9 ms·
> Our industry's hiring practices are absolutely obnoxious. Agreed. The solution is to not work at a tech company, but instead work in a tech capacity at a re
by reaperducer 9y ago
> Our industry's hiring practices are absolutely obnoxious.
Agreed. The solution is to not work at a tech company, but instead work in a tech capacity at a real company.
- No silly games (before or after hiring).
- Better benefits (I'd rather have proper health coverage and a pension than a room full of toys and vaporware stock options).
- Immensely more job security (Henry Ford didn't have an "exit strategy").
- People respect you more as a professional with a needed skillset, and not a throwaway cog in a machine who can be replaced or offshored on a whim.
- And in many real companies, proper internal HR groups focused on making you a better person and a better employee, and not some farmed-out commission-based headhunter group that makes money on employee churn.
> In an ideal world, you could trust someone's resume.
That's not an ideal world. That's the real world. Meaning not SV, and its wannabes.
- teachrdan 9y agoReal talk? I'd be concerned that, at a non-tech company, I'd be seen as a IT rather than a software engineer. And the conventional wisdom goes that IT is a cost center. Some of the best career advice I've ever gleaned is to work on something that visibly makes money for the company. I get to do that every day at my tech company. I don't know that I could say that if I worked in a technical capacity in another industry.
- Clubber 9y ago>And the conventional wisdom goes that IT is a cost center. Only by beancounters, and if you take it away and go back to paper, they'll quickly change their mind.
- ams6110 9y agoThe best "work environment" tech job I ever had was at an investment bank. Didn't disrupt anything (quite the opposite) but got great experience with databases, unix, C, scripting, working with internal clients, determining requirements, managing projects, etc. 9:00 - 4:30 daily hours, no nights, no weekends. Full benefits, good salary, good yearly bonus, quiet office, great people who were there to get a job done and then go home. Had to wear a shirt and tie but that's not the worst thing in the world.
- SilasX 9y agoInteresting! How would you recommend someone transition from a startup-y job to one of those? Anything they look for in terms of qualifications?
- user5994461 9y agoThey're large companies recruiting pretty much in all area of technologies. If you have experience in something, you should be able to get an introduction through a recruiter or find an existing employee to reference you. The only trouble is that finance is only in the NYC area. You can't be there if you are in the valley.
- jonhendry18 9y ago"The only trouble is that finance is only in the NYC area. You can't be there if you are in the valley." There used to be some in Chicago. Bank of America, Swiss Bank, First Chicago. Swiss Bank is now UBS and I don't know where they do their trading system development. First Chicago got absorbed by JP Morgan Chase. B of A might still do some trading development there, but I have no idea. Back in the 90s Swiss Bank and First Chicago used NeXT for trading apps, and Swiss Bank had Symbolics machines here and there.
- cocoablazing 9y agoApply. I would like nothing more than a flow of applications from smart software engineers with BSs over scientists exiting of postdocing and MCFs. The skill I look for over all others is an understanding of the standard principles of software design, and principles of testing is a bonus. I want to see that the candidate is honestly interested in our language to the extent that they are familiar with the obvious pitfalls of the standard language features. Candidates who prepared by writing option pricers and passing leetcode challenges won't necessarily understand any of these, because they are simply writing functions. I assume that anyone who got through a rigorous engineering undergrad has the mathematical preparation to perform as a quantitative developer. This won't be true for all roles, but it's true for all of the QD roles that I have contact with at BB. If you are interested in a dev role in finance, and see requirements for basic financial knowledge, risk, etc. -- as long as the requirement isn't quite specific, such as experience pricing specific option types, pricing complex products, or with a specific product, I would just ignore it and apply. Many of these concepts are quite simple compared to what SEs are trained to model and implement, and the people on the team who need help know that. I've seen GPU and C++ skills requested for a Pandas shop. Just apply. I think hiring managers and HR think they will attract better candidates by adding these things, but it is counterproductive. From what I can tell from salary surveys, we pay an entry-level dev better than many others. >150 guaranteed all-in first year, and better than that afterwards if you just do your job. Promotion path is good because modern skills are in dire need.
- reaperducer 9y ago> I'd be concerned that, at a non-tech company, I'd be seen as a IT rather than a software engineer. Depends on the company. Where I am, IT is in charge of maintaining the computers and networks so that the software developers can develop software in and for other departments.
- aje403 9y agoNo, that's nearly every company. But if there's 10 software engineers working with 50 MBA's who drive the business, none of them can tell the difference and treat you as such, which happens more often than not outside of a tech company. They are the ones making the company money, and you are the programmer doing that "easy programming stuff for IT nerds". It's not that rare of a situation
- neurobashing 9y agoReal talk? There is nothing wrong with being in IT. Imagine if someone said "I would be concerned I'd be seen as a carpenter and not a woodworking artisan". You're a carpenter. You nail boards together to serve the business interests of the company. Even if the boards are SQL queries or ReactJS or whatever. Companies need tech. You can bring value by making everyone's jobs better with your technology - sand off those rough edges on everyone's workflows. Demonstrate your value.
- retbull 9y agoIT fixes peoples computers. Software Developers don't do that. We aren't Network Admins, we don't know how to set up or fix AD and we don't manage hardware. IT is a different field. I write software to process data and mostly I don't interact with hardware or troubleshooting arbitrary software directly. If I am offering support I am a level above IT. I understand that IT needs to be done but it is a very different job and should be treated that way.
- Clubber 9y agoThat definition morphs by time and company. At the last place I worked the IT department was the devs, dbas, net admins, and help desk.
- ams6110 9y agoThis is the case at every non-tech company I've worked at. It's (mostly) the tech companies that segregate IT as a lower-status function.
- Viliam1234 9y agoIt can happen either way. I worked in a tech startup, where everyone did everything, and where doing everything was considered high-status: it meant you were competent at everything. Or perhaps the other way round: trying to avoid any computer-related task, for whatever reason, was perceived as an admission of incompetence, therefore low-status. (I didn't agree with that philosophy. I am humble enough to admit that I am not an expert at something, e.g. setting up printers; and lazy enough that I want to avoid such work if I can.) I also worked in a non-tech company with sufficiently large internal software development department, where as a programmer I focused on developing software; and if any part of the technical infrastructure stopped working, I just called the internal tech support.
- spelunker 9y agoI've worked at a non-tech company as a software developer. At that place the department (we were rolled in with IT) was viewed as just another cost center. It's not great.
- snowwrestler 9y agoMany companies these days make a distinction between IT, digital, and product. IT runs the network, phones, issues and fixes laptops, maybe provides servers, often is in charge of information security. May own the financial and business intelligence technologies. Unless it's a very enlightened org, this is often the "cost center" team. Digital talks to the world in a modern way--runs the websites, blogs, social media channels, paid digital ads, etc. Often housed within a larger communications and/or marketing division. Technically a cost center but the visibility makes up for it in the eyes of executives. Product builds the technology that makes money. This would be like the e-commerce platform, ad network, mobile apps, etc. Executives value things that make money. Often, all three groups need developers. The tools and roles may differ, but you can be a developer in a major company without feeling "stuck in IT."
- rdiddly 9y agoThe solution to the first point is to go to a place that already has an IT department. The second (making a bottom-line impact) is probably a non-issue. If it's not a tech company, that means they are likely failing to use tech fully, in places that really could benefit from it. Automate stuff that needs it, and quantify the time saved as: (time it took before - time it takes now) * number of times each person has to do it per week * number of people * what those people get paid / what you get paid = time T you saved in a week, in terms of your own hours. Each time you do something, add its T value to a running total. Likely an hour here, an hour there. Eventually it hits 40 and you and the managers can clearly see that your employment is paying for itself. Keep going and you're making them money.
- sudhirj 9y agoThis isn’t true any more with software eating the world. I work in movie distribution for instance, which was traditionally sending reels of film, but is now all RSA, certificates, HSMs, remote device management, logistics, Analytics, ticketing, databases and distributed computing. The software team gets pretty much the same treatment as everyone else, but everyone knows it’s the future of the company and sets a pretty high bar.
- sudhirj 9y agoSpeaking of which, our interview process is to ask you to solve a challenge on Github, but you’re free to keep it open source as an indicator of your skills. And it’s not work for us, these are obviously toy / proof of concept problems that we solved ages ago.
- jcims 9y agoMost larger companies have clearly defined boundaries between IT and software development. And with the push towards automation and security at every layer of the stack, even IT has a growing role for software architecture and development skills.
- ubermonkey 9y agoYeah, NEVER be overhead if you can avoid it.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- collyw 9y agoThe problem is that no one gives a shit about code quality at such companies.
- recharged95 9y agoIf code IS supposed to be treated like a language, ya'll are being equivalent to English snobs. Yes, bad english can be detrimental: starts wars, malpractice, etc... We just take it for granted. If code is treated like math, then we can talk about absolutes and good code. But 90% of us talk about it in the language context, hence why we call it a programming language....
- hueving 9y agoYou're not just comparing a tech company to a non-tech company. You're comparing a startup to a non-tech company. When you compare a non-tech company to a big tech company like Google, the benefits and comp arguments switch to the favor of the big tech company along with the respect and job security. The only advantage to non-tech companies when comparing across big ones is the simpler interview.
- lajhsdfkl 9y ago>Agreed. The solution is to not work at a tech company, but instead work in a tech capacity at a real company. Ha ok, this is a sure fire way to experience the worst of what the industry has to offer. >Better benefits (I'd rather have proper health coverage and a pension than a room full of toys and vaporware stock options). Tech companies have the best benefits period, what "tech" company did you apply for that didn't have health coverage? Your entire post seems completely detached from reality.
- fao_ 9y agoHave you considered that you might both be talking about different sectors of tech, and different countries? The EU / UK / US / etc. tech markets vary wildly in these things.
- lajhsdfkl 9y agoOf course he could be talking about Europe but there are very few European "tech" companies. Tech is a horrible descriptor of course, he could be talking about 1000 different things. OP seems to be referring specifically to tech startups with dubious financial situations but then goes on to say that all tech companies are bad to work for
- fao_ 9y ago> there are very few European "tech" companies. I very heavily disagree.
- flerchin 9y agoPivotal and Amazon would not meet the rate and benefits that my current real company was paying, let alone the one that just poached me for a 15% raise. She's spot on.
- lajhsdfkl 9y agoWhat company do you work for so I can point out 20 different tech companies with significantly better benefits?
- adventured 9y ago> Henry Ford didn't have an "exit strategy" The several hundred other auto makers in Detroit did, they went bankrupt or sold out for peanuts right before going bankrupt. Google, Microsoft, Amazon, Netflix, Apple, Facebook, Cisco, Oracle, Intuit, Adobe, PayPal, nVidia, Intel, etc. don't have exit strategies either. For the vast majority of businesses, you're either going bankrupt, or you're going to eventually sell as an exit. One in a million businesses turn into the next Ford scenario.
- foobiekr 9y agoI would be very interested in learning what this entails, actually.
- erispoe 9y ago> Immensely more job security (Henry Ford didn't have an "exit strategy"). Ford is a public company. That's an exit. An exit is whatever makes your stock liquid, not the end of the company.
- freehunter 9y agoFord didn't go public until ~10 years after Henry Ford died.
- JPKab 9y agoI've done both. It depends on the company. MOST non tech companies imho treat all tech workers like IT, with the exception of embedded data/analytics people IF the company is even forward thinking enough to have that. You compared the best examples of corporate with the worst examples of tech.