3 ms·
The LDC D language compiler can now generate WebAssembly
- CyberShadow 8y agoCool, great that you can now do this with LDC directly. There was a way to compile D to WASM before (using the dscripten package), however that was more akin to a collection of loose pieces strung together. As with Go, a big obstacle for running typical D code in browsers is reliance on a garbage collector, which requires scanning stacks and temporaries for reachable heap object. Though it's possible to overcome in theory with just compiler support, garbage collection in WASM itself seems to be an ongoing discussion.
- kodablah 8y ago> There was a way to compile D to WASM before (using the dscripten package), however that was more akin to a collection of loose pieces strung together. Also carried the large Emcripten runtime. Sure it gives you a lot of things like posix impls, but the unknown triple is very lightweight (at the cost of sys/OS abstractions of course).
- Ace17 8y ago> Also carried the large Emcripten runtime. Sure it gives you a lot of things like posix impls And also, SDL2 + opengl bindings. Which makes it very adapted to compiling the same project for both targets: native and web. For video games, this is a killer feature (e.g try the game in your browser, and if you like it, download the native app (smoother, less input latency)).
- jokoon 8y agoPlease no, leave that to js. Why can't they just let devs embed their own garbage collector? Isn't he role of an assembly language to let the developer do stuff at a low level?
- ben-schaaf 8y agoI'd wager there's a lot of lower level optimisations - especially for different architectures - that you just can't get with platform agnostic 'assembly'. I also think its better for everyone if you don't need to load/download, decode, compile and run a full language runtime on every page load. Imagine a JVM running on web assembly: Every page load first has to decode and compile a full many-MB JVM, then the JVM can start booting - without any platform/architecture specific optimizations. The more stuff that's common for webasm-targeting-languages that we can move into the browser, the less effort wasted overall.
- megaman22 8y agoSomebody wake me up when we move beyond reimplementing Java applets and Flash once more. We had nice batteries-included VMs in the browser, and we turned our backs on them and went back to square one. Again, and again, and again. So we could bang rocks together with javascript. Almost makes me wish VBScript IE had won. We might be writing browser apps in .NET now...
- kodablah 8y agoOne might be seen as sleeping back then too if they considered proprietary, complicated, insecure behemoths with large, sometimes shitty standard libraries and forced high-level constructs as "nice batteries-included VMs".
- crooked-v 8y ago> sometimes shitty I still have to do .stream() and .toList() (or .collect(Collectors.toList())) back and forth in Java all the time just to get reliable access to map/filter lambdas while still having a valid return value.
- megaman22 8y agoJava's shittiness is a problem, but for the mid 2000s, it wasn't extra shitty in comparison. That long stagnation after 1.6 really hurt.
- Ace17 8y ago> There was a way to compile D to WASM before (using the dscripten package), however that was more akin to a collection of loose pieces strung together. Indeed :-) The toolchain building scripts were a maintainance nightmare ; I'll be happy to drastically simplify them, especially if it means I can now use the vanilla LDC compiler (instead of having to integrate fastcomp and clang-fastcomp (Emscripten's forks of llvm and clang, respectively)).
- Tim_cas 8y agoThis is great news!
- Ace17 8y agoThe title is misleading : only a small subset (-betterC) of the D langage currently is supported, and that's too bad!
- giancarlostoro 8y agoIt's a start and ideally eventually all of D will be able to run under -betterC or just enough of it at least is what I understand is the goal.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- amelius 8y agoYeah, I'd like to see some examples of passing anything other than doubles, for example Arrays, and I'd like to know how GC works after the Array has been passed, and if the Array is passed by reference (instead of being copied), and things like that.
- earenndil 8y agoThis was already technically possible by compiling to llvm bitcode and then using emscripten to compile that to wasm (or asm.js). Still cool though!