14 ms·
China Is Nationalizing Its Tech Sector
- TheRealmccoy 9y agoProvide incentives and support to local companies to become multi-unicorns (BATs etc). These companies start investing in other leading startups, scross the globe and have substantial stakes in them. Then, nationalise these companies and you have then indirect control/semi-control/access over vast majority of leading startups across the globe. This seems to be a nice move by Chinese government.
- jorblumesea 9y agoBut, where does the next wave of innovation come from? More startups? Just seems like China's steal/nationalize everything doesn't create true innovation centers.
- adrianN 9y agoChina has a billion people and produces vast and rapidly growing numbers of highly skilled academics, both in their local universities and by sending students abroad. Many of the smartest people I know are Chinese and have returned to China after completing their degrees and collecting experience in western companies.
- chillacy 9y agoI don’t want to take a side but the parent is almost certainly going to point out that academic papers != innovation (especially with the news that lots of papers from China have falsified data, paper mills, etc). What are actual innovations made by China in the past 20 years? On demand bikes comes to mind as one example.
- dogruck 9y agoCould someone please list the top 10 technological innovations that originated in China?
- unmole 9y agoHow about top four? Paper, printing, gunpowder and compass.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- purple-again 9y agoI downvoted the parent comment but your response is also disengenuous. Unless I’m allowed to claim credit for Rome’s victories the ‘China’ that invented those things shares nothing with the China being discussed right now.
- manjushri 9y ago>shares nothing with the China being discussed right now. Seems like apples to oranges, assuming the implied comparison is with western post-industrial age nations, which began industrializing centuries ago, as compared to decades ago with China.
- pishpash 9y agoThey share the familial authoritarianism that is the explicit governing model for every version of "China".
- dogruck 9y agoI down-voted your answer because those are only 4 ancient, general technologies. I’m sure the list is much longer than 10, that’s why I asked for the top 10. I’m talking about IP from the last, say, 20 years.
- dogruck 9y agoWhy was I down-voted? It was a sincere question. Did I strike some nerve?
- dalbasal 9y agoThe "trade war" thing has been the most/only interesting ideas to come from trump, to me. It was interesting in that he did recognized (fluked into?) an actual shift in public/expert position. China is the pro-trade side. They'll be willing to make concessions, do the work, etc. It's the beijing consensus now, not washington. Large american companies are still on the pro-trade side, being multinationals. They also have pretty obvious interests. They want market access, american IP protection, they want freedom to operate mostly independently of the CCP. Market access is a typical request. This has been the basic definition of free trade for a while. They probably can get this protection. Independance is a trickier one. I'm not sure it's realistic. Imagine a Chinese company operating in the states, with an a fully imported senior management and all "c-level" discussions in chinese. I dunno. I doubt they'll get what they say they want. The "IP" point is interesting. Why does the american economy want US IP rules everywhere so bad? Same reason Disney does. They have the biggest IP portfolio. A pharmaceutical company's value (for example) is mostly IP. IE, the market cap is the IP portfolio. Why would china want to use this IP system, where they start with fewer chips than the US? I'm not sure. Who says a fake Gucci is a crime, if the buyer knows it's fake. Why should a US drug patent grant a worldwide monopoly. This one would be a concession. Anyway, it's not just pharmaceuticals that need IP. The economy is ethereal these days. Capital isn't building and machines. It's intellectual property of one sort or another, whether or not it's legally formalized as such. .. PS: I'm Irish, not American. Realize from the wild votes in both directions (didn't think) that I've obviously waded into live american politics. I wasn't trying to make any political points. Just musing and bullshitting on the shifting world of political interests after reading the morning paper. I'm not against anyone, nor do I mean anything too seriously.
- diego_moita 9y agoTrump might be fighting for a good cause, but he is doing it in the most stupid way. The road to hell is paved ... Case in point: the original TPP had plenty of protection for American IP. The orange demagogue ditched the treaty, all the other countries removed those protections and now he wants to come back. The pattern of stupidity is pretty obvious: the US needs international allies to prevail against China, but it won't get any ally with an "America first always" policy.
- myth_buster 9y agoThe tech sector in the west can breath a sigh of relief. It's no surprise the power grabbing politicians would want to control the booming tech sector. But I naively thought that their affair with quasi-capitalism would run longer. We have been here before and know how nationalization affects innovation. Being a leader of a communist nation gives you perhaps more opportunity to run these kinds of massive experiments while thinking this time things will be different. Capitalistic (Darwinian) society wouldn't be as forgiving. /rant
- thisisit 9y ago> Tencent Holdings Ltd., with nearly 1 billion users, reported that its net income almost doubled in the last quarter, to $3.3 billion. Alibaba Group Holding Ltd., which dominates online retail, is expecting growth of 55 percent this year. Investors may worry about Chinese debt, but they're giddy about Chinese tech. Anyone knows the SEC equivalent site for pulling revenue numbers for Chinese companies? If possible, direct links for Tencent and Alibaba will be even more helpful. The reason I am asking is Alibaba has been investigated for their creative accounting: https://www.thestreet.com/story/14277425/1/alibaba-still-cooperating-with-sec-probe-as-it-forecasts-45-to-49-sales-growth.html https://www.thestreet.com/story/14277425/1/alibaba-still-coo... And, I recently watched "The China Hustle" documentary. Discussed here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16726355 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16726355 One of the highlights in the documentary was the financial reporting. There was a huge gap between revenues western Media and US markets was seeing vs what was being reported in China. The whole idea being accessing financial data for Chinese companies was hard.
- jk2323 9y ago> Tencent Holdings Ltd., with nearly 1 billion users Sounds reasonable. I would start wondering if they claim 20 Billion users, but hey, you never now. Alibaba is also an outstanding company: http://brontecapital.blogspot.de/2015/10/alibaba-yeah-right-jack.html http://brontecapital.blogspot.de/2015/10/alibaba-yeah-right-... http://brontecapital.blogspot.de/2015/09/job-interview-questions-size-and-scope.html http://brontecapital.blogspot.de/2015/09/job-interview-quest...
- justicezyx 9y agoWell taobao pretty much is the majority of buying for many people. The blog posts are roughly as baseless as what it claims Jack Ma is.
- jk2323 9y ago44% of income? Wow. I think total online sales in the US are something like 7%
- andrewclunn 9y agoAnd thus the brain drain from China will commence at full speed (more than present). Seems government regulators in China don't understand market forces either. Good to know.
- AmericanChopper 9y agoCentral planning has always proven to be an inefficient way to allocate resources, so I’m not sure why free markets would be worried about China implementing more central planning.
- dd36 9y ago*Regulated free markets. Unregulated free markets could prove to be at a disadvantage. We shouldn’t be engaged in free trade with China. Countries or robber barons of those countries shouldn’t be allowed to destroy their environment to have a cheaper price.
- hn0 9y agoThe age old liberal hymn. I’m not going to say this is wrong, but it’s a very black and white stance in the matter. Plenty of succesful economies have been centrally planned and/or protectionist. Likewise speculative booms in unregulated markets have produced massive amounts of deadweight loss. Not to mention the administrative overheads of running large scale free(ish) markets we observe in all first world countries, it makes the USSR look lean and mean by comparison. This is not to excuse the flagrant absurdities seen in state-capitalist economies all troughout the 20th century. The best model of central planning appears to be government guided bank credit allocation as seen in postwar Japan and the Asian Tigers, this lets entrepreneurs handle the micromanaging aspects whilst the state can avoid boom-bust cycles typically associated with private finance.
- Fins 9y agoSeems pretty obvious that you have neither ever lived in USSR nor experienced the Soviet economics first-hand. Although I would like to see a sample of a single lean and mean organization in USSR...
- abhiminator 9y agoIt's interesting to observe how China has managed to fuse together, almost seamlessly, the major functional modules of it's government -- Communist Party committees, for example -- with the tech sector. As other commentators in various publications have pointed out, this deep integration coupled with massive investments in auxiliary sectors, a culture of scientific inquiry and a heavily STEM focused primary education[0] will only keep the scale of the momentum tipped in China's favor going forward. [0] https://www.theglobeandmail.com/news/national/education/what-shanghai-can-teach-us-about-teaching-math/article17835021/ https://www.theglobeandmail.com/news/national/education/what...
- rayiner 9y agoSeems like premature celebration. The Soviet Union was incredibly successful (turning a backwater into a superpower in a few decades) until it wasn’t.
- petre 9y agoCorruption and incompetence eventually takes over. The Brezhnev era is sort of illustrative.
- hn0 9y agoThe biggest plusses of representational democracies imo, open opposition and replacement of the leadership every few years.
- diego_moita 9y agoThe first catastrophic failure of the Soviet Union was agriculture. When the West was beginning Borlaug's Green Revolution they were deep into Stalin's great famine, the Holodomor. Their inability to put bread on tables is at the root of their collapse. Most tragedies in China's recent history also have their cause on failure to produce food. I wonder how China is prepared to handle the impact Global Warming will have on agriculture.
- 9y ago
- phyalow 9y agoA picture is worth a thousand words. The sculpture outside the front of Tencents Shenzhen HQ. https://pbs.twimg.com/media/DXRIsWrVQAAJgjl.jpg https://pbs.twimg.com/media/DXRIsWrVQAAJgjl.jpg
- tanilama 9y agoLOL...
- mlvljr 9y agoHaha
- ataturk 9y agoTechnology is the boot on the human face forever.
- onetimemanytime 9y agoGo ahead and not put that sign in there. See how long you last. Also, it's possible that they believe it, say, "China needs this to be a strong country" even if some freedoms are sacrificed. A necessary evil for a while. As for nationalizing: they are in a sense nationalized. You must x, y and z or you're done. The Party is judge, jury and the executioner.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jarsin 9y agoThis is the company that seems to be investing in just about everything now days. Scary!
- alehul 9y agoAs someone with parents who experienced the USSR, this is what really terrifies me about China's rise, and the reason I can't say I'm against a trade war if it hinders them more than us. Imagine a world in which China holds more control... a country with little legal or social respect for individualism, where your fate is 'centrally planned' by how impressive your maths skills are. By contrast, ~30% of American billionaires are dropouts. We highly value ambition in the U.S., and we attract (and reward) people who have it; those people, upon coming here, largely have the freedom to create and build and be in charge of their own future. It just seems like the U.S. will self-select for the ambitious and the inspired and those who desire freedom, and it would be immensely worrying if this model we have appears wrong.
- state_less 9y agoIf you tend toward optimal decisions, having your mind made up for you seems like it could be a real drag.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- ihsw2 9y agoIt seems tech companies in the US could definitely benefit from increased oversight on operations and stronger compliance with privacy laws, not only that but the establishment of integration with state-owned firms could boost domestic consumption of tech services that don't revolve around ad and social media consumption.
- tobltobs 9y agoWhat state-owned firms do you mean with: "... but the establishment of integration with state-owned firms". Amtrak, USPS, National Parks or one of the Federal Loan Banks?
- ajeet_dhaliwal 9y agoHow would they benefit?
- baybal2 9y agoComparison Baidu - Google Baidu is horrid, even in Chinese. Baidu doesn't have nearly as big stronghold on advertising in Chinese market as Google has in every market outside of China. End of discussion. Alibaba - Amazon On commercial side, Alibaba steamrolls Amazon with some margin remaining. Tech-wise, Alibaba sucks big time. Their search algo is something horrid. Alibaba has a relatively big part of Internet ads pie in comparison to Amazon. They need more competent tech people, or better to say let more competent people to lead, and less talking big. I personally knew the person who nearly single-handedly created half of all business Alibaba group has outside of China, yet he did quit the company because he was denied promotion and never given recognition for his efforts. Moreover, his superiors were intentionally keeping quiet of his existence and appropriating credit for his work. Tencent - Facebook Company-wise Tencent is way better on focus and management quality. People there are very well conscious what the company needs and for what. They don't have much random RnD initiatives or "see what sticks to the wall" internal startups. Their money cow are their horrid mobile games, and WeChat wallet. While they are unquestionably a social network company, they are almost invisible as such. WeChat team prides themselves on their "Zero popups" experience. Their idea is plain - solidly done, undisturbed by ads social side of the ecosystem must be kept as such so that users will have less impediment to use value added services from the commercial side of the ecosystem when they want to. This is what FB can't do.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- petra 9y agoAmazon vs Alibaba - to simplify, this game will be won by the best supply chain, And sure Amazon leads by far. But what happens when the "one belt one road" railroad is finished ? Will Alibaba get a preferential treatment ? And if so, could Amazon handle that ?
- adinobro 9y agoHave you tried Amazon outside of the USA? It sucks. In the UK I've been told it is ok. In Australia, Thailand and China it is not a great experience. In China Tmall is an amazing experience. In their home markets they both seem to be entrenched but globally I'm not sure if either will win.
- reeedom 9y agoActually this is not even close to nationalization. The article's title is misleading even by the standard's of the article, which goes on to call it, "quasi-nationalization". But even that is misreading the situation. The objective is not "control" of the tech sector as the article pretends, it is just greater collaboration. So the state and tech companies can both benefit. The state doesn't want the burden of taking control. Plus they don't want to interfere and slow things down. They want to learn from tech to better their own ogranizations and also to teach tech how they can benefit from working with the state more closely. It's about greater integration, not control. And since China is so successful at organizing and governing more than 1 billion people already, the more they work with cutting edge tech, the better things will get. You can say they are making a police state, but at least they can maintain law and order, and are willing to keep thinking long-term and keep innovating even in government. The government wants to support its nation's tech companies. If Chinese tech companies can become the best / most valuable in the world, it will be more advancement toward the great rejuvenation of the Chinese people that China is pursuing. In the drive to find any negative spin to put on Chinese progress, commentators frequently miss important points, and mischaracterize / misread significant developments. Finding fault is easier, and perhaps more satisfying for someone who is really desperate to feel good about themselves without other reasons to, but seeing what's really going on is more useful.
- paganel 9y agoFor what it’s worth you can “maintain law and order” without having to have a dictatorial state in place. Not living under a dictatorship also comes with the added benefit of being free to read and speak whatever you want to, which I (and other people like me) regard as a fundamental human right.
- dunpeal 9y agoYou claim: > The objective is not "control" of the tech sector as the article pretends, it is just greater collaboration. From the article: > This quasi-nationalization applies to China's startup scene, too. One recent report found that 60 percent of Chinese unicorns have either direct or indirect investment from the BATs. China's venture-capital sector is dominated not by traditional tech dealmakers but by the state: There are more than 1,000 government-owned VC firms in China, controlling more than $750 billion. So the Chinese government buys stakes in most Chinese startups, through its wholly-owned VCs and other vehicles. These stakes give the Chinese government control over these startups. You further claim: > You can say they are making a police state, but at least they can maintain law and order, and are willing to keep thinking long-term and keep innovating even in government. Which frankly sounds like PRC propaganda.
- motohagiography 9y agoWould a more accurate description be that China is "militarizing," its tech sector instead of "nationalizing" it? When we think of nationalization, we tend to think of centralized control by committee, removal of competition, five year plans etc. But militarization of an economy, like that of Britain during WWII, means working toward and pricing based on a shared (if mandated) national objective. Western aviation is largely militarized in this sense, and looking at communications tech in China the way we look at aviation here is probably a better simile. There is a tendency to portray the Chinese communist party as a farce of clumsy peasants toeing the party line and driving their economy into ruin, as though they were the bolsheviks or Stalin's apparatchiks. Those tropes do a disservice to those of us who really do need to be aware of the sophistication and hyper-aggression of Chinese economic warfare. Viewing China as an "emerging," economy and society presumes the end state will evolve to something resembling western democracy and a free market economy, which is the very hubris they are exploiting to consolidate and militarize their industries and territories for global expansion. It would be helpful to everyone to elevate the quality of discussion of these topics, as CFIUS will only protect us so much.
- sah2ed 9y agoYou make an excellent point about nationalization being an inaccurate metaphor. China sees it tech industry as a strategic asset the way the US and Russia see their defence industries as strategic towards advancing their goals as super/regional powers, so in a sense, militarization is probably a better metaphor.
- bdavisx 9y agoWell that's good for everyone else competing with China. It will slow innovation. Imagine if you had to worry about doing something that pissed off someone on your companies "Communist Committee" (or whatever the article called them). Yes, in general a company in China has to be careful how it treads with respect to the national communist party, but now they'll have to worry about the lower level people that are inside their company. And those "party" people will have ambitions, and when the company does good, they will do good. BUT, those (at least some of those) same party people will be risk averse, probably a lot more risk averse than a typical tech innovator. Think about politicians here in the US and how long it takes them to embrace things that are already popular with the general public (marijuana legalization for example). That's what these companies will be up against, and it will slow them down.
- perpetualcrayon 9y agoSome threads are discussing Chinese companies, at C-level, doing business in Chinese language in US. I'm curious to know opinions folks around the world have about the likelihood that Chinese language will somehow become an important international language? In my (perhaps biased) mind it appears the world is already well on its way to adopting English as THE international language.
- seanmcdirmid 9y agoChinese is much more important in the rest of Asian than it was 10 years ago because of tourism. English is still the best language to get a long with internationally, but things could change. But I don't think Chinese will become a significant business language for the rest of the world since they, like Japanese companies were found to be, are mostly insular. Not a lot of foreigners work in Chinese companies, Chinese companies don't have a lot of international exposure, China doesn't allow for much (if any) non-Chinese immigration. The reason English became dominant is that America (and before that the UK) is much more globalized.
- adrianN 9y agoI think it's very unlikely that (today's) Chinese will become a dominant language because it's too hard to learn. The writing system is just awful. Maybe if they manage to adobt Pinyin or something similar as the official way to write Chinese it has a chance. But until then I doubt that many foreigners will start learning it.
- chillacy 9y agoI’d just like to point out that no Lingua Franca has lasted forever. It was French before English, till post WW2. Also this doesn’t matter as much, but, English is one of the more difficult languages (compared to Spanish say) due to all of its spelling inconsistencies and large phonetic possibilities. I don’t know if a tonal, character based language will be any easier though. I say it doesn’t matter because it doesn’t seem to be the difficulty of learning the language that matters, only the strength of the language in terms of economic opportunities.
- watertom 9y agoAll tech companies need to re-think manufacturing in China, it was always a risky proposition, but not, you'll really be handing your IP over to the Chinese Government, and they'll be collecting IP from every company. It's time for tech manufacturing to move.
- pm90 9y agoWhere will it move to? Tech manufacturing is till pretty labor intensive, at least for the consumer electronics that I believe we are talking about. India probably has better IP laws on paper, but they're hardly ever enforced. The only real alternative seems to be that we reach such a level of automation that these factories can be viable in the West. Still, China's integration into the supply chain of global manufacturing is breathtaking. Not saying it can't be done, but it would take some amount of determination, deliberation and a lot of Capital and skilled labor force.
- Shivetya 9y agoAfrica, even China has been moving that way.
- justicezyx 9y agoLook who's already there 2 decades ago and enjoying more influence than anyone else...
- pm90 9y agoAre you saying that African nations have laws that protect American IP? I think you're sorely mistaken. China has been moving to Africa mostly for influence building and securing supplies of raw materials. It is a brilliant strategy, and I would argue that as long and they're helping improve the quality of life, an overall good thing. China is NOT opening up high-tech manufacturing plants in Africa. In fact most of the infrastructure in Africa is sourced from Chinese Companies (e.g. railway coaches)
- kchoudhu 9y agoCome to South Asia -- Bangladesh, India, Pakistan. Weak institutions and governments concerned solely with infighting mean that your IP is probably safe from marauding governments. All your clothes are already made there, why not your electronics?
- wei2012 9y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RbM2F-cfN0A https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RbM2F-cfN0A
- wei2012 9y agoChina Everyday Everywhere Everything... Thanks Trump
- Jerry64545 9y agoDoes it covers software companies ? Does this mean a software engineer will be an government employee ?
- neves 9y agoThe greatest problem of the article critiques is that China economical politic is working. They aren't just the almost slave workers now, there are tech and innovation.
- contingencies 9y agoPublic private partnerships are quite de-rigeur in the west, what's so special about China that the same is somehow not-so-subtly construed as a demonic plan to debase capitalism and instill the vicious vector of bogeyman communism in a Chinese community near you? Frankly IMHO the media on China coming out of the US - Bloomberg, NYT and Washington Post especially - reeks of xenophobia and tabloid hype. America's journalists may do well to visit the museums of Chinese in LA and New York, as I did, and take a long deep look at the China side of their country's nasty and continuous history of whipping up anti-foreign sentiment at all levels of government and society then conveniently sweeping racism under the rug. Disgusting.