17 ms·
One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Nightmare
- Gravityloss 8y agoMiami also has a cool small futuristic monorail. It's free too, recommended for the views!
- rileyphone 8y agoIt is pretty cute, though it's slow, unreliable, and services only three neighborhoods. I live 50 ft from a stop and rarely find myself using it.
- Gravityloss 8y agoYeah, I guess most such things would need a big network effect to be successful. I don't know which places people go to in Miami anyway, besides the beach ;)
- HarryHirsch 8y agoCommuters between Miami and Ft Lauderdale can already take Tri-Rail; service started in 1990. What's missing?
- jabgrabdthrow 8y agoThis one goes to west palm beach and eventually to Orlando. I think it is faster too but not sure.
- josephpmay 8y agoDouble average speed, fewer stops, station is in Downtown FTL instead of West of I95, doesn’t have the stigma that it’s what poor people take when they can’t afford a car
- Nition 8y agoThey are actually careful not to say the average speed, only the top speed. But they then compare the top speed to the average speed of cars.
- rayiner 8y agoIt’s slow and has too many stops. It’s a problem with public transit in general: it can’t figure out what it wants to be. Is it core infrastructure to get people to work? Is it a life line for people too old or poor to drive? Etc.
- yardie 8y agoI'm a Miami commuter for the moment and I know the ins and outs of this system as I guess I'm in the minority of Miami commuters who actually try and use mass transit. Tri-rail is strictly a commuter train and is not an intercity train. Except for West Palm Beach all the train stations are just outside the main corridors of major cities, along I-95. You'll need to take a bus, shuttle, rideshare or taxi into the city center. Miami has it far worse as Tri-rail doesn't follow the I-95 corridor and heads west to Hialeah. Basically dropping you off into a train yard where you then have to take the metrorail into the city of Miami. Brightline is another attempt at creating real intercity rail. A few stops at major cities. There is parking but it is not commuter park and ride. Btw, I don't own a car. I use mass transit, rideshare, and care hire. In South Florida I'm a bit of an anomaly.
- fma 8y agoI don't understand it either. I'm originally from Fort Lauderdale. The Fort Lauderdale stop is in downtown Fort Lauderdale. If you work there you probably live in Broward. I suppose it gives people waaay in the future to live near a station in Miami and Palm Beach and commute down on the train. My guess is they are banking on ridership to Orlando. It talks of connecting to Atlanta, and other cities, which would be nice. I've transplanted to Atlanta and would take a train over driving or flying (at a reasonable cost) in a heart beat.
- djsumdog 8y agoI really hope they succeeded. Imagine if one day we had rail from Orlando up to Atlanta, and then on to Chattanooga, Nashville? ... I think once we saw really good high speed systems, Americans would demand more. Florida and California are the two hot spots right now that really need to succeed. I don't think I'll see real high speed rail expansion in the US before (if) I reach retirement age, but I think it will greatly benefit the next generation. But for that to happen, it needs a lot of support to expand now.
- spc476 8y agoSouth Florida (area between Jupiter and Homestead) is roughly 100 miles north to south and about 15 miles east (Atlantic Ocean) to west (Everglades swamp) so it's a narrow stip of land. Tri-Rail runs mostly (but not entirely) along I-95 (about 2 to 4 miles from the Atlantic Ocean). Nice if you live near a Tri-Rail station, or work near a Tri-Tail station, but that's not the majority of people, who have to travel a significant portion east/west. Again, nice if you have a car. Less so if you don't [1]. [1] Years ago, some friends and I took public transportation from Boca Raton to the Miami Zoo. One way took over three hours and involved several transfers between rail and bus systems.
- fma 8y agoHow does a train that has 3 stops in south Florida going to solve the problem? People will still need to move east/west. At least tri rail has more stops, so you don't need to move north/south as much. Additionally Brightline schedule is showing a train every 2 hours. I don't believe their target audience is commuters, but people flying into MIA and stopping in Fort Lauderdale, Palm Beach or Orlando - or vice versa, from Orlando to down south.
- cdelsolar 8y agoTri-rail is basically ratchet AF and slow, but it is convenient if you have nothing else.
- BurningFrog 8y agoThis is a sadly dishonest sounding comparison... "The train runs at a top speed of 79 miles per hour on the leg between Miami and Fort Lauderdale compared to an average speed of about 34 miles per hour for cars"
- matte_black 8y agoIndeed, the average speed is likely lower. Traffic from Miami to Ft Lauderdale is horrendous in rush hour.
- ubernostrum 8y agoTop speed of 79 is also the case for Caltrain in the SF Bay area. Which only happens on certain stretches of track, and can be affected by how many stops a particular train needs to make or how many others are ahead of it.
- melling 8y agoWhat’s the average speed? For a distance of 30 miles, shouldnt we be able to build a train that averages 60 mph for 30 minutes? China is working on low-speed maglevs.
- ComradeTaco 8y agoIts possible to achieve substantially higher speeds, but that would require grade separation and electrification, which are much too expensive for a private company to take on.
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoThe maglev in Changsha between the airport and HSR station runs at 100km/hour. It is on a viaduct for much of its path, however, and isn’t very urban (goes nowhere near downtown Changsha). It only averages 57km with stops. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Changsha_Maglev_Express https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Changsha_Maglev_Express
- 8y ago
- foobarian 8y agoAt $10 a ticket sounds like they would need to move ~32k passengers every day for 10 years to break even on the $1.2B purely from tickets. I wonder what other subsidies are coming in to make this make sense.
- mrfusion 8y agoI checked your math and it seems correct. I don’t get it. I could see them possibly moving a few thousand passengers a day but 32k seems out of the question? What are we missing?
- jageen 8y agoWell they can also generate revenue by advertisement. plus property rate around station will going to be high (it will be great impact on money rotation) more people traveling in train instead of personal car will also reduce co2 in air which is eco friendly too. less traffic means there is a wide and safe road for bicycle rider and people who like to walk. one big benefit of travel throw train is time. you can be on place on estimated time. due to less traffic. All my comments are based on my experience, I am traveling throw train for work, here in tokyo.
- 8y ago
- yardie 8y agoI took the inaugural train this weekend from Miami to Ft. Lauderdale. The distance is 24miles as the crow flies and the journey exactly 30 minutes. So the average speed for this leg of the journey was 48mph. This same journey would take 45 minutes by car in the express lane. I don't even want to imagine what this would be in the non-express during rush hour.
- ComradeTaco 8y agoIt's definitely a good option and it's just a conventional speed intercity service: A true high speed rail line would take about 14 minutes.
- yardie 8y agoYes, but this is passing through developed land at this point. I've yet to see a european high speed train hit it's top speed in a populated area. Even TGV doesn't do it's namesake while in Ile-de-France.
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoIn China, HSR can hit full speed in urban areas, but they are also on viaducts.
- bobthepanda 8y agoChina also lacks actual mechanisms ensuring that land seizure serves the public and results in fair compensation. Some models are better off not being applied.
- jfoutz 8y agoI’m not sure if you are asserting eminent domain is a mistake.
- bobthepanda 8y ago
- vondur 8y ago20$ a day for a commute is going to block the people that would benefit the most. Only middle and upper middle class people will be able to afford it.
- usaphp 8y agoWhy do you think that lower class would have benefit from this commute more?
- maxxxxx 8y agoIt's not about benefiting more but about benefiting at all.
- fma 8y agoIf someone is making minimum wage, I doubt they are commuting from Palm Beach to Fort Lauderdale in the first place.
- noobermin 8y agoIf you commute using this, it would cost 100usd a week. Doesn't seem feasible except for the upper middle class.
- strictnein 8y agoAssuming no discounts for frequent use, $400 is less than a car payment, insurance, maintenance, and gas would be. If there are discounts it would be even more reasonable, especially for middle class families trying to decide whether or not to get a second vehicle.
- noobermin 8y agoI definitely agree with you re the cost of owning a car but I don't think people will sell their car to just ride this train. They still have to alight and navigate either city using their possibly poor transit system. Could see it making an effect on marginal[0] decisions (like buying a second car as you state) but it still sounds more to me like being used more for one off trips than for commuting. It's far to expensive for that. [0] marginal in the economic sense
- Overtonwindow 8y agoThis reminds me of the subway system in Sydney Australia. Lots of private lines branching off.
- djsumdog 8y agoAre there a lot of private trains in Sydney? Melbourne has the regional V-lines, but other than that, I think it's the iter-city touristy rail lines (i.e. The Overland to Adelaide). Sydney to Melbourne was the most traveled air route in the world at one point. There really needs to be a high speed line between the through via the ACT. They could have probably built one with the money the wasted on Myki.
- toomanybeersies 8y agoFlights between Melbourne and Sydney are cheap though, and already fairly fast. The train would need to be under 4 hours to really be competitive with flying. It could be done, with something like a TGV style train. I can't imagine how much it would cost though.
- forapurpose 8y ago> Flights between Melbourne and Sydney are cheap It may be expensive if you include the externalities of climate change.
- dx034 8y agoWith most Electricity in the region from coal, externalities of a high speed train might not be much better, esp considering the environmental impact of tracks. I'm a fan of trains but high-speed rail consumes a lot of energy.
- forapurpose 8y agoHow much energy is used by the two technologies to move 100 people 100 miles? I'd bet flying them consumes a lot more, but I don't know much about the train technologies.
- feedmeseymour 8y agoNobody I know wants this thing speeding through our town 30 times per day, filled to the brim :/ Companies like this team up with the government to steamroll, figuratively and literally (IIRC, this thing has killed 3 people already), small towns for the benefit of nasty cities like Miami.
- omarforgotpwd 8y agoyeah, not in my back yard!
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- scythe 8y agoI grew up in a small town in Florida next to the railroad tracks. I could hear trains passing by at night from my bedroom. There are trains coming through many times a day carrying freight. I don't understand why people would be any worse.
- Niten 8y agoI also grew up in a small Florida East Coast town, which Brightline will eventually pass through on its way to Orlando. My parents, who still live in Florida, regularly give me an earful about the train. To an extent, I can see where they're coming from: there has been some controversy over who will pay for crossing upgrades to handle these faster trains, and increased train traffic will mean increased crossing delays in these smaller towns. There have also been some well-publicized pedestrian deaths (https://bit.ly/2GA0QN2 https://bit.ly/2GA0QN2) along Brightline's existing route. But I'm in favor of these trains, and I think most of the opposition amounts to classic NIMBYism. Transportation in Florida is a nightmare, and passenger rail is the obvious solution. And I find it inconceivable that any accidental deaths due to the additional train traffic won't be offset by even fewer deaths on the highways. Florida has a proud history of rail transportation (there's a reason Florida has an entire county named after Henry Flagler), and Brightline could be a return to some of those past glories: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overseas_Railroad https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overseas_Railroad
- wallflower 8y agoHistorical note: Miami owes its founding to Julia Tuttle's successful sales pitch to a railroad company. > Julia Tuttle, a local landowner, convinced Henry Flagler, a railroad tycoon, to expand his Florida East Coast Railway to Miami. On July 28, 1896, Miami was officially incorporated as a city with a population of just over 300. > Julia DeForest Tuttle was an American businesswoman who was largely responsible for, and the original owner of, the land upon which Miami, Florida, was built. For this reason, she is called the "Mother of Miami". https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_Miami https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_Miami https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Julia_Tuttle https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Julia_Tuttle
- dforrestwilson 8y agoPart of Flagler's motivation for building the railroad was beach property rights. The government at the time incentived railroad construction by granting land along the sides of the rails extending several miles. By building the railroad Flagler gained rights to most of Florida's east coast beach property. So in a sense, Miami was a giant public works project. Are we going to be willing to do the same for space exploration?
- intrasight 8y agoThere are no "land" grants in space. Perhaps you mean on the moon or on mars?
- virmundi 8y agoI doubt it. NASA and the US government has lost its sense of adventure and conquering spirit. Too many people in the administration (not Trump's, but rather the deep-state) are 1) afraid of deaths, 2) afraid of being seen as colonizers. That's why we don't have moon bases yet. People couldn't figure out a need, so they became timid hamsters with their Shuttle. So our magnificent men in their flying machines just "go up tiddly up up,they go down tiddly down down." [1] 1 - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fUTBYI6rcxs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fUTBYI6rcxs
- 8y ago
- forrestthewoods 8y agoWait, they've spend 1.5 billion dollars for 30 miles of train? That's only 50 million per mile! Most city light-rail projects in the US are 150 to 200 million per above-ground mile. https://www.citylab.com/transportation/2018/01/why-its-so-expensive-to-build-urban-rail-in-the-us/551408/ https://www.citylab.com/transportation/2018/01/why-its-so-ex...
- ggg9990 8y agoThat’s what privatization can get you. They’re probably not paying some union “inspectors” $70/hr to sit around playing poker.
- dx034 8y agoNo, that's what existing infrastructure gets you.
- yardie 8y agoThe track was already there. $50mm/mi is just new stations, trains, and signaling.
- zaroth 8y agoAnd they still don’t have signaling that qualifies for going >= 80mph. I don’t get it?
- makomk 8y agoThey're using existing tracks and stations, as I understand it. So they basically managed to hit a third to a quarter of the cost of actually building a new rail line without building anything.
- _delirium 8y agoIt's quite a bit cheaper than that per-mile for the existing segment. Not sure where the above poster got "30 miles" from, since there are already 70 miles of track in service (Miami-W. Palm Beach). The $1.5 billion figure is for upgrades to the entire existing Miami-Cocoa corridor, which is 200 miles, so about $7.5m per mile in upgrades. Another $1.5b is budgeted to construct the new 40-mile line from Cocoa to Orlando, so that'll be $37.5m/mile for the new-construction portion if that comes in on-budget (remains to be seen).
- Derbasti 8y ago"High-speed train" ... "runs at a top speed of 79 miles per hour". That doesn't sound right. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-speed_rail https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-speed_rail
- tehabe 8y agoI like trains, I prefer them over any highway project any time. But I have a few concerns about this train service. Like it has only 8 north and 8 south bound trains per day. Will this be really interesting for enough commuters to switch? Also most people won't be at their destination when the train stops at a station, will the ticket be compatible with other transit providers? Nevertheless I hope it is a success, even though the patriotism on the site is annoying me: "We’re American-made and 100% Buy America-compliant." At least the trains were made by Siemens. ;-)
- Shivetya 8y agoyou get them to switch provided your end points are convenient and have adequate last mile options to get people to their destination. the problem with trains is they are not flexible to change in population needs where buses are. however since this is between two cities it avoids a lot of waste that is inherent in light rail that cities use for metro transit. the real numbers that matter is maintenance, how is this budgeted for. one of the major issues facing public light rail is the tens of billions in deferred maintenance combined with removing buses because of the cost of paying for the rail. will this succeed? who knows, they have to convince people that it is worth their time and money to park their car at point A, ride the train to point B, and secure transportation at cost to their destination if it is not close. that is a lot to overcome and the city needs to assist by not preventing ride hailing services and taxis from providing options at both ends as well as making sure if there are local bus services that they do come to the stations
- tehabe 8y agoI like light rails, prefer them over busses. People kinda trust light rail more than busses, because for light rail you need a track and a station, for busses you just need a bus stop sign. My bigger point is, when you $10 for a ticket with the train you need to pay additionally for you next leg of the commute. If you commute it is really a good idea when the ticket is valid for your entire commute, not matter to which transport you transfer: train, light rail, or bus.
- CalRobert 8y agoFantastic! This sort of thing would be more common if we had user fees on the US' most-used form of transport (roads) as opposed to making them a taxpayer-subsidized all-you-can-drive buffet that you get to pay for whether you use it or not. (Fuel taxes only cover about half of road building/maintenance costs, and that share has fallen over the years)
- chiefalchemist 8y agoAt 50k ft this sounds great. On the other hand, is the $10 fare sustainable? At what point will, fare reflect cost? Will, in time, taxpayers - local and national - be called upon to subsidize and/or bail this effort out? I hope it work. But I can't help being a bit cynical. p.s. I hope this train floats because it won't be long before Miami is treading (climate change) water.
- jsilence 8y agoYou ackknowledge the topic of climate change and yet you fail to make the connection to the much more enrgy efficient transportation system trains are? Are the costs to counter the effects of sea level rise (in Miami) accounted for in car transportation? We are already bailing out fossil fuelled individual motorized transport, but who is attributing these costs to the culprit?
- chiefalchemist 8y agoI didn't fail to make the connection. One train isn't going to save Miami. I might even go so far to argue that projects such as this (e.g., the ship is going down but the band keeps playing) led the general public to believe that there's nothing to worry about. "Who would build a billion+ train that's going to end up under water?" It's a good idea. Or is it?
- ecshafer 8y agoWhy do you not worry about the sustainability oh the high way system this is many to alleviate. Trains are vastly more efficient than roads which are almost 100% tax payer funded.
- Clubber 8y agoHe's talking about sustainability via usage. The highway system has no shortage of that. Unfortunately climate change is not yet an economic model; trains are. I know there are monorails (outside of Disney) that Florida municipalities spent a lot of money on but are rarely used (for a multitude of reasons). I don't think the revenue even covers the cost of maintenance in many cases. I think he's referring to that. I remember talk about a train that goes down the 95 corridor from Jax to Miami. I'm not sure whatever happened to that.
- uniacid 8y agoAs a South Floridian sorry to say but this is probably a massive waste of money and investment in an old technology that frankly I don't see how it's going to benefit people when it only has a few stops and because it can't seem to stop killing people it seems to be running slower and slower every week, wasn't this supposed to be a "Fast" train? Also sure Florida has plenty of freight trains, something I'm used to but it seems like Brightline passes more frequently (not sure if they're still doing test runs here and there) which mess up local traffic patterns especially in rush hour times.
- thrownaway954 8y agothis is the exact reason Fort Lauderdale decided to kill the WAVE Streetcar project, old technology that nobody seemed to want: http://wavestreetcar.com/ http://wavestreetcar.com/ http://www.sun-sentinel.com/local/broward/fort-lauderdale/fl-sb-lauderdale-wave-vote-20180426-story.html http://www.sun-sentinel.com/local/broward/fort-lauderdale/fl...
- CalRobert 8y ago" it can't seem to stop killing people it seems to be running slower and slower every week, " I presume you aren't familiar with how well freeways perform in this respect?
- marrone12 8y agoWhat newer technology would you rather people invest billions of dollars into for mass transit that is proven to work?
- fma 8y agoFormer South Floridian here asking any current South Floridian. Thoughts on Tri-Rail Coastal Link? Yay, or Nay?