14 ms·
Seeing this and simultaneously hearing about what YouTube is doing with certain firearm-related content makes me wonder whether we’re on — or at least near — a
by gnicholas 9y ago
Seeing this and simultaneously hearing about what YouTube is doing with certain firearm-related content makes me wonder whether we’re on — or at least near — a slippery slope.
I can certainly see limiting videos that are illegal (child porn) or that describe things that are illegal throughout the US (converting semiautomatic weapons into automatic).
But banning videos of adult pornography and showing legal firearm-related content is a different beast. A private company surely has the right to decide not to host such content, but consumers can likewise consider whether they want to do business with (including giving unfettered access to email and search queries) a company that proceeds down this slippery slope.
To be clear, I’m not saying we’ve slid down the slope at this point, just that we appear to be perched on/near it.
- twblalock 9y agoIt seems like you're arguing that we are about to slide down a slippery slope of... companies and consumers both doing things they have a right to do?
- gnicholas 9y agoYep, google appears to be on the brink. And yep, consumers have the right to jump ship when google goes too far (in their opinion). Basically, we should make sure not to be a frog that gets boiled (to throw in another metaphor).
- xevb3k 9y agoThe frog metaphor is false (in the sense that frogs do actually jump out, regardless of how slow the water is boiled) [1]. But I think it’s also false in many of the contexts where it’s applied. People do notice change, even if it happens slowly. They’re just not always able to do anything about it. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boiling_frog https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boiling_frog
- scarface74 9y agoI am not pro gun by any stretch of the imagination, but when I heard YouTube was banning firearm related content it made me real uneasy. I didn't have as much of a problem with a crack down on hate speech. I know a lot of people who I would consider gun enthusiasts that wouldn't hurt anyone unless they weren't given a choice.
- strken 9y agoI live in Australia, which is the poster child for gun bans, and it makes me uneasy too. One of my co-workers is a sports shooter who reloads her own ammunition for environmental reasons, and she's already been inconvenienced by the YouTube restrictions. I'm not sure why the gun politics of a foreign country (the US) should impact on her ability to perform basic maintenance. Hopefully this wave of censorship will lead to better privacy-respecting tools.
- LifeLiverTransp 9y agoI think what happens, is a sort of renewal cycle of the internet. It centralizes, giving companys controll, giving goverment content controll via the companys - a state of affairs which gives birth to a new encrypted, decentralized form, which sheds the old, silod and walled in internet like dead snakeskin and beginns to get subverted yet again.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- LifeLiverTransp 9y agoNotice how the ecosystem of parasitic subverters thrives on the company driven siloing and goverment wished for backdoors in monocultured software. The centralization and monolithic architecture is the source of insecurity - an thus its creator of its own downfall and demise. The Centralization is the root-cause of the rampant security issues in recent years.
- 9y ago
- ams6110 9y agoI don't have a problem with the illegal porn ban; people are actually being victimized there. I do have a problem with the gun stuff. Even "how to" videos that result in somehting that's currently illegal. Information should not be banned, and it's a futile effort to try to do that. The internet is too big. Any high school chemistry student learns enough to build a bomb. Should we ban chemistry videos? Ban learning about chemical oxidation? But bottom line, it's Google's service and I guess they can do what they want with it.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- JshWright 9y agoCodysLab is another educational channel having significant issues with strikes.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- rocqua 9y agoThat is true, but it is less obvious of an example. I could see a very careful person actually taking issue with some of his videos. Less so with the other videos.
- chii 9y agowhat issues can be had with Cody'sLab videos? They are completely educational, and in the parts that are dangerous, he clearly warns of it, and also tells you how to do it safely.
- DanBC 9y agoCodysLabs is an odd example. Some of the stuff is poorly set up. He's injured himself several times making videos, and it's only luck that he hasn't had a serious injury. He teaches poor habits and bad practice. But, even with all that, he is educational for people with the attention span to watch. He does a minimal amount of "blowing shit up", and even that tends to be small amounts of explosion with lots of explanation. I think it's weird that Youtube would take that channel down because most people aren't going to have the patience to watch it, and they're not going to copy it. Compare that to this fucking idiot, who has a huge and young audience: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DeNgIWj8ZM0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DeNgIWj8ZM0
- koolba 9y ago> But banning videos of adult pornography and showing legal firearm-related content is a different beast. A private company surely has the right to decide not to host such content, but consumers can likewise consider whether they want to do business with (including giving unfettered access to email and search queries) a company that proceeds down this slippery slope. Sure both businesses and consumers have the right to make their own choices. My issue with the current state of affairs is the blatant push by certain industries, particularly the media, to push one side of an agenda. They glamorize businesses that kowtow to a minority of loud voices as if it's the only acceptable course of action. That may seem like an accomplishment but it could very well be flipped around when the loudest opinion is against you on an issue. > To be clear, I’m not saying we’ve slid down the slope at this point, just that we appear to be perched on/near it. I like to think of it as more of a roller coaster. Some times we're sliding down, some times the momentum carries us back up, and some times we level off for a bit. I just hope that there's enough momentum on the preservation of our rights to carry us through the current wave of hysteria.
- kadenshep 9y ago> a slippery slope. No. The dystopian fetish ever present in popular culture has done more harm than any poorly crafted piece of legislation has ever done in the U.S.
- cooper12 9y agoI wonder how these people even get out of bed considering it could be a slippery slope to murder or something in their overactive and moral-compassless imaginations. I still remember how just a few years ago people were saying legalizing gay marriage would lead to legalized bestiality, death camps for cis couples, required gender transitions for children, etc. Nothing like some hysteria from reactionaries.
- kadenshep 9y agoMystical future historians and grandstanding on my HN? Never! Also have you read 1984? It's a pretty ground breaking book.
- cooper12 9y agoI've been on the internet long enough to notice this mass hysteria. And providing a recent and relevant example is grandstanding, huh? Funny how tangents on freeze peach aren't considered grandstanding to you (especialy when your average HNer couldn't give two fucks about the rights of sex workers except when they can exploit them). And lastly, I read the book for the second time just last week. Most memeified and over-interpreted book in existence. Interestingly there's this reocurring event of two-minutes hate, as well as war fervor against whoever the government has deigned the enemy. This enemy is never the same entity, but during the war fervor, everyone pretends they're the worst when they were just allies a week ago. Seems awfully familiar. I also see some nice examples of doublethink in these types of threads where HNers usually drool over capitalism and the rights of private organizations; and they also pride themselves on being so logical (2 + 2 = 5); yet they can't seem to understand that free speech only applies to the government. Soooooooo Orwellian, oh em gee. It's so cringey hearing people use 1984 as a stand-in for anything and everything when they've barely read the book, or from a high school understanding of it.
- mindslight 9y ago> me wonder whether we’re on — or at least near — a slippery slope. What's with the reservation? Feel that wind in your hair? We are currently flying down the slope, cheered on by the pantheon of gleeful authoritarians each with their cute idea of how individuals are best controlled. The only question is whether we'll have a chance to stop after the centralized surveillance industry has been fully coopted for their goals, or whether the momentum will carry us all the way to oppressing the refuge of Free p2p communications.
- IAmEveryone 9y agoSlippery Slope was coined to describe a logical fallacy. It's funny how things sometimes turn out... Specifically, it's not a meaningful argument because it's far too broad, and applies to more or less anything. Example: "Now they're just banning asbestos and lead. But next year it'll be wood and orange juice!"
- Joeboy 9y ago> Slippery Slope was coined to describe a logical fallacy. Is that true? I always assumed the fallacy was named for the already existing expression.
- wjn0 9y ago> Is that true? I always assumed the fallacy was named for the already existing expression. Funny! I'd never thought of that. For those curious, Wiktionary says that it's actually from the Latin, "fallere", to deceive [1]. [1] https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/fallacy https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/fallacy
- jpttsn 9y agoWho could be against saving the forests and decreasing harmful sugar consumption?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- rhizome 9y agoA private company surely has the right to decide not to host such content And a company can absolutely do that, but paying that much attention to the content of the media changes their responsibilities under the DMCA and Section 230 of the CDA. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Online_Copyright_Infringement_Liability_Limitation_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Online_Copyright_Infringement_...
- icebraining 9y agoThey've always paid attention to the content so the could ban porn. The DMCA says they must not be aware that the content is infringing, and you can't know that just by looking at it.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- yorby 9y agoReddit also has been banning many sub-reddits lately (that didn't do anything illegal)... Almost like someone is pushing all those companies. like /r/gundeals
- ocdtrekkie 9y agoReddit admin's political push has not been even slightly subtle. Bear in mind during the net neutrality nonsense, the entire front page of Reddit was the exact same post, from tons of completely off-topic subreddits. (Why does r/gardening have a net neutrality sticky?) It made Reddit mostly unusable (beyond it's usual uselessness, mind you) for about a week, and most sub moderators were either unwilling to moderate the net neutrality spam, or quite often, the ones posting it. But where it really started to grind my gears was when the Reddit admins posted an announcement proud of it, like it was some sort of accomplishment that the entire site had been replaced by spam of a single post, because, of course, it's a political view they're lobbying for. I have gained a lot of appreciation for HN's ability to allow reasonable debate of all views, and really to keep the site's content enjoyable, interesting, and varied. I can't say remotely the same for where Reddit is right now. If you don't agree with Reddit's political views, you should most likely be looking for alternative websites.
- jotm 9y agoSo they should've stayed neutral is what you're saying? One of the biggest resources in the world. Them removing subreddits is exactly the result of agendas such as removing Net Neutrality. For the right cause, everyone needs to be political. It's how it works.
- FSharper 9y agoI left when they announced support for 300,000 Americans dying each year from Obesity. They think this is a good thing.