast, why not put some of it to use as a counter-weight?
- tomatotomato37 8y agoBecause that's more expensive to implement/load/unload then dumping the whole heap in an open bay and insuring the hell out of it
- totalZero 8y agoYou dont need silos, just baffles. If the cargo doesn't slosh over to one side or another, then it cant solidify in such a position either.
- 8y ago
- failrate 8y agoAwesome. My boy and I were talking about liquefaction and phase solids last night when he was showing me how the sea salt behaves as a solid in the shaker (humid here) until he bangs on thr glass.
- mcguire 8y agoCheck out the physics of ketchup.
- tomc1985 8y agoThey mention that solids are stored in a sort of liquid suspension. Why is that? I feel like a solid, airtight box (like a shipping ocntainer) 100% full of sand wouldn't doo too much.
- hermitdev 8y agoEver moved a large pile of sand that's been stored outside? Once you get a foot or so into it, there's going to be some moisture. It's not going to be much by weight, but it's there. Of course, it's going to vary depending upon environmental factors (humidity, temperature how recently it rained, etc). That contributes partially to the liquefaction.
- Atreus 8y agoThe loading and pseudo-solidification can cause residual internal stresses that change the dynamic response so that a small signal input gets a big change as a result. I'd imagine that the exact values are not monitored, so that what is written as "in the hold" and what is actually there are subject to natural variation, which can be asymmetric, and thus theory and practice are not the same thing. If seawater gets into the mix, it will have more water. There are thermal phase changes in the liquefication. It can behave very differently at 10 deg C warmer than one expects from 0 deg C warmer. Over a relatively long trip, with agitation, the mean particle size is going to change. Big particles are going to break into smaller particles. This is going to change the liquefication physics.
- lordnacho 8y agoPardon my ignorance, but what would happen if you just divided the hold into smaller compartments? That way sloshing would only move things slightly to one side.
- trjordan 8y agoIt would cost a bunch of money but go part of the way towards fixing the problem. But if you're going to spend the money, maybe you could entirely fix the problem. You'd have to run the numbers!
- rriepe 8y agoIt's already divided into smaller compartments, through the containers themselves. Think of a ship transporting prisoners in their own little cells. Then think of all the prisoners working together to throw their weight against the walls of the cells at just the right moment in an effort to sink the ship. The prisoners would only have enough of an effect to make the guards a little nervous. The ore sloshing around in the containers weighs tons and tons, though, enough to actually sink the ship.
- blt 8y agobut the article suggests that permanent accumulation in one side, rather than transient force, is the cause.
- pvaldes 8y agoI was expecting a Sperm whale's reference somewhere ;-)
- userbinator 8y agoI find it sad that the article speaks of "new technology" and proposes lots of complex (thus error-prone and not cheap) solutions, when the very simple solution has been known for a very very long time: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Free_surface_effect#Mitigation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Free_surface_effect#Mitigation Keep the cargo in containers which are always full or nearly so. If it doesn't have room to slosh around or shift, it won't. The added bonus is that it costs less per volume to ship, if the vessel is always full.
- jonny_eh 8y agoAnd/or load less of the stuff onto a ship. I'm surprised that wasn't suggested either.
- glenneroo 8y agoI believe it was mentioned, albeit somewhat indirectly: > Commercial agendas also play a role. For example, pressure to load vessels quickly leads to more hard loading even though it risks raising the water pressure in the cargoes. And pressure to deliver the same tonnage of cargo as was loaded may discourage the crew of the vessel draining cargoes during the voyage. If crews don't want to dump some cargo to restore balance, they surely don't plan to to ship less cargo.
- ChuckMcM 8y agoSo here is a random observation for some enterprising grad student or postdoc; is electric charge responsible for liquefaction on packaged solids? Triboelectric charging is not well understood yet, it happens in dust storms and volcanic eruptions where charge is transferred to particulates from the air. As charge increases this results in "dry lightning" or other discharges. If you wanted a research topic, I think you could look into the hypothesis of whether or not a powdered material could be charged to exhibit liquid properties. Note that the way these bulk solids are loaded on to ships it typically by conveyor belt where they then drop through the air (charging opportunity) and then dropped into a conductive container (the hull of a steel ship). If someone has looked into this already I'd love to read the paper on it.
- contact_fusion 8y agoLiquefaction has nothing to do with triboelectricity. The article has a pretty good description of how liquefaction proceeds: higher pressure -> water present in material reduces contact between solid particles -> material friction reduced -> material behaves like a fluid. If you want more, find a book on basic rheology. I'm certain there are civil engineering textbooks that contain the material. Further, it does not stand to reason that charged materials would suddenly acquire fluid properties. Solid materials are quite capable of sustaining charge without changing their bulk properties. Prior to significant change, local voltages would exceed the breakdown voltage and the charge would be neutralized.
- ChuckMcM 8y agoYou are offering to do the experiment? The physics is pretty straight forward, particles which share the same charge will repel each other, this will hold them apart and allow them to 'slide past' each other just as diamagnetic material float along a magnetic field.
- nappy-doo 8y agoAlthough unlikely that liquefaction caused this wreck, my mind went first to the SS Edmund Fitzgerald.
- 24gttghh 8y agoThere appear to be many factors that went into that sinking: huge storm, 30-35 ft waves, possible rogue waves even larger; improperly secured hatch covers, no water-tight bulkheads(!!); regulations that allowed overloading and decreased freeboard, etc, etc.[0] [0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SS_Edmund_Fitzgerald#Theories_on_the_cause_of_sinking https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SS_Edmund_Fitzgerald#Theories_...
- vvpan 8y agoI don't understand the point of "two-phase" materials. Why would you add water to ore?
- tialaramex 8y agoFirst up, we're not talking about a soup here, this isn't like it's a litre of water for every kilo of ore, it's just that it's enough to allow the solids to move without the friction they'd incur if entirely dry. Ore starts out as rock buried in the ground. So, you're going to need to get that out of there. While you could do that with a bloke and a pickaxe I'm sure lots of the processes actually involved add water, even if not terribly much. Also, this stuff isn't expensive, it's basically just slightly valuable dirt, so if it's stored somewhere they're not going to be keeping it in water-tight containers, it'll be in an open truck, or an open freight car somewhere, getting rained on. Now, shipping dirty water across the ocean is pointless and costs money, so it's not as though they're going to add more water just for fun, but if the contracts involved don't specify that it has to be less than so-and-so much water in the cargo, then it's nobody's job to ensure it isn't damp.
- vvpan 8y agoAh! Thanks. I imagined an intentional mix for some reason.
- spurcell93 8y agoIf I recall, this problem was used in "The Martian" by Andy Weir, when one of the rockets carrying supplies failed. At high pressures, some of the cargo liquified and the rocket exploded due to shifting weight distribution. It may have been another book...
- JshWright 8y agoYep (spoilers), that was what happened to the rocket that was supposed to bring supplies to Watney so that he could survive until the next scheduled mission (prompting the crew currently returning to earth to "turn around")
- srtjstjsj 8y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=My4RA5I0FKs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=My4RA5I0FKs YouTube science educator Mark Rober's "Liquid Sand Hot Tub - Fluidized air bed"