14 ms·
Mark Zuckerberg's Facebook hearing was a sham
- mtgx 9y agoYou're not going to get the "real deal" with the next hearing. If anything, they're going to take it easy on Facebook. https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/politics/2018/04/04/facebook-gave-most-contributions-house-committee-question-zuckerberg-also-got-most-contributions-fac/486313002/ https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/politics/2018/04/04/face...
- bonestamp2 9y agoNot to mention, Zuck had a private meeting with lawmakers on Monday. I wonder what they talked about then. I assume at a minimum they reminded him that he can't talk about any government spying that facebook assists with.
- cconcepts 9y agoIt does sound like it was a sham. However, what is really going to make a difference now that Facebook has critical mass is people voting with their feet. This doesn't just mean attempting to remove yourself from their system but also communicating broadly how the system actually works. Most of my non-tech friends still just see it as a way to keep up to date on what is happening in the world. Babylonbee seem to be doing a good job of spreading FBs transgressions via satire: http://babylonbee.com/news/mark-zuckerberg-promises-to-do-better-at-hiding-facebooks-data-mining-activities/ http://babylonbee.com/news/mark-zuckerberg-promises-to-do-be...
- Deimorz 9y agoThe article points out that the extremely short time limit for each senator's questions made following up on anything almost impossible, but their overall poor understanding of the topic was just as significant. It was obvious that, for a lot of the senators, the questions had been supplied to them and they didn't really understand what they were asking beyond a superficial level. They'd start out with a pretty solid question or two, but then be completely unable to follow up. Quite a few of them ended up wasting almost their whole time getting sidetracked by unimportant misunderstandings.
- Casseres 9y agoThey should have had subject matter experts asking the questions. Instead there were people had no idea what they were talking about, wasting time on shout-outs to their sons/nephews or whomever (I was only able to follow it for a minute). The CEO needed to be under oath so that lying would carry consequences, and they needed someone who could cut through the BS of how some of the answers were worded. We need more programmers, engineers, etc running for office.
- netsharc 9y agoThe best part was someone asked if Facebook tracks you even if you've logged out of their website. Holy shit, moment of truth for Zuck, I thought. Nope, he deflected by saying he'll get his team to get back to the senator, and then he spewed jargon ("I know websites use cookies [bla bla] for security"). Oh, he knew the answer, but he couldn't say it in front of all the cameras watching. And of-effing-course he knows what cookies are. And also he emphasized too much how people are in control of what data they share. The better question is, what data does Facebook save that the users can't see: all the analytics, all the location tracking, all the websites they visit. I didn't volunteer that data to you, Zuck, and I can't even control whether you have that data or not! (Well ok, on desktop I have Ghostery that blocks many many tracking pixels...).
- nerdponx 9y agoStop using Ghostery and switch to uBlock Origin.
- cdolan 9y agoWhy
- yjftsjthsd-h 9y agoPretty sure they got sold or something a bit back. There was also this: https://lifehacker.com/ad-blocking-extension-ghostery-actually-sells-data-to-a-514417864 https://lifehacker.com/ad-blocking-extension-ghostery-actual...
- spacehome 9y agoI was struck that on the surface it looked quite adversarial. Senators were trying to ask fairly pointed questions (despite any technical ignorance). But underneath the surface, the two parties here have fairly well aligned goals -- less freedom on the Internet. The senators want to show that they're doing something, and Facebook welcomes regulation in order to suffocate would-be competitors with it. I'm sure they're going to collaborate to find something that works well for both of their interests. We're witnessing the death of the free internet. It was a nice experiment while it lasted.
- deif 9y agoNot sure what your definition of free internet is, but mine is one where the users are free, not the businesses.
- aje403 9y agoThose two things are positively correlated
- dvfjsdhgfv 9y agoNot necessarily. The ultimate aim of each business is to crush the competition and become a monopoly. If they succeed, and we do have some de facto monopolies now, they can do whatever they want and users/customers have little or no choice. Regulations limiting the power of companies are designed do counteract that.
- adventured 9y agoIt doesn't matter if Google crushes the competition in search. You do not actually have to use their search engine, that's part of the freedom of the Internet. Further, you're not entitled to their search engine, that's also a critical aspect of actually having the freedom to use the Internet as you see fit. They can't do whatever they want. So long as the Internet is free from overbearing government restrictions and the ISPs aren't segmenting it (locking users into restricted sandboxes), you can go wherever you want without using Google search, or shopping at Amazon, or using Windows, or using Chrome, or using Facebook, or shopping on eBay, or paying with PayPal. The only real limiting premise as it pertains to the Internet, are the ISPs and the backbones. So long as you can get on a free Internet, engineers can perpetually build their own new products at will, crafting new tech universes that didn't exist before. They have been doing that non-stop in every category for the last two plus decades since the Web took off. Don't like Chrome because it managed to acquire 99% of the market? Fine, spin up your own clone and put it out there. Or use Firefox or Edge a dozen other lesser used competitors. Don't like Go or C# or Java? Fine, use one of 37 other languages. Don't like Google search? Fine, use Bing or DuckDuckGo or a dozen other less well known search engines. Build a new one maybe, nobody is stopping you, maybe it's time for a new search paradigm. Don't like AWS? Fine, use Hetzner, or Digital Ocean, or a dedicated box provider, or Vultr, or Linode or Google Cloud, or Azure, or build your own new competitor. There are vastly more options today, in essentially every way, than there were in 1995 or 2005. The free Internet has worked extraordinarily well. It has never stopped producing alternatives, and alternatives have never stopped existing. The only thing that can crush it is government regulation, specifically if they fuck that up.
- lwansbrough 9y agoI believe writers from the Guardian would sooner hand over control of the United States to the EU rather than try to understand why the US does things differently; but I think this question bears repeating: ethically, what has Facebook done wrong? Understanding the full context of this hearing is vital to your opinion on the matter. I'm nobody with an outsider's perspective, but to me Facebook has made very few errors in bad faith. This whole uproar has been about Facebook's well known (or, what I once thought was well know, I guess) practices as a data and advertising platform. We know Facebook cooperates with governments around the world to produce data on its citizens. We know what can happen with our data if we _let_ it fall into the wrong hands. I started using Facebook when I was 13 in 2007. (As a side note, I think Facebook should not be sharing data about minors to any parties.) I filled out a fair few questionnaires and I may have even participated in "Your digital life" somewhere along the line. At that time I started using Facebook it was providing an interface for establishing informed consent (basically their OAuth flow), to the extent at which it was reasonable for them (which to this day extends beyond the requirements of the law in the US as far as I know.) I consented to sharing my data with the 3rd party, which was essentially a license for that party to own that data. I knew that, and I did it anyway because I couldn't predict the ramifications of its collection and aggregation by a hostile party. I think the people who are most upset about this whole controversy are the ones who blame it for Russia's Active Measures. In my opinion, the solution isn't a GDPR-esque approach. I think we have to teach people why data is valuable and how it can be used against them. This is important for both creating an intellectual barrier to the efficacy of propaganda and so that people can make real, informed decisions about their privacy so that when they're asked if they want to share their friends' birthdates and phone numbers, they know what their answer should be.
- ngcazz 9y agoThe value of people's data is precisely _why_ GDPR is important. I should be able to take it away from you after I granted you temporary access to it.
- cm2012 9y agoYour data on FB is worth precisely one thing to them: the ability to target you with ads on FB. When you don't use FB, it's useless to them.
- chiefalchemist 9y agoThese are the same elected officials that approved ISPs selling usage data? The same officials that were silent when Snowden released what he had? Etc. Do I trust MZ and FB? Yes, as much as I trust Uncle Sam. Hint: Not much. The sham is on us. Again.
- listenallyall 9y ago+1. Zuckerberg should have pointed out exactly who voted for the renewal of the FISA surveillance program in Jan. "Look, if an American citizen is angry enough and chooses to never share any more data with Facebook, s/he has that right and the ability. With the NSA/CIA/FBI/TSA/Homeland Security/traffic cameras/license plate readers/stingrays, there is no opt-out. Period."
- chiefalchemist 9y agoIn theory yes. It would be entertaining. The reality is, he'd be screwed. Nor can we discount FB isn't a favored front of sorts for various "data collection agencies." p.s. I find it (sadly) funny how so many are upset with ZM and FB, but are completely unaware about Snowden, Obama's expansion of the Patriot Act, etc. FB is the obvious scapegoat. It currently has to play the role, even if it hates doing so. But for how long?
- mistermann 9y agoThis is a good explanation of why this hearing was so poorly designed such that nothing could be discovered. I highly doubt it was accidental.
- mmd45 9y agoWhat type of discovery would you like to make? It seems to me that whatever fb has they control and do with as they please and have the money for lobbyists and lawyers to corporate-splain their actions away and pay the occasional fine (cost of doing business). I'm having a hard time understanding why any of what is known is at all a surprise to someone who understands tech.
- gaius 9y agoIf a person logs out of Facebook, and Facebook continues to track them anyway, then that’s clearly violating consent, and there was a meeting where someone said “we need a way to track people who explicitly do not want to be tracked” and everyone in the room nodded.
- notspanishflu 9y agoFacebook tracks everyone, every time. Tracks users and non users. Tracks even people trying to avoid that company. For example, the infamous pixel code. <!-- Facebook Pixel Code --> <script> !function(f,b,e,v,n,t,s){if(f.fbq)return;n=f.fbq=function(){n.callMethod? n.callMethod.apply(n,arguments):n.queue.push(arguments)};if(!f._fbq)f._fbq=n; n.push=n;n.loaded=!0;n.version='2.0';n.queue=[];t=b.createElement(e);t.async=!0; t.src=v;s=b.getElementsByTagName(e)[0];s.parentNode.insertBefore(t,s)}(window, document,'script','https://connect.facebook.net/en_US/fbevents.js'); fbq('init', '477623695968553' ); fbq('track', 'PageView'); </script> <noscript><img height="1" width="1" style="display:none" src="https://www.facebook.com/tr?id=477623695968553&ev=PageView&noscript=1" /></noscript> <!-- DO NOT MODIFY --> <!-- End Facebook Pixel Code -->
- diasp 9y agoIn diaspora* you own your data. You don’t sign over rights to a corporation or other interest who could use it. https://diasporafoundation.org https://diasporafoundation.org
- throw2016 9y agoWritten in ruby, difficult to install. Have a look at the install requirements. Like all ruby apps you need a full build environment and tons of dependencies, and if by chance a specific gem fails to compile you are toast in dependency hell. Given the goal of the project an easier to install and use stack would have helped them.
- the-dude 9y ago
- ijafri 9y agoi guess it's about time, all state level elected bodies, should dedicate 5-10% seats ... at least ... on an extremely specialised profession basis, such as software, medical etc ... look most of these guys are lawyers by profession that's massively over represented in all houses everywhere .... why just we can't ....
- Hasknewbie 9y agoThis is a flawed view based on the premise that elected officials would somehow be incapable of grasping the concept of "having special advisers". You might be interested to know that Hong Kong has a system similar to what you're describing. It's not working out to well (hint: one's expertise is useful only in narrow cases, while corporatist self-interest applies all the time).
- clon 9y agoListening in I could not help but see parallels from Monty Python's Bridge of Death sketch. https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=cV0tCphFMr8 https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=cV0tCphFMr8 Especially with the follow up question..
- Hasknewbie 9y agoAnother needlessly strident and self-righteous article from The Guardian, that says one useful thing (the hearing is too short), followed by paragraphs of "and they are allowing this Zuck guy to SPEAK at a HEARING can you BELIEVE this? iamoutragediamoutraged." There are so many important points to cover on this topic for a mass readership to whom most of this is new (as in: a new threat they often don't quite yet understand), such as Fakgbook merely being the current symptom and Russia/CA the current user. This has happened before and will happen again. People on a global scale need to be made familiar with key synonyms when discussing this, such as "personal data" = "private property", and "privacy" = "security", so as to put the issue in perspective, allowing for a saner debate while avoiding the stale sophistry and astroturfing that always come up (i.e. if you replace "privacy" with "security" it becomes harder for them to throw around disingenuous soviet-style phrases like "well you have nothing to fear if you have nothing to hide"). Any newspaper that takes the "duty to inform" seriously would spend more time on exploring the subject properly, instead of publishing this self-serving filler. It's not like there are going to be an infinite number of opening to cover this issue. This is precisely the kind of moment and topic where the media are expected to come up with informative analysis, and yet they fail to rise to the occasion.
- gizzlon 9y agoI would not call this an "article from The Guardian"
- Hasknewbie 9y agoCome on, The Guardian is not some Medium blog hoster. You can't say this being in their opinion section means it doesn't count. If you discounted everything tagged as opinion, their front page would have a whole lot of empty spaces.
- ZenoArrow 9y ago> "Come on, The Guardian is not some Medium blog hoster." Why make the distinction? I don't trust the opinions of journalists over the opinions of the general public, both can be informative and both can be misleading.
- ftlio 9y agoIt was fun to watch Congress pretend like there's something to legislate here, and to watch Zuckerberg pretend like whatever legislation Facebook helps write might be a burden. The openness to the idea of AI modulating discourse so that we don't ever have to feel uncomfortable was my favorite part.
- kaitnieks 9y agoMaybe I'm too cynical about politics, but it appears to me that the point of these hearings is not to solve or investigate anything, it's to generate soundbites that voters or potential future voters would like. It's not even that important what the reply is, as long as the politician asks the hard question and demonstrates his concern, and if it makes the news & press, that's victory for them.
- yodsanklai 9y agoWhat I find particularly annoying in this kind of hearing is the condescending tone of the politicians. They are eager to put the blame on someone else when they are ultimately the ones who vote the laws.
- bitxbitxbitcoin 9y agoThis is the key point in the television farce. The politicians, more so or just as much as Zuckerberg, are trying to save face.
- bonestamp2 9y agoYou're not wrong, but on the flipside... do we really want them sitting around all the time thinking up laws they can enact to prevent every possible wrongdoing in society? It's a reasonable expectation that people self-govern with some morality and ethics and not look for every possible way to advance at the expense of someone else.
- craftyguy 9y agoCompany (mis)handling of user information is not exactly a new, one-off problem that came up just this one time. I would argue it's the exact problem they should be trying to curb with legislation, except for the fact they'll undoubtedly get it wrong since they'll look to "industry experts" like Mark Z for guidance.
- austenallred 9y agoNote how many of the senators who voted to expand surveillance programs and the NSA became suddenly very concerned for privacy. They just wanted to try and dunk on him and get in a sound bite.
- Dowwie 9y agoI have had enough of the latest anti-Facebook vitriole. A lot of people want to see someone, preferably Zuck, drawn and quartered, but I don't. He has accepted responsibility for mistakes and has agreed to do more to protect its users. I believe him. I also believe he has earned a chance to redeem himself, considering the value that Facebook has created for society at little to no cost to its users. Most of the Hacker News community has benefitted by Facebook, as users or through myriad successful open source projects. To take with both hands and to bite is unethical. It is wrong. Facebook and Zuck aren't the only people who need to change.
- arcticfox 9y ago> considering the value that Facebook has created for society at little to no cost to its users. Is Facebook a net positive for society? Every positive use of the platform I've seen has been offset by a negative one. Maybe I just have bad friends. Also the "little to no cost" is debatable, when the users have been packaged and delivered as fresh marketing meat to firms like Cambridge Analytica in exchange for a $500B market cap.
- sveme 9y ago> considering the value that Facebook has created for society at little to no cost to its users. Would you mind listing the positives (and negatives as well) that you believe facebook created for society? I'm strongly against Facebook, but I'd be happy to be convinced of its generally positive effects. Though please don't mention their Open Source contributions, that's not Facebook, the social media network.
- pi-squared 9y agoHow do I downvote?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- simias 9y agoYou need to reach a certain karma threshold, I don't remember the exact value.
- itakedrugs 9y agoWhat's all those lobbyist doing? I thought that they were supposed to advise them in a way that would be beneficial to the citizens?
- thret 9y ago"the senators elevated him to a kind of co-equal philosopher king whose view on Facebook regulation carried special weight. It shouldn’t." Why not though? I assume he holds more sway than any senator of any country.
- bonestamp2 9y agoTrue, although the senators are there to protect the people and they can't protect the people from someone if they take advice from that person.
- ada1981 9y agoPlay along @ Zuckerberg Senate Bingo: http://mfbc.us/m/nk7mja http://mfbc.us/m/nk7mja
- rajacombinator 9y agoThe idea that a senate hearing could be anything but a sham is rather innovative. Are the authors naive, stupid, or evil?
- Simulacra 9y agoIt was painful to watch. From Zuck's smug, condescension, to the Senators grappling with how to ask the softest question while still looking tough.
- wiz21c 9y agoFB is now too big to fail.
- throwaway413 9y agoDamn social logins. The biggest one is Spotify. They require you to make a whole new account instead of just unlinking your FB one, and then all of your playlists etc are gone. I’m going to set aside a day to migrate all of my services, but it’s going to be a pain. Worth it.
- bnewton149 9y agoI did this a couple months ago. You can share playlists from your original account with your new account and copy them over. You can even make a playlist of your saved songs and and save them all at once to your new library (select all > Save to your Library)
- throwaway413 9y agoAwesome, thanks for the tips.
- dishanr 9y agoYou can ask the Spotify customer service to migrate your data from the old account to the new one. I did and they transferred all my content.
- throwaway413 9y agoI actually did contact them and ask and they were the ones that told me to just open a new account as they couldn’t disconnect it (which I obviously knew to be BS). Maybe I’ll try again asking even nicer...thanks for sharing.
- wvenable 9y agoI made the smart choice a long time ago to never use one of those social logins. It actually kept me off of Stackoverflow for a long time. I'm not even particularly socially minded or privacy conscious -- I just don't think one coordinated login is a good idea.
- 9y ago
- avoutthere 9y agoThe author used the term "monopoly" six times in the article. Facebook is a lot of ugly things, but "monopoly" is not one of them.
- usernum3hundred 9y agoCambridge Analytica was probably a "Pearl Harbor" moment for the US government, they probably wanted to put regulations on Facebook for a long time.
- DiffEq 9y agoYet it is not new and how is it different than when Obama did it? https://www.investors.com/politics/editorials/facebook-data-scandal-trump-election-obama-2012/ https://www.investors.com/politics/editorials/facebook-data-...
- jonbarker 9y agoWhy was there no discussion about the price discrimination which occurred in the last election, and to be fair, probably also happened in previous elections? No other media company is allowed to do this. Does the Honest Ads bill even address this?
- lazugod 9y agoA photographer present at the hearings was able to get a picture of the notes Zuckerberg brought: https://twitter.com/becket/status/983846618263891968 https://twitter.com/becket/status/983846618263891968.
- Chardok 9y agoIf you have any doubts that this wasn't a sham just look at how well FB stock did yesterday.
- arbuge 9y agoIf greater regulation in the social network space comes along, it's probably a win for Facebook. They have the resources to implement compliance. One more barrier to entry for any aspiring competitors, as if any more were needed.
- dosycorp 9y agoMark is more like an Emperor come to visit affiliated crowns than a servant being questioned by his masters. Maybe the Senate’s deference in part is motivated by their belief he may run and win in a few years and they hope to win favor from a man they may end up working for. Secondly perhaps it is motivated by them not wanting to appear too knowledgeable nor too much of a threat to Mark, to put him at ease, lest they otherwise provoke his wrath. Third I think their attitude is certainly motivated by the awareness, from those in governments, just how powerful internet giants, particularly FB, are. I believe in no small ways have these companies upended the conventional relationships of individuals, and corporate individuals, to the state. They command vast resources, such as people and intelligence ( and automated processes pertaining to them, i.e, algorithms or bureaucracy, pick your favorite term ), traditionally the purview only of state entities. I’m quite sure that many in government consider these companies are direct threats to the future of their model of governance. But they also feel they must handle them very delicately. Because they do not want to risk a premature confrontation they are unprepared for. But if any person alive today was going to mount some sort of the future coup against conventional government, spearheaded by the new tech elite, then Mark is a perfect candidate. He is a student of history and demonstratedly strategically effective. In this light, perhaps the biggest takeaway of a public questioning such as this is how much of a theatrical side show and possibly a distraction it is from the new reality these powerful groups find themselves contesting.
- panic 9y ago> Maybe the Senate’s deference in part is motivated by their belief he may run and win in a few years and they hope to win favor from a man they may end up working for. The US Senate doesn't work for the President. They're part of independent branches of government.
- ghostbrainalpha 9y agoAnd it's beyond naive to think Zuckerberg could ever win for President. Just because Trump could do it, doesn't mean Zuck could. You have to be likeable. You have to be good on camera. He was the villain in his own movie for gods sake. Conservatives hate him because he is a liberal nerd. Liberals hate him because he is a corporate tool. We will accept stupid. We will accept dishonest. We will accept mean. But we won't accept entitlement or arrogance. There is nothing less popular than a genius or wealthy person who knows they matter more than normal people and acts like it. Trying to act like a "normal person" is the most important part of being a politician. He will never do that to an acceptable level. He may have an advantage no one else does, with demographic info from Facebook. He may be the person who could basically appoint any person he wants to the office of the Presidency. But that doesn't mean he could appoint himself.
- notacoward 9y agoYes, the hearing was a sham, but not quite in the way the OP thinks. To quote Hannibal Lecter, in turn quoting Marcus Aurelius: > Of each particular thing ask: what is it in itself? What is its nature? What does he do, this man you seek? What do senators do? Primarily, they get themselves elected. They see that Facebook might have a role in that. They're trying to figure out if it can help them, or help their opponents, or if they can turn it from one to the other. Secondarily, while there's so much negative sentiment about Facebook (I'll write about journalists' role and agenda in fanning those flames another time), they want to be seen as asking hard questions. They don't want to be asking hard questions until they know where the advantage to themselves might be, but they want to seem that way. Anything else is just window dressing.
- AnnoyingSwede 9y agoI find it ridiculous that a company that runs a web-community should be held accountable for what it's users do, while weapons manufacturers are not. Why not just hold the people that breached their terms and conditions responsible like we do with guns?
- zippy786 9y agoQ. Can the users completely delete their data ? Zuckerberg: Yes, there are two options. First to deactivate because students and want to suspend and come back because they want to study for exam. Second option is users can totally delete all their data. Where is the second option anyone from Facebook ? There is only an option to delete the account after you DIE, not an option to delete it when you are alive. So many lies.
- oneplusone 9y agoEasy to google: https://www.facebook.com/help/delete_account https://www.facebook.com/help/delete_account
- zippy786 9y agoThanks. But I could not find the link anywhere, can anyone even get here from Facebook page: https://imgur.com/1ijzgqV https://imgur.com/1ijzgqV
- eilyra 9y agoFrom what I remember, you need to click "Learn more" in the "Deactivate your account" text which will take you to a help page that allows the deletion of the account as well. But yes, it is very much hidden and not meant to be found.
- kristianc 9y agoOf course it was a sham. No one's interests are aligned to getting this solved. Facebook want to get away with as minimal regulation as possible, and any regulation that does happen it wants to harm its incumbents. Politicians want to get re-elected, and want regulation in so far as it harms the chances of anyone 'doing a Trump' and using social media to unseat their own Congressional seat. They're not that exercised about privacy otherwise they wouldn't have spent the last year arguing for a right to hack people's phones. Users want to make the right noises / virtue signals to their friends about privacy but ultimately don't want to pay for Facebook. 'Researchers' want to make a name for themselves off the back of this issue and appear on TV but Oh My God don't ask me any questions about how this actually works or what an alternative looks like. The media and publishers want the exposure and ad revenue that comes from running this story, but want to avoid anyone asking any difficult questions about them signing over their involvement in FB schemes such as Instant Articles or how they track their own users. The process worked exactly as designed - it allowed everyone to have their pound of flesh while ensuring nothing actually gets done.
- twostoned 9y agoBest summary that I've seen thus far.
- Nikita_Sadkov 9y agoFacebook Bans for Anti-Putin Poetry on Your Wall After the ban they also enabled forced pre-moderation on all my wall posts (everything I post to my wall gets marked with "We removed this post because it looks like spam and doesn't follow our"), so now I cant post anything at all. Do we need more proofs that Zuckerberg is a Putin's friend? Hello, Facebook! I'm a citizen of Russia who is just being critical of Russia and Putin. How much Russia pays Zuckerberg to censor dissent opinion and promote Russian puppets, like Donald Trump?
- garettmd 9y agoI haven't seen many Congressional hearings but what I have seen is always a sham. Are these things ever more than just for show?
- msie 9y agoTed Cruz scored a lot of points from conservatives on Twitter but he was a client of Cambridge Analytica!
- bArray 9y agoIt seems as though everybody in the room has a very different agenda and even more different level of education on the subject. Some seem to be using it to grill Zuckerberg, some to setup discussion and some to air dirty laundry. It's a bit of a circus in there. Current hearing live on Youtube: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16812334 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16812334
- exodust 9y agoJust watching this now on youtube, and surprised to hear Zuckerberg say he isn't aware of the term "shadow profile", even though he confirmed in the previous sentence that they collect data on people without Facebook accounts. Very odd denial of a term he is surely familiar with.
- swati2260 9y agoFacebook Grilling Shows Real Need For Decentralized Social Networks https://cryptocomes.com/facebook-grilling-shows-real-need-for-decentralized-social-networks https://cryptocomes.com/facebook-grilling-shows-real-need-fo...