10 ms·
Airlines propose long list of rules to kill or revise
- em3rgent0rdr 9y agoWill US airlines also propose to get rid of rules preventing foreign airlines from competing with domestic flights? http://www.slate.com/articles/health_and_science/transportation/2013/08/cabotage_will_revive_airline_competition_foreign_airlines_should_be_able.html http://www.slate.com/articles/health_and_science/transportat...
- Someone1234 9y agoWhich may actually reduce costs and increase consumer choice, their stated goal of this whole imitative. Somehow I don't expect that to be one of the cut regulations.
- nradov 9y agoAn "open skies" rule allowing foreign carriers to operate flights would reduce prices and increase consumer choice, however the restriction exists primarily for national security reasons. The federal government needs a large domestic airline industry as a strategic transportation reserve that they can commandeer to move troops during a war or other large emergency.
- smnrchrds 9y agoI imagine in those cases the government can and will force any airplane in American soil or airspace to act like this, whether they are owned by an American or foreign corporation.
- rgbrenner 9y agoSure for a minor incident. But any foreign airline would immediately move their planes out of the US if war broke out. And there would generally be warning signs before it happens, giving them plenty of time to discontinue flights.
- nradov 9y agoYour imagination is not realistic. There's no legal way to require foreign pilots who are citizens of another country to follow US government orders. And it's not possible in the short term to put US pilots on those airplanes because each airline has a unique combination of airframes, engines, and avionics. Plus if the maintenance and logistics infrastructure aren't located in the USA then those airplanes would quickly become inoperable.
- an_account 9y agoA foreign airline operating domestic routes in the US would likely use many US pilots/employees.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- sorenjan 9y agoThat seems as anachronistic as the second amendment. The US military has its own logistics, and that's an understatement. 45 C-5, 222 C-17, 333 C-130. It's nothing but a pretext to protect domestic companies instead of doing what's best for the citizens.
- nradov 9y agoProtectionism is certainly a factor but you don't seem to understand how much airlift is required to sustain an expeditionary military in the field. Current transport capacity has been stretched for years with the ongoing conflicts. At any given time many of those aircraft are out of service for maintenance.
- sorenjan 9y agoTo quote the Slate article linked above: > In practice, despite fighting two wars simultaneously for a decade, CRAF seems to have been activated just once at the very beginning of the Iraq War when the Pentagon activated 47 passenger aircraft and 31 wide-body cargo planes. > On the other hand, as a 2006 Congressional Research Service report on the program observed, “the program is voluntary” and domestic airlines participate in it because it’s financially beneficial to them. But my main gripe with it is that the US government apparently thinks it more important to maintain a military airlift reserve to be able to quickly fly soldiers and equipment to other parts of the world in a hypothetical future war than to let their own citizens have a well functioning free market that would give them more affordable transportation everyday. It's nothing but corporations first, citizens last, under the guise of national security. Just like the new steel tariffs are said to be because of national security.
- nradov 9y agoSome things are more important than well-functioning free markets. The recent wars have actually been relatively small with only a small fraction of the total military deployed at any given time. CRAF is an insurance policy for a potential major future conflict that requires transporting the bulk of the military around the world on short notice. All wars are hypothetical ... until someone starts shooting.
- bbarn 9y agoIt was a sad day when Virgin was sold out from underneath Branson, because of this very regulation.
- rayiner 9y agoWhen foreign countries stop heavily subsidizing their airlines, sure. It’s not free trade to allow subsidized products into your country, it’s economic lunacy.
- lemonforest 9y ago-rule to kill; don't kill pets and don't bludgeon passengers. !profit.
- Someone1234 9y ago> Now, the Trump administration may roll back a rule that requires airlines to give passengers such as Hill the option of getting off a flight that is delayed too long on an airport tarmac. And that's not the only regulation that might be weakened or scrapped. With or without this rule, I could never quite grasp how it wasn't tantamount to kidnapping? At least within a "reasonableness test." Obviously if you're at 10K feet, and ask to get out, reasonably the airline cannot comply. But if you're sitting on the tarmac of an airport, there's no reasonable argument for why they cannot de-board people after a two or three hour delay. It fails the reasonableness test. Before this rule was introduced airlines did this a lot. Several people literally set off the escape slides trying to get out, called 911, or got arrested for asserting their rights. Is that really something we want to return to? I get that this administration is anti-regulation, but this was a hugely dehumanising situation before that isn't legal in other countries for just that reason. I'd hope if they do remove it individual states step in to re-instate it immediately.
- ams6110 9y agoReturn to the gate (is one available? probably not) burning thousands of dollars of extra fuel, disrupting the gate schedule and inconveniencing perhaps thousands of other passengers to allow one person to disembark? Sounds unreasonable to me. Also there is an upper bound on this sort of thing because crews have duty hour limits. They are not allowed to take off if they will be over the limit before they land, so there's only so much time they can spend waiting on the ground before they know they aren't leaving today, at least not with that crew.
- bbarn 9y agoThe plane shouldn't be leaving the gate if it's not planned to depart in the next half hour. Shuffling passengers from "relative" comfort in a terminal vs. putting them in a hot box for hours without the ability to go to the restroom, is wrong. Arriving planes can deplane people, back away empty if they aren't leaving soon instead of filling up with their next cargo, allow other planes to arrive and deplane, and idle WITHOUT human beings for the sake of a little fuel cost savings.
- pimlottc 9y agoWarning: embedded autoplay video ad
- blauditore 9y agoWhy go back and forth with those rules, but never talk about the ridiculous "security" rules introduced after 9/11? Most of it is just security theater and cannot prevent a well-planned terrorist attack. But no one dares touching that topic, apparently.
- Spivak 9y agoIs this not the same argument people use when talking about bad software security practices? Seems odd to flip when the discussion isn't about tech. Physical security is still a spectrum and depends on what kinds of threats you're trying to prevent. There are certainly a number of arguments against the TSA but "a sufficiently well planed and executed attack could get around the checks" isn't one of them. Just because you can't defend against state-level adversaries doesn't mean you shouldn't have a password on your phone. Just because your door could be broken down with a battering ram doesn't mean it's pointless to have a lock.
- blauditore 9y agoWell, I totally agree where this applies, like that knifes and guns are not permitted. But there are also other, quite ridiculous measures that target to prevent high-profile attacks. One of the most infamous ones is prohibiting liquids. That's like putting your phone into a Faraday cage to defend against fraud calls.
- amluto 9y agoI find the proposed elimination of the rule requiring advertisement of the full price to be odd. Wouldn’t an honest Republican administration be in favor of price transparency as a measure that increases the efficiency of the free market?
- maxerickson 9y agoAt this point it is a request coming from an airline group. Lots of people think that the fees and taxes should be made clear so that people are aware that they are paying them, but there's no reason that can't be done in addition to showing the actual cost of purchasing a given ticket.
- lisper 9y agoExactly, which is what reveals this particular proposal to be disingenuous.
- maxxxxx 9y agoThat's one thing to bugs me in the US with a lot of products. The price you actually pay is often vastly different from the advertised price. I don't really care if there is some additional fee they have to pay. It's their cost of doing business. Maybe I should start a business that advertises everything for free. Then add management fees, sales tax, cost on loans, employee payment fee and so on.
- zajd 9y agoWhat makes you think Republicans care about increases in the efficiency of the free market?
- maxxxxx 9y agoTheir interpretation of "free market" is one where companies can do whatever they want, not functioning market as in price transparency. The same could be said for health care. They always talk about the market but as patient you have no market power since you don't get any prices and I haven't seen any Republican effort to address this.
- 9y ago
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- paws 9y agoAirlines for America, in its filing, said the [24-hour cancellation] rule allows passengers to hold "an unlimited number of reservations at once, free of any cancellation penalty during the 24-hour hold period," thus eliminating a carrier's ability to sell those seats to another buyer. "eliminating a carrier's ability to sell"? What a bunch of horse puckey. 1) Airlines routinely oversell flights. It seems unlikely random individual passengers are buying out a bunch of seats just to cancel at hour 23. 2) Even if that were considered a risk, a passenger would still need to pay for the seats upfront.
- ghufran_syed 9y agoWhy not make a rule where each passenger delayed on a plane more than x% of the total journey time, gets $y per hour of delay?
- Symbiote 9y agoThe EU rules [1] give compensation of €250, €400 or €600 for flights of <1500km, <3500km, >3500km, with a delay of over 3 hours. For example, a 9 hour late departure due to a "technical problem" led to me missing a once-daily connection, and an eventual 24 hour delay in arrival. The distance was 3000km, so I got €400 compensation. Also, a meal voucher at the departure airport, and a hotel overnight + breakfast at the connection airport. The rules apply on all flights within the EU, all flights originating in the EU, and flights into the EU operated by EU airlines. [1] https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/index_en.htm https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-right...
- Bizarro 9y agoYou're no longer a "free person" once you hop on that plane. So since the government has instituted more and more rules to take away your civil rights in an airport/airliner they should give us a break, and give us some options to get us back to the free world.