9 ms·
This looks like it's going to be an increasingly big problem for the platform giants, as it pertains to their increasingly aggressive speech restrictions. As th
by adventured 9y ago
This looks like it's going to be an increasingly big problem for the platform giants, as it pertains to their increasingly aggressive speech restrictions. As they ramp those restrictions up, I'd expect the need for security to increase accordingly.
A mentally unwell person is likely to feel targeted, oppressed, threatened, harmed, etc. by being silenced. They'll feel isolated and it'll very likely feel like a personal attack by the tech company. The platforms today are so large, it surely can seem like being cut off from society in general, like a human right is being revoked.
The people the platforms are looking to restrict based on expressed views or behavior, I suspect, are going to tend to have higher than normal rates of mental illness (emphasis that I think it's likely to be a higher rate, not universal).
- taneq 9y ago> A mentally unwell person is likely to feel targeted, oppressed, threatened, harmed, etc. by being silenced. Even a perfectly healthy 'normal' person will feel this way after being (what they see as) unfairly and arbitrarily silenced / disenfranchised.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- adventured 9y agoOf course. I emphasized that I believe it's likely to be a higher than normal rate of mental illness, specifically to preempt the obvious responses I'd get, people will emotionally jump to a conclusion that I'm saying everyone falls into that category. I personally know a few extreme conspiracy theory prone people, that drift into some pretty terrible areas intellectually (from lizard people to anti-semitism). In one case, the person has gotten progressively worse as the years have gone by, they seem crazy at this point. Their views are now being aggressively silenced/blocked by Facebook. I believe mental illness is a not uncommon context with a lot of people that end up like this person and end up getting silenced by the platforms.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- nkrisc 9y agoI don't want to debate the state of her mental wellness as we can only speculate at this time, but I don't think a healthy person would feel that a tech giant is specifically targeting them, even if they think it might be unfair and arbitrary.
- dominotw 9y ago> I don't think a healthy person would feel that a tech giant is specifically targeting them not specifically that person but people who think like him/her.
- koheripbal 9y agoShe didn't think she was being specifically targeted. In one of her rants she specifically stated that she knew of many other content creators having their videos censored, age restricted, and demonetized. Her methods are nuts, obviously, but her beef with Youtube is entirely justified. The end result, unfortunately, isn't going to be Google/Amazon/Facebook/etc... realizing the error of their ways - it's going to be them over-reacting to protect themselves. I expect Silicon Valley campuses will get locked down. I expect any content that even slightly might maybe insinuate violence will get taken down. tldr; The problem is going to get worse before it gets better.
- MBCook 9y agoI don’t agree that will happen, but it may be good if it does. It’s about time many of these companies start to realize their decisions have very real consequences on people’s lives (in who makes money/a living and who doesn’t, harassment levels) and their seemingly capricious decisions and rule changes are very problematic. They’re not the small semi-isolated bubbles they used to be, they’re powerful entities that have large effects on the online economy. Obviously they shouldn’t be subject to physical attacks/assaults/etc. But YouTube is not what it was in 2007 anymore.
- Faark 9y agoYeah, they should probably have censored way earlier to prevent that. They now have to go through with getting rid of the radicals they raised. Or re-open the floodgates, accept even more radicalization and thus even more painful consequences later down the line. Just like most problems, ignoring them rarely makes them go away and you instead loose you most pleasant remaining ways out.
- trhway 9y ago>The platforms today are so large, it surely can seem like being cut off from society in general, like a human right is being revoked. probably similar to say imagine Bell's denying a landline in 197x because of your speech.
- tlrobinson 9y agoI believe that would be illegal because phone companies are “common carriers”? Not sure if that was true in the 70s.
- taneq 9y agoThe implication being that private companies (Google, Facebook, etc.) now fill the role that common carriers did a few decades ago, and that, curiously, they enjoy many of the privileges usually allotted to common carriers (eg. can't be prosecuted for content passing through their networks) without the responsibilities.
- awinder 9y agoIsn’t that fact quickly changing with laws like SESTA? I feel like tech companies have been at forever war against not being afforded common carrier protections in a way phone companies were not, and I wonder if that regulatory uncertainty has led to self-policing & hedging
- adventured 9y agoThere are a bunch of these in society that are interesting and very deserving of more public discussion, including that one (broadly communication access). Given the importance to work and life of having access to the wireless networks today, owned by AT&T, Verizon etc., should they be allowed to blanket deny you access to them as a customer (assuming you can pay)? Especially given the wireless carriers are essentially a group monopoly (spectrum limitations). Or how we take away voting rights for felons, until a certain amount of time after they've been released, or in some states permanently (unless altered by a court order or governor's action). Something like 1 in 40 American adults can't vote right now because of that. It revokes the ability to participate in a critical democratic function. I'd expect an increasingly large societal debate about the context of the platforms and what their rights are when it comes to restricting access. Whether they increasingly get treated as public utilities and if the FCC sets down guidelines/rules for them to comply with on access restriction. That overall conversation probably accelerates the longer they're part of a big part of society. I'm not sure how far that debate will get in the US in regards to actions/regulations, I expect it'll get pretty far in some nations though.
- s2g 9y agoAs opposed to not filtering out awful content and letting people get radicalized via their platforms?
- gaius 9y agoA mentally unwell person is likely to feel targeted, oppressed, threatened, harmed, etc Interesting that we’re going for “mentally unwell” rather than “gun owner” this time.
- adventured 9y ago> Interesting that we’re going for “mentally unwell” rather than “gun owner” this time. We're? Your response comes off as quite rude and dismissive. When in the past did I go for "gun owner" instead of "mentally unwell" or similar, such that your statement makes any sense? Your assumption/s about me and what I believe, have no place on HN, in my opinion. If you want to know what I think about something, you should ask. There's a polite, collegial way to add to the conversation in doing so.
- gaius 9y agoNot you in particular, the collective narrative.
- adventured 9y agoRight, that's my point: I'm not the collective narrative, I'm an individual person, with a mix of beliefs and thoughts on any given subject. You apparently assumed I was projecting something (a narrative?), based on some past experiences you've had. If your guess is incorrect about what I believe and why I'm saying what I am, what then? That's why you ask.
- daenz 9y agoHe could have gone with "extreme animal rights activist"[1] too, depending on how you want to spin it. Mentally unwell best sums up her beliefs + actions. 1 http://www.sandiegouniontribune.com/sdut-peta-protests-militarys-use-pigs-training-2009aug13-htmlstory.html http://www.sandiegouniontribune.com/sdut-peta-protests-milit...
- dragonwriter 9y ago> A mentally unwell person is likely to feel targeted, oppressed, threatened, harmed, etc. by being silenced. A mentally unwell person is equally likely to feel targeted, oppressed, threatened, harmed, etc. by a platform that harbors content which, in fact or merely their perception, endorses, advocates, or directly does any of targeting, oppressing, threatening, or harming them or any group they identify with. Heck, even a mentally well person might reasonably feel that way, though they may be less likely to respond to it violently.
- TheOtherHobbes 9y agoI'm struggling to understand the difference between a mentally unwell person and a mentally unwell corporation or government. I don't think YouTube is mentally unwell, but there have certainly been examples in the past of corporations acting in ways that resulted in the deaths of individuals - either through negligence (justified economically) or through rare but not nonexistent direct corporate violence. Contemporary examples of murderous governments are trivially easy to find. Why do we consider murderous individuals mentally ill, but not murderous groups of individuals once they're beyond a certain level of political and/or economic influence?
- pjc50 9y ago> Why do we consider murderous individuals mentally ill, but not murderous groups of individuals Other way round, surely? Recieving a diagnosis of mental illness is one of the few things that will save a murderer from punishment. There is a tendency for news and the public to reclassify certain kinds of crime as "mentally ill" when they can't, or don't want to understand, the motivations. Often it's a form of terrorism and radicalisation.
- wu-ikkyu 9y ago>Why do we consider murderous individuals mentally ill, but not murderous groups of individuals once they're beyond a certain level of political and/or economic influence? Because "might makes right" is an implicit virtue for many of the most powerful of people.
- 9y ago
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- hycaria 9y agoMaybe with some AI we could target unhealthy people and flatter their egos. Like fake accounts subscribing commenting and agreeing with the troubled soul.
- solarkraft 9y agoThis doesn't make me optimistic for the future of social media.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- nextlevelwizard 9y agodoesn't really help with ad revenue
- wu-ikkyu 9y agoIndeed, how can they sell you stuff you don't need if you're content with the way you are?
- prawn 9y agoIf you have a profile on Instagram and try to build a following through hashtags, this may as well already be true. You tend to get random international followers (at least temporarily) who post fairly inane comments trying to seem engaging. Fake AIs could probably come up with better content!
- hux_ 9y agoYou are talking about people with mental illness. I think the platforms produce mental illness. If you influence and produce a certain kind of behaviour through appropriate reward mechanisms and then after a few years of conditioning reduce/remove the reward what do you think happens? Mental illness. YouTube has conditioned a generation of people to chant "subscribe like and share" like a robots. The day the "subscribe like and share" model stops being viable the robots will break down. For those who care about doing something here is a starting point - humanetech.com
- token_throwaway 9y agoThe platforms might be the difference between crazy and crazier, but nobody is going from normal to psychotic because of YT.
- Wingwing 9y agoWhere has it been described that the woman was suffering from mental illness? That seems like a retroactive label.
- Karunamon 9y agoI think mental illness is automatically implied when you go on a shooting spree for a video sharing site's monetization policies.
- 9y ago
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- cporios 9y agoAs far as I know, her videos were demonetized, not rejected. There's a huge difference between being silenced and being refused ad placement on your videos. Getting paid to express your opinion is not a human right.
- wu-ikkyu 9y agoAt least according to her website, she claimed her videos were hidden from search results.
- falcolas 9y agoAccording to various YouTubers, demonitized videos are penalized in search results, and in their ability to appear on even viewers' home pages.
- holstvoogd 9y agoTru, but if it is your primary income, I can see how people get mad. Mind you, not, lets go shoot some people mad, but still. Being fired by a demonetization algorithm is kinda shitty. Loads of people rely on YT for there income and recent changes to the content algoritms are demonetizing all kinds of video's without any warning or clear indication that it happened (or why ftm) and no real recourse to fix things. It already was a bit of a crap shoot, but now it is quite easy to loose months of income without being acknowledged as a person. I mean, even if you reach the 'you-get-human-support' level of views, you still only get to mail with bots... Anecdotal evidence: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tzb8U0Bje5A https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tzb8U0Bje5A ;)
- lallysingh 9y agoAren't there any competitors that can come into this space?
- cookiecaper 9y agoVid.me tried and failed: https://medium.com/vidme/goodbye-for-now-120b40becafa https://medium.com/vidme/goodbye-for-now-120b40becafa
- ataturk 9y agoAt what point is someone "mentally unwell" versus "revolutionary" though? Because it occurs to me that these huge corporations are trying to rob us of our rights by privatizing free speech and thus doing an end-run around the Constitution. Sites like Youtube are the modern village green in many ways. Also, Google/Alphabet/Whatever the hell they call themselves for tax reasons got pretty stingy about paying the content providers and then the whole "we don't like what you're saying so we'll just demonetize you <click>" thing took place. Do you want angry killers? Because that's how you get angry killers. Finally, Youtube, and social media in general fed the egos of these people. They fed their narcissism and then stole away their claim to fame from them. What did they expect to happen?
- twothamendment 9y agoThis was nearly 20 years ago at the same building the news station was in. Maybe a news station was a platform giant in 1999. I guess it was a very restrictive platform. They talked and you listened. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Triad_Center#1999_shooting_incidents https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Triad_Center#1999_shooting_i... After that, they added some bullet proof doors. Since then the heavy doors sagged and have been replaced with ones that "look better".
- jlarocco 9y agoIt certainly doesn't help that Google's customer support is so terrible. There have been several articles posted here about well known people having to use their high level Google connections or "go viral" just to make Google pay any attention. Combine mental illness with that feeling of helplessness, and it's not going to end well.
- ricochet310 9y agoThe problem isn't the mentally ill person. The problem is building a platform so practically anyone can be heard.
- krapp 9y ago>The problem is building a platform so practically anyone can be heard. That's not a problem. Freedom of speech is never the problem, nor is a platform that practically anyone can publish on a problem.