10 ms·
One of the biggest problems with US health care is that it's usually impossible to find out what treatments will cost before having them. This makes "shopping
by BurningFrog 9y ago
One of the biggest problems with US health care is that it's usually impossible to find out what treatments will cost before having them.
This makes "shopping around" and being an informed consumer near impossible.
If this actually happens in a meaningful way, hospitals will have to be competitive on price, and I can easily see a 30% cost reduction across the industry just from that.
...which is why I'd be surprised if that actually happened. Such a big restructuring of such a politically powerful industry doesn't just happen in our system.
- txcwpalpha 9y agoThe article already states that these online prices will be meaningless to most people, as they are the 'list prices' that no insurance company or individual would actually end up paying. So it will still be nearly impossible to find out what a treatment will cost before having it.
- sigmar 9y ago>It may still prove to be confusing to consumers, since standard rates are like list prices and don't reflect what insurers and government programs pay. Does not mean "meaningless." And the purpose of shopping around is comparing between hospitals. List prices should be a good relative predictor for comparing cost.
- txcwpalpha 9y ago> And the purpose of shopping around is comparing between hospitals. List prices should be a good relative predictor for comparing cost. When is the last time you dealt with any healthcare bills? This is almost universally untrue. Hospital A's list price for an MRI might be $1000, but your insurance has a deal with them where you only pay $100 out of pocket. Meanwhile Hospital B's list price for the same MRI is $500, but your insurance doesn't have a deal with them, so your OOP cost is $500. This is very common, and in many cases is impossible to know if it will happen until after you have had the procedure and are billed.
- sigmar 9y agoI mean, yea, you check with your insurer first? How could the hospital possibly have information about how much each insurer would cover considering there are literally hundreds? This seems like a "perfect is the enemy of good" situation
- txcwpalpha 9y ago> I mean, yea, you check with your insurer first? If you're checking with your insurer to find the price, then that makes the hospital's listed prices meaningless, which is the entire point of this comment chain.
- sigmar 9y agoThe insurer doesn't know what each hospital charges. Posting costs online is just to make it more convenient to find the information. In the perfect world, everyone would sit down with the hospital, look at the likely range of costs of a procedure, call the HMO/PPO to check how each outcome would be covered, and then repeat that process at several locations. But that is arduous and people don't have the time or patience.
- txcwpalpha 9y ago>The insurer doesn't know what each hospital charges. Yes they do. Providers are already required to make their list prices publicly available, and insurance companies have it (they are already available to the general public as well, but they're probably going to be hard to find/understand for a layperson). Many insurance companies already have cost lookup tools specifically for this purpose. Posting the hospital's list price online like the article is talking about is purely for the consumption of the patient. It is not of use to the insurer. >In the perfect world In a perfect world, I'd contest that you wouldn't have to worry about healthcare costs at all, but I digress. >everyone would sit down with the hospital, look at the likely range of costs of a procedure, call the HMO/PPO to check how each outcome would be covered Except you already can do this even without looking at the list prices from a hospital. Your insurance can already tell you exactly how much you will be charged by any provider. They do not need these online 'list prices' to do so.
- refurb 9y agoList prices should be a good relative predictor for comparing cost. The problem is it's not a good predictor. I'm sure you've seen articles that say the cost of an MRI can vary between $500 and $5000. Those are the list prices. For a given insurer, the contracted rate is probably pretty similar with the $500 rate being only marginally discounted and the $5000 rate heavily discounted.
- bufferoverflow 9y agoIt's not meaningless. Because you know if the procedure costs X, and your insurance covers 80%, you know you will only pay 0.2X at most. There will be no random charge for thousands of dollars for something trivial. And it will introduce price competition.
- txcwpalpha 9y ago>It's not meaningless. Because you know if the procedure costs X, and your insurance covers 80%, you know you will only pay 0.2X at most. There will be no random charge for thousands of dollars for something trivial. That's not how insurance works, though. You would pay 20% of your insurance's negotiated cost, not the list price. So you could still end up paying more at a hospital that has "lower prices", based on how well your insurance negotiates with them. >And it will introduce price competition. This is not universally a good thing.
- nopinsight 9y agoIn what ways would price competition be worse than no price competition, given that other relevant information like quality of care is available as well?
- txcwpalpha 9y ago> given that other relevant information like quality of care is available as well? Well first off, that's not a given. The article only mentions Medicare using price and electronic medical records as a way of 'rating' providers. I can't find anything similar about Medicare rating providers based on quality of care. Second, look up the situation with Lasik eye clinics. Another user in this thread suggested it as a "great example of a highly functional healthcare market" driven by price competition. In reality, price competition in the Lasik market has caused eye clinics to operate more like car salesmen (complete with sales commissions, aggressive/pushy sales tactics, and deceptive marketing), and not like someone who actually has your best medical interests in mind. I'm not saying that simply introducing price competition to hospitals will lead to something like that, but it's certainly an example of price competition not being a good thing.
- poulsbohemian 9y agoI think this is the issue that should push us all toward a single-payer, government-backed system. The fact that we all (or our employers) pay a ridiculous amount for health insurance each month, PLUS end up paying out of pocket a high amount anyway as our health insurance really only kicks in once there is an extreme situation (emergency, chronic illness). And as a consumer I am stuck in the middle of it, with there being no competition but no recourse either.
- djsumdog 9y agoWhere as other high income/developed countries, citizens don't have to shop around because everyone is insured by the State and pays the same prices. The biggest problem with the US health care system is that it's decades behind every one of our counterparts in Europe, Australia/NZ, Japan, Canada, et. al. People in other developed nation don't have to worry when they're sick. They know they can see a doctor and it either won't cost them anything, or it will always cost the same amount. If they lose their jobs, they don't have to worry about their health as well. People can chose to quit their jobs, or take long unpaid periods to work on their own projects, without having to worry about how they're going to pay for health care. In America, we're required to pay for private insurance, even if you leave the workforce. There is a huge cognitive load when health is in the background of your mind. In America, we have to work. If you don't work, you don't get services; not until you're old enough to get Medicare. In other words, you don't get medical services until you're too old to be a working member of society; until the country bleeds you dry as a resource. That is America.
- txcwpalpha 9y ago> Where as other high income/developed countries, citizens don't have to shop around because everyone is insured by the State and pays the same prices. Exactly. Everyone praising this is doing so because they think it's great that this will allow Americans to "shop around" when it comes to healthcare, but they seem to be missing the fact that even the very concept of "shopping around" for healthcare is absurd. If you're having a heart attack, or just have a broken bone, or even if you just have a stomach ache, the last thing that you are going to want to have to spend time doing is "shopping around" before getting your problems fixed. Being able to shop around isn't something that should be praised, it's something that should be relentlessly mocked and is evidence of a failing healthcare system.
- ams6110 9y agoCompletely disagree. Providers are not all the same. Some doctors are so incompetent they should not be allowed to practice, some are excellent. People should have full information on their providers, including costs, to be able to make informed choices.
- SilasX 9y agoExactly. And it's pretty much standard practice for providers to expect you to just throw yourself at their (or your insurer's) mercy and only learn the price later. They don't even upper-bound the amount you might need to pay by default. I don't know how a patient can be expected to make a decision in that situation -- either legally or economically.
- matwood 9y ago> One of the biggest problems with US health care is that it's usually impossible to find out what treatments will cost before having them. I've had places laugh and hang up when I asked about pricing and paying cash, while others give me exact figures and a discount for cash. Maybe this law will at least start us down the path of pricing transparency.
- WhompingWindows 9y agoYou're presuming that consumers have the ability of easily making a switch to other healthcare centers. This is divorced from the demographics of healthcare in the USA, because the problem is that the sickest and oldest patients incur by far the most costs. Many of these individuals are unable to get to even their own hospital effectively, never mind doing market research and trying out different centers many more miles away. Simply put, there is far less ability for consumers to choose in healthcare, even if this step by Medicare is one small step in the right direction. By far, the most sensible system is to have a single-payer, universal healthcare system. Prices can be set nation-wide for drugs, our gov't can bargain and negotiate with providers, and most importantly: healthcare professionals will mostly not operate on a fee-for-service basis, which is a perverse incentive divorced from the Hippocratic oath.
- alkonaut 9y ago> This makes "shopping around" and being an informed consumer near impossible. Add to that the fact that you are likely ill. I think the biggest argument against healthcare-as-a-market is simply that patients can't be (expected to be) informed consumers.