15 ms·
What can defend against off-the-shelf drone weapons?
- falcolas 8y agoAnything that blocks radio control or GPS. The same things that defend against off-the-shelf radio airplane weapons - a risk that has spanned decades. A couple of dozen dollars and some foam core creates an equivalent risk (or greater, since it has a longer range due to being more efficient than multirotors).
- chrisseaton 8y ago> Anything that blocks radio control or GPS. Don't they have inertial navigation if they can't get a GPS signal, and pre-programmed routes that don't need radio control.
- nielsbot 8y agoOk, then, laser turrets.
- finaliteration 8y agoOther drones with lasers.
- KaiserPro 8y agoThey give you what direction is up, but not really where you are and how fast you are going. You need odometry for that. There are opticalflow modules that will allow you to do that, but they cost power.
- dharma1 8y agoPower draw by a SoC like Nvidia tx2 (can probably do it with a cheaper chip too) for camera based navigation without GPS is not a big issue, the motors are far more power hungry
- falcolas 8y agoPractically speaking though, a mortar would be cheaper, simpler, and more deadly. Same(ish) range, high rate of fire, designed to be anti-personnel, provides plenty of time to vacate the area after initiating a bombardment. Bringing tech into the equation doesn't add much when you're talking about a payload in the single-digit pounds region.
- falcolas 8y agoInertial navigation is possible, but the sensors are fairly low quality for anything over a couple of dozens of feet.
- chrisseaton 8y agoCan it be combined with scene reconstruction from cameras? My simple iPhone seems to extremely good at it in the AR kit.
- falcolas 8y agoAt the cost of money and payload loss (or a range reduction), absolutely. If you're willing to spend engineering hours and thousands of dollars per drone, you can absolutely have nearly fully autonomous drones that don't rely on GPS. Still, not really a new risk, however.
- Throwaway452146 8y agoThe drone with a machine gun is an ad for that years new CoD and is fake. That the article didn't acknowledge it shows they don't do their own research or are trying to mislead the reader. https://www.themarysue.com/fake-cod-quadrotor/ https://www.themarysue.com/fake-cod-quadrotor/ Edit: spelling
- LeanderK 8y agoBut I don't think they claim that it was real? "Whether reality or simply show, these examples make it clear that a good defense against drones is vital for both bodyguards and military in the field."
- walshemj 8y agoI suspect a big drone could carry a one shot recoilless weapon I suspect with modern tech you could get the weight down to say > 10Kg You can get drones that can carry over 40Lb an that's not far off a ww2 57MM M18's weight.
- mr_overalls 8y agoI find it funny that the "evil Russian" in the video is actually a gunsmith from Valdosta, Georgia.
- astebbin 8y agoThis gun-drone is real, however, and may have already been deployed in Israel: https://youtu.be/VaTW8uAo_6s https://youtu.be/VaTW8uAo_6s It carries a stripped-down AR-style carbine, and makes shots at what looks like 50-100 yards with sufficient accuracy.
- petermcneeley 8y agoThe economy does. There are no off the shelf drone weapons. To develop them would require moderately skilled professionals. Moderately skill professionals in good economies do not engage in guerrilla weapon production because they have better ways of making money without the criminal liabilities.
- KaiserPro 8y agoISIS/hamas et al says otherwise. War brings out terrifyingly brilliant innovations from the strangest of places.
- petermcneeley 8y agoTerrorism like this tends to happen in more impoverished areas of the world. And any innovation that is found in this pales in comparison to what the US military already has.
- wyattpeak 8y agoHow is that relevant? The fact that IEDs wouldn't pass muster in a proper military doesn't mean we don't need tools to deal with them. Having a better weapon doesn't stop a shitty weapon from killing you.
- petermcneeley 8y ago"Having a better weapon doesn't stop a shitty weapon from killing you." True I guess that im just making an argument about the modern west.
- erobbins 8y agoIt's true.. when was the last time the US fought "proper" army regulars? Iraq in 2003/2004? Most war these days is asymmetrical.
- KaiserPro 8y agoI don't think 1970-90s UK counts as "impoverished" the IRA/UDF did lots of innovation. Deadly destructive innovation. Making bomb timers that lasted months/years to avoid detection was no mean feat in the early 80s
- devoply 8y agoThe fact that most people value their freedom and are not looking to commit crimes. There are many many things that could be done, but if done mean essentially destroying your life. Most people don't want to destroy their lives.
- 21 8y ago? Most people don't want to destroy their lives by shooting someone with a gun, yet it happens every day.
- devoply 8y agoOkay I guess then we should do something about all them guns. Point there being that guns are readily available and this seems to be maybe slightly more dangerous in certain cases.
- 21 8y agoMy point was not about guns in particular. People use knifes for that too, or rocks, or baseball bats, and we aren't going to ban those. My point was that there are people who want to murder, and drones will be very suitable for that, and the fact that 99.99% of people don't won't really matter.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- JoeAltmaier 8y agoOne griefer with a website that offers exploding drone swarms to a given target? 'Most people' isn't everybody, and it only takes one. And the website could be anonymous (bitcoin anyone?)
- devoply 8y agoI am almost certain we have laws on the books to deal with that. The point is identifying that before they do anything.
- KaiserPro 8y agoA number of things. 1) blocking GPS. 2) Electronic noise (mostly the same as blocking GPS, but needs lots more power) 3) thin nets. (bonus points for barrage balloons) 4) shotguns 5) flak (air burst anti-air shells 6) rain Off the shelf quadcopters are fragile and not designed to cope with hostile flight. Loose a motor and your falling out of the sky. Loose a GPS track and you'll either hover, or descend. This could be hacked to rely on dead reckoning, but that's inherently inaccurate. the sensors are designed to tell you what way up you are, how fast you are deviating from desired angle, they rarely have odometers. A small > 250watt narrow band transmitter, Something with harmonics for 2.4gigs, or just a modified microwave magnetron with a decent directional antenna will destroy most hardware. A thin fishing net is thin, light, cheap and almost invisible. The hardest part is keeping it in the correct place.
- sushisource 8y agoTo the article's credit, none of these solutions address the "high up drone dropping a grenade on you in an area you can't secure beforehand" - simply because you won't know it's there until it's too late.
- mikec3010 8y agoBut that's not uniquely a drone problem. Aren't modern mortar shells wicked accurate?the trigonometry that governs them has been known for centuries.
- gruez 8y agoi can't imagine how unguided shells can be that accurate, especially if you only have one shot. trigonometry helps, but there are way too many unknowns (mainly atmospheric cconditions) for it to work perfectly.
- kevin_thibedeau 8y agoWe have guided bullets today. A guided mortar is downright trivial in comparison.
- spaecMonkey 8y agoHonestly, I think underground, subterrainian cities are quite possibly the only silver bullet answer, as a correction for some of the emerging technology we'll be forced to confront, if things get out of control with everything laid out in the open. There's this view, held by some, that with the atomic bomb, the cat's out of the bag, and the escalation of weaponry hit the ceiling in terms of organized conflict. But that there's also a non-linear side effect. The outlook of this view holds that, if we indeed smacked into the ceiling, harnessing the same natural power that fuels the sun's daily dose of daylight, well, there's a whole vacuum of optional behavior between a floor of sharpened wooden sticks or hurled rocks, and a maliciously used hydrogen bomb, and all of human creativity to imagine interesting ways to negotiate that gradient between a single hostile neolithic ape, and nuclear age, mutually assured ICBM psychosis. So maybe we got only a foot off the ground with primitive biological sabotage, or fumigated battle trenches dug into former farm fields, before we catapulted into the upper limit with the idea of multiple re-entry vehicles delivered in waves, to target thousands of cities simultaneously. And what was the idea for how to cope with all your favorite cities being instantaneously incinerated? That's right. Cave networks underneath mountain ranges. Going full dwarven on the problem. So, the bonus side effect of going full AD&D dwarf character class, is that it also models well for self contained space stations. Maybe closing the door to the biosphere, whilst certainly a tragedy of the commons it may be, possibly opens a window to outer space?
- pavel_lishin 8y ago> And what was the idea for how to cope with all your favorite cities being instantaneously incinerated? > That's right. Cave networks underneath mountain ranges. Going full dwarven on the problem. I've played Dwarf Fortress, and I know how those games typically end. I think we have enough !!FUN!! on the surface.
- a_e_k 8y agoSomething like this? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15304951 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15304951
- AnimalMuppet 8y agoBut drones can fly in your underground city, too...
- merpnderp 8y agoIn the end there's really no good way to electronically block against a drone. Someone could preposition some infrared lasers pointed along the expected flight path and the drone could use those to perfectly navigate to the target. Or a single laser that tracked the drone by scanning the sky and the drone acknowledging when the laser was pointed at it. Or I'm sure a dozen other schemes. Someone willing to spend a year tinkering could come up with a drone that is only stoppable by directly disabling it.
- wiz21c 8y agoFTA : >>> Armed groups such as the terrorist militia "Islamic State" (IS) pioneered the use of small drones rotfl... Armed groups such as colonialist US Army pioneered the use of big predator drones. ah ah ah
- walshemj 8y agoI think you mean the German V1 :-)
- wiz21c 8y agoHmmm V1 had no remote pilot, it doesn't count :-) Japan's kamikaze are closer to the real thing (it's not a remote pilot neither, but at least they came close to the enemy whatever its defense, much like a drone) :-)
- nyolfen 8y agothe US had crewless bombers piloted via television for suicide runs in germany: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Aphrodite https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Aphrodite they were ineffective, though regarding your original comment: the topic at hand is weaponized commercial drones, things that can be assembled by semi-skilled enthusiasts. predators cost millions of dollars per and use satellite coms and guided munitions. isis uses off the shelf quadcopters with mortar shells. the latter is essentially the 3d printed gun of assassination tools -- there may have been forebears, but it's the accessibility and ease of deployment that is important and alarming.
- walshemj 8y agoIt was autonomously controlled to run on a set path and to dive when I thought it had reached the target. drones don't have to have a human controller.
- blhack 8y agoNothing.
- mjevans 8y agoActual security by design. Hold events with high-value targets //indoors// with no open roofed areas near by. This might mean throwing a net over the inner alcove or erecting a temporary tent to block the outside facing windows.
- 1001101 8y agoDirected energy with automated tracking.
- facing_worlds 8y agoAlso probably the same machines that are installed for crowd control already a lot of military installations (microwave emitters) can do this already.
- protomyth 8y agoI would imagine that defensive sensor drones would be the first priority. You really need to detect enemy drones and having a swarm of sensor drones able to follow potential targets would be really good. Radar and microphones are going to be interesting when applied to drone detection. Once the target is detected, a rather large cheap swarm deployed on the attack vector to block projectiles and intercept the enemy drone would probably make the most sense. The drones can absorb the hits and blow up when they reach their targets. ECM-based solutions do seem to have problems with also taking out the good guys equipment and capabilities.
- DenisM 8y agoOther drones, obviously. Whoever has more money to purchase and deploy drones wins. Same as it's always been.
- junke 8y agoNULL pointers
- lazyjones 8y agoMany will not like this, but: off-the-shelf shotguns in the hands of competent shooters, among other things.
- Ibethewalrus 8y agoCheck: Tom the dancing bug - Goodguy with a Gun
- hinkley 8y agoI make a kidding-not-kidding joke about skill with bolas making a resurgence as a counter to drone harassment.
- CraigJPerry 8y agoExplosives are heavy. Are drones a realistic delivery vehicle?
- coolspot 8y agoNot for anti-tank, but they have enough power to lift a hand grenade and throw it onto personnel or if very lucky into open hatch of a tank [1]. [1] - https://www.reddit.com/r/CombatFootage/search?q=drone%20grenade&restrict_sr=1 https://www.reddit.com/r/CombatFootage/search?q=drone%20gren...
- ThrustVectoring 8y agoThe US military's current hand grenade - the M67 - weighs 400 grams, has a kill radius of 5 meters, and a casualty radius of 15 meters. The DJI Inspire 2, chosen at random, can carry 790 grams. Yes. It doesn't take that much explosive to kill someone.
- dogma1138 8y agoIt can likely carry nearly 3-4 times that but you’ll burn out your engines, but on a short one way trip that is not a concern. A claymore mine can be fitted to the bottom of most drones it’s much more effective and it’s electrically triggered.
- 13415 8y agoA tactical nuke that emits a strong EMP.
- subcosmos 8y agoUnderkill
- ebcode 8y agoSince nobody's mentioned them yet: Net guns. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Net_gun https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Net_gun
- gbuk2013 8y agoSomething like this: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Krasukha_(electronic_warfare_system) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Krasukha_(electronic_warfare... and something like this: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pantsir_missile_system https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pantsir_missile_system (Not familiar with the western equivalents but the idea is the same.) A small drone does not have the ability to carry the shielding required to protect itself from interference, which can include jamming GPS and even taking over controls of the drone to capture it. A larger drone is easy target for AA systems.
- gandhium 8y agoThose failed to protect Russian base in Syria even against low-quality homemade drones.
- gbuk2013 8y agoThey have not failed - not sure where you get your information from. Maybe you are confusing with the mortar attack earlier this year? From earlier this year with pictures: https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/middle-east/russia-military-bases-drones-syria-armed-attacks-tartus-uavs-latakia-a8151066.html https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/middle-east/russia-... There were several attacks repelled in the last month also but I only have Russian language sources (maybe South Front will have some more details in English - coverage of Syria in Western media has been pretty sparse in the last months with all the government successes in Daraa).
- stcredzero 8y agoI think there's a dangerous combination represented by the FPS Russia video with the drone-mounted gun. But instead of going for automatic fire, mount something like a TrackingPoint computerized rifle instead. This combination could be made even more dangerous by emphasizing low noise and observability, perhaps by using ducted propellers and fixed wings. If such a drone were inaudbile from 3000 feet, it could amount to an undetectable assassination machine, requiring rich and powerful people to have a 24/7 team of anti-drone specialists. https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2013/01/17000-linux-powered-rifle-brings-auto-aim-to-the-real-world/ https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2013/01/17000-linux-powered-... EDIT: Before you accuse me of making up fantasy weapons, you'd best read the above link, and the one below. Computer aimed firearms that perform at "sniper in a box" levels actually do exist. https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2015/01/trackingpoint-shows-off-the-mile-maker-a-smart-rifle-with-1800-yard-range/ https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2015/01/trackingpoint-shows-...
- bjt2n3904 8y ago... Quick question. Have you ever shot a gun in real life, or developed an electromechanical system more complicated than an RC car? Because what you just described is a fantasy. What you described would be a perfect invention for Dr. Doofenshmirtz, or perhaps Wile E. Coyote. Inordinate amount of R&D effort, still doesn't work on the big day. The only thing it does is terrify people into making stupid legislation. Source: competed in several long range rifle matches, designed autonomous electromechanical systems
- 3pt14159 8y agoYeah, aiming isn't easy. Dropping explosives is though.
- stcredzero 8y agoTrue, but putting a bullet in one person is less likely to provoke a certain level of response. Drone bomb attacks are getting a bit too close to full warfare. A big enough drone-bomb is basically a cut-rate, very short-ranged cruise missile.
- memnips 8y agoSerious question: why is it hard to make small, anti-drone missiles? I assume it needs to only be within X distance of target and detonate to disable a drone.
- ceejayoz 8y agoAutomated missiles at every public building, gathering, and billionaire's motorcade? What could possibly go wrong?
- geggam 8y agoShotgun with birdshot.
- 0xdeadbeefbabe 8y agoMore off the shelf drones? Seriously.
- nimbius 8y agos/drone/guerilla tactics/ and the answer, speaking as a veteran, is nothing. I expect to get downvoted for this, but after a tour in Iraq I firmly believe theres no weapon or countermeasure thats going to be unilaterally effective at arresting the concept of guerilla warfare and terrorism except negotiation. Otherwise, you end up dividing your city into red and green zones, and pretty soon even if a terrorist attack hasnt happened in a few months, terrorism is pretty successful in making peoples lives outright miserable. smoking kills more americans than terrorism in 2017, but we still have to take our shoes off at the airport. People just want equality, some measure of freedom, liberty, and prosperity. Show up with tanks, rig an election in favor of your candidate, and disenfranchise an entire segment of the population like we did in Iraq, and you will find people will adopt all sorts of creative and clever methods to not only sabotage your mission, but actively eliminate your high value targets youve come to rely upon for 'nation building' or whatever geopolitical pursuit du-jour is popular. In Iraq, we called it "winning hearts and minds." doing things to fix problems like providing clean water or just a few meals made incredible progress in crushing the enemies ability to recruit anyone more sophisticated than an angry goat herder. And he quit being angry once we fixed the sidewalk to the mosque. In maduros case, he is reviled by a sizeable majority of his population. he openly ignores major problems like starvation, he engages his people with violent tactics, and he disregards basic human rights and living conditions. Nothing, no technology on this earth, will keep you safe if your people turn on you. There is no police or military force that can endure sustained guerilla terrorist tactics indefinitely. Not even the US Military.
- xenadu02 8y agoThis is the correct answer. What can defend against someone who is resourceful, determined, and has an axe to grind? Not much. Anyone remember Killdozer?
- dsfyu404ed 8y ago>Anyone remember Killdozer? Go over to ar-15.com or some prepper forums and everyone will know exactly who you're talking about, here probably not so much. This crowd doesn't tend to idolize that kind of thing.
- FollowSteph3 8y agoThe answers I read here are classic over engineering. Sometimes the simplest answer is the best answer, and you don't need to build a complex system. That is to say the same methods that are used to defend against a gun, either another gun to disarm the assailant (be it a person or drone) body armour. Killing the GPS, etc. are all good methods too, don't get me wrong, it's just that they may be more Factory.getFactory().getFactory().getInstance()... type of solutions. Initially just the same methods should work.
- staunch 8y agoThe answer is obvious: anti-drone drones. Military units and major political figures will need to have swarms of anti-drone drones patrolling their vicinity. Things like auto-targeting lasers might work too, but the way the way to fight technology is with better technology.
- itronitron 8y agoconcealing your location is probably the best defense
- exabrial 8y agoActually, simple off-the-shelf weapons are extremely effective against drones. A 12ga loaded with #9 pellets can easily defeat any off-the-shelf drone. And to boot, the pellets fall harmlessly back to the Earth if fired into the air.
- astebbin 8y agoI imagine a scaled-down version of the U.S. Army’s C-RAM, or Israel’s Trophy system, could work quite well for VIPs. Some drones can be VERY fast (think hobby-sized jet engine fast), so you’d need active radar and full automation to stand any kind of a chance. Perhaps you’d use shotgun shells loaded with rock salt, so any overshoot into a crowd would be less-than-lethal.
- Dowwie 8y agoIf you haven't read Daniel Suarez's science fiction novel "Kill Decision", now is the time
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- GreenToad5 8y agoWhen we are talking about one-off drone attacks, sure there are counter-measures. if we are talking about WW3 and China's capability to produce millions of autonomous, AI driven drones per day? No, there is no effective counter measure.