8 ms·
Circular Shock Acoustic Waves in Ionosphere Triggered by Launch of Formosat‐5
- SteveNuts 9y agoCan someone ELI5 how this would cause GPS errors?
- sdamodharan 9y agoIonosphere's charge density introduces change in speed of the radio waves passing through it. This messes up with the GPS' calculations which assumes that ionosphere's density doesn't changes rapidly.
- lmm 9y agoGPS works by computing your distance from satellites by measuring how long it takes radio signals from those satellite to reach you. As an electromagnetic wave, radio moves at a different speed through plasma (which is full of charged particles) than through holes in that plasma, so this will change how long those radio signals take to reach you, which will change how far away from the satellite you think you are.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- stanmancan 9y agoCan this cause any other issues other than GPS errors? Lines like It is followed by ionospheric hole (plasma depletions) due to rapid chemical reactions of rocket exhaust plumes and ionospheric plasma. sound concerning but that's most likely because I only understand half the words, and have even less of an understanding when they're strung together in that manner!
- lainga 9y agoIt is followed by ionospheric hole (should be It was... holes) A ~900km wide patch of the ion blanket around the earth became thinner. Probably in the density sense, not the size sense: there was less plasma there than normal. (The abstract measures this in terms of how many electrons they counted in that area.) due to rapid chemical reactions of rocket exhaust plumes and ionospheric plasma. They think the thin patch was caused because the Falcon's exhaust reacted with the ion blanket. I'm not sure how.
- wlesieutre 9y agoI'm curious about this too. The Falcon burns RP-1, essentially a very refined kerosene, with liquid oxygen. Exhaust should be water, carbon dioxide, and a bit of carbon monoxide. Not typically the most reactive things, but perhaps there are different interactions with plasma?
- lainga 9y agoThis other paper [0] seems to indicate that TEC (total electron count) fluctuations are caused by shock waves, not rapid chemical reactions, and can arise from ground explosions as well. IANA ionosphere scientist, so I don't know if the parent paper made a mistake. [0] https://arxiv.org/pdf/physics/0007043.pdf https://arxiv.org/pdf/physics/0007043.pdf
- marcosdumay 9y agoAnything is reactive when interacting with plasma. There should be little of those gases naturally up there (mostly so for water), and even throwing a large mass of gases up there may be enough to disturb everything.
- hinkley 9y agoI wonder if in the future this means large rockets may have to throttle back while transitioning through the ionosphere to reduce side effects? Is the altitude stable enough to predict it accurately for a given launch?
- blattimwind 9y agoIt might affect short wave propagation and things like atmospheric electricity.
- kodis 9y agoI wonder why a SpaceX Falcon-9 was singled out. Wouldn't any sufficiently large rocket have the same effect? And if so, wouldn't the Falcon heavy cause an even more dramatic effect?
- fooker 9y agoA sufficiently large rocket with a similar payload being launched to reach a similar orbit. Apparently that combination is not very common.
- staplers 9y agoRead the article before asking questions. "This unique nearly vertical trajectory is different from the usual satellite launches that the rockets fly over horizontal trajectory "
- davidcuddeback 9y agoTo add to that, also from the article: "This is the largest rocket‐induced circular SAWs on record."
- 1137 9y agoI would but the site's not responding for me.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- eganist 9y agoI'm taking the liberty of reworking their "plain language summary." I aimed for maintaining accuracy with relaxed precision, but please correct me if I've lost too much of either in the process. I corrected a specific bit of imprecision in language in the source's plaintext summary not clearly distinguishing between vertical/y v. vertical/z, something the technical abstract clarified by stating "vertical altitude." --- In plainest language, the rocket was lobbed up, not hurled forward, and this resulted in a shock wave that was followed some interesting reactions in the ionosphere between the rocket exhaust plume and the plasma in the ionosphere, all of which need further study because of potential risks to things like how accurate your GPS might be in the area around the "hole" caused by these reactions. --- Plain(er) Language Summary On 24 August 2017, a SpaceX Falcon 9 rocket took off from Vandenberg Air Force Base in California, carrying Taiwan's FORMOSAT‐5 Earth observation satellite into orbit. The lightly weighted solo payload lets the rocket fly a path higher than the bare minimum to insert the payload directly where it needs to operate (the mission altitude), at 720 km. This unique nearly vertical path away from the ground is different from the usual satellite launches where rockets fly over horizontal paths more closely to the ground and insert satellites at 200 km above Earth and rely on orbit maneuvers to reach mission altitudes. Because of this lofty (more vertical) launch path, the rocket launch generated a gigantic circular shock wave in the ionosphere covering a wide area four times greater than California. It is followed by an ionospheric hole (plasma depletions) due to rapid chemical reactions of rocket exhaust plumes and ionospheric plasma. Large spatial gradients caused by these reactions and the resulting hole could lead to ~1 m range errors into GPS navigation and positioning system. Understanding how the rocket launches affect our upper atmosphere and space environment is important as these human-caused space weather events are expected to increase at an enormous rate in the near future.
- gremy0 9y agohmm, I put your "plainest" language answer into XKCD simple writer, and there was some complexity in there. In most simple language, the space truck was thrown up, not tossed forward, and this caused a sound wave that was followed with some interesting events in one of the high bits of the sky, between the space truck refuse air and the hotter-than-air stuff in the high sky, all of which need further study because of possible bad things like how true your sky-computer computer-map might be in the area around the "hole" caused by these waves.
- m3kw9 9y agoEven plainer language: Rocket exhaust can have impact with atmosphere, we need to study it more on short and long term effects.
- eganist 9y agoThis is ELI5 territory, which is cool because we probably need one of these as well.
- m3kw9 9y agoI call it EOD explanation.
- uryga 9y agoEOD?
- gffrd 9y agoI'm assuming "End Of Day." As in, after a full day, my brain is fatigued from overly-complex discussions and just needs the most direct, un-fussy information possible. That sound right, mk3w9?
- woweeeee 9y agoExplosive Ordnance Disposal
- richmarr 9y agoEsoteric Order of Dagon
- m3kw9 9y agoYes, the - at the “End of the Day” EOD
- taneq 9y agoThe rocket made the air go funny which meant your phone got confused about where it was.
- jessaustin 9y agoThe worst such event on record caused errors of ~1 meter. I didn't think civilian GPS was that precise anyway, and that's why various schemes are used in conjunction with GPS for greater accuracy? Presumably, military GPS has similar schemes to deal with this sort of event?
- donohoe 9y agoUS currently claims 4m RMS (7.8m 95% Confidence Interval) horizontal accuracy for civilian (SPS) GPS. Some devices/locations reliably (95% of the time or better) can get 3m accuracy.
- jhayward 9y agoYes, my expectation is that standard consumer-grade devices with GPS capability (even using tiny chip antennas) can achieve ~2.5M horizontal on L1 when using WAAS/SBAS augmentation.
- Rebelgecko 9y agoMilitary GPSs use multiple frequencies which helps them mitigate errors from the ionosphere. NOAA publishes enough space weather data to let commercial receivers make their own corrections, but I don't know if any actually do. In the relatively near future, GPS satellites will broadcast multiple frequencies for civilian use, once commercial receivers catch up everyone should be able to reduce the error due to atmospheric conditions
- peterwwillis 9y agoCivilian devices can use two frequencies as well, they just don't for cost and complexity reasons. The new L5 frequency has been available for some time and new devices supporting it are coming out this year. There are also multiple augmentations users can use to increase their accuracy to even greater levels than military users: https://www.gps.gov/systems/augmentations/ https://www.gps.gov/systems/augmentations/
- ethbro 9y ago
- mattbeckman 9y agoCould major GPS issues become a nonstarter for the BFR intercontinental transport vision?
- ethbro 9y agoMaybe that's why the BFR interplanetary version is the focus. Screwing up GPS is less of a deal when you're leaving the planet for good... ;)
- dpflan 9y agoAre there any noted events in history that have exploited such ionosphere disturbances?
- bwang29 9y agoPlainer news headline style "SpaceX Falcon 9 launch might have interfered GPS signal coverage in area three times larger than California"
- lwhalen 9y agoI'd be curious to know roughly how long the disturbance lasted. Did it dissipate/recover in minutes, or did it stick around for the better part of a day (or two, or three)?
- pavon 9y agoAccording to arstechnica's reporting on the paper (I don't have access to full text): "In the case of this Falcon 9 launch, it induced a plasma hole that lasted for two to three hours, which a magnitude comparable to a magnetic storm" https://arstechnica.com/science/2018/03/spacex-launch-last-year-punched-huge-temporary-hole-in-the-ionosphere/ https://arstechnica.com/science/2018/03/spacex-launch-last-y...
- bdamm 9y agoDid anyone try downloading the actual paper? My browser opened and then closed a tab. Kind of odd.
- cbhl 9y agoThe paper is behind a paywall. It probably went back to the abstract page because the login / buy panel is on the right side of that page. Maybe see if your local library or university has an institutional subscription you can use to access the paper?
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoThe paper is on scihub.
- zaroth 9y agoI thought orbiting was all about horizontal velocity, otherwise what comes up must come down! Did the rocket just turn sideways to accumulate the necessary horizontal velocity to actually maintain an orbit at a much later phase in its flight?
- Tuna-Fish 9y agoYes, absolutely. The total sideways velocity required is fixed, going on a steeper trajectory requires more fuel for the same target orbit. The reason Falcon 9 still does that sometimes is that a more vertical trajectory makes the return flight back to the launchpad easier. So if the payload is light enough that there is enough free delta-v, they want to do that. If there isn't, they land on the barge or fly expendable.
- InclinedPlane 9y agoIt is almost, but not quite, entirely about horizontal velocity. You also need sufficient altitude to be outside the atmosphere, as orbits with altitudes of under 100km are very short lived. Additionally, it's generally not great to try to spend a lot of time accelerating through the atmosphere. For this reason rockets tend to fly upwards and then once they are out of the bulk of the atmosphere they fly mostly sideways.
- stonlyb 9y agoRelated at all to the flight delays earlier today?
- lopmotr 9y agoSAW also means Surface Acoustic Wave which is a different type of wave like what travels along the ground in an earthquake. That's a terrible double use of an acronym! I think the author of this story might have just made it up and not seen the existing meaning.
- krick 9y agoEvery time somebody else burns a hole in the ozone layer I wonder if they did it over their home or over mine. Somehow I don't expect to be pleased by the answer.
- jazoom 9y agoAs an Australian this is what we've had to deal with for decades. We don't produce much pollution but the hole is largely over us and giving us skin cancer.