8 ms·
In fighting homeless camp, Irvine's Asians win, but at a cost
- DataWorker 9y agoThis is very similar the stories one hears regarding NIMBYism in the Silicon Valley. Hard working, successful immigrants seem to subscribe the just world hypothesis, exactly as one might predict. Their tolerance for those who aren’t able to do the same is pretty low from what I’ve seen. If they can come here poor and in a generation become millionaires and buy a home in California of all places, then why can’t everyone else.
- rossdavidh 9y agoAnother angle I've seen, in Austin, is that people who are close to falling off that cliff are among the least tolerant of those who have. Those who are scraping by with service jobs are often least tolerant of the mentally-ill homeless person who hassles them on the way to work, and quickest to call the police. If you are a first-generation immigrant, I think it often means you do not take it as a given that you cannot fall out of the successful class, even if you are doing well now. Someone born into the professional class may feel better about themselves for tolerating uncomfortable behavior from someone less fortunate, whereas someone who in the back of their mind is worried about "that could be me someday" is not feeling good about themselves for being tolerant. Just my own anecdotal view, I have no data to back that up on a large scale.
- api 9y agoNo data but I have similar anecdotes, and also have to point out that in the past 50 years or so a lot of the strongest political opposition to increased social programs has come from the working class. Most of the wealthy I've spoken to are less opposed to social spending. In addition to the reasons cited another factor might be diminishing marginal utility of money. A 1% tax hike on a millionaire will have zero tangible perceived effect on his or her lifestyle. A similar tax increase on a working class person could be devastating.
- zeth___ 9y ago> Irvine boasts a median home value of $740,000. I don't see these people as 'nearly falling off'. I see these as people who don't want to have the value of their homes fall even one cent because 'we got here on our own hard work'.
- rossdavidh 9y agoCertainly, but that was no doubt true before it became an immigrant community. First generation immigrants are more likely to have experienced a very different level of wealth earlier in their life, which makes one's attitude towards the possibility of losing it different than if you were born into that class and society and had always been there. But, I could be wrong.
- zeth___ 9y ago>If they can come here poor and in a generation become millionaires and buy a home in California of all places, then why can’t everyone else. If they can do it here, why couldn't they do it back home?
- api 9y agoPolitical corruption, totalitarianism.
- zeth___ 9y agoPlenty of people got rich in China. Sounds like excuses from people who just couldn't cut it.
- api 9y agoIt's easier to cut it in California?
- zeth___ 9y agoInfinitely.
- NedIsakoff 9y agoYes.
- kss238 9y ago*Plenty of lucky people got rich in China.
- imgabe 9y agoPlenty of people got rich in Russia too. That doesn't mean it was something open to anyone.
- zeth___ 9y agoSounds like something losers tell themselves to feel better. After all, you just need to rise early, work hard and strike oil to make it rich.
- odnforthday 9y agoHere's the part I don't buy. She says Irvine is made up of 45% Asians, but the protesters are mainly immigrants. Unless all 45% are first-generations, then what she said doesn't add up. She uses the word immigrant only twice in the article, near the top, with little proof backing her statement. Those that she interview have Asian names, but that doesn't mean they are immigrants. By using the word immigrant, she made the article sensational. She tried to turn the protest into a topic of race, rather than simply stating Irvine residents don't want a homeless shelter in the neighborhood. Are most immigrants intolerant of homeless in Irvine? That's rather absolute to be true. What about the other 40% whites? Do all of them approve of the homeless shelter? 40% vs 45% are about the same weight, but she chose to focus on only one side of the story. It would be more correct to state: Irvine, made up of 45% Asian ethnicity, fights back against homeless shelter.
- chrischen 9y agoShe almost definitely categorized non-whites as “immigrants” based on assumption, simply based on the fact that I highly doubt she conducted a background survey of the protesters.
- electriclove 9y agoYou are absolutely correct. No one (Asian or not, immigrant or not, Irvine or elsewhere) wants homeless moved into their neighborhood.
- ams6110 9y agoIt's a trend in the media, that everything is framed as A vs. B. Whether that's immigrant status, race, color, religion, sex, it's all done to create a division, pander to one side or the other, and get viewers.
- chrischen 9y agoYou can’t expect them to have the solutions for a societal problem. The fact that there isn’t affordable housing and job opportunities for these homeless is a failing of the US government, not Irving’s government, and definitely not of that local community. However if all the homeless congregate in that area, it’s an unfair burden to that community from a problem caused by a failing of the government. They have the right to complain, and they don’t have the responsibility to accept that burden alone. They can certainly take action to remove the burden without being blamed because no other community will step up to the plate.
- humanrebar 9y ago> ...not Irving’s government... Surely city governments are responsible for acute mental health issues. Not all homeless have need for serious mental health care, but the number is high and those needs should be taken care of before (or at the latest, while) talking about jobs. EDIT: At least, local governments should be educating the public about how much help they need from state and national government.
- chrischen 9y agoThat would assume that the homeless were caused by / came from Irving. That’s unlikely, as there are no borders in the US and people are free to move about. See this article on how US cities pay homeless people to leave town, and they end up somewhere else, as someone else’s problem: https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/ng-interactive/2017/dec/20/bussed-out-america-moves-homeless-people-country-study https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/ng-interactive/2017/dec/... Problem is nobody wants them, yet no one will enact policies that will solve the problem. So if you sit back and accept the homeless while not really solving the issue, you’re just being a chump.
- humanrebar 9y ago> That would assume that the homeless were caused by / came from Irving. Something can be your responsibility even if it's not your fault. Particular people with particular problems is a local issue. Particular tent cities hurting particular parks or businesses is also a local issue. Go ask a local social worker or police officer. They know everyone on a first name basis. They just don't have anywhere to go with their information. > Problem is nobody wants them, yet no one will enact policies that will solve the problem. So instead of shifting responsibility in one way or another, local governments and communities need to organize more around these issues. It's true that it's a huge problem, arguably one that will never get solved completely, but the local governments need to start by getting the word out about the particular needs they have: studies, funding, legal frameworks, training, coordination systems, etc. This is the kind of targeted Medicaid expansion that should be discussed, especially since mental health is in the news so much these days.
- electriclove 9y agoFWIW, there is a ton of affordable housing initiatives in Irvine, but the demand is greater yet. http://www.cityofirvine.org/community-development/affordable-housing http://www.cityofirvine.org/community-development/affordable...
- neonhomer 9y ago> a dentist with offices in Irvine and Orange, said he paid about $5,000 to sponsor seven buses… I understand this dentist wanted to protect his neighborhood in his mind, but it's really sad if he's not donating any money to actually help the homeless.
- lykr0n 9y agoI don't think $5k will do much in a state that spends far beyond that per person.
- chrischen 9y agoThe problem is nobody wants the homeless at their doorsteps, including this community. If you leave them in tents in some place, nothing will change. If you apply pressure to the problem then hopefully it will get solved.
- lightedman 9y agoYou're correct, and all those thousands of people in Irvine whom are demonstrating are wealthy enough that a meager donation from most of them could've settled the problem in its entirety by building a local shelter or two. Meanwhile, the people here who have no clue about the homeless problem being exacerbated by these same unthinking people just downvote you and demonstrate their own lack of critical thought.
- kimco 9y agoIs there any data on what is driving this? How much of this is due to the cost to rent? Is California a homeless destination due to climate and general tolerance to homeless camps...etc?
- api 9y agoCalifornia and Florida are indeed major homeless destinations due to climate, and California more so due to tolerance.
- tcoff91 9y agoCalifornia is definitely a destination for homeless people due to climate and tolerance. There is a practice known as Greyhound Therapy where many cities around the country put mentally ill people on a bus and just ship them off to be someone else’s problem. Many times they pick California because they know that the homeless person would be better off there.
- NedIsakoff 9y agoThen reverse it, ship it them to Montana
- well-here-we 9y agoThere are even programs in various cities in the middle of the country that will pay to bus homeless people to California. And then those states try to stop all federal funding on homelessnes. California is housing the country’s homeless, federal funding should be taking care of most of this problem.
- chrischen 9y agoThe US allows local governments to control zoning. Local government will always protect incumbent landowners since incumbent landowners probably have control of local government. As such, ceding control to localities will result in a lot of localities protecting their investments and preventing dense developments. A possible solution is to enforce national level zoning laws that forbid such practices that prevent dense developments where they otherwise should be.
- mirkules 9y agoThis really is a regional problem. I live around the area, near the beautiful Santa Ana trail which connects two counties to the ocean. A few months ago, I rode down the 40-mile stretch for the first time in a long time, and I was absolutely shocked to see the extent of the tent city near the Anaheim Angels stadium. The people living there were living on hard times, it felt post-apocalyptic in some sense. The tent area spanned for a couple of miles - there was garbage everywhere, people washing the clothes on the trail, people urinating on the side, and some wondering around in a zombie-like state I can only assume was either mental illness or drug abuse. Finally, officials decided to close the trail to do a clean-up. There was about 400 tons of trash, 14,000 needles and 5,000 lbs of "waste" removed. http://losangeles.cbslocal.com/2018/04/07/santa-ana-river-trail-reopens/ http://losangeles.cbslocal.com/2018/04/07/santa-ana-river-tr... Honestly, I can't blame Irvine for not wanting this in their backyard. But unfortunately, as the people were getting evicted from these makeshift cities, they are setting up the tents in other neighboring cities. There is a small area near where I live now too. I don't know what the answer is, or how to deal with it. All I can tell you is that it was not a good feeling, both from a humanitarian and safety point of view, i.e. I felt awful for the people living in this, but also uneasy around it.
- fouc 9y agoI think if you were living in limbo, you'd be pretty zombie-like. Regardless of drugs or mental health.
- NedIsakoff 9y agoSo as someone said: if city X has a problem, they fix the problem by evicting the people, the people move to my city (city Y). Why should we (city Y) have to deal with it? Just evict them like city X did. What's good for the goose is good for the gander..
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 9y agoEventually, they will end up in San Francisco who will welcome them.
- selftemp 9y agoI read the article and then realized why is it on the front page of Hackernews. Half the comments are flame-baiting. Wonder if there was a better way to self-moderate this without the moderators who may be offline on a Sunday.
- NedIsakoff 9y agoI'm Asian/Canadian (arrived in Canada in 1988 at 8) and have worked in the US since 2009. I consider myself a 0.5 generation immigrant. Talking my parents, other first generation immigrants, and even some second generation etc. They do have a common view. If we came here with very little (my parents arrived with $200 in their pockets), worked hard, and eventually became successful then why can't other people do the same. These people had much easier start then us (they didn't coming here at mid 40s with $200 in total) and had better opportunities. Most of them see people collecting welfare we leeches off them (and the taxes they pay).
- azinman2 9y agoDrug addiction, mental illness, little education / scaffolding, no family support, etc. Their view that if they did it why can’t others is the same as the libertarian / rich people perspective of “I got mine, you should be able to get yours.” Except not all people are the same, not all people have the same abilities, support, drive, etc. One should have compassion for those unable to help themselves. There will always be people trying to exploit a common good, but that doesn’t mean they’re the majority. If you’re willing to risk everything by moving to a new country with no money where you might not even speak the language, you’re have above average drive and appetite for risk. For example, grandchildren of such immigrants do not share the same economic outlook [1]. [1] https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2018/03/19/upshot/race-class-white-and-black-men.html https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2018/03/19/upshot/race-c...
- NedIsakoff 9y agoIf you talk to the group, their answer to drug addiction is its their fault for starting drugs. For family support, they had none when the came here and had very little opportunity too. My mom's first job was an sewing machine operator in a garment shop in Halifax. My wife's mom had barely finished grade 8 school. Note that this is my oberservation of their views only.
- jopsen 9y agoProbably your parents had enoumous will power, most people don't migrate to another country. Immigrants are not representative of the general population. Often they are stronger in many ways :) Similarly, you can ask why didn't everybody from their native country emigrate. Just my random guess...
- electriclove 9y agoThe problem I see is that the county (Orange) is unilaterally deciding which cities (Irvine, Huntington Beach, Laguna Niguel) the homeless should be moved to.
- prostoalex 9y agoIt comes down to land ownership - county owns more land in some cities than others. They cannot propose homeless housing in Rancho Santa Margarita or Coto de Caza since most of that land is owned by someone other than the county.
- blondie9x 9y agoHomelessness isn't a regional problem. It's a national problem. There needs to be an area designated for them at a a national level. Pushing people from place to place regionally is a terrible solution. An area needs to be designated for them nationally like Native American reservations when they were first created. The national solution needs to have programs to assist with addiction, mental health, and job training. This is a really national issue. There are homeless everywhere. Let's approach it together with a national area all homeless people can go to for help.
- fourthark 9y agoProbably would turn into concentration camp though.
- blondie9x 9y agoNo there would be job training, substance abuse rehab, and mental health programs. Its just getting homeless off the streets nationally and getting them to one central place where all efforts can be combined. Regional approaches don't work. We have to tackle it in one place nationally. We cannot have people living on the streets who don't get help all in one place. Now people are going town to town aimlessly and without direction.
- Jolter 9y agoSounds awfully like a gulag. I have to assume you're trolling.
- boyaka 9y agoIn response to other children of this post: perhaps you can give more evidence as to how this solution would end up like the harsh imprisonment by oppressive regimes? Why do you instantly shoot down one of the only creative solutions in this entire discussion, other than trying to raise more money to throw at it (which clearly has not even begun to solve these problems).
- tdb7893 9y ago
- bmarquez 9y ago> Asians are usually quiet, you know. Not this time. I'm just pleased to see more Asian-Americans getting involved in politics. I lived in Irvine for a few months a while back, and it was a very clean city. I didn't see any leaves on the street, or homeless people for that matter (which I thought was strange, but I also felt safe not being accosted like in other areas of LA.) People can throw the NIMBY card around but if this is the issue it takes to see my former neighbors get involved in politics, so be it.
- NedIsakoff 9y agoAgree!
- fourthark 9y agoWhat cost. Sounds like they just plain won.
- draw_down 9y agoYeah, I had the same thought. It didn’t cost them anything. Also shout out to the people whose first involvement with politics was to say “fuck you stay out of my community”. I’m sure they’ll be sticking around to help with constructive alternate solutions to the problem.
- spicymaki 9y agoFWIW I think the implication is a moral cost.
- newsunday 9y agoexcuse me dang, i have tried repeatedly to contact the admins through email without any response. i believe that my account tempagain567i and its associated ip has been incorrectly rate limited. i havent posted or commented in more than a day and it still wont let me post anything. i would be more than happy to correct my behaviour if you would be so kind as to point out my violation of site guidelines. Thanks.
- dang 9y agoIt just takes time to write replies, especially on weekends. We detached this comment from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16787870 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16787870 and marked it off-topic.
- fatjokes 9y agoHeh, this reminds of a similar incident in New York a few years ago: https://www.nytimes.com/2014/07/26/nyregion/homeless-shelters-opening-in-queens-stirs-ugly-exchanges.html https://www.nytimes.com/2014/07/26/nyregion/homeless-shelter... tl;dr: they opened a homeless shelter in a heavily (Asian) immigrant community and were met with protests. The result was a sadly hilarious exchange between the two groups with one side yelling "get a job" and the other side yelling "go back to [some Asian country]". A more paranoid person would see these moves as politically intentional. As the stereotype goes, they're expected to take it quietly, they're not as politically involved, and when they do, they're less likely to invoke sympathy (xenophobia in America seems to be more acceptable, at least vs. racism, and there appears to be a lot of resentment towards Asians.) The problem then becomes minority-vs-minority, so racism accusations are not directed at whites.
- Simulacra 9y agoWhat troubles me about the Irvine case, is that it sounds like every other "concerned" group across the country when it comes to homelessness. No to tents, no to shelters in the neighborhood, no to homeless sleeping on the benches, etc. Everyone, it seems, wants the problem to go some place else, but no community, particularly in Silicon Valley, has stood up (to my knowledge and please correct me if I'm wrong here) that the homeless people of a community are PART of that community, and the community should embrace them, and integrate them. Perhaps I'm overly optimistic...