15 ms·
I've done a lot of research on sleep and sleep disorders, and have experimented on myself a few different times. Things I've found that help the most: Number
by jedberg 9y ago
I've done a lot of research on sleep and sleep disorders, and have experimented on myself a few different times. Things I've found that help the most:
Number one, far and away, is arranging my schedule such that I don't have to set an alarm clock. I did this once in college when I was able to get only late classes, and I do it now since I work for myself (although the kids sometimes wake me up). Any time I can go for a week or more without setting any alarm clock, I feel far more refreshed throughout the day.
Number two, no blue light at night. I went a little nuts with this one, not only getting flux, but I work in the dark at night with the brightness on the monitor at the lowest setting with a blue filter, and I also replaced all the night lights in my house with special night lights that run at 1850K (candlelight). I also installed a second light in bathroom with it's own switch and installed an 1850K LED bulb in it so that I could do my nighttime routine in "candlelight". Basically, after the kids are down, there is no source of blue light anywhere in my house.
These two things seem to have made the most difference. I've done other experiments with temperature control, sleeping position, bedroom darkness, etc. They all seem to make some difference as well, but not nearly as much as those first two things.
- bamboozled 9y agoYou could take this one step further and just say NO devices or TV at night or after 7pm, period. I can honestly say it's been game changing for me to do this. I just read paper books now, taken a while to get into the habit but my sleep has improved so dramatically since then. Also, my phone charger lives in the kitchen, so my phone doesn't come to bed with me, also a dramatic improvement. What is strange about all this is that fluorescents, while not pleasant to use, don't seem to keep my up like devices do. In that I can have one on for 30 minutes before bed and sleep well. Maybe it's not the light but the stimulation that affects us?
- jedberg 9y ago> You could take this one step further and just say NO devices or TV at night or after 7pm, period. I've done that before and it didn't make any difference for me. If I read a book on a screen or on paper before bed, it doesn't seem to matter, as long as the light is 1850K.
- satysin 9y agoI found the same. Eliminating the blue light was all I needed to make a big impact.
- bamboozled 9y agoSo it's not a one size fits all thing, that's ok. How do you know when to go to bed when idling on a device? There is just endless streams of crud to browse, code to write or whatever. Do you need to have a "bed time" or you just end up feeling tired? What I've noticed about eliminating (most) device use after 7pm is that I'm actually pretty excited to go to sleep around 9:30-10pm because I just end up feeling tired. When I was browsing, consuming social media etc, I just didn't really know when to stop.
- lloeki 9y ago> How do you know when to go to bed when idling on a device? Mindfulness helped me reining that in: I learned to listen to my bodily feelings instead of half-consciously shunting them because ooooh shiny compulsive refresh. It worked both ways: I realised sometimes I tried too hard going to bed when I wasn't tired enough (if at all) and I just slept a couple hours tops, then couldn't sleep for the remainder of the night, which just sucks when the end of the next day comes. Along with practicing mindfulness, the biggest change for me was killing all blue light sources. This had the most dramatic effect of all things.
- jedberg 9y agoSometimes I just get tired. When I find myself thinking "hey sleeping in this chair right now would be cool" I force myself to get up and sleep in the bed. Sometimes I fail and end up falling asleep in the chair, which is bad. But the thing that really helps me is the feature in f.lux that is a reverse alarm clock. Starting at midnight, it pops up an alert saying "you're waking up in eight hours". It does that every 1/2 hour, counting down. So at least every 1/2 hour a get a reminder to at least think about going to bed.
- 9y ago
- fastball 9y agoWhat about a Kindle?
- Antimachides 9y agoWhat method would you recommend for a sleep schedule reset? I'm currently trying to move my fall asleep time from 4AM to 10PM.
- hailk 9y agoThis might sound obvious and you might have tried a lot of these already, but for me what works in similar situation is that if it crosses 4, I skip sleep that day. And having a strict wake-up time works. Of course as the parent comment suggests, the night light played an important role. I have three different lights near my bed, each less intense. Also having dinner early, cold showers before sleep and no exercises at least two hours before.
- jaggederest 9y agoNot OP but my tip is to take a weekend or some other time without obligations and stay up 1-4 hours later each night until you have rotated around to the correct schedule. The other way is to develop a sleep debt until you can sleep at your desired time, and set an alarm to prevent yourself from oversleeping and falling back in to your normal routine. This will also lose you time out of your normal schedule, and is pretty terrible-feeling to boot, but it doesn't require quite as long. Sleep physicians or sleep therapists are good about setting this kind of stuff up, if you have reasonable and inexpensive access to medical help.
- jedberg 9y agoSo for me, sleep and wake up times don't matter much. But for most people, if you want to optimize for one, don't worry about when you go to bed, worry about when you get up. Your body will naturally get tired at the right time each day based on your activity that day, as long as you avoid blue light and mental stimulation at night. To get your body set to a wake up time, use an alarm clock for a while. As long as you're good about your nighttime light and stimulation habits, you'll find that after a month or two you don't need the alarm anymore. If you're already using an alarm, then clean up your nighttime habits and see if that helps. Note: This is all my opinion on reading a lot about this. I'm not a doctor and this stuff only applies to people with otherwise normal health. If you have a sleep disorder, all bets are off.
- whataretensors 9y agoAlarm clocks are evil. The working conditions for engineers are pretty dumb in a lot of places. Force engineers to come in by 8-9am in order to have a 'scrum'/paycheck validation meeting. Sit around tired most of the day and then rush to have something for tomorrow so you don't get fired(no reward for doing well, only reprimands if poor updates). And while this is happening you are signing away all rights to any recurring income or royalties.
- orcdork 9y agoAnd people say devs are not grounded in reality - how dare those fat car plutocrats force workers to show up at 9. What is this, the mid to late 90s?
- superlopuh 9y agoLive in the future
- magic_beans 9y agoMy manager allows the devs to come in whenever — we roll in from 9 to 11 and stay til the day’s work is done. Everyone comes in absolutely ready to get shit done.
- Kudos 9y agoI run my team's standup at 11 for the same reason. Some folks with stricter routines will still start at 9, others (including myself) start closer to 11.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- dasmoth 9y agoThe downside of this is that the 9am-ers don’t get a solid stretch of focus in the morning. Have you considered an asynchronous status-reporting thing instead?
- clumsysmurf 9y agoOut of curiosity, I'm wondering which lights (1850K) you are using. The closest thing I could find was this SCS Amber LED https://www.amazon.com/dp/B018S18860 https://www.amazon.com/dp/B018S18860 If you are traveling and don't have as much control over the lights, you can get a Zebralight red flood headlamp http://www.zebralight.com/H502r-Red-AA-Flood-Headlamp_p_124.html http://www.zebralight.com/H502r-Red-AA-Flood-Headlamp_p_124.... The XP-E emitter is pretty old-school tech, but they make great products.
- jedberg 9y agoI use these: https://www.cbyge.com https://www.cbyge.com I picked them up at Target on a super sale. Honestly, all the functionality sucks, but since the only thing I do is set it to 1850K and lowest dim level and then leave it, it doesn't matter that everything else sucks about it. I also picked up so no name LED multicolor night lights at Costco, but one of the "colors" is a yellow that's really close to 1850K.
- graeme 9y agoDo you think the phillips hue bulbs which go down to 2000 K would be about as effective, or would that rxtra 150 make the difference? The Hue seem much better reviewed in terms of their controls.
- jpindar 9y agoThe 2000K is as far as you can set them using the color temperature format, but they can be set to other colors with the xy or hs format. I often set mine to an almost orange color in the evening. See the diagram on this page: https://developers.meethue.com/documentation/core-concepts https://developers.meethue.com/documentation/core-concepts
- John_KZ 9y agoYou can get yourself an incandescent bulb. Nothing better than the sweet spectral distribution of blackbody radiation. And if you're American you can buy a 240V bulb. At 120V the color temperature will be much warmer.
- avip 9y agoI don't even have an alarm clock. I let either kids or birds wake me up. Love being a remote tech worker!
- 0x4f3759df 9y agoFlux is great, but may I also recommend the extension 'deluminate' it really saves your eyes
- Heliosmaster 9y agoI am a big fan of very warm light, but i'm struggling to find LED with a low enough setting here in Europe (at an affordable price). Maybe i should just use real candles :-(
- StavrosK 9y agoIf you get a yeelight bulb, you can adjust it down to 3000k, which is a deep orange. Although I guess you can set any rgb color, so you can just make it red if you want.
- m_st 9y agoHave a look at LIFX. They allow you to set the light temperature you want. I've replaced almost all lights with their LIFX mini (color) and couldn't be happier.
- dahauns 9y agohttps://geizhals.eu/?cat=hhleuchtled&xf=3910_2200&sort=p https://geizhals.eu/?cat=hhleuchtled&xf=3910_2200&sort=p <2000K seems to raise the prices, 2000K is quite affordable. Dunno if it's low enough...
- vasco 9y agoI'm curious why you do it for you but not for your kids?
- dpatrick86 9y agoNot meaning to answer for jedberg, however, melatonin production declines naturally with age. The truth of the matter is that sleep hygiene (especially management of light) is probably a lot more important for him than his children. Another important factor is also getting bright light early, which is often neglected and may have relevance for depression and more. Also, not widely known, melatonin is one of the reasons late night eating can be a bad thing: emerging evidence suggests that receptors in pancreatic beta islet cells suppress the production of insulin in response to the release of melatonin. Here's a great podcast with Dr. Satchin Panda, a circadian biologist from the Salk who was involved in some of the early research elucidating the effects of melanopsin, which is the photopigment that actually synchronizes our internal clock to light. He drops some pretty amazing circadian knowledge... https://www.foundmyfitness.com/episodes/satchin-panda https://www.foundmyfitness.com/episodes/satchin-panda
- jedberg 9y agoMostly because of what dpatrick86 said. They don't have any trouble sleeping nor being awake when they need to. Also, they are only 3 and almost 1, so they just sleep when they want. Also, my wife doesn't like the yellow lights, so mostly I can only "shut down" the house after she goes to bed or at least retires to the room for the night. As the kids get older I'll probably start teaching them about good sleep hygiene if they seem to be tired all the time.
- _pmf_ 9y ago> I've done other experiments with temperature control, sleeping position, bedroom darkness, etc. Have you tried ashwagandha? I've found the effects of ashwagandha to dwarf any environmental changes I've tried.
- twelvechairs 9y agoAnother I recommend trying is ensuring any indoor daytime lighting you use is broad spectrum (not just a [edit] cool [/edit] temperature). Also on this subject, John Ott's books on light are a great read. In the 50s he was doing time-lapse films of plants for Disney and as he noticed his plants growing and blooming differently under different light, became basically obsessed, expanded his experiments to humans and cells and pushed an agenda of light quality that few wanted to hear the rest of his life.
- upofadown 9y agoWouldn't you want a cold (bluer) light temperature for the daytime?
- twelvechairs 9y agoThanks, corrected
- tonylemesmer 9y agoCannot find candle 1850K colour temp bulbs anywhere! Found 2000K [0] [0] https://www.any-lamp.co.uk/philips-classic-ledbulb-e27-a60-7-5w-820-gold-dimmable-replaces-48w-19217 https://www.any-lamp.co.uk/philips-classic-ledbulb-e27-a60-7...
- fizgig 9y agoI went the opposite route and started wearing blue blocking glasses 1-hr before I go to sleep. Seemed way easier than trying to address each device and rouge blue LEDs around the house. Along with melatonin and magnesium (also 1 hour before bed), this has helped my sleep quality greatly.
- dingaling 9y agoAll our domestic bulbs are 6500K daylight-frequency ( i.e. blue-shifted ) and I have no problems falling alseep even after checking my phone just before lights-out. I wonder if the blue-light problem is the result of its contrast with warm-white 3000K illumination.
- Declanomous 9y agoBiologically speaking, blue light performs a very specific function in your circadian rhythm. It's possible that your lights and phone are not bright enough for it to be an issue; the sun is insanely bright. I do kind of doubt that the contrast has anything to do with it though. There are a lot of feedback loops in your body though, so it's entirely possible that your body produce the protein that triggers the breakdown of melatonin though. Other theory: you bulbs are blue, but are missing the particular blue that causes meletonin to be broken down by the body. I have 6500k 92 cri bulbs for most of my lighting and it definitely screws up my sleep cycle if I don't remember to switch to my 3000k area lighting. I have a really flexible schedule so I didn't notice how screwed up my schedule was for a while.
- wool_gather 9y agoAlso, leave the booze for special occasions -- no drinking a "nightcap". It makes you feel similar to being tired, but it really lowers the quality of sleep. It seems to interfere with REM particularly, which is really important for actually feeling rested when you wake up.
- jghn 9y agoI’ve been using a sleep tracking app since I got an Apple Watch and the effect of alcohol on my sleep quality has been eye opening. I knew it was problematic but it is far worse than I ever expected
- nomy99 9y agodid you try exercising ? I find when I'm exhausted from exercise I sleep very well.
- 0xcafecafe 9y agoI absolutely hate alarm clocks and have gone years without needing to set one. A trick which my uncle told me in my childhood works wonders for me. He said "think real hard what time you want to wake up in the morning, and say you want to wake up at X, 5 times". The internal body clock has not failed me yet (regardless of whenever I sleep or how tired I am).
- yosito 9y agoI don't even have to say it five times. As long as I go to bed knowing what time I want to get up, I very reliably wake up exactly 10 minutes before that time, as long as I've had at least 6 hours of sleep. The challenge is, if I don't "need" to be up at that time, I'll often roll back over and sleep for several more hours.
- 0xcafecafe 9y agoYes, over the years it has become more of a subconcious thing rather than having to say it. Like you, if I know I have to be up at a time, I get up by myself.
- dingo_bat 9y agoThis exact same mantra was told to me by my father and it is effective af!
- egypturnash 9y agoI do this too! I tell myself several times, “it’s X right now and I want to wake up at Y”. I’m pretty much always at the “awake but not getting out of bed yet” stage when the alarm goes off.
- throw501 9y agowhich 1850k bulbs do you recommend?
- yosito 9y agoThe longest stretch I've gone as an adult without setting an alarm clock was three years. At first it was great, but after awhile I started sleeping 9-10 hours a night. I didn't notice it was a problem until everywhere I went people started telling me I looked tired, and I noticed that I had perpetual dark circles under my eyes. I think I was oversleeping. When I went back to only letting myself sleep 7-8 hours a night, the dark circles went away and I started having more energy. Of course, this is all completely anecdotal, but it seems to me that there are a number of things about modern life aside from artificial light and alarm clocks that disrupt natural sleep and waking up cues. It's important to have both, waking up cues included, for healthy sleep.
- wry_discontent 9y agoI've also had problem with oversleeping. I had a lenient job and so I'd sleep 10 hours a day. I was groggy and exhausted all the time. About 7 to 7.5 hours makes me feel good.
- flanbiscuit 9y agoWhat is the science behind oversleeping affecting people negativity?
- anotheryou 9y agoI think one Idea is that people simply dehydrate. Any anecdotal evidence against this? (you who have problems, would you wake up, have a sip of water and continue to sleep, or sleep 10h straight?)
- CoolHandLuke2 9y agoI wanted to do the no blue lights thing but incandescent light bulbs which one can place on a lampshade and which basically act as candlelight are forbidden in Brazil (for being inefficient). You can still buy the yellow fluorescent ones (or the LED ones) but they are absurdly expensive here for some reason (probably tax-related). Economically they still are more efficient if you keep them for 5years+ but it's just ridiculous that you can't get the incandescent ones which used to cost pennies.
- zebraflask 9y agoAgreed about blue/artificial light v. natural light.
- njarboe 9y agoIn an effort to save electricity (most charitable interpretation of the law) the US has banned incandescent light bulbs for the standard bulb sizes. The lowest temp LED bulbs one finds in most stores is 2700k (soft white) and, since those cost more than higher temp ones, I bet most people are buying the high temp bulbs. Plus, LEDs don't have anything like a blackbody spectrum like a heated filaments or the sun has. Rather they have bi-modal spectrum with a high blue peak and a lower one[1]. Maybe the lack of low wavelength radiation is also a problem. I wish bulb packaging had to display the spectrum, not just some "temperature" of unknown calculation. It seems like blue light in the evening is not good for human health. I wonder if banning incandescent bulbs will be seen as a horrible health problem caused by an ill informed government. Similar to the anti-fat campaigns of the past that ended up having people eat much more sugar and hydrogenated oils. At least butter was not banned in that case. Anyone know where one can buy low temp incandescent (like the regular old ones) bulbs of the standard sizes and watts in the US? Maybe they could be sold as a special "full spectrum" bulb and one could get special permission from a doctor to buy them. [1]https://www.soundandvision.com/content/led-vs-cfl-bulbs-color-temp-light-spectrum-and-more https://www.soundandvision.com/content/led-vs-cfl-bulbs-colo...
- keithpeter 9y agoUK: 'industrial' ruggedised filament lamps are still available in 40w and 60w ratings in UK. Halogen lamps are available as well and look to have a warm spectrum.
- dwringer 9y agoIt appears incandescent bulbs have not been banned, but low-efficiency designs have been. [1] I still see incandescent GE Reveal bulbs at the store all the time. [2] > light bulbs using incandescent lighting technology were not banned by the government. More accurately, save for a few exceptions, any lamp failing to meet the energy standards set by EISA in 2007 could no longer be manufactured. [1] https://insights.regencylighting.com/was-there-actually-an-incandescent-light-bulb-ban https://insights.regencylighting.com/was-there-actually-an-i... [2] https://www.amazon.com/dp/B071VCLT6G/ https://www.amazon.com/dp/B071VCLT6G/
- Waterluvian 9y agoDo you think the outcome of no alarm clock is because you sleep more, or you awake at a more ideal moment in your sleep cycle?
- jedberg 9y agoBecause I wake up at the optimal time. I've tried many sleep trackers, and although they all have their problems, one thing they agree on is that with no alarm I get up at the optimal time in my sleep cycle.
- quadrangle 9y agoWhy "after the kids are down"?? We switch our amber bulbs on about an hour or two before bedtime, so we all (kid included) get used to the dim relaxing light before we turn in. This is part of evening routine for the kid too. Although it's a different sort of solution, a $5 pair of amber safety goggles is actually all anyone needs to completely kill blue light all evening.
- jedberg 9y ago> Why "after the kids are down"? For practical reasons. My wife doesn't like the yellow lights, and she usually goes to bed around the same time as the kids, or at least retires to the room at that time.
- quadrangle 9y agoYou and the kids could wear amber goggles… My wife was the same at first and was insensitive to my complaints when she would turn on a bright light late in the evening, but since we were focusing on the kid building good sleep routines and discussed our routines, we built the habit. The other night, I was in the bathroom, up past bed-time, and had some need for bright-clear light, and she actually needed to come in and she turned off the bright light — clearly not liking the feeling. So, in my case, after she got used to the routine, without saying anything, she now just naturally gets how uncomfortable it is to stimulate us with bright lights at night. I'd say: ask your wife to try a month of not just tolerating but working to appreciate the lighting, for the sake of the kids. Talk about how it feels like doing stories by the campfire, etc. and embrace the feeling it has. If after a month, she wants to go back to the bright lights, you'll accept that. … … unless you have higher-priority tensions in your relationship to work on and can't afford pushing this.
- sizzle 9y agoCheck out this great REM sleep calculator www.sleepyti.me
- jedberg 9y agoBeen using that for many years! Any time I have to be up at a certain time (and use an alarm) I use that to make sure I'm getting to bed at the right time.
- fahayekwasright 9y agoTotally agree. Haven’t used an alarm in five years, the difference is astonishing.