13 ms·
Does Clean Laundry Have Germs?
- mlindner 9y agoEverything has germs... The idea that you can get rid of them is flawed.
- astrodust 9y agoUnless you live in a literal bubble you're going to have contagions. The people exposed to the dirtiest conditions as children are perhaps the least vulnerable in their adult lives. Excessively clean conditions are a problem.
- bsder 9y ago> Excessively clean conditions are a problem. Maybe. But for those of us around immuno-compromised people, this kind of data is good. Am I going to worry about standard dirty clothes? Meh. Not really. Am I going to pay more attention when someone is sick and I have to do their laundry? Yes.
- astrodust 9y agoIf you're immuno-compromised I'd invest in the right equipment, like perhaps a more industrial-grade cleaning system. The sort used by hotels can kill anything.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- cVwEq 9y agoTL;DR: Only bleach and/or a high temperature in the dryer kills most of the bacteria. Various laundry detergents seemed to have no effect. If you are a norophobe, try to use disposable paper towels, nappies, etc. when you can.
- kyberias 9y agoAfraid of Norovirus?
- criddell 9y agoSome people seem to think putting their clothes (especially denim) in the freezer will kill the bacteria that stinks. It doesn't, at least not for long.
- lostlogin 9y agoThe article seems to miss UV/direct sunlight. Don’t leave strong colours like red out too long, but it nukes washing. I’ve had a search but can’t any decent measures of what sunlight does.
- cowsandmilk 9y ago> The article seems to miss UV/direct sunlight She has another article on that: http://www.stopthestomachflu.com/does-sunlight-kill-germs http://www.stopthestomachflu.com/does-sunlight-kill-germs
- peterwwillis 9y agoSunlight does nothing. UV radiation, which you are exposed to in the outdoors, will disrupt a microorganism's DNA, preventing it from reproducing (it doesn't kill the microorganism, though). There's no guarantee that just leaving something out in the sun will penetrate enough to be effective. A glass window filters out almost all of the UVA spectrum, but you can buy a UVA lamp if you want to disinfect the surface of some item indoors. (DO NOT USE THIS LAMP ON YOURSELF). As an example, The SteriPEN uses a UVA lamp to sterilize water, but needs to be on for a sufficient amount of time as the water is agitated. edit I'm an idiot, the SteriPEN uses UV-C, which doesn't even get through our atmosphere. UV-A and UV-B do get through and do affect organisms. Here's a paper on the SteriPEN: https://www.travelmedicinejournal.com/article/S1477-8939(15)00174-X/pdf https://www.travelmedicinejournal.com/article/S1477-8939(15)...
- 27182818284 9y agoThis site is pretty interesting in itself...like even clicking away from the laundry and checking out their tests of various products like hydrogen peroxide and such on their counter tops is interesting to look at
- aoki 9y agoagreed. i really enjoyed the fact that she (as a phd in biochem) orients to many of these tests as experiments. in her test of the SteriPen, she tries water samples with varying levels of turbidity (the SteriPen is based on UV) rather than just trying one thing and declaring "woo! it works!" (which is all you'd really expect from a product review blog).
- fl0wenol 9y agoOn the downside the site seems organized in such a way to SEO for Amazon link referrals and to drum up visibility of a vanity-published book series written and illustrated by her daughter. Not that it isn't an accomplishment, but it feels... forced? And not in the way of someone inexperienced with web stuff and proud of their kid. It has that auto-generated-from-the-previous-contents-of-the-expired-registration domain parking website feel. Pages go on forever, disorganized navigation, boilerplate explanations duplicated everywhere, very little in the way of charts or tables or summaries, and most of the links about products go to Amazon.
- Too 9y agoThat explains the focus on detergents and not temperature? I was baffled she hardly even mentioned the temperature setting, here it is well known that you should run your washer with at least 60C if you want to kill germs.
- wil421 9y agoHonestly I never expected laundry detergent to actually sanitize anything. I use it to help remove stains and grime from my clothes during a wash. Do people expect the laundry to actually sanitize clothes? I would think having to option to use cold water is a dead giveaway. Anyone have a link for a dishwasher test similar to this one?
- komali2 9y agoAge-old wisdom passed from my grandma to my mom to me is that if poop gets on something, just throw it in the wash, even with other laundry (unless it's like A LOT OF POOP), on a hot cycle. Always seemed to work just fine, now I'm horrified.
- mikepurvis 9y agoYuck, I would never throw something poopy in the wash— hand scrub it at the laundry sink beforehand for sure.
- munificent 9y agoAs someone currently fostering a batch of kittens with stomach bugs... I'm going to go home and burn all of my clothes now.
- dmckeon 9y agoYou might want to google feline toxoplasmosis. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Toxoplasmosis#Parasitology https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Toxoplasmosis#Parasitology
- munificent 9y agoYeah, I'm familiar with it, though hopefully not familiar familiar with it. As far as we know, it's some other kind of coccidia. Either way, there's a whole lot of washing and hand cleaning going on these days.
- cm2012 9y ago
- TylerE 9y agoThis site is making my skeptic radar ping really hard... especially the referral links to buy 'essential oils', and all the carefully posed super-mom photos.
- sulam 9y agoReally? Did you read it? She does an amazing amount of laundry, but otherwise, she's not really pushing anything other than bleach.
- atomical 9y ago"Certain essential oils are proven immune boosters. We sleep better thanks to essential oils, and as you no doubt know, sleep is an integral component to good health. We soothe minor cuts and scrapes with essential oils. After switching to as many all natural, essential oil based products as possible, we’re quite sure that our exposure to potentially harmful (and immune damaging?) chemicals has been reduced. The best thing about making alternative household products yourself with essential oils is that you at least know exactly what’s in them. If you look at the ingredient list for even a bottle of simple shampoo, there might be dozens of ingredients with names that you could hardly pronounce—whereas with DIY products, there might be five ingredients, all of which you know are safe for your body, your children, your pets, etc." Yeah, what a bunch of bullshit. https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMoa064725 https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMoa064725
- detaro 9y agoUnder the headline "viewer comments". (although I'd personally not published such a comment)
- gamblor956 9y agoI can cite studies too. Here's one from the NIH on the use of essential oils to fight infections: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5435909/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5435909/ By the way, the blogger is a PhD in biochemistry. You're not going to win a science battle with her.
- jwilk 9y ago> Crystal Wash allows you to do your laundry with NO detergent! You put these 2 balls in your washer that contain special "bio ceramics" that change the pH of the water and allow dirt and bacteria to be removed naturally. The company claims that it is as good as regular detergent, natural, and will save you money. To recharge your crystals, you simply set the balls in the sun for the afternoon. Is this a real thing? What's the chemistry behind it?
- JTbane 9y agoSeems like snake oil.
- facetube 9y agohttp://laundry.reviewed.com/features/crystal-wash-tested-does-this-detergent-alternative-actually-work http://laundry.reviewed.com/features/crystal-wash-tested-doe...
- xkcd-sucks 9y agoI mean a shitload of copper wire would kill mold and probably bacteria, but also stains laundry green. However a 'bio-ceramic' that is supposed to go in your body hopefully isn't coppery or otherwise biocidal If it's generating peroxide in situ, it won't kill anything until long after it eats up your clothes and nothing can renewably generate that much peroxide or else it would be used for energy, not advertised on infomercials
- IvyMike 9y ago
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- kovrik 9y agoThis is interesting indeed and I appreciate the amount of work done, but honestly I don't see the point. Yes, germs are everywhere (surprised?), so what? First, you can't bleach all you house. Second, even if you could, why do that? Our body seems to fight nasty stuff pretty well. If you have some specific condition or disease, then just take targeted measures.
- chrischen 9y agoYou can use Norwex detergent and Lysol laundry sanitizer together. Those two specific brands had the only bleach-like results.
- nowarninglabel 9y ago> I don't see the point. >If you have some specific condition or disease, then just take targeted measures Did you even read the article? That's exactly what she says she is doing. When there's a stomach flu or other harmful bug going through the household, she is using targeted washing methods to rid those germs.
- robbrown451 9y agoI have a hard time buying the idea that if you are going to catch stomach flu, it will be from germs from "clean" laundry. Most germs just get washed away, and you can't completely eliminate germs elsewhere in the environment, so that seems like one of the least likely vectors. Sorry, but this just seems like OCD disguised by a bit of science.
- kovrik 9y agoExactly what I meant. Yes, you can bleach all your clothes, but not your whole house. Then, if you already have stomach flu, then I don't see how bleaching your clothes might help here. Take a medicine. Finally, reading about stomach flu (I'm not a doctor), it doesn't look like a serious problem: > Most people with the stomach flu require no formal treatment. The key to a rapid and safe recovery at home (home remedy) is proper hydration. If it gets more serious then take a pill or/and go to a doctor.
- seiferteric 9y agoFor towels at least, I do a "bleach load" every few weeks when I start to notice normal washing is not enough and they smell a bit after only one or two uses. After I was with bleach, they smell clean and I can use them for like a week before a normal wash. I try to only use white towels.
- pooloo1 9y agoGranted this is a real life study with a large set of data sampling a small number of machines, though likely using the same city water. The culprit might be the city water, or the build up of bacteria in the machines from long term use of the city water?
- chrischen 9y agoShe tested the water in the article too and found it free of bacteria.
- pooloo1 9y agoIts difficult to find any evidence relating to bacteria in water systems, but its certainly not 100% disinfected, or free of bacteria. The problem with washing machines is they are devices that are rather difficult to disinfect. If you were to take a brand new washer, as in never had water ran through it, you would probably see a drastic reduction in her results. However, after a few uses bacteria from the air, cloths, water, and other sources will eventually end up in the system. If the system is not vented, then wet spots will exist throughout each washing cycle carrying with it any bacteria. With that said, what I am suggesting is the washing machine is the culprit for bacteria from city water, which is not 100% bacteria free. Add in the fact that High-Efficiency washers use substantially less water then older units, and you have a perfect bacterial soup machine. Older machines used more water, which allowed for further dilution and flushing. Would the situation be the same if the water was 100% free of bacteria with a brand new washer that would be dried completely after each use?
- gamblor956 9y agoIf you had read the article, you would know that (a) the water was free of bacteria, (b) she tested an old HE washer, an old normal top-loading washer, a new HE front-loading washer, and a normal front-loading washer and (c) the problem wasn't the washers.
- kenjackson 9y ago
- infinitone 9y agoRelated to germs, how often do people clean their keyboards/mice/electronic surfaces in their office. How come tech companies don't have such a service? Would people be interested in it?
- kardos 9y agoThe cost to pickup, clean, and return a computer mouse/kb is almost certainly higher than buying a new mouse/kb
- sushid 9y agoThat totally depends on your setup. But in my case, I keep a container of 90% isopropyl alcohol on my desk to wipe away my keyboard, mouse, laptop surface, desk, etc. regularly. It certainly seems easier than having some service take it away for a day or even a few hours.
- cimmanom 9y agoI just use the Clorox wipes that are always on hand in the office kitchen.
- jeffdubin 9y agoWould a UV lamp (of appropriate wavelength and duration of exposure) accomplish the same thing, without needing to remove the equipment from service?
- ahjushi 9y agoSome readers are asking what's the point since germs are everywhere? I was actually quite interested in this. As a practitioner of BJJ, a common rule among schools/dojos is to not allow you to train with dirty gis, and a lot recommend washing it as soon as possible after sessions. Staph is an ever-present (though not incredibly common) concern with all the sweat, rolling around, and close contact. A bit grossed out to read that washing doesn't do all too much to reduce germs and therefore chances of staph.
- dictum 9y ago> sweat, rolling around, and close contact Though germs are a concern, body odor is a very practical reason to always train with clean clothes, and for some people it requires enforcement through peer pressure.
- peterwwillis 9y agoStaph isn't fun, but you should also be worried about HIV, hepatitis B, and other bloodborne pathogens. Not all blood pathogens can be killed by traditional disinfectants, even bleach. You need to soak the affected article for 10 minutes with a caustic sterilizer such as Sporicidin or CaviCide (which unlike disinfectants will kill bacterial spores) No training center I have ever seen cleans their mats this way. Roll at your own risk...
- Fomite 9y agoI'd be surprised if there are any documented transmissions of those pathogens, especially given they need more complicated uptake. The issue with Staph is that skin-to-skin contact, or the indirect version mediated by a mat, is more than enough for it go to "Yeah, I live here now..."
- peterwwillis 9y agoAccording to doctors/nurses I've talked to, smooshing a mucous membrane or open sore onto material which came into contact with infected blood can be enough for transmission. Which is why competent BDSM dungeons clean their apparatus with cavicide before/after use, and why they recommend a barrier between a person and the apparatus.
- clumsysmurf 9y agoI thought it was common knowledge to sanitize your wash machine every month with a bleach load to kill germs and whatever. Sadly though, none of the coin laundry shops I go to do that. When I ask they are like, "it does 3 cycles, there are no germs". Then people throw dog beds encrusted with feces "If you wash a load of just underwear, there will be about 100 million E. coli in the wash water, and they can be transmitted to the next load of laundry," Gerba said. https://abcnews.go.com/Health/Wellness/washing-machines-loaded-bacteria-dirty-clothes/story?id=10751420 https://abcnews.go.com/Health/Wellness/washing-machines-load... "Bacterial Exchange in Household Washing Machines" https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4672060/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4672060/
- jonnycomputer 9y agoCould be, but I don't think the washing machine is the source of most of the bacteria in her experiments.
- jonnycomputer 9y agoThe author of the post was putting a dirty water solution on the cloth. In her control treatments, with no dirty water solution, there were no bacterial growth, despite being in the "dirty" washer. sheesh
- Johnny555 9y agoI thought it was common knowledge to sanitize your wash machine every month with a bleach load to kill germs and whatever After decades of doing my own laundry, I'd never heard of that practice. Well, at least not until recently when I got an HE front loader machine, now I run a bleach cleaning cycle once a month or so to kill odor causing germs. But not to keep germs off my clothes.
- roenxi 9y agoThere is a delicious irony in what you are saying. More than likely, the reason that you perceive an odor is because your body is trying to keep the germs off. So from an evolutionary standpoint, you are probably running a bleach cycle to keep germs off your clothes.
- e12e 9y ago> My sister Christy has an older top loader (not HE). She washed this laundry on hot and added the 1/2 cup chlorine bleach directly to the wash water and it was very, very clean. She measured the temperature of her wash water when the tank filled up using her meat thermometer and it was 130 degrees F. She used Sam's club detergent. Her laundry was perfectly clean (to the limits of my detection abilities). So, 130F is just under 60C - what's usually the minimum considered to kill bacteria. While I haven't measured the actual temperature, my aging, second hand washer have three "white" programs: "hot" is 90 C, and there are two rated 60C. I'd never assume any of the other programs had a sterilising effect. If "hot" is just 60C, and often not that - I can see a need to use bleach for some loads (or other means of killing off bacteria) if the norm is to use warm (not hot) water for washing. Would be interesting to see similar test with just water (no soap, bleach) and a 90C degree program. I'd guess the results would be "dotted middleground" like many of the test here. Also would be nice to see how hanging in the sun would effect otherwise clean clothes (airborne bacteria vs uv death ray stand-off - might be meaningless without checking for type of bacteria).
- ChuckMcM 9y agoAn interesting side effect here is that the house water heater has its own temperature control. For years people have been turning down the temperature setting on their water heaters to save energy, as a result the typical house water heater might be set to 60C (130F) and the washing machine was doing the best it could.
- distances 9y agoWashing machines use cold water and heat it up themselves, so I don't see the connection?
- ChuckMcM 9y agoClearly not all of them do :-) But curious as to the relative ratio I discover that best buy has a separate listing for machines that include an internal water heater. According to their web site, of the models that Best buy sells the population is about 40% (54 models with internal water heaters over a population of 138 models)
- abalone 9y agotl;dr Only chlorine bleach and certain washers with a "sanitize" setting reliably sanitize laundry. With bleach you have to make sure you add it to the water at the right time which a malfunctioning dispenser can fail to do (and you might not realize it), but apart from that it works reliably and even with cold water. A "sanitize" setting can get similar results but it depends on the machine; her neighbor's didn't work as well as hers. Unfortunately non-chlorine bleach and "sanitizer" additives do not reliably sanitize. The obsessiveness of the post can given the impression that this is someone who's a germaphobe, but she actually notes that it's not necessary to kill germs most of the time. She's just motivated to figure out how to effectively sanitize in the cases where you want to do it, like a household illness or cloths used to wipe up raw chicken.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Fomite 9y agoNote that even this may not work perfectly. For example, Clorox recommends using 1/2 cup of Clorox regular bleach in laundry. That's 8 tablespoons worth. That's on the low end of what the CDC recommends per gallon of water for disinfecting something that's contaminated with Norovirus (a viral stomach bug especially common in the winter). Norovirus is also pretty heat stable, though the sanitize setting should get hot enough, though it's not clear if its hot enough for long enough.
- overcast 9y agoMy Samsung washer I bought 10+ years ago has a sanitize setting that releases steam and silver ions into the wash. Used for Bedding / Sheets / Towel wash cycles.
- praptak 9y agoEuropean washing machines usually have the "almost boiling" setting: 95 degrees Celsius. I use it for linen and towels. Other types of cloth don't bear this so well.
- kome 9y agoyes, I was wondering the same... that should be enough.
- bbitmaster 9y agoThe issue I suspect caused this is all of the newer energy efficient washers/ dryers. The author tested a Samsung dryer. I recently lived in apartment with a similar model, and it was terrible. When visiting parents I was stunned at how well their older washer/dryer worked. The clothes came out much more clean too. In my experience the newer energy efficent washers/dryers are almost total garbage compared to the older ones. I would love to see this experiment repeated with an older 90's kenmore or whirlpool or really any brand from the 90's or before. I love the idea of saving energy, and energy efficient laundry sounds like a great idea on the surface, but what I think happened was the government put regulations in place without really considering the actual impact this would have on the quality of the washers/dryers.
- yongjik 9y agoGrowing up in Korea, and living in the US for 5+ years now, what I've heard is that American washer models are so forceful that they wear clothes out. If you are accustomed to such washers (and clothes made with such expectation) I can see how you think the newer models are not as good. But I would choose a Samsung/LG washer over Whirlpool any day, if the prices were the same.
- hocuspocus 9y agoCompared to Korea, I'd think that tumble drying is the main culprit behind wearing clothes out. Anecdotally when I first moved to Korea I had a huge top-loading Samsung washer that made insane amounts of lint. Front-loaders are vastly different between the North American market and Europe or Korea. I remember my friend's brand new LG in California would run an eco-friendly cycle in 40 minutes. A similar model in Europe takes 4h30!
- Reason077 9y ago"A similar model in Europe takes 4h30!" That's not true of modern front-load washers. At my old (UK) flat we had an old Beko front-loading clunker. It worked perfectly well but was very noisy and took a long time (not 4 hours though! maybe 1.5 - 2 hours). At my current place we have a much more modern one where a fast/economy cycle takes 36 minutes. It's nice and quiet too.
- manigandham 9y agoDetergent is a surfactant, designed to lift dirt, food and other stains from your clothing to be rinsed away with the water. It does absolutely nothing in terms of bacteria or germs beyond this. In cases where that's necessary, like hospital linens, a combination of bleach and hot water is used. Most new washing machines now come with a "sanitize" setting that will use a built-in water heater to get to boiling temperatures to clean clothes. You should also clean your washing machine regularly, using empty cycles and letting it completely dry out. You can't clean much if the cleaning equipment itself is dirty.
- beamatronic 9y agoWon’t that cause cotton to shrink?
- pmoriarty 9y ago"Detergent is a surfactant, designed to lift dirt, food and other stains from your clothing to be rinsed away with the water. It does absolutely nothing in terms of bacteria or germs beyond this." But it should wash away the bacteria, right? That's why hospitals advise doctors and patients to wash their hands with soap, isn't it? It's not like they're under any illusion that soap will kill the bacteria/viruses, but just that it should wash them off.
- manigandham 9y agoYes, you're right, but the physics are different. Soap is different than laundry detergent and is designed for your relatively non-porous watertight skin, which when held under a stream of water lets bacteria wash away easily. Fabric is much more porous and absorbs deeply, along with the trouble of being enclosed in a sealed container. No matter how much soap and water is used, it's unlikely to truly wash away the microscopic bacteria trapped within the fibers. There are some experimental machines using ultrasound to agitate clothing for removing stains, germs and even the water itself for instant drying, but that's not quite production ready.
- rl3 9y agoFunny enough a clothes line on a sunny day might yield good results. I wonder if anyone makes a dryer with embedded UV lights, that'd be interesting.
- c12 9y agoI once had a UV steriliser for an aquarium set up, the wattage of bulb needed to be effective was quite expensive and they didn't last all that long either.
- Fomite 9y agoUV lights are used to kill pathogens in a number of different settings (some hospitals have super-neat UV robots). The issue is you need direct UV exposure - a pile of clothing in a dryer would largely shield itself.
- jonnycomputer 9y agoI am an advocate for energy efficient appliances, but dang it, things got to work. I have a new dishwasher that takes 3 hours to wash, and I struggle to keep red bacteria from growing all over the place in it. I just did a no-dishes bleach wash this morning. I've never had this problem before.
- Bokanovsky 9y agoA few years back I got a new washing machine. After a few weeks of use a light came on that simply said "Hygiene". I had no idea what this meant so looked in the manual. It turns out that the washing machine expects to have a 90 degree C cycle every so often so it kills all the germs inside. This was a feature that my previous machine didn't have.
- handbanana 9y agoSemi related. But dr bronner's sal suds is quite nice as a laundry detergent - works better than the regular dr bronners (for laundry). 2 tablespoons is all it takes, smells great, and it should be fine for most people with sensitive skin.
- cnst 9y agoIf you're ever forgotten to dry the laundry for just a day or two, you can easily notice what your "clean" laundry starts to emanate. I think that's a simple enough experiment that confirms that "clean" laundry does have LOTS of bacteria, especially before it gets killed by removing the leftover water. Speaking of bacteria, another interesting at-home experiment is the one with tea. Not everyone knows, but tea is highly anti-bacterial. If you leave an old tea-bag from milk-free green tea lying around with just enough water to keep it moist for a few days or even a week, the chances of spoilage or mold are extremely low — the water will evaporate faster. (I sometimes didn't throw old tea cups from my desk for weeks, and none of them ever developed anything bad, unless they had something other than the tea, e.g., milk tea will develop mold pretty fast.)
- taneq 9y agoDoesn't matter what a thing is (Edit: Except for a green tea bag, apparently?) if you leave it around damp for a couple of days it'll start to smell musty just from airborne bacteria growing on it. If that thing is a warm damp mesh, it's basically the perfect home for bacteria and will start to smell even if it was 100% sterile when it came out of the machine.
- brianpgordon 9y agoThis is why I've always been grossed out by shared washing machines. In public laundromats you're soaking your clothes in water that's been used by the whole city. People are washing cloth diapers full of baby poop for all you know.
- patsplat 9y agoIs sterile laundry clean?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- exabrial 9y agoIsn't this why you need to dry your clothes on the hottest setting?
- lerie82 9y agoyes. yes it does, and I don't need a study or article to tell me otherwise, it's common sense imo
- portlander12345 9y agoAnyone know a good way to sanitize wool and high-tech fabrics?
- Kiro 9y agoAnyone else get reminded of Oxygen Not Included while reading this thread? A big part of the game is about germs, temperatures and how to manage heat or use gases like chlorine to kill germs.