30 ms·
‘I Fundamentally Believe That My Time at Reddit Made the World a Worse Place’
- jpzisme 9y ago/r/mma is an absolute gem. /r/BlackPeopleTwitter is great as well. I'm also getting tired of these apology tours from SV people. The biggest flaw they have (aside from collecting scary amounts of data) is seemingly taking a too-rosy view of people. It'd be more refreshing for somebody to stand up and quote a somewhat notorious fighter by saying, "I'd like to take this chance to apologize... to absolutely nobody."
- megaman22 9y agoI'm sure that's what most people could say about their time at, or on, Reddit.
- tudelo 9y agoI can't say that I agree with that. There are plenty of subreddits that are not the official ones that have great communities and do great things for its members... (/r/learnprogramming or /r/askamechanic and such)
- antoineMoPa 9y agoThere are marginal nice subreddits, but the platform as a whole has a problem.
- irrational 9y agoReddit is just a reflection of the world. There is both good and bad there. It is very easy to avoid the bad. Only visit the subreddits that you know are good. For instance, I'm a boardgamer and r/boardgames is a very friendly place. Other subreddits I frequent like r/woodworking, r/bodyweightfitness, r/campingandhiking are likewise places that positively contribute to the world.
- ben_jones 9y agoReddit is a reflection of the internet world. Don't forget how many people don't use the internet at all, or people who interact with the internet in only a minor way during their day to day (a debit card transaction, a text message, a social media notification...)
- wanderr 9y agoReddit is a skewed reflection of the internet world. It does not appeal to all groups equally.
- jrochkind1 9y agouh... how many?
- borkt 9y agoYeah I read a number of hobby subs including r/woodworking and it is pretty amazing how helpful and positive these subs can be. I do not ever go except for specific subs. r/vacuumcleaners helped me find a vacuum etc. Without reddit I would find a lot of bad info on google thats often just paid advertising.
- adamsea 9y agoThe medium is the message.
- fancyfacebook 9y agoNo, it's a reflection of a white male internet world.
- austincheney 9y agoReddit wouldn't be so toxic if the vote counts were hidden, but echo chamber validation is the ultimate badge of honor there. There is so much in this document that applies to all things Reddit (please note that I wrote it inspired by my time on Reddit): https://github.com/prettydiff/wisdom/blob/master/Avoiding_Trolls.md https://github.com/prettydiff/wisdom/blob/master/Avoiding_Tr...
- Reedx 9y agoThere are some subreddits where they are hidden for a period of time (not sure how long, but it's quite a while). I wonder if anyone has analyzed those?
- minimaxir 9y agoA formal statistical experiment was done in /r/politics about the impact of hiding vote counts temporarily but it did not find statistical evidence that it made an impact on discourse: https://htmlpreview.github.io/?https://github.com/mitmedialab/CivilServant-Analysis/blob/master/reports/stylesheet_experiment_results.11.2017.html https://htmlpreview.github.io/?https://github.com/mitmediala...
- thaumaturgy 9y agoLow-effort comment, but: I really appreciate your content, both here and on Reddit. It's refreshing to see anyone doing any of this sort of analysis, and it takes a lot of effort to do it, and you do it really well and at a rate that's mind-boggling.
- minimaxir 9y agoThanks! I do have other cool things planned with the Reddit data pipeline too, so stay tuned! ;) (for clarification, the linked statistical analysis isn't mine)
- cookiecaper 9y ago/r/politics is aggressively left-wing, so much so that I'd doubt anyone interested in real discourse is trying anymore. I'd think an experiment like that would need to be done on a clean subreddit that isn't bringing in any baggage, or a pre-existing ideology-based ban list, to test its validity.
- darepublic 9y agoWhat I can never reconcile with is that when mainstream media means 'toxic' they are never referring to the /r/latestagecapitalism plastered all over the front page of reddit. They protest the fact that somewhere, hidden from popular view a minority of people hold a different view from the extreme leftist one.
- Synroc 9y agoWhat’s wrong with r/latestagecapitalism?
- conanbatt 9y agolatestagecapitalism is pretty noticeable. It is an echo-chamber by design, and it is fairly popular. Its absolute cringe, and it is humbling to me that I dont get why anyone joins such a place.
- rightos 9y agoAdmins do nothing to prevent extreme moderation as occurs on there from deleting any comment with an alternative viewpoint. Yet it appears quite consistently on the front page with only agreement in its comments section.
- 49531 9y agoI'd say extreme moderation is probably the opposite of toxic.
- rightos 9y agoYou're right, censored discussion is probably a better way to put it. They delete anything questioning their viewpoint, not just spam, hate speech, harassment etc.
- bduerst 9y agoDon't they sticky that disclaimer in big letters on every post? Why do people expect otherwise? Example: https://www.reddit.com/r/LateStageCapitalism/comments/8crq8r/greek_communists_try_to_topple_a_statue_of_truman/dxh8p0p/ https://www.reddit.com/r/LateStageCapitalism/comments/8crq8r...
- unixhero 9y agoInteresting observations. However I disagree that Reddit can be understood as one entity.
- TAForObvReasons 9y ago> The incentive structure is simply growth at all costs. There was never, in any board meeting that I have ever attended, a conversation about the users, about things that were going on that were bad, about potential dangers, about decisions that might affect potential dangers. There was never a conversation about that stuff. This externality-disregarding culture was idolized in SV for the last decade or so. It's nice to see some self-reflection, but unfortunately the VC community, without heavy regulation, is structurally unable to value anything other than growth.
- adamsea 9y agoIts as if the members of the VC community were a bunch of capitalists or something ;-)
- noobiemcfoob 9y agoRegulation doesn't solve all the problems. In and of itself, regulation can create just as perverted incentives as the existing VC culture. With the perceived impact that Facebook had on the election, I'm starting to believe our culture is evolving into one that won't allow such disregard with or without laws enforcing it.
- closeparen 9y agoYou would really prefer to see Ajit Pai’s FCC in charge standards for internet discourse?
- empath75 9y agoFundamentally, the problem with the site is that Reddit was happy getting growth on the back of people searching for jailbait[1] and creepshot porn and white supremacists for years and they have a user base that reflects that. A lot of the power mods that run the largest subreddits are just awful human beings. I don't see how they fix that short of nuking the whole site from orbit and starting over. [1] http://web.archive.org/web/20110429125747/http://www.alexa.com/siteinfo/reddit.com http://web.archive.org/web/20110429125747/http://www.alexa.c... (check the top search terms)
- 2RTZZSro 9y agoThese people exist and no amount of censorship will eliminate that. Protective bubbles exist in the form of moderated subreddit and other forums outside of Reddit.
- abnry 9y agoI think there is a very important distinction that needs to be made. The popular reddit experience is vastly worse than the customized reddit. It took me a while to realize that my reddit experience was vastly improved once I was very picky about which subreddits I follow.
- gcbw2 9y agoreddit cannot be customized. You can subscribe to X subforums. and only ever see those same X subforums. But you can NOT see "All" excluding only things racist subforums for example. So it is either your little bubble, or the full blown promoted/paid xenophobic posts.
- palebluedot 9y ago> But you can NOT see "All" excluding only things racist subforums for example. So it is either your little bubble, or the full blown promoted/paid xenophobic posts. For /r/all, there is the ability (on the right sidebar) to filter subreddits. You can add whatever subreddits you wish to exclude when browsing "All".
- wyldfire 9y agoI think this is an important distinction. I could never quite understand what all the hub-bub was until I realized that. I've used my account to comment since before they added subreddits. And I never stumble across one of the "toxic" ones except for the rare occasions when one of the other subreddits links to those ones.
- ggregoire 9y agoWait, how did it work before adding the subs? A single board like HN, but without any specific topics? It seems crazy. I can't imagine Reddit without subs.
- 0xffff2 9y agoYes. That was a long time ago. The total volume of reddit at that time was probably smaller than even a moderately larger subreddit today.
- lechiffre10 9y agoI've significantly reduced my time on Reddit. Used to pull up the website out of curiosity every day but the atmosphere is incredibly toxic. My front page was riddled with Russiagate stuff too for some reason and every time you'd bring up an argument that isn't the norm you get a mob after you.
- kevindong 9y agoI personally go to Reddit to relax and not fret about the state of the world. So, I unsubscribed to all of the serious or semi-serious subreddits (all news, politics, etc.). Turns out if you unsubscribe from all of those types of subs, Reddit becomes a really funny and interesting time killer where the community actively tries to come up with ways to make you laugh.
- colordrops 9y agoIt's hard to bring up without being attacked, even off of Reddit, but for long-time heavy users it's been obvious for a while that Reddit has purposefully undergone several changes to control the narrative at the behest of advertisers and the powers that be.
- revscat 9y agoI feel similarly. No matter how politely arguments are framed, or how carefully and respectfully made, downvotes and ridicule follow my every post. It's obvious that Reddit (and the media at large, honestly) is intentionally and structurally designed to promote a narrative that is blatantly pro-vaccination. It's maddening. The bias is everywhere you look. Try and say "vaccines cause autism" almost anywhere on Reddit! Downvotes, ridicule, and anger will be your only responses. It's all part of the pro-vax narrative that everyone has bought into. /s
- opportune 9y agoI think it's more that Reddit grew so much that the original community gets drowned out by everyone else. You can't have a community that big without it becoming filled with, for lack of a better word, normies.
- minimaxir 9y agoAs many on Hacker News know, I've been an avid fan of Reddit and believe that their data and community, and there's still a lot more that can be done that can be derived from that data that can't be found anywhere else. That said, from an administrative perspective, the intense hands-free policies are baffling. You'd expect a company based off the nature of community would engage with their community and their needs. Admittingly, that's not very profitable.
- rockostrich 9y agoBut they did get engaged! They banned all subreddits related to the trading/purchasing of firearms and alcohol. /r/beertrade, a subreddit for trading beer, had a strict policy that users were not allowed to sell beer for money (something that's actually illegal) and only allowed people to post about trading beer. Even someone like me, who doesn't ship beer and only trades in-person, is no longer allowed to talk about trading.
- wvenable 9y agoIt's unfortunate that beer drinkers aren't likely to DDOS the site or brigade other subreddits -- you might have been left alone then.
- Spooky23 9y agoThey did after realizing they would be facing lots of regulatory problems. Organizationally, it should be very obvious to anyone who thinks that things like facilitating anonymous gun and alcohol sales, etc is probably not a good idea.
- rockostrich 9y agoExcept they banned trading as well as sales. Trading beer is legal.
- burger_moon 9y agoThey actually went back and corrected some of those subs which were link aggregators essentially. r/gundeals was reinstated and they have a stickied post describing what needed to be done to be brought back to life. The main takeaway is that there is no p2p transactions allowed, only links from stores/manufacturers.
- douglaswlance 9y agoReddit is the only popular website where rational discourse can actually happen, thanks to the infinitely threaded conversations and complete markdown. While there is objective rude comments on there, this is why some people call it, "toxic," because their ideas are challenged, and they'd rather preserve their ideological bubble than seek to understand reality.
- ApolloFortyNine 9y ago>Reddit is the only popular website where rational discourse can actually happen, thanks to the infinitely threaded conversations and complete markdown. Except comments people don't like can be downvoted to oblivion, causing no one to see them (unless they purposely sort by controversial).
- commandlinefan 9y agoDownvoted is ok (and usually, when it happens, completely warranted). My problem is when they're deleted entirely by unaccountable moderators with their own agendas.
- wvenable 9y agoIt's toxic because a relatively small number of mentally ill people can effectively overrun any conversation. These people are not interested in rational discourse. You can't spin that as "the challenging of ideas". Reddit has been fully gamed at this point and engaging in the most popular areas is just frustrating.
- opportune 9y agoAlso because those same mentally ill people are the exact same people with the time and desire to become internet moderators (no offense to dang or anyone else here, the moderation here is good!). Reddit needs to take control of subreddits back from moderators; too many subreddits are curated echo chambers, moderators are always trying to make money through bullshit like referral links, there's no transparency, etc. Keep in mind that reddit skews younger than here, and probably considerably less educated as well. It's just too big to have the kinds of discussion you can have here
- Reedx 9y agoThis is going to be an increasingly common realization, especially in Silicon Valley. Which got way too caught up in the idea that everything was making The World a Better Place. But Zynga and Facebook are like fast food companies. This realization started really kicking in with Free to Play mobile games a few years ago (also mostly here in the Bay Area). I worked in F2P early on, left and moved to a non-F2P company. One of the most common things we heard from interviewees is that they were looking to get out of the F2P side of the games industry.
- md224 9y agoI still can't get over the fact that their official mobile app stops rendering comments past a certain level of nesting. There's no indication that anything is missing, no "continue this thread" link, nothing... the comments just aren't there. I don't understand how one of the world's largest social media platforms could have a mobile app that silently hides content from the user. Just blows my mind.
- lazycouchpotato 9y agoTheir mobile website is equally bad. A gigantic pop-up takes up half of the screen to tell you to use their app. Third party apps make Reddit so much more usable.
- tootie 9y agoI always use https://i.reddit.com https://i.reddit.com. It's their years-old mobile site and it's super fast and reliable.
- WhompingWindows 9y agoWow, thanks for that link. I was having the same problem as the parent comment, I definitely don't want their app but I also don't want a giant pop-up in my face every time I load the mobile site.
- tscs37 9y agoHow long is that gonna stay available for mobile users?
- mozumder 9y agoThey're suffering the same problem as Facebook & YouTube. They're leaderless, being driven by and reacting to the mob of users, instead of the producing a planned product that understands people. The problem with social media is that they don't have people telling the public that their ideas are crap, so everyone thinks they're awesome. Editors get to make sure people understand that, no, they are not awesome. Social media, like any advertising-driven media, needs editors to tune their site. They're trying to have it all - the profit of big advertising with the automation of tech, but advertisers only want something specific, and automation isn't going to get what advertisers want. No major advertiser wants their beautiful fashion brand ad nexts to a post of child mutilation on Reddit. And editors get to tell people that their content is garbage or great. And editing means people are going to be unhappy. You are officially taking a certain viewpoint, and are literally filtering out incompatible expression. The people that get edited out, they'll get mad, but they'll have to deal with it, like the millions of other people that get edited out by various editors around the world and deal with it appropriately. To fix it, Reddit & other social media needs Editors-in-Chief. Just tell the users: "This is the boss. Keep that person happy. Want to be pissy about it? Go somewhere else." YouTube is now trying that with their kids channels. In the long-run, things work out better with editors.
- gaius 9y agoAnd sure enough they didn’t do anything, and sure enough deaths were caused because of the shit going on in their channels. Which incident is this referring to?
- smittywerben 9y agoLikely this, but perhaps something else... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sunil_Tripathi#Misidentification https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sunil_Tripathi#Misidentificati...
- NotAMoose 9y agoNo, Discord wasn't around at the time of the Boston Bombing. I believe (though don't know) that he's referring to some of the white nationalist stuff, like Charlottesville perhaps.
- joeyaiello 9y agoOnly just getting started reading this, but I had to jump into comments to give a shout-out on how amazing 924 Gilman was for me as a kid growing up in the East Bay. I wasn't there for the glory days of the 80s/90s, and I have no idea to what extent Dan played a role in its founding, but as a space for playing and watching music, I've never found a venue in my life that comes even close to what they were able to achieve. We actually had a great scene in the East Bay, with a decent number of spots for young, local punk/hardcore/metal bands to play. But as a teenager, it was frustrating when an overzealous security guard would go off on a 15 year old kid for moshing, or when a skating rink would flip the lights on and kill the power an hour and a half before the bands had agreed earlier. 924 Gilman had none of that. I remember the first time I saw this sign[1] and then realizing that there were no security guards to enforce those rules. And yet, the punk ethos was strong enough that folks were just generally good to each other. Or the graffiti all over the walls with a graffiti code of conduct posted every so often: don't tag over color with black and white, don't put doodles over real art, that sort of thing. Sure, it wasn't 100% followed, but people really respected it for the most part. Or the 25 cent bottles of water and cans of soda. No profit, just kids handing out there zines and making sure no one goes thirsty. Anyway, I'm going to go finish the article now, but if this guy got 924 Gilman, and wants to take that ethos into the internet, I couldn't be more supportive. Godspeed. [1]: https://www.flickr.com/photos/61992100@N03/23226226149/in/album-72157660564998867/ https://www.flickr.com/photos/61992100@N03/23226226149/in/al...
- kickme444 9y agoGilman was a huge part of my life and I played various roles in participating and helping to manage it over the year, though I don't want to take ANY credit for this, it's not my place and no person should. But, the experience I had there showed me what is possible when things are started with good intentions and managed that way going forward. There were and are rocky times at Gilman, but overall it's a model that should be studied. Also, we made and shared a lot of great music with the world, which is the real upside of gilman. I miss that time in my life.
- joeyaiello 9y ago
- blindwatchmaker 9y agoThe fundamental problem I have with reddit is that it seems extremely easy to game and astroturf. Things like /r/politics felt like a Democratic party propaganda platform around the 2016 election for example.
- motohagiography 9y agoThe entire Hollywood mythology was built around being "discovered," and elevated to fame and stardom, and arguably it's main product wasn't movies, it was hope. If I were Conde Nast, I would use reddit as a farm team for finding, creating, and monetizing internet celebrities through its "legit," properties the way that movie studios created vehicles to profit from actors. Costs them hardly anything to talent scout redditors and try them out in other publications, then promote the story back of how success story X was "discovered," on reddit. Keeps their monetization platforms hands clean, while bringing a steady stream of talent to market. The difference between hollywood and Conde Nast is that now, Conde Nast literally owns that talent source instead of relying on a bunch of agents.
- maxerickson 9y agoCondé Nast doesn't own reddit, the parent company to Condé Nast, Advance Publications, is the majority owner of reddit, but not the only shareholder. Block me on Twitter!
- motohagiography 9y agoGood color. Single party has control of Conde Nast and Reddit, so while there is a legal distinction, this isn't a correction to the basic business dynamic.
- cookiecaper 9y agoThe introduction indicates that this is part of a series that NY Mag has been running called "The Internet Apologizes", where it appears they specifically seek out influential people willing to say bad things about online communities and properties. This series can probably be reasonably interpreted as part of the traditional media smear campaign against democratized speech platforms -- they quite prefer speech controlled by their fancy executives and programming directors. While it doesn't necessarily diminish anything the interviewee states, it's important to understand the context and framing of the discussion.
- wvenable 9y ago"They believe that if they have a billion unique visitors a month, that they have a property that is going to be worth a ton of money in some way eventually." This is stupid; users are fickle and visitors mean nothing if you can't monetize them. And usually attempting to monetize visitors causes them to leave to the next platform trying to reach a billion unique visitors. I can't believe intelligent people think this is a valid way to run an Internet business. It might work for small startups looking to be bought out by a larger company (who will then try and monetize it, driving away all the users) but for a company like reddit it's a bit ridiculous. (Edit fixed typo)
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- fudged71 9y agoI think the idea of reddit collapsing entirely is much harder than a single news site for instance. It's not one product, it is hundreds of strong communities that have gathered from different places on the web. There are discussions and communities that I would not know how to find elsewhere on the web.
- wvenable 9y agoReddit is not profitable. Your strong communities are supported by investors hoping to get a return on their investment. If the growth stops, the investment stops, and the servers go away. The fact that the communities are strong matters not.
- tripplethrendo 9y agoHe's basically saying that freedom of speech is too risky on the internet for any platform. That is scary to me.
- tootie 9y agoA lot of the banned subs were downright abusive if not criminal. Shaming, harassing, threatening. Reddit is not obligated to provide them a platform and that's not a free speech issue.
- quadrangle 9y agoIt is scary. This is what convinced me that maybe "hey, freedom of speech, even for stuff I dislike" could actually leave us too vulnerable: https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2017/08/25/546127444/episode-790-rough-translations-in-ukraine https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2017/08/25/546127444/epis... But I have no real solutions. Maybe even if we censor things, we work as hard as possible to keep the censorship records transparent and to make the censored stuff accessible and have some complex accountability system?? I dunno. maybe it's all hopeless.
- streb-lo 9y agoFreedom of speech has nothing to do with Reddit.
- commandlinefan 9y agoNo, the first amendment of the constitution of the United States (which describes the US government's responsibilities in regards to freedom of speech) has nothing to do with Reddit. Freedom of speech as a concept can be applied to anything: reddit, the government, hacker news, you or I.
- T-N-T 9y agoAmerican corporatism and singular definition of 'freedom of speech' as being 'the amendment' really polluted the well of any discussion of the topic on English-speaking platforms. We, in Europe, have limited freedom of speech. You can't do things like denying the holocaust. But that doesn't mean we don't recognize the concept of freedom of speech, and that we don't have discussion platforms that feature freedom of speech -within the limits of our laws-. Censorship is still censorship, even when it's done by a corporation. Listening to americans there can be no debate as to whether censorship even exists if it's done by a corporation because corporation are free to do anything and we shouldn't even debate what they do and whether we should boycott a place and move onto something else because corporations can do no wrong and exerting individual judgement, opinion, and sharing them, encouraging the growth of freer online platforms and the likes is heavily discouraged. No, everything has to do with the law and if the law doesn't call it bad then it's not bad and it shouldn't be judged as bad. That worship of the law and constitution as the only sacred values in human societies is disgusting.
- Rotdhizon 9y agoThat confirms the actions of what Spez usually does. He remains silent on the rampant abusive subreddits UNTIL someone publishes a news article about it, then he steps in with the whole "We're dedicating ourselves to stepping up regulating these harmful subreddits, and other blanket PR statements". Like most, I enjoy the hobby specific subs(tech related for me) like sysadmin, networking, netsec, etc. Those communities are often very closely monitored by moderators who don't want off topic things floating in. I do browse the news sections everyday but it's normally not terrible. Most people have caught on now to the bot comment structure so those accounts get their comments downvoted to invisibility. I think the biggest problem is that Reddit has created a poison with two perfect ingredients. 1) Having little to no moderation on abusive/illegal topics due to fear of PR backlash. 2) Creating a platform that allows people all over the world the communicate. Mix those together and suddenly you have extremists, criminals, and just outright mentally sick people joining together to create massive communities where that behavior and mentality is allowed to prosper. When insane people have insane views, they typically have them amongst themselves or in a very small groups. Their not going to go around telling the town about their views and intentions, so it can be hard to find others to connect with that are in the same boat. That isolation I think tends to lead to towards those ideologies to fizzle out, or continue in private but without the backing to do any harm. When you suddenly have hundreds/thousands of these small groups of insane people banding together in a place where they can share their views publicly with anonymity, things get out of hand. Take Incels for example, which is a now banned sub that was made up of generally unappealing men would very likely never experience intimacy with a female due to their own shortcomings. It's one thing for a guy to think in a brief moment "I really want to do X with a female, maybe I should just do it forcefully". That's just a personal thought and likely to fizzle out because it has no backing. Now when you have an entire echo chamber of like minded individuals saying things like that, now it's leading to encouragement and active planning of those illegal actions. All because Reddit refuses to step in. Reddit truly doesn't offer much in terms of positives. Sure the easy going, user friendly, rolling forum type setup makes it easy for people to discuss hobbies and interests. However, forums have been doing just that since the internet began. Sure you can get news, cooking recipes, tech help, etc in a fast, easy going manner but you can get all of those from plenty of other sources too. Think of it like this: In many areas down south in the US, militant groups are living in the forests. Generally they are white extremist, pro gun nuts who have small communities being self sufficient in the deep woods. These groups hate government interference and usually have a shoot on site policy. By themselves, these groups are nothing. Even the ones who threaten the public, pretty much never do anything. Now what if these groups had a way to find and communicate with each other in as efficient a manner as Reddit provides? Now you go from harmless threats to a potential, real world problem that could lead to violence and destruction since many groups would now have banded together.
- stinger 9y agoCan the sentences for this article get any longer?
- nemild 9y agoI've been actively working on a media literacy guide for engineers, contributions welcome: https://github.com/nemild/hack-an-engineer https://github.com/nemild/hack-an-engineer (Think Reddit influences so much of engineering thought from things like r/learnprogramming to all the cryptocurrency subs)
- IAmEveryone 9y agoThis is just a collection of stereotypes of journalism that are already commonly believed among the tech crowd. Just one example: it’s insulting and hurtful to any quality journalist (ie at the NYT, WSJ, or Economist) to suggest that their reporting is motivated by personal financial incentives, or their employer’s.
- nemild 9y agoI'll respectfully disagree. Financial incentives influence everyone, including the editors at top publications who are constantly looking at what is read, watched, and shared to decide what to invest in and feature. You might really like "All the News That's Fit to Sell" which is written by a media economist that digs into how market incentives influence coverage (he's the director of the journalism program at Stanford). There's lots of discussion as well about media coverage decisions in the lead up to the 2016 presidential election at even the national networks. This Cecil the Lion example at the Washington Post has always been illuminating to me: https://www.nytimes.com/2015/08/17/business/where-clicks-reign-audience-is-king.html https://www.nytimes.com/2015/08/17/business/where-clicks-rei... Even at the top publications, financial incentives influence choices. It's not as malevolent as someone paying off a journalist. For example, at most top tier newspapers, there is an incentive for "if it bleeds, it leads". This is an economic outcome, as this elicits the most reader interest and also increases profitability. (See my data analysis on this in the NY Times: https://www.nemil.com/s/part3-horror-films.html https://www.nemil.com/s/part3-horror-films.html )
- str33t_punk 9y agoHowever stereotypes about journalists from the tech crowd doesn’t have much visibility. The journalist crowd thinks a bunch of stereotypes about tech. And they have the platform to broadcast their prejudice to the world. Some of their stereotypes are quite insulting to any quality Engineer. Why is it bad when we stereotype them, when they have been doing it aggressively for years? Rather, I believe it is our duty to start reporting on the media and our opinions about the media, as no one does. The media holds all the power in broadcasting opinions on the populace, and there are very little entities that check their power.
- zaidf 9y agoThis is the latest flavor of humble bragging in the Valley.
- pessimizer 9y agoSpeaking from one of his nine yachts over a satellite phone, Spammy Tachsdodger McScrapyface said "What we did at Zynga was terrible and should be regulated. My new company is available to consult on how that should be done."
- AriaMinaei 9y agoWith the complaint that VCs are incentivised to favor short-term metrics and over emphasise growth, how would you go about fixing that? Also, as a founder, how would you seek investors that wouldn't pressure you to scale too fast?
- fudged71 9y agoThat's the problem with VCs in general, and it doesn't fit their business model from a math perspective if you are low-growth. There are some investors who are trying a new model (see Indie.vc). The alternative is either to go without funding (at the expense of an ad or subsciption model), or have your users help fund you through something like an ICO or equity crowd fund or patreon etc. Or you find a way to remove infrastructure costs through some technical decentralization or open-source and treat development/support as a hobby, but that doesn't scale to this size.
- foobaw 9y agoOne thing that really annoys me from Reddit is the mob mentality. For instance, a person will make a seemingly "logical" argument and everyone will just keep adding their own "opinion" agreeing with this argument to be part of this mob. Later, even if this argument is proven wrong, you will get insulted, downvoted and threatened if you make any sort of counter-argument. I hate generalizing but my experience was that most people were unwilling to take back what they said.
- tedunangst 9y agoNot unique to reddit. Once a forum comment has been accepted as right, it will always be the top post. Child comments only ever see fewer views. The correction will never be as popular.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- digi_owl 9y agoAs a foreigner, i am massively puzzled by how people seem to want to place all this on some left-right axis when both "sides" seems to have a massive problem of authoritarianism and groupthink.
- Karrot_Kream 9y agoMany of the comments here are picking apart pieces of subreddit drama or are discussing specific Reddit positions, but I think that's missing the forest for the trees. The VC grow-at-all-costs model seems to be resulting in monopolistic business practices and more negative externalities than positive ones. Msatodon/GNU Social/Qvitter right now is a thriving social network run by instance owners that federate their instances. Or you can run your own instance if you want total control of everything. Secure Scuttlebutt is a growing social network run in a fully distributed (as opposed to federated) model. The cat is out of the bag, and if you're complaining about social media today I see no reason not to embrace modern social networks.
- sangnoir 9y ago> The VC grow-at-all-costs model seems to be resulting in monopolistic business practices and more negative externalities than positive ones. Bingo. The essence of it was captured by: "I think a start-up needs to think about the monetization and how it can work with the users instead of against the users." The VC-mindset monoculture doesn't help ("majority [...] are all the same archetype").
- skybrian 9y agoSome programmers see a problem and say "I know, I'll add federation". Now you have 7 problems. More seriously, I'm not seeing how federation solves any social network problem better than subreddits did? In either case, the quality of the discussion will depend on the moderators, who can be good, bad, or evil.
- Karrot_Kream 9y agoFederated social networks give you the ability to change allegiance or fork. Don't like a particular moderator on an instance? Leave to another instance, or start your own. Things can get problematic if other instances refuse to federate your own, but if you maintain even a bit of social capital, most instances will not block an instance with a single user. There's a growing culture (and a set of actions in the ecosystem) of letting people know when you've changed instances, because instances are becoming easier and easier to run and more and more people are trying to run their own. But if you don't want to deal with it, join one of the large already existing instances.
- tootie 9y agoBring back Ellen Pao.
- tomcam 9y agoReddit has been a completely positive force in my life. I subscribe to hundreds of subreddits and they all seem quite well-moderated. If I want to ask a question of doctors, engineers, lawyers, or manufacturers, I can. If I want to spend some time look at cute baby elephant pictures, I can. If I want to learn about a new GarageBand feature, it's easy. I literally didn't know about the things like jailbait until they became national controversies.
- SlowRobotAhead 9y agoI’ve seen absolute junk science on gun control posted in reddit science. Comments that questioned the “study” were flat out removed. Millions of subscribers on that sub, at the time it was a default. No one is implying that gonewild or programmerhumor are bad forces... but news censors, worldnews is manipulated, politics is beyond a joke. Those three particularly are almost certainly bought and paid for. Reddit is pretty bad, particular subreddits can be great. You need to understand the content vs the company.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- UncleMeat 9y agoI used to be a mod of r/science. There is an incredible amount of garbage in the comment section. This makes precise moderation very very hard. In general, I think the sub is far too lenient about leaving up comments. Far too often the top comments are pointing out some "flaw" in the study that is either irrelevant to the paper or addressed in the paper body.
- shostack 9y agoReddit has been mixed for me, but overwhelmingly positive. I'm a part of industry subs that have incredibly high signal-to-noise ratios and counts founders and executives as some of its members. I've gotten amazingly deep answers quickly, and for free, for some of the most challenging and technical problems in my space. And for hobbies, it is now my goto place for really deep dive info. I've received consulting opportunities, and also just connected with people IRL (including someone who ended up working literally around the corner from my office). If I had to summarize my negative experiences, it would come down primarily to being made increasingly aware of how broken the world is with places like /r/politics and /r/worldnews, and the sheer amount of my free time Reddit ends up consuming that is, let's face it, mindless scrolling and brain candy. To help with the negativity I've found adding more positive subs to my list helps balance it (like /r/uplifitingnews). It really is a balancing act though and I'm constantly aware of the self-imposed filter bubble I'm cultivating, so it is important to step outside of that.
- gottam 9y agoThe comments here have this mentality of "there are people with different opinions from me, why don't these websites deal with these opinions". It's dangerous thinking that can be applied to your opinions. The internet always worked this way. There are the cesspools, maybe things you don't like, but if you don't feel like engaging with these communities you simply keep going. Problem with these social media forum sites is that as much as you don't want to engage/debate with these communities they still use the same website as you so its unavoidable. This is why centralizing these forums onto one website was a bad idea, blame that. Because now, there's too much money involved and excluding people of certain political ideas or whatever means you lose a substantial chunk of userbase, which means users would depart to another website.
- ikmujn 9y agoThe world went to war with those different opinions not that long ago.
- youdontknowtho 9y agoTo be fair, some of the "speech" on Reddit is actually dangerous. Like, get people hurt dangerous.
- partiallypro 9y agoI've never seen an active threat on Reddit, what do you define as dangerous? Can you give an example? I've been on Reddit almost since the beginning and I've never come across a post that I felt posed any danger. Maybe I'm in the wrong subreddits.
- youdontknowtho 9y agoYou are in the wrong subreddits. EDIT: AND your anecdotal experience isn't conclusive.
- Karunamon 9y agoSo you have no examples? Bare assertions don't make for very good discussion.
- pessimizer 9y agoreddit - anarchic garbage = metafilter metafilter has 12,000 users, not mansions, yachts and tennis star wives. No one is asking metafilter mods about reddit, they're asking people who got rich off reddit, because they respect people who get rich, not people who have well-run, wisely-moderated forums. This is because well-run forums are common, and reddit.coms are not.
- lsmarigo 9y agoReddit has been overrun by extremists and special interest groups and has become a dangerous tool for indoctrination and misinformation. This interview feels disingenuous and a thinly veiled humble brag/promo for Imzy. Jailbait Really? How can you mention jailbait but not coontown, KKK, fatpeoplehate, incels, boston marathon, there are so many worse communities/incidents that have spilled into general reddit than jailbait. the cycle is media backlash > ban a few subs > replacements/under the radar alternatives readily available in the ban announcement comments. no one seems to fully appreciate the massive influence that reddit has on the news cycle/national discourse and how the company policies can actually shape world politics. It's insane we're not studying this and talking about it more.
- searchencrypt 9y agoThe big tech industry is weirdly obsessed with growth. I'd guess that this is because platforms that have collected huge amounts of users can monetize them later. And...startups that sell for millions make growth look like the best KPI to monitor.
- Uhhrrr 9y ago>if Reddit, specifically, focused all their efforts on the health of their platform, on the people that are really the contributors and not the consumers, they would see growth beyond what they’re getting. I think Digg tried this, shortly before being crushed by Reddit.
- kwelstr 9y agoI used to have an reddit account from the first year reddit came out and I finally decided to delete it this year. I kept going into smaller and smaller subreddits because the ones I used to like, askscience or askhistorians etc. grew too much and became non enjoyable for me. At the end even the smaller subreddits were a waste of my time. I feel good about this and I don't think I'm going back to reddit.
- sneak 9y agoBold claim; most people in the world have never heard of Reddit.
- LordHumungous 9y ago>Were there moments in which Reddit chose to double down on something and made it that much harder to work toward a solution? >> I don’t know. I’m trying to think about your question. >Is there something recent that you’re thinking of? >> I can’t remember the specific instances right now, but there was a bunch of press about things that were going on on Reddit and Discord, and they both reacted and banned the subreddit. >> I’ve got a lot of advice for start-ups, and it’s not very fucking complicated. It’s just: Think about the impact that you want to have on your users and on the people consuming your content and do the right thing. They know what the right thing is. Sounds like this guy has a lot of vague complaints but not much in the way of concrete solutions, other than "do the right thing" which in his mind is extremely obvious and yet undefined.
- otoburb 9y ago>>Sounds like this guy has a lot of vague complaints but not much in the way of concrete solutions, other than "do the right thing" which in his mind is extremely obvious and yet undefined. Maybe he's operating on the same principle espoused by Justice Potter Stewart's "I know it when I see it" threshold test[1]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/I_know_it_when_I_see_it https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/I_know_it_when_I_see_it
- munificent 9y agoThat's an uncharitable interpretation of what are, I think, pretty clear words on his part. He says he doesn't know how to fix existing broken entrenched sites like Reddit and Twitter but does have suggestions for sites that are just getting started.
- VectorLock 9y agoHow well did those things work out for him?
- andygates 9y agoSounds like it's "don't be so stuck on 'free speech' that you let nazis and trolls dictate the dialogue"; strong moderation is what's been missing. Banhammers from on high, and damn the whiners.
- pfarnsworth 9y agoreddit is probably one of the best social sites on the internet. You need to pick and choose the best ones though. Like everything, there are shitty ones and great one. The great ones have great mods with a very precise focus.
- naasking 9y ago> I had conversations with Jason [Citron] a year ago about the problem of white supremacy on his site, and he said, “I don’t want to invade their privacy by going into their channels and reading what they’re doing.” And I said, “They’re gonna cause deaths because you’re not doing that.” And he said, “You really think so?” And I said, “Yeah.” And sure enough they didn’t do anything, and sure enough deaths were caused because of the shit going on in their channels. I'm not sure I can agree with this kind of moralizing. It's the same argument that blames gun manufacturers for school shootings. Clearly the latter argument is absurd, and yet very intelligent people subscribe to the former argument. So either some step is missing here that differentiates these two arguments, or we should be focusing on the real problem.
- Joeri 9y agoGuns are a bad analogy because manufacturers have no control over their use post purchase. If gun manufacturers could take back their guns (ban users) when somebody threatened illegal violence the analogy would be closer, and it would be quite reasonable to expect them to do so.
- legulere 9y agoWho you're selling to can make a big difference. An extreme Example is Heckler and Koch that supposedly exported G36 illegally to the conflict zones of Mexico. But there are also legal examples, for instance weapon manufacturers lobby for laxer laws, including how weapons need to be handled after they are bought.
- naasking 9y ago> If gun manufacturers could take back their guns (ban users) when somebody threatened illegal violence the analogy would be closer, and it would be quite reasonable to expect them to do so. Except creating a new profile on reddit is trivial, so "banning" is a weak threat at best.
- dleslie 9y agoIn doing so you lose your social connections and any moderator privileges you have; so it's not without threat.
- dredmorbius 9y agoI was quite disappointed not to see more from McComas on what went wrong with his so-called kinder, gentler Reddit alternative, Imzy. He briefly mentions the investors, but not his role in the site, its own group behaviours, staff, etc. I'd explored it and was impressed by several of its technical features, but found the net of its founding cohort and technical design, as well as staff and volunteer management & moderation, hands down the most toxic online experience I've seen in 30+ years. (Yes, pre-dating the Web.) The session-based anonymous identity dynamic in particular gave rise to dynamics such that every conversation was a single-iteration Prisoners Dilemma encounter with a strong dose of Zimbardo. I've been hoping to see a post mortem with some degree of introspection. That's not happened. More on my experiences: https://www.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/500ysb/the_imzy_experience_well_that_escalated_quickly/ https://www.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/500ysb/the_imz...
- VectorLock 9y agoReddit focused on openness and push growth as hard as possible. Imzy focused on heavily policing their userbase. Where is each of them at today?
- iosDrone 9y agoEveryone knows that Reddit died the day they killed FatPeopleHate. Ellen Pao is cancer in human form. She poisons everything she touches.
- mcny 9y agoI hope it has an implicit /s because spez and the entire leadership seems on board with everything she did
- sctb 9y agoWe ban accounts that won't follow the guidelines by commenting civilly and substantively. Could you please do that? https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html