16 ms·
Cities don't have to offer huge subsidies to companies like Apple and Amazon
- tracer4201 8y ago"The second alternative takes this same approach and applies it to very young companies and to emerging technologies with more speculative prospects." Aside from maybe being young, isn't this what tech companies are generally doing?... working on new ideas, not focusing on a single vertical and have multiple lines of somewhat experimental businesses? Instead of arbitrary tax breaks, it sounds like some cities ought to mandate the benefactors create at least some n number of jobs with a total comp of $x for employees living within the same town, city, county or whatever municipality.
- abhiminator 8y ago>benefactors create at least some n number of jobs with a total comp of $x for employees living within the same town, city, county or whatever municipality. Directives like the ones to create more jobs in order to reach an arbitrary target set by the bureaucrats in the government adds needless pressure and thus might stifle the potential and resources for innovation and experimentation in an organization, especially for a startup.
- trophycase 8y agosomething something... when the measure becomes a goal it ceases to be a good measure
- abhiminator 8y agoI think you're referring to Goodhard's Law -- "When a measure becomes a target, it ceases to be a good measure." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goodhart%27s_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goodhart%27s_law
- michaelt 8y agoIsn't the most popular justification for giving bungs to attract/retain employers that it "creates jobs"? If you're going to pay someone to do something, it makes sense to agree the details of what you're paying them to do - that seems like common sense to me. Otherwise you might spend $$$$ thinking you're attracting a software development centre with 200 employees on low-six-figure salaries, but instead get a data centre with 20 employees on mid-five-figure salaries.
- abhiminator 8y agoI get the gist of your argument, but my point was when government interferes with the hiring process in the pretext of helping the local population (like setting an arbitrary number of job to create in exchange for tax-breaks, for example), it starts to have a strangulating effect on the performance of the private organization.
- s73v3r_ 8y agoThen that organization doesn't need the tax break. If you're not going to be able to bring something of value to the area, then my tax dollars should not be subsidizing you beyond what anyone else gets.
- frgtpsswrdlame 8y ago>Instead of arbitrary tax breaks, it sounds like some cities ought to mandate the benefactors create at least some n number of jobs with a total comp of $x for employees living within the same town, city, county or whatever municipality. You can't go adding requirements in a race to the bottom. Cities are competing on tax incentives in order to attract business. If I start requiring contractual guarantees to those incentives it's functionally the same as just offering a smaller incentive and the business may go elsewhere. The problem is that cities are allowed to compete for business on this playing field at all.
- bilbo0s 8y agoI don't even mind a city competing on that field if they want to do so. My issue is when cities compete on that field with state money ala Racine-Foxconn. So now Pardeeville, which has problems of its own, is on the hook to subsidize jobs for a bunch of illinois guys who will be taking the train in to Racine every morning. That's not cool. But yeah, if Racine County wanted to come up with the 4 billion on their own, that would be a whole different story.
- frgtpsswrdlame 8y ago>I don't even mind a city competing on that field if they want to do so. I think you should since it's fundamentally distortive of the market. While a few giant corporations who are going to get the mayor and some council member's names splashed across the paper get billion dollar deals the rest of the employers in the area don't - it's an unfair competitive advantage. There's two marketplaces at work here. One is with cities as atomistic units competing amongst themselves for jobs and the other is within cities with businesses competing amongst each other (on multiple dimensions.) Right now we corrupt both, the proper solution is to corrupt neither and that requires entirely ending these tax deals.
- cozzyd 8y agoI wonder how many high-level employees will choose to commute to Foxconn by Amtrak from downtown Chicago or Glenview.
- BooneJS 8y ago> Undoubtedly, Wisconsin scored a political and commercial victory by winning the Foxconn bid. But by virtue of its location, Illinois came in a close second and that's pretty good. http://www.chicagotribune.com/g00/business/columnists/ct-foxconn-illinois-wins-robert-reed--0730-biz-20170727-column.html?i10c.encReferrer=aHR0cHM6Ly93d3cuZ29vZ2xlLmNvbS8%3D&i10c.ua=4 http://www.chicagotribune.com/g00/business/columnists/ct-fox...
- bilbo0s 8y agoBest part is that Illinois taxpayers don't have to pony up a single nickel. In a very real way, people in LaCrosse, Independence, Pardeeville, and Spring Green will be subsidizing jobs for people in Illinois. I don't know how Chicago does it, but they always come out on top in any big deal that seems to happen in Wisconsin. Now please excuse me while I go recharge my account to pay Illinois more of my money for the pleasure of using their iPass system on the weekends. :( (Maybe I should change my HN screen handle to "AnotherWisconsinSucker"?)
- BooneJS 8y agoThe FIBs play the sneaky long game. Or they get lucky.
- weberc2 8y agoWhy would they? Who would pay the insane realestate and tax prices plus an hours-long commute? Sure there’s more to do in Chicago, but you’re not doing anything during the week if you’re working ten hours and commuting 3. Better off to live in Wisconsin and visit Chicago on the weekends.
- bilbo0s 8y ago
- BooneJS 8y agoWisconsin even gave Foxconn concessions they didn’t ask for, mainly around environmental impact. https://urbanmilwaukee.com/2018/07/02/the-state-of-politics-foxconn-deal-has-divided-the-state/ https://urbanmilwaukee.com/2018/07/02/the-state-of-politics-...
- extralego 8y agoDemocracy is the only solution: Vote for politicians willing to refuse corporate donations. See justicedemocrats.com for details on how to do your part.
- germinalphrase 8y agoUnfortunately, Wisconsin has been “very effectively” gerrymandered to protect the status quo majority. Gerrymandering is anti-democratic. We need to develop a better way.
- geofft 8y agoSince tomorrow is the 4th of July, it's perhaps worth remembering that democracy also relies on the implicit credible threat of revolution. Without that threat, what is the motivation for politicians to remain honest?
- grzm 8y agoIn a democracy the threat of being voted out of office can be a sufficient threat: one doesn’t require the threat of revolution.
- geofft 8y agoThe threat isn't against the politicans - new politicians can always be bought, or simply ineffective. The threat is against the people doing the buying.
- ataturk 8y agoI disagree. Mao said "power emanates from the barrel of a gun." Force is all the state knows and government at all levels has grown enormously since the 1950s and is now an unruly beast. The people are not speaking with one voice, but if they did, and there was a real threat, the bureaucrats and the pols would listen. They are spineless opportunists, after all.
- TAForObvReasons 8y agoSurprised the article didn't compare the situation to sports teams' incentives. There's a similar problem in that space, where the teams try to extract benefits from the municipalities.
- walterbell 8y agoDo the same lawyers handle negotiations with cities?
- frgtpsswrdlame 8y agoThese are long-term strategies and they're not very exciting which is why politicians don't engage in them. My mid-sized Midwestern city also has a contingent (which in my estimation is a vocal minority but I could be wrong) of people who want to be like the metropolises - NYC, LA, Chicago - and they seem to have a strong influence on local politicians which drives those politicians to engage in these give-aways to prominent companies. It also seems articles like these are really talking around the issue when the answer is right in front of us. Let's just ban cities and states from handing out these tax-breaks.
- zazen 8y ago> Let's just ban It's rarely that simple. I don't know exactly how local government works in the USA, but I presume the federal government can't just summarily revoke powers from cities and states?
- DannyBee 8y agoNo it can't. This person has not read the part of the US constitution that says "The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people."
- tomdell 8y agoPolitician mind: You've just got to find some passage of the Constitution that can be construed as somehow giving the federal government that power, though - or push an amendment through.
- jldugger 8y agoFederal politicans don't care about other state's problems; and certainly don't typically want to restrict their own state legislature's powers. You're better off going the Uniform States Code route, as demonstrated by UCC. Publish a recommended law, then lobby state governments to adopt it. Maybe using a 'when 30 other states also ratify it' language similar to the NPVIC https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Popular_Vote_Interstate_Compact https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Popular_Vote_Intersta... The chief problem here is convincing states that cities poaching their neighbor's businesses is harmful.
- pnathan 8y agoI would like to see Tacoma, WA take this route. There's a lot of cheap housing there, and it's close enough to Seattle to be able to reasonably haul in some of the software engineers that might be a bit more financially constrained. I could easily see an Startup Center coworking space being put together which links accelerators(plural), local universities, the city, and relevant infrastructure to allow a huge working space for very cheap rent until success comes together.
- ahelwer 8y agoTacoma would also have to do some serious PR about its smell, a phenomenon so established it has its own Wikipedia article: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aroma_of_Tacoma https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aroma_of_Tacoma
- markkanof 8y agoThis is real, but the severity seems way over blown. My brother lives in Tacoma and we visit him frequently. I have heard about this aroma, but have never actually experienced it during any of our visits.
- bytematic 8y agoThat sounds perfect! PR just like that will work, I like the personal touch.
- pnathan 8y agoThat really stinks. It's not the original Aroma, but there's often a certain odor in the air in the morning. Not that other major cities don't have issues there too.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Pica_soO 8y agoIntroducing, the end to city prostitution - the city-company marriage.
- tantamount 8y agoOr we could use the US state's ability to apply organized violence as leverage to give these companies an ultimatum: either pay a higher rate of taxes or we will hunt your money down wherever in the world you might try to put it, and we will take that money. Or you could work with us and still make good profits. Then we could take that money and redistribute it to local entities. Of course, that brings in potential new problems of state corruption, which may be just as bad as or worse than the current problems.
- ksec 8y agoHow about the simple procedure that we have been using and somehow "forgot" in the past one or two decades; built a new city?
- bilbo0s 8y agoThat's a pretty "Jedi Handwave-y" solution. There is an enormous amount of effort required to "just" create a new city.
- jamestimmins 8y agoThere's an interesting book called A History of Future Cities that discusses this exact subject by looking at St. Petersburg, Bombay (Mumbai), Shanghai, and Dubai. https://www.amazon.com/History-Future-Cities-Daniel-Brook/dp/0393348865 https://www.amazon.com/History-Future-Cities-Daniel-Brook/dp...
- azinman2 8y agoPerhaps cities do this to raise their stature, trying to solve a chicken-and-egg problem to bootstrap new industries. It’ll attract talent, training, infrastructure, etc. It’s a risky strategy, but that can’t be ignored.
- crb002 8y agoApple brazenly bribed the Waukee IA city council with $100m to abate $170m in property tax; screwing the school district/county/state. The Governor's right hand man then got an Apple gig for doing the bribe. If you or I bribed our city council $1000 to abate $1700 we would be in jail. For Tim Cook it is "tax efficiency".
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoApple gave $100 million directly to city council members and no one batted an eyelid? Or did they give $100 million to the city? Those two things are very different accusations.
- TAForObvReasons 8y agohttps://www.desmoinesregister.com/story/money/business/2017/08/24/apple-puts-faith-waukee-100-million-pledge/596775001/ https://www.desmoinesregister.com/story/money/business/2017/... > Apple Inc. pledged up to $100 million to Waukee under a multi-decade partnership announced Thursday during a visit from Apple CEO Tim Cook. > Waukee, in turn, will provide Apple with $194 million in tax abatement and infrastructure improvements. > Apple's $100 million investment in Waukee likely will be paid out over decades and go toward things like street and sidewalk projects and quality-of-life amenities like libraries and parks, Cook said. There are more details in the article, but it seems like the city is forgoing tax revenue with the understanding that Apple will be investing in the community.
- jandrese 8y agoAnd if they don't follow through then, uh, is there any sort of enforcement on this? I've heard this story before. 20 years down the road the few people who remember the deal and try to find numbers on it discover that the company did almost nothing to hold up their end of the bargain once it was out of the spotlight.
- munificent 8y agoIt's actually "up to $100 million" and the money is supposed to go to a civic "improvement fund": http://www.latimes.com/business/hiltzik/la-fi-hiltzik-apple-iowa-welfare-20170829-story.html http://www.latimes.com/business/hiltzik/la-fi-hiltzik-apple-...
- bradstewart 8y agoThe "second alternative" makes a lot of sense, but building a startup ecosystem is a difficult, long-term play involving a ton of variables. You need universities driving research and producing competent technical graduates; you need to foster a entrepreneurial attitude and provide resources (accelerators, mentors, office space, etc) to would-be companies; you need a source of capital to fund these companies. And then you wait for these companies to grow. Courting a single, large entity is a lot simpler: they tell you what the want; you give it to them; jobs. That's a much easier sell for politicians and local governments. You'd need decades of cooperation between incoming and outgoing politicians to build a successful startup ecosystem.
- Kalium 8y agoYou've nailed the political calculus of it. Setting the stage for an ecosystem is the work of decades, and little of it pays off politically until things are successful. Bringing in BigCo pays off in an electoral cycle or two.
- mygo 8y agoit seems you entirely glanced over the fact that it also costs to bring large successful entities to your city. They’re usually also being simultaneously courted by other cities. They don’t just want to employ a workforce, they want business incentives. They want tax credits, they want prime location, they want natural resources, they want special exemptions. Often times the city ends up paying for the companies to come there in one way or another. Instead of being the quick payoff you describe, it can very much turn out to be a long and drawn out courting period (how long has this Amazon process been so far?) and also a long-term investment in terms of the projected payoff. And once the large company has used up the incentives they may still decide to uproot themselves from the community they had implanted themselves in and go elsewhere. So it’s still risky. Either way, whether growing local businesses or courting big ones from elsewhere, it can be a risky investment.
- bradstewart 8y agoI wasn't trying to say that bringing in large businesses is a quick payoff with no costs, but rather offering a possible explanation as to why we typically see cities going after large businesses. Should have made that clear. There is absolutely a cost associated with either option. There is absolutely a payoff period in years or decades with either option. However, I do think it's easier to get a single company to say "yes", than it is to build an ecosystem; particularly in the context of an elected official's term in office.
- olivermarks 8y agoReminds me of US cities funding oligarch owned sport team new stadium fiascos that occur every few years. Oligarch organization gets massive tax breaks and subsidies then holds city to ransom threatening to move the team to another city that is dangling incentives. The premise is usually jobs, local pride and prestige...and it usually ends really badly for the locals...
- swsieber 8y agoExcept for the Green Bay Packers - the city owns the Packers, and it seems to be doing well(?). I'm not sure, but there at least isn't uncertainty about whether they'll stick around or not.
- olivermarks 8y agoGBP are a wonderful exception and the only credible way for a city to have a team imo
- swsieber 8y agoSadly, from what I know, other teams can't become like them because of team ownership restrictions (well, in the NFL). (Please correct me if wrong). I think the only reason the Packers have this setup is because it was around before the new ownership restrictions. I think they are the only town team to survive the transition to the NFL.
- xxpor 8y agoIt's not the city that owns them, it's the fans themselves. The NFL has specifically banned that form of ownership since.
- retbull 8y agoWhy did they ban it?
- 8y ago
- bluedino 8y agoThis has nothing to do with tech - cities offer huge subsidies to pretty much any company in an attempt to get them to stay or hire more people. We are a small factory and we've been offered a 10 year moratorium if we build a new HQ across the street from our current offices.
- extralego 8y agoRight. It’s a symptom of a much more serious problem: Consolidation of capital which is only available to society on speculative grounds which demand returns at a rate unsustainable without exponential expansion of the western economy. As a result, almost all of our society’s wealth is caught up in last ditch effort expansion schemes. Startups were actually a decent band-aid in terms of continuing the madness but because they don’t effectively break the capital free from the consolidating parties, but merely stir it a bit, they wind up adding to the cesspool of desperate investments. Rich people are freaking out right now because they can’t find ways to profit off the society without contributing to it.
- Spooky23 8y agoThat’s why the focus on controlling property, tangible goods and infrastructure with private interests is pushed so hard. Paper wealth will vaporize when inflation catches up to us. The people who own natural resources, public spaces and infrastructure will be in the best position.
- ryandrake 8y ago> Rich people are freaking out right now because they can’t find ways to profit off the society without contributing to it. I read this all the time: “There’s so much capital out there but nowhere to deploy it!” Our infrastructure is crumbling, the homeless and mentally ill cant get help, teachers have to buy their own school supplies, yet the rich have no idea what to do with all their money and are accumulating more and more by the second.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- peterwwillis 8y agoMy big question is, who are these representatives signing these deals, and how are they not held accountable by voters? What voters actually want to give away hundreds of millions of their tax dollars to the richest corporations?
- bdcravens 8y agoThat gets to the underlying issue with all politics today: who is the real constituent? The voter, or the donor?
- germinalphrase 8y agoFurther, if political seats are gerrymandered to protect incumbents - doesn’t this push politicians toward donor desires (and against constituent desires) as the most credible threat to their re-election is a well funded primary challenge?
- peterwwillis 8y agoVoters should be able to control their reps, via votes. If they can't, then the representative democracy is flawed and needs new legislation to fix it - and that case should be brought to the people, so they know how to vote to fix it.
- chucksmash 8y ago> Voters should be able to control their reps, via votes. If they can't, then the representative democracy is flawed and needs new legislation to fix it The ballot box is a very low resolution feedback tool and an election cycle is a very long iteration cycle. Imagine you only had performance reviews every two years and the feedback from your boss was either "you're not as good as the next best choice, so you're fired" or "you're not fired right now." Voter willpower is diffuse (different people care about different things at different times) and only infrequently expressed. Special interest willpower can be much more acutely and frequently applied. It's hard to see how you can correct the imbalance between these two things given the current system and the inertia of incumbents who benefit from it.
- ghosterrific 8y agoThis nugget of doublespeak: >But many public leaders haven’t switched gears yet, often putting taxpayers at great risk, especially because some tech companies have become very aggressive about demanding big tax breaks. Since when is promising not to steal (via taxes) at threat of violence to encourage more job creation a "threat" to the other taxpayers being stolen from? 2 wrongs do not make a right
- wpdev_63 8y agoThe banks profit the most when property prices go to these astronomical prices. People need to remember that they're are mostly paying interest each month. If taxes rises then property prices decrease in value and more money goes to public services. That in theory anyways.
- twblalock 8y agoA lot of cities are making shortsighted deals to attract companies and sports teams, and that's bad. On the other hand, if companies (and individuals) were not able to shop around for the tax regimes they prefer, there would be nothing to prevent extortionate taxation -- companies and people wouldn't be able to avoid it by going somewhere else, and governments would be able to do whatever they wanted. On balance, I prefer competition in the regulatory and taxation space over the alternative. It limits the ability of governments to use taxation as a weapon or a form of expropriation. I'd rather live in a world where governments need to attract investment rather than coerce it. Some might say that such competition would result in a race to the bottom, but we already have that competition and taxes are still quite high in many places -- a race to the bottom would have happened by now if it was going to happen.
- tmpz22 8y agoHonestly what qualifications do city officials have to make these kinds of ginormous financial decisions? Are super competent financial minds really at the heads of local governments?
- robotresearcher 8y ago"It has been said that democracy is the worst form of Government except for all those other forms that have been tried from time to time." https://richardlangworth.com/worst-form-of-government https://richardlangworth.com/worst-form-of-government
- mikec3010 8y agoA democracy is rule by the people. We're living in the era of a government by the corporations, for the corporations. I honestly cannot understand how companies have any representation or access to politicians. The closest access to the system should be persuading their own employees to vote favorably or write their congressman. Lobbying should be entirely illegal because we are on track to making Idiocracy a reality.
- sheeshkebab 8y agoAll these big tech companies need to be broken up - they are all monopolies that hacked around monopoly laws. No single socially irresponsible corporate entity (these corporations are only responsible to their shareholders, by law) should be able to exert this much influence over social and business environment.
- ThomPete 8y agoStrong startup ecosystems are evolutionary but normally have a revolutionary beginning. SV isn't the most important venture market in the world because it's in California it's because it was central to a technological revolution which created alumni of expertise from taxation and legislation to access to talent to knowledge to people who focus on building companies, academia supporting building and access to money (accumulated from the success of the revolution) You need something to kickstart that somewhere else, something that SV doesn't see and then be right there while the market grows. It's not obvious what that would be, maybe China because they are less affected by ethical considerations which can give them an advantage. It's hard to see it happening in any significant shape and form.
- partiallypro 8y agoLet's also apply this to major sports franchises.
- niftich 8y ago"A regional government asks: which industry sectors are we already comparatively good at?" Nothing. Most regions that don't already tilt toward a particular specialty dominated by a few large employers aren't specifically good at anything. This isn't a slight: it's just reality. The employment and talent base in most areas tilt toward retail (overwhelmingly consisting of national chains, and dominated by the likes of Walmart), human services (healthcare, education), and government. Small businesses then cover a wide gamut of services required for daily life, but don't stand out. There are very regions whose competency comes from a convergence of independent actors, and most of these seem to focus on healthcare research intertwined with healthcare delivery, because the products, talents, and facilities aren't readily transplanted elsewhere: the article's example of NC Triangle, central Maryland, Cleveland, Grand Rapids. Rochester, MN would get an honorary mention, but it's dominated by a single actor -- the Mayo Clinic. So what's everyone else to do? South Carolina began an ambitious plan that culminated in landing BMW in the 1990s, and now the state is a major center of automotive manufacturing and related businesses. For them, the gamble, even with generous incentives, paid off. This is the same kind of thinking behind northern Nevada's (and Arizona's) chasing of manufacturing and high-tech looking to flee from California. Rural areas chasing datacenters might seem a bit puzzling, but they support a comparable number of local jobs, while having fewer externalities than trucking distribution centers -- another typical rural development opportunity. On the other hand, the scope of the subsidies in the Foxconn plant and the nature of the behavior of Wisconsin officials are unjustifiable: it shows desperation, ruthlessness, and a disregard for local residents and local economic realities. Most cases are not that egregious. A jurisdiction landing a large-footprint warehouse-like building, like a datacenter or a distribution center, or even a Walmart, offers a short-term boost of jobs in construction, and then a steady, if low, number of jobs in years to follow. It also vests national or international corporations to the local plant: these sorts of sites are unlikely to close or move. A few million dollar subsidy is comparable in cost to grading and paving roads for a new subdivision, or installing water and sewer service. To cities and counties competing for the long term, this is often seen as an investment in the future of the area.
- opportune 8y agoThis is a really good point. However, I think we really should be making a distinction between skilled and unskilled labor. The reason wealthy nexuses of comparative advantage emerge is generally due to skilled labor. You get a network effect from having that labor after which you may no longer need to offer incentives. The Bay Area is a great place to start a tech company because of all the tech workers/investors/incubators, NYC for hedge funds and IB, Chicago for trading, DC for nonprofits, etc. And generally other areas can experience a similar phenomenon owing to natural resources. However, I think an area makes a mistake in investing (via subsidies/tax breaks/whatever) in unskilled labor when it’s not tied to their natural resources. The difference is simple: you don’t gain the network effect from unskilled labor because, well, it’s unskilled. A distribution center doesn’t really make it better for a call center to pop up in the same area. That said, all large business will cause at least somewhat of an incentive to build other large businesses by it due to infrastructure.
- segmondy 8y agoIndividuals are already bad enough playing game theory games let alone cities. Mayors are trying to get elected next election, to brag and say, "I brought in XYZ company and THEY WILL provide N jobs" is a great line. They don't care about the outcome.
- crazygringo 8y agoI seriously think about if it would be better if there were federal law, or even a constitutional amendment, which prohibited any city or state anywhere in the US from giving favorable treatment (tax or otherwise) to any business, sports team, stadium, or anything else. All it produces a race to the bottom where businesses win and people lose. And it distorts the free market into an uneven playing field, creating situations which are a win to individual business but where the change/move is a net loss for the economy overall. I don't understand why this isn't more of a hot-button issue. Everyone should care about this.
- defertoreptar 8y ago>All it produces a race to the bottom where businesses win and people lose. If only businesses win, then why do cities want the business to come to them in the first place?
- caust1c 8y agoThere are some small economic kickbacks for local economies, but realistically I would guess that it's probably small-scale bribery. That or local governments are just really bad at math. Do they really think a business starting in their community is going to give back more than the billions in breaks they're giving?
- TangoTrotFox 8y agoRemember government is really just a collection of individuals. You can't discount the basic human motivations in things like this. Competing is fun, competing and winning is much more fun. Getting a big company/sport/etc to sign on to your city means you beat everybody else they were negotiating with, and those were all big players. That's a big win. It also helps build your legacy. The guy who brings "The SportsTeamers" to a city is going to be remembered for exactly that, not the net economic effect. And yeah that does no doubt open the door to 'consulting positions' after leaving office though I do not think that's a primary driver in the deals, just icing.
- 8y ago
- zavi 8y agoCities can do whatever they want.
- aoner 8y agoThere is a 3rd alternative. All big cities make a pact to cooperate and never give tax deductions etc. I think this is one of the ideas of the fearless cities movement : http://fearlesscities.com/en/book http://fearlesscities.com/en/book This is one of the ways cities can create supra national entities that can become a counterweight against multinationals.
- ggg9990 8y agoThis is like telling women they don’t need to shave their armpits or men they don’t need to shave their face to find a date. Sure, it shouldn’t be needed, but when everyone else is doing it, it sure makes it a lot harder to find a date if you’re the only one who doesn’t.
- nameisu 8y agokickbacks rule
- purplezooey 8y agoStop putting so many right wing people in office is a good start. Megadeals are able to be made because these people do not value, understand, or advocate for essental government services that cost money. The constituents of these cities are the losing party.