10 ms·
The YIMBYs lost in California but they’re just getting started
- abalone 9y ago> ...local regulations used by homeowners to block new development. If the YIMBYs want to win they need to realize their opponents are not just homeowners. Low-income renters have issues with them too. YIMBYs are generally in some form of denial about that. They like to believe that they are fighting the progressive fight against rich, old homeowners. They like to proclaim they are fighting for "poorer, younger, and (frequently) non-white people" (Stripe).[1] But when it comes to explaining why poorer and non-white renters aren't always on their side, YIMBYs are caught flat-footed. If they're not careful they end up sounding condescending. Like, Didn't you guys take economics? Supply and demand, bro! That's probably why the bill failed. There were significant amendments added to address the concerns of low-income housing advocates, who see a greater need for BMR units among other things. But these were added only after substantial protest. One low-income housing activist said it best: "The YIMBY movement has a white privilege problem."[2] They are kind of in denial about the effect of development-stimulated gentrification on rents in affordable neighborhoods. They like to think that young tech workers are in the same boat as minimum wage earners, all in need of "affordable" housing. They really don't like to think about things like induced demand, where adding capacity can actually create more demand. In the long run even the tech industry needs affordable housing for service industry workers to support its continued growth. It's not just about economic justice or turning back gentrification. Quite simply, if cooks and teachers and artists can't afford to work here it's not going to be as desirable a place to live. If the market alone can't solve that -- and many low-income housing advocates believe it can't -- then we need to fight for BMR and other strategies to create and protect truly affordable housing. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16988398 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16988398 [2] http://www.latimes.com/politics/la-pol-ca-housing-bill-failure-equity-groups-20180502-story.html http://www.latimes.com/politics/la-pol-ca-housing-bill-failu...
- nerfhammer 9y agothey have a problem with low-income housing activists more so than actual low income people. check the 2nd to last graph on this page: http://www.ppic.org/publication/californians-and-housing-affordability/ http://www.ppic.org/publication/californians-and-housing-aff...
- abalone 9y agoSee, that's exactly what I mean. First, it's kind of condescending and dismissive, like low-income housing activists don't actually represent the populations they live with and fight for. Second, you're misinterpreting the graph. It just says renters want more housing. But if you scroll up you'll note the kind of housing "strong majorities favor": "affordable housing projects" -- not market rate. The debate here between YIMBYs and the low-income housing activists is not the same as it is with NIMBYs. Both want more housing. The issue is how much market rate to facilitate vs. how much BMR and other developer concessions to negotiate for.
- pcwalton 9y agoTenants' rights groups in California don't want new housing. That's why they opposed SB 827, and that's why they opposed SB 35 (even though some of them, for example MEDA, went and used it anyway to construct affordable housing, while still maintaining their opposition to save face).
- ewjordan 9y agoPeople want more affordable housing by apartment count; activists will happily block large projects that would include sizable numbers of affordable units because they're not happy with the percentage of affordable units. The percentages that they want tend to be high enough that the projects would be unprofitable, so the end result is that 0 units get built, either at market rate or BMR. Most YIMBYs are perfectly happy to add more affordable units, as long as the economics work out so that something gets built. Many (not all) activists would prefer to block everything than compromise.
- abalone 9y ago
- pcwalton 9y agoInduced demand in housing is a myth. Research confirms that building more housing reduces displacement. UC Berkeley's Urban Displacement Project study covers this quite well: http://www.urbandisplacement.org/research#section-84 http://www.urbandisplacement.org/research#section-84 Key summary: "What we find largely supports the argument that building more housing, both market-rate and subsidized, will reduce displacement. However, we find that subsidized housing will have a much greater impact on reducing displacement than market-rate housing. We agree that market-rate development is important for many reasons, including reducing housing pressures at the regional scale and housing large segments of the population. However, our analysis strongly suggests that subsidized housing production is even more important when it comes to reducing displacement of low-income households."
- abalone 9y agoYou misinterpreted the summary. Reading the actual study, it confirms induced demand: "At the local, neighborhood scale, however, new luxury buildings could change the perception of a neighborhood and send signals to the market that such neighborhoods are desirable and safer for wealthier residents, resulting in new demand. Given the unmet demand for real estate in certain neighborhoods, new construction could simply induce more in-moving." "...What we find largely confirms this regional versus local argument;... This suggests that indeed in San Francisco, and by extension similar strong markets, the unmet need for housing is so severe that production alone cannot solve the displacement problem." (p7) Note that the summary concerns the regional effect of new housing construction -- with a strong emphasis on subsidized housing. Exactly what low-income housing advocates are campaigning for.
- zkms 9y ago> we need to fight for BMR and other strategies to create and protect truly affordable housing. The "BMR or nothing" thing that those low-income housing advocates do pisses me off so much (and I say this as someone whose current income qualifies them for BMR housing (the waitlists are many years long so it's not really an option though)) and it's so frustrating to see how effective the "displacement" concern-trolling is at preventing the right actions from being taken; namely "build enough dense/tall/small market-rate housing such that the market-rate becomes affordable for everyone, and remove bans on medium/high-rise buildings, and small apartments/SROs/rooming-houses". Avoiding eroding/ending NIMBY-enabling zoning/planning/land-use laws because it'll cause disruption/displacement is the same sort of understandable-yet-suicidal decision as someone refusing to push the stick forwards in a stalled plane because they're afraid of causing the thing to pitch down and lose altitude. Doing the non-instinctive/unfamiliar/counterintuitive thing is terrifying and unpleasant; but if you don't wanna hit the ground you gotta point the nose at the ground to get airspeed. I'm legitimately shocked how even amongst people who don't have anything to gain via artificially scarce housing, the mindset is disturbingly often isomorphic to "pulling back on the stick puts me farther from the ground, time to pull back!" and well, I really don't want to follow that trajectory to its sad, pancake-shaped end.
- fiter 9y agoIf "development-stimulated gentrification" and normal gentrification are our problems, then what's the solution? You are setting up a scenario where there is gentrification no matter what. The problem with trying to get BMR units everywhere is that less units are created. Big picture, you're just helping two classes: those who qualify for BMR and those who are rich enough to buy the units that are subsidizing the BMR. What happened to the people in the middle?
- pcwalton 9y agoTenant activist groups want to return the Bay Area to the way it was in some romanticized time in the past, often the 1970s. They want nobody to move in and for tech to move out. It's certainly true that magically freezing California in time would solve displacement and gentrification. (Of course, it's not possible to do so, and it would be deeply unfair for the same reason the Chinese hukou system is unfair, but that doesn't stop them.)
- stale2002 9y agoThe market isn't being ALLOWED to to solve the problem. Allowing the market to solve the problem would happen if we significantly upzoned the land. (ie, we need to double the allowable density across SF). The best way to produce more affordable housing isn't that build so many houses that the market price is BELOW the affordable housing price. But if you really care about affordable housing, one thing that could be done is incentives. IE, if you make 30% of your units affordable then in exchange, you can build you building to be 3 times the height of whatever it is currently zoned for. YIMBY people would absolutely be in favor of an incentive like this, that triples density, in exchange for making 30% affordable.
- OrganicMSG 9y ago>induced demand, where adding capacity can actually create more demand. The timeline on induced demand for number of houses required has to be pretty long. Also, if you are worrying about induced demand from housebuilding, then you are attempting population control with homelessness.
- wbl 9y agoWhich poor neighborhood in SF would SB 827 have lead to new development in?
- emodendroket 9y ago> Quite simply, if cooks and teachers and artists can't afford to work here it's not going to be as desirable a place to live. At the risk of sounding excessively cynical, I think the most exclusive cities are pretty able to foist this burden onto those workers by making them travel long distances.
- abalone 9y agoGlad you brought that up. The bay area's unique geography (and/or inadequate regional mass transit to match it) make this a much greater problem here. There was a really great map that I'm trying to find again, comparing how far you could travel from an affordable market-rate unit on mass transit in an hour in different metros. In NYC you could reach most of Manhattan from affordable neighborhoods in Brooklyn or Harlem. In SFBA, the vast majority of SF was unreachable. Just small areas around the BART stops basically. This is a huge problem for the service industry, for example. It is getting very hard to hire restaurant and retail staff in SF without jacking up prices so high that the business fails. Not a lot of people want to commute 3 hours a day to a minimum wage job.
- ggg9990 9y agoBART is pretty good... you can get from a cheap gang infested area of Richmond to downtown SF in an hour. It’s pretty expensive though, an hours pay for the round trip.
- emodendroket 9y agoI heard a pretty memorable discussion on the radio about people walking all the way from Queens and Brooklyn to their jobs at the Manhattan McDonald's because their pay was too low to afford the subway fare.
- damnyou 9y agoYes, "induced demand" for housing exists. But that extra demand is generated by the extra economic activity more people bring in. It's called having a growing, lively city.
- wahern 9y agoHere are 25 concrete suggestions proffered by not just a YIMBY but a bone fide, for-profit housing developer: https://urbanize.la/post/25-solutions-builder%E2%80%99s-perspective-fix-california-housing-crisis https://urbanize.la/post/25-solutions-builder%E2%80%99s-pers... Which of those specific, concrete suggestions do you find objectionable? Like some other YIMBYs (myself included) he even admits that we may need to expand rent control. NIMBYs can't shake their fingers at housing developers and will them into burning money on unprofitable projects. And even a city government as rich as San Francisco couldn't build a small fraction of the units necessary to relieve the pressure before it would bankrupt the city. This is the cold, hard truth. Renters have exactly two choices: continue opposing (by action or inaction) new development while prices rise and the rent-controlled stock slowly disappears, or be part of the solution. But tacking on BMR requirements is not a solution--it's no different than saying, "you can build new housing, but you still need to jump through all the same hoops and, oh, yeah, you have to give it away". WTF!? On top of all that, while NIMBYs complain about displacement and the depletion of rent-controlled housing, there's literally no organized movement on their part that I'm aware of that proposes mitigations as part of a grand bargain. All I hear is, "no, no, no; but, but but." Rather, it's the YIMBYs proposing comprehensive solutions, including expansion of rent control. The funny thing is, rent control and density go hand-in-hand. The more units in a building the greater the turnover and the less the burden on an individual landlord.
- abalone 9y agoIf by me you mean low-income renters.. then probably #10, where the bona fide for-profit developer explicitly opposes affordable housing fees. You offer no support for your assertion that BMR requirements of any kind are unprofitable.
- wahern 9y agoThe evidence was in the article: And yet SLSs are dying in Los Angeles. Los Angeles has run out of missing middle zoning, and they are not creating any more of it in plan updates. The city has recently looked to tighten rules on the development of SLSs. Recent increases in fees (See rule #10) has hit SLSs hard. Entitlement applications for SLS have dropped. New developments increasingly skew toward luxury sky-rises precisely because smaller, mid-rise, middle-income projects have increasingly grown unprofitable. It's a vicious circle: the more exactions imposed on the developers the bigger and more expensive the units need to be in order for the project to be viable, which fuels resentment and political pressure for more exactions. The problem with BMR requirements is that though they make politicians appear responsive to voters and tough on developers, the greater effect is that they permit politicians, voters, and developers alike to avoid difficult decisions. Such as, for example, expanding rent control, changing master zoning plans rather than relying on negotiated variances (a costly process), investing in transit, reducing parking requirements, etc.
- saosebastiao 9y agoIf induced demand in housing was actually a thing, silicon valley wouldn't be overpriced because everybody would pack up and move to Indianapolis, Dallas, or Houston, where housing is plentiful and nobody is stopping more from being built. The reason prices keep going up when you build more has nothing to do with inducing demand. The demand was already there and already growing, for a million reasons you have no control over. Prices keep going up because you're not building enough. And if you refuse to accommodate or allow growth, you're gonna get displacement. The reason San Francisco has become a displacement nightmare is exactly because of the stupid induced demand myth, that somehow by not accommodating new arrivals that they'll just stop coming. San Francisco's problems are only the fault of people like you who refuse to accept economic reality.
- abalone 9y agoThat’s not how induced demand works even in the classic example of traffic congestion. So you’re not really in a position to lecture on “economic reality”. YIMBYs sometimes argue that we can solve the affordability crisis by simply building more market rate housing, because the law of supply and demand dictates it will bring prices down. But that is a simplistic understanding of supply and demand; even in Econ 101 we learn that the price change depends on the demand curve. So what’s the demand curve for housing in SF? Induced demand is the phenomenon where lowering cost motivates people to change their behavior and start using the good. It shifts the curve. This counterintuitively keeps the cost high despite expanding supply. It’s why roads are always congested even after expanding them. There are a lot of tech people in the world who would still like to move to SF. There are speculators too. Like adding lanes to a highway that never gets better, it’s possible that a purely market rate based approach will not result in prices low enough to address the affordable housing crisis for folks who are not making tech industry salaries. YIMBYs as a rule really do not like to admit that. Adding lanes too a highway can help put more people on the road who can tolerate high (opportunity) costs, but you’ve got to look at other solutions too like protected lanes for qualified vehicles. The analogous things in housing would be things like BMR units for qualified residents.
- saosebastiao 9y ago
- danieltillett 9y agoRather than trying to fight NIMBYism directly since development imposes large costs on the current residents and home owners in an area, fight it by using a reverse dutch auction process [0]. Developers can bid what they are willing to pay a community for development approval of what they want to build and the communities can compete against each other to win the development. The amount the developer is willing to pay rises each month and the first community to say yes gets the development. This way rather than all the surplus going to the developer and all the costs to the community, both sides benefit. Win-win. Edit. Since it has come up a few times in the comments you can cover the location issue via the developer's bid requirement documentation. For example, they could say they need conditions x, y, & z for any site and only communities with sites that meet those conditions can bid. The developer can make the conditions as narrow or broad as they like (all the way from only one site in state meeting the conditions to thousands of sites). It will be in the interest of the developer to keep the conditions broad since the more flexible they can be the more communities will compete for the development and the lower the cost to them. 0. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reverse_auction https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reverse_auction
- schoen 9y agoI doubt that the locations for prospective real estate developments are fungible enough to make the plans and conditions applicable to each interchangeable. Remember that the things that are said to matter the most in real estate are "location, location, and location". https://www.nytimes.com/2009/06/28/magazine/28FOB-onlanguage-t.html https://www.nytimes.com/2009/06/28/magazine/28FOB-onlanguage... Housing developments and their costs of construction and their suitability for a particular site and their aesthetic appeal to an area and the demand curve that they face there and their utility connection options and the other regulations that they will be subject to apart from permit approval are all different in different places, so a developer's level enthusiasm for building a particular project in one city or another, or one neighborhood or another, is very unlikely to be exactly transferable... You might say that the auction mechanism would nonetheless take account of this because the developer would only bid amounts that would lead to profitability literally anywhere, but I don't think such amounts exist. ("Cool, the 50-story apartment building concept has been approved for construction on a vacant lot with no existing utility connections 5 km from the nearest other building and 30 km from the nearest bus stop! Let's go build it!")
- nikanj 9y agoIf only the young people voted. The average age in most states is ~40, so the governments should not be completely ignoring the young.
- IIAOPSW 9y agoIf only there were a politician that reflected the political interests of the under 40 demographic.
- favorited 9y agoThat won't happen until under 40s start voting. Politicians reflect the political interests of their voters.
- IIAOPSW 9y agoThat won't happen until Politicians start considering under 40s. People vote for those whom reflect their political interests.
- landryraccoon 9y agoThe problem with your position is that the politicians still win if under 40 doesn’t vote, but people under 40 lose. People under 40 hurt themselves, not politicians, by not voting. People in office already won office. Why would they be motivated to care to win people who won’t vote anyway? They clearly can get elected without them.
- IIAOPSW 9y ago>Why would they be motivated to care to win people who won’t vote anyway? I'm saying the under 40s would vote if there was someone worth voting for. Doesn't vote != won't vote. Its a volcano waiting to erupt.
- 9y ago
- olliej 9y agoWell the “progressive” people in CA (especially SF) are both xenophobic (only people from SF should be allowed to live there), and short sighted (if you don’t build new housing their children won’t have anywhere to live, even without people moving to the city) For public servants, and other people whose salary is directly or indirectly tied to government salaries housing will only get less affordable as prop 13 guarantees that landlords can profit from true market value of their properties without paying taxes on that value. Prop 13 is literally a tax payer subsidy to businesses and nothing more.
- hahahahaha9 9y agoA sanctuary city is somehow xenophobic?
- chrischen 9y agoJapan solves the problem by forcing permissive zoning at a national level so that localities can’t pull their blocking policies. Localities will always overpower those trying to movie in, forcing people to live further out or move to a different city, but if it’s a national problem a national law is due.
- knuththetruth 9y agoJapan solves this problem by having home values that drop to just about nothing over time, such that everything outside of commercial property investment is unattractive to Global Capital. Zoning is a problem, but without additional stopgaps to prevent this kind of financialized speculation in the housing market, you can’t resolve the affordability crisis.
- chrischen 9y agoPart of home values dropping is also their culture of preferring new constructions over old buildings. But then again I think objectively, all things being equal, everyone prefers a new house, but Americans are more tolerant of old buildings.
- knuththetruth 9y agoNew is culturally preferential, but the government also doesn’t enforce any kind of building standards for typical home construction (including earthquake resistance). You essentially have to buy or build new because there are zero guarantees any used housing is safe.
- A2017U1 9y agoJapan has some of the strictest building standards for earthquake resistance in the world. Seismic design code: https://www.fujipress.jp/jdr/dr/dsstr000100030341/ https://www.fujipress.jp/jdr/dr/dsstr000100030341/
- A2017U1 9y ago
- llsf 9y agoSF needs more multifamily homes (apartment buildings). Now, I can see how SB827 could have scared lots of people, like in SF. If SB827 had passed, I am sure some SF neighborhoods and cities in the Bay, would have either defund existing or stop any new public transit projects, to avoid up zoning. I think the City should just create a plan like Haussmann did in Paris. The City should start by preempting all the lots that are underused (parking lots, gas stations, car wash, single story commercial buildings, etc.) and build to the limit for the area. We could even keep the single story business at ground level (car wash, some parking, etc.). That should bring lots of units to the market. Cities in the Bay should build more too. It is a bit crazy to have Apple or Google, creating those giant campuses for 10's of thousands employees, in cities that do not build anything close to accommodate the families of those employees. Cupertino and Mountain View welcome taxes from Apple or Google, but do not do much to house those employees and their families. Maybe every city should provide at least the same number of units as they have employees.
- nradov 9y agoThere are only about 20 gas stations in San Francisco. You can't have a city without gas stations; they're just as essential as housing.
- electricslpnsld 9y ago> You can't have a city without gas stations Manhattan has ~1 gas station per 42,000 residents, and it seems to be doing just fine. Back of the envelop calculation puts the San Francisco ratio to ~1 gas station per 43,000 residents, so it is about on par with other dense areas of the US.
- schoen 9y agoI just searched a few times on Google Maps in different neighborhoods and I think I found about 50 gas stations, which didn't feel like a complete list to me. Especially along Van Ness and Lombard (signed as US-101), 19th Avenue (signed as CA-1), and exits from the 101 and 280, they are fairly numerous. Google Maps found more than 20 in the southeastern neighborhoods alone! I don't mean to argue from anecdotes, but I've never known anyone who lives in San Francisco and owns a car to complain that gas stations are particularly rare or hard to find or access here. (They may often complain about parking, but not as much about gas stations.)
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- DmenshunlAnlsis 9y agoWhy the rush to increase the population in a water-poor, earthquake prone region? It seems crazy to me, and “money” seems an insufficient answer. California as a whole seems less than sustainable over the next 50 years, so maybe planning should aim in another direction? Instead of inducing people to live there, build competitors in less seismically unstable regions that have access to fresh water that isn’t just about gone. I appreciate that every place is subject to some kind of disaster, but massive, regular earthquakes liquefying soil is second only to massive floods for destructive capacity. It’s also true that if for example you live near a Great Lake, you have water. In terms of risk to people and infrastructure, tornadoes are pretty minor compared to earthquakes and drought.
- saosebastiao 9y agoPeople don't need a lot of water. It's the lawns that need all the water. Why relocate millions of people when all you have to do is get rid of the stupid fucking lawns?
- DmenshunlAnlsis 9y agoThe lawns are part of the problem, so are toilets and baths and showers, and agriculture and industry. The point is that identifying the problem isn’t hard, it stopping it is downright impossible. Who is going to stop people from having lawns? Who will stop powerful agricultural interests from growing almonds? Until the water runs out, people will waste it.
- saosebastiao 9y ago> Who is going to stop people from having lawns? The same mythical creatures that can stop people from moving to Silicon Valley. Or you could just price water appropriately and watch them disappear on their own. Quadrupling your water bill increases the cost of being a human by a percent at most, but increases the cost of owning a lawn several fold.
- 9y ago
- 8bitsrule 9y agoNot many people can build a home these days. So I'm not against developers. BUT: if there's any public money involved, then a -good- law will protect the future of those homes from becoming exploitation centers. And a -great- law will recognize that most people will never be rich, and will still need affordable housing ... and will be designed to bake that -directly- into the system. So we never again wind up with the tragic situation we're faced with today.
- PeterStuer 9y agoWonder how many of the YIMBY's are actually YIYBY's (Yes is YOUR backyard)
- saosebastiao 9y agoOnly NIMBYs are trying to control other people's backyards. YIMBYs can't do anything to your backyard, because you own it and can make any choices about your property for yourself. But you don't own your neighbor's backyard any more than some schmuck who lives hundreds of miles away does. Perhaps you had the impression that your title and deed gave you property rights over your neighbor's yard merely because you live in the same neighborhood. If so, you were mistaken.