30 ms·
Solar Surpasses Gas and Wind as Biggest Source of New U.S. Power
- mchannon 8y agoWith the appearance of the "duck curve", utility providers and customers are going have to reckon with the fact that a kWh of solar electricity at the noon hour is not worth the same as a kWh of solar electricity at 5pm. So long, dinosaur coal plants. My lungs are looking forward to solar eating the rest of your lunch.
- adventured 8y ago> So long, dinosaur coal plants. My lungs are looking forward to solar eating the rest of your lunch. Absolutely. The coal industry, like any industry, will obviously attempt to hang on as long as it can. However the US is down to a point where there are only ~50,000 coal mining jobs left (vs 175,000 in 1985). Solar, wind and natural gas can easily replace those. There's no way coal pulls out of this decline (EIA first quarter updated figures): https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/images/2018.03.20/main.png https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/images/2018.03.20/main.png
- Gibbon1 8y agoIt's not really about coal at this point the war is between solar/wind and natural gas.
- adventured 8y agoWhile I agree with that sentiment, when over a quarter of US electricity generation is derived from coal, it's still clearly about competing with coal to drive it into the ground. Between the US, Europe, Japan, China and India, there's about $23 trillion in economic activity that depends on coal. Certainly all the generation growth and replacement going forward is contained in that war between renewables and NG.
- pjc50 8y ago> competing with coal to drive it into the ground. Good choice of words, in that what we need to do with both coal and oil is leave it in the ground; which means that the people who've invested in its extraction need to be overcome somehow. Whether that's buying them out, making it uneconomic, or something more coercive.
- Gibbon1 8y agoI think my point is the economics and uncertainty for coal is so bad now it'll disappear even with idiots like the Trump administration trying to subsidize it. Coal usage in the US is down 1/3 in ten years and that's going to accelerate.
- gm-conspiracy 8y agoI see two to three coal trains a day come through my town, with at least 40 hopper cars of coal. The coal is still going somewhere. I assume overseas, but unfortunately (in this instance), as people of earth, we all share the same atmosphere.
- rsynnott 8y agoAssuming you live in the US, the US doesn't export much coal. It's going to remaining coal plants, probably. But these will eventually be decommissioned, and it's highly unlikely that new ones will be built.
- philipkglass 8y agoUS producers are trying to partially compensate for declining domestic demand with exports through new export facilities in California and Washington. Unfortunately, exporters may be able to force facility approvals through against local and state wishes: http://www.latimes.com/business/la-fi-oakland-port-coal-20180515-story.html http://www.latimes.com/business/la-fi-oakland-port-coal-2018... https://www.publicnewsservice.org/2018-05-15/energy-policy/6-states-join-fray-as-backers-attempt-to-revive-wash-coal-terminal/a62529-1 https://www.publicnewsservice.org/2018-05-15/energy-policy/6...
- mikeash 8y agoCoal still makes up about a third of US electrical generation. It’s declining, but it will take a long time to disappear.
- IkmoIkmo 8y agoIt'll take a little longer than you think. Further, you're referencing a coal job figure, which is meaningless in this context. Coal production in the US over the past decade was higher than ever, by quite a large margin too, it's just that humans are no longer necessary for much of it. I'm not a fan but these are the facts. Fortunately, production is now dropping worldwide, but it really is early days, it's still way up compared to 10, 20 or 30 years ago, and it certainly isn't because of renewables. It's a gas-driven change.
- magicalist 8y ago> Coal production in the US over the past decade was higher than ever, by quite a large margin too No it wasn't. It peaked in 2008 and is down quite a bit since then. 2016 production dropped 18% over 2015 and was the lowest since 1979. And despite the current administrations best efforts, 2017 production increased ~6% over 2016.
- ben_w 8y agoIsn’t this a 75% solved problem, because power generation and use were already out of sync due to people not working at night and a significant fraction of power generation being fixed-output such as nuclear?
- 2sk21 8y agoExactly - even in summer, I recall reading that utilities have been begging for power consumption.
- agumonkey 8y agoWith Power pack like products I also wonder if there's an opportunity to 'level wear' the energy demand programmatically.
- ben_w 8y agoA less smart version already exists. In the UK, some domestic energy is supplied at different costs at different times of day. This is optional and typically used for heating, but means that night time energy is cheap compared to daytime energy.
- agumonkey 8y agoof course, I got caught in my technological views, but the price ranges are made for this entirely
- distances 8y agoSome areas in Europe do offer spot pricing (~hourly interval IIRC) for electricity, even for consumers. I don't have such a contract, so I'm not sure how good the pricing APIs are for autoscaling your consumption.
- kasey_junk 8y agoSeveral utilities in the states offer hourly rates. Most use human behavior inputs (sms messages) to drive the changes but others actually deliver the spot prices via smart meters.
- jerven 8y agoA rather biased source for sure but last years first solar analyst day presentation had an interesting remark regarding the duck curve. See page 3 of http://investor.firstsolar.com/static-files/2c0866ad-c821-49f6-a212-bb3d9816db9d http://investor.firstsolar.com/static-files/2c0866ad-c821-49... But yes it is going to be harder and harder to compete with solar in a supply priced market.
- tomp 8y agoIs that file available anywhere else? I get "Access Denied".
- jerven 8y agoIt is the technology update from last (2017) first-solar analyst day. Page 4. Key part for the duck curve discussion is that there is a big duck curve on a low load day in May but no such duck curve on a high load day in August. Then they talk about how their solar is starting to be dispatchable (market wise) by curtailing production. I.e. if they commit to sell 80% of their production then 20% of it becomes available as dispatch able power. That only makes sense if the solar power is cheap enough. Which it is does in some situations in some markets.
- baud147258 8y agoThere's no content on page 3...
- jerven 8y agoSorry page 4.
- prolepunk 8y agoHere's pie-in-the-sky idea, what about building high-voltage transmission lines across the continent? In the case of US, New York at 8PM would get electricity from California at 4PM. There would be some losses from transmitting power for such large distance, but shouldn't it be better than just wasting energy or storing energy even less efficiently?
- kfarr 8y agoSeems like it's not such a crazy (pie in sky) idea after all: https://www.technologyreview.com/s/609766/how-to-get-wyoming-wind-to-california-and-cut-80-of-us-carbon-emissions/ https://www.technologyreview.com/s/609766/how-to-get-wyoming...
- sfsafsaf 8y agoIts not great. Even before solar the advantage of a cross continental TL were there (namely ironing out the demand curve, hydro storage, ect). To limit resistive losses you have to go to really high V -> massive pylons (there were some built behind the iron curtain). But you still have capacitive coupling (and reflections after the TL is larger than $\lambda$/10 -> You need to go to very low f or even DC But high V. DC is hard! and low f AC is massive. Ultimately it hasn't been done because it hasn't been worthwhile.
- lutorm 8y agoHVDC is harder than AC transmission, but isn't it a solved problem? "In July 2016, ABB Group received a contract in China to build an ultrahigh-voltage direct-current (UHVDC) land link with a 1100 kV voltage, a 3,000 km (1,900 mi) length and 12 GW of power, setting world records for highest voltage, longest distance, and largest transmission capacity." (From https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-voltage_direct_current https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-voltage_direct_current)
- asafira 8y agoCan you expend on some of these, or give a reference? Specifically, why does going to high voltage limit resistive losses? Why does really high V mean massive pylons? Why is low frequency AC massive?
- twothamendment 8y agoThere is a coal powered plant in Eastern Montana that is having troubles. "Data processing and blockchain interests are the latest entities to court the ailing Hardin Generating Station, a 109-megawatt coal-fired power plant that is seeking a buyer to avoid closure." - https://www.apnews.com/6a577c7d0dc1488b9481d03685950e96 https://www.apnews.com/6a577c7d0dc1488b9481d03685950e96 Great, now we can watch train loads of coal go into a building and bitcoins come out! Yeah, that is the smell of progress.
- Proven 8y ago...during daytime.
- announcerman 8y agoI wonder how will these new green energy sources affect the petrodollar once electric means of transportation start becoming commonplace. Will it have a big impact?
- seren 8y agoTransportation is still 92% petroleum https://www.eia.gov/energyexplained/?page=us_energy_home https://www.eia.gov/energyexplained/?page=us_energy_home It will take some times to replace all existing vehicules by EV. So it might be a bit early to ask the question.
- Retric 8y agoPrices are heavily linked to demand, further if demand starts to drop significantly some producers will try to dump as much as possible before their supply becomes 'worthless'. On the other hand many suppliers are rapidly running out of oil. IMO, it's going to get interesting.
- gm-conspiracy 8y agoIt is easier to convert an ICE to run on NG than electricity.
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> the petrodollar Petrodollar hypotheses get the dollar's hegemony in international trade backwards. Petrodollars (i.e. oil producers' surplus revenues invested in U.S. dollar denominated instruments [1]) don't cause the hegemony. The United States being (a) the only advanced economy not bombed to the 19th century post-WWII and (b) the world's largest single consumer market [2] created and create international holders of U.S. dollars. (In the initial case, thanks to Bretton Woods. In the recurring case, since Americans pay with U.S. dollars.) Those holders, in turn, drive demand for dollar-denominated investments. The interaction between these processes, international consumption by Americans and the reinvestment of international dollars, drives economies of scale in the American financial system. (It is why, until very recently, it was cheaper and faster to send U.S. dollars between two European capitals than initiate a Euro-denominated transfer.) TL; DR Every watt the U.S. generates from solar is a watt of (a) cheap, domestic energy and (b) petroleum the U.S. has the choice to export. Cheap and plentiful energy drives economies; economies, ultimately, drive demand for their currencies. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Petrocurrency https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Petrocurrency [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_largest_consumer_markets https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_largest_consumer_marke...
- pjc50 8y agoSlightly offtopic, but I do miss the blog http://www.theoildrum.com/ http://www.theoildrum.com/ for discussing energy issues - it had the highest quality discussions of the subject I've ever found on the internet. Is there a current replacement?
- nl 8y agoAnd it's going to get even bigger. Just yesterday they announced a 2.49kW/h deal for solar in Arizona[1]. That's cheaper than the "low" price of wind power (which is the cheapest source). [1] https://www.pv-magazine.com/2018/06/11/lowest-approved-solar-power-contract-in-the-united-states-2-49%C2%A2-kwh/ https://www.pv-magazine.com/2018/06/11/lowest-approved-solar... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cost_of_electricity_by_source#Lazard_(2017) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cost_of_electricity_by_source#...
- abainbridge 8y agoWow, that's cheap. To give some perspective, an average cyclist can sustain about 100 watts, so generating a kilowatt hour takes ten hours. You'd then need to eat about $5 worth of food to compensate for the exercise. So buying this electric is 200x cheaper than generating it yourself with a bicycle! At this point I'd like to start a flame war about the CO2 impact of cycling ;-)
- Kliment 8y agoTo clarify, that should be 2.49 cents (USD cents) per kilowatt-hour.
- epistasis 8y agoAnd today, there's a new low in Nevada: $0.002375/kWh on a 25 year contract. https://pv-magazine-usa.com/2018/06/12/would-you-pay-1-795¢-kwh-for-solar-power-in-2043/ https://pv-magazine-usa.com/2018/06/12/would-you-pay-1-795¢-...
- dalbasal 8y agoHere's what I'm looking forward to: a world where energy<>pollution. This whole period where energy production as our greatest environmental problem has promoted the wrong type of thinking. It's Energy austerity, the need to take steps back, slow or reverse progress. Since technology, industry and energy are so closely coupled, this has almost made futuristic thinking politically incorrect, or at least unpalatable. I want to get back to a future that's futuristic, where we can build 100X bigger, desalinate sweetwater rivers, have floating stuff all around us.... Basically, I want to get back to the old curve, where we make more energy every year and that's a good thing.
- roryisok 8y agoThe amount of energy sent our way from the sun every day is more than enough (I half recall a fact that one day of sunshine has the same energy as all the fossil fuels left on earth, someone correct me). I think with solar getting cheaper all the time the challenge is going to become storing energy cleanly and distributing it efficiently.
- trothamel 8y agoOkay, in December 2017, the US produced 345,939 GWH of electricity, of which 1,476 was solar. https://www.eia.gov/electricity/monthly//epm_table_grapher.php?t=epmt_1_01 https://www.eia.gov/electricity/monthly//epm_table_grapher.p... If you look at the best spots in the US in December, they seem to get about 4,500 watt hours per square meter per day. https://www.solar-electric.com/learning-center/general-solar-information/solar-insolation-maps.html https://www.solar-electric.com/learning-center/general-solar... So that means we'd need 76,875 square kilometers of solar to match the current generation of the US, not counting losses from storage. That's between the size of South Carolina, and West Virginia, just coated with solar panels.
- neolefty 8y agoOr 70% of Nevada. I for one welcome our paving-the-deserts-with-solar-panels robot overlords.
- reacharavindh 8y agoA dream would be to have onshore and offshore windmills where it makes sense, solar panels on most residential and commercial roofs, panels serving as roofs for car parking lots, hydro power generators where water flow needs to be regulated, and to supported such a renewable power generation - connected micro grids with local battery warehouses to serve as a power buffer. Some centralised govt provided services could be run on "excess power" such as pumping water to a overhead storage for a local community, or powering a water purification or sewage cleaning plant to run during periods of excess power. Now, I need to wake up and go get a coffee :-)
- roryisok 8y agoIt's a beautiful dream and I hope it happens
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> solar panels on most residential and commercial roofs If one's aim is progressing along the Kardashev scale [1], then the single metric to optimize is the cost, including of externalities, of energy. Rooftop solar seems doesn't seem to scale as efficiently, both in measured and externalized environmental costs (e.g. installer safety and carbon consumption), as utility solar. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kardashev_scale https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kardashev_scale
- reacharavindh 8y agoAdmittedly naive ask. I hear this argument that residential solar panels are not very cost-effective. A former colleague once told me that after Government subsidies, his break-even point for solar investment was 12 years. I didnt ask him at that time. I'm assuming he was referring to energy buyback from his utility provider for his math. Isn't that against their business incentive to support residential solar? If one has a house, and covers the roof with self-purchased solar panels, and hooks them up to a large enough battery-box, wouldn't it just be "I saved the cost I would have paid as my utility provider's bill"? That way the return on investment is more manageable and is without being held at the mercy of the power companies?
- kokey 8y agoThe success of solar (and the end of coal) is really a story of the success of natural gas. Gas turbine capacity was so cheap to deploy that most of what's deployed in the past is enough to cover demand, in other words there are very little 'new' gas generators coming online because they're not needed. Solar capacity is much slower to deploy, hence why we will see 'new' capacity added over a long time to come. This is also a good thing, since with gas you still need to provide it was gas and expand the sources of gas and without carbon capture of gas generation it still has co2 emissions. However, gas allowed a massive short term reduction in co2 emissions and displaced coal and will for a long time fill in where solar can't, until we find a way to store energy from coal and that way might actually be synthesised gas.
- api 8y agoGas can also be produced from biological and even synthetic processes. There's been a great deal of research in producing CH4 from CO2 and H2O using surplus electric power from wind, solar, and off-peak nuclear. That means someday all our gas turbines could double as battery discharge machines for a giant chemical battery and the existing gas transport and storage infrastructure could store and transport renewable energy. That's pretty nice from a recovery of sunk cost perspective. Coal and oil can pretty much only be economically obtained from fossil sources.
- ben_w 8y ago> Coal and oil can pretty much only be economically obtained from fossil sources. Given that vegetable oil can be used in a Diesel engine after being used for deep fat frying fish and chips, and given we currently over-produce food to the point that obesity is one of our largest health issues, I’m going to have to [citation needed]-you on that.
- AshleyGrant 8y agoA gas turbine and a diesel engine are two completely different things. The only thing they share is that they are internal combustion engines. A gas turbine is basically a jet engine.
- zer0faith 8y agoIs there a DIY on powering a whole house using solar panels that are independent of any company?
- EADGBE 8y agoSure there is, scale it yourself. I like Misouri Wind and Solar (https://mwands.com https://mwands.com). I've also looked into Wholesale Solar (https://www.wholesalesolar.com/ https://www.wholesalesolar.com/) which focuses on DIY installation and design.
- jonbarker 8y agoWe need multifamily dwellings with the feature of no utilities bill because of local renewable energy on site. This would be awesome. The current vision of the future being sold to us seems to be single family homes with electric cars in the garage and solar cells on the roof. A horrible use of land and not really scalable to global population levels given the rise of cities.
- have_faith 8y agoHow do you convince the middle class to accept this? It will be very difficult.
- epistasis 8y agoI think that much of the next generation middle class would gladly accept multi family dwellings if it means less driving, more walkable amenities, etc. The problem is that there's not enough of that type of development out there, and land ib those types of settings is therefore very expensive.
- EADGBE 8y ago> A horrible use of land and not really scalable to global population levels given the rise of cities. Think outside the bubble, though. There's unused land everywhere I look. Why are we dissing zero-emission cars and self-production of home energy?
- dashundchen 8y ago> Think outside the bubble, though. A single family homes and car mindset is the bubble, though. The US and much of the developed world has a problem of over-consumption, and shuffling to more power, some green, does not solve it. We need green energy, but if we want to reduce emissions we need to cut usage as well. The amount of energy needed to cart single occupancy cars, on hour long commutes through sprawling suburbs of energy guzzling single family homes is horribly inefficient, no matter how it's powered. Nearly a third of the energy consumed in the US goes to transportation. It makes no sense for multi-ton hunks of steel, plastic and lithium using tens of kW in energy to transport a 150 lbs person to work. Denser cities and towns organized around public transit, cycling, and walking knocks out a multitude of problems. 1. Reduced distances between home, work, and shopping and allow for healthier, emission-free walking and cycling 2. Increased density reduces per capita cost on infrastructure and services and makes fast, frequent transit a realistic alternative 3. Denser multifamily development offers efficiencies in shared heating and cooling systems, a major consumer of energy 4. Cutting back on sprawl reduces the amount of land developed and contaminated by development, and frequently preserves productive agricultural land from being permanently developed These aren't radical ideas. We have models throughout the world of greener, denser and healthier cities, mostly built before the auto.
- paidleaf 8y agoWhat clickbait nonsense and misleading nonsense. Solar accounts for 1.3% of our electric production. https://www.eia.gov/tools/faqs/faq.php?id=427 https://www.eia.gov/tools/faqs/faq.php?id=427 Saying that solar is the biggest source of "new" US Power is like if bill gates picked up a penny from the street and bloomberg saying picking pennies from the street is bill gates' biggest source of "new" wealth. I understand being pro-solar, I am too. But why is HN and much of social media rife with lies and misrepresentations about solar? Reading bloomberg and HN, you'd think solar was a significant contributor to energy and coal was dead. But that's just factually incorrect. And they been lying for years now. But most importantly, it's the scientific lies about energy production and solar that is bothersome. As if solar panels are the answer for coal. Natural gas ( a fossil fuel ) is why coal has leveled off ( not died but leveled off ). Solar had nothing to do with it. And coal is still the biggest source of electricity around the world and the 2nd biggest source in the US. Solar energy is going to be a minor part of the world's energy strategy unless a revolutionary breakthrough happens ( a significant breakthrough on par with cold fusion ). That's a basic fact of current state of physics. So sick of misleading clickbait from media outlets like bloomberg. Edit: If you want a total world view of energy sources. https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/9/9d/Bp_world_energy_consumption_2016.gif https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/9/9d/Bp_world...
- durkie 8y agoI think the misunderstanding here is that you're talking about now: "solar is 1.3% of our electric production", "coal is still the biggest source", etc. This, I believe, is missing the point of the article. The importance of noting that solar is the biggest source of new power is that is signifies the economics of power generation have changed. So sure, there's still lots of coal and there's still lots of natural gas. But if you're adding new capacity we're at the point where it makes more sense to build large solar arrays. So in a sense, this article is noting the beginning of the end for coal and natural gas. The present percent contribution of solar or coal is not so important.
- cgriswald 8y ago"New" is relative, hence the Bill Gates picking up the penny example. Sure, it's a true statement the second he picks up the penny, but it's not a meaningful one. In the case of the article, we are talking about a single quarter.
- gwbas1c 8y agoEven with a tariff on panels, the cost of a solar installation, with incentives, is still significantly cheaper than grid electricity. With federal and state incentives, my panels work out to about 4-5 cents a kilowatt hour. Normally I'd pay about 17 cents a kilowatt hour. (This makes running a space heater cost about as much as running a natural gas furnace.) Furthermore, my panels are financed with a fixed-rate loan instead of tied to market price of energy. That means the cost will never go up, but instead go to zero at the end of the loan.
- acidburnNSA 8y agoWith free fuel and falling supply chain costs this is all well and good. Worth noting is that the value of solar electricity goes down fairly sharply as a function of market penetration because of the intermittency. Once you start adding massive chemical electricity storage costs and environmental impacts get more gnarly.
- murph-almighty 8y agoWhat kind of environmental impacts? Also, what do we do with dead solar panels? Is there a recycling program, or research going into such a thing? I'm so excited for this news and I feel like these are pretty minor cons though.
- phinnaeus 8y agoGiant batteries aren't great for the environment because they involve heavy mining.
- jerrycruncher 8y agoAnd have a one to two decade lifespan, at best. After which you have to dispose of them.
- toomuchtodo 8y ago
- mrybczyn 8y agoI hope at least some of these panels are manufactured in the USA... Otherwise, it's another sector of the economy getting outsourced and impoverishing the north american economy in the long run.
- JudasGoat 8y agoTo put things in perspective. The amount of solar power produced in the US is roughly the amount estimated to be used in indoor cannabis growing. https://motherboard.vice.com/en_us/article/9a3bd8/growing-marijuana-uses-1-percent-of-americas-total-electricity-industry-says https://motherboard.vice.com/en_us/article/9a3bd8/growing-ma...
- kragen 8y agoNote that this 13% rise (1Q 2018 over 1Q 2017) is way below the 2010–2015 trend, even discounting 2016; the article shows US photovoltaic installations growing during that time by 55% per year. Trump is clearly having a huge negative impact. For better or worse, other parts of the world are not Trump-restricted, so PV is continuing its exponential trend there. Paidleaf raises the reasonable question in https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17292776 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17292776 as to why it matters when PV is only about 2% of US electric production (and thus about 0.6% of the total US energy maket). (The 1.3% number paidleaf gives is wrong; see https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/energy-environment/wp/2017/06/09/the-u-s-solar-industry-is-doing-just-fine-under-trump-for-now/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/energy-environment/wp/20... for more details, for example.) The reason is that exponential-growth phenomena, like the adoption of any new technology, are tiny for a long time until suddenly they aren't. If we suppose a 30% annual growth rate and an asymptote somewhere well above current world marketed energy consumption, then three years before PV is the majority of world marketed energy consumption, it will be only 32%; three years before that, only 17%; three years before that, only 8%; three years before that, only 4%; three years before that, only 2%, like the US's current electricity market. Of course, you could reasonably argue that an immense drop in PV's annual growth rate from 55% to 13%, or even the SEIA's projected 0% for all of 2018, indicates that we're already approaching the asymptote! And, if that's true, of course it's relatively inconsequential what happens with PV — it might eventually grow from 2% to 4% or 6% or something, but it'll never be a viable alternative to coal, and at worst it's a dangerous distraction from the necessary switchover to nuclear power. But every indication on the fundamentals is that this isn't the case. We aren't running into limits on energy demand, on raw-materials availability, or on solar-resource availability. Photovoltaic energy remains cheaper than other sources, even in the US — that's why it's the majority of new generating capacity — and panels continue to drop in price, indicating ample raw materials and a smoothly running supply chain. The majority of even high-solar-resource land is still not shaded by solar panels. (I'm not saying that shading the majority of high-solar-resource land with solar panels is a good thing or a bad thing. I'm saying that a scarcity of high-solar-resource land is not currently a factor that could cause solar adoption to level off.) bcatanzaro comments that the capacity factor for the solar panels on his house is about 12% https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17293375 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17293375 and so 55% of new installed capacity is actually much less when it comes to actual generation. But utility-scale solar's capacity factor is typically closer to 25% (I guess bcatanzaro didn't choose his house's siting and roof angle optimally for solar power generation, but utilities can; or maybe he just isn't dusting them) and the other new generation is almost entirely natural gas and wind, which generally also have very low capacity factors. Every indication is that economic development is still solar, and economic development is still happening, despite the gradual growth of what appears to be WWIII. It's just that the US is missing out.
- nickik 8y agoIf people on the left had the same obsession with nuclear that they have with solar climate change would be solved. Honestly it seems to me like 'liberals' (lack of a better term) are closing their eyes on this. This eternal year on year constant media bombardment about the successes of solar energy and in the last couple of years batteries is totally out of proportion with any realistic view of the current energy system or any energy system that could realistically exist in the next 10 years. What is ironic in this whole discussion is that while liberals can never stop pointing out how France is so much better in terms of health care system and child care and whatever else. The fact that France has abolished carbon in their energy production 40 years ago is somehow ignored. A modern industrial nation abolished carbon in 1970 with technology that is essentially from the 50/60. This success if it had been done with solar and wind would fly on every flag of every news paper and environmentalist poster. This could easily be repeated today in any other industrialized country. Switzerland and Sweden currently work like that (just with more water). What is really sad is that the carbon industry has discovered this in the 70s already. Carbon based energy producers have long supported anti-nuclear campaigns because they know it will be incredibly difficult for solar/wind to remove goal/gas as baseload powers and thus they are only a very, very long term thread to them. While a nuclear plant could be plopped down right next to every coal plant.
- toomuchtodo 8y agoNuclear is too expensive (billions of dollars per facility) and takes too long to build (10+ years), full stop. This doesn't even address the waste storage issue. France is going to need to address its expensive, aging nuclear generators at some point. By then, of course, solar will be much cheaper than it is today, and there will be more HVDC transmission lines shuttling power between EU countries.
- sergioj97 8y agoNuclear plants may be expensive, but it's still the cheapest energy out there. It's kind of misleading when you talk only about the cost of nuclear facilities and not about the efficiency in the long run. There are lots of legit arguments against nuclear energy, yet you chose to complain about the cost of the facilities or the time it takes to build them. Your only real point was the waste storage issue (the aging reactors problem is essentially the same as the cost problem). An airplane is also more expensive than a bike, and takes longer to assemble. This doesn't mean it has no use.
- sigzero 8y agoI'm curious if anyone has gone the Tesla Solar Roof route? https://www.tesla.com/solarroof https://www.tesla.com/solarroof
- WalterBright 8y agoWhen I flew to Munich a month ago for the D conference, I was impressed with all the rooftop solar and stretches of panels out in fields. I didn't do a count, but it looked like a good quarter to a third of homes had panels on the roof. Lots of random windmills here and there, too.
- XalvinX 8y agoYay! Now, if Trump would just spend that money he was going to subsidize coal mines with on training the miners to build, install, and service solar cells. The green energy revolution is one of the biggest economic opportunities in the history of the world. Are we going to let China have the whole thing?