24 ms·
Would You Let the I.R.S. Prepare Your Taxes? (2015)
- sologoub 8y agoColleagues from the EU countries who relocate to the US generally tend to have a two-fold reaction - excitement at the lower tax rates and dismay at the filing complexities. Would be amazing to have the cake and eat it too - lower taxes and a simple filing system!
- isostatic 8y agoI guess "lower taxes" depends what the extra $200 a month in taxes (on a $70k salary in CA rather than UK) gets you in terms of services. Apparently the average health care cost is $1300 a month, making taxes and other essential expenditure $500 per person per month more in CA than in the UK for a 2 income family on $70k each.
- rb808 8y agoLower taxes? In France the bracket for a family for €104,120 to €279,132 is only 30%. Sure if you live in Oaklahoma you might pay less than that but CA/NY state taxes plus property taxes, plus fewer investment tax free options, I think US taxes are now similar or higher. Ie 28% federal + 10% state + 10% property taxes equals nearly 50%. Sure sales tax is lower. Plus - you still have to pay for your medical care, and universities and no social safety net.
- noir_lord 8y agoIn the UK you don't pay 45% until 150,000 and only 45% on any amount over 150,000 as it's tiered.
- lloyddobbler 8y agoPoint of information - the progressive taxation ("tiered") method from the UK is the same as in the US. You pay in tax bracket A up to $X, then the next tier is taxed at tax bracket B, and so on, and so on.
- zip1234 8y ago20% VAT on everything makes a difference as well although it isn't an income tax
- mFixman 8y agoRaising income tax rates is unpopular, so the UK government adds hidden income taxes that aren't reported anywhere. You need to add 12% to your marginal tax rate before £46500 per year for national insurance payments (and 2% after that), and 20% between £100k and £121k per year for the loss of the standard deduction. The real marginal tax rate for someone making £100k is 62%. Also include 12% employer's NI (which by law isn't included in your salary, but must be paid by your employer), and a nice 20% sales tax levied on everyone except people with a significant amount of savings.
- refurb 8y agoWho pays a 10% property tax? The $165K to $315K bracket for a family in the US is 24%. A healthy chunk lower than France. Plus mortgage interest deduction, etc.
- Xixi 8y agoIt's 30% of what remains after the "cotisations sociales" (or "charges sociales" as people who hate them like to call them). These social contributions amount to close to 50% of what the employer pays. So it's 30% of what remains, which is already only barely half of what the employer paid... These social contributions cover health insurance, retirement contributions, a pretty generous unemployment insurance, etc. So even though they are expensive for people working in France, the social safety net they provide is pretty good. The 30% income tax you refer to would not be enough to cover that. I think the income tax in France doesn't even cover the interests of the national debt, that how little it is in the grand scheme of things. Hence why we have a hell of a lot of other taxes (VAT at 20%, CSG, etc.) to keep going...
- rb808 8y agoOK, my mistake, so that adds to 67%, which is a lot. If you add Social Security and Medicare to US taxes I still think North East comes to 55%+. With virtually nothing to show for it. At least we have the benefit of 14 aircraft carriers.
- greedo 8y ago10% property tax would spawn a rebellion. Mine is a bit over 2% and people complain about that.
- rb808 8y agoI mean 2% of the property value, then that $ amount as %age of income. California is much lower.
- gamblor956 8y agoIn France, that 30% tax is on your gross income without deductions, and doesn't include a number of other taxes on your income that were already taken out as payroll taxes, usually about 10-20% of your wage income. In the US, you face a 24% or 25% tax on your gross income after deductions, not including additional credits that may also apply. Payroll tax deductions are also much smaller in the US. Not aware of any state which has a 10% property tax and an income tax. I am aware of some states having high property taxes but no income taxes... Finally...we do have a safety net. It's a safety net, not a dole like the European model.
- Assadi 8y ago>Not aware of any state which has a 10% property tax and an income tax. I am aware of some states having high property taxes but no income taxes... California's can be as high as 13 something percent, I believe (though, I think with the kind of numbers the other guy was talking about, it'd probably be like 6-7%). But, you're right that the property tax is a serious exaggeration. Like, expensive places like Austin are around 2%, from what I remember.
- gamblor956 8y agoCalifornia's property tax can't reach 13%. It's been capped at 1% since 1978, and the assessed value can only increase by 2% each year, or when a property is sold. But the tax itself remains 1%...
- phamilton 8y agoHe means income tax
- Xixi 8y ago"Charges salariales" + "Charges patronales": it's way more than 10-20%. It's around 28% for a minimum wage worker, and around 45% for a software engineer making 45k "brut" / year.
- 8y ago
- froindt 8y ago> ...I think US taxes are now similar or higher. Ie 28% federal + 10% state + 10% property taxes equals nearly 50%. You can't just add the percentages up like that since federal and state taxes are marginal rates. You'd have to add the effective tax rates. > Lower taxes? In France the bracket for a family for €104,120 to €279,132 is only 30%. This range is $118,000 to $318,000 USD. At the federal level for a family $165,000-$315,000 is at the 24% marginal rate of taxable income (not gross). In the convoluted system we have, you'd knock off $24,000 as a standard deduction, then any amounts contributed to retirement accounts (401k's and IRA's), HSA contributions if applicable. If you add all those vehicles up, that's up to another $54,000 taken off of your gross income. No idea how taxes in France works, aiming to point out there are tax advantaged spaces which would significantly reduce the tax burgeon. Quick looking at things, NY state income tax would be about $20,500 on $323,000 in earnings (no deductions, credits, averages to about 6.3%). I'm curious where you got your 10% property tax guesstimate though? I'm not familiar with New York to try to estimate through things, but [5] makes it seem not nearly that bad. Is it a highly localized thing? "Property taxes in New York vary greatly between New York City and the rest of the state. In New York City, property tax rates are actually quite low. The average effective property tax rate in the Big Apple is just 0.80%. The statewide average rate is 1.65%." -- Interestingly, Iowa, which people on the coasts would probably lump together with Oklahoma as low cost of living flyover states, has very high state taxes. 8.98% on earnings above $70,785. [4] New York's highest bracket hits at $2,100,000 and is 8.82%. [2] [1] Federal Income Tax: https://www.nerdwallet.com/blog/taxes/federal-income-tax-brackets/ https://www.nerdwallet.com/blog/taxes/federal-income-tax-bra... [2] NY Income Tax: https://www.tax-brackets.org/newyorktaxtable https://www.tax-brackets.org/newyorktaxtable [3] NY Property Tax: https://smartasset.com/taxes/new-york-property-tax-calculator https://smartasset.com/taxes/new-york-property-tax-calculato... [4] Iowa Income Tax: https://www.tax-brackets.org/iowataxtable https://www.tax-brackets.org/iowataxtable [5] New York Property Tax: https://smartasset.com/taxes/new-york-property-tax-calculator https://smartasset.com/taxes/new-york-property-tax-calculato...
- jejones3141 8y ago"Interestingly, Iowa, which people on the coasts would probably lump together with Oklahoma as low cost of living flyover states, has very high state taxes. 8.98% on earnings above $70,785." True, though so far, at least, I think that's still balanced by being able to deduct federal income tax when figuring what you owe the state. I recall that there's a move to get rid of that deduction.
- gnopgnip 8y agoIn France on an income of $100k USD your effective tax rate is 44%. Social security tax in France is significant. In CA you are paying 21%. At $300k USD it is 54% to 30%. The sales tax in CA is half the rate in France. Property taxes cannot be directly compared to income, they are based on the location and value of the home. There are large changes to the property tax system in 2018-2020 in France. We can compare overall property tax revenue for the country and divide it per person. In 2015 in France the average property tax revenue per person was $1422 USD. In 2010 in CA it was $1472. CA is higher but not substantially so.
- ptaffs 8y agothen dismay over medical costs, lack of government services and, many little things like cell-phone and cable fees and taxes.
- stephengillie 8y agoI'm annoyed that there is no simple system for the IRS to tell me what I owe, and let me pay or dispute. Instead, we play this game where the IRS provides a bunch of complicated documents, I guess which ones to fill out and submit, then wait 3 years to see if I was randomly chosen to see if I was correct. So it's very easy to make a mistake for dozens of years, then suddenly be penalized at random. It's the worst kind of selective enforcement - random enforcement. And this is to help H&R Block and others sell "tax insurance", just in case you're randomly selected for audit and H&R Block was also wrong about which tax documents to submit. The IRS have all the data - from employers, banks, Social Security, unemployment, and other government services. I might have most or all of the data, and could verify or contest items they have on file. Edit: So the IRS may not always have all of the data, and would still need a way for us to submit documents in some edge cases.
- slededit 8y agoCanada sends you an assessment after you file letting you know their initial thoughts on how much you owe. You can still get audited to see if there were any omissions or factual errors - e.g. Your home office isn't really an office.
- gruez 8y agobut don't you still have to fill out a tax form? in that case, isn't that the same as in US?.
- slededit 8y agoYes, but you have a much better idea of whether it was actually done correctly and matches CRA's information. I don't claim its better in every way, just this one specific issue has a solution.
- tobib 8y agoYou're actually able to electronically fetch all the data that the various companies (employer, broker, bank, etc) report to the CRA anyway. All you have to do is check it and send.
- xutopia 8y agoIt's not that simple. Depending on how you spend your money you can have access to some tax saving measures. You can also make money cash that you have to declare when filing your taxes.
- peatmoss 8y agoHaving lived in New Zealand where the IRD does this, yes. Yes I would. If they owe you money, you can file. If you owe them money because they screwed up, you don’t need to do anything. This assumes pay as you earn, standard employee status, not entrepreneurial revenue. Easy for the common case.
- philliphaydon 8y agoKiwi living in Singapore. I prefer Singapore's method of deducting it from your bank account directly each month, or you pay your own lump sum. In NZ (and Australia) you have tax withheld, which means the employer holds your tax, they are not obligated to pay that tax for ( i believe 6 months ) so they tend to pay 1/4 yearly or 1/2 yearly, leaving the money in their own account. In Singapore you get your full salary and you pay it yourself, either via lump sum, or monthly deductions from your bank account.
- chatmasta 8y ago“Your taxes” is such an overloaded term that it’s almost comical to refer to it as if it means the same thing for everyone. There is basically one straight-forward case where the IRS preparing taxes makes sense: that of full time employees whose only income is from their job which issues W2s. For everyone else — which includes: - People working multiple part time jobs - People with non-standard investment portfolios or real estate holdings - Contractors, with or without an LLC - Full time employees who are also contractors - Dual residents - Small retail businesses - Small internet businesses - Megacorps — there is a different set of requirements. The idea that the IRS would be able to optimize everybody’s return so they pay the least amount of tax, is absurd. And that’s not even considering the moral hazard of misaligned incentives, i.e. the IRS has no incentive to make sure you deduct as much as legally possible from your return.
- clarkevans 8y agoEveryone else is, what 10% of filers? If you're in the 10% you'll know it and you'll do private preparation.
- ghaff 8y agoAbout 2/3rds of people do file a 1040 rather than a 1040A or 1040-EZ which at least suggests that most people do have taxes that are more complex than just just a W2 and a standard deduction.
- ghouse 8y agoLike a 1099? The government has this data as well.
- kevin_thibedeau 8y agoMost people are using tax prep services that will default to 1040 since their software doesn't care about which form is going to be used and it's simpler to code for just the general case.
- teej 8y ago
- pnathan 8y agoI would absolutely let the IRS prepare my taxes... if this workflow or one like it is followed: Jan, I get a 1040 form, prefilled out. If I don't agree that it states my financial position correctly, I can correct it & send it back by Mar 1st. If I do agree, I place it in my file cabinet. But as patio11 noted, at least once, the IRS enforces taxes to the amount Americans will tolerate. What he did not say, but I have heard elsewhere, is that tax evasion is enormous, and pervasive in the cash economy. which is part of why I favor abolishing cash. :-)
- mox1 8y agoThis is the irony, that in your scenario (which I agree with), My "check" would be to purchase Turbotax or similar and run the numbers. So whether the IRS pre-fills the 1040 or I do it myself, I'm going to use tax prep software. I guess they loose the e-filing fees, but most version of the software come with 1 free federal and 1 free state..
- pnathan 8y agoIn this scenario, I am quite comfortable checking my own numbers without the aid of specialized software. I use TaxAct today because of e-filing. In other scenarios, I would prefer to cough up money to talk to a specialist.
- jonnycomputer 8y agoFree, unless you earn too much, or if you have any any business income.
- simplecomplex 8y agoThey already do prepare your taxes. They just make you do the same work twice.
- craftyguy 8y agoIf they do, they are terrible at it. I get 'corrections' from the IRS about once a year to previous returns, all of which are basically them making an error and then sending me a bill. Not only do I have to waste time preparing my taxes, but I have to waste additional time disputing their BS 'corrections'.
- jedberg 8y agoWouldn't it be so much easier if they just sent you all the corrections first so you could just dispute them once? :)
- craftyguy 8y agoThat would, in the best case, still require as much effort as filing in the first place or, in the worst case, require as much effort as I have to do now because the disputes are a lot of back/forth/waiting with the IRS.
- mbreese 8y agoI once got a correction was was completely accurate. TurboTax has hidden something in a worksheet that errantly added something twice. The IRS corrected it and sent me a notice to let me know the correct value. It did reduce my refund, but it was correct.
- topmonk 8y agoI'm in my 40's and have only once received a correction that was an error on the IRS's part. I wonder why you receive so many, is your tax situation rather complicated?
- rndmize 8y ago13 million in lobbying over five years to prevent more efficient tax filing for an entire nation and protect your business model. Sounds like an amazing deal for a company with 5 billion in revenue. I'm consistently amazed at just how little money it takes to buy off the government effectively.
- ritchiea 8y agoIt's not just that, anti-tax zealot Grover Norquist has outsized interest on the right and he gets republicans to sign a pledge to not raise taxes, and if they violate the pledge Norquist raises money and campaigns against them. The problem is, the pledge also requires signees also do not support legislation to make paying taxes easier. The radical anti-tax groups are so anti-tax that they see making it easier to pay taxes as support for taxes. So they want it to be difficult to pay taxes to make it easier for them to argue against taxes entirely. The system is broken in so many places trying to approach it with any rationality gives you a headache.
- phonon 8y agoWhere do you see that? https://s3.amazonaws.com/atrfiles/files/files/Federal%20Pledge.pdf https://s3.amazonaws.com/atrfiles/files/files/Federal%20Pled... EDIT: OK, found this https://www.atr.org/taxpayer-advocates-issue-joint-free-file-a7496 https://www.atr.org/taxpayer-advocates-issue-joint-free-file... https://reason.org/wp-content/uploads/files/ba148cd5babdda39f9ebb43b336b01d4.pdf https://reason.org/wp-content/uploads/files/ba148cd5babdda39... https://s3.amazonaws.com/atrfiles/files/files/041111lt-wycoatstaxprep.pdf https://s3.amazonaws.com/atrfiles/files/files/041111lt-wycoa...
- forgotmypw 8y agoI stopped filing my taxes starting in 2011 for 2010. I had always hated the process, but in 2010 I had switched jobs several times, and had misplaced one of the stubs mailed by an employer. I have almost always worked as an employee, not a contractor or business, so I did not owe money--they probably owed me. I decided that rather than get the couple hundred bucks I would receive as my return, I will forgo the stupid process altogether. I have yet to hear from anyone about it, and I have become a little bit happier by not having to deal with that crap. In 2014, I gave up income altogether, so I am no longer required to file. Before then, I guess you could call it civil disobedience.
- newman8r 8y agoWhat do you mean by giving up income? Do you have a lot of money saved up or something?
- forgotmypw 8y agoI have gradually converted to a currency-free lifestyle. I don't use money for almost anything.
- zacharycohn 8y agoYou may want to consult a tax attorney, if you haven't already...
- canadaj 8y agoI second this. Uncle Sam isn't going to just overlook 4+ years of un-filed tax returns.
- ars 8y agoIf the returns show a refund, then yes, they will.
- jonnycomputer 8y agoYou are not required to file if you earn under around $10k as an individual. That could be the case for this person.
- jonnycomputer 8y agoIn answer to the question, I would have, yes. My spouse has a business now though, so no.
- all_blue_chucks 8y agoI would rather audit the IRS than have the IRS auditing me.
- the-dude 8y agoDutch IRS does this for salary, saving accounts and mortage accounts. You start your filing prefilled. Works like a charm.
- Ftuuky 8y agoIn my country (Portugal) they do prepare my taxes and so far I can't complain. Even if something wrong happens you can file for appropriate compensation. Any payment is concluded in less than 2 weeks.
- benicafe 8y agoI'm moving to Portugal!
- djKianoosh 8y agoand it's a beautiful country on top of that! sign us up
- fimdomeio 8y agoLast year the state introduces fully automated tax filling. It's beautiful. It took me 2 minutes. On the other hand, if I remember correctly its still a java app running on the browser where you have to accept an unsigned certificate and doesn't run on my mac. :/
- Avamander 8y agoEstonia's tax system sounds like a heaven now. It took me from start to finish 2 minutes (including software installation add 1min) and can be done on Mac, Linux and Windows, with Mobile-ID (requires special SIM card) the support extends to Android, iOS.
- Karishma1234 8y agoAs a rule of thumb I would not trust IRS to do my taxes but I am happy if they send me a draft and I have to just sign or make corrections.
- jkaplowitz 8y agoIn every country I'm aware of where the government does your taxes, you have exactly that option to accept (whether explicitly or through inaction) or to correct. I don't know anywhere that forces you to accept the government's calculation without a chance to provide your own.
- Karishma1234 8y agoIn USA too you get W2 and other statements that give you all the numbers. Things only get complicated when you have several streams of income.
- kartan 8y ago> I would not trust IRS to do my taxes but I am happy if they send me a draft and I have to just sign or make corrections That is how it works in Spain and Sweden. But, in the end, the tax office will randomly select people and check their tax applications. If you did something wrong they will send a correction so you pay the difference plus an interest rate. But even then you can send allegations to justify your original tax application. Only if they reject the allegations you need to pay the difference.
- maxxxxx 8y agoThat's how it works usually.
- dsfyu404ed 8y agoWill the IRS take responsibility for the accuracy of my taxes? I'm not going to trust some 3rd party to do my taxes unless they're responsible for the accuracy of my taxes. The federal government (government in general for that matter) does not have a particularly good track record of not holding other people accountable when it screws up.
- madengr 8y agoI'd rather end all payroll deductions, then everyone must write the IRS a check N times a year. That way people know exactly what they are paying.
- dudul 8y agoInterestingly this is pretty much how it used to work in France up until this year. No deductions from your paycheck, and on year N+1 you pay your income taxes for year N. People need to be careful to set aside enough money to be able to pay these deferred taxes. However, now they are moving to payroll deductions :)
- kartan 8y agoI have paid taxes in Sweden and Spain. In both countries, I get a preliminary tax form with all my data. If I don't want to change anything I just need to go online. Click Accept. And pay with my credit card the difference between what my employer pays to the government monthly and the total, around 100$. It is very efficient. I have the feeling that apart from lobbying USA loves to hate taxes. To make paying taxes overly-complicated adds to that feeling. When you only need to pay 100$ at the end of the year after one or two clicks (or you can get a paper copy mailed to your home and pay at the bank) makes it less painful.
- cortesoft 8y agoThis is certainly true. In particular, Americans for Tax Reform (the group founded by Grover Norquist) lobbies against any attempt at making paying taxes easier for this reason. Their argument is that people should be constantly aware of how much they are paying in taxes, and making it too easy would hinder this. These groups, combined with tax preparation companies, prevent any meaningful attempt to make paying taxes easier.
- sgustard 8y agoMost people have tax withheld from their paycheck then are delighted to receive a refund the next year. I don't think that provides any meaningful awareness of how much they are really paying, any more than if the process were entirely automatic.
- eftychis 8y agoIrrational feeling people have with tax refunds. If you receive a high refund you should be crying. That is money you lost. Nobody is giving you free money. With a really pessimistic 5% return, you ended up paying $5 more per $100 of refund...
- recursive 8y agoThat's assuming you had all the money at the beginning of the year.
- ghouse 8y agoMost of the rest of the world does this. If you only have W-2 or 1099 income, the government already has all of the data necessary to complete your taxes using standard deductions. If you have other income, itemize, or have other circumstances, you can continue doing your taxes as is. It is curious that some proponents (in the US) of lowering taxes intentionally make taxes more complicated so as to make people more opposed to taxes in general.
- testvox 8y agoWhich proponents are you talking about? Usually one of the talking points on tax "reform" is that the tax code is too complicated and reform is needed to make compliance easier.
- repiret 8y agoIf by 1099 you mean 1099-MISC, which is what I think most people mean when they say "1099 income" without an additional qualifier, then the IRS almost certainly has no idea what detections are available to you, and there may be taxable things that they don't know about either.
- s73v3r_ 8y agoI'm willing that in the vast majority of cases they do, and the small minority of cases where they don't isn't a good enough reason to not do this. Especially because, if you do fall into that case, you can just file your taxes as normal.
- repiret 8y agoIf you get a 1099-MISC, you need to file Schedule C [1]. They can make a guess at line 1 based on the 1099-MISC, but none of the other lines come with a counter party filing forms with the IRS to give them hints. I agree that most people who don't need to file Schedule C, who don't have investment gains or losses outside of tax sheltered accounts, and who don't pay for childcare while they work (Form 2441), and who don't have miscellaneous deductions (which include medical expenses and unreimbursed employee expenses if they exceed 2% of your income) could have the IRS correctly fill out their taxes for them. And thats a lot of people, and the IRS should do it. But the parent comment said "If you only have W-2 or 1099 income, the government already has all of the data," and my point is that unless they mean something weird by "1099 income," then thats wrong. [1]: https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-pdf/f1040sc.pdf https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-pdf/f1040sc.pdf
- mbrumlow 8y agoYES! I WOULD! It should be they prep it, and I can verify and dispute it if I think they did it wrong.
- Nokinside 8y agoIn Finland and many other countries they already do this. They send you tax report already filled and all deductions done based on information they know. You check it for errors and correct if there is need and send it back. If you don't send it back, they just assume the default was OK.
- jedberg 8y agoI pretty sure almost everyone would agree that having the IRS fill out a return and send it to you for approval would be better (except for the Norquist zealots that think the IRS would "hide" deductions from you). Most tax filers have a single W2 income and use the standard deduction, so the IRS would just send you a form that has that. For the rest of us who actually don't use the standard deduction, at least it would help me know which forms the IRS has and what they think I owe them, so I don't forget anything, or can correct things. I've had incorrect 1099s filed against me and had no idea for years until the IRS notified me of a discrepancy. So yeah, there is no downside to the IRS doing my return and then letting me amend it.
- jandrese 8y agoSending a pre-filled form that we can append with any deductions would be the best. Hell, it could be a website. The web is great for filling in forms. I live in Virginia and about a decade ago we had an online website to fill in the state taxes. It was so easy. H&R block bought off the legislature to have it shut down and now they charge one of the highest rates in the nation to file state taxes for Virginia. The stated reason for shutting it down was to save money, because $40k was apparently too expensive to save the residents of the state millions.
- LanceH 8y agoI would settle for a list of data that they do have. I hate looking for every form and hoping it is complete and correct. I just got a surprise from last year that a 401(k) rollover was (incorrectly) filed to the IRS as a distribution. No tax form was sent to me, but the IRS knew all about it and sends me a letter saying I owe them several thousand, interest is accruing and penalties are about to start. They had this data at tax time and I could have fixed it all before filing.
- darkerside 8y ago> “If you’re a typical American and you get this packet from the I.R.S. that says, ‘Here’s what we’ve determined your liability is,’ no one is going to challenge it,” Mr. Ellis said. “People are scared, intimidated or otherwise occupied in their lives, and they’re going to just accept what the I.R.S. sends them.” Patronizing and offensive to Americans
- yxhuvud 8y agoYes. I do it every year, and taxes take roughly 10 minutes to prepare. And the majority of those is because I'm a part owner of my dads company, so I have to verify that the given numbers are correct in two forms instead of only one. Also note that companies usually prepay part of salaries as tax, so generally people only have to pay a few K, or receive a few K. Depending on how much is paid. Taxes seem complicated in USA.
- funkaster 8y agoIn Chile, the government gives you the opportunity to pre-fill all your info. You could use gov-only accounting tools and at the end of the year everything is done for you. Just one click and you get your return, this has been true for 10+ years IIRC. When I moved to the US (7 years ago) I was so overwhelmed with taxes that I decided to pay for an accountant. This year I used TurboTax and even though there's a nice "wizard" it still feels overly (and unnecessary) complex. As others have stated in comments, there's nothing special about US taxes that mandate it should be this complex, other than special interests of people wanting to make things complex for their own benefit.
- DeepYogurt 8y agoI would love to just get a bill.
- filleokus 8y agoI'm torn on this issue. On the one hand, in Sweden, taxes are extremely simple to file, and I love it for practical reasons. All work income (even from multiple part time jobs which someone said would be an issue) is declared by the employer, almost all saving/stocks/bonds/other stuff resulting in financial gains are reported by the broker/bank. I think many people don't change any of the data, almost 1 million (out of a 10 million population) just send a text message saying basically "Okay!" [0]. On the other hand, this also irks me in some way. It is good that it's so simple to file it, but at least when just texting an okay it probably hides just how much people pay in taxes. It's almost the same thing as the fact that most employers in Sweden just show the taxes they withheld from the salary, i.e not the significant payroll taxes the company had to pay (which could just as easily have been shown for/"payed" by the employee). Regardless of ones opinion on how high taxes should be, and wether one believe they get good value for their money, I think everyone ought to know roughly how much they pay. I guess this is the reason why Grover Norquist of the Norquist pledge [1] tries to stop measures like this [2]. I imagine, if there was interest, it could be done in a way that actually _raises_ the awareness of how much tax is payed/withheld from people's income. [0]: https://www.skatteverket.se/omoss/press/pressmeddelanden/2017/2017/rekordmangadeklareradedigitalt.5.5c281c7015abecc2e202d8ab.html https://www.skatteverket.se/omoss/press/pressmeddelanden/201... [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grover_Norquist#Taxpayer_Protection_Pledge https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grover_Norquist#Taxpayer_Prote... [2]: https://www.npr.org/templates/transcript/transcript.php?storyId=521132960 https://www.npr.org/templates/transcript/transcript.php?stor...
- masklinn 8y ago> I think everyone ought to know roughly how much they pay. Why do you care? More importantly, why do you want to force people if they don't give a flying fuck? > I guess this is the reason why Grover Norquist of the Norquist pledge [1] tries to stop measures like this [2]. Grover Norquist tries to stop measures like this because he absolutely hates the very concept of taxation and has made it his life's work to make taxes as painful as possible so others will as well. There is nothing benevolent to Grover Norquist, the man is an intellectual terrorist trying to make countries fail entirely.
- nielsbot 8y agoNeeds a [2015] tag!
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- excalibur 8y agoThis should probably have a (2015) in the title. I'm not getting why there's a sudden interest in this. The article is over 3 years old, and it's not even close to tax season.
- sctb 8y agoThanks, we've updated the headline.
- triplee 8y agoYes. Next question.
- digi_owl 8y agoAnd once more the supposed nation of the future shows itself to be massively stuck in the past...
- dev_dull 8y agoForget the federal government. I wish this was something states worked out. After all they collect my taxes on my behalf. I should just be able to fill out my state return and let them deal with the federal government.
- paws 8y agoIntuit's lobbying budget was $2.39 million last year [1], and H&R Block's $2.66 million [2]. Makes one wonder... [1] https://www.opensecrets.org/orgs/summary.php?id=D000026667 https://www.opensecrets.org/orgs/summary.php?id=D000026667 [2] https://www.opensecrets.org/orgs/lobby.php?id=D000022016 https://www.opensecrets.org/orgs/lobby.php?id=D000022016
- trumped 8y agoCould be great... and they could give you a few options... ie: filling with your spouse, itemized deductions, just plain and simple or you're on your own.
- s73v3r_ 8y agoThey already do. How does anyone here think they verify things? They already have all the information. It's absolute idiocy and stubbornness that causes people to think that they shouldn't be able to do that.
- avar 8y agoThe "Stanford Professor Loses Political Battle To Simplify Tax Filing Process" article[1] discussed here a year ago [2] is relevant to this topic, although in that case it concerned California state taxes. That article also answers a question many here have ("why don't they pre-fill the form like <insert EU country here>"). It's because Grover Norquist, the well known promoter of the "Taxpayer Protection Pledge" took the counterintuitive view that just making the process easier equated to a new tax, since taxpayers might end up paying taxes already on the books that they might have previously unintentionally evaded. The same applies to any such improvements in the IRS filing process. 1. https://www.npr.org/2017/03/29/521954033/stanford-professor-loses-political-battle-to-simplify-tax-filing-process https://www.npr.org/2017/03/29/521954033/stanford-professor-... 2. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13990391 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13990391
- cozzyd 8y agoI screwed up on my taxes last year (read the tax wrong off the table) and the IRS kindly noticed and gave me the $100 extra in my refund.
- buchanae 8y agoI'm an American who was lived and worked in New Zealand in Australia. I couldn't believe how easy it was to do taxes there, there was basically nothing to do.
- intopieces 8y agoI want to see a study comparing the two: Return-Free and Traditional. If return-free ends up with the government collecting more in taxes than the average traditional+Intuit fees, I would be opposed to it. I fear that people would consider whatever form the government sent them, with whatever number it had on it, the final say, resulting in the government not being accountable for the taxes they collect.
- jejones3141 8y agoIf I remember rightly, they had a phone number you could call for tax advice--probably now it's on a web site--but they wouldn't accept any responsibility if the advice proved to be wrong. Given that, no. No way would I let the IRS prepare my taxes.
- alkonaut 8y agoHere is the key: the tax code has to be such (so simple) that 50-75% of people can just quickly look at their return statement, and deduce that "yes this is right". For example: there should typically be no deductions possible. It shouldn't require any form of "trust". A person should be able to tell within minutes that it's correct. Otherwise the filing method isnt't the problem but the complexity of the tax code (for the large majority).
- hulton 8y agoThe IRS administers and enforces the income tax laws beyond the parameters of the laws passed by Congress and signed by the President as well as beyond the parameters laid down by the U.S. Supreme Court. Moreover, the IRS’s own internal procedures, manuals and literature itself indicate the IRS knowingly deceives the American public about the scope of its true income tax authority.
- bcheung 8y agoThe most time consuming part of filing taxes for me is not the actual filing or the data entry, it's the gathering of the data. Logging into a bunch of websites. Calling people trying to figure out how to get the forms. Looking through folders and old emails, etc. At a minimum if there was a secure way that we could look that up and then feed that into tax prep software I think that would save us 80% of the time.
- mesozoic 8y agoDefinitely not. It's a conflict of interest. Perhaps for persons with lower income and simple taxes it would be worthwhile but why would the IRS help me make use of all of their loopholes?
- doktrin 8y agoYes, and I'd prefer it. TurboTax, H&R and their ilk are unnecessary parasites feeding off of a diseased whale. The fact that people feel the need to utilize 3rd party solutions just to file completely run of the mill returns is a sign of a fundamental problem in the system.