27 ms·
Estonia plans to become a free public transport nation
- 317070 9y agoThat is amazingly good news! The small payments for tickets in many places in the eu are already barely covering the cost of the transport. Just get rid of this bureaucratic process and go for a flat and easy approach to ticketing.
- illuminati1911 9y agoFree* *Terms and conditions apply.
- petecox 9y agoWell we all pay taxes, so why not? A study a number of years ago for my city suggested that the costs of a ticketing system from maintenance of machines to employing station staff and ticket inspectors was higher than the revenue that was collected from fares.
- failedartifact 9y agoCan you tell us which city?
- petecox 9y agoMelbourne, with trams, trains and buses. That was before they went $AU1billion over budget designing Myki, a smart ticket system. Tickets are more expensive than most international cities I've visited and even then they still run at a loss, having to compensate private operators.
- tzahola 9y agoWhat license are they using? LGPL? MIT?
- jacquesm 9y agoFor some reason they still can't get rid of the tracking and ID requirements though. Estonia is interesting, small enough to make risky moves, large enough to make them meaningful. I wished NL was half as progressive.
- liberal_098 9y agoThe main question is who will really pay for a "free" service, which is obviously not free but rather is a kind of flat rate. In the case of Estonia the expenses could be directly or indirectly covered from EU budget (which is filled by NL, DE etc.) and also the experiment is possible due to relatively low salaries. I cannot imagine such an experiment in NL.
- v2ikesibul 9y agoThere's no experiment and it has nothing to do with the EU. It's a local thing that didn't initially even have central goverment's backing. Public transport in Tallinn (1/3 of Estonia's population) was made free in 2013 and its expenses are covered from personal income tax from Tallinn's residents. As to other towns and rural regions, which are poorer, the central government recently passed a measure to increase subsidies to municipalities in an amount that would allow them to make all public transport free, if they wanted. It's now up to municipalities to find a balance between fully subsidized, partially subsidized and commercial lines.
- danbruc 9y agoI guess that is only because it was at first limited to Tallinn and even after the extension to all of Estonia you still have foreigners not covering the costs with their tax payments. I have no idea what fraction of the people would fall into the respective categories but I would guess that after the extension to the entire nation it is not really worth the effort and costs to make foreigners pay because they are a small fraction compared to the costs of maintaining a payment system.
- jacquesm 9y agoAlso, tourists tend to pay 'tourist tax' in one way or another so they're already covered to some extent.
- severine 9y agoDoes anyone know if the initiative is tied to the educational system?
- albertgoeswoof 9y agoIn London I get the tube/bus everyday. Each bus idles for 2-3 minutes at every stop, and there are stops every 100-200m, for a 2km bus ride roughly half of the time, and fuel, is spent waiting for people to get on and off the bus, with the bottleneck at the front of the bus where you have to tap in your RFID card. The bus system is not generally used by wealthy people (house/rents are way higher near a tube station) I would guess that at least 60-70% of the people on a given bus in London are either over 60 (so not paying), under 18 (paying a reduced rate) or on benefits already (so the government is already paying indirectly). So what is the point in charging? I think you could remove the requirement to pay / tap in on the bus and cut the number of buses running in half, without reducing profitabliity or service significantly. And you'd get better air quality in London as well.
- wayanon 9y agoYour thoughts made me look into London bus demographics and I agree makes sense for rides to be free but I found this saying: 'Over half of day and night bus passengers work full-time (51% and 59% respectively).' p.8 from http://content.tfl.gov.uk/tfl-bus-users-survey.pdf http://content.tfl.gov.uk/tfl-bus-users-survey.pdf
- lozenge 9y agoIt depends on your route. Grandparent sounds like they are bussing in central London. Further out busses are often the fastest route as all the tube lines are headed into the city, but people often want to go in other directions. There are many people further out whose commute is bus then tube as well. Bus stops are 1km apart and the bus might stop for 30 seconds or skip stops entirely.
- albertgoeswoof 9y agoOn page 17 of that same doc you can see that 67% of day bus riders (higher at night) have a total household income of under 30k GBP, which isn’t enough for a household in London without tax credits or other government support
- 9y ago
- Dowwie 9y agoWorld's First Entirely Tax-Funded Public Transport Nation not free.
- teddyh 9y agoEvery. Time. https://satwcomic.com/every-time https://satwcomic.com/every-time
- yani 9y agoI absolutely support free medical coverage and free education... but I cannot put transportation in the same wagon. People who say that it is paid by taxes and it is not free are not wrong thou. The article should notnuse free but a different word. The system in nordic countries is wonderful but it is also starting to get abused.
- icebraining 9y agoNothing, except maybe for sunlight, is costless. Someone is always paying. Free means the users don't pay, not that it doesn't cost anyone anything.
- yani 9y agoUsers dont pay directly. But they still pay via some form. It is actually prepaid in this case
- icebraining 9y agoSome users pay, some don't. Not everyone is a net tax payer. And not every tax payer is a user.
- yani 9y agoAgreed
- 9y ago
- IkmoIkmo 9y agoMakes sense and I'm a big fan. The only worry I have are a lack of market forces. How do five bussing companies compete if there's no revenue model. I wonder how they tackled that. For example it may make sense to charge more for luxurious buses, or for a buses that drive on a dedicated lane for which they pay a more expensive license but are faster, or buses that offer wifi, or buses that come by every five minutes, or buses that drive at 3am. These all have fundamentally different cost components. Does the government pay for it all, allowing bus companies to inflate prices? Are there caps? If so, on what basis? And how does pricing work in a low-competition area like a subway operator with a 30y license, and government paying for it all? Again, I'm a big fan and we need to move this forward. But I'm interested in what system they (and other cities that experiment with this) put in place to manage it all. Either way, can't wait to see this arrive in my city. Working remotely, strong local walkable communities, ubiquitous public transport and automated ridesharing are strong candidates for the future, all of it electric and low-sound. That should increase traffic density, clean up cities from sound and pollution, make traffic safer and cheaper. edit: another issue that comes up is demand-control. For example I currently have a 60-70% discount subscription but only if I travel outside of peak hours. That absolutely induces me to travel differently, e.g. leave home earlier or stay a bit longer at work or uni until I get my discount. Free public transport removes that instrument. There's a lot of talk nowadays about trying to change the 9 to 5 model to one that's spread out more. e.g. universities having an 11 to 7 model, some companies going 10 to 6. Part of that story is traffic management, and free public traffic throws out this instrument. It may also disincentivize cycling, to a small extent walking, and perhaps most importantly, wanting to live as close to the 'rest of the day' (work, school, friends) as possible to reduce costs.
- hndamien 9y agoDon't forget electric scooters!
- IkmoIkmo 9y agoYup, will definitely be a big part of the story! Not sure I'm a big fan myself. They sort of sit between bicycles and electric mini cars. [0] The cars are safer and allow easy multi-passengers, groceries, long-distance, all weather conditions, intercity travel. Bicycles are cheap, good for your health, nimble, safe on dedicated cycling infrastructure (see the Netherlands). Scooters take the best but also the worst from both. They're low-effort and relatively high-speed compared to bicycles, but nimble and relatively cheap compared to cars. But they're also relatively expensive compared to bicycles, have poor weather conditions of bicycles and are relatively unsafe and can't do intercity trips or grocery runs as easily as cars. They also aren't really suited for automation, and I feel they're less suited for ridesharing, but it's not easy to identify exactly why that is. I kind of feel every scooter ride is better off either as a bicycle ride or car ride, assuming you have these ubiquitous self-driving car2go 'travel pods' you could call em, and assuming you have nice cycling infrastructure. (I have a very European/Dutch perspective on this, outside cyclist-friendly cities I'd much rather have an electric scooter. But as a city I'd rather promote different infrastructure choices than scooters.) [0] https://www.car2go.com/media/data/germany/stuttgart/stuttgart-parking_492x20.jpg https://www.car2go.com/media/data/germany/stuttgart/stuttgar...
- yani 9y agoThailand has free buses since like forever ago. There are different tiers here, free, cheap, normal price, luxurios. I would love to see free medical than free transportation.
- John_KZ 9y agoI disagree with a completely free public transport. Paying creates an entry barrier that suppresses traffic surges and misuse. Instead you can offer free tickets to those who actually need them and subsidize it enough to be a competitive choice regardless of free tickets. An example of what I mean: one time I was returning home from the airport with the bus after a long flight. The bus was already packed at the airport, but as it crossed the city, a bunch of youngsters started entering without tickets, turning a mild inconvenience into a 90 minutes of living hell. Many of them used the bus for a mere 1-2 stops, others took this (more expensive) express bus instead of the regular one, and some were just joining for fun (I think this was after a football match or something). Point being: having to pay optimizes usage.
- icebraining 9y agoDoesn't your story show the opposite? The bus being paid didn't actually prevent misuse and a living hell.
- yani 9y agoHumans need free medical coverage more than free transportation. Oh and free emergency transportation too.
- tinus_hn 9y agoYour point is that if you have to pay you don’t have to share the bus with the poor people. The real solution for the problem of crowded buses is to have more of them.
- iamben 9y agoAlways thought this would be an amazing idea for housing in places like London. Make transport free and regular (as in runs all night) between the centre and the far cheaper to live satellite towns and cities and (young) people (especially) are far more likely to live elsewhere and be happier doing so.
- martinald 9y agoThere's just not the capacity to do that. Nearly (probably all) railways into the centre at at 100-200% capacity in the morning and evening peaks. It isn't possible to make the trains run any more frequently (incremental capacity improvement is possible at extreme expense, but nothing that would allow a step change in housing trends).
- kpil 9y agoI think this is bullshit - from a psychological perspective. We need to foster our children that our actions take a toll out of our shared resources. It's clear that "free" sometimes is valued as "worthless" - The Swedish city Uppsala introduced free bus rides for teenagers a couple (20?) years ago, and the experiment was cancelled after short period due to extensive vandalism - buss seats where destroyed, etc. If you look closely enough, a lot of "free" resources that are actually funded or subsidised are overused or misused, or just plain vandalised - probably due to that it's not obvious how the resource is being paid for in the "background".
- hk__2 9y ago> The Swedish city Uppsala introduced free bus rides for teenagers a couple (20?) years ago, and the experiment was cancelled after short period due to extensive vandalism - buss seats where destroyed, etc. Anecdata. Dunkerque, a city in the North of France, saw a 59% decrease in vandalism acts when they tried free transports on Sundays and holidays during 6 months.
- emodendroket 9y agoI don't think it's bullshit. I think it makes a lot of sense. In the US driving is free (excluding the cost of maintaining your own car, but if you own one you're already committed to most of these costs) despite the substantial cost of maintaining the roads, while riding the train costs money. This is pretty much backwards when we consider the relative effect of riding the train versus driving.
- icebraining 9y agoGas is free in the US?
- crispyporkbites 9y agoIt’s basically subsidised- if you had to pay for the external costs of the gas you burn per trip you wouldn’t do it.
- 9y ago
- snvzz 9y agoThis makes sense. What's usually true with public transport is that: 1. High % of the cost of running it is due to the fare system. 2. The infrastructure is paid with tax money and yet only rich people (as in, able to pay the fare) can benefit from it. So, it should really be free to use.
- marcosdumay 9y ago3. There are some very large benefits on scale, on costs and administration. 4. It reduces the use of a severely limited public good. It's a wonder that they are not free to use everywhere.
- opk 9y agoOne big advantage is that you get much more use out of public transport. I'm well served by trams where I live but there are many times when it would be convenient to travel just one or two stops. It is too expensive to even consider it for short journeys. From the article. it looks like Tallinn requires residence permits or something. So perhaps they still need a fare system. I'd make all local public transport free for anyone. May even avoid the need for the diesel car bans being mooted in my city (and some other German cities).
- chiefalchemist 9y agoI hate to mince words but...instead of free, I'd prefer if we used publicly funded, or similar. 1) Usage might be "free" but ultimately someone somewhere is paying for it. 2) More accurate wording would actually better reflect the priorities of that particular culture, often in contrast to others of different priorities. Free here sounds like "oh, a ride doesn't have to pay a buck. How nice." But the accomplishment is much bigger (and requires a larger financial commitment) than that. p.s. As a side note, I hope someone is going to study the health related side effects. That is, for example, will riding more mean walking less? Will that add up to an unintended consequence?
- C4K3 9y agoSingle-payer transport, just like single-payer healthcare. That said, I would like to add an anecdote to your P.S. I commute to Copenhagen, so I take a train and then a bus to reach my destination. I have a travel pass that lets me take public transport for free in a specified region. Copenhagen also has a bike sharing system, but using the bike sharing system costs money, even with a travel pass. As such, I'm incentivized to not use the bike sharing system and take the (usually crowded) bus instead. In fact, I know of no one who uses public transport for some part of their journey, who also use the bike share. People either live within biking distance, and therefore use their own bikes (unless broken or for other reasons unavailable,) or they live far enough away that they need to take some public transport no matter what (my situation,) and then just take public transport the entire way. In the end, the bike share mostly just gets used by tourists, when it could very conveniently replace the bus for last-mile transport for many people.
- imtringued 9y ago>1) Usage might be "free" but ultimately someone somewhere is paying for it. That is the definition of free. Free always means that someone is paying for it. If I give you a book for free I still had to pay for it. The purpose of the word is that the receiver of the good didn't have to pay.
- chiefalchemist 9y agoThe point is, those using the service are paying (in taxes, or similar). They just don't pay at the time of being served. Pre or post paying doesn't make it free. Let's not be so naive.
- baybal2 9y ago>Estonia to Become the World’s First Free Public Transport Nation Wait a minute... What about USSR?
- icebraining 9y agohttps://history.stackexchange.com/questions/32632/was-public-transportation-free-in-the-soviet-union https://history.stackexchange.com/questions/32632/was-public...
- teren 9y agoPublic transport was not free in the USSR.
- ddon 9y agoUSSR we paid to use public transport, and I even remember when my father was caught for not paying and he had to pay a fine...
- swebs 9y ago>To ride Tallinn’s network of trams, buses and trains for free, you must be registered as a resident, which makes the municipality profit €1,000 from your income tax every year. All you need to do then is getting a €2 green card and carrying your ID on public transport So that's more like €83 per month public transit. In comparison, a 30 day pass in Tallinn costs €23, or €8.50 for students. Seems like you could simply not register as a resident and come out ahead. Does anyone know if being a registered resident of Tallinn comes with any other benefits, or is this just a case of people willing to lose €60 to get something for "free"? The following quote from the article makes it seem like clever marketing. >There’s no doubt that we not only cover the costs, but also come out with a surplus. We earned double as much as we have lost since introducing free public transport. We’re happy to see that so many people are motivated to register as residents in Tallinn to make use of free public transport
- point78 9y agoWhen you rip off good social services they end up not working for anyone. If you don't agree with it, don't move there. Society doesn't need people like you.
- swebs 9y ago>When you rip off good social services they end up not working for anyone. I think the ones doing the ripping off are the ones charging €83 for a €23 service then calling it "free". Then again, there could be other benefits to registering as a resident of Tallinn, so I don't know. >If you don't agree with it, don't move there. Society doesn't need people like you. I don't plan to move anytime soon, but what's stopping the current residents from putting 2 and 2 together? I think society needs more people who know to read the fine print.
- v2ikesibul 9y agoPersonal income is taxed at 20% and collected by the central government no matter what. Half of that is then transferred to the municipality you're registered in. Personal income tax makes up approximately half of a municipality's budget and covers far more than only transport-related expenses. Such scheme incentivizes municipalities to compete with other municipalities and offer their residents all kinds of benefits ranging from childcare to public transport to keep them registered there.
- VLM 9y agoI am impressed by whoever in Estonia's government has been doing PR; I've never seen a national government manipulate so much positive free press coverage, between E-residency in recent years and now the free transport initiative. Note that just like E-residency this "free transport" never has to amount to anything, yet by sheer qty of press coverage you'd think Estonia is the eighth continent. Much like E-Residency the commentary here on and on most tech blogs pretends it'll be implemented to change the world and vast engineering-think discussions of how to implement, whereas in a couple of years it'll be yet another "New Coke/Classic Coke" and Estonia will have moved on to getting massive positive press over... I donno, changing all national laws using grep and tr to have gender neutral pronouns, or free 3-d printing as a constitutional human right, or ban freedom of association to eliminate racism, or legally mandating drone transport corridors in the national building code and planning commission documents, or ...
- kristerv 9y agoI (as an estonian) am amazed this topic is reaching the top of HN or any other outlet. Locally it's a dispute of whether what people need is free bus transport or actually a more frequent schedles (I would vote for the latter). The E-residency thing is way more awesome however and (like the blockchain tech) will take even more time for it to live up to the hype :D
- scrollaway 9y agoI'm used to cynicism on HN, but never have I seen such mindless cynicism. You used two whole paragraphs of noise to basically say "I don't care". Depressing.
- VLM 9y agoOh come on. Every government in the world would like tech startups and has a bus system, but Estonia consistently has the best PR dept I've ever seen, including countries many times larger and better funded. That kind of compliment is hardly a "I don't care".
- omarforgotpwd 9y agoI predict this will be one of the worst public transit systems you could ever ride within a few years. Absent market forces the only way for the city to improve their financial position is to make a service so bad nobody wants to use it. If tickets had prices there would be an incentive for them to meet customer demands and improve their financial position. If I were in charge of this I would make public transit free for the lowest income levels and very cheap for others.
- sleavey 9y agoNot every country has incompetent local government, and not every service requires market forces to operate effectively. As long as the Estonian government (or whichever organisation is looking after the network) prepares for the short and medium future, and keeps collecting and spending tax money effectively, then there's no reason why this can't flourish.
- ropeadopepope 9y ago> not every service requires market forces to operate effectively Can you name a service and a city/country that operates effectively in the manner you state?
- sleavey 9y agoSwiss Federal Railways: "88.8% of all passengers reached their destination - measured from departure station including any necessary changes - with less than 3 minutes of delay" [1]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swiss_Federal_Railways https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swiss_Federal_Railways
- ropeadopepope 9y agoFrom wikipedia > The company is headquartered in Bern. Formerly a government institution, since 1999 it has been a special stock corporation with all shares held by the Swiss Confederation or the Swiss cantons. That certainly sounds like market forces to me.
- stevespang 9y agoThis is not free - - Estonia takes 1000 Euros from your income taxes each year to support this system. Let's see what it looks like in say 5 years. Surely it cannot be any worse than 'Vegas, where in 2016 I used the city bus system to get around, and every bus I rode had a security guard on it with a 45 on his hip. Almost every street corner had street people.
- techrich 9y agoIts a great way to track who travels where, and how often. They wont make it so people can wander on and off as they see fit. No tap required or anything.
- ataturk 9y agoReminding you all this fine Saturday that nothing is really free. Ever.
- Simulacra 9y agoI wish this would happen in DC. The D.C. subway is grossly overpriced. All of the federal employees who take it everyday get subsidized fares. That leaves tourists and poor people to shoulder the burden of exorbitant rates. If I drive to work it costs me about $12 to park, and twenty minutes to get there. If I take the subway it costs $5 to park, and $10 round trip, plus a journey that can take up to an hour. If you live further out, it's even worse.
- tejasmanohar 9y agoFunny how I saw a Lyft “Become a Driver” ad beneath the article.
- gpvos 9y agoIt would be nice if they invested a bit more in their railway system, which is pretty minimal.
- finphil 9y agoExpect taxes to increase.
- ethagknight 9y agoSo great. In Memphis, TN, I have tried for years to convince our transit authority MATA and our downtown commission DMC to make our light rail (ahem, historic trolley) free, on the following basis: MATA covers 1/7th of its overall opex from fare boxes revenue. The trolleys bring in approximately $700k in a good year. Why even bother with funds control and ticketing services at that point? The direct benefit of increased visitor and resident mobility far exceed the cost and could _easily_ be made up for from hotel occupancy tax or myriad other sources. Instead, the city focuses on a convoluted and expensive parking garage scheme that is mainly an inhibitor, while still losing money on the mass transit. My lobbying is always met with "heh, how are you planning to pay for that plan!" and all the mechanisms I point to will take some amount of work and political will to shift around, notwithstanding the same sources that currently pay for the remaining 6/7ths of opex. if anyone has constructive new ideas for me to sell the idea, I can be in the mayor's, MATA GM's, and DMC's Pres' office next week to pitch it. end rant.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- mmt 9y agoWhen the revenue is that small a percentage of the operating expense, I have to wonder what the incremental cost is of that revenue. Do you happen to know? Modern fare collection systems can be expensive boondoggles in their own right. That likely doesn't apply to a historic trolley, but you mentioned ticketing services, and even one annual salary is a hefty proportion of that $700k.
- ethagknight 9y agoI’m an armchair transit specialist, and I do not know specifically, but generally, it would seem the cost for each additional passenger on a transit system follows a step function such that n + 1 < $0.01 until you hit ‘capacity’, a loosely defined term at which point the next passenger causes losses (congestion and delay boarding and disembarking). In a properly running system, the fixed costs dramatically outweigh the additional burden of each passenger, in the same way that the bus engine hardly noticed the additional weight of another 170 lb passenger relative to the 40,000 lb bus. Even with consumables like ticketing, the whole revenue system far outweighs the increment.
- himom 9y agoVery cool!!! I would explore more of the city here if this were possible... work from different parks and establishments. Instead, seniors and the disabled get hit with another $1 price-hike and have more of an inconvenient, expensive bus system without additional value being delivered.
- m0skit0 9y agoSo then not everything was bad back in the Evil Empire?
- Tomminn 9y agoDamn this is a good idea. The general problem with "free" is that, without the price signal, overuse occurs. But public transport is orders of magnitude more efficient at moving people than cars, so even if people use public transport to travel 10x more than they would use a car-- which is a ridiculous assumption-- this would still make cities like 6x less congested if those people stopped using their cars.
- nopcode 9y agoI thought this wasn't allowed by EU? Completely defeats any chance of a competitive transportation market cross-border. That said - I wish they would do it in my eu country too. It would be cheaper on the taxpayer - even if he/she doesn't use public transportation.