18 ms·
Duolingo Suddenly Has Over Twice as Much Language Learning Material
- kwaldman 9y agoThe new version is very good for Chinese. It is giving me much more complex sentence structure.
- _betty_ 9y agoI'm just annoyed it forces you to learn the writing system.
- CrystalLangUser 9y agoRight, when I’m learning mathematics I hate how they force you to learn math notation. Learning a romanized version of a language is not learning a language. Sounds in one language don’t map neatly to English sounds, and beginner language learners who use romanization always have pronunciation issues because their headspace isn’t in the language, it’s in a romanized variant of that language. What’s the point of learning Chinese or any other script language if you don’t learn the script?
- Mediterraneo10 9y ago> What’s the point of learning Chinese or any other script language if you don’t learn the script? I once learned Chinese in a very intensive course that focused on the spoken language and only taught a few hundred characters. It has proven very useful for my occasional travels in China, being able to interact with hotels etc., having nice enjoyable conversations with my drivers when hitchhiking, etc. For me, my present skills are enough for what I want to get out of the country; for me, China is just one country among many. The few characters I know are enough of a bare minimum to find my way around. If I were keen on reading Chinese literature, then I would definitely go further with characters, but there is value for many people in having simply a minimum command of the language.
- xenihn 9y agoWhat was the course?
- chillacy 9y agoYou should look at Pimsleur if you just want to be conversational in Mandarin. But regarding the writing system, that's where the interesting stuff is IMO, it's a system where words are linked to more to meaning than sound (unlike most other writen languages), which meant it could be used as the writing system for many various regions all around what is now modern China, Korea, Vietnam, and Japan.
- thunderplot 9y agoHow it's possible to learn a foreign language without learning its writing system?
- skosch 9y agoLearning characters has enabled me to watch movies, because subtitles are often easier to follow (and look up) than mumbled, fast, dialect-tinged dialogue. And the ability to watch movies is a game changer for language learning. Note that recognizing characters is much easier than being able to write them correctly from memory (and you really don't need the latter – even Chinese can't write anymore; look up "character amnesia").
- btcindivist 9y agoI still find their spaced repetition lacking. I never see some of the words again after seeing them for the first time.
- cletus 9y agoMy observation from using Duolingo (Spanish) was similar to this. My theory was that there spaced repetition was simply based topic and then once a topic was chosen it then decided what words to test you on. This is crude, simplistic and ineffective (IMHO). Like you say, there are words you see rarely. Also, certain topics end up reinforcing earlier topics. I lost count of the number of times that the stupid "algorithm" would make me go through the exercise of translating "no, nada". At some point, don't I just know this? Additionally, when you have topics that aren't "gold", it simply selects the first non-gold one to repeat. This can mean that a bunch of stuff at the bottom of the tree gets rusty because you don't get to it while you end up redoing stuff you know backwards. I made this observation in the forums but couldn't really get any traction on the issue. At some point they also introduced the stupid heart system, which was pretty much my trigger for just abandoning the whole thing. Also, I'm really not sure how much this format actually works. Like having completed the Spanish tree, I'm honestly not sure if I really remember anything more than a small fraction of it.
- btilly 9y agoWorse yet is that there is a world of difference between being able to recognize a word when primed, and being able to recognize it when not primed. When it decided that I need refreshing on a phrase I probably got flashcards corresponding to translate this English phrase into Russian, translate the Russian phrase into English (from a set of pre-chosen words), type this Russian phrase in Russian, and maybe type the English version of this Russian phrase and/or type the Russian version of this English phrase. All with the same phrase. Lumped with many other variations of the exercise on the same topic. Introducing them all together is helpful. However after some level of proficiency I would like to receive them separately. In a group with unrelated exercises. On a schedule indicating how well I know that phrase. That said, they have been a painless way to gain a basic foundation.
- rando444 9y ago
- zealsham 9y agoDuolingo still lacks a structural syllabus
- 2bitencryption 9y agohas anyone had success with any of these language-learning apps, even as supplemental material to a more traditional education? I've tried to use Duolingo for Japanese, with very little success on its own. Paired with my own studying, it was only a bit more helpful, but not more helpful than flashcards. Another app, LingoDeer, was better, because it had a curriculum and more unified lessons, and I could swap between Kanji/Katakana/Hiragana at will to learn one at a time. (Whereas DuoLingo will bring you to 15% understanding of Hiragana before dumping you into Katakana).
- tdumitrescu 9y agoNot apps, but I've had good results with the old Teach Yourself... book+audio series as well as the Pimsleur audio series. Tried Duolingo for a while and it felt more like a vocabulary course than a language course. Not useless, but it didn't improve my language skills.
- symmitchry 9y agoAbsolutely. I did Duolingo Spanish (although I a) was fluent-ish in French, and b) had taken a Spanish course at University.) I can say without a doubt that I learned a ton (via Duolingo) and a trip to Cuba made it very obvious. I am far from fluent, but I could get by in nearly all situations. I'm learning Swedish now, and it's getting to the point where new languages are easier and easier to pick up. My partner is further than me, and knows a shocking amount of Swedish just from the Duolingo app.
- SwellJoe 9y agoI find it fun (enough) and quick enough to use daily to keep my mind thinking in Spanish now and then, but I agree it isn't very effective at allowing me to speak it. I draw a blank whenever trying to converse in Spanish. But, I do find I can read quite a bit more Spanish after a year or so of using Duolingo mostly daily. I only use it for about 10 minutes a day, so I don't expect miracles. I find the "you are 53% fluent in Spanish" notifications laughable, though. I'm maybe 10% fluent, on a good day, when listening, and about 20% when reading. Though assigning a percentage to fluency is a bit weird anyway. So...yeah, I think you kinda get out what you put into learning a language, and Duolingo is way closer to putting in "nothing" than it is to putting in "something". One shouldn't expect to get much out, if you're just doing little memory quizzes a couple times a day. But, I can do it without needing a lot of free time, and maybe it'll help some day when I am able to spend a few months in Mexico, so I can immerse myself in the language, to really learn it.
- jonbarker 9y agoI think Duolingo is good for getting you past complete beginner but to go deeper I recommend Anki.
- reiichiroh 9y agoWhy Anki?
- CrystalLangUser 9y agoThe short version is that Anki’s spaced repetition is very good for retaining and learning vocabulary. My background is that I’ve used it while studying Korean. I’m at about 2,000 korean words now, of which Anki has helped me a lot. Each day I review 50 words and add 20 new ones. It sucks but it works. As you see new words in reading material, etc, you can add it to Anki. That’s supposed to be how it’s done, but there are premade decks also. The real beauty lies in anki’s customization. You can add pictures or custom fields and style them. You can reverse the deck so you’re seeing one side or the other when reviewing. Anki is NOT helpful with a word’s context if you don’t know it or don’t add sample sentences. Which is why people recommend building your own deck over time by reading short stories or news, etc, and adding every word you don’t know, rather than using a premade 5k word deck. If you have any other questions feel free to ask.
- jonbarker 9y agoFunny coincidence, I am also studying Korean and think the searchable repository of pre-built decks is a great feature. I also enjoy that the spaced repetition algorithm seems to make it exactly as difficult as it should be without becoming frustrating. Would be interested in Anki decks for studying programming languages.
- komali2 9y agoIf anybody interested specifically in Japanese Anki tips, see a previous discussion on this: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16748008 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16748008
- 9y ago
- GavinMcG 9y ago[Meta] So far in this thread, there are several comments that could be the grounds for substantive discussion, but don't bother offering the substance. For example: Why does jonbarker recommend Anki for going deeper than "complete beginner"? What does zealsham mean by Duolingo lacking a "structural syllabus" and why is that problematic? The conversations can be a very valuable part of HN, but not if most comments are at the level of "I still find their spaced repetition lacking" with only the tiniest bit of elaboration. Hopefully I'm not out of place in encouraging something more substantive.
- krelian 9y agoStandard for HN is it no? Easy criticism and nitpicking without any substantial real-world solutions.
- brotoss 9y agoWelcome Redditors!
- skybrian 9y agoIf you're interested in learning more about something someone said, maybe you could reply to them with a question? People often respond well to a bit of encouragement, and replies are more likely to be seen than a meta-comment.
- komali2 9y agoNo doubt - we're not here to write counter-blogs, just to discuss.
- GavinMcG 9y agoOf course, and to the extent that I want answers to those specific questions I'm happy to ask. Asking individual questions, though, doesn't encourage a different mindset in the way that I hope my meta-comment will.
- craftyguy 9y agoInstead of making a "meta" post complaining, you could reply to those folks with your questions. That might help develop the discussions you would like to see more so than this tactic.
- googlemike 9y agoI have only used Duolingo for languages I am fluent in. There is a mode somewhere where you can take a set of exams to see where you place on the fluency spectrum in any given language they offer. I do this for pure curiosity to see how far I get up on their "track". I find it to be a super shallow and lacking system - the words encountered have little to do in the way of everyday conversation, things you see on TV, the grocery store, or even most professional settings. I don't have too many examples off the top of my head, but one that really kept coming up in the French test was "the little spider is red" - When does someone need this? Whys is this any mark of proficiency? I always leave feeling as though this app/product is a giant waste of time.
- lambda 9y agoHmm. Those all seem like fairly basic words to know; OK, maybe "spider" isn't as common a word to need, but it is something that comes up in conversation sometimes. That particular phrase isn't one you're going to have to say very often, but I'd say it would be pretty hard to say you're fluent in a language if you don't know those words. I've been doing Duolingo for French for the past few months, trying to dust off the couple of semesters of French I took in college and get a bit beyond that to maybe get to the point where I can get by. Yes, there is a bit skewed towards things like family relationships, clothes, the house at the beginning; things that might be important if you're living somewhere but possibly less important if you're just visiting. But they are always adding new content, and as the original article points out they just did a revamp to give access to a lot of newer content they hadn't provided access to before. I don't know; a language generally has a huge amount of vocabulary, as well as grammar to learn, and you need to learn it in some order. The main thing I do find lacking is that it's pretty much all translation or transcription of simple sentences, or word matching. I do find these helpful for learning vocabulary and grammar, but they aren't going to lead to fluency. The article does mention that something that they are working on is longer listening comprehension exercises, which I think would help out with that a lot.
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoIsn't the point of phrases like "the little spider is red" that you can substitute to say many phrases, so you can - vocab willing - then say that 'the big dog is scary' or 'the small pizza is hot' or whatever. You're supposed to be learning a model sentence [definite article][adj][n][v][adj] to enable you to make statements about things in the present tense.
- Sir_Cmpwn 9y agoThe reason Duolingo is ineffective in my opinion is multi-faceted. First, my main language for study is Japanese, and Duolingo's Japanese course is awful - these are the specific things I noticed when trying it: - There were several factual errors in their material and important points entirely omitted - Japanese grammar is very flexible and their tools aren't, so they often mark you as wrong when you were correct - Their approach to learning Kanji (borrowed Chinese characters) is completely ineffective These flaws make me wonder if they even had actual Japanese users working on developing the tools for learning Japanese. I can't speak to any other languages, but my experience with Japanese leads me to belive they don't have expertise in many of the languages they offer, instead trying to cram their prepackaged square-shaped tools into a variety of circle-shaped holes. All languages are different and each requires a different approach. On top of that, however, is that they don't go nearly far enough. In my opinion there's no magic bullet that can teach you a language. Each student learns differently and will need to leverage a large variety of tools. Even if Duolingo's course were good, it would only make up a small facet of an effective study strategy. Vocabulary drilling with flash cards, focused grammatical study, reading genuine material in the language, writing novel material in the target language, and regular conversation practice with native speakers are all incredibly important and distinct topics of study. Duolingo tries to mix a diet version of each into an scatterbrained, ineffectual method of study.
- lambda 9y agoThe Japanese lessons are listed as being in beta. But yeah, I think they're going to have to do a pretty complete revamp of the Japanese course, and possibly add some more features like handwriting recognition for learning the characters. I did a little of that on my own, putting together a flash card deck that I could type in Japanese in, and used Android's Japanese handwriting input method to enter characters, and found that pretty good for learning kana, but I didn't feel like putting all of the work in for building such decks for the kanji I was learning as well. I find Duolingo much better for the lessons that are more well developed, and which the software was originally written for, like French. I think that they could eventually get to the point where the Japanese lessons are useful, but now is not that point; they will need both some software updates that make Japanese learning work better, and a revamp of the curriculum.
- naveen99 9y agoI think google translate is good enough to learn from now. I think duolingo, rosettastone etc. aren’t going to survive long.
- pducks32 9y agoI speak Irish pretty well and Duolingo I think is a fantastic tool to get better and learn some new words that I didn't no. (Neither my dad nor I knew portán meant crab). The issue is that pronunciation in Irish is kinda varied but the lady who does it for Duolingo is on some extreme. The majority of Irish speakers would not pronounce things that way in the slightest and it would be misleading for someone who learned on the app to actually try and speak it as I'm not sure I would understand them
- Y_Y 9y agoThis is a good point. Especially for minority languages like Irish, they can end up being completely dominated in mass-media by a specific group. Duolingo and TG4 (main Irish-language tv channel) mostly speak Gaeilge Cúige Connacht (the western dialect) meaning the northern and southern pronunciation and style are neglected.
- dorchadas 9y agoWhich is funny, as the Caighdeán hardly reflects Connemara Irish at all. It's mostly Munster.
- dorchadas 9y agoThe lady who pronounces things for Duolingo is a native speaker. The issue with Irish is that most learners, including teachers, pronounce it horribly wrong. They're never exposed to native speakers os they just substitute English sounds in. That said, DL's Irish course is useless for anything except a little vocab. There's tons of incorrect answers, or things that only work in certain situations, or direct translations from English nobody would say, or things that are mistranslated, etc etc.
- ocfx 9y agoDuolingo has a lot of nonsense sentences which is rather annoying. Trying to use it for non latin alphabet languages hasn't been a good experience for myself either (almost always a better alternative). I attempted to learn Greek from duolingo and despite it saying that I knew 70 words I only knew 2 or 3 via recall. I started listening to some podcasts(?) called Language Transfer and I've had a much better experience with that so far. It's not an all in one solution, but it has been a far more intuitive approach (at least for Greek). The creator is Greek but has a lot of languages available to learn. I still use duolingo for vocab but I don't think its a great place to learn a language from scratch.
- losvedir 9y agoThe biggest problem I had with Duolingo was knowing what to do next. I much prefer a simple "next lesson" button, which both introduces new material and reviews stuff you've covered previously. But with Duolingo there's a set of available lessons you can choose, and you can either work on going down the list and opening up new lessons, or re-doing ones you've already done and leveling up those particular ones. Then there's also a "barbell" which you can press and takes you into some lesson, but I never quite figured out what it did. But I spent quite a while getting a bunch of "crowns" on the first few lessons (essentially, doing them over and over) before realizing I should be doing some forward progress as well. My wife is a fan of the app and recently paid for premium, but I'm personally a little happier (at least for my use case of Spanish) with Babbel, which I pay for. It has a single way forward, so you never have to choose what to work on next, and that single way will bring back earlier stuff just to refresh your memory for you. It also has little grammar asides, which I found very helpful, and which Duolingo lacks.
- tom_mellior 9y ago> Then there's also a "barbell" which you can press and takes you into some lesson, but I never quite figured out what it did. It takes you into a lesson that it thinks you should review next. Duolingo is meant to implement spaced repetition in that it keeps track of all the times you have seen every word, and it tries to give you lessons that are "due" for repetition according to its algorithm. In the web interface they show you how "strong" each word is in their opinion, but I found that their data on when you last saw a word was buggy. Anyway, the barbell is useful to keep you up to speed by revisiting stuff once you have finished all the lessons once.
- Gregordinary 9y agoI particularly like the audio courses from Language Transfer. They create rules that help you transfer words from English into a destination language. For example, words ending in ation in English, will end in ación in Spanish. Further, these words are also 'ar' verbs. Conversation -> Conversación -> Conversar I've found it quite helpful, especially in conjunction with Duolingo. At some point, I realized what I learned via Language Transfer was applying more as I progressed in Duolingo. https://www.languagetransfer.org/complete-spanish https://www.languagetransfer.org/complete-spanish
- firefoxd 9y agoI did Duolingo seriously for more than 370 days in a row. Spanish: I speak french and English so Spanish is relatively easy to complete. After completing the course, I tried having conversations with people (with friends but mostly uber drivers) and I was surprised how many times i learned it all wrong. I had to read a lot or children book to remedy that. French: As a french speaker, I went through it as a meta course just to see. It was very awkward. The correct answers are always cringe worthy. Some of them even wrong. Japanese: This is very different from the languages I speak. But after completing the entire suite, I still can't look at a japanese text and read it. I can't form a sentence on my own because it never teaches you how. I can't count to ten because it only gives you numbers randomly. I know a few colors. I know words, but those words make no sense on their own. I also had to follow youtube lessons to make any sense of what I learned. Duolingo is cool at making it look fun to learn. I don't think you'll learn to speak any languages with it.
- KeitIG 9y agoExactly my problem with Duolingo. It is great for Vocabulary, but in the end it's just knowing it by heart, and I was suprised there are no real courses explaining you the synthax of a phrase or some other advanced rules.
- simias 9y agoI don't find it great for vocab either, Anki or Memrise are massively better IMO since they only do that and they do it well. Of course it Duolingo you get the words in some context which could be better but since half the time the context makes no sense anyway why bother? I just did a Duolingo review about "household items" right now and it repeated twice the word "stairs" and thrice the word "kitchen", words I have no real trouble with. How about giving me some vocabulary I actually need to practice instead? And at least on Anki or Memrise you can select decks that match what you want to learn, such as getting the basics to order at a restaurant or ask for directions. On Duolingo I think I've learned how to say "the bishop sends a pineapple to the queen" before I learned how to say "bathroom".
- rando444 9y ago
- slipszenko 9y agoI've tried with Duolingo quite a bit, but what I studied never seemed to stay in my memory. I've had much better luck with Language Transfer - https://www.languagetransfer.org https://www.languagetransfer.org Disclaimer: the guy who runs it is a friend, but I met him through the project.
- Itaxpica 9y agoThe biggest issue I have with Duolingo is that they offer "grammar notes" to explain why specific elements are the way they are... but only on desktop web. In-app, which is the main way that I (and I'd imagine most users) use Duolingo, there are no grammar notes and no way to access the grammar notes - they just seem to assume that you'll pick it up from context. Personally I've been studying Russian, a language with extremely complex grammar much of which has no analogue in English or Spanish (the two other languages I speak), and were I not supplementing Duolingo with a textbook that actually explains the grammar, I would be extremely confused.
- nulagrithom 9y agoGrammar in general is my definitely my biggest issue. I have a firm grasp on grammatical terms in English, and it would be much easier for me if the rules of grammar were simply explained instead of implied. I've found I end up looking at the comments frequently and just hoping that someone was kind enough to plainly explain the grammar at some point. Failing that, I end up asking fluent Spanish speakers random questions like, "Are adjectives gendered and pluralized in Spanish?" Which works up to a point, but when you start asking about things like "gerunds" and "past participle" you end up having to explain what those things mean in the first place (using English) and then ask the question again about Spanish. Would love to see an app that focuses less on implied methods of teaching and is more willing to dive in to grammar lessons.
- robryan 9y agoYeah it makes no sense, a read more button that sends you to a screen that is basically just a text box with the notes would be enough. It has been requested for years on their forums.
- stevenjohns 9y agoI really can't understand why they don't provide the grammar notes in their mobile apps. If it's trivial things like table rendering then I'm sure they can come up with something. It's such a crucial part of learning another language and it's completely ignored.
- salimmadjd 9y agoavid Duolingo user here. 1 - the new update is a massive disaster (I'll explain in a bit). Maybe it's different for other languages, but for Russian language I vehemently hate the update. I dislike it so much that I tracked down Duolingo PM person on LinkedIN and tried to message them directly. The app updated for me a week ago with one dialogue that I tapped to confirm. Thinking it's just another incremental update. Suddenly everything changed. I thought I might figure it out, but nope. The article says, some of whom wrote excellent tutorials on the company’s message board [0]. It's not a tutorial as much as people are very confused (glad it wasn't just me) how the new update works and it's just a LONG thread to help with the confusion. If a mobile UI/UX designed for a consumer app needs a long thread like this, you can see it's probably was a poorly executed update. The UI/UX is not the worse part, the worse part is that now I hate using Duolingo. Let me explain: Duolingo has been a great daily motivator for me. The gamification of the app (up to now) was excellent. That is its biggest benefit. It's a motivator with a structured progression plan. The Russian lessons are okay, but they're just the starting point, I often have to go online and google something to understand the grammatical reasoning. All together, I have now bought 4 Russian books plus a Russian cheatsheet. That's just the Russian version, I was told the French has some hints and explanations. Some backgrounds on Duolingo's gamification parameters: A - You have a daily goal. This could be 1 lesson, 2 or etc. Users set this goal. I set mine to 1 lesson/day but I often do more. Each day when you complete a lesson you get some points. You get more points (from a choice of troves) if you watch an ad. B - Each lesson is inside a specific language skills. Like "Adjectives 1". There are 1-8 lessons inside each skills. C - When you complete all lessons inside a language skill you get more points and then you can move to the next skill. Each lesson is a series of questions in form of translation from English to Russian. Russian to English or listening to a phrase and typing it in Russian. I think there are like 20 questions per lesson (but I have never counted them). D - When you start a new lesson (up till this new update) you have life levels (IMPORTANT background about the new update.). This is exactly like a video game. You get 5 or 6 lives which are visually represented as slices of arcs of a circle around a heart. If you have a grammatical error each time you answer a question you lose one life. If you lose all your lives you're unable to complete the lesson. If you can complete a lesson you lose your streak. But you can use tokens you have accumulated or buy tokens to get more life. So you can reach your daily goal. However(till now), if you went back to an already completed lesson you would not use any lives. So you could repeat an existing lesson and make your daily quota. This had two benefits. One, I could directly pick which lesson I wanted to repeat. More importantly it was an stress-free process for me to accomplish my daily goal. Basically you're not anxious about losing your allocated lives and instead you can focus on language learning. D - You have a consecutive daily streak. I'm currently at 197 days now. Which for me it's a biggest motivator. I also get daily email reminders. If you lose your daily streak you can pay from $2.99 to $9.99 to maintain it. $9.99 if you have a longer streak. E - There is a double-or-nothing wager if you can maintain a 7 day streak. Basically you spend 50 tokens and if you maintain a 7 day streak you get 100 tokens back. So what is so terribly wrong with the new update? i - The UX as I mentioned above is incomprehensible. Basically there is a long thread on what all these things mean and do now. ii - MOST IMPORTANTLY, they added a lot of anxiety now to learning a language. The biggest motivator for me which was maintaining my daily streak, has now become a source of anxiety. Why? Because I was able to repeat existing task without the risk of losing all my lives and still finish my daily goal. After finish my daily goal, I would either repeat another lesson that I thought I was weak at or start a new lesson. But, it was all risk free. So I had no worries about making any mistakes just focus on learning. Now, you have no choice on what specific lesson inside a skill you want to repeat and new level or old level you lose life with each mistake. As a result I started looking elsewhere to see what other app I could use. So why did Duolingo make such an awful update? I'm guessing to increase their revenues. The new updates at least with my experience is forcing people to buy more lives to maintain their streaks. I think it might be their way to force out the people who are just casual users, and focus on serious users like myself and try to better monetize their serious users. In practically you could end up paying as much as $1.99/day to maintain your daily streak. 2 - Is it a helpful teaching tool? It's just a great motivator. I already speak two languages natively (because I'm an immigrant). I took one course of Japanese in college and I did okay. And I still remember some phrases. However, learning Russian proved to be harder than I thought. For one, I'm older now and we do not retain languages as fast. But also Russian grammar and way of thinking in that language is very different. Verbs not only have present and past (masculine, feminine) tenses, there is also concept of perfective and imperfective, also Imperatives. Then nouns have gender and also nouns have six different cases. Then there is variations on some of these rules for cases. All that said. It's the vocabulary that finally becomes the hardest part. Because there are no easy mnemonic to remember a word since there are very few associations to words we are familiar with in English. As I said above, I had to buy 4 Russian books and one cheatsheet. One visual learning book, two books on Russian etymology to help me remember the words better by understanding their etymology. One Russian grammar book which helps explain a lot of the stuff. The Russian cheatsheet for a quick reference of a grammatical rule. I've recently play Russian101 pod twice a week when I'm driving which has been helpful learning some new phrases. With all these, I still have to google stuff when I'm using Duolingo to quickly understand something. It's worth mentioning Duolingo added TinyCard, flashcards app. Which actually helped to retain some of these words. I often parallel my daily Duolingo with TinyCard. It was probably their most important teaching tool they added. Basically, it's a great motivational tool. It's a free way to get you started and get you motivated. However, I'm not sure with the new update if the motivation to continue after the first lessons will be there or not. [0] https://www.duolingo.com/comment/26612939/Where-are-the-instructions-for-new-skill-levels-crowns https://www.duolingo.com/comment/26612939/Where-are-the-inst...
- OldFatCactus 9y agoAnyone have advice on learning French?
- chillacy 9y agoI did the following: * Start the Duolingo tree * Start Pimsleur French around checkpoint 2 when I realized I couldn't speak at all * Start taking classes at Alliance Francaise when I started struggling with the grammar, starting at 103 * Spend at least a week in immersion in a Francophone country to solidify the learning * Start drilling nouns + gender with Anki when I noticed that native speakers kept correcting my gender usage
- OldFatCactus 9y agothanks!
- Mediterraneo10 9y agoBackpack in Morocco and West Africa. And when I say backpack, I don’t mean just follow the hostel trail and stay with other foreigners. Try to stay independent and maximize your contact with the local people. (I learned active French over several months hitchhiking in the region, for example. Before going, I had a decent passive reading knowledge like any bookish European). I highly recommend learning French there because the local people are much more tolerant of mistakes than in France proper. They will just be happy you can communicate. And yet, many urban Moroccans and Senegalese speak French so well, so virtually natively, that they are good models to learn from.
- OldFatCactus 9y agoThanks!
- WheelsAtLarge 9y agoI've used Duolingo for about a year now. This is what I discovered: 1) It can't be your one learning source. You get the essence of the language but you'll never become fluent. 2) It's very good at keeping you engaged. It gets an A from me on that. 3) The web app is stricter and will force you to learn better than the Android app 4)On the Android app you can get thru the challenges without learning a thing. You can just guess. 5)Your mindset should be to learn as opposed to getting thru the challenges. 6)Grammar is important so make sure you read the text they post on the web app. The phone app does not have it. 7)Find someone to speak the language with you ASAP. Speaking is the fastest way to fluency. 8)They've started to monetize the app so ads are a problem now. And ad-free is expensive. 9) It's many times better than the in-class teaching I got in junior high. They should replace the 1st few semesters with the app.
- pnathan 9y agoNifty. I've been able to use Duolingo to bootstrap my way into being able to sort of read French. It's also decent at drills in German, a language I took in college. I really like Duolingo for drills and for getting a sort of 101-level language map. A lot of the early sentences are absurdly inane, to be honest, but they are useful in the drill sense. That said, I took a run at Chinese, a language which I see as something potentially really useful, and it was a complete non-starter.
- qwerty456127 9y agoBTW what are some good alternatives to Duolingo? More grammar-focused perhaps, less fun if necessary.
- senatorobama 9y agoDo they have Sanskrit?
- lambertsimnel 9y agoUnfortunately not. The only Indo-Aryan language I can find listed on DuoLingo is Hindi and that hasn't yet started beta testing.
- Kyragem 9y agoI speak four languages fluently and Duolingo is a joke at all of them. Crowdsourcing is definitely not a silver bullet because if you pay peanuts you get monkeys. In my book Duolingo is a $50M VC investment above the Juicero disaster.
- EWBears 9y agoIt's interesting to see how many people don't find Duolingo or other apps to be effective learning tools. I spent the last 2 years creating a Thai learning app (that I think of as a 'digital textbook') specifically to address the issues that many people here raise. I won't cite the name since I'm not trying to advertise, just bringing it up as a talking point. Duolingo does lots of AB testing and found that gamification greatly increased user engagement, but I think that they took it too far and lost the forest in the trees. Everyone learns differently but in my experience you need to hear or read explanations of the second language in your native tongue and then hear that construction in the second language to reinforce it, because the key is lots of comprehensible input. Can a complex sentence become comprehensible input with just games? Sure, but if someone can explain how the grammar works in English then you can get to that same point faster and without the guess work. That's my opinion, at least, and so far users are seeming to find it effective since reviews have been largely positive! I think that serious language students will seek out appropriate apps or textbooks, and Duolingo will be a fun option for people that want a mixture of cognitive exercise and entertainment that may also be useful when they're traveling or interacting in a foreign language.
- kbd 9y agoctrl+f "Thai". Since Duolingo doesn't have a Thai module, would you mind sharing your app?
- EWBears 9y agoSure the main app is called Pocket Thai Master and it teaches reading and speaking, with cultural notes and historical facts sprinkled throughout. I’ve also made a second app that is a subset of the first that only teaches reading, which I creatively named Pocket Thai Reading. I’m currently re-writing a lot of the content to create a pared down version for travelers that teaches basic grammar and vocab through audio and transcriptions and without learning the Thai script. It takes many hours to learn the script and it is 100% worthwhile if you’re living in Thailand and it’s great for pronunciation, but it isn’t a worthwhile use of time for people that might just be visiting for a week or two. If you take a look and have any feedback I’d be happy to hear it - I’m actively working on updates! Next update I’m trying to add some different exercises to test comprehension since it’s multiple choice quizzes only right now.
- aabajian 9y agoPimsleur audio books all the way. It's spaced-learning/repetition with conversations.
- visarga 9y agoCame here to say the same. Pimsleur is also excellent for pronunciation and I have this feeling that once I learned something from the course, I never forget it. It just sticks, even after months or years. It is also most similar to how babies learn - without grammar, reading and writing, just by dialogue.
- tralarpa 9y agoYes, Pimsleur gives you excellent pronounciation and the sentences really stick (which is very good, of course!). But apart from that? It doesn't teach you grammar, so you are repeating and repeating like a parrot, hoping that one day you will know why they say XY in one sentence and YX in another sentence. It's true that babies don't learn formal grammar, but they usually grow up in an environment with full immersion (several hours per day over several years), surrounded by native adults who give their best to interprete, repeat and correct (!) their utterances. In addition, Pimsleur is very slow but it gives you the illusion that you are learning a lot by keeping you constantly busy. At the end, how many words do you learn in three levels? 400? That's barely A1! Most annoying, 70% (just a guess) of the time, you are just listening to the English speaker ("Now repeat this", "Try to say that",...).
- carlosgg 9y agoDoes anyone have any experience with the Fluent Forever approach? Their Kickstarter campaign received more than twice the amount requested[0]. Their book is currently selling for $2 on Amazon[1], and has some glowing reviews. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15498952 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15498952 [1] https://www.amazon.com/Fluent-Forever-Learn-Language-Forget-ebook/dp/B00IBZ405W/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1523571330&sr=8-1&keywords=fluent+forever%27 https://www.amazon.com/Fluent-Forever-Learn-Language-Forget-...
- alangou 9y agoIt works. And it's written by someone who's (a) learned multiple languages himself, (b) done the research on human language learning and memory/expertise to condense an immensely effective method into a book. He's gathered a vast amount of material for French, Spanish, Japanese, Chinese, and more on his website, https://fluent-forever.com https://fluent-forever.com. I've used his pronunciation trainers for Spanish and Japanese, and it's obvious the enormous effort he's put into all of his materials. Wyner obviously loves his work. Learning a language has no shortcuts - only different methods with varying levels of effectiveness, i.e. fluency gained per hour of work put in. I can say that of all the apps and methods I've tried, from Pimsleur to Rosetta Stone to Duolingo and Memrise, Fluent Forever is by far the most effective one. I used it to learn Spanish for a few weeks - his approach of learning pronunciation first, then basic vocabulary, seems counterintuitive at first, but it really, really works. Which I found out to my pleasure when I went to Spain on vacation with my friends. Even though they'd studied Spanish all throughout high school, both my pronunciation and my fluency were miles above theirs. I couldn't employ advanced tenses, but as he explains in the book, it'd be impossible for me to fluently internalize more advanced grammar before the simpler forms for any language, anyways. I've moved on to Japanese for now, since I have a much longer trip there coming up. This will take much, much longer (it's a Category V language versus a Category I language), but so far it's been just as effective at teaching me pronunciation and hiragana/katakana (their phonetic lettering system). I highly recommend the book - it's practically free at that price. Compare it to the $300 you'd spend on Rosetta Stone and don't hesitate.
- alangou 9y ago
- justinhj 9y agoI’ve used Duolingo and Memrise for a year learning Mandarin Chinese They both have pros and cons Memrise has native speakers in videos saying the phrases you learned Duolingo forces you to learn the characters rather than letting you get by with pinyin Duolingo is often slightinly wrong or not natural either in the english or the chinese translating
- nealdt 9y agoI'm still puzzled by duolingo - it uses an outdated pedagogy and an overemphasis on 'fun'. I have only looked briefly at the courses but I find the structure unconvincing. Regarding something mentioned in the article: what is the point of learning 'entertaining' phrases like 'they are washing the holy potato'. From a pedagogical point of view this is a waste of time is no better than the famous 'plume de ma tante' (look that up if you want to know more). For any language learner, it's important to remember that the most fun you can have in language learning is experiencing success. That success needs to come from your language acquisition, not arbitrary games. Learning a language is great!
- gregn610 9y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/La_plume_de_ma_tante_(linguistics) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/La_plume_de_ma_tante_(lingui... Saved you a click
- ghrifter 9y agoI loved duolingo before the newest update rolled out. Will probably stop using it and learn from a book/videos now
- bradleyjg 9y agoHow much does it cost to place an an advertisement masquerading as an article at fast company?
- njsubedi 9y agoUnfortunately Duolingo is only getting bashed here.
- amaccuish 9y agoWhat really bothers me about Duolingo is its Rosetta Stone approach to language learning. For adults, learning by osmosis is not a thing for languages. The creator has said that the reason the grammar notes (as bare bones as they are) are not available in the apps, is, that he wants, users to pick up the grammar through the exercises. I study French, German and Russian at uni, and for doing translations, or even just writing letters or speaking, this is not good enough. You want to be comfortable in a language, and that comes with a rock solid grammar foundation, as 'dull' as it seems. As many have said, Duolingo should be a tool amongst many. It has actually been really helpful for drilling through particular problem areas where I get a case wrong here or there. What they really need to do is get listening and reading comprehension out there; working alongside some people who really never understand grammar explanations, they can often work it out in their head after reading through a passage with a few examples, it makes it personal to them and they can see the 'point' of the rule. Also they need to get a better vocab tool, memrise/anki style. Sometimes I just wanna practice shopping items because I'm on the bus to get 'groceries' and I wanna make sure im all sured up.
- xtracto 9y agoI have found that a combination of Duolingo / Rosetta Stone in combination with the FSI Courses ( https://www.livelingua.com/fsi-language-courses.php https://www.livelingua.com/fsi-language-courses.php ) gives a good combination of Grammar + Speaking material to learn a language.
- amaccuish 9y agoThe FSI language stuff is great, highly recommend!
- seancaptain 9y agoThis is such a gift, getting to see so many dedicated users' experiences with the app. Will help my future coverage.
- dbolgheroni 9y agoI'm learning Italian with English as the base language. One of the things I felt with Duolingo (at least the "old" version, didn't try the new version) is that the exercises make you write mostly in English, not Italian, which is the main point of why I'm on Duolingo in the first place. It's rare for an exercise that makes you write in Italian, even when assembling your own sentences is the basics for those who are learning a new language. Finishing an entire module doesn't make you entitled to write anything. So I inverted things. Instead of the Italian course, I applied to the English course (which I am already fluent) as an Italian native speaker. This way, I write mostly in Italian, with almost no exercises to write in English (same problem with the Italian course). Learning has been much more effective.
- fapjacks 9y agoAnd there is still no Classical Latin despite years of requests and overwhelming support and a horde of volunteers and even a few forum posts with nearly complete but informal Classical Latin courses.
- puppet_heart 9y agoThis thread is living proof why many people are seemingly unable to learn languages (well): they're more concerned with tools and methodologies instead of simply putting in the effort and learning the language they want to learn (emphasis on "want to learn"). Yes, it's (sometimes hard) work to learn a language and there is no magical fairy dust.
- nemetroid 9y agoThe top comment is from someone who put 370 days straight into Duolingo and completed the content for multiple languages. Is that indicative of someone unwilling to "simply [put] in the effort"?
- puppet_heart 9y agoYes, straight into Duolingo. A tool. A gimmick. And the results were, according to the commenter, underwhelming. But I can tell you what I mean by putting in the effort: I had to learn Classical Latin and pass an exam in order to enrol in University in Germany. For that I took a two-month crash course. What did we do in this course? 4 weeks of grammar, interspersed with reading, analyzing and translating classical texts, then 4 weeks of reading, analyzing and translating classical texts. 4 hours in class plus 2-4 hours self-study each day. It worked like a charm. The bottom line: if your aim is to read classical texts, read classical texts. And the key here was not that I learned 4-8 hours each day, the key was that the learning was not dumbed down, gamified, artificially made fun. And I have found that this is applicable to pretty much every other language.
- kumarski 9y agoLow efficacy ed-tech solutions like this don't work. Context is king in languages. I think true solutions have to account for the following in language learning: Video / Audio Dual Subtitles Transliterated Subtitles Tongue Positioning for Pronounciation I haven't found a solution that does this....
- mkstowegnv 9y agoI would pay good money for a speech to text plus translated text solution - something like a dual subtitle AR set up. I am probably unusual in that translation is less of a problem for me than accuracy in hearing. I invariably wish the other side of the conversation had much better diction/ clear pronunciation. I often find that I am hearing very different sounds from what my conversation partner later tells me they were saying. I don't have this problem with English but I do when the partner is speaking the three languages I have studied (French, Japanese and Spanish - none of which have particularly foreign phonemes from English). Any phone apps that do something like this well?
- tralarpa 9y ago> I often find that I am hearing very different sounds from what my conversation partner later tells me they were saying. That's normal. Everybody has the same problem to some degree. Your brain is mapping what it hears to the sounds and sound sequences that it knows from your native language. That's usually a good thing because it helps humans to understand others even in the presence of background noise or speech impediments. Less probable but also possible: You have a hearing loss which your brain is able to compensate for your native language, but not for foreign languages. Had a friend with that problem. He was not able to discriminate between similar words starting with different sibilant sounds. He didn't have the problem in his native language because he knew from context which word would come. Have you tried to listen to audio books based on books that you know very well in your native language?
- wallflower 9y agoDoing Duolingo well just makes you better at doing duolingo. In real world, even in your native language, there are certain situations that can make you tongue tied. The goal of practicing with teachers from sites like iTalki is to get you comfortable opening your mouth and spitting out something, anything. To get past the fear of saying the wrong thing and just saying something. However, if you want to say the right thing and just spit it out, there is a way... For most people learning a second language, one of the fastest ways to learn can be the most painful way for some of us to learn. Rote memorization. Bor-ing. Methods like Assimil and Glossika and others use this as their core method, with some tweaks. By memorizing grammatically correct phrases, you will know that you are saying something correctly. I've heard saying that some incorrectly things is literally like I just wrote - your brain processes based on patterns and when you say it in the wrong subject-verb order or even phrase cadence, the person listening gets confused and sometimes irritated. If you are musically inclined, this can be song lyrics. Or you can hire someone to translate things that you would like to say from your native language into your second language. You must memorize phrases because memorizing single words without the context of an enclosing sentence can create bad habits that have to be unlearned later. Like learning violin, mastering the fundamentals are important before you can learn to play music. For learning a language, the two most important things are speaking with the right accent and speaking like a native speaker would in a given situation (which is usually grammatically correct but smooth).
- mgiannopoulos 9y agoIt seems the author didn’t bother to really check the app’s forum where users are heavily complaining (about 1500 comments in the main announcement thread) about the redesign, which at best was handle badly (people didn’t understand what was happening) and at worst has removed critical features like spaced repetition.
- neeleshs 9y agoIn my opinion, Duolingo tries to teach language by forcing familiarity. I for one, just cannot learn a language using that method. I like to learn starting with fundamentals - alphabet, grammar, words, sentences and so on. Are there any recommended books/material to learn Spanish that way? Everyone says spanish is easy to learn, but all apps kinda try to teach you by repetitive methods with no insights in to the structure of the language.
- mrcactu5 9y agoDuolingo has to be supplemented with reading and / or YouTube materials in the language of choice. Any language course the examples are necessarily contrived and never to your exact needs. But we have the internet and can look for (and hopefully find) something that matches our interests. If you're looking to do business in Japanese... then you need to be looking at the NHK news app which has beginner resources. If you're looking to do scholarship in German or Spanish or cooking in French then you need to search for vocab resources connected to those tasks.
- seancaptain 9y agoHi folks. I'll be talking to Duolingo next week about your criticisms and concerns. Feel free to ping me directly with any suggestions to ask them about. seanjcaptain@gmail.com