14 ms·
Berlin-Munich high-speed train services carry 2M passengers in first six months
- hotdog97 8y agoI rode that train (Munich to Berlin) after I got stranded in Munich during the 2014 Bardarbunga, Iceland volcano eruption. It was kind of slow for an ICE at the time, and quite expensive (IIRC like 150 EUR in second class). It was one of the nicest train rides I've ever taken though - you got to see so much of Germany. The onboard restaurant was awesome.
- jacquesm 8y agoThis is the new line, the old line is quite a bit slower.
- hotdog97 8y agoOh yeah, forgot to mention that. Seems like it's 3h 55m now; when I did it was at least six hours, I think. I hope you don't miss out on seeing the incredibly scenic Bavarian landscapes and villages. I could do without looking at the mostly industrial landscape further up north though.
- zwaps 8y agoYeah so the line from Munich to Berlin is new. There aren't any industrial landscapes as such on the direct way, so I kinda wonder what way via ICE you ended up taking ;D
- philippnagel 8y agoProbably Bitterfeld.
- noobermin 8y agoAssuming similar prices for the new train, that's quite a bit of revenue for six months, is that typical for a single route train?
- nisa 8y agoIt's regular price but if you book in advance a certain train it's often cheaper (~20-80€ depending on the time of departure...) Here are some details (only found a german link: https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Verkehrsprojekt_Deutsche_Einheit_Nr._8 https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Verkehrsprojekt_Deutsche_Einhe...) - costs for the whole track was around 10 billion euro.
- withdavidli 8y agoFor ICE trains, if you buy within one week for that distance you pay 120-150E. But if you buy 2 weeks or more ahead of time there are steep discounts. Prime time likely 80E, I did similar distance for midnight or the 4-5am trains for 30-60E.
- scurvy 8y agoI thought train systems were heavily subsidized by the state across Europe. Why are tickets so expensive? The distance isn't far at all, by American standards I'd expect to pay roughly $20-30 for a train ticket across that distance. 150 EUR you should be able to fly for that price.
- rayiner 8y agoGerman/UK/French trains are less subsidized than in the U.S. That is to say, the government subsidizes the capital costs, but not the operating costs. 150 euro is not expensive for that distance. That's almost as long as DC to Boston, which is a $200+ Amtrak ticket (Northeast Regional, not even Acela) during business hours on a weekday.
- the_mitsuhiko 8y agoThe systems in Germany, Switzerland and Austria are only cheap if you get a discount card or book tickets ahead of time. Once you have a discount card they are very cheap though.
- dagw 8y ago150 EUR you should be able to fly for that price. Taking the train between major cities is often more expensive than flying in Europe. People choose the train because it's comfortable and convenient, not because it's cheap. Also 150 EUR is a full price ticket. If you book a few weeks in advance, and are willing to take the 'slow' train you can probably get a ticket around 30 EUR.
- gpvos 8y agoDepending on the route, often even on the day before. On more popular routes, prices rise more quickly though.
- gpvos 8y agoLong-distance services run with no or little subsidies. Regional services, especially in rural areas, are fairly heavily subsidized.
- Rockslide 8y agoOn the new line you don't see much more than noise barriers and tunnels though.
- melling 8y agoThe distance appears to be about the same as Los Angeles to San Francisco.
- gok 8y agoNot with the route the California High Speed Rail is using. Phase 1 of CAHSR will be 840 km, this route is quoted at 623 km.
- melling 8y agoAbout 135 miles. Will the CA train run at 186 mph or 220 mph? This will translate to an extra 30-45 minutes?
- gok 8y agoParts 220, parts much slower (more like 120 from San Jose to San Francisco, for example). By the way, CAHSR predicts ridership 20-30x higher than that mentioned in this headline.
- Scoundreller 8y agoDuring Oktoberfest... 2012, we stayed during the week in Munich and then planned on leaving for Berlin before the weekend. I recall the cost of 2 train tickets being comparable to gas and 1 day 1-way rental for an entry level Mercedes (E class perhaps?). Autobahn or train... it wasn’t a hard choice. Edit: As Canadians, we took the car rental. We couldn't turn down an experience of no-speed limits, even if driving is work.
- nisa 8y agoYes. Regular ticket prices for trains are horrible expensive in Germany. You can pay a yearly fee (called Bahncard) to get 25% (62€) or 50% (255€) off. There is also a flatrate for everything called Bahncard 100 (4.270€) You can also book early. Often you get a ticket for 20-60€ but these are limited. At least they made an UI for this: https://ps.bahn.de/preissuche/preissuche/psc_start.post?dbkanal_007=L01_S01_D001_KIN0014_sparpreisfinder-content-button_LZ03#stay https://ps.bahn.de/preissuche/preissuche/psc_start.post?dbka... If you don't use ICE/IC you can get a daily flatrate for 44€ for whole Germany or for 20-25€ for one (or multiple) federal states. Now we often have empty trains and busses are on the Autobahn...
- scurvy 8y agoWhy are the prices so high?
- nisa 8y agoIt's difficult. They privatized everything in the early 90ies and even attempted to go to the stock exchange - this resulted in cuts and bad long-term decisions - now most of the Deutsche Bahn is public owned but a private company. They probably want to make some profit where it's possible. They need to invest a lot of money in the coming years because their infrastructure is crumbling and running on attrition. Here are the prices vs. inflation: https://media0.faz.net/ppmedia/aktuell/wirtschaft/1643856533/1.2598616/default/die-preise-der-deutschen-bahn.jpg https://media0.faz.net/ppmedia/aktuell/wirtschaft/1643856533... However the price for a certain track depends on a lot of things and this new high-speed track has lot's of buisness customers that avoid a flight this way - so it's priced higher. It's a complicated system with lot's of subsidies, subcontractors and so on. There is a price to pay for using the track to a different company that runs the train... Another problem is that freight train traffic is even more expensive and they simply forgot to invest in the system for 30 years - now the Autobahn is clogged with trucks...
- maoistinquisitr 8y agoThe question is Does it make money? Every high speed rail system in the world I'm aware of loses money hand over fist. Buses and airplanes have obviated most of these systems.
- jakecopp 8y agoWith Sydney house prices 12.9 times the median yearly household income [1] second only to Hong Kong (SF is 9.1, Hong Kong is 19.4, San Jose is 10.3 and Vancouver is 12.6) would value capture make a similar high speed project work in Australia? Is the cost in the infrastructure or the rolling stock? Something like Newcastle <-> Sydney <-> Wollongong? [1]: http://www.abc.net.au/news/2018-01-22/australian-housing-unaffordability-experts-disagree-on-extent/9349796 http://www.abc.net.au/news/2018-01-22/australian-housing-una...
- oger 8y agoEven though the rolling stock is technically more advanced and loaded with sensors (sometimes resulting is degraded service aka. lower speed for security reasons) the main cost definitely lies in infrastructure. You basically need to rebuild the whole track for highspeed trains. And with Australia being a litigious nation it will also take a while to acquire and execute the land rights.
- 2sk21 8y agoThe line north of Sydney towards Grosford would have to be completely rebuilt to support fast service.
- robbiep 8y agoThere’s some enormous developments happening in gosford at the moment. Talk of building a medical research hub over the station (sort of like how the shopping centre is over Chatswood). Now if only there was a half hour train to the CBD you would be laughing
- jakecopp 8y agoI wonder if a high speed link to Newcastle via Gosford or a northern beaches link would be more politically doable.
- robbiep 8y agoIt would change things a lot - really spread the city that direction (and hopefully reverse some of the social problems that occur on the coast from having a lack of young professionals). I think it would also need a light rail connecting gosford - erina - terrigal - the entrance - wyong as well. Then you'd have a real transport system. unlikely to ever happen!
- cameldrv 8y agoThey had a "High Speed" line before, but it was on old tracks, and they had to use tilting trains. I took it a few times when I lived in Berlin. It was somewhat slower than driving. Still, the ICE is an excellent train. It's very punctual (Germans will complain when it's five minutes late), it's smooth, it's clean, the seats are comfortable, you can get a seat with a table if you want, there are power outlets, and if you get hungry, you can go get a snack, a beer, or a full dinner. It's just just a civilized, pleasant way to travel. The Internet, either through the DB system, or my normal 3G/4G tethering was a bit spotty, but I was nearly as productive on the train as I would have been at the office. At six hours Berlin-Munich, it was much nicer, less stressful, and more productive en-route than an airplane, but somewhat slower. At four hours, the train is a no-brainer. Air travel is the king of hidden time fees. They say that it's an hour from Berlin to Munich, but you have to show up at the airport an hour before the flight, it takes 15 minutes to get off the plane and get out to the curb, even if you didn't check a bag, it takes 40 minutes to get to the airport, and another 40 minutes to get from the airport to the city center. By the time you add it all up, 4 hours is how long it takes on the plane, and most of that is annoying stressful walking from one place to another, waiting in one line after another, cooped up in a tiny seat, and for maybe 30 minutes of the whole 4 hours, you can use your laptop and do something useful.
- jakobegger 8y agoI also love working on trains -- train rides are perfect for a few hours of distraction free coding. The best thing about trains is that you end up right in the city center, and you can often just walk wherever you need to go.
- GordonS 8y agoGlad it works for you, but I feel really nauseous after an hour or so of coding or reading while in a moving train, bus or car. I think this is quite common.
- jakobegger 8y agoWhat kinds of trains are you talking about? Coding on the bus or in a car makes me nauseous as well, but the train routes I usually take are an incredible smooth ride and don't induce nausea at all. (I'm in Austria, and we have the Railjet, which is similar to the German ICE)
- jakobegger 8y agoWhat the article forgets to mention: The train ride takes 3 hours 55 minutes.
- tialaramex 8y agoAlso, three times per day. You'd have to plan as you would with air travel so that you were at the station to catch these specific trains even if you weren't price sensitive enough to book a seat in advance. Three per day isn't enough for it to make sense to just show up and catch the next one.
- _Microft 8y agoThe faster ones that only need 4h are indeed going only three times a day but there is a connection every hour that takes 4.5h (on workdays from 6 am to 7 pm). Seems fine, I think? (Source: www.bahn.de, the official website of Deutsche Bahn)
- amzans 8y agoAs a frequent Berlin-Munich traveller, it’s such a joy to now be able to make this route in less than 4 hours directly from and to the city center. Last month I had to instead take a flight (direct ~1h) but it ended up being more stressful and pretty much taking the same time since you have to add the time it takes to get to the airport and go through security. Not to mention that the trains are quite comfortable and there’s lot of room to walk or even sit down at the on board bistro for a beer or some food.
- kome 8y agoWell, that took very long... it's 2018 and finally a real high-speed connection between Berlin and Munich. In France they had that since forever, and also Spain and Italy have a much better high speed network than Germany. If anything, why Germany is so late to the party?
- Kliment 8y agoBig mess of privatization of the rail operator and then decades of non-investment in infrastructure maintenance while overspending on badly planned flagship megaprojects (this one was completed 17 years behind schedule)
- tpm 8y agoGermany was divided - Munich in West Germany, Berlin in the middle of the eastern/socialist DDR. So there was the unification to do, with huge costs. Also there is no high-speed rail in the UK (except for the Channel Tunnel Rail Link).
- isostatic 8y agowhile that's true, intercity trains in the UK run at 125mph, which I believe falls into the "high speed" category in the U.S. Also frequency wise the Uk wins over this link. London to Edinburgh, 534km, takes 4h20 and runs every half hour. HS2 is under construction which is a true high speed line and will knock an hour off trips to Manchester, Glasgow and Edinburgh, and allow more frequent trains (the WCML can only support one train an hour to Glasgow for example as the lines south of Rugby are crammed - over 40tph in each direction, or one every 3 minutes on each track)
- MagnumOpus 8y agoHS2 will arrive in 15 years optimistically (20 years realistically) and will only get you from London to Leeds - the other half of the distance to Edinburgh or Glasgow will still be on slow tracks... Better than the US for sure but two decades behind FR, DE, IT or ES.
- hihat 8y agoI took this connection for the first time this week and I was really impressed. I even took a picture of the screen once it showed that we crossed 300km/h. They used the latest ICE model, wifi was really reliable and they now even offer onboard entertainment. You can watch tv shows, movies, get access to audiobooks etc. on your phone, tablet or laptop (even though the selection is still quite limited). The train is one of my favorite places to get work done. I always try to get a seat in the cabin where phone calls are not allowed.
- beeforpork 8y ago> DB will introduce the nre ICE 4 train on the route, which allow bicycles to be taken for the first time and with 830 seats provide 10% more capacity than the previous model. These ICE4 are the worst ICEs in terms of comfort. They've been reducing the distance between rows over the years, and it is now only 85cm. It used to be 102cm in the ICE1 -- that was cool. ICE2 had 97cm, ICE3 had 92cm, which was still comfortable for me. Now, 85cm is too short to sit comfortably if you are a tall person. The previous models all had good seats and enough space. But the ICE4 is awful. The seats are also too upright and the backrest can only be tilted when pulling the seat to the front, which is impossible for taller people because the legs will have no space. Without this, the seats are so upright they almost push you over. Naps are impossible due to this. And where some lordose support should be, there is a hole. I really hate the ICE4s, I always end up with a sore back. But sure, there is 10% more capacity thank you very much.
- nisa 8y agosame with the new ICs - I used to really enjoy going with a IC - even more than a ICE - now it's just a like white RE the seats also seem to be the same.
- ahartmetz 8y agoICE4 also has a maximum speed of "only" 250 km/h. Deutsche Bahn has apparently given up on higher speeds. By the way, even ICE1 trains are less comfortable than they used to be because the rubber rings in the wheels were removed for safety reasons.
- currysausage 8y agoYes, most German routes are not built for higher speeds, so it made sense to optimize new trains for cost and reliability instead of speed. But Berlin—Munich has a Vmax of 300 km/h, so it would only make sense to put more ICE 3 on that route. I doubt the ICE 4 info is correct.