27 ms·
Study Shows a Productivity Boost of Working From Home
- tribby 9y agoof course it's a productivity boost, but is it healthy for the worker?
- heurist 9y agoNo commute, homemade lunch, more family time...?
- King-Aaron 9y agoMore distraction, less diverse social interaction, more requirement for stringent routines (assuming for a percentage of people)... It would be interesting to weigh up the pros/cons.
- woogiewonka 9y agoWait, these are cons to working from home? If you get distracted at home, you probably get as equally distracted at work. I have been working from home for close to 5 years now and for me it's been the exact opposite - less distractions, more work done in shorter amount of time it would take me to do it in the office. Less social interaction - sure, but it doesn't have to be that way. Social interaction lost one place can be gained elsewhere. Stringent routines? What's wrong with discipline and having the ability to engage and disengage when you please?
- cs02rm0 9y agoHome gym, quiet working environment with walls and a door, ability to receive online orders, monitors as large and high res as I wish to pay for, fridge and kitchen to myself stocked as I wish. Friends and family nearby if you want to lunch with them. You bet it's healthier. Except perhaps slightly increased exposure to the three germ incubating kids under 5 that live here, but there's not much I can do about that now apparently.
- tribaal 9y agoNot to mention: able to live in a large, comfortable house in the country side in the middle of nature (if that's your thing). EDIT: I think kids-flu is hard to avoid at that age, home office or not :P
- collyw 9y agoMy cycle to work and back is half an hours hard cycling each way. I am in good shape since I started this job. (Previously it was a <10 minute roll down a hill followed by 15 minutes cycle back up).
- thaumasiotes 9y ago> slightly increased exposure to the three germ incubating kids under 5 that live here, but there's not much I can do about that You could homeschool them.
- tribby 9y agono doubt there are positive outcomes! I guess what I'm speculating about specifically is a reduction in the number of people one socializes with in a collaborative way and a blurring of the line between work and home that may affect a significant portion of the work-from-home population in a negative way. for me the best situation has always been being a few minutes walking distance from the office. work stays at work, home stays at home, no commute, no bullshit.
- gowld 9y agoModern employers provide better lunch. Family time isn't necessarily quality time.
- heurist 9y agoI disagree with your first assertion :) And I have a long daily commute which takes a lot of time and energy that would otherwise be available for my family. I'd argue that the little interactions throughout a workday at home are more valuable than few or no interactions from the office - quality time or not.
- quickthrower2 9y agoLess likely to catch a cold.
- woogiewonka 9y ago1. Poop any time you want 2. Take a nap vs. pretending to work 3. Less stress - no dealing with assholes in person, now you can simply click away. 4. Spend time with kids 5. No driving needed, avoid polluted highways, more sleep, less stress, less frustration. 6. Eat healthy home made. No need to ingest preservatives every day. 7. Keep sanity by working only when you are most productive vs. pretending to work when you can't get anything done. 8. Less stress from seeing asshole "managers"
- kuriho 9y agoWorking at home offers very little protection from the pains of working for the wrong company.
- Clubber 9y agoYes, but it makes it more tolerable.
- woogiewonka 9y agoI am most productive in early mornings and late evenings. Should I go ahead and tell my boss that I won't be doing anything mid-day and they should be cool with that? Name one place where people will okay this. I can already hear the argument - "but, working at home doesn't mean you can take the afternoon off!!!" I'm sorry to say this, but anyone who thinks they are 100% productive all throughout the day has not had to try hourly work where you get paid by the hours you work and not by the full day. Hourly freelancers know what I am talking about. I will go on record to say that most if not all people can NEVER function at 100% capacity. To believe that looking busy all day long = working is just wishful thinking, ignorance or foolishness, take your pick.
- kuriho 9y agoSo your fictional boss trusts you enough to allow work from home but somehow does not trust you when you propose to work early mornings and late evenings? I can not comment on the hourly freelancer part, but as I understand the US law that keeps getting cited in this thread: "it's illegal to require an independent contractor to be on site or to even set hours".
- agumonkey 9y agothere's the life/work balance that is different and can stretch negatively but it has a lot of value
- godzillabrennus 9y agoGuess the answer needed a study but to me it was answered when Yahoo killed work from home options back when they tried to give it another go. We all know how well that worked.
- tehlike 9y agoI would also like to see long term effects on one's career progress when working from home.
- 49bc 9y agoOr even the long term productivity boost. How long does it last, and why?
- tribaal 9y agoFull remote engineer for 7 years here. I don't think it ever stops. If I had to venture an answer as to why, I'd say "fewer interruptions" - most interactions are asynchronous (email, IRC in my case but slack just as much). The only times I need to have synchronous discussions are either our "watercoolers" (social face-to-face over google hangouts) or the eventual meeting. Note: the companies I've worked for in this setup are all committed to 100% remoteness, and understand that keeping meetings to a minimum is a good thing (note, not abolish - but make sure "meetings" are only called for when actually needed).
- tehlike 9y agoDistractions are indeed costly, and productivity (as in technical throughput) i can see increase quite a lot. That might end up keeping one happy for quite a long time - i noticed my happiness for a day depends a lot on how much stuff i got done that day.
- DecayingOrganic 9y agoI think it's important to be cautious here. People have the tendency to search for, interpret, favor, and recall information in a way that confirms one's preexisting beliefs. So we need to look at the issue in a rather more elaborate way and look for both its upsides and downsides. For example Ray Dalio may have not succeeded applying this technique to his own company; Bridgewater. Because for him, creating a culture of radical transparency and truthfulness is so important. I wonder how he would be able to create such a culture and preserve it if the employees were not working in a common building.
- terenceng2010 9y agoI prefer to work in office in the morning and at home for afternoon. Seems to get the most benefits ( communication in office, focus time at home)
- kuriho 9y agoWhile I agree with your sentiment, this is probably the worst solution for people with long commutes.
- loco5niner 9y agoAgreed. Part of my desire to work from home is to reclaim an hour to an hour and a half of my life back every day.
- tex0 9y agoIt depends a lot on the type of work you do and the company setup. As a developer in regular software companies I like working from home one or two days a week. That gives some nice focus time while still giving enough days for meetings and communication. Working from home 100% probably only works in remote only companies (like GitLab), otherwise there a huge information gap. In general I'd love to see a right to home office as a law. That could help to cut a lot of emissions and useless commuting back and forth.
- ghaff 9y agoIt doesn’t need to be at an entire company level. Where I work, some teams are mostly co-located, others are more distributed, some are pretty much fully remote. And things can shift over time.
- ak39 9y agoFirst para hits the nail on the head. The issue is: trust between managers and employees. Also, "work from home" paradigm will only succeed when management paradigm changes from managing time to managing outcome. And changing that management style is not easy. Managing outcomes requires managers to understand not only the strategic agendas set by the bosses higher up but also the technical paths to achieve them confronted by the "serfs" under. It also requires that managers themselves are empowered to make decisions on budgets and execute on outcomes - managers who can't make decisions daily without checking in on higher up bosses for authorisation will be unlikely to agree to a work from home scenario.
- GordonS 9y ago> Also, "work from home" paradigm will only succeed when management paradigm changes from managing time to managing outcome. And changing that management style is not easy I've been working 75-80% from home for several years now, and I've had 5 managers during that time. Before that, I mostly worked in an office, but my managers were located in another country. In that whole time, even having some terrible managers at points, all of my managers were more focused on managing outcomes - it always just seems to come naturally. I'm in the UK, working for a Norwegian company - maybe things are just more progressive here than in the US?
- Clubber 9y ago>maybe things are just more progressive here than in the US? Probably. For many in the US, managers tend to do very little to actually help things, but take all the credit (and rewards) for the positive outcomes. I suspect the US is successful in spite of how we do business, not because of it.
- l5870uoo9y 9y ago> managing time to managing outcome A task will take the time that have been reserved for it. That is inefficient. Changing to a result-orientated approach where an employee is giving weekly or daily tasks (if it isn't too complicated - which is really a good question) would also mean that if an employee is finished with his weekly tasks after 3 days, he gets to go home. For many seems counterintuitive (fixed time management is essentially used from the first day of school and is pervasive in society) and it does have it own difficulties changing. For instance, how does co-workers feel when one fast employee always gets to leave early? How easy is it to pick tasks for employees? Freelance programmers are one group where this result-orientated approach works, not sure it can be extended to other sectors easily.
- kccqzy 9y agoOn the other hand, it is also imaginable that working at home away from everyone else makes communication harder, and more opaque. Or it can make you lonelier. Not every company has policies and culture that makes it conducive to work from home.
- ILikeConemowk 9y ago> lonelier How can being at home ever make you lonely when it gives you more time to focus on relationships that actually matter. Am I alone in thinking that those who expect any kind of meaningful bonding at work are misguided? Yeah, one can enjoy smalltalk and the like but I'd much rather change that for a chat with a friend or my dad early in the morning.
- paganel 9y ago> How can being at home ever make you lonely when it gives you more time to focus on relationships that actually matter. Not all of us have kids or live with our family, and as such those 8 hours of office work are the only option for having a human presence around us during the day. Working 8 hours trapped in the loneliness of your house's walls each day, every day can be quite unsettling in the long run.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- John_KZ 9y agoIn my experience even family men get frustrated with working at home. Sure, 1 or 2 days per week is fine, but more than that is generally too much. Work is probably the most common (or even exclusive for some) way adults meet new people, especially people they wouldn't otherwise meet. It sounds dumb when you don't experience it, but after spending a month or two working at home it start becoming apparent that you are getting too detached from society.
- gowld 9y agoSocial people enjoy both chatting in the morning and having company during the day.
- bryanh 9y agoWe've got a lot of experience running a remote team, in fact, we wrote a guide/book on it: https://zapier.com/learn/remote-work/ https://zapier.com/learn/remote-work/ We certainly don't claim to have all the answers, but we've found it makes people pretty happy and we all seem pretty productive. If you want to give it a go, we're hiring! ;-) https://zapier.com/jobs/ https://zapier.com/jobs/
- iovrthoughtthis 9y agoConfirms my bias!
- eksemplar 9y agoI’m not sure realism/positivism is the best approach to empirical data on this. Only one of my workers is more productive from home, in the IT department almost all the workers are more productive from home. We haven’t done any research on the causality, but the personality’s profiles for or digitization and IT departments are vastly different, so too is the work we donald the way we go about it. If you looked at us over all, there’s 20 workers in my department and around 60 in the IT department and around 55 of the 80 are more productive from home. The setup I personally use to gain the most out of my employees is letting them work their own hours the way they want. I don’t check their hours but trust them to put in the hours they need, and they do, in fact the biggest problem is getting them to only work the 37 hours they are hired to put in. Sometimes they come in late and leave early, sometimes they work from home and I can tell by what they produce they spent half the day doing something else. But then sometimes I’ll get an email at 2am on a Saturday because someone found his/her coding flow at an off hour. This would be extremely unhealthy if I required it, but my employee satisfaction went up from 4.3 out of 7 under the previous manager to 6.3/7 under me and our performance output nearly doubled. Working at home is fine, but I don’t think you can truthfully say that it works for everyone. I think it’s important to leave the option open along with other options in a framework that encourages team work and communication, and then trust your employees to do the right thing and only intervene in their schedule and where they want to work, when you begin to spot trouble.
- ramblerman 9y ago> Sometimes they come in late and leave early, sometimes they work from home and I can tell by what they produce they spent half the day doing something else. But then sometimes I’ll get an email at 2am on a Saturday because someone found his/her coding flow at an off hour. god bless you for this insight. As a contractor I've worked at multiple places, and my current gig cares more about 'asses in seats' than output. It's incredibly demotivating, having come from an environment where output was the goal.
- ende 9y agoAs a contractor, you are under no obligation to be an ass in any seat, and if client says otherwise you can point them towards IRS reclassification.
- a_imho 9y agoParticipants were not even selected random Enter Bloom, who helped design a test whereby 500 employees were divided into two groups--a control group (who continued working at HQ) and volunteer work-from-homers (who had to have a private room at home, at least six-month tenure with Ctrip, and decent broadband access as conditions).
- inglor 9y agoCame here to find this. Precisely what I thought - I think that some people work better remotely and some work better in an office setting (like myself). If you ask people to volunteer for remote work then people who are better remote workers are likely to volunteer and more likely to work harder to prove it can work.
- lawnchair_larry 9y agoStill interesting that people who volunteer for remote work are more productive on average than those who prefer office work.
- isostatic 9y agoAnd cheaper of course - no need for a desk ($2k/yr), means they should be paid more.
- MoBattah 9y agoHave you ever seen the accounting side of this? I've previously seen accounting docs at a major defense firm I worked for. They tallied the exact dollar amount spent on each employee's square footage of office space on a monthly basis. Furthers the argument you make.
- isostatic 9y agoWell it's fairly simple - we have a building that only has office people in (not many, but some) The cost of that building divided by the number of people there. There's then power, heat, cleaning, etc, but that's all small fry compared with the rent or opportunity cost of an office building. The technical infrastructure (Cisco switches don't come cheap) is probably offset by the cost of supporting remote infrastructure, vpns etc. The cost per deal in central London is on the order of $10k-$20k a year. I'll take that in cash thanks. http://www.cityam.com/233082/london-office-rents-tube-map-heres-how-much-desk-space-costs-across-the-capital-in-one-simple-map http://www.cityam.com/233082/london-office-rents-tube-map-he...
- piyush_soni 9y agoDid their sample involve men with a 2 year old at home that constantly needs their attention as long as they are at home, and thinks that when their father is sitting on the laptop, he's making pink and blue spheres in paintbrush? Honestly, I can achieve little at home these days and feel like I'm doing injustice to both, work and the kid.
- inglor 9y agoHonestly one of the biggest motivations I have to work from home which I otherwise dislike is to be there for my children when they're 2. Especially since where I live (Israel) like most of the world men and women are still usually not equally responsible regarding child care and I personally think remote work could help with that (as well as personal motivation to be there for my kids).
- GordonS 9y agoI work from home, and my wife looks after our children during the day. Working from home has been great for us all - we get to have breakfast and lunch together every day, and I'm around to help out at those times (if you've got young kids, you'll know meal times can be stressful at times!).
- GordonS 9y agoI don't think it's possible to work from home and look after a child at the same time - that won't give your work or your child sufficient focus.
- isostatic 9y agoOf course it's not, sounds like the OP has a problem with discipline, both his own (actually work rather than play with child), and the child (who hasn't been told to leave alone) I'm assuming that there is someone else actually looking after the child, you can't leave a 2 year old alone for more than a couple of minutes (and even then you have to keep one eye on them)
- anoplus 9y agoI work from office (40min train) and some days from home. Home working enables me to recharge quickly and stay healthy. Office is good for seamlessly collaborative work. If I had to choose just one mode I would go for "home". It's just saves huge amount of time and energy. Feels much healthier. You can still collaborate fairly well if you have internet.
- piva00 9y agoI have worked exclusively remotely for a couple of years in my career and I'd say the perfect world for me is this hybrid. I can go to the office when I need or want, it's better to collaborate, to do pair or mob programming and to get discussions going on. Working from home is great when I have a clear view of priorities and the task at hand but I sorely missed the social interactions of an office when I didn't have the option for it. As most things in life, it's a spectrum, there are some people that probably work much better away from the office, personally I still need sometimes the social aspect of work to be my most productive self.
- kuriho 9y agoWith the population exploding and space to build new houses growing ever so scarcely I can not imagine a long-term future in which working from home would be profitable. Instead of working from home, living at work seems to be the more logical step forward. Personally I'd prefer living at a shared-workspace or company campus as long as work and living facilities are clearly separate.
- coldtea 9y agoYeah, it's called peonage.
- ende 9y agosee also: Company Towns (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Company_town https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Company_town)
- dvt 9y ago> Personally I'd prefer living at a shared-workspace or company campus as long as work and living facilities are clearly separate. May I ask why? I'd prefer living close to my family and friends, many of which may not work for the same company as I work for. I'm trying to see what your motivating factors are because I, for one, could not disagree more.
- kuriho 9y agoA shared-workspace campus for you and your friends would work out then? You can picture it as a shared-workspace town if that is more appealing to you. Living quarters, parks, etc. on one side of the highway. A shared-workspace campus hosting multiple companies/teams on the other. Living and working stays strictly separate, everyone has a short commute and you still have all project members available on-site at the same time to reliably work together and gasp actually meet up when required. To answer your question, I do not want to bring work into my home. BYOD resolves most of the factors that would make me want to provide my own office at home. May I ask how you currently manage to live close to your family and friends and (because I have to assume you are surrounded by like-minded individuals) their families and their friends and so on? Frankly, I find this very unrealistic, but maybe that's because my friends and family are spread out across the globe.
- TomMckenny 9y agoRelative to an open office environment, working in a gas station bathroom is more productive.
- ende 9y agoI knew one of you would be in here.
- dev_north_east 9y agoI must be one of the few devs who doesn't like working from home. I do it when I have to but feel lonelier, out of the loop on the project/news, don't like that there's no distinction between home and work place. I think it's important to be able to switch off and mixing the worlds doesn't do it for me.
- kp10 9y agoWell, I can testify that. Also, If you follow Pomodoro technique, it further boost your productivity
- throwaway84742 9y agoAs a manager: some people can work from home, and some just can’t. The problem is, you don’t know which is which when recruiting, and firing someone even remotely in a protected class is a huge hassle. Even so, if I were to start a company today, I would try very hard to hire remote, for many reasons, the most important of which is this would dramatically expand the talent pool, and (I believe) lead to less stressed employees and better results. People who lack intrinsic motivation typically don’t perform well even in the office.
- minipci1321 9y ago> As a manager: some people can work from home, and some just can’t. The problem is, you don’t know which is which when recruiting, ... Interesting! So, has it ever happened to you to hire a remote worker with a proven track record (say, 3-5 years, references checked) and then realize after some time that this person "doesn't fit the bill" for working remotely for you? (If it has happened, I'd be interested to know details -- was it because of the specifics of your company's procedures, or something else?)
- throwaway84742 9y agoI had employees who would ask to “work from home” and then not actually do much, hoping I won’t notice. But good managers do notice, of course, especially when some of the peers work from home as well and turn in reams of high quality code at a rapid clip. I never had anyone who had a track record of _remote_ work specifically, though.
- lawlorino 9y ago> 500 employees were divided into two groups--a control group (who continued working at HQ) and volunteer work-from-homers (who had to have a private room at home, at least six-month tenure with Ctrip, and decent broadband access as conditions). That's a huge selection bias - if the 'treatment' group are self-selecting volunteers from your pool of all employees then that causes a whole host of issues.
- lozenge 9y agoNot really, this increases its applicability as this is the usual case in which people are considering working from home - as an option at a non-fully-remote company, or as an option to join a fully remote company.
- js8 9y agoIt is selection bias, but the study shows more work being done. If people who self-selected for working from home would do so to try to avoid working, then why there would be positive result (and more work done)?
- gowld 9y agoThe journalist made a mistake. The paper says: > After a lottery draw, those employees with even-numbered birthdays were selected to work from home, and those with odd-numbered birthdates stayed in the office to act as the control group.
- partycoder 9y agoLibrary etiquette = staying quiet, don't disturb people But suddenly if you are programming, reading and writing code, you require less concentration? TV dramas show people talking over their desks and try to convince people this is what being productive looks like, but that's far from reality. Joel Spolsky said it in 2000: "Do you programmers have quiet working conditions?" https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2000/08/09/the-joel-test-12-steps-to-better-code/ https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2000/08/09/the-joel-test-12-s...
- Aissen 9y agoLooks like this is summary of a 2014 paper: https://academic.oup.com/qje/article-abstract/130/1/165/2337855?redirectedFrom=fulltext https://academic.oup.com/qje/article-abstract/130/1/165/2337... (paywalled :-/ ) I wonder how many years of rediscovery of basic knowledge about productivity it will take before these ideas are widly accepted: open plans offices are bad, remote work can be done, etc.
- atypeoferror 9y agoLink to the actual paper: https://people.stanford.edu/nbloom/sites/default/files/wfh.pdf https://people.stanford.edu/nbloom/sites/default/files/wfh.p...
- thinkingemote 9y agoThis really needs to be higher, and the paper actually read by us, as it addresses the nature of the work, the study size and methodology, as well as sociological issues. All things that these other comments speculate about Crucially it's not IT, the work is a call centre travel agency (and it's also in China). "First, the job of a call center employee is particularly suitable for telecommuting. It requires neither teamwork nor in-person face time. Quantity and quality of performance can be easily quantified and evaluated. The link between effort and performance is direct. These conditions apply to a range of service jobs, such as sales, IT support, and secretarial assistance, but they are far from universal. Second, the firm can closely monitor the performance and labor supply of the employees thanks to its extensive centralized database. Team leaders and managers could generate a report from the database of the performance of the team members daily and easily detect problems in individual employees’ performance. Third, the extent of WFH was limited, so that it did not require a significant reorganization at the workplace. Team leaders continued to supervise their teams with a mix of home and office workers without any major reshuffling of team membership."
- netsharc 9y agoGeez, a call-centre? I thought "virtual call centers" are common nowadays, i.e. you can be at home doing laundry, when the phone rings, it will say "Call for $COMPANY", you pick up and say "Hello, $COMPANY, Angela speaking, how may I help you?"...
- Rainymood 9y agoPhD student here so take my opinion with a grain of salt. I personally love the fact that I can choose to work at home or at the office. I can really concentrate at home (private room where I feel comfy) but on the other hand it is also significantly easier to distract yourself from work. Netflix is just one tab away and there's no one to look over your shoulder and whisper in your ear "Don't watch Netflix when you're working". It also depends a lot on my mood. When I feel down and worthless because my research feels like its going nowhere I distract myself more easily. If I feel optimistic like I'm a predator hunting some prey because my research is leading somewhere fruitful I can work anywhere with great focus without the need for distraction.
- OpenDrapery 9y agoI think the big dirty secret is that even in the office, there is a need for down time. The problem is that my options are limited, so I sit at my desk and look at the same stupid web sites in a clandestine manner. Or I get up and go for a walk, and try to get some fresh air. But my office building sits on an interstate and there are no walking paths or benches in sight. At home, my breathers are more energizing, which is the point. I can't believe how ridiculous it is that managers feign surprise when they are told that a task estimated at 4 hours will take a calendar day to complete. That is the nature of the work.
- jkcorrea 9y agoThat last sentiment really resonated with me. I'm currently working somewhere that more or less requires a typical M-F 9-5 schedule. I often don't feel in the "mood" on various weekdays, while some weekends I get that "predator" feeling you described and can code non-stop for hours on end. However, since I need to be in the office M-F I more often feel, and give in to, the pressure to not work weekends lest my family and social life/general well-being suffer. I wonder how many productive hours I've lost due to this conundrum, and beyond that how many productive hours have been lost in my company or the modern workplace.
- wool_gather 9y ago> the pressure to not work weekends It's interesting that you describe feeling pressure to not work; usually I think people talk about feeling the pressure to work. But I know what you mean. It's hard to know how to balance the two. On the one shoulder is a little voice saying "Don't be a sucker and spend your free time making money for the company! It's just a job! Go have a life". On the other is the pride of craft, and the thrill of having a really good idea that you want to see to the end. I've been thinking a lot about this, not least because my relationship was a bit strained last year due to both of us probably putting too much emphasis on our work. I don't know if ultimately one side or the other is the right answer. Doing good and creative work is important and fulfilling. But friends and family are equally important and fulfilling. Maybe the only way is to carefully guard against either one predominating.
- pilingual 9y ago“If companies want hackers to be productive, they should look at what they do at home. At home, hackers can arrange things themselves so they can get the most done. And when they work at home, hackers don't work in noisy, open spaces; they work in rooms with doors. They work in cosy, neighborhoody places with people around and somewhere to walk when they need to mull something over, instead of in glass boxes set in acres of parking lots. They have a sofa they can take a nap on when they feel tired, instead of sitting in a coma at their desk, pretending to work. There's no crew of people with vacuum cleaners that roars through every evening during the prime hacking hours. There are no meetings or, God forbid, corporate retreats or team-building exercises. And when you look at what they're doing on that computer, you'll find it reinforces what I said earlier about tools. They may have to use Java and Windows at work, but at home, where they can choose for themselves, you're more likely to find them using Perl and Linux.” http://paulgraham.com/gh.html http://paulgraham.com/gh.html
- gowld 9y ago> hackers don't work in noisy, open spaces; they work in rooms with doors. > They work in cosy, neighborhoody places with people around Which is it? That article did not age well.
- hobofan 9y ago> Which is it? The statements are not contradicting each other. The first statement is on the in-building level and the second one is on the out-of-building level.
- mikekchar 9y agoOddly my most productive place is the train -- especially the shinkansen (I'm in Japan). My next most productive is MacDonald's. It is super weird. However, I think part of the productivity increase is due to it being an unusual place. I don't live anywhere near MacDonald's and I only work there when I visit my mother in law (who lives in a fairly big city). I couldn't possibly afford to travel on the shinkansen all day (although the prospect of travelling for 8 hours and then spending the night in a new city every day is really compelling -- One of these days I'll go up to Akita or somewhere that will take a whole day :-) ). I like working from home, but I actually hate the fact that I'm basically forced to work from home every day (because I live in the countryside). Quiet is nice, but quiet all the time is a bit hard to bear. At least for me.
- Promarged 9y ago> Enter Bloom, who helped design a test whereby 500 employees were divided into two groups--a control group (who continued working at HQ) and volunteer work-from-homers (who had to have a private room at home, at least six-month tenure with Ctrip, and decent broadband access as conditions). Did it say volunteer? That already stains the results as control group and the test group are not similar. Maybe volunteers are already more productive than people that don't want to experiment?
- gowld 9y agoThe journalist made a mistake. The paper says: > After a lottery draw, those employees with even-numbered birthdays were selected to work from home, and those with odd-numbered birthdates stayed in the office to act as the control group.
- jankotek 9y agoThere is also gender equality. Women find it much easier to work from home!
- acrive 9y agoI had work from home. Never again in my life. Going to the office helped me to split the time in my day and mark when work and when I can rest. Also, when stressed a coworker can help much more easier than from home. My home is my home, my office is my office. Never mix these places.
- dijit 9y agoThere are people who prefer the office, there are people who prefer the home. Surely not forcing everyone either way is the right approach?
- acrive 9y agoYou're right. At the beginning I'm was very happy, but after two months I wanted to go back to the office. I was lucky because nobody forced me a choice.
- aogaili 9y agoWorked from office..never again. Stuck in traffic, too many distractions, co-workers complains and politics. If I don't want to work from home I can go to a cafe or travel while work. Never mix socializing with work.
- gowld 9y agoThis study was about call-center agents, not professionals working on complex team projects.
- Angostura 9y agoI worked for a very good company which let me work from home when my first child was born (I tried to resign, they said - wouldn't you prefer to work part time from home). The only problem I had was that the whole watercooler thing was real, and you tended not to find out about the interesting little projects or chip in with bits of insight. After 3 years, I ended up resigning and going freelance because they were paying me quite a lot of money, but I didn't really feel that I was contributing. Yes, I know - middle-class first world problems.
- fuscy 9y agoIs the population data specified anywhere for the 500 participants? I shared this article to some colleagues which are married and have small children and they seem to disagree with these findings. I tend to agree because home disturbances can be major in a household unless you isolate yourself totally. On the other hand this could be great for single workers in the short term, unless we ignore the fact that most relationships occur due to high frequency meetings (aka work, study etc.).
- anentropic 9y agoanecdotally for myself I find the reverse is true
- atrexler 9y agoI wonder at how this would vary across industries and also company sizes. I'm surprised the study had positive results at a relatively large firm. I think its easy to imagine working-from-home gains in small firms and startups where typically there's a much stronger selection for highly motivated and enthusiastic people. It's not clear the same would result in a huge firm where you have less of that selection. Also how does one measure productivity? (this is probably a naive question as a relative neophyte) An article I found on this says they were 13.5% "more efficient" but I'd love to get the details on what that means. Its a travel agency so are they just booking, scheduling, organizing, etc? Would love to see a similar study in a SW dev environment, alternately something less tech focused but collaborative...I dunno but something creative most likely.
- kapauldo 9y agoThe photo is so unrealistic that it made me laugh.
- JepZ 9y agoWhat I find most interesting about this is the productivity boost coming not just from people working more, but also from fewer sick days. > Additionally (and incredibly), employee attrition decreased by 50 percent among the telecommuters, they took shorter breaks, had fewer sick days, and took less time off.
- bsvalley 9y agoWorking from home is the product of only one person, the CEO. If the CEO approves working from home then the rest is history. Switch your CEO and the whole working from home policy in your company is in danger.
- adriand 9y agoI think it depends on what you want to optimize for. If you want to optimize for individual productivity (and there are no trust issues) then sure, working from home is effective. However, you may decide that the individual productivity loss of having people work in an office is outweighed by the group productivity and morale gain from having people working together. Here are some reasons from a holistic company perspective for requiring people to work out of the office: - To more effectively add to the culture of the company. - To take part in ad hoc training opportunities, either to teach someone who needs help, or to learn something from someone when an obstacle is encountered. - To be able to attend in-person meetings or stand-ups when urgent things come up - without the awkwardness and delays of conferencing in multiple people. - To provide mentorship to junior staff. - To collaborate more effectively. - To show clients/prospective clients, partners and recruits, a vibrant and energetic team and working environment that is worth investing in/joining. - To build morale and a sense of teamwork and camaraderie. At the same time, measures need to be taken in the office working environment to ensure that individuals can be productive, which means providing quiet working spaces, enforcing do-not-disturb rules, etc. Last point. To anyone who is running a business where your employees can easily choose to work from home for any company in the world, such as software engineers: creating a vibrant company culture is one of the ways in which you can attract and retain team members. Many people like being part of an in-person team and working with each other on a regular basis. But if they're already working from home and rarely seeing their co-workers, what difference does it make if they choose to work for some startup out of SF?
- wolco 9y agoAll of these items can be done remotely. Training/mentoring/team work/stand ups/taking accountibility. Showing clients you have employees working might seem like it will help land some clients if you bring them for a visit but more impressive is having a global remote team you can conference in.
- frockington 9y agoYou can't greet the client shake their hand and establish a connection over a video conference nearly as easily as you can in person. As a client I find myself paying attention to the little things. Did they offer coffee or water? Did they open the door? How was the handshake? Did they look trustworthy? If you are remoting in a global team it will be more difficult to provide the experience.
- merinowool 9y agoI find it bizarre that most of companies I worked with had recognised working from home as a privilege and it was mostly frowned upon by colleagues who for any reason had to work in the office. It was also not recognised that people working from home got more things done and thought of compensating employee extra for using their own space, internet connection, electricity at home was a fantasy. Some employees that tried to force others to be in the office often had problems at home and office was their escape. If work in the office would have become optional, then that would have been their bad dreams come true - if their spouse for example learned they don't have to come every day. This has a big impact on people who don't have problems, but also don't want to be subjected to open office shenanigans. I think solution would be to pay employees more so that they can either rent their own offices or cover the use of their homes. That way those who don't want to stay at home could have their own private space to work in.
- chiefalchemist 9y agoI'd like to see a study that looks at commute time, commute method (e.g., car, bus, rail, bike), and commute time. Personally, I find having to take the train to a client site and being on site invigorating (to some extent). The ride in, I read and generally get mentally prepared. The ride home I read and decompress. The defined start and end keep the time in between focused. Mind you, we're talking a couple (or three) days a week (not all five). It's also not driving (which I'd dread.) It might just be how I'm wired and approach things; the cycle, if ypu will, might just sync well with my brain.
- chrisper 9y agoI despise working from home (but I welcome the option of choosing). I just keep getting distracted by other stuff.
- camdenreslink 9y agoWorking from home definitely allows for more “heads down” time. When you are in the office there are more distractions to break your focus.
- gravis7777 9y agoI don't work in IT, so I can see some differences from that field to mine. But being a functional manager in a business, I can't tell you how invaluable it is to walk outside my office to 20-30 cubicles and being able to get a quick answer or have a quick discussion on something, and how often people overhearing conversations in the office saves useless work.
- hprotagonist 9y agowhenever I work from home i spend more time with my family and alphabetize my socks and disinfect the lightbulbs. that is a productivity boost, but perhaps not what the study had in mind.
- potatote 9y agoI've been working from home once a week in the past couple of months, and noticed that I spend more time working at home than I do in the office. For example, if I work from home, I'd be working from 8am to 6pm (with a few short breaks for lunch and etc.). If I go to work, I clock in at 8:30am (commute) and checks out at 5:30pm sharp. In a way, my employer is getting an extra 30-60 mins out of me for the days I work from home (assuming that I'm as productive working from home as I am at the office, which I believe is to be the case).
- OpenDrapery 9y agoAs usual, the workers and managers are playing different games. As a developer, it's easy to assume that productivity is the game. Form a strong team and add business value through execution, right? Wrong. Management is playing a game of consistency and control. Blanket policies are the name of the game. I don't care if you are 100x more productive at home. I can't have all these other losers asking me why they aren't allowed to work from home. God forbid I consider a stratified policy where some people get privileges that others don't. This is why small companies move the needle on innovation, because they don't have to cater to lowest common denominator of 5000 people. Large companies are ruled by old men, and are beholden to status quo.
- lev99 9y agoWow. This really highlights the differences between a small company and a large company. I have a hard time justifying keeping B- employees on my team, I couldn't imagine calling people under me in the org chart "losers" without having an active plan to remove them.
- OpenDrapery 9y agoYeah, it's fairly gross. Insurance and banking are chock full of corporate cockroaches. They can hide for years without adding any real value. But boy, do they want their fair treatment.
- yosito 9y agoSome managers play the game of productivity. But many who do probably find that they work themselves out of a job.
- vfc1 9y agoThe arguments against remote work often remind me of the arguments that we used to hear against Amazon vs brick and mortar retailers: "Amazon is never going to replace them because people like too much the social aspect of going to the store and maybe bump into their neighboors". Yes, of course, working from home is much more productive. This is true for creative professions especially (like software development or content creation), where the ability to focus and concentrate is essential for getting anything done. It's very demoralizing and stressful to have your day split up into 1000 random interruptions, very hard to code or write productively in those circumstances. Most meetings are useless and this is especially true for standups, and deep down we all know it. In most companies, people get to their desk and just start emailing people 3 meters away, might as well do it from home. All this wasted time, unnecessary facetime and excessive long hours, polution caused by transports, wasted time from peoples lives comutting, simply in the name of doing things the way that they where always done. Remote work will be very common in 10 years, the economics are there: people want it as they want a better life, they save money, and the companies save money too.
- detaro 9y agoProblem is, you could have said your last paragraph 10 years ago too. So while I hope you're right, it's far from clear that your arguments will win now. Still lots of companies building massive campuses instead of distributing.
- OpenDrapery 9y agoThings that have gotten better in the last 10 years: ubiquity of high speed internet, tools such as voip, screen share, chat, cloud hosting across regions, lower cost of home office hardware like monitors Things that have gotten worse: traffic and congestion, real estate prices The needle is moving in the direction of wfh, I definitely believe that those that embrace it will be ahead of the game.
- isostatic 9y agoI said exactly the same thing in 2010, and I've worked away from the office most of the time for 6 years (not necessarily working from home - I visit a lot of locations for work, next week it's Windsor, last week was Nairobi, Moscow's coming up early next month) Because I have to be able to work from anywhere, it makes working from home easy. I may see the rest of my team on the 22nd, and we have an away day to a supplier on the 30th.
- maxfurman 9y agoAt my job, we do Monday-Wednesday-Friday in the office and work from home the other two days. It seems to me to be the perfect balance between the coordination and social benefits of being in an office and the freedom and productivity gains of remote work. I'm surprised more companies don't try this kind of schedule.
- jaaames 9y agoThis is excellent. Combined with some basic rules like no meetings on Fridays it can quickly become a simple and effective company culture.
- MoBattah 9y agoI'm starting a new role next week and that's exactly the schedule I negotiated. The mix, I think, is good on a social level. When I used to work 100% remote, I found myself walking to the grocery store just to see other people.
- sytse 9y agoI think that working full-time from home is hard in a firm where the leadership is at the HQ. If everyone is remote you no longer miss out by working from home.
- _Codemonkeyism 9y agoDidn't watch the Tedx talk, sadly the article doesn't mention what "productivity" is and how it was measured.
- n_t 9y agoFor me, it didn't work out due to multiple reasons. But if you have any input for others as to how to make it work, add your insights here - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17047340 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17047340
- nicodjimenez 9y agoI've been working "from home" for two years now and I've learned a couple thing. Living with family is huge because it really relieves the burden of loneliness as well makes you feel safe, which makes it a lot easier to take bigger risks in your work. Living with my girlfriend has been great, but it was terrible when she had a 9 to 5. It really throws you off to live with people on a 9 to 5 schedule imo because it's a totally different mindset and increases perceived social isolation.
- sparrish 9y agoI've been working remotely for 10 years now. I've got 7 kids that my wife and I homeschool. I'm never 'lonely' <grin>.
- mr_tristan 9y agoI've worked remotely for my last two jobs, and in general, love it. I live in a city I love, and the companies I've worked for are in places I really don't want to be in, physically. What I don't see, however, is a "third option" that I'd really, really want: the option, say, one day a week, to work in a shared space, with people related to my domain. My company actually has an office that's in a suburb of where I live now. But it's inhabited by people who work in completely different functions and unrelated products. So going there would mean... I'd just basically sit there and chat with my coworkers online all day. Maybe have awkward superficial conversations in meatspace with a sales member, but I find the chats are just not very interesting, because I end up spending all my time explaining what I do, instead of actually having a conversation. Again, what I'd love, is a shared space with other software engineers working on different products or tech. Sure, there are always issues of IP and privacy, but, I'd guess that the random watercooler conversation with someone tackling a very different kind of problem would be valuable. The added bonus of networking would be useful too.
- Nowyouknow 9y agoHave you tried a coworking space? Look into it! I'm actually trying to come up with a way to regularly do this and expense it, just got to pitch it the right way :)
- mr_tristan 9y agoYeah, in the end, I guess I'm just trying to find ways to justify a budget for a coworking space. Seems like option that's not frequently discussed when researching remote work.
- cletus 9y agoThere are several topics that I must admit to tiring of on HN, not because of any issue with the topic itself but the inevitable response it engenders. Any topic about tech company hiring and interviewing invokes regurgitation of the same tired responses (probably by the same people) on both sides of whiteboard coding (as just one example). Remote working (as a topic) is the same. You get the same responses ("it works fine for me", "Being in an office is completely pointless", etc). The problem is a significant chunk of particularly the pro-remote work crowd has an axe to grind. Some just want to work remotely (which is fine) but then will often use anecdata and often dismiss any of the valid issues brought up by remote working (communication, culture, isolation, etc). It's interesting because this inability to separate one's personal desires with what's good for the whole is exactly how NIMBYism exists. This approach of deciding on a given outcome and thenc onstructing "reality" to support that view taken to extremes is incredibly dangerous. You don't have to look that far to see some frightening examples. Just this week we had Trump withdraw from the Iranian deal for pretty much no other reason than "Obama = bad" with basically zero evidence to support it. Hell the US started a war in Iraq because of this same construct-reality-to-match-your-beliefs view (then about WMDs). These obviously are extreme examples. I find the inability to have reasoned discourse to be disappointing with well-reasoned comments on this thread lambasted as "bullshit". Likewise you see the downvote-because-I-disagree-with-you attitude that I personally can't stand.
- shadowtree 9y agoBut I like whiteboarding with a few people in a physical room. :(
- elbear 9y agoI can confirm the part about feeling isolated after working remotely for 7 years. I try to compensate by going to co-working spaces or cafes and working from there. Another thing that doesn't help my situation is that I'm mostly working alone on the project that I'm working on. I tried to compensate for that by volunteering my programming skills for an NGO.
- dfsegoat 9y agoIsolation led to mental health issues for me as well. What you describe sounds like a very good solution to that part of this (Also: Meetups).
- elbear 9y agoYes, I've also started going to meetups.
- Nowyouknow 9y agoSolo projects are no fun. When I get bogged down with it, I will usually set up a call for info with coworkers and just talk through it with them. That brainstorm time is re-energizing and helps me get over the humps.
- mtw 9y agoTake this study with a grain of salt. Shanghai is an extremely competitive and expensive city. There is a lot of social pressure to work hard, or at least pay for overpriced rent. If the employees were authorized to work from home, they can't afford to watch TV or hang around in coffee shops or coworking spaces.
- madrox 9y agoThis is a study of a large travel agency, not creative/knowledge workers. This would explain why the study's results don't map to my experiences. If you're doing creative work or work that requires frequent communication with peers, you need an environment that encourages diversity and collaboration. Working from home is not collaborative.
- notadoc 9y agoUltimately most tech / knowledge workers need to work somewhere that allows them to focus and be uninterrupted. Whether that is home, a dedicated office, coffee shop, or you're one of the rare individuals that can pull it off in a cube farm or the worst of the open office designs, do whatever works for you. This is where employers must be flexible, not everyone is going to be productive in the same environment. And speaking of focus, disabling virtually all notifications on your phone and computer will increase productivity too.
- graeme 9y agoI worked on my business from home for years. It was very productive. Then a year and a half ago, I got an office two minutes away from my apartment. I would say I'm less productive, but significantly more relaxed. I think this is an improvement. (I say think because there's defintely a tradeoff to growing slower. I'm trading relaxation now for less relaxation later) I'm not sure exactly why this is. Part of it is just being able to walk to the computer and quickly solve a task when it comes to mind. Or, conversely, to leave work and cook food/shower etc with no friction and then get back to work.
- jakebaker 9y agoI think that the productivity boost may be somewhat binary -- some people are AMAZINGLY more productive at home vs an office environment. For me, I've personally struggled with the home environment at times. The shared team construct of an office setting helps me get over my common obstacle of procrastination. When I do work from home, I've used some forms of productivity and accountability tools to get over that barrier. These have included services like Focusmate [1] which lets you schedule co-working video sessions with a partner. That has been incredibly helpful for me, getting me to move immediately to working on whatever the difficult task at hand is. [1] https://www.focusmate.com https://www.focusmate.com
- dmcgill50 9y agoThis study was several years ago with a company that does call center work. This sort of productivity is easy to measure compared to other forms of team work. I don't think that it would be beneficial to extrapolate that finding to all kinds of work. Co-location is a huge benefit when working with small, focused teams. There have been volumes written on the benefit of being in close proximity to members with a shared goal.
- elieldepaula 9y agoVery good! I work remotely a few years (about 8 years) and it definitely changed my life. Less traffic time, more family time and all the advantages we already know about remote work. But there are a few butts in all this. 1- You definitely need a good working environment at home, no use sitting on the kitchen table with your notebook. 2- A certain level of self-discipline is required for those who will work remotely to avoid procrastination. I know a lot of people who can not work at home, it turns into Facebook and Netflix. 3. Remote work is a culture that has to be applied to the whole family. For a long time, and even nowadays, because I was at home, people thought I was at ease and / or their disposition, which caused some friction. The remote worker has to make it clear to family members that at that time it is as if he is not there. Other than that, I think it's very valid, and I think it's good that everyone could work remotely.