13 ms·
As someone who was eating insects long before cricket protein bars became in vogue, I don't see entomophagy becoming anything more than a fad in the west, espec
by ravenstine 8y ago
As someone who was eating insects long before cricket protein bars became in vogue, I don't see entomophagy becoming anything more than a fad in the west, especially America.
The taste of insects simply does not compare to meat and poultry. Granted, this has a lot to do with cultural expectations, but that's exactly why I don't think that people are going to gradually shift to consuming a very different flavor.
Also, as someone who used to be heavily into protein, I don't buy the notion that people need more protein than what they are currently getting. A human body really doesn't need that much protein, and even body builders don't need as much protein as they often consume. If someone is telling you that you need to consume protein, it's probably because they're trying to sell you something. Even more so if they are calling it a "super-food".
Maybe things will actually change. I dunno. The insects that I thought were the most tasty(moth caterpillars) are the ones that people are least likely to want to eat. People might be fine with dried crickets and meal worms, but I challenge them to eat something more substantial.
Every "bug person" I used to follow on social media warns us of a looming food crisis and that insects will save the world. I thought it no coincidence that most of them either give paid lectures, sell books, or are associated with a "bug startup".
- tomcam 8y agoI agree with your assessments about entomophagy. However, I think it no coincidence that most of the “tech people“ on this blog either give paid lectures, sell books, or are associated with a “tech startup”.
- adventured 8y ago> most of the “tech people“ on this blog either give paid lectures, sell books, or are associated with a “tech startup” That's false, you're vastly under-estimating the size of HN. There are tens of thousands of users and millions of HN readers. Dang noted three years ago that there were 300k daily uniques and ~3m monthly uniques. A small fraction of those give paid lectures, author/sell books, or are associated with a start-up. Most is an extreme exaggeration. It's closer to 1%-5% than 51%.
- tomcam 8y agoYour precision is noted. I was indulging in a bit of satire.
- MrBuddyCasino 8y agoThe whole idea of directly eating insects is stupid. They can be fed to animals we normally eat (e.g. fish). The advantage is that insects can process stuff that we would otherwise throw away, and are very efficient.
- swolchok 8y agoI don't think that your conclusion follows from your argument. You could say the same thing about directly eating vegetables -- they can be fed to animals we normally eat (e.g., cattle). More directly to your point, isn't there significant energy inefficiency from eating higher on the food chain?
- acomjean 8y agoIt’s less efficient higher up the food chain. I think the point being made is a grasshopper, goats or cows can digest plants a human could never and get sustenance out of. They have different food processing stomachs
- privacypoller 8y agoI agree with your points - each step of processing feed material leaks some of the efficiencies gained by harvesting at lower levels. Generally the benefits from chaining production come from the lower level consuming the waste products of the higher level, like fertilizing aquatic plants with fish waste. Where insects could make a big difference is replacing more expensive or less effective inputs into higher-level products, ideally commodities. For example, if we could produce breads using crickets that have higher caloric densities for the same price that would be a huge global win. We're not there yet though.
- adrianN 8y agoEvery step up on the food chain loses roughly 90% of the energy.
- tomcam 8y agoI do not understand how the first sentence was supported by the next two sentences. Hundreds of millions of people eat insects daily, and it seems way more efficient than using them as an intermediary food source.
- maxxxxx 8y ago"Also, as someone who used to be heavily into protein, I don't buy the notion that people need more protein than what they are currently getting. A human body really doesn't need that much protein, and even body builders don't need as much protein as they often consume. If someone is telling you that you need to consume protein, it's probably because they're trying to sell you something. Even more so if they are calling it a "super-food"." Totally agree. Most people need more exercise, not more protein. Maybe once they exercise 6x a week for 2 hours we should think about getting more protein.
- arghwhat 8y agoWait, are there people out there that consume absurd amounts of protein for "health" reasons without doing any exercise? Do they seriously think they have a protein deficiency?
- maxxxxx 8y agoYes! I have seen this a lot in the US. Some overweight guy/gal will proclaim "I need some protein right now" (no idea on what this determination is based on) or ask me (vegetarian) "where do you get your protein?".
- ravenstine 8y agoI've seen cereal boxes that say "good source of protein", and I feel like the sports bars section has a new brand of protein cookie or brownie every time I walk by it. Like yeah, you'll get diabeetus, but you'll have your protein!
- linkmotif 8y ago> I don't think that people are going to gradually shift to consuming a very different flavor. How do they taste?
- Semirhage 8y agoMusty, and the bigger ones taste like what they eat. Grasshoppers have a strong chlorophyll flavor, and not in a good way. Personally if I need protein, I’d rather eat beans and lentils if I’m avoiding meat and fish. Bugs are never going to be cheaper or more efficient than lentils!
- forkLding 8y agoMost of them are relatively tasteless and people season them with lots of chili, salt and pepper, its the texture and gooey insides that turns people off. I've had cicadas, scorpions and silk worms along with the normal crickets etc.
- jodrellblank 8y agoits the texture and gooey insides that turns people off and the intestines full of insect shit, bluntly.
- ravenstine 8y agoThat's a common perception, although usually insects are supposed to be "purged" for a day or two to clear their intestines. In the case of caterpillars, they can be easily eviscerated(although it's a disgusting process).
- ravenstine 8y agoNot like a whole lot, usually. :) In my experience, the taste ranges between earthy, nutty, and sometimes "crustaceany". Even when they hit some of the better flavors(according to my cultural background), they're nothing to write home about. It's really things like grubs and caterpillars that have the protein, the fats, and the flavor. The sphinx moth caterpillar tacos I've made were easily comparable to shrimp tacos, and were some of the best tacos I've ever eaten. (I did this as a sort of personal study as I never hear of people eating them today but apparently they were a staple of some native peoples.) Good luck getting people to eat wiggly, squirmy things, though.
- Asooka 8y agoI would actually be OK with something like a sausage that's 40% pig, 60% crickets, if it's possible. I also wouldn't mind if half of my McDonalds burger was made of crickets. A reduction in demand for meat might also have the positive effect of enabling the production of higher-quality meat from better-cared-for livestock.
- tomcam 8y agoThat's pretty brilliant.
- onemoresoop 8y agoWhy bother with 40% pig? Why not replace it with 40% plant based fibers?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- RandallBrown 8y agoProbably so it still tastes good.
- jonknee 8y agoThen you probably don't want crickets which aren't known for their tasty flavor or sausage like texture.
- YokoZar 8y agoIf you're willing to dilute pork you can also use a much more flavorful and fatty cut than you would otherwise.
- losvedir 8y agoFor the past few months Sonic had offered their "Signature Slinger" burger whose patty was a 60% beef and 40% mushroom blend. My wife and I adored it, but sadly they pulled it from the menu just recently.
- komali2 8y agoOptimum adaptation for weight lifters is 1.3 - 1.8g for each kg of bodyweight. So, a 180lb person that weightlifts should eat ~144g protein. But, you can do better >Elevated protein consumption, as high as 1.8-2.0 g · kg(-1) · day(-1) depending on the caloric deficit, may be advantageous in preventing lean mass losses during periods of energy restriction to promote fat loss. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/22150425 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/22150425 The ".8g per pound of bodyweight" rule is pretty solid.
- vidarh 8y agoIt makes a difference, but the difference is small enough that unless you're a serious lifter (or on a really drastic diet) you won't get anywhere near noticing it. It matters for a serious lifter because the year over year improvements once you're past your "newbie gains" are so low that every tiny little advantage you can get matters if you care about maximising your lifts. But we're talking about maybe the top 5% of gym goers, and a much smaller proportion of people in general.
- skellera 8y agoI'm not sure if there are numbers but it seems a lot of people I know have very carb rich diets. It would probably be good for them to switch some of that out for protein.
- gm-conspiracy 8y ago...and fat. I switched out my morning half-and-half in my coffee w/ one tbsp of organic unsalted butter and one tbsp of coconut oil. It has helped me lose body fat and curbed my appetite.
- lovich 8y agoYou put butter in coffee?
- gm-conspiracy 8y agoYes. Initially, I thought it would be gross, but it actually tastes good, and I tend to drink less because the caffeine seems more powerful.
- nradov 8y agoYou can't prove that your change in coffee additives was what caused a loss of body fat or reduction in appetite. It could have been caused by other factors and there was no experimental control.
- robbrit 8y agoThis is not really a good idea, especially if they are getting enough protein in their diets already (about 0.8g per kg of bodyweight) which most people have no problem getting. Eating too much protein-rich food increases the risk of excessive uric acid build-up and can lead to all sorts of fun problems like gout and kidney stress. Despite what fad diets say, carbs are not bad for you. You will gain weight if you eat too many carbs, but that is the same for too much fat or too much protein.
- 8y ago
- lgregg 8y agoReally you just need 52-58g per day of protein for men if I recall correctly.
- ibdf 8y agoDon't throw stones at me here, I'm just the messenger... if you are living an active life style and would like to have some muscle, the golden rule at the gym is that you need at least 1 gram of protein per pound in your body (daily intake). An though I find that there's tons of mis-information out there about what's needed, the 1g per pound is surprisingly consistent throughout most researchers on the subject.
- mikekchar 8y agoIt's been a super long time since I looked at this (decades), but at least when I did a lot of reading on it, this kind of recommendation is based on making sure you have protein availability in the bloodstream when it is being taken up for muscle building. It's not so much the amount as the timing. Again, at least at the time when I was reading about this stuff, there were lots of recommendations for having 5-7 meals a day, or splitting your carb and protein intake (for example eating your protein 1 hour after eating your carbs in order to take advantage of the insulin rush). There are dangers corresponding too much protein intake -- calcium depletion, for example. It's also pretty hard on your kidneys. A lot of advice in the gym is not necessarily geared towards health as much as it is to maximise muscle development/protection. I will also say that nutrition research is chock full of poor science and worse explanations of that science by well meaning popular books. It was my hobby when I was at university (hence decades ago) to look up the actual papers referenced by popular sports nutrition theorists and never once did I find that it held up (either the papers they were referencing were horrible studies, or they got the conclusions completely wrong). It's been a long time since I've had access to a good library, so I've completely lost touch, but I suspect that little has changed. I do wonder about some sports teams and whether or not they are puzzling things out. For example, the Sky cycling team is famous for their "marginal gains" approach -- trying to get a tenth of a percentage of improvement from anywhere. But I haven't found them to be particularly forthcoming about nutrition, for example.
- jcfrei 8y ago> The taste of insects simply does not compare to meat and poultry. Poultry, especially the meat of chicken and turkeys is close to tasteless. I would argue the opposite, the average consumer doesn't really care for the taste of the meat itself as long as the marinade is delicious.
- XalvinX 8y agoYou mean "factory farmed poultry" ...wild bird meat is amazing, and free-range chicken (and their eggs) has a nice flavor too. When they eat a lot of insects and other foods they find in nature it makes a huge difference.
- ahje 8y ago> wild bird meat > free-range chicken Words don't suffice do describe the difference. Anyone with enough time and space should get a few chickens. They're amazing at converting insects and weeds into food, and they're quite funny as pets too.
- notheguyouthink 8y agoWhich makes me wonder, what would industrialized farming and eating of insects do to the taste?
- beauzero 8y agoThey would taste like chicken.
- darkerside 8y agoDepends what you mean by taste, but chicken is a blank canvas to be painted with flavors. What it does provide is an excellent texture that I doubt can be replaced with insect protein.
- tomc1985 8y agoDark meat roasted chicken is hardly tasteless
- blacksmith_tb 8y agoI would think insect protein could easily play the role that soy protein does in lots of 'mystery meat' processed foods like hot dogs or hamburgers. That said, I am skeptical it could be produced more cheaply than soy.
- moate 8y agoIDK, the reason soy works so well there is the texture you're able to produce with it. I feel like one of the largest issues most people have with insects are the texture. The bigger issue here becomes all the side effects of consuming large quantities of soy and how it affects hormone production. Not saying cricket flour wouldn't have a new set of health problems associated with it, but it could be a reason for people to move into insect protein.
- jakevn 8y agoThere is no hormonal side effect for humans consuming large quantities of soy.
- i_am_nomad 8y agoI’d like to believe this, but there’s too much published research to the contrary. https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/soybean-fertility-hormone-isoflavones-genistein/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/soybean-fertility...
- vlan0 8y agoIf only that article linked to actual studies to backup those claims. The article also discusses rats at length, but doesn't support any of its claims with human studies. The one link I attempted to follow is a dead link. That being said, my confidence in the author's ability to speak intelligently on this subject is pretty damn low. So here are actual human studies with data. Clinical studies show no effects of soy protein or isoflavones on reproductive hormones in men: results of a meta-analysis.[1] Isoflavones made simple - genistein's agonist activity for the beta-type estrogen receptor mediates their health benefits.[2] Soy food and isoflavone intake in relation to semen quality parameters among men from an infertility clinic. [3] [1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/19524224 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/19524224 [2] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/16513288 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/16513288 [3] https://academic.oup.com/humrep/article/23/11/2584/2913898 https://academic.oup.com/humrep/article/23/11/2584/2913898
- paulschraven 8y agoAlso, it seems to be questionable how efficient crickets actually are when it comes to Protein according to some studies: > Although it has been suggested that crickets reared for human or livestock consumption may result in a more sustainable supply of protein, this study finds that such conclusions will depend, in large part, on what the crickets are fed and which systems of livestock production they are compared to. When fed grain-based diets at a scale of economic relevance, populations of crickets in this study showed little improvement in PCE compared to broiler chickens fed similar diets. When fed processed, organic side-streams of relatively high quality, cricket populations achieved a harvestable size. Yet, whether crickets could be raised economically on substrates of similar quality and level of processing requires further analysis. The unprocessed and lower-quality organic side-streams tested in this study could not support adequate growth and survival of cricket populations. Therefore, the potential for crickets to supplement the global supply of dietary protein appears to be more limited than has been recently suggested. http://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0118785#abstract0 http://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal....
- anonytrary 8y agoI have heard that insects taste like roasted almonds or other nuts. If this is true, why would Americans even feel the need to start eating them? I still freak out every time I see a big moth in my house. I can't touch them. I can only touch small bugs ~ fruit fly.
- arkh 8y agoInsects can give some different texture to a dish. Just don't do an "only insect with some seasonning" dish: make something like veggies or pasta and add some insects for the crunchy feel. Think Paella, not barbecued steak.
- vibragiel 8y agoYou know, traditional paellas already have snails as an ingredient, which aren't insects but I think still have the cultural unfamiliarity to Western palates.
- CuriouslyC 8y agoTake them out of their shell and tell people they're a type of clam and they'll never know the difference.
- BrandoElFollito 8y agoAs a Frenchman I had to taste snails. Dreadful. There is no taste, just some earthy blob drowning in butter and garlic. I tried three times in three different restaurants and I was disappointed every time.
- amelius 8y agoThe food industry already intentionally feeds us insects, though most people don't know it. The red dye in many food products, for example, often originates from industrially squished insects. https://www.wired.com/2015/09/cochineal-bug-feature/ https://www.wired.com/2015/09/cochineal-bug-feature/
- coldtea 8y ago>As someone who was eating insects long before cricket protein bars became in vogue, I don't see entomophagy becoming anything more than a fad in the west, especially America. Entirely agree. I've been reading those articles for the "rise of bug farming" for the last 30+ years. It's like those "holographic disks" -- something that's always coming in the next 10 years. I don't doubt some such business exist. I doubt they'll become anything substantial, both here and even over there where they traditionally eat some insects anyway.
- ryanmercer 8y ago>The taste of insects simply does not compare to meat and poultry. Granted, this has a lot to do with cultural expectations, but that's exactly why I don't think that people are going to gradually shift to consuming a very different flavor. Not even the taste, if you process it into something like a bar or a protein powder the texture is not terribly palatable.