8 ms·
"Humans and sharks, for example, make hemoglobin using nearly identical genes. That means hemoglobin genes were already present in their common ancestor." Um.
by chiefalchemist 9y ago
"Humans and sharks, for example, make hemoglobin using nearly identical genes. That means hemoglobin genes were already present in their common ancestor."
Um. If this gene was the result of a mutation, isn't it possible, at least in theory, that mutation happened more than once? At two different times? At two different branches on the species tree?
Not really my area but there seems to be an assumption that species development (dare I say evolution) was linear, with humans being the ultimate achievement in that process. But doesn't the fact that genes mutate - sometimes triggered by viruses - imply the process was not at all linear?
- phito 9y agoConvergent evolution is totally a thing. What if at some point in time, there was a virus running around and copy pasting some dna around?
- mannykannot 9y agoI think it is generally true to say that individual genes don't work in a vacuum, and neither do the biological mechanisms they encode for, so the transferred DNA would have to contain a suite of co-dependent genes. Admittedly, there is a counter-example in the transfer of genes conferring resistance to a particular pathogen. I think it is also true to say that convergent evolution often produces results that differ genetically, even though the resulting phenotypes serve the same purpose.
- fifnir 9y agoCheck out these guys: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transposable_element https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transposable_element
- stevenwoo 9y agoLike this retrotransposon? https://www.theatlantic.com/science/archive/2018/04/the-shellfish-gene/558131/ https://www.theatlantic.com/science/archive/2018/04/the-shel...
- shawabawa3 9y agoI'm not an expert in the field but my understanding is that DNA has a huge amount of "junk" in it. This junk doesn't do anything but can act as a fingerprint for where the DNA evolved from, as it's impossible for the junk to be evolved twice in exactly the same way
- jbrooksuk 9y agoI'm sure the "junk" DNA does something, we just don't know what yet.
- kingkawn 9y agoThe concept of junk DNA was mostly taken apart a few years ago. Those sections often serve regulatory functions and other purposes related to controlling how genes are used and at what rates.
- dekhn 9y agoYou're referring to regulatory regions which really represent a tiny component of the genome (in terms of base fraction)... but nobody has really constructed a strong argument (that can be tested) that long stretches of Alu (which comprise most of the junk DNA) actually have a regulatory or other function. It's speculated those regions are gene foundries, but it's mostly speculation with limited evidence.
- 9y ago
- gort 9y ago> Um. If this gene was the result of a mutation, isn't it possible, at least in theory, that mutation happened more than once? At two different times? At two different branches on the species tree? Genes are long sequences of information. You could easily have quite different genes doing similar things, but if you have the very same gene (sans minor differences) it's just too unlikely to have originated completely independently twice. The closest thing I can imagine to your scenario is where, because of shared ancestry, 2 species have a certain gene, and then some minor mutation hits both of them, and now they both have some other gene. I suppose that's possible. But they already shared the original gene to start with.
- lkrubner 9y agoIf a mutation in a given gene leads to death 99.9999% of the time, but leads to oxygen transport the rest of the time, and the mutation happens many millions of times, then it is reasonable to think it could have been invented twice. Most of the time the mutation leads to death, but every once in a million times it leads to a happy result. Over the course of a few million years, the mutation happens many millions of times. In that scenario you would expect to happen at least twice, and probably much more often. As an example, write a simple program that randomly generates strings of letters from 1 to 20 characters in length. Then include an English dictionary in the program. Compare the randomly generated strings with the words in the dictionary. How often does the random process generate actual words? Not often, but sometimes, and that is all that is needed.
- gort 9y agoSure, but this is only possible if the original (shared) gene was really quite close to being able to transport oxygen.
- rlpb 9y agoWhat if there are a million different possible genes that produce hemoglobin? In that case, if two different species were found to produce hemoglobin but use the same gene, then what would that imply? I think this is what grandparent meant by "You could easily have quite different genes doing similar things".
- zimpenfish 9y ago> there seems to be an assumption that species development (dare I say evolution) was linear, with humans being the ultimate achievement in that process Only amongst people who haven't done any reading or learning about evolution. > the process was not at all linear Indeed. > If this gene was the result of a mutation, isn't it possible, at least in theory, that mutation happened more than once? Yes. But if the gene is nearly identical in sharks as in humans, the chance of that happening from convergent evolution would be small enough that "they have a common ancestor" is a much more likely cause.
- kevin_thibedeau 9y agoThere is always the possibility of horizontal gene transfer mediated by a pathogen.
- glenneroo 9y agoMosquitoes supposedly helped transfer bits of DNA between species, which over millions of years influenced multiple species... or is that because they were the pathogen carriers?
- huntertwo 9y agoEvolution is not linear. All species are at a different leaf of the tree of evolution from some sort of “proto-being” as the root node. Humans are no different than dogs or cacti. Humans may be the common ancestor of two different species that exist 1 million years in the future. It is definitely possible that the two same mutations for hemoglobin happened at different points in time, but as I understand it, there is an assumption of parsimony. In other words, it is much more likely that the creation of genes for hemoglobin for sharks and humans happened at the same time than at different times.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- PurpleBoxDragon 9y ago>Humans are no different than dogs or cacti. I think we will always have a special place in the history books (perhaps not a pleasant one) because we were the first to have some ability to consciously edit not only our DNA but the DNA of other species. Thinking about it, if life begin in millions of different universes, there would seem to be one of two possible outcomes. Life eventually goes extinct (due to something happening on the planet that life can't evolve to survive, if nothing else the death of the planet's star), or life develops a species with enough intelligence to be able to modify their own evolution. An idea similar to the anthropic principal. Though different in that we are a sufficient end case for the anthropic principal, but we haven't reached a sufficient end case in regards to evolution (though we have begun to grasp it).
- lostapathy 9y agoWe'll also have a special place in the history books because we were the first species to write them.
- dekhn 9y agoConvergent evolution is a thing, it occurs, but it's generally considered super-rare due to the parsimonious assumption. It's unlikely that the sequences of the two independently evolved proteins would be so similar; you also wouldn't see a chain of progressively similar hemoglobins as you moved down the gene tree to older ancestral organisms.
- joshuahedlund 9y ago> Convergent evolution is a thing, it occurs, but it's generally considered super-rare. Not anymore - though it depends on what precisely you mean by convergence, of course. I highly recommend the new book Improbable Destinies by Jonathan Losos[0] [0]https://www.amazon.com/Improbable-Destinies-Chance-Future-Evolution/dp/0399184929 https://www.amazon.com/Improbable-Destinies-Chance-Future-Ev...
- dekhn 9y agoBy convergence, I mean in the sense that two independent organisms that did not share a historical character trait (in this case, a specific homologous gene) independently evolved an identical trait (a gene with provably no homology, but identical function) through the process of natural selection, with no information sharing via horizontal gene duplication. This was argued out a while ago with stick insects that lost and then regained the ability to fly (several independent subspecies did this). A lot of people thought it meant the stick insects "completely lost all the genes associated with wing formation" and then "gained an entirely new set of genes that caused wing formation", but folks in the evo devo world believe- and I agree- that the insect never lost anything except a few regulatory domains that managed the expression of pre-existing components that are depended upon by multiple other subsystems (IE, wings are composed of basis proteins that are used for many body parts). My interest is in molecular evolution, not full character traits, because those phenotypes are incredibly complex and IMHO beyond our current level of sophistication in analysis.
- joshuahedlund 9y ago> By convergence, I mean in the sense that two independent organisms that did not share a historical character trait (in this case, a specific homologous gene) independently evolved an identical trait (a gene with provably no homology, but identical function) through the process of natural selection, with no information sharing via horizontal gene duplication. I'm no expert and could be wrong but I think this is what Losos is referring to in his book. For example, "New and Old World porcupines do not share a common evolutionary heritage… The two lineages have independently evolved their quills from different, unquilled rodent species." Dozens of stuff like this. He goes into more detail with tropical island anoles, his field of expertise, and orients the whole discussion around Stephen Jay Gould and Simon Conway Morris's competing views on the overall paradigm of convergence. See this NPR interview for a quick summary[0]. A key quote (which I'm not discerning enough to tell if it challenges your claims or if your claims are actually already in response to these claims): "the flood of molecular DNA data that has come forth in the last two decades or so has in many cases revised our understanding about how species are related to each other. And it has revealed that many species that we thought were similar because they're closely related, that they're not closely related and that their similarity is the result of convergent evolution." https://www.npr.org/2017/09/07/549250035/biologist-jonathan-losos-explores-convergent-evolution-in-improbable-destinies https://www.npr.org/2017/09/07/549250035/biologist-jonathan-...
- searine 9y agoYes, as other have said "convergent evolution" is a concept in biology. However, in the case of hemoglobin this is unlikely because this gene is particularly large, and sensitive to change. As a result it is highly "conserved". That is, mutations in this gene are selected against at a high rate because they tend to be deleterious. To create a gene like hemoglobin, you'd need hundreds of mutations to develop a hemaglobin gene from raw material. It is possible, but unlikely that humans and sharks would have independently accrued the same exact mutations in the same places since their divergence to create the same gene. It is far more likely that since this gene is essential, it has remained mostly unchanged since the divergence of sharks/humans from their common ancestor.
- fahadkhan 9y agoI believe it's called "convergent evolution". But I am not a geneticist, biologist,... https://www.sciencemag.org/news/2013/09/bats-and-dolphins-evolved-echolocation-same-way https://www.sciencemag.org/news/2013/09/bats-and-dolphins-ev...
- xenadu02 9y agoEveryone is right in a way. Evolution is messy and undirected. Some genes appear very early in the tree of life. Others have re-evolved two, three, or hundreds of times. This happens both because there may only be one reasonable way to encode the same function or because the same existing structure can be re-used for the same “new” function (evolution often re-uses existing features because that’s far easier then evolving ex nil)
- fastaguy88 9y agoThere is a lot of confusion in this discussion (and in the original paper) about what "genes" are, and what "novelty" means. Human genes and shark genes (the DNA sequences) are not nearly identical, in fact, the DNA sequences that encode human and D. rerio (zebrafish, closer than a shark) hemoglobin share about 67% identity over about 2/3 of the mRNA coding length, which is which is quite statistically significant (expected 1 in 10^-30 by chance). But hemoglobin "genes" (the DNA) encode hemoglobin protein, and the human and D. rerio protein sequences share more than 50% identity over the entire length of the protein; a level of similarity expected by chance once in 10^45 searches (these low probabilities would be much much lower for an average length protein of 400 amino acid, globins are much shorter -- 145 aa -- so they have excess similarity or statistical significance). In the protein world, sequences with less than 30% identity often have very high statistical significance. As several writers mention, when the amount of similarity is so high that the odds of it occurring by chance are very low, the simplest explanation is that the similar sequences diverged from a common ancestor. Let me reassure you that computational biologists who do these kinds of analysis are very aware that evolution is not linear (hence the many methods for building evolutionary trees), and that similar mutations could (and do) occur in different branches of a tree. The argument being made here is that something new has appeared -- there are many new trees that emerged about 650 million years ago. (In the protein world, 650 million years is a relatively short time, so evolutionary relationships at that distance should be detected.) That said, it is very dangerous to talk about "novel genes" or "novel proteins" without being very clear about the nature of the novelty. Just as protein sequence comparison is more sensitive (has a longer evolutionary look-back time) than DNA sequence comparison, there are methods (not used in this paper) that can look back even farther, and we know that there are ancient evolutionary relationships that are difficult to recognize using sequence comparison, the approach used here. Moreover, many proteins are build from modules (called domains) that can be rearranged, so even though the module might be old, the particular arrangement might be newer. After a quick scan of the paper, it was unclear to me whether the authors are claiming that there are a large number of genuinely novel domains (unlikely), or simply arrangements (more likely), or perhaps simply duplications of existing genes (very likely, but not very novel).
- chiefalchemist 9y ago
- pvaldes 9y ago> That means hemoglobin genes were already present in their common ancestor Or that some DNA capture happened in some part of the road. Now we have transgenic tomatoes with flatfish genes in their DNA. There is not any guarantee that the common ancestor of both species would had developped those genes yet at the time of the code fork.