10 ms·
Microsoft Urges Congress to Regulate Use of Facial Recognition
- ihsw2 8y agoHow does one reconcile this with jaded cynicism of "regulations for thee but not for me"? Furthermore, does this regulation target the hardware products themselves, the software performing the recognition, the biometric data itself, the transfer of this biometric data, aggregate ("anonymized") biometric data, the processing of biometric data? There is a lot to talk about here.
- mattnewton 8y agoI’m fine with Microsoft’s motives being hurting rivals with regulation, if it gives me more privacy rights. In fact that’s great, because their coffers are much larger than the eff or whoever else could take up this lobbying effort.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- craftyguy 8y ago> if it gives me more privacy rights Meanwhile, microsoft still defaults to collecting/retaining telemetry information from users of their software.
- gaius 8y agoMicrosoft has to play these games because Google and Facebook do. But if it disappeared overnight MS would still be in business... and they would not.
- bradford 8y ago<disclaimer, MS employee> I'd like to point out that MS adheres to GDPR regulations and has applied those protections to all users. https://www.techrepublic.com/article/microsoft-extending-gdpr-protections-to-all-global-customers-heres-how/ https://www.techrepublic.com/article/microsoft-extending-gdp...
- chopin 8y agoI'd like this to be verifiable. For Windows 10 telemetry it is certainly not.
- craftyguy 8y agoOK? But it still defaults to 'collect all the things': > But users now have access to a privacy dashboard that allows you to easily regulate or opt out of any data collection. How about microsoft does not collect user data by default and lets them opt in?
- zeusk 8y ago> > But users now have access to a privacy dashboard that allows you to easily regulate or opt out of any data collection. > How about microsoft does not collect user data by default and lets them opt in? A) Not all users are technical enough to understand how telemetry helps developers find faults and better understand crashes/bug reports. B) "Most" users don't care if data is collected about the software and not the data they put in that software. C) If you work in tech, I'm sure you know how many people pick options other than default.
- zeusk 8y agoThere is a big difference between collecting telemetry (data about the product you're using) for improving the product internally and collecting private data for reselling to the highest bidder.
- rconti 8y agoHere's the thing; Microsoft is a large corporation with lots of assets to protect. This kind of sketchy technology can easily be (is already?) a race to the bottom in terms of privacy and morality, and a big company has more to lose. Incidentally, big companies also have economies of scale in complying with regulation. So they can be all for facial recognition tech AND benefit from the regulation of it.
- dsfyu404ed 8y agoThe problem isn't the recognition, it's the data retention... You can recognize me all you want as long as you get rid of the data and metadata when the my interaction with your system is over. Edit: I'm not saying it's even possible to have facial recognition be useful without lots of data retention, just that retention and potential for bad things as a result of these sorts of data sets existing is the problem, not the act of recognition itself.
- s3r3nity 8y agoI'm not sure I understand your comment. How would you _not_ retain data/metadata information about recognition and still provide any utility? Wouldn't the analogy be like Facebook identifying your face in photos, but not retaining the fact that you're in the photo?
- ajmurmann 8y agoIt depends on the use case. Example: I walk through the airport and an application scans my face and either calls security because I was recognized as a known terrorist or let's me pass because I'm awesome. The parent's point matters for what happens after. In the not a terrorist case the problematic system would retain that (it thinks) you walked through the airport. In a even more problematic system you now get ads because you were there.
- s3r3nity 8y agoWait - wouldn't you _want_ the system to retain that information in your first case if you were mis-identified as a terrorist? I.e. you were recognized, but you were confirmed not a terrorist - so you won't be flagged later. Or maybe I misunderstood. Otherwise, you run the risk of not updating the model to fix the false positive, and you might be flagged multiple times in the future.
- ajmurmann 8y agoI wouldn't want the system to keep information about me having been anywhere unless I'm a criminal. How would that information be helpful in updating the model. It already worked correctly.
- bsenftner 8y agoHa! They must be aware they can't keep up with FR advancements, so they are turning to regulations to stifle innovation. Plus pointing the finger at FR and data retention conveniently moves attention off all the analytics their OS captures and retains for Microsoft.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- gaius 8y agoI guess you have never seen what their Face API is capable of. They’re as good as anyone in this game.
- bsenftner 8y agoI guess you don't know, their solution is weak.
- s3r3nity 8y agoDamned if they do - damned if they don't? If they supported its use: "Microsoft is back to its old ways and is untrustworthy." When they do something pro-consumer & pro-privacy: "Microsoft can't innovate in the marketplace and needs to stifle innovation." (Yes, I know it's a straw-man argument, but it's more to point out the general hypocrisy of such a comment.)
- huntie 8y agoCorporations are amoral. All of their actions are self-serving and should be viewed as such. While a particular action (such as this one) may be good for consumers, this is merely a side effect and not the intention.
- s3r3nity 8y agoI agree with your premises, but there's no reason to think that an action can't be pro-consumer + pro-ecosystem + pro-company all at the same time.
- madrox 8y agoHaving worked at a large company that cares a great deal about COPPA, I've seen how regulation really can work for consumer benefit. I'm not sure if people appreciate how much COPPA cleaned up in child privacy. However, it's definitely hurt the bottom lines of small businesses that liked playing fast and loose with data. The sudden commodification of facial recognition means most of the companies racing to fill business needs are startups. Large corporations like Microsoft are much better positioned to deal with industry regulation. This may be a self-interested, anti-competitive move on Microsoft's part, but I don't care as long as I benefit as a consumer, too.
- econochoice 8y agoAgreed. Rare instance of corporate and personal interests aligning and what not.
- alkonaut 8y agoAgree. And anyone who sees a business opportunity in a shady area where basically “regulation hasn’t kept up with tech” just deserves to have the rug pulled from underneath by regulators. The message to the next company should be “if it seems shady, it’s probably not worth trying”.
- maxsilver 8y ago> I've seen how regulation really can work for consumer benefit. I'm not sure if people appreciate how much COPPA cleaned up in child privacy Yes absolutely! Similarly, HIPAA has been incredibly useful in forcing hospitals and other for-profit companies to at least kind of care about medical data security. It's not perfect, but without HIPAA that data privacy/security would be in a far worse state.
- vonnik 8y agoMore regulation will benefit companies like Microsoft and lead to less innovation, because of the legal hurdles startups would need to clear. Much in the same way that the primary beneficiary of GDPR has been Google, because advertisers trust that its scale makes it more likelihood to be compliant with the new laws. But facial recognition has a lot of applications that aren't creepy, ranging from fun (fake mustache on Snap) to useful. Facial identification might be a better target for regulation, but getting the government involved here is inviting a bulldozer to the rose garden.
- bargl 8y agoThere are two technologies at play here. Face Recognition (who you are). Face Detection (where the face is in frame). There really is nothing bad about Face Detection. That would have to be paired with other data in order to uniquely identify a person. But Face Recognition can give exactly who you are which should probably get regulated. We have a lot of protection for identification of people out there I don't think this should be an exception. Although educating congress is going to be a VERY tough job.
- pasbesoin 8y agoPrivate people can be accused of stalking. If corporations are "people"... Seriously. I don't want to live in a world where I am "stalked" by billion dollar "people" who decide whether I get insurance, and at what price, and who can search "big data" for any and every possible "infraction", also retroactively, at their "discretion". And who turn around and rat me out to whatever authorities, who are not permitted to directly collect such data but who are free to take it -- or purchase it, using my tax dollars -- from such third parties. Two years ago, I helped a casual friend with a prior felony drug conviction, to get and stay sober. Now, Facebook et al. put me in that felon's "graph", and what happens to me? For example, am I -- by computed association -- an insurance risk? One simple example, of how you can't have a functioning society in the face of such ueber-monitoring. They will destroy what they are ostensibly trying to "shore up". Society works, in good part, because people are free agents. Ironically, the same message these bozos try to convey during election season. And the one they use to rail against "big government". Well, big (private) surveillance is no different. Worse, even, because it's becoming apparent that people have little or no say in whether and how it's done. Not even a vote during elections, with which to influence policy. Politicians have, to a significant extent, externalized the political cost of what they -- contrary to their rhetoric and also in the name of their big business buddies -- are pursuing.
- reaperducer 8y agoFacebook et al. put me in that felon's "graph", and what happens to me? For example, am I -- by computed association -- an insurance risk? It's coming. Just wait. But just because one insurance company was stopped, doesn't mean others have been, or will be. https://www.theguardian.com/money/2016/nov/02/facebook-admiral-car-insurance-privacy-data https://www.theguardian.com/money/2016/nov/02/facebook-admir...
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- chapium 8y ago>>Seriously. I don't want to live in a world where I am "stalked" by billion dollar "people" who decide whether I get insurance, and at what price, and who can search "big data" for any and every possible "infraction", also retroactively, at their "discretion". If this can be automated passively and cheaply, its an inevitable outcome; regulation or not.
- exabrial 8y agoWhy? The people we don't want to use it (NSA, FBI, local police) are going to do it anyway.
- saagarjha 8y agoBecause there are companies that use facial recognition data that will be bound by these rules.
- econochoice 8y agoIt sets precedent. If you're concerned about government actors, that will make it harder for less shrewd prosecutors to enter evidence tainted by the unlawful use of facial recognition.
- andrestan 8y agoAre those really the people you fear the most?
- jMyles 8y agoPeople with a great deal of political power who are heavily armed and nearly no public or civil accountability? Yes, it's reasonable to fear people in such a position. History and common sense are both instructive on their likely actions.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- jMyles 8y agoThis is really the crux of the matter. Any "regulation" is just meant to divide-and-conquer, while the actual bad actors do whatever they please. Moreover, I surmise that the "regulation" will rarely be invoked to protect vulnerable populations. However, I can certainly imagine an app that recognizes and faces of police officers and / or agent provocateurs and catalogs their presence at scenes of illegal activity might well be "regulated" out of existence.
- mtgx 8y agoWhy not support a law like GDPR instead? Why does every market needs its own special regulations? Is there going to be a separate law for voice recognition, too? And I could go on.
- kevingadd 8y agoThere's no way anything resembling GDPR would pass in the United States, at least not in the next decade. Targeted regulations seem more likely to be feasible because they will be smaller and easier to get through negotiations and approved by the US House and Senate. (Not that I think even this sort of regulation would be easy with how things are right now) Laws the size of GDPR in scope often take more than a decade here to pass - the ACA is a good example, and even after it passed there are still people fighting over whether it's valid and how it should be enforced, while other people are actively trying to repeal it. If we tried to handle something like facial recognition that way, the law would be useless because by the time it made it through the process and got put into effect the harm would already have been done.
- mleland 8y agoAre they really only taking this stand because Amazon is looking to get a government contract for its Rekognition software, and Microsoft is trying to deter that?
- blihp 8y agoMost likely. You'll rarely see a corporation encourage the government to do anything unless it helps them or hurts their competition.
- ohthehugemanate 8y agoI don't think it's SPECIFICALLY the rekognition contract, but that is the broad stroke. Microsoft has a strong ethics review process for all things AI, and routinely turns down fat projects because they don't pass ethical muster. The contracts that rekognition is designed to bid for, are largely in the grey zone where MS would turn a lot of things down. Government regulation would help lower the cost of Microsoft's ethics policy.
- sargun 8y agoAccording to who / what?
- hirsin 8y agoFernando Diaz, for one, has mentioned passing up projects. Principal on the MSFT AI Ethics group (FATE)
- glitchdout 8y agoI didn't find anything on Microsoft turning down projects due to ethical issues. However, I found a podcast with Fernando Diaz talking about the ethical problems of using AI and experimenting with users without their knowledge, which is commendable.
- bufferoverflow 8y agoI don't understand why people expect privacy in public. Either when it comes making public comments or walking on a random street. Literally anyone can take a photo or a video of you, it's completely legal. Expectation of privacy is quite establish in law: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Expectation_of_privacy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Expectation_of_privacy
- adamnemecek 8y agoAnyone being able to take the photo and you being recorded all the time are two really different thing.
- bufferoverflow 8y agoYou realize a video recording is just a series of photos? How can you allow one and not allow the other? How are you going to write that law? No more video recording outside? A 30 minute limit? No more documentaries?
- throwaway2048 8y agoDid you know everything on earth is made of atoms, killing people is just shifting some atoms around whats the big deal.
- iamdave 8y agoAre you deliberately ignoring the "all the time" part of the comment you're replying to? This is the entire fulcrum that their point resides on.
- craigsmansion 8y agoYou realise stalking is just a series of semi-continuous short encounters? A different (larger) amount of a same thing can have different properties, some of which might not be desirable. That's how one can allow one thing and not the other, because the effect is different, even though it can be argued that it's technically the same.
- 8y ago
- CNJ7654 8y agoWhy contain it?
- sqdbps 8y agoMost likely they just want a federal law to deal with instead of having to make unworkable carve-ups for illinois and texas. This unsurprisingly provided an ideal preamble for the NYT to try and reinforce the unsubstantiated claim that tech firms swayed the election and salivate about how this might open the door to further regulation. To keep things overboard newspapers should provide a disclaimer that they are reporting on business rivals when they write about tech firms.
- crb002 8y agoI don't see how they can under the 1St Ammendment; not to mention Microsoft wants to kill off facial recognition startups with government red tape.
- mindslight 8y agoTotally blocked out the Black person in the example scene. Classy! Even disregarding the obvious concerns of totalitarianism, polite society is going to require some accountability lest random developers' lame [0] biases turn into universally baked-in ones. [0] Or simply expedient. As in, the recognition probably performed poorly on a darker face, so he was cut. But that won't stop the sales guy from promising that the implementation is ready...
- dendisuhubdy 8y agono
- dang 8y agoWould you please stop posting unsubstantive comments to Hacker News?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- 0xBA5ED 8y agoMaybe this is more of a PR move than an ethics one, considering the growing sentiment against tech giants. Facebook has developed an image of quietly doing their deeds for a long period of time, then "getting caught red-handed" all of a sudden and dragged through the media. Maybe it's about getting ahead of the curve in this regard because they believe up and coming tech will continue to deepen privacy concerns rather than plateau any time soon. Of course, it's reasonable to assume the stakes will continue to rise with the power and reach of technology, so it's a good idea to publicly appear concerned long before the SHTF. It also passes off some of the responsibility to the government for whatever disaster they think could happen.
- cinquemb 8y agoLaws and regulation are only local maxima on the capabilities of technology and how they will be applied. Consumer protection from this stuff is a joke in the age where GDPR skinner boxes give people feelings of warm fuzzies when continuing to download crApps on to their platforms to suck up everything passively and with users active engagement, to backends that are ever more becoming open to the public for consumption (due to the lack of corporate accountability on such downsides). Combine that with increasingly cheaper storage costs, and more people becoming knowledgeable of the tools… yeah if one is banking on MSFT and its current behemoth brethren forever maintaining an advantage… Kings of years past wanted to regulate the use of the printing press, and were modestly successful at first, though only in time most people realized that such diktats were futile.