14 ms·
Why Cities Boom While Towns Struggle
- montrose 9y agoThis seems a very important point, if it's correct. It affects so many of the big stories we see in the news, from SV's housing shortage to the widening gap between Republicans and Democrats. It would also mean that Y Combinator making founders move to SV (at least temporarily) turns out to be perfectly aligned with the times. "The emerging knowledge economy, Mr. Moretti argues, depends on constant innovation, which turns out to be a social process. To succeed, cities need a critical mass of highly educated workers engaged in the regular, often informal, exchange of ideas. Once this critical mass comes into being, it feeds on itself: Innovation hubs attract new innovators in a self-reinforcing process, while areas lacking this critical mass fall further behind. In the early stage of the information revolution, it was fashionable to argue that new technologies would eliminate distance. People could do creative work in rural Colorado and communicate their ideas anywhere on earth with the flick of a finger. This thesis rested on an excessively individualistic understanding of creativity. In fact, remote exchanges of ideas are no substitute for the elemental human process of face-to-face communication. Innovators don’t do their work in isolation; they stimulate one another."
- meric 9y agoIn the early stage of the information revolution, it was fashionable to argue that new technologies would eliminate distance. People could do creative work in rural Colorado and communicate their ideas anywhere on earth with the flick of a finger. I think that effect is true to a limited extent. People could do creative work in countries such as Vietnam, India, Thailand and communicate their ideas to anywhere on Earth; The equalisation of Geography didn't apply between rural vs urban. It applied between developed and developing countries. I can speculate several reasons why, but without deep enough research or sources I'll leave them as an exercise for the reader. (https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=bsder https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=bsder is an interesting comment)
- closeparen 9y ago"Economies of agglomeration" [0] have explained the phenomenon of urbanization for quite a while. It's not a stretch to think that there's an intellectual corollary. Why do university researchers work in centralized walkable enclaves? Greater connectivity amplifies the productivity of headquarters cities by enabling them to more readily project their power and distribute their output globally. With easy access to the output of Silicon Valley/Seattle/New York, there's less reason for each Nowheresville to have its own knowledge-work economy. The once-powerful bank manager of your local Chase is replaced by an algorithm in New York. The once-lucrative IT systems engineering work at your local manufacturer is replaced by AWS in Seattle. And so on. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economies_of_agglomeration https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economies_of_agglomeration
- api 9y ago... which is a terrible, terrible thing and a recipe for the rise of disastrous politics or even the descent of the majority of humanity into a new dark age. The phenomenon you describe is a problem. It's one of the greatest problems of the early 21st century.
- cryptonector 9y agoExplain?
- jjeaff 9y agoThe current US president is a result of the process you described. If that's not a big problem, I don't know what is. And it's caused by people in "towns" unable to find work and unhappy because if it.
- mr_overalls 9y agoI think Trump's rise isn't explicable only in the light of _economic_ stagnation in small towns. Growing insularity and racism (or maybe a climate where those are freely expressed?) are to blame as well.
- nawitus 9y ago"The emerging knowledge economy, Mr. Moretti argues, depends on constant innovation, which turns out to be a social process." Why can't this happen online?
- viraptor 9y agoIt's hard to find niche forums where you have small communities these days. Or maybe I lost touch with what the young crowd is doing. From my school times, I remember hanging out on forums where we worked on things like reverse engineering Siemens feature phones. Or my town's IRC channel. Or weird international places like cdc discussions (or was it nsf?). I don't even know we're I could find people with commitment to such ideas anymore. Maybe some private slack instances, or diving into one of the distributed Twitter replacements? I'm not saying these were placed where invocation actually happened, but I know they were a jump start place for many people. It's hard to have meaningful, small, dedicated communities online these days. Anything good gets popular and anything too popular gets bad in the end.
- nawitus 9y agoThere's still communities for niches. Subreddits, Facebook groups, forums, Slack instances etc.
- mistermann 9y agoI think to a degree the runaway success of Stackoverflow had the unfortunate side effect of sucking enough of the oxygen away from some dedicated forums to kill the critical mass needed to maintain these communities on an ongoing basis.
- closeparen 9y agoHave you ever tried working on a difficult bug or vague and ill-defined new problem space with a combination of local and remote coworkers? Can it happen online? Probably. But proximity vastly decreases friction and increases the chances of success. Even between offices with enterprise-grade fibre and high-end videoconferencing-integrated conference rooms, telepresence isn't that good yet. There's no substitute for unscheduled hallway conversations and impromptu whiteboarding. These things might be unnecessary distractions if your job is to churn out code that fulfills well-defined specifications, but if you're doing something new and innovative and not fully understood yet, or something complex enough to require deep interactions with your coworkers (beyond task assignment and status updates), they are a major boon.
- austincheney 9y ago> "which turns out to be a social process." I used to agree with this 100%, particularly as I was teaching myself to program. Now I don't. Not even a little bit. I learned to program, almost entirely, on my own, in a vacuum. I started learning to program just before I was pulled into my second military deployment, years on the job at Travelocity, and then refined my skills during my third military deployment. It wasn't completely a vacuum as I could talk to people online. I learned most of my early architectural concepts from practicing against the recommendations of Douglas Crockford. I had nobody in the real world I talked to about my programming. In reflection this made me a substantially better programmer, and I never realized it until somebody in the military explained why. I am a JavaScript developer. I first started learning to program just before abstraction libraries became the religious dogma that nobody could live without and ultimately coalesced around jQuery. This was not a technology phenomenon it was a social phenomenon. I largely missed the insanity that was so popular in the social business world as I was bouncing around various FOBs in Afghanistan without an internet connection. I learned to write against the vanilla DOM and optimize my code to perform quickly, cross browser, with simplified logic. I didn't an abstraction library and a bunch of dependencies to slow me down. When I came back to Travelocity my ability to write fast code in the browser that just always seemed to work earned me a promotion and I became a senior developer and the A/B test experiment guy for the company. When I started my second deployment I taught myself to program by writing an open source code beautification tool that worked in the browser. Node.js was just invented and I wasn't aware of it just yet, so my tool was limited to the browser. I taught myself language parsing for various different kinds of grammars. Much of this code mostly worked but it was poorly constructed and certainly not 100%. When I was sucked into my third deployment I wasn't skilled enough to be a software architect. I had more learning to do, but a few months in I really learned to refine my approach to architecture and wrote some new language parsers from scratch that turned out to be solid and extensible. At this time while I was again out of the mix from the corporate world large MVC frameworks became the rave that suddenly became the thing developers could not live without. I learned to live without them and continued programming on my own refining and extending my little open source application. I was easily able to apply the architectural concepts I taught myself in place of large generic MVC frameworks to produce code that is significantly smaller and generally executes much faster. Late into my third deployment I overheard a conversation about the origins of Best Buy. The key guy, Richard Schulze, never went to industry trade conventions or focused on common industry practices for doing business of his new "Best Buy" store model. He had found the concept by accident and refined it over time into a more retail without commission concept that allowed his stores to out sell the competition. This was a process of refinement and reward over time by practice and experimentation. The concept was successful because it discard the social process of industry peers! The social process is a means of validation. It lets you know how you fare against the median population you are competing against. If your goal is to be average the social process is your guide. If you want to be more than that you have to be willing to step back from what is popular.
- flexie 9y agoI believe it’s true, yet some of the best work of man was done largely alone. Einstein had his miracle year not at a university but by himself at the patent agency in which he worked and at home in his apartment in Bern. He was all but isolated from peers with very little face-to-face time with anyone who understood just a little about advanced physics. In our time, he could have been working from home somewhere in a small town, couldn’t he?
- hyperpallium 9y agoHe actually had a little club of three people, who discussed physics. However, I'm not sure of the time line, I think it was before his miracle year. Explaining an idea to someone (rubber ducking) can help a lot. It may be that he had the hint of the ideas before, and spent a year working out the details, and writing them up.
- oblio 9y agoEverybody likes to pick these miraculous examples. Sure, Einstein worked alone. Did the people who expanded and industrialized his theories also worked alone? I’d say solo genius, lone wolf kind of work is the minority of work. And it’s probably not enough to keep employed huge masses of people.
- omgPhysics 9y agoExplain Linux with this rational... the most successful and possibly most innovative project of our lifetime.
- jcfrei 9y agoLinus started development at the University of Helsinki...
- omgPhysics 9y agoHe is also one of the biggest proponents of working only through online communication. He, as the sole contributor to Linux at that point with famed single line license, release linux to the open internet. The entire philosophy is based on the idea of: 1. Being open to skepticism (this includes being technically evaluated on your work, which is possible through public submission of that work) 2. Allowing people to work on the things at which they excel. If you don't subscribe to these ideas, it doesn't matter where you work, how you work or what you do. It will not be 'innovative'.
- selectodude 9y agoOver 20 percent of kernel contributions come from Intel and Red Hat. Over 90 percent of patches are written by people who work for corporations. Linux wouldn't be 10 percent of what it is now if it relied solely on volunteers communicating on the LKML.
- hutzlibu 9y agoDoes it matter, that they work for corporation or on their own, when the topic was that the overall working process of Linux is mainly online? ation?p
- selectodude 9y agoSure it does. Most kernel development is done by developers working in an office. They don't have to brainstorm over the LKML.
- bsder 9y agoI, personally, would flip this around. It's that towns have far too much friction. If I'm in a city, the airport is probably less than 30 minutes away. A town means 2+ hours to the airport or a ticket that is triple or quadruple from the tiny commuter airport. If I'm in a city, a lot of office space already has a fiber connection. If I'm in a town, people will shrug and wonder what I'm talking about. If I'm in a city, I probably get daily early deliveries from UPS and FedEx--maybe even multiple ones. If I'm in a town, I get a late delivery and pickup and that's it. In my hometown, the FedEx office wasn't open 3 days a week. I can go on and on. Running a business is risky enough without adding all that friction on top of it.
- analog31 9y agoThere's also friction for workers. If you work in a town, and your job sucks or your employer fails, you may have to move to another town. In a city, you pick up your bag and walk across the street. On the other hand if you live in a city and the schools fail, then you're hosed.
- toomuchtodo 9y agoI’ll take my economic chances before having to live in the city. The quality of life just isn’t there. Lower costs in the suburbs or rural areas means my runway is much longer than in the city, which offsets the job availability (6 months of city non-discretionary expenses is a year or more outside the city). I can also afford a 4 bed/2.5 bath house with a pool on a quarter acre, which would be impossible in the city.
- strandedinburbs 9y agoYour entire lifestyle is subsidized by the cities surrounding your unsubstainable, racist hobbitholes. You couldn't actually afford to live like that if you actually had to pay the full cost of living in society. But you don't. You suck off civilizations teet while pretending that you make it entirely on your own
- Terr_ 9y ago
- powerstructures 9y agoThe power structures (formal and informal) in towns are stifling. They tend to be fairly unified or homogenous. Formal (new businesses challenging established players, even indirectly such as competing for talent) and informal (personal and/or political nonconformity) challenges to these power structures are punished mercilessly. This is less true in cities, because with greater scale (and broader power structures with more players,) small "threats" to the established order can emerge and incubate, or even be nurtured by large competitors (think VC) without being directly crushed.
- sverige 9y agoHaving lived in both, I have found that informal challenges to power structures in cities are much more merciless. Ask any (nonconforming) conservative in nearly any large city, especially on either coast. Or in any online forum dominated by people from such places, for that matter. On the other hand, people in the small towns and small cities that I have lived in are much more tolerant of the nonconforming aspects of my personal views and lifestyle -- which, ironically, they tend to view as 'liberal,' even though objectively I am much more 'conservative' than they are in most respects. This new world driven by the constant emphasis on differences rather than on commonalities is exhausting, frankly.
- Splatter 9y ago> This new world driven by the constant emphasis on differences rather than on commonalities is exhausting, frankly. I know this is technically off-topic and I'll likely be down-voted for an "Amen" post. But, Amen. I seek, and have yet to find, a venue where folks regularly embrace commonalities, much less celebrate them, while together seeking solutions to society's ills from politically-competing perspectives.
- liveoneggs 9y agoisn't that supposed to be how church works?
- nitwit005 9y ago
- QasimK 9y agoIs there any way to actually read this? I can’t get past the first couple of paragraphs before a subscribe/log in
- randomdata 9y agoThe answer seems to be to use Chrome. Other browsers get the paywall.
- strathmeyer 9y agoDoesn't work in Chrome here. Why is it so hard for some people to post good links?
- thesumofall 9y agoThat’s what the “Web” link in HN is for
- adjkant 9y agohttps://outline.com/mJN8RV https://outline.com/mJN8RV Outline beats most major paywalls.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- randomdata 9y agoHow do we measure struggle here? Looking at data for the small town I grew up in (current population: 1,200), it has grown by nearly 20% in the last five years. Compared to the nearest major city (~150 miles away), the median household income is 16% higher and the median individual income is 32% higher. The unemployment rate is 22% lower. None of that seems to indicate struggle to me, and anecdotally being able to get back and visit time to time, it doesn't feel like it is struggling. Booming seems more appropriate. What may be notable is that the largest employer in town is a tech company who seems to have done quite well for itself, now employing about 150 people. I would suggest the town is doing well because of this company and the spinoffs that have come from it's success. That suggests to me that it may simply be that success begets success. Cities boom because they have have preexisting success stories to build from, small towns not necessarily.
- mathgeek 9y agoThe article is measuring struggle in aggregate. Your hometown, while it sounds like it is indeed booming, is a single data point.
- randomdata 9y agoThat was partially my point though. If success begets success, cities are biased by the fact that they have already been successful. All communities started with nobody. A major business success of some kind is why these particular locations became cities over other communities. Without a major success story under the belt of a small town, there is lack of capital, lack of expertise, lack of attention from the rest of the world, etc. that places with those success stories are able to thrive with. I mentioned my hometown because it would appear that if a small town can break out with a success story, then it starts to attract all the same things that cities do, suggesting to me that it is not so much the people as much as it the history that has resulted in cities booming.
- rcarrigan87 9y agoChattanooga is a fairly good example of this.
- hownottowrite 9y agoArchived Version: https://archive.is/9yDHx https://archive.is/9yDHx
- thesumofall 9y agoCities are the future for the foreseeable future. Beyond benefits in information exchange they are also much more efficient in terms of energy usage and hence a great way to reduce energy consumption until we’ve finally solved our energy-related issues
- randomdata 9y agoOn the other hand, in Canada, a smaller share of the Canadian population live in cities now than did in 2011. Small towns saw the largest growth. It would appear to me that the efficiencies cities can provide are at odds with the cost of being able to provide sufficient shelter for the people of those cities. The high cost of housing, which is a large concern in Canada's major cities, is pushing people from these cities.
- spoonie 9y agoInteresting! Do you have a source for that? I’d like to learn more. Is it really small towns, or just suburbs/exurbs/bedroom communities? Regardless, it’s a good reason to focus on making housing more affordable in cities (build more!).
- randomdata 9y agoStatscan[1]. The actual numbers are by population size. I use the term town and city colloquially here (technically speaking Canada has towns with hundreds of thousands of people and cities with thousands). [1] http://www12.statcan.gc.ca/census-recensement/2016/ref/dict/geo049a-eng.cfm http://www12.statcan.gc.ca/census-recensement/2016/ref/dict/... > Regardless, it’s a good reason to focus on making housing more affordable in cities (build more!). I am going to have to disagree. Seeing the economic activity spread out to smaller communities has been the best thing to happen to Canada in a long time. I would argue that much of the countries woes are directly related to the drive into the big city that happened 10-20 years ago. As we've seen in Germany, a decentralized economy comes with many benefits.
- 9y ago
- adventured 9y agoYou can hardly talk about cities booming, while ignoring the obvious and dramatic other examples. The big epicenters of intense poverty and murder are all hyper concentrated in the cities, not in towns or rural areas. Baltimore has a murder rate 20-25 times that of a typical US town. Or: LA's massive homeless encampments. Chicago. Detroit. etc. West Virginia is really poor right? Considered one of the poorest states in the US, and has among the highest unemployment rates. You won't see homelessness, murder and extreme poverty in the towns around Morgantown like you do in the aforementioned cities. The entire state of West Virginia has 1/5th as many murders as Baltimore, with three times the population.
- rtkwe 9y agoCities partially just make the poverty more visible. There's extreme deep wells of poverty all over the country, it's just more spread out so it goes unnoticed. In a city with tight space though the homeless get pushed together with the rest of society so they get noticed more. Cities do exacerbate it some because of tight housing supply and cost where other places poverty means they might just have a really bad house in the city there's not the space for it. It is also partially self feeding because there's just a lack of services for the homeless/poor outside of big cities and because cities are booming and productive there's just a lot of extra that can support a homeless person than in a rural or small town.
- golemiprague 9y agoMaybe West Virginia doesn't have a big black population, all the crime in the cities is mainly a black problem. It will be more interesting to compare those cities to rural places with a large black population concentration, maybe Mississippi?
- astrodust 9y agoRent in West Virginia is a joke. Rent in Los Angeles or Chicago is murder. Also being homeless in West Virginia is a death sentence. You're going to have to get on a bus and go somewhere you can survive, which is usually a major city.
- neonate 9y agoWow, this is striking: "In 2016, Hillary Clinton won only 472 counties, but they represented fully 64% of GDP. Donald Trump’s 2,584 counties accounted for only 36%."
- dahdum 9y agoI wonder if a good portion of that is due to the continued collapse in manufacturing, mining, timber, and other areas that are now predominantly imports.
- ebikelaw 9y agoI don't really see how it could be that, since manufacturing in the USA is more valuable today than it has ever been, has a higher output than any other country but one, and more than some other continents, and makes up 1/3rd of GDP.
- dahdum 9y agoThe GDP was relative, so even if the pie did get larger it doesn't mean the ratio couldn't go down. "Manufacturing gross output and value added shares of the economy declined steadily between 1997 and 2013, as shown in Figure A. One reason for this decline is the rapid growth of manufactured imports, which have reduced the demand for domestically manufactured goods. Total imports of manufactured goods increased from $744 billion in 1997 to $1.83 trillion in 2014, rising from 8.6 percent of GDP in 1997 to 10.9 percent in 2013. Had it not been for the increase in manufactured imports, and of the U.S. trade deficit in manufactured goods, manufacturing output and GDP would have been significantly higher in 2013" > https://www.epi.org/publication/the-manufacturing-footprint-and-the-importance-of-u-s-manufacturing-jobs/ https://www.epi.org/publication/the-manufacturing-footprint-...
- exolymph 9y agoAh, but how many people does it employ, and in what types of jobs? http://slatestarcodex.com/2018/02/19/technological-unemployment-much-more-than-you-wanted-to-know/ http://slatestarcodex.com/2018/02/19/technological-unemploym...
- thriftwy 9y agoTowns were hot where they had to motivate people to move there. Most of towns are XX century phenomena. Now that people are already there and many of them are unemployed, they can pay peanuts and still expect workers to show up. The dynamics became toxic. Only when local business sees such need in work that they need to expand, they have to offer good salaries to be competitive.
- intrasight 9y agoGreat towns near great cities are the best compromise, IMHO. Cities are too noisy and stinky for me. But I need to have one close by for events that only a city can host. And for better air transport.