13 ms·
VLC removed from Amazon Fire TV store by VLC developers
According to VLC devs from their mailing list, VLC 3.0 was never approved for Amazon Fire TV store. Now the 2.1.1 got removed as well, and even got uninstalled from the sticks, where it was installed previously through the store.
- knelskid 9y agoSo instead of catching that mouse running around the house, this guy decides to burn down the house to kill the mouse.....classic
- knelskid 9y agoIt might have had some bugs but it was still working for most of us and doing what was needed...i.e. play the media files from local storage........why on the world you decided to remove it ? Sounds like you had a battle of ego's within yourselves and Amazon and wanted to show that you had more POWERRRRRRRRR!!!
- Reegie 9y agoHi, I’ve stupidly un-installed it from my firestick as I was having a few problems watching my iptv through it..now I can’t install it as it’s obviously not available. Is there any way I can get the old version back?? Thanks
- srge 9y agoThat’s just my opinion but I don’t like the Fire TV. For instance, it’s impossible to stream content from recent Amazon tablets to Fire TV’s unless you hack some sort of DYI solution. Returned mine pretty quickly. By comparison my 5 years old Apple TV works like a charm.
- RIMR 9y agoAmazon knows they have an inferior product. Why do you think they removed all competing products from their website when they launched it?
- kuschku 9y agoWhen Google allows Amazon (or open source developers) to receive Chromecast streams, then that argument may hold some truth. For now, Google v Amazon a fight between two anticompetitive proprietary systems, neither of which should be supported by any consumer.
- scarface74 9y agoGoogle allows Roku to receive Chromecast streams and they support AirPlay for iOS devices.
- kuschku 9y agoYou are saying you can stream with any Chromecast-supporting app to a Roku? I’m not talking about the open cast standard, which Amazon spearheaded (and Roku and many apps support), I’m talking about the actual Chromecast protocol, which according to Google, you are not allowed to reverse or implement receivers for.
- lsaferite 9y agoI can stream from official google apps to my Roku devices. From what I understand it's using DIAL which was developed by Netflix and YouTube. Chromecast devices have changed to using mDNS now, but the clients still seem to support both.
- scarface74 9y agoAfter reading, it's more complicated... https://www.howtogeek.com/214943/how-to-use-your-roku-like-a-chromecast/ https://www.howtogeek.com/214943/how-to-use-your-roku-like-a... - DIAL - Chromecast use to support DIAL and it's still supported by the YouTube app and Netflix. Chrome also supports DIAL from computers. -Miracast - both Android and Windows support it for screen mirroring. So all of this time I thought it was the "Chromecast" protocol it's actually two other protocols that do the same thing(?)
- 9y ago
- azinman2 9y agoLink to the mailing list?
- mappu 9y agohttps://mailman.videolan.org/pipermail/android/2018-April/013657.html https://mailman.videolan.org/pipermail/android/2018-April/01... although it doesn't mention uninstalling from existing devices.
- foepys 9y agoDoes anybody know if other video players are affected as well?
- HipstaJules 9y agoAmazon Fire TV is terrible. I bought one and I'd love to switch to Chromecast. It's so slow and limited. In the current state it's a meaningless product
- amorphid 9y agoRe: Chromecast, I found it to be buffering a lot of video. One thing that helped was buying a wired Ethernet adapter for it, and plugging it directly into my network. That made the Chromecast much more usable for me.
- dahdum 9y agoI threw mine away after struggling with it for a week. I should have known when Amazon booted Chromecast out of their store, they knew they couldn’t compete. Roku stick is a pretty solid option, with the remote it’s handy for travel / hotel rooms.
- otp124 9y agoSounds defective -- I've had the opposite experience. Try sending it back for a replacement, or upgrade to the latest. I've used ~7 different smart devices for my TV, and the FireTV is my favorite (I'm using the FireTV stick with the Alexa remote).
- chrisper 9y agoWhy not switch to Android TV like Nvidia Shield?
- badsectoracula 9y agoWhile it certainly isn't as convenient as downloading it from the store, can't you sideload the APK? Or does Amazon block sideloading?
- manojlds 9y agoThere are easy ways to sideload.
- wavesplash 9y agoSideloading is supported. There's even an app called Downloader (http://www.aftvnews.com/downloader/ http://www.aftvnews.com/downloader/) that lets you sideload from the web.
- jacquesm 9y agoIt's a sign of the times that we now need a different word for what used to be normal: installing software on hardware you own.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- userbinator 9y agoWhat's more disturbing is the fact that a lot of people are completely fine with something like this: and even got uninstalled from the sticks, where it was installed previously through the store. In the physical world, it would be like giving to the companies of everything you bought, permission to enter your house and remove or modify its products at any time. It's perfectly reasonable to stop offering a product or broadcast recall notices, but IMHO going beyond that is overstepping a boundary.
- Hydraulix989 9y agoI think everyone just puts Kodi on their Fire TV anyways immediately after unboxing it.
- lostmsu 9y agoAny good tutorial? why are they not in the store?
- Hydraulix989 9y agoa) Tutorials are everywhere on Google b) Potential piracy / Amazon wanting control / business as usual
- themihai 9y agoSomething tells me that any player that takes a signifiant market share will be removed from FireTV, AppleTV etc..
- jbk 9y agoSo, I am the one who disabled it from the Amazon Store. Not Amazon. So, the issue is not that dramatic. The reason is that they refused to approve the 3.0 version of VLC, which meant that people were downloading a beta version from quite a long time ago, with lots of bugs. So I preferred to disable it instead of having more people load an old version. The actual issue is that this precise version had a small database bug/issue that is very annoying to fix/work-around, and when you update, you lose the first audio playlist (video files, audio files, playlist files work fine). So, I'm not even sure that we can fix that in a correct way. But, for Amazon, they think it is a blocker. Sure, that meant that version is buggy, but that's even more the reason to not have more people download it. Remember, we don't make any money from VLC, even if it is free, you are not the product (no ads, no spying, no telemetry). Anyway, this is one of the reason why I dislike appstores: they make you lose a lot of time jumping through hoops, and the quality is not even there. All of those appstores have lots of crap in there. And, except the Google PlayStore (that has other issues), all the interfaces to upload/edit are very bad and buggy...
- bambax 9y agoThanks for the info, but why won't they approve v3.0??
- jbk 9y agoBecause when people update from 2.1.1 to 3.0.0, they would lose their custom playlists. Indeed, it is a bit annoying, but we considered that it was not worth fixing that, notably for the FireTV UI, where it is very hard to create some playlists, therefore not many people are impacted.
- logicallee 9y agoHi, First of all I appreciate the work all of you put into VLC. This is my media player on desktop. I've tried lots of other players but always ended up going back. In my respectful opinion as an outsider with no Amazon Fire device or association with Amazon, an update should not lose user bookmarks, playlists, documents, etc. Users should feel confident clicking "update" on any software, ever. I am sure you can empathize with your users if you consider what might happen if you updated Chrome or Firefox and lost all of your bookmarks. It is easy to see how users might feel the same way about playlists they put work into. (Some users might even feel the same way about something much more trivial such as what page number they were on in each book in an ebook reader. If the ebook reader changes some internal structure it's easy to see how the new version might not migrate that stuff. I personally would find this okay, since I could find my old place within a few minutes.) To try to empathize: how many hours might some of your users have spent making a custom playlist? There is something big and important here: helping users feel confident always clicking "update" without a second thought. Although the amount of work seems excessive in this case (and would be even more excessive in an ebook reader that has to export all of page numbers you're on, even if this is difficult technically) I think the secondary effect might be worth it. I definitely see your point of view too, just thought I would offer this perspective. Thanks again for all of your work, which I appreciate.
- Freaken 9y agoCouldn’t you submit the app with a different name such as VLC vNext ? This would allow people on v2 to keep using it and bring v3 to the store ? It’s a major release after all, so breaking changes are to be expected.
- kuschku 9y agoThis would probably be the best option – if you remove functionality, make the upgrade optional.
- jbk 9y agoThe functionality is not removed, some playlists are just lost.
- kuschku 9y agoThat’s basically the same for the users, though. I’m currently planning a new release for one of my own apps, and I’ve got a similar problem. And still, I’d rather wait a few weeks with a release myself before I’d ever release a version that deletes a user’s settings, or, much worse, their actual data. If I have time once I’m done with my releases, maybe I’ll be able to take a look at the issue you’re having in VLC, and maybe I can fix it.
- elbubi 9y agoHello! I recently sold my Roku sticks purchased two fire sticks (with voice) just tu use VLC for playing my DLNA files. Sadly yerterday, when plugged them in and tried to install VLC, it doesn't shows anymore on AppStore. Searching I found this news about it being removed due to burocratic issues. Is there any way to install it manually? Kind Regards and thanks in advance!!!
- Reegie 9y agoHi did you have any joy re installing it? I’m having the same problems for watching iptv through it! Thanks