12 ms·
Amazon shareholders demand it stop selling facial recognition to governments
- dsfyu404ed 8y agoGood. "We don't want you doing shady things that damage the brand's reputation in order to make a buck" is the kind of message shareholders should be sending to all companies. Edit: Apparently I'm wrong and shareholders should be pushing for profits regardless of means? I know Amazon isn't exactly known for treating people well but they're no Monsanto or Blackwater either. Amazon sells to consumers and is therefore dependent on public opinion to make sales. With the increasing public awareness of just how pervasive consumer tracking is it's becoming a touchy subject. If Amazon wants to keep expanding its market share for home goods then anything that risks associating its brand with government tracking is a very high risk. That would make me uncomfortable if I had Amazon shares.
- philwelch 8y agoThe US government is a huge customer of AWS, and AWS has deliberately built entire regions to cater to them: https://aws.amazon.com/blogs/publicsector/announcing-the-new-aws-secret-region/ https://aws.amazon.com/blogs/publicsector/announcing-the-new... https://aws.amazon.com/govcloud-us/ https://aws.amazon.com/govcloud-us/
- hn_throwaway_99 8y agoA much more accurate title would be "19 Amazon shareholders demand it stop selling facial recognition to governments." They even wrote a sternly worded letter!
- analognoise 8y agoPretty soon, they'll have to move to outright scowling at at Jeff Bezos!
- kickopotomus 8y agoOr a tweet. That is how most official communication is handled these days, right?
- pests 8y agoIs there something wrong with this? Email, fax, phones, telegrams, snail mail, etc. Everything was the new weird thing at one point in time.
- twinkletwinkle 8y agoTweets have the side effect of being public. Sometimes that becomes the main effect. Emails and the rest of your examples don't have that property.
- vuln 8y agoTransparency!
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- kbsletten 8y agoYou've clearly never had somebody forward your email on you. All digital communication is effectively public by virtue of fast, easy copying.
- what_ever 8y agoThere is a difference between public nature of tweet where anyone can go and read it vs public nature of email where you would need to forward it to everyone (or one of them would have to tweet it which is back to what GP said).
- frozenport 8y ago
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> They even wrote a sternly worded letter Privately delivered to Amazon by the ACLU. Until one of the signatories, who is also a major Amazon shareholder, goes public with their disgruntlement this should merit no further attention.
- _rpd 8y agoCNN[1] says that it is "Nearly 20 groups of Amazon shareholders ... which include the Social Equity Group and Northwest Coalition for Responsible Investment." [1] http://money.cnn.com/2018/06/18/technology/amazon-facial-recognition/index.html http://money.cnn.com/2018/06/18/technology/amazon-facial-rec...
- bigiain 8y agoI don't know who those groups are - but they're exactly the sort of name I'd choose for my single-share-holding activist organisation... (It's a more-than-impulse-buy price of ~$1700 right now - but if I were the sort of person who bought single company shares to push my personal causes at shareholder meetings, I'd probably have bought in at a few hundred bucks 5 or more years back...)
- professorgerm 8y agoI was curious, so I looked up the Northwest Coalition for Responsible Investment [1]. They have 16 member organizations, including the Tacoma Dominicans and the Sisters of St Mary of Oregon. Most of their actions seem to be 'dialogue,' which they apparently engaged in over 60 times. [1]: http://www.ipjc.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/10/NWCRI-Annual-Report-2016-web.pdf http://www.ipjc.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/10/NWCRI-Annual-...
- jonknee 8y agoA much more accurate title than that would be "Shareholders representing X% of Amazon demand it to stop selling facial recognition". I mean Jeff Bezos and myself are both shareholders, but his stake is worth mentioning. Activist funds are able to shake things up with a lot less than 19 shareholders, so the count isn't important at all unless it's giant.
- istvanp 8y agoWhile I applaud this effort, this will not stop the use of the technology. It will simply steer them to another provider or a custom implementation (on top of AWS if they so choose to) of this now well-understood technology.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- FartyMcFarter 8y agoSure. But let's be clear - it is good to have as many software developers as possible steering away from unethical work.
- Spivak 8y agoIs it really the tool that's unethical or the argument here just about depriving governments they don't like tools in general? "Twenty shareholders from Ford demand they stop selling cars to local law enforcement."
- FartyMcFarter 8y ago> Is it really the tool that's unethical Amazon runs the tool on AWS servers they control, so they can (and should) be responsible for having policies that forbid its unethical use. Here is AWS's Acceptable Use Policy: https://aws.amazon.com/aup/ https://aws.amazon.com/aup/ I don't see anything there about ethics.
- somethingwitty1 8y agoI don't know about this argument though. If Amazon bans a book based on their ethics, people freak out about censorship and how one company has so much power and shouldn't be doing that. If their AUP stated what they deemed ethical, how many potential startups or corporations wouldn't be able to start? Take a "simple" example: A business that counsels families on abortion. Is that ethical? Who gets to decide that? I think this is one of those cases where we have to be very careful what we are asking for.
- PenguinCoder 8y agoTime for Amazon to divest this division into a wholly owned subsidiary!
- amelius 8y agoYeah, but Facebook's software could contain tagged data of actual people.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 8y agoI think this kind of “don’t sell technology x to governments” is kind of misguided for the following reasons. 1) You are saying that you are from be with private entities having access to this technology, but not public entities? Private individuals and companies should be able to use facial recognition, but not governments? Throughout history, governments have typically been the first ones to acquire tech. Of note is that the major Airplane companies (Boeing and Airbus) have very large military units. 2) It is likely to be ineffective. All you need is a third company that serves as the bridge that buys facial recognition from Amazon and resells to the government. 3) International relationships really are a competition. I am sure Chinese AI companies are working hand in glove with the government to make sure their government is able to deploy the latest AI tech. If AI is the gamechanger people say it is, you have given an incredible leg up to China vs the West. 4) If employees at companies keep on pushing this anti-government, anti-military thing with AI, there is a good chance that it will get reclassified as a sensitive technology and heavily regulated.
- merlincorey 8y ago> 3) International relationships really are a competition. I am sure Chinese AI companies are working hand in glove with the government to make sure their government is able to deploy the latest AI tech. If AI is the gamechanger people say it is, you have given an incredible leg up to China vs the West. I think this is a really important point, here. I think the paranoid line of thinking is helpful in this instance: Who benefits from the US government not having access to AI technologies? - The argument on the face of it seems to be that we, the people of this world and in the US, benefit thanks to keeping these tools out of our government's hands - The unmentioned argument is benefits go to China, Russia, and other countries whose tech sectors cooperate with the government I am not suggesting that the article was written by China or Russia to hurt our government - that certainly sounds like "conspiracy theory"; however, I am suggesting that it is a valid concern that the US as a country may want to "keep up".
- int_19h 8y agoYour analysis ignores an important point: the only thing that the US government would need to gain such access, would be to stop doing the things it is being called out for. It's not that government having such tools that's inherently the problem, but the way they're going to be used here and now.
- bb88 8y agoI don't think it matters. Third parties are going to be in this space anyway (Raytheon, Lockheed Martin, Boeing, and the foreign defense contractors) so it doesn't make a lot of sense to shut off a profitable segment. I was just thinking how much I would like an facial recognition API for my home security system. That way I can give someone's name to the police to make it easier to track someone down.
- _jal 8y agoMe, I've been thinking about ALRs. If this stuff is going to be available, I think everyone should have it. So this is one of those projects I am just never going to get around to, but someone else, please do it - it shouldn't be that tough to build a cheap Raspberry-Pi-ish automatic plate reader anyone can point out their window to capture every plate going by. With a network of them, everyone can know this stuff, all the time, for free. I find that to be a frightening outcome, but I think it is a less frightening one than only certain people having access. We have to learn how to live with this tech; far better to not allow it to be a tool of selective control while we're adapting. And it can be a more honest resource - police and other official vehicles' movements will be visible to those paying for those cars, whereas anything official will have official holes.
- bb88 8y agoWell, I think the hard part is done here: http://www.openalpr.com/cloud-api.html http://www.openalpr.com/cloud-api.html
- manigandham 8y agoGovernments are just people, led by politicians. It would be far better if efforts were spent on recognizing and electing qualified and capable people to run the government as wanted instead of this silly run-around with commercial companies.
- _jal 8y ago> Governments are just people, led by politicians ... empowered to do things we lock up, tase, beat, sick dogs on, and/or kill other people for doing. Kind of an important distinction to make. If you have reason to think exhorting your peer-proles to 'pick qualified and capable people' will lead to better outcomes now than it has in the past, certainly, please continue. Some of us, however, don't see that happening and prefer to explore other approaches, even if you happen to find our pessimism 'silly'.
- jopsen 8y agoBig corporations can also make your life miserable... And they aren't exactly as accountable as our governments.
- bigiain 8y agoAnd their being accountable to shareholders is the avenue of accountability these groups are trying to use. Might not work, but surely it's worth a try?
- manigandham 8y agoYes, it's called authority. The point of the comment is that we should pick the proper people to give that authority to, instead of fighting against them through some strange corporate proxy. If you want an alternative, why don't you become the qualified and capable person to join the government to shape it the way you want?
- int_19h 8y agoAnd we're working on that, too. But it's a slow process, and meanwhile there's damage to mitigate.
- newscracker 8y agoAfter Facebook, Amazon is the other company I wouldn't trust to not do evil. Even if many more shareholders join in on this, I don't see Jess Bezos caring about these things. The Amazon stock won't suffer even if he publicly says he won't listen to such shareholders. On the contrary, the stock may just shoot up. The larger question on this topic is, "If the big technology companies do not sell the technology to the governments, won't somebody else do?" Of course, the governments would find some domestic or foreign companies to buy such technology from (or even spend money on developing it). I think that's inevitable over the course of time. But such pressure on companies could possibly help shape policy too (added several adjectives to indicate how difficult this would be).
- salawat 8y agoThe problem comes down to the engineers and researchers involved. As an INDUSTRY, we have some very important decisions to make, one of which is, "will we work on this type of system knowing full well what it will be used for?" Yes, everyone has their price, but the fact remains that the tools are nigh useless without the expertise of the knowledgeable people to integrate and fine tune the final product. If there is enough ethical backlash by we tech people, the progress any government makes can be set back decades. It can't be stopped at this point most likely, as the data and initial research is out of the bag as it were, but it does"t have to be carried one inch further. Personally, I won"t touch it. No benefit is worth the risk of this type of system being leveraged against a population. I've fully thought through the security, search and rescue, administrative, etc... applications, and as cold as it may sound, it is not worth it. The invasion of privacy, the chilling effects put on public discourse, the enabling of active population social engineering through ubiquitous surveillance and negation of dissidents is not a legacy worth having anything to do with.
- pfisch 8y agoToo many people don't care. Just look how many people are plugging away at AI even though it could easily lead to extinction level events. Even before that people were making the H bomb and even other smaller scale weapons. Too many people are too greedy and don't care. I just don't think this kind of opting out is going to do much. Maybe slow things down a little, but not that much.
- turdnagel 8y agoI understand this is a practical reaction to what most of us would agree is an egregious use of the tech, but wouldn't it make more sense to stop the problem at its root? I'm talking about surveillance. Why aren't we complaining about camera companies selling surveillance equipment? The gov't already has the data and Amazon's APIs just make this a little bit easier. But they can go direct to EC2 and get a couple hundred GPU-optimized instances and do it themselves.
- mankash666 8y agoThe only effective way to achieve this is getting a majority of the board to vote for this. Everything else is mere virtue signalling without effect.
- confounded 8y ago> Everything else is mere virtue signalling without effect. By that definition, isn’t almost every form of non-decisive influence “virtue signaling”? Virtue itself? Marching against a war? Voting for a candidate you like the policies of, but who doesn’t have good media coverage? Declining to purchase unethical goods?
- intopieces 8y agoYes. That’s the objective behind the term “virtue signaling” - to call into question the motives of anyone and everyone who claims to care about something so that it becomes deeply uncool to care about things so that they’ll stop trying to make the world a better place. Even if you presented a 100-step well funded plan for changing the status quo, prepare to have it leveled by the sneer of “you’re just virtue signaling.” You can never prove your sincerity to anyone who uses this term, because it will never be enough.
- mankash666 8y agoHow's legitimacy relevant here? I'm not trying to place doubt, trying to make an honest observation that a result needs the majority of the board to vote for the measure.
- jiggunjer 8y agoI don't see any issue with the phrase "virtue signaling" per se. My issue is with the implicit or explicit statement that it is useless. Virtue signaling is cool. People who say it with a mocking tone of voice aren't.
- bcheung 8y agoCan't find the actual letter. Anyone have a link?
- bcheung 8y agoThis seems like it is approaching the problem from the wrong angle. This should be addressed at the government law level. The problem is where do you draw the line? Any technology can be used for evil. Do you next ask companies that sell cameras not to sell to the government? Then ban computers? Laws that concern themselves with targeting and surveilling people encompass any technology. Facial recognition is not a hard problem and this is just a matter of convenience. Government can just go around and implement it themselves if nobody provides it to them. At least through Amazon there is some level of non-government control to shut it off if they end up doing anything nefarious.
- _rpd 8y ago> Facial recognition is not a hard problem Low quality facial recognition is easy. High quality facial recognition is hard.
- zaptheimpaler 8y agoI agree with this in principle, but in the US the intelligence/police don't really seem to be accountable to the people. They regularly conduct surveillance on huge scales and no one even knows about it until we get lucky with a leak like Snowden. Who knows how many dozens of other secrets like that they still have. The CIA/FBI etc. have a history of doing this kind of thing for decades, at least since WW2. Then it gets declassified 50 years later when no one cares. Surveillance is a case where its good for the government, but bad for the people the government is meant to represent. Bottom line is they will never police themselves on this issue. So going after the people making it like Amazon may be a better idea.
- manigandham 8y agoThe intelligence and police apparatus are the people. They are not some alien overlords, you can meet these employees and see what they do, and alter their course of actions by shaping the government through direct voting. Trying to change it via corporate proxy is not going to really work.
- omar01204142345 8y agoGtryy
- m3kw9 8y agoWhat percentage is a group of share holders?
- skybrian 8y agoPreventing facial recognition techniques from spreading would seemingly require some attempt at keeping them secret. But aren't AI techniques often openly published in scientific papers? And it seems likely that there is also open source software available?
- anonu 8y agoThis is a perfect example of social governance: stockholders feeling empowered to control how a company operates. We need to see more of this type of governance. Ultimately, shareholders should just vote with their dollars. Sell a stock you dont like or dont invest in the first place.
- TangoTrotFox 8y agoI agree with you, but I think we disagree. What I mean is that this article specifies 19 share holders, without mentioning their share. It's a very safe bet to assume that it's not even a significant fraction of a percent. In other words, in 'voting with their dollar' these individuals would have a literally unnoticeable impact. When a substantial chunk of society feels something ought be changed, then I certainly agree they have the right to make such change happen. But we live in a time where headlines, such as this, are constantly driven by irrelevantly small numbers. For instance traditional fear mongering was stuff along the lines of 'video games are driving kids to kill.' What that really translates to is 'one mentally unstable kid who happened to play a lot of video games killed another kid, primarily because he was mentally unstable'. The conflation between the views/actions of society and the views/action of the individual is counterproductive. If you polled people, proportional to share of amazon, what percent would agree with the statement 'I demand Amazon stop selling facial recognition to governments'? On that we can only speculate, but I imagine it would probably be quite small.
- hedora 8y agoI get that people are upset with government abuses (I am too!), but stepping back for a minute, I think it is much more concerning that we’re building a world where a few tech companies get to decide what computing may or may not be used for. The fact that even the government is hitting headwinds gives me an extremely negative outlook for where the cloud is headed with respect for individual rights.
- FooHentai 8y agoIn the past 24 hour cycle of news I have seen: - Microsoft catching heat for their deal to allow ICE to use their capabilities - Amazon catching heat for their deal to allow government to use facial recognition - A photo of Satya Nadella, Jeff Bezos and Trump sitting next to each other and shaking hands What's the play here?
- r00fus 8y agoPRISM?
- TangoTrotFox 8y agoMoney. - Companies making money by developing and licensing software. - Media making money by creating sensationalistic headlines.
- jpalomaki 8y agoThere's growing number of investors who are looking also at the non-financial side of business (social responsibility, environmental issues etc). Companies who ignore these things exclude themselves from the portfolios of these investors. Some banks and investors are saying the don't want to be involved with certain types of legitimate activities. Here's one example: "Deutsche Bank avoids entering into, or continuing, any kind of business relationship with entities with clear, direct links to the following types of Controversial Weapons business [...]" [1] I'm not saying face recognition is same thing as antipersonnel mines, but things can change over the years, especially under pressure from public. [1] https://www.db.com/newsroom_news/2018/deutsche-bank-upgrades-its-policy-on-controversial-weapons-en-11582.htm https://www.db.com/newsroom_news/2018/deutsche-bank-upgrades...
- remarkEon 8y ago>Companies who ignore these things exclude themselves from the portfolios of these investors. Sounds good to me. It seems very unwise to run your business based whatever pet project "socially conscious" investors are supporting this week.
- anonnel 8y agoToo. Late.
- whack 8y agoIt's weird that we have so many people directing their protests towards the tech companies, and not the government itself. The whole premise of capitalism is that profit-motivated-corporations will inevitably succumb to evil temptations. That it's the government's job to regulate corporations, and police their moral behavior. Instead, we have the complete opposite. Americans expect the government/military to engage in morally unacceptable behavior, and are looking to corporations to "enforce" morality instead, by denying the government specific services. Not that there is anything wrong with tech companies and workers doing their part. But when we see corporations as the best catalyst for pro-social outcomes, and not the government itself, there's something very wrong with our political system.
- ericnyamu123 8y agowow.check out this cool forum http://mawazo.byethost7.com/index.php http://mawazo.byethost7.com/index.php
- 64564577 8y agothis is a very nice forum,check it out https://www.bit.ly/2M0hqJa https://www.bit.ly/2M0hqJa
- skywhopper 8y agoThis is interesting. The marketing has certainly been disturbing, reinforcing the worst uses for this sort of tech and overstating its usefulness for those cases. But ... unlike Google's contract work with the Defense Department, I'm not sure Amazon could legally get away with refusing to sell an on-demand product to a government agency. This service is nowhere close to the worst thing that's running on Amazon's servers on behalf of governments. The software exists and could easily be set up to run directly by governments or their contractors on Amazon's infrastructure (I guarantee that is already going on far more extensively than Amazon's own specific service will ever grow to). Ditto for GCP and Azure and everything else. I sympathize with these investors, truly, but the only solution here would be to get out of the cloud computing business altogether.
- derEitel 8y agoI'm starting to think we have the need of something like the ICAN for facial recognition (FR), promoting the regulation of FR worldwide. There a little valid systems where FR is truly helpful. Most of todays applications are around things like "access control" and "tag your friends here", i.e. banalities which are either unnecessary or can be solved with simpler tech. On the other hand the risks are incredible, FR in combination with AR systems could completely eradicate privacy. Autocratic governments could use it for a new levels of surveillance. Military usage could perfect the use of autonomous weapons etc. It's just not worth it and should be internationally outlawed. Just like A-bombs and chemical warfare.
- ohthehugemanate 8y agoI work in a department at Microsoft that does a lot of Machine Learning and AI work for MS customers. I'm proud that our organization regularly turns down opportunities because of ethical considerations. We have a concrete set of ethical standards, and if a project makes it past that review and into your hands, and you still feel uncomfortable, you are strongly encouraged to flag it for second review in committee. The whole system is called AETHER, for your googling - er, Binging - pleasure. The ground rule that would apply here is, we don't do anything that makes choices about restricting or injuring humans. So no perp detection systems, no autonomous weapons of any kind... Not even a camera to disable the ignition if you're detected as drunk.