31 ms·
Starbucks Frappuccino Sales Tell a Troubling Tale
- laurex 8y agoWhere's the kombucha? And maybe some avocado toast with flavoured salt? The zeitgeist is passing them by...
- dmfdmf 8y ago>...Starbucks struggled to draw customers in the afternoons. My local Starbucks stops brewing decaf at 11am. I can't drink caffeine in the afternoon and I don't think I am alone.
- craftyguy 8y agoMost of the locations near me close up fairly early in the afternoon, so those of us who can drink caffeine in the afternoon have no choice but to take our business elsewhere.
- masonic 8y agoThere is no extra charge for a pour-over (e.g. for decaf or dark roast). If they try to upsell you to a Clover specialty variety for more money, don't pay any upcharge.
- JohnTHaller 8y agoMaybe folks are realizing that even when you call basically-a-milkshake a coffee beverage, it's still basically a milkshake... and not something you should consume regularly.
- craftyguy 8y agonot likely. obesity in the US is still a thing, and it's not getting any better.
- keyle 8y agoVote me down all you want, but I fail to see why this is relevant to HN and landed the first page...
- 67_45 8y agoDon't mention being down voted. It's against the rules and not very appealing. But I do agree with your sentiment
- gameshot911 8y agoWhy did you feel the need to create a new account for this comment & thread?
- OhYouKnowWhy 8y agoOh, come on. You know everyone on this site is a fucking asshole.
- gameshot911 8y agoTrue, but I didn't think IP was saying anything particularly controversial. Hence my curiosity! I was almost wondering if OP just created new accounts for every thread out of some hyper-privacy orientation.
- 67_45 8y agoI pressed logout by accident and I didn't know the password
- everdev 8y ago> Perhaps this shouldn’t come as a shock, given that Frappuccinos pack a lot of calories and customers are increasingly looking for healthy choices. Glad that people are making healthier choices but consuming stimulants and refined sugar every day (sometimes multiple times per day) probably isn't a healthy habit either.
- craftyguy 8y agoI stopped going to starbucks because I had to wait in the same like as the "large mocha frappuccino with whipped cream and low fat milk please" folks who took forever and a day to order their crap, when all I wanted was a black coffee. Why can't there be a way to get a regular, no frills coffee without waiting for tens of minutes?
- praneshp 8y ago> when all I wanted was a black coffee. This is incorrect at least at all the Starbucks I've been to in the past 5 years (ATL, LAX, San Diego, bay area). If you order just drip coffee, the cashier just fills it for you whilst billing. No waiting in line with the other folks who have different tastes from yours. Also I agree with my sibling commenter; if all you need is black coffee McD is much better. But you might have to wait in line with "big mac and fries" folks to order their crap.
- tudelo 8y agoAnecdotally, it really depends on the Starbucks. There are plenty that do not fill it for you right away. IME, if it's hot coffee usually they will. Iced coffee, they won't.
- bmelton 8y ago> Why can't there be a way to get a regular, no frills coffee without waiting for tens of minutes? McDonald's, Dunkin Donuts, and hell, even Starbucks offers that if you order ahead with their app and just pick it up when you get there.
- 8y ago
- wgerard 8y agoSomewhat related, but I always wonder if things like this are symptomatic of something larger happening - i.e. I wonder if we're at the start of a recession of some kind, and this is a symptom of that. Of course the more logical part of my brain says "Starbucks is over-saturated, local coffee shops have surpassed Starbucks in many ways, and people are starting to realize how horrible frappuccinos are for them." Still, sometimes it's hard to shake this nagging feeling that things like this are dead canaries. I'm not quite sure why, though.
- parthdesai 8y agoanecdotal, but i stopped having them after they were required to put calories on the menu. That and i got common sense and started making my own coffee rather than spending ~$5 per coffee everyday.
- nyolfen 8y agoif you don't have any particular attachment to the romance of drinking coffee, a month of caffeine tablets will run you about $5 (or less)
- tudelo 8y agoCoffee tastes good :)
- parthdesai 8y agoi do like the taste of coffee
- stephengillie 8y agoIf you do have a particular attachment to the taste of coffee, consider a Keurig ($120-$250) with a reusable filter. Each cup of coffee uses ~1/3 oz of ground coffee, so a 12oz bag ($6-21) gives ~33 cups. With expensive coffee, and an expensive machine, at 10 cups per day, after 100 days (1000 cups), that's $886.36, or $8.86 per day. If you find a cheap machine and good, inexpensive coffee, you're looking at $301.82 or $3.02 per day. Add in $13/300 paper filters for easy and compostable cleaning, and you're looking at $3.45 - $9.29 per day, depending on your coffee price. And 32oz of vinegar for the descaling ($4) for another 1000 cups, increases to $3.47 - $9.30 per day. As a bonus, if you're also a Futurama fan, you will experience time at an unusual rate once every 10 days.
- 67_45 8y agoStarbucks is the defacto mascot of money wasting. People always talk about abstaining from starbucks when they talk about saving money. The frappuccino is often the specific product that is mentioned. How is it any surprise that it's popularity has waned? Star bucks stores feel more like McDonald's stores than anything else, there is almost no atmosphere to speak of which I would guess is rather important to the coffee snobs who buy fraps. What kind of world do we live in when McDonald's is expensive (everything besides the simple cheeseburger is a total insult to value) and when Starbucks is McDonald's?
- baybal2 8y ago>Starbucks is the defacto mascot of money wasting. >People always talk about abstaining from starbucks when they talk about saving money. Except when they come and buy them :) For the money wasting culture.... The latest Starbuckses in China are mindblowing... Not only they have nearly $11 bucks drinks ( you can buy 4 full meals for that price in China ) the decorum looks like something out of ritz carlton if not more posh. They are thriving here.
- 67_45 8y agoBut in the article it says that Starbucks growth in China has fallen significantly behind market growth
- obelix_ 8y agoStarbucks stores when initially designed, where intended to fill the need for a "third space" outside of home and work. Not everyone wanted to hangout at a bar. And not every city and town had such spaces. Which is why Starbucks worked. People paid for that space not really for the coffee.
- Teeer 8y agoFunny you mention McDonalds, because that's where I buy my fraps now instead of Starbucks. They taste exactly the same but are significantly cheaper.
- gameshot911 8y agoFunny that decreasing growth is the main cause for concern in this article. Talk about ubiquity itself not being enough for investors.
- orev 8y agoThe need for growth eventually kills all these companies. There’s just no concept on Wall St. that a company can so completely saturate the market that there’s nowhere else to go. It’s a relatively new concept that companies really can dominate the whole world in their market segment.
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> There’s just no concept on Wall St. that a company can so completely saturate the market that there’s nowhere else to go They’re called utilities. They pay a nice dividend and are valued with at a sober multiple.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoI'm guilty of contributing to the decline of Frappuccino sales. I used to drink them regularly at Starbucks. Two (related) things happened: I got off the street and I got healthier. I use food in place of drugs. Me consuming enormous amounts of coffee for the caffeine is a sign of health distress. I have mostly quit drinking coffee since leaving California and getting back into housing. I was also going to Starbucks for the Wi-Fi. I now have internet service at home. It's anecdata. But maybe there are trends happening that are impacting Starbucks, but which are not really about Starbucks per se, and that don't say something dire about the world.
- dr_ 8y agoHow about improving on some of the food items? Starbucks had purchased BayBread/La Boulange for 100 million several years ago. Yet when I walk into a Starbucks and look at the selection of pastries behind the glass casing, they look dehydrated and unappealing. My local cafe has stuff that actually looks like it was freshly baked that morning. They usually don't make them in house, they work with local bakers. Starbucks should consider doing something similar.
- modzu 8y agowhy not support your local cafe instead?
- modzu 8y ago(in terms of the purely economic question of whats best for sb, that mass produced cardboard food must net more profit than the increased sales of more expensive higher quality food would)
- berbec 8y agoThe percentage of that profit staying in the local area is smaller at a Starbucks.
- masonic 8y agoOne is overrun with mannerless 18-25 year olds, so much so that they replaced the chairs with uncomfortable ones in an apperant attempt to limit them hanging out all day. The founder of the other was just put away for child sex crimes. True story. I've encountered two Starbucks stores that I consider exemplarily managed. I go there mostly.
- ovao 8y agoI agree they tend to look awful in the display case, but I've actually been fairly happy with their bakery items. It's possible all they really need to do is spritz the muffins with water every so often to make them appear more moist. The best way to sell baked goods is to bake them in-house, though, exposing customers to an aroma that's almost impossible to say "no" to. Subway clearly had the right idea when it came to selling cookies.
- siliconc0w 8y agoAside from wasting money, that amount of excess sugar also kills you similarly to alcohol. Diabetes, fatty liver disease, obesity, etc. Well I guess it's also wasting money due to the increased health care costs but one might also argue an early death saves money so YMMV.
- Teckla 8y agoI've never understood why they don't offer all the same sweet drinks, but with something like Splenda instead of sugar. Perhaps it's better this way, otherwise I'd probably be at Starbucks a lot more often.
- Simon_says 8y agoOddly enough, the zero-calorie (or very low calorie) sweeteners are almost as fattening as sugar.
- jonheller 8y agoIt is interesting that soda (i.e. Coke, Pepsi) sales took a huge hit over the past decade as people became more health conscious and looked for healthier options, and yet people will still consume 2-4 times that many calories and sugars in a sweetened coffee drink.
- walru 8y agoDoes anyone recall how Facebook's booming growth coincided with the growth of Zynga? A game genre which asked you to have a bunch of friends to get ahead, otherwise pay to win. (aka. a lot of people signed up for fake accounts) The recent US employment numbers have a similar stink, as it's impossible for the vast majority of people to survive off a single job's income, especially when little to none of them are offering full-time or benefits. The talk of a recession hasn't started, but it's here, if not something far far worse.
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> it's impossible for the vast majority of people to survive off a single job's income The average employed American earned $928.74 a week in May of 2018 [1]. That's over $46,000 a year [2]. That's a livable wage. In the same month, labor force participation for Americans over 16 was 62.7% [3]. So a majority of Americans have jobs, and the average job pays over twice the poverty rate for a family of three to four [4]. The vast majority of Americans can survive off a single job's income. [1] https://www.bls.gov/news.release/empsit.t19.htm https://www.bls.gov/news.release/empsit.t19.htm [2] 928.74 * (52 - 2) includes 2 weeks' vacation [3] https://data.bls.gov/timeseries/LNS11300000 https://data.bls.gov/timeseries/LNS11300000 [4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poverty_in_the_United_States#Recent_poverty_rate_and_guidelines https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poverty_in_the_United_States#R...
- stephengillie 8y ago> Perhaps this shouldn’t come as a shock, given that Frappuccinos pack a lot of calories and customers are increasingly looking for healthy choices. But Starbucks needs some new hits to give people a reason to come back through its doors, especially with so many insurgent and boutique coffeehouses chasing the same customers. Indeed, at over 500 calories, any given Frappuccino is almost 1/3 of my daily calorie budget. That's a lot to spend for a single treat. They keep trying to push these at the "Happy Hour" events they hold every other Thursday - announced by Wifi auto-login page, auto-signup email newsletter, and numerous app notifications. They're using just about every trick available, but sadly their caffeinated milkshakes aren't bringing paying customers to their 'yard'. As a frequent Starbucks customer, I face 3 issues with the stores: - Lack of low-carb, high-protein meal options. The protein boxes are acceptable, and more options would be lovely. - Long lines to order, and an uncomfortable wait for the drink. The solution I've found for this is to order through the app, from a store about 5 minutes away. By the time I arrive, my order is waiting for me at the end of the drink rail. - Unpredictable lack of seating - no way to know if all tables are taken at a given store, without actually being there in person. Google Maps can give some idea. Not sure of a better solution for this, short of table sensors or webcams. The long ordering times are a problem held by almost all coffee shops, and Starbucks app is the only thing that makes me opt for them over smaller local competition.
- masonic 8y agoLack of low-carb, high-protein meal options The sous-vide egg bites are the perfect keto snack. The steak and egg tomatillo works, too.
- Klover 8y agoWhat else do you eat? Avoiding any and all sugar does seem like a great way to lose weight, but how do you go about your day? Is it lots of cooking, lots of batch cooking, or getting things at cafés? I was telling a friend of mine the other day how I used to cook a lot of beef and assorted vegetables in a pot of water and it would last me the week, but I have barely any sense of taste.
- sonnyblarney 8y agoI think something better than Dunkin Donuts, but cheaper than Starbucks could make a killing. People like their coffee but not quite the price. Also - the brand is fully commoditized ... so high price points are harder to achieve.
- rabboRubble 8y agoThe Starbucks sugared drinks are so sweet my teeth hurt. One day, I ordered a black coffee, it arrived pre-sweetened when I was expecting bitter. Starbucks had spit up on their floors after that drink. Edit: Also, at one point I did a deep dive into my finances, and I realized I was spending more at Starbucks than I was on groceries at a grocery store. I ate out a lot. Started cooking home more, and made a rule about how much weekly to spend on coffee. That probably didn't help Starbucks' finances multiplied by all the financially squeezed millennials.