19 ms·
Time to rebuild the web?
- nailer 9y agoView Source still exists, the presence of JavaScript and CSS means that HTML is more meaningful (as it's it's free of display information and behaviour). But looking at the DOM is the inspector is even more useful to undertsanding the tree structure. I agree with the sentiment of the article, but developer tools are better, not worse, than they were 20 years ago.
- jacquesm 9y agoDeveloper tools are better mostly because webpages are 100's of times more complex now than they were in the past whereas the typical amount of information on the page is still roughly the same. Understanding how a modern webpage source in combination with a browser results in what you see is a pretty complicated affair, in the past you just did 'view source' and it was obvious what went where. The web is now much more machine-to-machine than it was in the past when the humans could process the pages roughly as easily as the machines could.
- nailer 9y agoThe point I was making was that web pages in terms of HTML aren't more complex than they were in the past. An HTML page now often has a smaller amount of elements and element attributes than the equivalent page created using older tech because every element doesn't have styling hacks and behavior added to them. HTML (stuff like GAE or BEM aside) is purer than ever.
- jacquesm 9y agoUnfortunately removing the 'styling hacks and behavior' has split the pages up into many different components that all interact in quite complex ways. The HTML being 'purer' has not made things simpler at all. Now there are many places rather than just a few where style and functionality can be modified. And that can obscure intent quite quickly. As opposed to <b>this is bold text</b> which any fool (this one included) could understand. There are obvious benefits to separating layout, style, software and content. But it isn't categorically true that this will always result in something that is easier to understand by a human.
- nailer 9y ago> Now there are many places rather than just a few where style and functionality can be modified. Styling is done in style sheets, functionality is done in JavaScript (with the exceptions already mentioned). Trying to create, say Hotmail in 2018 would result in a much better to understand and debug app than the 1998 version was.
- jacquesm 9y agoFor a seasoned programmer, sure. But a layperson had a much better chance of understanding an early 90's webpage with the exact same content as a modern day one.
- nailer 9y agoI specifically mean for a layperson. <div class="inbox"> <div class="summary"> <q>Hi John how's things?</q> (close all the things) Is way better than <td key="value"> <td key="value"> <img width=1px height=1px class=shim/> <td key="value">Hi John how's things?</td> (close all the things)
- jacquesm 9y agoActually, it isn't. Because it left out all the moving parts that are now in the CSS. That second example is complete, the first one isn't, the second one gives me a fair idea of what the result should look like, the first could look like anything (even a blank page...).
- nailer 9y agoYes, it seperates style from presentation. That's a great way to get an understanding of the structure and content of the document and seperate concerns. 'Table data holding table data' does not do this well at all. Not responding further after this because `Actually, it isn't.` isn't a setence typically found in a polite adult conversation.
- nurettin 9y agoWhile we are reinventing the web, why don't we have independent accreditation institutions which regularly verify the truth behind websites ? Finance seems to have solved this problem.
- quantumwoke 9y agoThe article mentions the demise of Google Reader (rest in peace) as a turning point for the spread of fake news. I agree that there needs to be some counterweight to the deluge of news designed to influence public opinion. However, I don't think the tool to build that with is RSS. I recently learned about jsonfeed [0] from Hacker News and built a news aggregator for my own personal use. I believe the future of news content is in aggressive, hackable aggregation tools for a variety of content. jsonfeed is a solid foundation to build on :). [0] https://jsonfeed.org https://jsonfeed.org
- bhaak 9y agoThat makes no sense. RSS and jsonfeed are just containers. Both may contain real or fake news. Everybody can put up a feed in RSS or jsonfeed without any trouble.
- quantumwoke 9y agojsonfeed is a much simpler and more hackable protocol than RSS. It's much easier to build scalable and sustainable aggregators that filter fake news in jsonfeed without the cognitive overhead of RSS. Without hackable tools we end up with the walled gardens of Facebook and Google Reader.
- bhaak 9y agoYou sound like a buzzword machine. A simple RSS feed can easily be hand written. But of course, you don't do that because there are so many mature tools to create or manipulate an XML feed already. Whereas with jsonfeed there is not much yet because it is so new. If you can hack JSON, you can hack XML as well. Even programmer novices can do this. Edit: Reworded the last sentence that could be interpreted as a personal attack. Wasn't meant as such, I was going for the impersonal you.
- quantumwoke 9y agoPlease be civil :). Avoiding ad hominem attacks is more conducive to discussion. I have already justified my preference for jsonfeed. XML has proved many times to decrease developer productivity. To my knowledge open source projects that have dropped or diminished their use of XML have only become more popular over time. Extrapolating a little bit, switching to JSON can only be a good thing.
- naranha 9y agoSPAs have made almost all desktop applications obsolete. DevTools have deprecated view source. Through progress and innovation the web can do a lot more than 20 years ago. Sure the web is being abused for tracking by Google and Facebook but that was also possible 20 years ago with a single img-tag.
- goatlover 9y ago> SPAs have made almost all desktop applications obsolete. Meh, Office and Adobe products still have widespread use, as do various code editors and related tools, along with specialized applications like SPSS or Matlab. Also, things like Slack are desktop, even though they utilize web technologies. And there remain plenty of PC games which still get made. Some things you don't want to run in a browser.
- harperlee 9y agoIsn't it office already a "local webapp", under the hood? You can open any document in-browser through SharePoint server, have (almost?) full functionality, all documents are XML... There are lots of little signs that Microsoft is rewriting everything to be seamlessly used through a browser, and that when you open it locally you just don't notice that you are using an "office browser". Even Visual Studio has also web tech under the hood, I think.
- goatlover 9y agoYou still download and install Office 365 as applications and run them independent of a web browser and can do so without an internet connection. They also have their own updater. Yes, you can run them on the web from the Office 365 portal, but that's the html version. The installed version is still fundamentally a desktop platform. I'm pretty sure it's written C# or C++ and runs on dotnet. An SPA is a web page run in the browser over http(s). Anything else is desktop, server, or mobile app, regardless of what tech it's made from.
- naranha 9y ago
- marsrover 9y agoThis article is more of a longing for the past than any concrete idea on how the web should be rebuilt. Not only that, but it sounds like the ramblings of someone who isn't merely longing for the past but stuck in it. Is not being able to copy code from Facebook using view source killing the web? Of course not. If you are just starting out there are more resources available now than ever. And I hope to God we never have a web built on block chain technology.
- purple-again 9y agoIt’s a bad example too. There are so ducking many ‘let’s clone Facebook to learn x language’ guides that yes anyone of any skill level should be able to build Facebook right now without relying on view source because there are step by step tutorials! Now if he means you can’t build Facebook the service...we’ll yeah Google didn’t go around telling everyone in the 90’s how it’s algorithms wirked either. But you can clone Googles website super easy!
- nlstitch 9y agoMy thoughts exactly. It's constant complaining and referencing old tech.
- jacquesm 9y agoThat reference to old tech may be there because the old tech was sufficient and the new tech has left a gap. Right now there are two webs and they're interwoven to the point that it has become hard to see, but there is the 'web of applications' and the 'web of information'. There is no particular reason why the second should be implemented using the tools for the first.
- jaekwon 9y ago> While many of the technologies I'd use already exist, rebuilding the web around blockchains and onion routing would require a revolution in user interface design to have a chance; otherwise it will be a playground for the technology elite We've been working on proof-of-stake and blockchain scaling/interoperability infrastructure since 2014. It all starts with a classical BFT algorithm which provides simple light-client proofs and fork-accountability. Your mobile phone can verify transaction finality in 5 seconds, with no need for an hour of block confirmations as in Bitcoin proof-of-work mining. https://github.com/tendermint/tendermint <-- blockchain consensus engine https://github.com/cosmos/cosmos-sdk <-- blockchain framework in Go https://github.com/keppel/lotion <-- blockchain framework in JS https://github.com/cosmos/voyager <-- blockchain explorer https://github.com/tendermint/go-amino <-- blockchain codec derived from Proto3 https://cosmos.network https://tendermint.com The Cosmos Hub will launch very soon. Lets build stuff! Onion routing for Tendermint would be a great addition. And DNS/name-resolution on Tendermint can actually solve Zooko's triangle. While we're at it, lets fork Go too. https://groups.google.com/forum/#!msg/e-lang/cQiXS_GnKS4/ZskTifaoBgAJ https://groups.google.com/forum/#!msg/e-lang/cQiXS_GnKS4/Zsk... Disclaimer: I'm a cofounder of the Cosmos project, cofounder of Tendermint, and long-time HN lurker.
- quantumwoke 9y agoIt's generally considered good Hacker News etiquette to declare affiliations on your posts.
- jaekwon 9y agoThank you, does that look good?
- quantumwoke 9y agoThank you :).
- progval 9y ago> And DNS/name-resolution on Tendermint can actually solve Zooko's triangle. How?
- nickjj 9y agoIt's weird that the author mentions the 90s and how the web was not meant to be walled gardens, but then decided to omit AOL from the story. AOL was one big ass walled garden back in the 1990s. It was pretty popular back then. The funny thing is, back then, it was popular for 2 groups of people. First were younger kids who wanted to stir up trouble on the network (AOHell, etc.). The second were old people. My uncle is ~70 and still has an AOL account because he thinks it's "the internet". That's how strong AOL's walled garden / marketing was. Although, it didn't help that back then you would have to dial an AOL phone number on your modem to connect, so I could see how it could be confusing.
- pvg 9y agoAOL and similar services connected to the internet but were separate from it. They predated wide availability of consumer internet service. There's not much of a parallel to what the author is discussing.
- always_good 9y agoHuh? You could access arbitrary websites from AOL. How is that not part of the internet?
- pvg 9y agoWhat if I told you that when AOL started, you could not access arbitrary web sites from it because there weren't any.
- always_good 9y agoI'd say that your core distinction then is nonsensical and I'd wonder what it contributed. What if I said that? Is this hypothetical tense helping the conversation?
- pvg 9y agoI don't think this bit really requires much conversation, you can just read the relevant wikipedia pages for a quick rundown on things like the history of AOL, the internet, the world wide web and the seemingly nonsensical but curiously real distinctions between them over the years. What if you did that?
- realpeopleio 9y agoI agree that having a few walled gardens is a problem, but having more smaller walled gardens probably won't change much. Bad actors can still sign up, post, spam, harass, etc. on several small walled gardens. What we need is a way to better identify and handle bad actors. The internet in the 90s seemed more fun and more open. Perhaps it's because the only people really participating were not interested in abusing sites or people. It was mostly nerds sharing nerdy things. Once money got involved, and free everything was available, it turned into this soup of bots, trolls, AI, fake this and that, big money, swaying public opinion, and gross content. Smaller sites and discussion boards have been at a disadvantage recently trying to fend off spam, bots, and sock accounts and very often lose out to the big sites. Effectively controlling abuse and doing it a cost-effective way can be very hard. RealPerson.io (https://realperson.io https://realperson.io) was created as a way for websites to verify that a user is a real person, but without disclosing personal details about the user. Each person can create a single account on RealPerson.io and then can create separate, randomly-generated codes for each site they use. Websites register on RealPerson.io and then for each user signup on their website they simply asks the user for their RealPerson code for their website. A backend REST call to RealPerson.io with the user code for the site returns "yes" or "no." Sites don't share codes so you can't track across websites. No shared logins or authentication code. Bots would have to pay for a code for each account which would be cost prohibitive to run a bot farm. The first implementation of this approach was done with RealPeople.io (https://realpeople.io https://realpeople.io) which uses RealPerson.io to verify that the user is real.
- pjc50 9y ago> Each person can create a single account on RealPerson.io That web page doesn't explain how they guarantee uniqueness of users or pay for the required ID checking?
- jasode 9y ago>how they guarantee uniqueness of users I was curious too so I clicked on the sign-up button to see how it worked. It immediately takes you to a page to pay $9.00 by credit-card. I guess it guarantees you're a "real person" because bots† don't pay with credit-cards. †(At the large scale required for profitable fraud)
- hasa 9y agoBlockchain mentioned! Where are other useless buzzwords ?
- JPGalt 9y agocloud, deep-learning, robotics, augmented reality, computer vision, actionable analytics, RUSSIAN BOT, Internet of Things, big data, agile, design thinking, freemium, gamification, incubator, lean, SaaS, thought leader...this is enough because thinking about this is making me lose all respect for humanity.
- Hedja 9y agoIt feels like this is already a work in progress using Beaker Browser and Dat. - Beaker lets you browse entire websites (dat archives) and fork them. - It lets you create and serve your own sites directly from the browser and seed it from a server (like a torrent). - It lets other sites create templated sites under your name for user generated content. - Visitors by default temporarily seed your website which may reduce single point of failures, hug of deaths and costs. With this peer-to-peer torrent-like approach, the web can become distributed again and feel more like a "web". There's still a lot of work left and maybe Beaker itself isn't the best implementation for this idea, but it's a good start. https://beakerbrowser.com/ https://beakerbrowser.com/ https://datproject.org/ https://datproject.org/
- staticvar 9y agoA new version of the mobile browser with support for more Android devices is coming soon: https://bunsenbrowser.github.io https://bunsenbrowser.github.io
- staticvar 9y agoI'd like to also add that not only does Dat / Beaker / Bunsen offer a great way to decentralize the Web for existing users, it also makes it more affordable for billions of other people to browse and host websites because you can sync websites P2P over offline wifi. The use of cryptography under the hood guarantees users don't get hit by man-in-the-middle attacks. It's like SSL for offline. *Disclaimer: I am a volunteer contributor to Bunsen Browser.
- loceng 9y agoIn Bunsen Browser and others, while browsing offline, are you aware if there is a feature that allows version control tracking, so willing websites can have an API call that shares latest version - to return to say if an update is "required" or available?
- staticvar 9y ago> are you aware if there is a feature that allows version control tracking, so willing websites can have an API call that shares latest version - to return to say if an update is "required" or available? @loceng Yes, that is how Dat works, thus any browser serving Dat Archives help propagated changes to Dat archives. Note that only changes that are signed with the archive's private key for the archive are propagated. All of that happens under the hood as an owner of a dat archive though. You just run `dat share` command in a directory, you get a public address for the archive, and any time you make a change to a file in the archive it automatically signs with the private key and share it out to the network. https://docs.datproject.org/concepts#version-history https://docs.datproject.org/concepts#version-history
- martin_drapeau 9y agoWhen I ask friends and family who use Facebook daily, privacy and security never come up as pain points. Media is blowing everything out of proportion. Replacing Facebook with RSS or Feedly is nonsense. My friends and family have no idea what those are. Facebook makes it easy for people to connect with old friends and family members through active human interactions: like this, follow her, read that. By doing so you do tell Facebook about you and others. Its interactive and solves a pain point - keeping in touch and interacting with others, your community. Feedly does not do that.
- sarreph 9y agoNot only do (our) family and friends have no idea what Feedly is, most of them would have no idea where to start with the websites / content providers they’d want to add to their feeds. This is clearly a huge appeal of social media sites, as they act as content aggregators that do the ‘dirty work’ (oftentimes very poorly) in getting relevant content to chosen eyeballs. As much as I want there to be a reversion to more ‘vanilla’ content consumption, I’m completely in agreement with your refutation that Feedly would indeed be a nonesense bet to make on where we should be headed.
- jen729w 9y agoOne of the few times I’ve heard a counter to this was an old fisherman who took us out on a boat here in Melbourne, Australia. Proper bloke, skin like leather from the sun, done nothing but run fishing trips his whole life. He was lamenting the loss of a particular forum with one of the other guys. “All just on Facebook now”, he said, and he said it with sadness. He missed that old forum.
- icc97 9y agoActually that makes a lot of sense, it's not that we need to have RSS replace Facebook, we need a resurgance of forums to take back from Facebook. Perhaps if forums could talk to each other you'd have an experience more like mastodon, but in concepts that more people understand. Something like an open source Stack Exchange network. So you can log-in to one of them but then easily create an account using the credentials of the original forum that you signed in from. Edit: I know discourse [0] is kind of working along these lines, but I don't think they're designed to have activity between forums. Perhaps it could just be called 'Friend Forums'. [0]: https://www.discourse.org/ https://www.discourse.org/
- dkns 9y agoI'm not buying it. Web development complexity grows but so does desktop software, kernel development, etc. You used to be able to have a small program written in BASIC or whatever that would give you a simple popup alert on desktop. Now you need to worry about backwards compatibility, different OSes, etc. But guess what? You can still write simple programs, without all the complex stuff, if you want to. The exact same thing applies for web. You can bundle megabytes of javascript, for some fancy stuff, or you can have simple static index.html with just text. "The web was never supposed to be a few walled gardens of concentrated content owned by Facebook, YouTube, Twitter, and a few other major publishers. It was supposed to be a cacophony of different sites and voices." It still is. Facebook, YT and Twitter are simply more known than your local pet owners forum but that doesn't mean the pet owner forum doesn't exists. It's similar to supermarket chains and your local grocery store. Both still exist.
- hvidgaard 9y ago> the pet owner forum doesn't exists They are increasingly moving to FB Groups. It's a good tool for what it does.
- nicbou 9y agoIt's still possible: http://motherfuckingwebsite.com/ http://motherfuckingwebsite.com/ When I made All About Berlin, it was just HTML and CSS. Nothing complex there. I eventually added Disqus and Google Analytics, but it's still possible to build simple websites.
- 3pt14159 9y agoFixing the internet is hard. There are so many things wrong with it. Take your website for example: 1. No encryption, meaning any intermediate router could have altered the contents or at the very least surveilled them. 2. Illegible line length without me boosting the font size or browser width. 3. No protection for the reader that this is actually motherfuckingwebsite.com and not some .com with a Cyrillic character instead. 4. No protection for the reader that what is on this site hasn't been fingerprinted somehow (zero-width characters, Cyrillic, etc). 5. Even if the site was encrypted the DNS lookup would have exposed that I was looking at it anyway. 6. It's on the root of the domain which has a number of headaches at scale and roots vs www in general complicate things like understanding certs, CORS, etc. I agree that we need something simpler and locked down and I've even thought through not just the web portion, but the underlying portion as well, but it requires a massive change to get something that is both secure / trustworthy, not prone to spam, useable by the non-technical, and resilient against well funded mal-actors like warring nation states. And none of the replacement makes the world better for most of the worlds well funded corporations. Silicon Valley and Hollywood would both take a real hit because their business models both rely on insecurity. Hollywood is reliant on surveillance to enforce copyright and SV is reliant on surveillance to supply targeted ads.
- fimdomeio 9y agoI've been toying with the idea of creating a web 0.5 that consists mostly of a meta tag and a piece of css (body:after{...}) that hides the contents while directing users to use a textmode only browser. Rules would be page is valid if it doesn't contain css or js. I think this could be an incredible fun experiment somewhat in the same style as the tilde club. If it became popular enough who knows... maybe the community could even create some sort of web rings :O
- majewsky 9y ago> Rules would be page is valid if it doesn't contain no css and no js. I believe the double negation is wrong there. You probably mean either "if it doesn't contain any css or js" or "if it contains no css and no js".
- fimdomeio 9y agoyep. fixed.
- lioeters 9y agoI like the idea of a text-only browser, back to the basics. Oh and I miss web rings!
- giancarlostoro 9y agoOf course then you get into Gopher only territory. I wouldn't mind some CSS / HTML only sites like HN, your JS is limited to 5KB, jQuery isn't allowed, etc. Minify the web! Literally.
- yoz-y 9y agoI think people that do care about this stuff already make webpages that are minimal. So there is probably no need to have a completely alternative space. Maybe just a directory/search engine that only indexes such pages.
- sidcool 9y agoWhat happened to the Seif Project?
- amelius 9y ago> Few walled gardens That sounds surprisingly like how our economy ends up working. Perhaps we need a broader view?
- mtgx 9y agoIsn't WebAssembly basically moving the web in the opposite direction?
- trumped 9y agoyes... WebAssembly is even worst then Angular (They both obfuscate the web)
- rasengan 9y agoConway’s Law
- macspoofing 9y agoIf you want the internet for the wealthy (and Western) technocratic minonority then that's what you do. If you want the internet to be used by 7 billion people, then Facebook (or something like Facebook) it is. I've become a believer of 'walled gardens' after watching my elderly aunt struggle with PCs and websites for years, until I set her up with an iPad, Facebook, and Skype.
- kobrad 9y agoNice that this website doesn't respect opening in new tab. Is this some ironic take or what?
- tannhaeuser 9y agoWorse, linking to Amil Dash's article on medium [1], of all things, makes complaining about oligopolization of the Web kind of inconsequential. [1]: https://medium.com/@anildash/the-missing-building-blocks-of-the-web-3fa490ae5cbc https://medium.com/@anildash/the-missing-building-blocks-of-...
- scandox 9y agoI feel like he's worrying but he isn't sure about what. I don't think the problems of the internet are related to how easily people can make their own sites. It's just that the feeling that your content might actually be seen and appreciated is gone. In the 1990s if you published something online it felt good like some people are going to read this and care. Now it feels like "hey another ball tossed into the massive gaping void". Part of this obviously is about search and curation. Part of it also is probably just the massive loss of intimacy on the web now that it is so big. It's easy to feel less relevant when you get a few hundred views, even though in the 1990s you might also have got only a few hundred views. So what I'd like is to have a new intimate internet. It would be effectively searchable by a Google equivalent that only indexed a small subset of the internet. How exclusive it would be, how exactly it is curated and managed I have zero idea. I'm just saying that is what I would like. Now HN: unleash your list of stuff like this that already exists.
- lmm 9y agoHonestly, this is exactly the problem that Facebook (and other social media like HN) solve. I can write a blog post/article and rather than tossing it into the void, I share it on Facebook or a suitable subreddit or here. And while I may get a small number of views, they're likely to be from people I care about (either friends or people in the same hobby community), and those people have a chance to respond and comment.
- edraferi 9y agoYou want an “intimate Internet” with its own search capability to restore the feel of the early web? Probably we should make sure it’s easy for less technical people to use. Needs a good story around mobile and rich media. Oh dear, we’ve reinvented Facebook! Seriously though, I think this is more about community than technology, and more about channel saturation than centralization. I think the best shot for what you want is the re-distributed web and niche social networks (subreddits?). The peer-based web stuff will give you that feeling of being ahead of the masses on tech, and subreddits for your favorite hobby will let you connect with people who care about your random thing.
- nicbou 9y ago
- zaarn 9y agoThe problem usually lies in UX. Most projects attempting to "fix the web" as admirable as it be, suffer for pretty bad UI. Usually because the UI designer was also the developer. I'm also guilty of this. A recent project that got around this was Mastodon and Pleroma, both have pretty decent UI/UX.
- jsilence 9y agozeronet has a pretty decent UI.
- dschuetz 9y agoThat's the narrative you get if you say that the internet, the web and its users are broken: "Does it affect me? No. Does it still work for me? Yes. Is the internet broken? For users who don't know how to use it, yes." So, why even bother arguing? Everyone lives on their special little islands of some niche web/IP semi-commercial projects and do not particularly care about ads or cookies, because whatever.
- eddieschod 9y ago"The web was done by amateurs." - Alan Kay
- kabes 9y agoThe context of that quote had nothing to do with what this article is about.
- psyc 9y agoI really don't care, because it's important enough to repeat in any discussion about rebuilding the Web. Involve some real systems people. Design a real app platform, with multi-language support, especially compiled languages. Have a cohesive end to end development story.
- 9y ago
- jancsika 9y ago> The web was never supposed to be a few walled gardens of concentrated content owned by Facebook, YouTube [...] What are the numbers on views of original Youtube content vs. views of clips of material that infringes copyright? My guess is that the latter still makes up a significant portion of clicks. If someone makes a serious P2P alternative to Youtube, not only will infringing content be there-- such content's existence will be a measure of how successful the platform is. Either that, or you design something like the unexplained decentralized internet on the show "Silicon Valley" which somehow still has a single company controlling the pipes. If not that, then "P2P-tube" has to house Silvestri's "Back to Future" theme[1] just as it houses impassioned vlogs of walled-garden escapees. If you don't have both you'll end up with a bunch of walled-garden escapees rationalizing the virtues of housing unpopular, homogenized content. Anyway-- as passive onlookers its easy to dismiss Youtube's infringing content. But it's a lot more difficult when its a fledgling service that content owners cannot monetize. I think we've been through this before with Bittorrent. What was O'Reilly's opinion then? [1] The first Youtube link that popped up was obviously put together in a consumer video editor and currently has over 9 million views: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e8TZbze72Bc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e8TZbze72Bc Edit: clarification
- jhasse 9y ago"Peer-to-peer-YouTube" already exists btw: https://github.com/Chocobozzz/PeerTube https://github.com/Chocobozzz/PeerTube
- woranl 9y agoUnlike in the past, people don’t build websites for fun anymore. I remember I used to visit topsite ranking sites just to explore what other had built. Nowadays, it’s all templated design hosted in a walled garden.
- needToSay 9y agoNo wonder if all the Silicon Valley homos write on medium because it's hip.
- CM30 9y agoSadly, I don't think many people do anything for fun anymore. Feels like every site/channel/project/venture now is done with the possibility of a career in mind, and nothing online is made without some sort of extrinsic benefit to the creator. Seems like the idea of a hobby in general has died off sometimes.
- qznc 9y agoThey still do: https://neocities.org/ https://neocities.org/
- randomsearch 9y agoI don't believe the problem lies in any technology. We don't need blockchain, it's not JavaScript minification, it isn't the centralisation of services that are the problem. It's the business model. No amount of tech is going to change that. If you want to change the situation, start social media businesses with a different business model.
- JBReefer 9y agoTotally agree. It's ads and the attention economy. They thrive on controversy - it's the psychological version of the banner ads in the 90s, but 10,000x more effective.
- gkya 9y agoIs there a study on the (in)effectiveness of online ad campaigns? Is it or is it not a bubble that drives all this ad publisher to the ad platforms instead of buying ads more directly? I don't know the prices but I can bet buying an ad directly from a vlogger is cheaper and more effective than any ad platform out there. Is it really the dumbness of ad publishers that keep this system alive or is it me that I'm really ignorant when it comes to the economy of internet?
- reaperducer 9y agoJust watch what the big advertisers do. Coca-Cola, McDonald's, Procter & Gable, etc... When your company spends millions on advertising, you have teams of people to figure out if your strategy is effective. Follow the leaders.
- gkya 9y agoI haven't seen one of them advertise online. Online adverts are way different than TV adverts. For one the latter costs way more, if I'm not mistaken. And even if that's not the case, still, those companies have so much money that running ads is like a hobby for them. So I'd rather not follow them. Just like Google can get away with killing Reader, they can get away with many things which if a smaller company did would be suicide.
- d--b 9y agoThese articles are annoying. They completely miss the point. The web as it was in the early 90s was an alternative to major content delivery platforms (TV, press, mostly). So there was these massive systems that were the press and the TV who would own most of our attention span. And then there was this cute alternative technology with a great community that was yet unpolluted by the big guys. Today, the big content guys colonized the medium, so it no longer feels like the web is "a cacophony of different sites and voices" to quote the article. But in fact, we're in the same situation: big guys with money and loads of content on one side and small guys with communities on the other side. The web as it is today doesn't prevent you from spreading your ideas to the world on your very own server... And websites like reddit and hacker news are great amplifiers of small voices. I would probably never have read this article if it had been published in the 90s. Since it's #1 on HN, perhaps 50k people have read it today! The way I use the web feels very much like the 90s: a few aggregation sites, a lot of excellent content written by independent guys, links between them... Who cares about the centralized internet when the internet that we've loved since the 90s is still there and thriving?
- _bxg1 9y agoIt's more a question of culture. Theoretically, yes, nothing has been lost since the 90s. All those technologies still exist. But culturally, the norms of the web have shifted. The proposal is to create technologies that encourage/empower regular people (people who don't read hacker news) to make a cultural shift back to the web's original vision.
- loceng 9y agoCulture shifts with awareness, education, and well-designed solutions being available. The next "Facebook" platform that isn't designed to control or have a strategy to collect or hoard data will exist. The layman doesn't generally know what's good for them in any specialized area, that's quite clear when we saw the level of technical understanding shown during questions to Mark Zuckerberg; it's obvious career politicians will need to eventually evolve over to successful people with strong holistic standing of all systems, with the ability to learn in depth and have strong critical thinking. We need to do a better job as a society of developing these people, and of capturing society's attention with genuine interest and excitement, and not merely with hype and paid-for reach.
- noir-york 9y agoThe web reduces the cost of information transfer to pretty much zero so anyone can publish, with no gatekeepers (of old). Scale matters. Information inequality was inevitable. Free trade led to growing concentrations of economic power and rising economic inequality. We also have information inequality to go with it, and because information transfer is much lower cost than trade, information inequality will be much higher and power more concentrated (social media stocks should thus be valued higher than companies which make real things) Not sure the article understands that inequality is inherent in the structure of the web. If you wanted to reduce inequaliy there are two options: 1. redistribution 2. raising the 'transaction' costs In economics we know what those look like: 1. progressive taxation and a welfare state 2. legislation to raise environmental standards, increase minimum wages, etc. What's the equivalent of a social welfare state and higher minimum wage when it comes to information? Another way of looking at this is in terms of externalities: free social media generates both positive (connecting with old friends) and negative externalities (fake news, election mischief, etc). One way of internalising both would be for Facbook to charge users. That is never going to happen. Carbon credits and the like make polluters internalise the costs that society would otherwise incur. So, what kind of legislation (and it will have to be legislation) would get social media companies to be pay for the negative externalities?
- chappi42 9y agoWhat I miss in the article is tax. Yes, "Much as we may complain about Facebook, selecting relevant content from an ocean of random sites is an important service". Same with google, they do a terrific job with providing YouTube and the Search infrastructure. But YouTube, Facebook, Google destroy (a.o.) the 'normal media' as they oligopolize advertising. They hinder progress/competition as they cross-subside their ventures with ad-money. The simplest solution imho would be to tax advertising strongly. This could be done independently by countries. E.g. every single advert in Germany would bear a tax of 30 - 70 %. This gives a country the power (and money) to steer in directions which benefit the country as a whole, i.e. support traditional media, public broadcaster, culture. Concentrated advertising money is dangerous. It should be regulated. The same approach is being done with e.g. cigarettes and gas. Tax is here to contain an unwanted action (smoking) or to build infrastructure (roads). Couldn't the same approach be taken for the internet?
- noir-york 9y agoI think you're on to something. A thought which came to mind would be for a country to levy an access charge (think of the BBC license fee) to access social networks based on usage. The money would then be used to clean up the negative externalities caused by the social network in that country.
- _bxg1 9y agoRaw HTML pages would instantly become 10x more palatable if browsers would make the default font sans-serif
- peterwwillis 9y agoI just came back from China. I could not message my loved ones, check my mail, update my social media, or listen to internet radio. This was not Facebook's fault, it was not even China's fault (though they were the ones blocking me). It was the fault of the way we use existing technology. So Facebook is banned. Fine. That shouldn't stop me from being able to at least send data somewhere that will end up at Facebook. And I should have been able to send an e-mail that bounced through intermediary relays without connecting to Gmail's servers. A lot of the web that _could_ be peer to peer isn't. And it's not because it is difficult, but because we simply haven't decided to use it that way. Email is the oldest, most successful distributed decentralized application. It does not require complex consensus. It does not use distributed databases. And it just works. You don't even need to be connected to the end server. There's no reason the web couldn't work like this. It is feasible today. On top of this, where your web content is stored should be simple: it should be stored on a device in your pocket, and cached and distributed on servers around the world, just like email already is. Again, no complex algorithms are needed for this. A very simple design could accomplish this with existing technology, and perhaps an extension to a protocol's RFC and an update to some core software.
- matthewmacleod 9y agoThis was not Facebook's fault, it was not even China's fault Absolute shite. It's 100% China's fault. Given the widespread, damaging, lingering ramifications of the lack of security on the Internet in general, the absolute last thing we should be doing is promoting the idea that this information and these connections should be less secure. I am baffled that anybody could even propose this idea.
- peterwwillis 9y agoWell, I propose it because 1) HTTPS is a tiny aspect of what makes one secure on the web, 2) I just want to talk to my loved ones on the web, 3) I don't care what China does with my data, 4) "lingering ramifications" of this are very manageable. Maybe I have a skewed point of view, but after being involved in computer security for 15 years, I literally have two cases at all where I care about the data I'm sending over the internet: logging into my bank, and making a purchase with a credit card. Virtually everything else, I don't care about.
- wsy 9y agoIt is somewhat ironic to see such an article coming from the VP of a large publisher. How can he seriously suggest to use Feedly as tool for finding relevant and high-quality content? Where one of a publisher's main services is to separate the wheat from the chaff, and to guide the reader to content useful for them. The whole issue I see with these articles is that they view the Web mainly from the content producer side. However, the majority of Web use is consuming content. And also the problem of the few walled gardens is on the consuming side. Everybody can nowadays put content on the Web with ease outside of these gardens. It is just hard to get attention for that content. So if you really want to make the Web more distributed again, you need to come up with models for distributed relevance assessment, spam filtering, quality checking, etc. Work on a new 'Web infrastructure' totally misses the point. (context: I have worked in P2P research for a while)
- spiralpolitik 9y agoIt's doubly ironic to see such an article from a VP of a large publisher that recently shuttered its own digital bookstore that sold unencumbered PDF copies and moved it's own content into walled gardens of concentrated content.
- extra88 9y agoThey still operate their subscription service, Safari Books Online. Other digital sellers, like Amazon Kindle, can and do sell books without DRM, if the publisher wishes it. The only thing lost seems to be per-book purchases in PDF, instead of EPUB or Kindle's format. Doesn't seem like much of a loss, an EPUB can be converted to PDF anyway.
- matthewaveryusa 9y agoI attribute the issues the web is having today with one simple fact: We never democratized home servers. If routers came out with home-server capabilities that were standardized for data transfers we would not be here today. Simple as that. Is that to say that adoption of home-servers is impossible because users would have never adopted them? That's a non-technical issue I frankly have no idea what the answer is. I'd like to think that if people of all walks are capable of plugging in a wifi router and logging in/signing up to social media websites, they would also be capable of managing their home server (as long as the UI was nice enough.) but I have no way of knowing if that's true or not.
- icebraining 9y agoMost people I know never plugged in their wifi router, the ISP tech did that for them.
- supermdguy 9y ago> You can't become a web developer by viewing Facebook's source; but you might by looking at a new site that isn't weighed down by all that CSS and JavaScript. I agree that web bloat is a problem, but why is it the responsibility of web developers to teach users of their site how to code? Is there any other area of software development where that's the case? Even major FOSS projects aren't designed to easily enable new developers to "copy the code they want".
- rafaelvasco 9y agoIt all breaks down to the problem: Everything today runs on Money , Power and Control, instead of Collaboration and Sharing. We we'll get there eventually. The world like it's running today is not sustentable and will collapse. Just a matter of time.
- PuffinBlue 9y agoThey could start the ball rolling by adding an RSS feed to their own website.
- icebraining 9y agohttp://feeds.feedburner.com/oreilly/radar/atom http://feeds.feedburner.com/oreilly/radar/atom
- arippberger 9y agoPiperNet
- lucasnichele 9y agothere is nothing new under the sun. We must pay more attention to new and validated technologies, like blockchain.
- LukeB42 9y agoEntities that aren't media corporations tend to suck at holding a crowds' attention relative to media corporations. You can't <airquotes> fix </airquotes> that by "rebuilding the web".
- eksemplar 9y agoI find these articles a little ironic. I absolutely agree with the message, but they are always published in walled gardens themselves. Maybe that’s how you get reader counts and views but there is is really nothing that stops anyone from building their own. It’s easier to use Wordpress than building your own, even easier to write a blog entry for O’Reilly.com but if your message is a decentralized network of enthusiasts, then maybe you should publish on your own platform, you know, to be the change you want.
- klez 9y agoUh? In this case I'd say it's published in the correct place. The guy works for O'Reilly, the post is about his work, it's published on O'Reilly's website. I would have agreed with you if it was published on Medium or Blogger or whatever.
- mbaha 9y ago“Any city gets what it admires, will pay for, and, ultimately, deserves,” the New York Times editorialized in October 1963, as demolition of the old Penn Station began. I suggest a corollary: "Any web community gets what it admires (fancy UX and feeds that work like magic), will pay for (=nothing), and, ultimately, deserves."
- blunte 9y agoOne big problem is search. Search determines what we see (outside of what we learn of from our peers or primary sources of info). A "cacophony of different sites and voices" may be more fair, but it isn't very useful. Most people shouldn't have a public voice, because most people don't have anything valuable (or accurate) to say. This includes me, of course, on many subjects. But here on HN, if many people think that my comments are garbage, they vote me down and at least new readers will be somewhat forewarned that my content may be of questionable value. Search was first supposed to help us find things. But when there were too many things to find, it should have helped us identify the good stuff. Instead, search is now 90% bogus results that are generated to help steer people to a particular product or service. So honestly, some walled gardens where people reasonably knowledgeable about the local subject can affect the visibility of the content within the silo, at least visitors less able to discern good from bad will probably see more good than bad. Of course, sites need money to operate, so then comes the corruption of the system. Even sites that try to be neutral still end up making some concessions in order to get funded by some source (and the corporations or political groups have the money, so they end up with influence).
- fragmede 9y agoWho's played with Glitch.com already? The author of the linked article credits Anil Dash's plan to reintroduce the building blocks of the web as having a greater chance of success, and one of those building blocks is glitch.com. Playing with Glitch.com, it's possible to see a way forwards that isn't just iterating a better UI on top of an RSS reader. It's still lines of code as opposed to trying to push some GUI-based programming language, but does very well to promote the idea of building blocks for the web. If most of us are basically plumbers but for data on the Internet, glitch.com is the consumer hardware store where they sell all the various fun pipe connectors that you'd use for building an epic ball machine as a kid. (Github.com would be is the store with a catalog that has table after table of parts in every possible variation.)
- EGreg 9y agoWe did it. Started in 2011, and it took us 7 years, and over $500K invested from our revenues but we did it. Shameless plug for our solution: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=pZ1O_gmPneI https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=pZ1O_gmPneI It’s FOSS so download and use it just like Wordpress. Feel free to email me at greg (qbix.com) if you want any help getting started and I will either personally help you or connect you with one of our developers on the team. Tim Berners-Lee is leading another project called Solid, that started about 3 years ago. We are a bit ahead because we started much earlier.
- cromwellian 9y agoEverything gets centralized when there are economies are scale, technology stack fixes can’t change that. Look at the ultimate “decentralized” technology, blockchain. The majority of mining power is now centralized in vast centralized farms with custom hardware and cheap access to power and half the Bitcoin is held by about 1000 people.
- tomcooks 9y agoIt's almost as if someone's feeling bad for having given up their own indipendent e-store to favour a certain DRM ridden publisher.
- bluetwo 9y agoIf the value network of a market evolves different than the way it was "supposed to be", the problem is with your assumptions, not the technology. You're not going to fix the problem by changing the technology.
- intrasight 9y agoI'm predicting a bleak, dystopian future which will make our current imperfect web look like a golden age of tech.
- tzs 9y agoThere's an amusing parallel between housing in major tech cities and the net. In both cases you've got the people who were there earlier and want the character of the place to remain mostly small entities like it was when they got there, and the people who came later and want to change the place to be dominated by large entities that will change most of the place's character. It's amusing because the tech crowd are opposing the NIMBY people in meatspace but are the NIMBY people in cyberspace.
- lxe 9y agoSo the technologies such as blockchain are too complicated and require significant UX work, yet “view source“ and copying and pasting HTML code is somehow a better user experience?
- kilo_bravo_3 9y ago>We'd also need to avoid many of the privacy and security flaws that were rampant in the early internet, and for which we're still paying. How many third (and first!) party trackers would you guess were blocked by my privacy and security flaws-preventing browser plugin when I clicked on the link to read the story? I'm sure they "add value" to my experience and I am missing out on all of the incredible opportunities that they present, but that's a chance that I'm willing to take. That website even (attempts to) logs when and where you click and what text you highlight, and then tries to send that info off to a third party. The Vice President of Content Strategy for ORM, Inc. seems to be advocating against content strategies he has implemented. Is "society made us do it" still a thing?
- guilamu 9y ago"That project is only likely to succeed if the rebuilt web is compatible with what we have today, including Facebook" Yeah the ONLY way forward is to get everything compatible with FB. Sure.
- Trillinon 9y agoI've always felt that Google Reader held RSS back by not supporting feed authentication. It was the defacto reader when RSS was growing, so what it supported defined what was possible with RSS. Feed authentication would allow for a variety of potential services business models. - Paywalls: Whether subscribing to a newspaper to supporting a blog through Patreon, it lets user directly pay for content provided through RSS. - Customized curation services: Whether manually curated by an editor, or using algorithms, you could build a business around providing content to individual users. - Social network integration: Instead of joining one or two massive Social networks, I could be involved in dozens of small, focused ones, all collected in a single RSS reader. I'm sure there are plenty of other possibilities. But for it to be useful, it has to be available and easy to use in all the major RSS platforms.
- jonathanlloyd 9y agoWhilst I take the point that the web has become too centralized (and that the path away from this is in part a UX problem) this piece ignores the fact that having a service provider manage your software/infrastructure is always going to have more leverage to provide a better user experience. This is what makes the focus on P2P technologies so disappointing. You lose the leverage of the service provider along with the well understood financial incentives for providing a good service. This is why I am much more excited about federated technologies rather than P2P - the problem isn't that I need a provider to help me share my content, the problem is that if I want to publish content as a social media user that Facebook is the only game in town!
- tokyo_fame 9y agoI'm curious whether such behavior of the web follows some formal law. Is there a relevant proposition in graph theory, Ramsay theory may be? Is the probability of decentralization bounded by system's complexity?