23 ms·
That's one thing I have noticed in general. I used to think that as a long time customer you are valued and get better deals. But this seems to have changed to
by maxxxxx 9y ago
That's one thing I have noticed in general. I used to think that as a long time customer you are valued and get better deals. But this seems to have changed to the opposite. Long time customers are viewed as something a company doesn't have to compete for anymore and instead more money can be extracted from them. See cell phones, TV cable, car insurance and others. Almost like employment where now the only way to get a raise is often to change jobs and not to stay.
It's a weird development and I wonder what the long term effects of this attitude will be.
- cryptoz 9y ago~15 years ago I sold cellphones for Rogers in Canada and there was the exact same system in place. Long time customers get no deals and deal with effectively rising prices for stale outdated monthly plans, while new customers get discounts and deals out the wazoo. Made a lot of long term customers really angry at me, the sales rep. Thanks Rogers.
- ams6110 9y agoYou can go in and demand the "new customer" deals. I've done it several times with Comcast. It's a pain, but they will do it. Best to do it in person not on the phone. It's not possible online AFAIK.
- AngeloAnolin 9y agoThe opposite thing happens to me though - with regards to communicating with the telecom company. I usually do it over the phone, ensuring that I get escalated to their Customer Care manager, who in essence, have more power to give you better deals. I find most of the staff at kiosks for Telecom companies are only focused on selling, and does not have any power to provide you a deal that you cannot resist.
- c22 9y agoA lot of the "kiosk people" have more power than you'd expect. Sometimes it's just a matter of finding the one who has bothered to explore the system, or goading them into it.
- maxxxxx 9y agoI looked a little over the shoulder of one of the guys in the AT&T store. They can override pretty much all prices. For example this guy gave me a $39 plan for $19 because they had messed up a previous order. He just typed in different price numbers for each item on the bill. I assume they have a certain amount of discounts they can give away each month.
- maxxxxx 9y agoThis constant struggle against not being abused is a real pain. Very unpleasant. Although it probably works for people who are aggressive by nature and live to fight.
- mschuster91 9y ago> Although it probably works for people who are aggressive by nature and live to fight. As these people are in the minority, the companies can afford giving them the goodies - the "suckers" foot the bill regardless.
- Larrikin 9y agoI haven't used them since I only have one bill I realistically have negotiation power on, but BillShark seems like a pretty good deal if they actually are skilled negotiators.
- arkades 9y agoRecently had an issue with Verizon where they flat out refused to give us the new customer discount, regardless of how hard we pushed. Ended up leaving Verizon. Someone will give us the discount, I don’t care if it’s their competitor.
- inferiorhuman 9y ago> You can go in and demand the "new customer" deals. I've done it several times with Comcast. It's a pain, but they will do it. Best to do it in person not on the phone. It's not possible online AFAIK. Sadly, everyone's favorite darling Sonic.net doesn't do this. They will gladly charge long-time customers more than the advertised rate though.
- s73v3r_ 9y agoI just tried this, although I guess I did so on the phone. Cox wouldn't budge.
- nitwit005 9y agoMy parents have the 12 month "deal" expiration from Comcast on their calendar. Every time it expires, they call and say they want to cancel, causing another "deal" to happen. They fully expect it.
- sokoloff 9y agoI used to do that as well. Now, I generally lock in the discount rate for 2 years on the call, cutting my work in half.
- stevewillows 9y agoIts funny that people say this. For me, I've almost always been with Telus. Their Retention department has been great to me over the years. Until recent, I never paid for than $50 for my plan (previously 6gb, lots of minutes, etc), but recently went to that 10gb plan that they were all hustling. I do the same process for internet (both Shaw and Telus). Each company has their own process for getting better rates, but it rarely takes more than fifteen or so minutes a few times per year to get them. I was with Rogers back in 2003 and had their retention give me a killer rate after a few months. For mobile, I always dig through the loyalty threads on Howard Forums first so I know what to expect. [1] https://www.howardforums.com/forum.php https://www.howardforums.com/forum.php
- evrydayhustling 9y agoYes, similar to voting for political positions, being a marginal (or "swing") consumer draws the most benefits. Over time, today's swing consumer becomes tomorrow's safe user, so it is really complacency that is penalized. That makes some sense, but is hardly the utopia where we get to spend less mindshare on fundamental services.
- maxxxxx 9y agoComplacency is the right word. Loyalty gets redefined as complacency that can be exploited.
- joezydeco 9y agoWhen you base the financial success of the company on 'growth', this is what you get.
- karmelapple 9y agoIsn’t it basically the model of places selling addictive things? Cigarettes, alcohol, other drugs - once you’re hooked, the provider can keep upping the price.
- icebraining 9y agoNeither cigarettes nor alcohol are particularly expensive, if you take out the taxes.
- thisisit 9y agoWhile it is weird, the long term effects of this attitude depends entirely on the market. Until there are competitors out there, Uber will keep using this tactic. But, once they get some sort of monopoly everyone is going to be worse off. Something which is happening right now with Grab's acquisition of Uber.
- goerz 9y agoIsn't Lyft a competitor in almost every market? Personally, I always check both Lyft and Uber to see which is cheapest (and wait for a little while, to see if they price fluctuates)
- Consultant32452 9y agoThe anecdote that comes to mind for this phenomenon is the more frequent flyer miles you have the more like you are to get a negative experience such as being bumped from a flight. This is because they know you're invested in their airline and are more likely to come back. A new customer might decide to take a different airline next time. Edit: Apparently this was an old wive's tail or something. Oh well...
- CaptainZapp 9y agoThat's absolutely not logical. With a lot of frequent flier miles you are very likely a status customer and airlines will bump those last and, depending on the status, will bump other low revenue passengers to make space for a high status customer. I know a bit about aviation and if an airline really needs to involuntarily bump a passenger (which is quite rare) they will chose an infrequent flier with a cheap ticket. Unless you can provide a source for your assessment I call bullshit.
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> airlines will bump...low revenue passengers This is accurate per everyone I know at airlines. The reason is it’s trivial to shift one’s loyalty. If an airline goes to shit, I’ll switch from spending cash with them to burning down miles while I book work trips with someone else.
- sidlls 9y agoThat doesn't match my experience. When I have a large reserve of frequent flyer miles I am generally treated quite well, actually. Frequently I have been bumped to first class gratis, or "economy plus" if that is what is available, given discounts/rebates on luggage and other fees, offered complementary access to the airline's lounge/club at the airport, etc. This is all above and in addition to the usual perks, like priority/VIP boarding order or whatever.
- chrissnell 9y ago"Frequent flier miles" don't mean a thing on any major US airlines. The only factor in how they treat you is your overall profitability, which is calculated in elite qualifying miles (EQMs). This is what determines your status and your status determines your perks. These miles come from buying high cost-per-mile tickets, i.e. a $300 SFO-LAX fare, a $20K international first class R/T from IAH to LHR, etc.
- rellui 9y agoDefinitely the result of larger companies with fewer competitions. Around my area there is usually one or two specific providers for any service, for example internet. If they hike the price, there's nowhere else to go.
- icebraining 9y agoWe have four Internet providers in my area, yet they still pull this crap (better prices only for new customers). We've actually switched in the past just for this reason.
- lotsofpulp 9y agoI'm not seeing the problem of offering a discount to new customers. The new customer is taking a risk by accepting a new vendor, and hence to entice them the vendor offers a discount. Now, if the vendor continuously offers the discount to the customer just because they keep asking for it, then that is unfortunate. But I usually only see this with monopolies, like Comcast. I'm sure their strategy is to do that on purpose just to satiate the vocal minority.
- icebraining 9y agoThe problem is that it removes any incentive for loyalty and encourages churn, while being a pain in the ass for the customer. What benefit can possibly come from getting people to constantly switch providers?
- lotsofpulp 9y agoThat would be a problem for discounting for people who threaten to cancel or cancel and re-subscribce. That is not a problem for new customers, who have 1 chance to try a new product.
- icebraining 9y agoIn this case, "new customer" is anyone not currently subscribed. So if you go from provider A to B and then back to A a few months later, you're a new subscriber.
- dalbasal 9y agoThat's a dynamic that emerges frequently. The examples you gave are in good company. Its a side effect of an optimization function, basically. New customers are price sensitive. Loyal customers are.. loyal. They will buy anyway. Advertising is expensive, and discounts can be a cheaper way of getting them. If your decision framework is "do what brings the most growth by lunchtime" you will often end up with new customer perks. If you have freebies and discounts to spread around, spending them on newbies will produce more sales. Politcal campaigns often consider voters in reverse order to loyalty. Party members are guaranteed votes, so don't spend effort courting them. Party supporters need some attention, to bring them out. Fence sitters or potential conversions are courted vigorously. Lots of tech "platforms" will be free for new users, cheap for small users and expensive for big clients. The big clients are more locked in, so it's hard to affect sales one way or another. New/small users are fickle, and more likely to respond to prices. Banks have better rates for new customers, sometimes actual free money. Its like when you don't put effort into dating your wife. It's not the right thing to do, but there are some difficult to avoid consequences to knowing she will go home with you regardless.
- zentiggr 9y agoI've imagined a company (cable phone or some other long term service) that signs everyone up at their full rate, and for every month you stay with them, they add 1% discount till after 50 months you are at 50% of full rate and stay that way. No coupons, no special just for you! offers, just an honest straightforward "we need to collect money to keep things running, but we value our loyal customers most". Fantasy I know.
- janekm 9y agoFantasy indeed... most consumers will prefer the offering of 40% off for the first year instead. Which can even be rational since there will frequently be another company offering a similar discount for switching to them the next year (ignoring intangible switching costs, of course).
- mattmg83 9y agoActually Canvas by Ford (month to month car rental) does this, but yes it's rare
- mathattack 9y agoIt’s because companies have financial incentive to spend resources where they have the biggest impact. Why spend on someone who won’t leave anyway? It took me a while to realize how misplaced my loyalty was. In reality, the loyalty becomes to the individual seller (that specific restaurant owner) or leader rather than corporate entities. For small businesses this type of service still pays. I know bars who hold tables for hours on a Saturday to save them for the regulars who come the rest of the week. But even there, loyalty is to the staff more than the owners.
- blktiger 9y agoYou should never have loyalty to a company, only to an individual (even then you have to be a bit careful; CEOs of public companies for instance, have responsibilities to share-holders which take precedence to their personal opinions and desires).
- rectang 9y agoCompanies are not people. They are single-purpose, amoral, profit-optimizing entities. The larger the company and the more detached the ownership, the less sensitive the company is to any negative effects. Like gut flora, they can be useful to humans -- but they are not like us.
- kodablah 9y ago> It's a weird development and I wonder what the long term effects of this attitude will be. Optimistically, middlemen or automated tools that ease the pain of changing in hard-to-enter markets. In easier-to-enter markets, the emergence of companies respecting simple pricing (we've already seen some of this). Simplicity will win in the long run, again, unless it's a market that can keep competitors out.
- tom_mellior 9y ago> Optimistically, middlemen or automated tools that ease the pain of changing in hard-to-enter markets. Not sure what it's like outside of the EU, but what made it easy and attractive to swich mobile operators here were neither "middlemen or automated tools". It was regulation. Namely, the EU directive that forced mobile operators to allow you to take your phone number with you when switching to another operator. Before this you had to get a new phone number when you switched operators, which was a huge disincentive.
- kodablah 9y agoIt's like that outside the EU too (e.g. in the US).
- blowski 9y agoOnline supermarkets in the UK as well. Your first order, you get £10 off, and a free gift. They encourage you to buy the same products again for 'usability' but hugely increase the prices on everything.
- matthewmacleod 9y agoIt's also just a total pain in the arse. I have no interest in repeatedly shopping around for new providers for things like energy, telecoms, savings accounts and so on. I just want to give a company money in exchange for services and have them continue to provide that service with reasonable increases in price as inflation happens. I feel like I'm constantly being bullshitted – "Good news, we're reducing your savings interest rate!".
- black_puppydog 9y agosee, the comfort of not having to shop around provides value to you. feels much more comfy now, doesn't it? ;)
- kolpa 9y agoYes, but it's a deadweight loss, waste that provides no value to anyone. It's a breakdown of trust leading to market failure. It would be better if the waste was converted to economic profit and the difference split between vendor and client.
- pishpash 9y agoCompetition will solve that. It becomes a problem when you have no effective alternative.
- qyv 9y agoCompanies understand this, that's why you get to pay them a little more for the convenience of not having to shop around.
- Scoundreller 9y agoThen there's a leveraged buyout/new CEO and the rates start creeping up. Initially things are great for shareholders, then they go bankrupt.
- andreasklinger 9y ago
- IloveHN84 9y agoTypical example: Apple old customers are drained like sheeps
- nealabq 9y agoYou mean they're fleeced like cash cows?
- frockington 9y agoI thought Apple price fixed their goods so everybody gets the same price
- sokoloff 9y agoThere are corporate and educational discounts.
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> cell phones, TV cable, car insurance and others Set a reminder to call cancellation every year or so. It’s annoying we have to do this, but it easily saves hundreds if not thousands of dollars a year.
- rdiddly 9y agoLots of examples here, but the one I can't stop thinking about is rent. The longer you stay, the more you pay. To get a decent rate, you have to move. But there's a lot of friction there, and landlords know it.
- gutnor 9y agoThat's the other way around most of the time where I lived (Continental Europe and London) Only in London, people I know have had both experiences. Letting agencies are really the one pushing. For the landlord, a paying tenant is a good tenant, there is friction in changing tenant: you can lose 1 month rent or need to do some refurbishments. Even missing a few weeks can mean losing any benefit of keeping the same tenant at the same rate for 1 or more years. Letting agencies offer a service to both the landlord and the tenant. As a tenant you get a certain level of service, like repairs or maintenance. As a landlord, the agency offer vetted tenant, management and various guarantees. They are the one pushing for rate increase as that's what they take their share from. The real problem with renting is the underlying skyrocketing price of housing. You can't escape it.
- HillaryBriss 9y agoOTOH, also consider local rent control laws, which often only allow a rent increase below the CPI. the longer you stay the more you save.
- 15155 9y agoLiving expenses artificially subsidized by the non-rent-controlled property around you, what's not to like?
- vkou 9y agoAs opposed to living expenses artificially inflated, despite the landlord not putting one iota of work into their property? (Because the neighbourhood gentrified, a new school was built with taxpayer money, Amazon opened an office..?) Property markets are perverse in many different ways, most of which don't benefit renters.
- brudgers 9y agoThe fundamental shift is that more and more businesses are exploiting consumer trust. The shift to online makes it easier. In face to face transactions, the emotional and psychological makeup of a business's sales staff bound what is practical at scale...it's hard to hire a lot of psychopaths into low wage high turnover jobs. The low wages make it hard for people to rationalize continuously taking advantage of trusting individuals, a business really needs high ticket goods and commissions to make it work (e.g. car sales). With automated online transactions there are no ordinary staff who might loose sleep at night over abusing trust.
- piracykills 9y agoYeah, I mean it only makes sense. It's about price discrimination - they don't want to give you a discount if you're willing to pay full price, same reason companies send out coupons or mobile app offers. They want to offer discounts only to bargain hunters and those who otherwise wouldn't be able to afford the service because that's where it's worth spending the money for them. If you're not already, find yourself a local deals site - it can really help you avoid getting screwed over by stuff like this. You can also wind up staying if you're willing to call your current provider back and say "here's what they're offering, beat it or I'm leaving".
- lotsofpulp 9y agoI suspect that for many on this forum, their time would be better spent making more money than figuring out how to save money.
- HillaryBriss 9y agotrue. OTOH, consider the value of the satisfaction you feel pushing back against a business that rips you off.
- lotsofpulp 9y agoIt's just business. If you really feel like pushing back, then focus your efforts on changing legislation or spreading your money around so that we don't only have 2 mobile providers, and 1 internet provider, and 2 taxi options, etc.
- piracykills 9y agoNot so sure, I saved over $1200 this year in about 1 hour of research and 1 hour of phone calls and live chats... my time is definitely not worth $600/hr.
- TrinaryWorksToo 9y agoWhat sort of research did you do?
- ABCLAW 9y agoFinancialization of everything and everything strikes again; we're now routinely applying quality of income measurements to determine book of business value - this means that increasing the current revenue take from recurring customers gives you a huge expected customer LTV bump prior to the increased churn. During this period, your numbers look great, so analysts pop up your ratings, which affords you access to cheaper capital - or alternately you can cash in and sell with a higher valuation multiple on your book. In larger firms, you'd think the incentive would be to account for the drop-off caused by eroded goodwill, but functionally there's a middle level manager who is using this spike in numbers to jump to another role before the piper has to be paid by his replacement. Even if the company blows up, he can lateral safely with his new title.
- DenisM 9y agoI would think the board would setup independent quality of business monitoring commitee as a matter of course. Is that, like, a thing?
- ABCLAW 9y agoSure but in the gap between your changes and the long term change in churn, a third party isn't going to be able to quantitatively monitor future churn rates before they happen. The solution doesn't fix the problem, because the problem is that quality of business models just plain don't sample for customer goodwill - they measure sales metrics rather than feelings. So the sales metrics are gamed at the expense of the consumer feelings that create the metrics in the first place.
- Benjammer 9y agoThe dark side of data rears it's ugly head.
- pishpash 9y agoMore like the dark side of stupid B-school ideas that should be discarded in the dustbin of history. The data is there if one cares to measure them and incentivize properly. But why would they favor that? They are intelligently blind.
- dcchambers 9y agoThis is a major gripe I have with the modern service/subscription-based economy. I give major props to companies that reward loyalty. IntelliJ, for example, offers discounted rates the longer you've been subscribed. It works for them because it's an incentive to never let your subscription lapse, and it rewards the dedicated end-users as well with cheaper prices. Source: https://www.jetbrains.com/store/#edition=commercial https://www.jetbrains.com/store/#edition=commercial
- FridgeSeal 9y agoPlus, perpetual fall-back is nice as well: decide to stop your subscription? You just stop getting updates, rather than losing access altogether.
- nfriedly 9y agoI just called up my ISP and got them to renew the $20/month discount for the 4th year since getting the service. I have to go to the retention department each time, but this time I didn't even have to threaten to switch. Doing this will all of your bills can easily save you hundreds of dollars a year, but it's socially awkward and kind of a pain in the butt (especially if you actually have to switch providers), so most people don't bother. Companies know this and capitalize on it.
- ryandrake 9y agoYou probably have an ISP with competition. I tried the cute “Give me the introductory rate for another year or I’ll cancel!” bluff, and the response from Comcast was: “Just a moment... OK sir your service has been canceled. Have a great day!” Oops
- nfriedly 9y agoLOL, ouch. In my case, windstream is the only wired option.. but they don't seem to realize it. The service used to be completely unreliable too, but as I've complained over the last few years, they seem to have improved things a bit. It's now approaching the reliability of Comcast (i.e. still not great), but at ~1/3 the speed and slightly higher cost.
- gnicholas 9y agoIt certainly helps to have competition but is not required. I have Comcast also, and there are no alternatives where I live (5 miles from Palo Alto, BTW). Sometimes when I call in they immediately give me the discounted rate, and sometimes I have to call in a few times to get a rep who can get it done. Kind of a pain, but worth it to save hundreds of dollars every year.
- knightofmars 9y agoI recently did this with Charter as AT&T is also in our neighborhood. The person at Charter first tried to do an up-sell (which would have cost more money) and eventually came around to saying that they wouldn't offer the lower rate again. At which point I said, "I'm going to AT&T who will give me a better rate, cancel my service." Which resulted in a slightly rude interaction before they canceled my service. A week later AT&T internet was up and running. It's was a very odd interaction given that Charter's fine print says that to qualify for the discount you have to not have subscribed to Charter's services for a mere 30 days[0]. Even with limited competition, now with MiFi hotspots a person could cancel their plan, do a pay-as-you-go MiFi hot spot for 30 days, and then resubscribe with the new rate. (Not sure if Comcast is the same.) [0] "Offers are valid for a limited time only, to qualifying residential customers who have not subscribed to applicable services within the previous 30 days and have no outstanding obligation to Charter."
- loceng 9y agoThe current VC model inevitably leads to this, a similar flaw/holistically inefficient long-term to that of like how the political system/most politicians only sell to the short-term perception to rally shallow needs instead of discussing the depth of what matters.
- amelius 9y agoYes, this should be simply illegal.
- GFischer 9y agoUnfortunately it does work. I worked in insurance, and you definitely got the short end of the stick if you were a loyal customer. New customers got all sorts of incentives. So, perversely, the system encouraged to switch providers every year or every 2 years. Many people (myself included) don't do it because of the hassle.
- xster 9y agoNot to summon my inner Bernie, though if you think about the nature of it, it's actually hard to think of a different outcome than the candycrushification of the producer-consumer relationship in an unregulated monopolizing market (thank god Candy Crush wasn't a monopoly of anything).
- pklausler 9y ago> Almost like employment where now the only way to get a raise is often to change jobs and not to stay. This has always been so, it's nothing new.
- sudomake 9y agoMy health insurance provider try to pull this on me this year. So I went got a better(relatively) plan on the exchange...from them.
- throwaway84742 9y agoSame with employers: if you don’t move around every 2-3 years, they get used to you and divert a part of raises and bonuses to the more uncertain targets. So I always urge people (including my own reports) to look around every now and then, and move to where the grass might be greener.
- tzs 9y ago> I used to think that as a long time customer you are valued and get better deals I bet that would lead to complaints that companies are exploiting the less wealthy. The argument would be that less wealthy people might not be able to afford to switch to a new company where they would not have the long term discount.
- duxup 9y agoA couple decades ago I used to get legit offers from banks or financal institutions on other services or products they offered. They were legit, and sometimes even includes some minor bonus for being a customer (or at least they said so or something was there). In the meantime I'd get really bad offers (I want to say scam, but they were IMO deceptive) from other places (they were still legit financial institutions) for whom spamming me via mail wouldn't cost them much and they'd make plenty if I was dumb enough to take their offer. Then I found I got the same, not a scam... but really bad offers from the places that I had done business with for years. It really irked me when I'd get those fake check (actually a loan) things from a bank I'd been with for ages... Eventually just said screw them and to a credit union who just keeps mailing me about local discounted baseball tickets. I can handle that.
- garfieldnate 9y agoI felt that last week with Amazon: https://twitter.com/garfieldnate/status/977994478911975426 https://twitter.com/garfieldnate/status/977994478911975426. For non-customers they show a nice price to get you into the web site, and for customers they might block an item altogether to get you to sign up for Prime. These days I always check the prices of large things in an incognito window.