20 ms·
I really wish all the car manufacturers would stop with this bullshit "you still have to be driving it" self driving nonsense. Claiming that the driver is stil
by olliej 8y ago
I really wish all the car manufacturers would stop with this bullshit "you still have to be driving it" self driving nonsense.
Claiming that the driver is still responsible for driving the car, while using a system designed to encourage the "driver" to not pay attention is a dumb idea, and all I can see is this kind of thing leading to regulations the delay actual self driving cars.
I'm not a self-driving car fanboy or anything. I don't think it's just around the corner, but it's clearly going to happen /eventually/ and I can't imagine it being more dangerous than regular drivers. But this kind of "self driving but not" features feel like the sort of thing that calls to government agencies for regulation, and sufficiently "dumb" mistakes from these systems seems like the sort of thing that triggers a reactive over-regulation.
- AceJohnny2 8y agoBlame Elon Musk. I'm serious. He's been promising "self-driving" for years, except the damn technology isn't ready/safe enough for what people are clearly using this from. The manufacturer puts a warning label, but the usage model/UI is clearly flawed. His engineers know this, which is why Tesla's self-driving group has had such a high turnover rate over the last few years. Musk keeps overriding them.
- ModernMech 8y ago> The manufacturer puts a warning label, but the usage model/UI is clearly flawed. Not just the model/UI but the actual sensor suite. Remember, the Tesla that resulted in a decapitation had over-saturated cameras that couldn't see a tractor trailer. Of course, that's where the UI comes into play, because if the driver hadn't been watching Harry Potter, he would have seen the tractor trailer as well.
- jfim 8y agoThat's the thing, how do you make an UI that unambiguously conveys that the car hasn't seen an object in front of it, so that the driver can react to it? Maybe with AR the car could highlight the objects detected so that the driver can brake if the car doesn't see an object it knows about, but a head mounted display seems pretty clunky.
- foota 8y agoI think the idea is that the UI needs to force you to always pay attention.
- jellicle 8y agoI don't think people realize that "Tesla Autopilot" will never, ever, ever stop for an object in front of it. Tesla has said repeatedly it isn't designed to do so. If you run a Tesla toward a brick wall with Autopilot on, it will crash into it 100 out of 100 times. It will hit ANYTHING in the lane ahead of you. It isn't designed to stop in such cases. So there's no need for a UI. If there's something ahead of you, you must stop or you will hit it full speed without braking.
- aetherson 8y agoWhat? That's not true. It can and does brake for objects in front of you that it senses. Its ability to sense objects is sadly very incomplete, but it does (quite often, but not often enough) successfully sense objects and slow or stop for them. See page 93 of this owner's manual, for example: https://www.tesla.com/sites/default/files/model_s_owners_manual_north_america_en_us.pdf https://www.tesla.com/sites/default/files/model_s_owners_man... (What it won't do is steer around obstructions in a lane, either full or partial.)
- beamatronic 8y agoWhat is the difference between “objects in front of you that it senses” and “obstructions in a lane”?
- aetherson 8y agoWell, I guess the second doesn't presuppose that it senses them. But I think you concentrated on the wrong thing: Autopilot is not designed to steer around obstructions. Autopilot is designed to brake for obstructions. It sometimes fails to brake for obstructions. But it sometimes succeeds in braking for obstructions. It never steers around obstructions, even if it senses them perfectly.
- jellicle 8y agoThe NTSB report said that the driver was not watching any movie.
- cma 8y ago> Of course, that's where the UI comes into play, because if the driver hadn't been watching Harry Potter, he would have seen the tractor trailer as well. Reports at the time said he was watching it on a portable DVD player, not the Tesla screen. Not sure about the NTSB report someone just cited though. If that report really said he wasn't watching anything, I wonder how that rumor started?
- deelowe 8y ago> because if the driver hadn't been watching Harry Potter This was proven to not be true: https://jalopnik.com/the-ntsb-to-partially-blame-teslas-autopilot-in-fatal-c-1803136365 https://jalopnik.com/the-ntsb-to-partially-blame-teslas-auto...
- dirkgently 8y agoTesla's "Auto-pilot" is one of the most blatant market-speak lies I have come across lately, and they have been getting away it.
- beamatronic 8y agoI feel like I-5 between SF and LA is probably one of the safer places to use it. Any place else, maybe not so much.
- wooter 8y agotypical fear-based, anti-freedom, anti-progress response in these comments. The NHTSA found a 40% crash rate reduction from Tesla's autopilot. So yea "blame Elon Musk"
- tptacek 8y agoNo, that's not at all clear, and is in fact unlikely; rather: some of the capabilities in the basket of features Tesla calls "autopilot" are associated with lower crash rates, and it's not at all clear which; there are steep reductions in accidents, possibly exceeding Tesla's numbers, from cars with automatic emergency braking. Just because AEBs are useful safety features does not mean that auto-steering is necessarily on net a safe feature.
- rohit2412 8y agoThank you for saying this. I'm just astounded people don't question things logically
- intortus 8y agoNo, the NHTSA found no such thing. They did, however, determine that Tesla was not participating in their investigations in good faith.
- simion314 8y agoThis is false, stop this Tesla propaganda with false facts.
- Apocryphon 8y agoIt's time to hold all of these tech CEOs accountable for their wild promises and myth-making at the expense of the public good.
- eanzenberg 8y agoIt’s pure arrogance. In the model 3 when you are in autopilot they have video games and memes to play/watch on the giant screen. How does this pass regulation and is allowed to be sold? Building products to actively distract an operator of a 2 ton vehicle moving 60 mph?
- mikeash 8y agoWhat are you talking about? There are no games or memes.
- eddieh 8y agoUm https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/998988641702526977 https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/998988641702526977
- mikeash 8y agoSuddenly we’re trusting Elon to deliver on his tweets?
- desdiv 8y agoHere are the easter eggs in action, on a production vehicle: https://youtu.be/1GrNv3ow9H8?t=640 https://youtu.be/1GrNv3ow9H8?t=640 Weird, the tweet was dated 2018-05-22 but the Youtube video shows easter eggs already deployed by 2018-05-23. I know all Tesla vehicles have automatic over-the-air updates but that's still surprisingly quick. Must be Musk playing around with his time machine again.
- ashleyn 8y agoI test drove a Volvo S90 recently. The Pilot Assist feature almost feels like a gimmick due to the attention required. If you don't give steering input in five seconds, Pilot Assist disables itself. It basically requires enough of your attention that there's little difference between using it and not using it. It seems pretty clear to me that Volvo only has Pilot Assist in the first place as a method to gather data via telemetry for the next generation of self-driving vehicles, because it otherwise doesn't seem to add anything useful to the driving experience. Consequently, I haven't heard of any notable incidents where Pilot Assist caused an accident. I haven't test driven Enhanced Autopilot but I see people on YouTube taking their hands off the wheel completely for much longer than the Volvo let me do. Tesla seems like they're pushing something half-baked out and representing it as something it isn't.
- MBCook 8y agoI’ve found lane keeping assistants to be fantastic, but you have to think of them as ASSISTING. It’s not going to drive for you. But it does an amazing job of basically canceling out crosswinds when you find yourself driving down the highway. It makes a huge difference, it makes it much less tiring/frustrating. Going slow on a windless day? Straight street? Not that useful. For helping with very gentle curves or very annoying crosswinds it’s quite nice.
- intortus 8y agoAnd for basic station keeping in relatively predictable stop and go traffic. It relieves you of some unnecessary micromanagement but it's not autonomous.
- vsl 8y ago> Consequently, I haven't heard of any notable incidents where Pilot Assist caused an accident. It may be, but is not necessarily “consequently”. That Volvo is not cool to write about plays a role. You don’t read about boring daily crashes either.
- Alex3917 8y ago> Blame Elon Musk. I'm serious. If you want to fix the problem, just charge him with attempted murder of a cop.
- buvanshak 8y agoEntities like Elon Musk is a symptom of the worsening of the disease of stupidity that has gotten hold of the global human population.... It is not really surprising when our whole system of existence has the stupidity and weakness of its inhabitants at its foundation. Point is, this will only get worse. Because any "progress" along the current lines asks the common man to be more stupid...
- admyral 8y agoNo offense but this is exactly the attitude that inhibits progress and led the auto industry to languish in mediocrity for years. If you wait until the technology would prevent all accidents, you'd be waiting forever.
- api 8y agoIt needs to be as good as an average human. Do we have enough stats to compare yet?
- admyral 8y agoAs good as a human at what? It's 100% better at not falling asleep behind the wheel or driving while under the influence which statistically are the most common cause of traffic accidents.
- jcims 8y agoThey are falling way behind in blasting errant pedestrians. Stories from the last 24hrs. https://www.google.com/search?q=pedestrian+killed&prmd=nvi&source=lnt&tbs=qdr:d&sa=X&biw=414&bih=660 https://www.google.com/search?q=pedestrian+killed&prmd=nvi&s...
- foolfoolz 8y agotell this to the families of the people who have died
- wooter 8y agoThe NHTSA found a 40% crash rate reduction from Tesla's autopilot. So how about you tell all the people who lives have been saved that you wish they hadn't been because you're an emotional reactionary
- olliej 8y agoI believe many people have found issues with the data used and how they were prevented. Also it's worth comparing the common case of accidents - bumper to bumper, etc on a freeway which I'd except all self driving systems to instantly reduce the rate of just by increasing the distance to the next car - to the number of serious crashes - e.g. driving into parked vehicles, concrete pillars - those have entirely different failure modes. That said, the reality is that the types of self driving systems currently deployed - Tesla or whomever - are all fundamentally flawed because they do two things: * Require attention from the human driver at all times * Cause driver inattention The first is fairly clear, literally every one of these products is prefaced with "the driver is still in control of the vehicle and must remain attentive", and the latter is clearly demonstrated because of all of the different mechanisms that the manufacturers are deploying to try and deal with the fact that if you tell a human to pay attention to a specific task, but they aren't doing that specific task, they will not pay attention. Every system tried just increases the time required for a human driver to adapt to unconsciously managing the various "pay attention" alarms. The solution is fully self driving cars. We don't have that yet. I fully expect them to be safer once we get there.
- ajross 8y ago> except the damn technology isn't ready/safe enough for what people are clearly using this from Outrageously false. These incidents are so rare that they have whole news stories written about every single one. How many crashes were there in Laguna Beach yesterday? Tesla accident rates in aggregate are quite good. Under autopilot the data is noisy but still underneath the level of an average car (not as low as luxury vehicles in the same price range, though). Claiming that it "isn't ready" is innumerate nonsense. It could clearly be better, sure. So could you. And no one is demanding to revoke your license, because you aren't a scary AI.
- cromwellian 8y agoHow many Tesla's are there? How many crash without autopilot, and how many crash with autopilot? How does this compare with other low-ownership rate cars in the same class? Seems to me that it's premature to me making bold claims like this. Of cars costing over $100k, what's the accident rate?
- ajross 8y agoThere were numbers thrown around in the last thread on this, I gave you my memory. The answer is "Teslas are safe enough". Human drivers with the same accident rate wouldn't raise even a hair on an eyebrow. And the "bold claims" bit is exactly backward. You are the one claiming that the technology "isn't ready" based on sensationalist local news story and not actual numbers.
- olliej 8y agoThe problem is that the argument being presented: "self driving is safer" is defeated by very obvious failures (driving into pillars, police cars, and people) that are /exactly/ the kinds of things that a computer should be able to handle. Human caused accidents in these situations are almost invariably due to inattentiveness that should not apply to any automated system. So we get to the problem of "if it can't do handle the specific obvious case where it should be absolutely superior" (I would argue an automated system should not have ever been able to make either the police cruiser or the 280 crash in any circumstances. Those were both in perfect conditions - clear weather, etc, etc), how can we trust it to handle any of the complex situations that a self driving car necessarily must handle? The Tesla system solves this by simply saying "the driver is still driving, we're merely assisting", but that assistance leads to inattentiveness - that's human nature, you have to design around it - which should be fine, if the systems were able to handle that, but that clearly are not. I would argue that given the configuration of the Tesla system they are less safe, not necessarily due to net accidents, but rather because of the failure modes of the accidents. Bumper to bumper accidents on a freeway happen all the time, even driving perfectly you can end up in them because not everyone else is driving perfectly. The problem with things like the Tesla system is that it's generally fine, except in those cases where it drives at speed into objects because it gets confused. If your vision or mental state leaves you unable to safely account for large obstructions you aren't allowed to drive. Because it isn't safe.
- mrb 8y ago«the damn technology isn't ready/safe enough» What data are you basing this statement on? Or is this just your vague gut feeling based on reading about a few accidents in the news? I thought statistical data showed otherwise, that the technology was safe enough (ie. better than humans). Edit: removed "debunked stats".
- _Codemonkeyism 8y agoThese numbers from Tesla have been debunked several times (see every older discussion on this on HN) because of the flawed methodology (mostly comparing apples to oranges).
- perl4ever 8y agoReading that blog entry makes me more distrustful of Tesla than I was, because I don't think it's appropriate to compare Autopilot miles to generic human driver miles. Autopilot is not suitable for all types of driving. The most readily accessible statistics that would be more comparable would be fatalities on interstates. US interstate deaths are about 1 per 183 million miles, so while Autopilot may be safer, it's not as clear depending on the uncertainty of the 320 million mile figure. Also, German drivers on the autobahn have roughly half the fatality rate, which is better than the claim for Autopilot. All in all, I think an honest assessment would be that it's probably as good as an average driver in good conditions who isn't drunk. But rhetoric about saving 900K lives raises my hackles - I do not want to trust the source of this sort of PR with my life.
- Iv 8y agoNope, I am still blaming government (and I am in no way a Musk fanboy) Self-driving tech has been there for decades. Convoy driving of trucks (one human-driven truck in front, several trucks following its lead) on highways was developed in the 90s. On well-maintained infrastructures, automated driving is a problem that was solved before deep learning. The fact that we don't have an automatic lane-driving mode for highways as a standard feature in new cars is a political failure. In 1997 a huge and successful demonstrator for an automated highway system was made. And legislator did not follow up by allowing on the road the systems they spent more than 10 billions to develop. [1] In my opinion, a technology should be considered ready/safe enough if it is x times safer than the average driver. Zero accident is a crazy requirement. 10 times safer as human is much more reasonable but no politician will accept that. And obviously it is easier to develop a safe system on some well known and well maintained road segments (e.g. highways) than on 100% of the roads and dirt roads on the North American continent. So yes, the only way for an economic actor to get into there is to bend the existing rules, as rules for automated vehicles were never made. You can't sell a car saying "no need to look at the road, I'll drive for you" so you put a disclaimer, while making sure people understand that you actually made a self-driving car. You can't sell a self-driving car and argue that your rate of accident is acceptable because the laws for such a notions are not there. A single accident in your self-driving car (that may be 10 times safer than a manual car) and you will be considered responsible. [1] https://www.smithsonianmag.com/history/the-national-automated-highway-system-that-almost-was-63027245/ https://www.smithsonianmag.com/history/the-national-automate...
- bazooka2th 8y agoFrom Wired's "People Keep Confusing Their Teslas for Self-Driving Cars" (https://www.wired.com/story/tesla-autopilot-crash-dui/ https://www.wired.com/story/tesla-autopilot-crash-dui/): A spokesperson pointed out that the owner's manual reads, “Autosteer is not designed to, and will not, steer Model S around objects partially or completely in the driving lane”. I haven't seen the encouragement to not pay attention. In some ad on TV, maybe it was for a new Cadillac, the driver opens a soda with both hands off the wheel, and that seemed to be as far as they were willing to go.
- na85 8y agoIt's called "Autosteer". That's misleading to non techies who don't have a firm grasp on the limitations of the tech. They should be legally required to call it something like "lane assist".
- bazooka2th 8y agoYou're right, 'lane assist' is probably more appropriate. However, it's not 'autobrake' or 'auto-no-crash', the feature is actually called 'autopilot'. (why does that article say 'autosteer') An autopilot maintains heading, and that's all. Many sailors are not techies --- an autopilot on a boat will run you right into an obstacle.
- mikeash 8y agoIt says “autosteer” because that’s the name of one of the components. Tesla’s Autopilot is autosteer, traffic-aware cruise control, and some safety features like automatic emergency braking.
- ceejayoz 8y ago> An autopilot maintains heading, and that's all. Aircraft autopilots can follow a flight plan, maintain an altitude or rate of climb/descent, do an instrument approach, and (using ADS-B) perform an automated avoidance maneuver when another aircraft is too close.
- acct1771 8y agoAgree, except self driving car regs have been published.
- foobar1962 8y ago>I'm not a self-driving car fanboy or anything. I don't think it's just around the corner, but it's clearly going to happen /eventually/ ... Self driving vehicles have been used at Rio Tinto's Pilbara mine for a couple of years. Sure, it's on private land and the complexity of the task is far smaller than for public roads, but it's happening now. http://www.abc.net.au/news/2015-10-18/rio-tinto-opens-worlds-first-automated-mine/6863814 http://www.abc.net.au/news/2015-10-18/rio-tinto-opens-worlds...
- romwell 8y agoOne can also see elevators as self-driving electric vertical motion vehicles. Sure, they are not operating on public roads, and the extra constraints reduce complexity, but they've been around for a while. Personally, I don't see mining operations as anything remotely close to public roads autonomous vehicles because you have a controlled environment in which paid workers that have been trained to interact with equipment and be aware of its limitations and dangers are performing the said interactions in a strictly constrained manner with the autonomous equipment clearly visible as such and while protected by all kinds of insurance and work-specific regulations. There's none of that even in the testing stage of current "autonomous" driving vehicles.
- Retric 8y agoVery large work sites are far from completely controlled environments. Visitors, wildlife, weather, equipment malfunctions, human error, and a host of edge cases from trespassers to protesters.
- lazyasciiart 8y agoVisitors, trespassers and protesters are all a very remote possibility in the Rio Tinto mines mentioned, and certainly wouldn't be a surprise if they did show up.
- zorpner 8y agoSee neighbor comment from someone who actually knows of what they speak: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17184043 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17184043
- omarforgotpwd 8y agoSo then we should ban cruise control too? No, we should educate people how to use new technologies properly.
- readhn 8y agocruise control - means just controlling cruising speed. thats all. Constant 55mph or whatever speed you desire. Auto pilot literally means vehicle operation without human participation. The name autopilot should be banned.
- hn_throwaway_99 8y agoIf Tesla called Autopilot "cruise control with lane-keep assist", I think people would be a lot less likely to abuse it. By calling it Autopilot (and even letting people pay for "full self driving capability" in advance) is enticing people to use it dangerously.
- omarforgotpwd 8y agoFirst of all, they do call it that. There is no “turning on AutoPilot”. You turn on “traffic aware cruise control” and “Autosteer” separately. You can turn on TACC and not autosteer, or turn them both on, or drive yourself and switch between these modes very easily. Collectively the self driving features come in an “Enhanced Autopilot” package which you can purchase to have those individual features enabled. Secondly, I have a Model 3. The idea that the name is misleading people is the dumbest thing i’ve ever heard. Even if people were confused, their confusion would be cleared up very quickly within a few days of use. When you pick up the car they talk to you extensively about what it can and can’t do, and there are many warnings in the car that explain it. People who make this argument probably haven’t tried using AutoPilot. Put this is context. you can’t just release a perfect system on day 1. In order to get the software to that level earlier versions need to be seeded into the public. I am 100% convinced the software is a huge safety and convenience win as it is.
- jonknee 8y agoI don't follow it super closely but there is exactly 1 car manufacture that I can think of guilty of pushing the self driving myth. The established car makers seem to market it as an assist, not as an autopilot. Tesla is the outlier, everyone else is much more conservative.
- hndamien 8y agoAuto pilot != Self driving. People love to conflate these two so much that the people saying it rely on everybody else conflating it to justify their ignorance. This is just like Fox "some people say" - Fox people say! Or Javascript Bitcoin miners - Monero is not Bitcoin! It's snowing so there is no global warming - It is "climate change" but the entire globe is warming! This hurricane is just weather, not climate change - it is the 10th 1 in 500 year hurricane we have had this month! I could go on. Sure, talking about the future self driving features (and selling them) is poor form to avoid this from Tesla, so they aren't helping - but they have always been clear that it is not self driving. It is the listeners/ readers that are incorrectly connecting the dots.
- jonknee 8y agoWell then maybe they shouldn't call it auto pilot? I mean, how dumb of a name could they have chosen if they didn't want people to think the car can drive itself? They should also retrain their sales staff because on my test drive the saleswoman specifically told me the car could drive itself and that I should take my hands off the wheel to test it out. They should also retrain their CEO who keeps talking about "self driving" in reference to existing cars: https://www.tesla.com/blog/all-tesla-cars-being-produced-now-have-full-self-driving-hardware https://www.tesla.com/blog/all-tesla-cars-being-produced-now... > "All Tesla Cars Being Produced Now Have Full Self-Driving Hardware"
- hndamien 8y agoHave full self driving hardware != full self driving software != full self driving capabilities. Auto pilot - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Autopilot https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Autopilot "An autopilot is a system used to control the trajectory of an aircraft without constant 'hands-on' control by a human operator being required. Autopilots do not replace human operators, but instead they assist them in controlling the aircraft. This allows them to focus on broader aspects of operations such as monitoring the trajectory, weather and systems.[1]" You are doing the exact conflating I am referring to.
- smnrchrds 8y agoWe have seen time and time again that if corporations can wash their hands off of something, they do so. For the past few decades, and perhaps for much longer, the operating principle of corporations have been "if it's not illegal, it's moral." As an example, rationally speaking credit bureaus and financial institutions are 100% responsible if they give someone a loan or open an account for them under your name. But they were allowed by the legal system to put the onus on the victims of the fraud to prove they are victims not perpetrators of it, and they called it "identity theft" instead of "bank fraud," and now we have victims who never did anything wrong or could have done anything differently battling CRAs and FIs for years to get out of a situation they should have never been put into in the first place [0][1]. If the laws allow companies to sell Level 5 autonomous vehicle while keeping the passenger (because it's not really a driver anymore) responsible for all legal matters, they would do so, and they would lobby against any law which puts the burden correctly where it belongs. And we would be forced to put our financial, mental, and legal well-being on the line just to get from point A to point B because it will be impossible to avoid autonomous tech then like it is impossible to avoid credit bureaus now. [0] Like this case: http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/manitoba/credit-report-error-fraud-walmart-equifax-transunion-1.3864593 http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/manitoba/credit-report-error-f... [1] Obligatory Mitchell and Webb: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-c57WKxeELY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-c57WKxeELY
- dirkgently 8y ago> If the laws allow companies to sell Level 5 autonomous vehicle while keeping the passenger (because it's not really a driver anymore) responsible Well, law is allowing Tesla to sell a Level 1 vehicle as Level 5. They have to start applying false advertisement laws first before they can think about other laws.
- rdiddly 8y agoDon't you see? When it's time to buy the car, it's self-driving. When it's time to take responsibility for avoiding obstacles, you're the one driving.
- modzu 8y agoits utterly insane uh, isn't a self-driving car you have to drive an oxymoron?? does anybody understand words??
- hedora 8y agoFrom the article: > "Tesla has always been clear that Autopilot doesn't make the car impervious to all accidents, and before a driver can use Autopilot, they must accept a dialogue box which states that 'Autopilot is designed for use on highways that have a center divider and clear lane markings,'" a Tesla spokesperson said in an emailed statement. From the picture at the top of the story, it is clear there is no divider on the stretch of road where the accident occurred. Maybe it should detect when it is being misused, and start blaring loud noises, do its best to make the driver carsick, or simply immobilize the car.
- cma 8y agoMusk demos auto-pilot to the press in response to a recent crash in an area that is: A) not a highway, and B) has no lane dividers: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AO33rOofFpg&t=2m18s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AO33rOofFpg&t=2m18s Also takes his hands off the wheel while using it in a manner that if someone else did and died, Tesla would slam them in the press for doing so, using dodgy-from-a-privacy-perspective and potentially-inaccurate (frequent reports of hands on wheel false negatives) telemetry.
- paulcole 8y agoJust read their autopilot page and tell me it’s not intentionally misleading to the average person: https://www.tesla.com/autopilot https://www.tesla.com/autopilot
- api 8y agoSelf driving strikes me as a technology with a hard boolean quality threshold. Either it is as good as a human or it just doesn't work. This is a lot like rocketry. A rocket that meets 95% of its design requirements explodes, crashes, or fails to reach the proper orbit. Its damn near 100% or failure. Too bad Elon can't see this. I think Tesla's obsession with autopilot is misplaced. Give me a solid reliable affordable EV with good range. Autopilot would be nice but only if it works. I can wait for that. But a solid EV is something I'm actually more excited about believe it or not. I'm sort of afraid Tesla will throw the whole game in pursuit of self driving tech.
- tim333 8y agoElon's argument is that it meets your hard boolean quality threshold and is as good as a human, and he's aiming for 10x lower accidents than humans. That may not be true but that's what he's going for.
- prawn 8y agoI think he can see it, but the first seriously solid entrant into the space is going to have a huge advantage and so that drives their interest in Autopilot. Eventually, you're not marketing to consumers but to fleet owners. Outside of that, he's in the grey area where he can build product excitement and fall back onto the "Keep your hands on the wheel" type of fineprint. I agree with those saying that it's far from ideal.
- cmurf 8y agoCadillac Super Cruise doesn't claim you still have to be driving it. It's hands free. It watches your eyeballs to make sure you're paying attention, otherwise it drives the car. But it only does this on specifically supported roads. It also doesn't claim to be fully autonomous.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- gU9x3u8XmQNG 8y ago> I really wish all the car manufacturers would stop with this bullshit "you still have to be driving it" self driving nonsense. To align with your statement, I can state; "I really wish all people would stop this bullshit "auto pilot means it can drive itself and I don't have to do anything" nonsense. I feel this is quite a critical analysis of an ambiguous product title; [1]'Telsa Autopilot (& Enhanced Autopilot)'. I read the title; "Tesla in Autopilot mode crashes into parked Laguna Beach police cruiser"... and wondered how this article is even news.. Where, besides future plans for their vehicle product (Which, as suggested by Wikipedia - may be an independent product itself, and not an extension 'Tesla Autopilot / Enhanced Autopilot'), does Tesla's product in question indicate it's self driving? Autonomous Car? I do admit, the 'summon' feature of their vehicles makes this slightly confusing... Additionally; what is the criteria to be 'self driving'? I assume; you are talking about 'auto pilot'..? If so; this over-simplifies the entire scenario. The very definition, and scope, of the title 'autopilot'/ 'automatic pilot' is far from specific. In fact; most of them are applicable only to [2]aerospace. > Claiming that the driver is still responsible for driving the car, while using a system designed to encourage the "driver" to not pay attention is a dumb idea, and all I can see is this kind of thing leading to regulations the delay actual self driving cars. This part of your post, I actually agree with. Having said that; I believe this is more so associated to an applied opinion of what a 'self driving' car is, and what we are seeing with these vehicles - and not because of any lack of technology advancements. But again; I urge caution in applying your, or anyone else', opinion of what a 'self driving' car is. FINALLY: I really wish we could start taking some responsibility of what we agree to. If the driver, even once, must agree to a clear scope of requirements to use the product - then blatantly disregards this; how, or why, is this even news? We all accept terms and conditions of use, and privacy policies - with almost every product we use - and don't expect to be shown them every time we use that same product. I'm one of the few that read these documents - and more often than not; refuse to use the product. I made the choice not to agree. There's other comments to this article that clearly indicate they believe a 'once off' popup is questionable at best - but I really don't understand this. Without a doubt; having to push a button to enable this Telsa/Enhanced 'Autopilot' feature, then scroll through a dialog to the end (Yes, okay, exaggerated) - and then click 'ok' would be a huge hazard. I don't believe the user should be prompted with the same notice every time they use a product. However; I do not necessarily believe prompted once is the right answer. What if someone else uses the vehicle? Or you sell it? I do not pretend to have the answers... -- Disclaimer; I know Wikipedia is not gospel. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tesla_Autopilot https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tesla_Autopilot [1.1] https://www.tesla.com/blog/dual-motor-model-s-and-autopilot https://www.tesla.com/blog/dual-motor-model-s-and-autopilot [1.2] https://www.tesla.com/autopilot https://www.tesla.com/autopilot [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Autopilot https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Autopilot
- danepowell 8y agoIt's not even necessarily a matter of inattention. Imagine that the autopilot was driving along just fine, and when it was just a few feet away from the parked cruiser suddenly veered towards it for whatever reason. It might be physically impossible for any human, no matter how well they are paying attention, to intervene and avoid a collision. I'm not saying that's what happened, but it's certainly possible. The mere fact that it's possible to me casts doubt on this entire design philosophy.
- true_religion 8y agoI agree, they should publicly distance themselves from the self-driving monicker until they at least reach level 4 coverage. At level 3, this should be at best described as 'driver assistance', or maybe a more descriptive but less palatable marketing term could be 'training wheels'---you still have to drive, but if you take your eyes off the road you might not die immediately like in a 'real' car.
- givinguflac 8y agoTo be fair, the system really isn’t designed to encourage the driver to not pay attention. Quite the opposite.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]