14 ms·
NPR Retracts Story 'The Man Who Spent $100K To Remove A Lie From Google'
- JulianAdamses1 9y agoIf you have infidelity issues or credit score issues and you need credit repair or better rating like I needed. i strongly recommend Notablespy to everybody right here. Let’s do this right. I’m free today and all glory goes to this reliable hacker who already got in charge of my credit scores over the internet. I hired him last year over my credit report which had been dropping simultaneously and since then we have been working together as one, over and over till the issue on my credit card stopped. He’s understanding, cooperative, smart and legit. He fix my scores for me without traces till now. With this i am well pleased. mail them Notablespy.org@gmail. com And be safe from your deepest thought.
- stevensonbaines 9y agoQ U A D H A C K E D @ G M A I L . C O M. I went on google in search of other means to take care of eviction report and late payments record from my credit report records and most people on different blogs kept talking about a professional . and how fast, affordable and reliable he is…I summoned courage to reach out to him, and told him my issues with my records. His response to my mails made me calm and optimistic about the whole thing. I made a down payment for the job and he cleaned my negative remarks in just a week and was approved by credit union in 3 weeks. that singlehandedly brought so much relief to me and its so amazing. Fix your credit report by contacting his email { Q U A D H A C K E D @ G M A I L . CO M } and by the time he’s done with your job . and when you get pleased with your job, you'll b willing to recommend just the way i am
- danso 9y agoThe discussion of the retracted story: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16752468 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16752468
- rightos 9y agoThink I found the full text of the original article hosted on another site too. Archived mirror here: https://archive.is/QxQtZ https://archive.is/QxQtZ
- ocdtrekkie 9y agoThanks, I saved a copy before someone manages to find and purge this too.
- montrose 9y agoIt's actually quite impressive that NPR will retract a story over what would be standard practice among the bottom half of the media.
- samschooler 9y agoI think NPR, since they are publicly funded, they hold themselves to a higher standard than the rest of the media. You can see it in the last sentence of the “under review quote”: “the highest standards of public service in journalism”
- mitchell_h 9y agoThey also have a really interesting way of dealing with bias. "Tell the truth".
- testfoobar 9y agoBy definition, bias isn’t about truth or fiction, but the selection of subject matter and emphasis. Editorial decisions are, by definition, biased.
- Retric 9y agoThat's just part of it, a very common form of bias is representing options as facts.
- anthony_romeo 9y agoOftentimes I try to look for the fairness of the presentation of issues. Bias is unavoidable, and most articles will include some degree of interpretation of the information. NPR, and even far more strongly opinionated publications like the Economist, at least give a generally accurate representation of both sides of an issue. This type of journalism is exceptionally far removed from the Brietbarts and Huffington Posts of the world.
- 9y ago
- vinhboy 9y agoI am confused why NPR removed the story instead of adding this correction to it. It seems that this revelation only makes the story more interesting, given that it's about a con-man.
- neonate 9y agoPerhaps he is litigious and they don't want the hassle, or their lawyers told them he has a case.
- scott_s 9y agoRemoving the story is the correction. They no longer consider it a valid story; that it is now more interesting is not relevant to the ethics.
- vinhboy 9y agoI had to visit like 3 different sites to understand the whole story. I feel like NPR got caught up in this scam. They should use the opportunity to investigate how this happened instead of burying it.
- jrochkind1 9y agoMaybe they are in the midst of such. It would be a good story.
- bamboo_7 9y agoThis American Life did an entire episode about correcting one of their earlier episodes when they found out that the individual had made up many of the details. Honestly, the retraction episode was better than the original one: https://www.thisamericanlife.org/454/mr-daisey-and-the-apple-factory https://www.thisamericanlife.org/454/mr-daisey-and-the-apple...
- jrochkind1 9y ago
- jbob2000 9y agoIt is no wonder people are turning to their echo chambers for news. Even the most established and respected (arguably) news organization can’t even do basic journalism.
- jiveturkey 9y agoWhat exactly is your criticism? That they published the original story? There's no such thing as perfection. It was caught and corrected. They seem to be operating at much higher than a "basic" level to me.
- dingo_bat 9y agoThe criticism is the removal of the original article. Any correction should be in addition, not removal of already published content.
- danso 9y agoIt's not a correction, it's a retraction. It's an admission that the story should not have been published, and that its assertions do not have NPR's standards of reported evidence.
- dingo_bat 9y agoOk, then they can admit it on the article. What is published must not be purged. Write a big notice on the page: This article has been retracted because it doesn't meet our standards. Removing it so nobody can see it is just plain censorship and goes against the essence of journalism and human decency.
- danso 9y agoWell yes, retraction is the act of withdrawing something, so I guess you could consider it "censorship" or at least self-censorship.
- 9y ago
- dang 9y agoUrl changed from https://www.imediaethics.org/npr-retracts-reporting-mistakes-substantially-undercut-story/ https://www.imediaethics.org/npr-retracts-reporting-mistakes..., which points to this.
- make3 9y agoiMediaEthics.. what an ugly year 2000 name
- jessaustin 9y agoIt points to this, but also includes important context. Perhaps even a better link, from NPR itself, would be the ombudsman's piece: https://www.npr.org/sections/ombudsman/2018/04/12/601650762/npr-issues-rare-retraction https://www.npr.org/sections/ombudsman/2018/04/12/601650762/... The ombudsman (person?) blames various parties, but (rightly, to astute readers of the retracted story) starts with the reporter, Aarti Shahani. She screwed up, and NPR management aren't sugarcoating that.
- badcede 9y agoWhy would they? It's in their interests to blame the reporter. That's the one-bad-apple way.
- jessaustin 9y agoLike you, I would prefer that the "three editors" to whom that link refers actually be named. I suspect that if the story had appeared without byline (kind of difficult with NPR's format, but e.g. Economist does it), the reporter would have remained anonymous even after the retraction. ISTM, however, that other organizations would have just thrown their source under the bus, like e.g. Rolling Stone with their UVa rape story. Perhaps NPR will do that eventually, but they haven't done so yet, to their credit. HN prides itself on its wisdom and judgement, but we got this one completely wrong too. When the original story appeared, nearly everyone here swallowed every detail of this whopper completely, while the few who didn't (hint: me!) saw their comments downvoted to oblivion.
- ocdtrekkie 9y agoSo did they completely remove it, so you have to find an archive site to read the original mostly-accurate story? Wow, both archive.org and archive.is' oldest snapshots are of a notice that the story is hidden pending editorial review. NPR may have purged this from the Internet pretty darn well. Makes me wonder who really called them about it. EDIT: rightos managed to find the original story on the archive.is page from another website: https://archive.is/QxQtZ https://archive.is/QxQtZ Generally a retraction is in the form of a note that the top, not attempting to purge a story from existence over a minor technicality.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- gowld 9y agoGenerally where? I went to check if that was the case for scientific journal, and I was shocked to see how easy it is to see full-text of a retracted article. There are "RETRACTED" tags scattered about, but it's still easy to grab a page of bad text. I'd expect the whole document to have some sort of marking on every horizontal line or as a watermark. https://www.nature.com/articles/ncomms6446 https://www.nature.com/articles/ncomms6446
- ocdtrekkie 9y agoUsually on the average news blog I've seen retractions in the form of "we didn't realize this author was paid by x and it doesn't meet our standards of integrity" notices, followed by "original article below".
- danso 9y agoDo you have any examples? A "retraction" is not just a synonym for "massive correction". It literally means to withdraw something. Some recent notable examples of retractions; in all cases, the story was completely pulled: https://www.nytimes.com/2017/06/26/business/3-cnn-journalists-resign-after-retracted-story-on-trump-ally.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/06/26/business/3-cnn-journalist... http://www.foxnews.com/politics/2017/05/23/statement-on-coverage-seth-rich-murder-investigation.html http://www.foxnews.com/politics/2017/05/23/statement-on-cove... http://www.newsweek.com/alt-right-trump-franken-mueller-twitter-810355 http://www.newsweek.com/alt-right-trump-franken-mueller-twit...
- modeless 9y agoSo what's the real story here then? Was the alleged lie actually true? Or was NPR just unable to verify whether it is true or not? Many people held up this story as a justification for the "right to be forgotten", but if it turns out that even a respected news agency can't figure out whether censorship was justified in this case, I think it rather supports the case against censorship.
- dingo_bat 9y agoGood luck understanding the whole picture when everybody is so fucking keen on censorship! I'm fed up of this. Censorship is never the answer. Publish a correction. Publish a retraction. What the fuck is this!?
- gnarbarian 9y agoIt's simple, many people are fine with censorship as long as they're in charge of what should be censored.
- jamesrcole 9y agoI think it's slightly different. They're fine with censorship of ideas they disagree with.
- cmiles74 9y agoWhy wouldn't you censor ideas that you know are false, harmful or both?
- Tohan 9y agoTODAY LOAN @ 2% INTEREST RATE with victoriafinancier@outlook.com I was searching for online lenders because my bank could not offer me the amount i need to start my business and get better life here in Florida because i just moved here. So, i found VICTORIA FINANCIER FIRM who help so many family and individuals with loan without delay. I contact immediately with victoriafinancier@outlook.com and she helped me with my loan @ 2% Interest Rate without any collateral. I will advice all loan seekers to trust and contact Mrs Victoria Financier today Via Her Email ( Victoriafinancier@outlook.com) to get your loan without stress or delay.
- DubiousPusher 9y agoPulled from at least one affiliate site too. http://tpr.org/post/man-who-spent-100k-remove-lie-google http://tpr.org/post/man-who-spent-100k-remove-lie-google
- ColanR 9y agoAccording to NPR's own standards, it is unethical to remove erroneous stories. > “We are guided by a newsroom policy that says it is inappropriate to remove content from our Website. If a report is inaccurate, we will correct it and state why it has been altered. If relevant new information emerges, we will update or do a follow-up story. > “But our content is a matter of public record and is part of our contract with our audience. To simply remove it from the archive diminishes transparency and trust and, in effect, erases history. This is not a practice engaged in by credible news organizations or in line with ethical journalism.” http://ethics.npr.org/memos-from-memmott/how-to-explain-why-we-wont-take-down-a-story/ http://ethics.npr.org/memos-from-memmott/how-to-explain-why-...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- justin66 9y ago"Mark Memmott, NPR's standards and practices editor, would not comment on the retraction. But he told me he could not recall another retraction since he joined NPR in 2009. (We did turn up a 2002 story that was eventually taken out of distribution, following a previous Ombudsman's column.)" https://www.npr.org/sections/ombudsman/2018/04/12/601650762/npr-issues-rare-retraction https://www.npr.org/sections/ombudsman/2018/04/12/601650762/... Either this is a rare corner case in journalistic ethics that could be handled a few different ways or there's simply some disagreement in the profession (and among NPR staff) about how to deal with it. Regardless, the comments below characterizing NPR's retraction of a shoddy story as "Orwellian" are... entertaining, I guess? If only they'd save us from the tyranny of the state by relaxing their professional standards a bit.
- da_chicken 9y agoExactly. Shoddy journalists would respond by doubling down. Attacking the people who question the original story, producing concurring stories and publishing them on sister sites, and then citing those stories in followup stories on your own site. Pushing the narrative and ignoring the truth at all costs.
- sqdbps 9y agoWow, a full retraction! I'm holding back on the kudos for NPR's editorial accountability until we get some context. The subject of that story was a hedge fund guy who didn't like the search results appearing for his name and the legal expenses that went into trying to change them, the piece was sympathetic to him and it was framed as a story about 'net privacy and the lack of regulation around it, but of course it wasn't about privacy it was about censorship, two concepts that are too often conflated nowadays what with publications falling all over themselves trying to extol EU regulations. The bottom line is that the so called "right to be forgotten" is as nonsensical an expression as it is a policy.
- aidenn0 9y agoPrivacy requires some censorship. For example, a law that makes it illegal to take certain photos lacks teeth without a corresponding law that restricts publishing them.
- sqdbps 9y agoWhat's with all the "teeth" comments lately? who's pushing that agenda? We enjoy great constitutional protection to publish, unless it's copyright violation or you're revealing the allied plan for the normandy invasion no court will rule against you.
- crisnoble 9y agoI read the original retracted story linked elsewhere in the comments: https://web.archive.org/web/20180403204501/https://www.npr.org/sections/alltechconsidered/2018/04/03/598239092/the-man-who-spent-100k-to-remove-a-lie-from-google https://web.archive.org/web/20180403204501/https://www.npr.o... But has anyone found the site that Jeff Ervine tried so hard to get removed from Google? This whole things sounds pretty interesting and part of me thinks that maybe NPR discovered the lie that was removed was partially true. Many are wondering why they would take down the story rather than publishing a note stating it was retracted. Maybe the same litigious Jeff Ervine is suing NPR to remove this story or preventing a correct version of the story from being written?
- cmiles74 9y agoI would really appreciate more information from NPR on why the story was retracted and what, specifically, was wrong with the story. NPR's statement mentions that the site that was allegedly defaming Jefferey Ervine was never contacted and that the author of that site was maybe not really the author and they weren't contacted either. In fact, reading through the retraction, I was left with the suspicion that the _only_ person that NPR talked to was Jeffery Ervine himself. Jeffery Ervine is now the president of Bridgit.com which... Well, even after looking at the site it's not clear to me what they do. It kind of sounds like they work with schools to combat bullying[0] and there's a page on the site covering the same material as the NPR piece.[1] But the NPR piece does end up spending a lot of time on Ervine and the story wraps up with a plug for his new company.[2] Without more information from NPR, my first thought is that Ervine mis-represented his story in an attempt to drum-up publicity for his new company and NPR was sufficiently embarrassed that they have removed the story from their site. Bu that's just me guessing, since this retraction has practically no useful information. [0] http://www.bridgit.com/about/#whybridgit http://www.bridgit.com/about/#whybridgit [1] http://www.bridgit.com/jeffrey-ervine/ http://www.bridgit.com/jeffrey-ervine/ [2] https://archive.is/QxQtZ https://archive.is/QxQtZ
- gcb0 9y ago1. spread lies that being rightly forgotten by google costs over $100k and get branded as an expert 2. start a company that offers a $50 form submission for $50k. a killer deal based on lies from #1
- ataturk 9y agoFake news, huh?
- aviv 9y agoNPR's biggest accomplishment in the last decade is selling people on the idea that NPR is unbiased.
- 3steve 9y agoAm I too late to point out that they have an article about sexual violence in the military[1] disallowed in their robots text[2]. I noticed this last summer and can't find a reason why, using Wayback Machine you can see it was added a while after publishing. [1]: www.npr.org/2013/03/21/174840895/sexual-violence-victims-say-military-justice-system-is-broken [2]: www.npr.org/robots.txt
- mherdeg 9y agoThose are some interesting exclusions, yeah: "" Disallow: /2013/03/21/174840895/ Disallow: /sections/ombudsman/2008/01/frequently_asked_questions_1.html Disallow: /sections/health-shots/2013/03/11/173816690/new-voices-for-the-voiceless-synthetic-speech-gets-an-upgrade "" Removing something from search engine result pages but not from archives seems like a middle ground that media organizations might consider when people say "I regret having talked on the record about this, can you remove it?" or when they say "hey, this is hurting my reputation and it's not a big deal, can you please make it harder to find?". I used to periodically poll The Harvard Crimson's robots.txt which until a 2015 site redesign used to exclude a lot of articles from search engine results. One example of an article excluded from search engine results for several years was http://www.thecrimson.com/article/2006/10/31/news-in-brief-student-charged-with/ http://www.thecrimson.com/article/2006/10/31/news-in-brief-s... , which also carries a lengthy editor's note with more info about the final disposition of the case and which I think I can see why the article subject might not want to affect their reputation. Among the other things that the Crimson's web site excluded from search results included -- drug arrest stories where the final disposition was "not guilty" and the final article was not hidden (but the original arrest and intermediate reporting were); some deeply personal sex columns; maybe an unruly party story; a story about a grad student being rude at a football game. I wasn't always able to find the articles -- one older piece of content, article id 523203 in their old-style format, was probably published in the print edition on 22 April 2008 based on the publication dates of article ids 523202 and 523204. The Crimson seems to have stopped doing this and most media organizations don't do it; while excluding an article from robots.txt usually makes users' search engine results calm down, sometimes it can have the opposite effect by broadcasting exactly what in the archives people do not want to be seen.
- 9y ago
- JoblessWonder 9y agoWhat strikes me is the NPR story is almost the exact same as this one published 3 years earlier... "Executive Wages a Painful Fight to Erase a Slur": http://library.cqpress.com/cqresearcher/document.php?id=cqresrre2015120420#PagenoteID0EGDAC1 http://library.cqpress.com/cqresearcher/document.php?id=cqre...
- mc32 9y agoI don’t see the significance of this. NPR, like many other outlets, but less emphatically, engages in shaping stories, not simply reporting things. Innskerp, for example, will often pursue an angle of his while ignoring implications of ignoring equally valid angles. Of course all journalism does this, but the point is while they are spearing “fair” here, it’s not the case in totality. Interestingly, or admirably, Greene is quite fair, for example, some personnel abide by this more than others.
- davesque 9y agoSerious question: why is this getting so much attention on HN?
- sizzle 9y agoNPR is a popular source of news.
- icelancer 9y agoThis is a story about people deleting stuff off the Internet without sufficient justification, which runs directly into Right to Be Forgotten and Internet ethics and standards in general. It is right up HN's alley.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- davesque 9y agoI guess it does seem like NPR may have been coerced into removing the article if that's what people are thinking. I do agree that would be significant.
- DoctorOetker 9y agoExtra! Extra! "The Right for Men with Funny Hats Not to be Viewed as Men With Funny Hats." advertisement: Buy Funny Amulets now! Funny Amulets stop 99% (by weight) of ridicule about your Funny Hat, never have people make fun of your hat again! Preorder NOW!!1 In other news: Person wearing Funny Hat ridiculed for wearing Funny Amulet. Crowd interviewed: A woman describes: "It all started when we saw a man wearing a Funny Hat" A blind person added: "Upon closer inspection the man was also wearing a Funny Amulet, at least that's what I heard" The first responding policeman reported: "When I arrived, everybody was rolling on the ground from laughter. Some were hyperventilating. I was trying to help them, when suddenly I saw ..." at which point the pink-faced policeman burst out in hysterical laughter. This story will be updated as more details emerge...
- firexcy 9y agoI don’t think there’s a problem with their retraction. Shall the original story remain there, (and maybe also indexed by Google,) won’t that do exactly the same harm to the alleged site owner what the story claimed to had been done to the “victim”? To unpublish the story may lose some informative and educational value for the public, but since NPR's notice is detailed enough to explain what happened, such value should give way to the protection to the wrongly-indicted site owner.
- caseysoftware 9y agoRegardless of their reaction to it.. this line is key: > "Fairness" is one of our guiding principles, and to that end we have pledged to "make every effort to gather responses from those who are the subjects of criticism." In this instance, that did not happen. The story referred to one individual as the "author" of a website that another person said had posted defamatory information about him. It also described the author's motivation as vindictive. But NPR did not contact the alleged author. So NPR did NOT contact the author and then described their motivation. It's good that they retracted this article but how many times have they released similar articles with similar total disregard for the truth?
- Naomi999 9y agoI’ve been looking for a way to get rid of my mugshots until i got introduced to this hacker that eventually helped me out.I was hesitant initially because i had already lost a lot of money to these removal companies who just extort people and never get the job done but this guy blew my mind,he was able to delete the mugshots and also remove some other negative online contents that i needed to get rid of..You can reach him at hacklordwiz@gmail.com for any ethical/unethical related service..Trust me,you won’t be disappointed!